Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
POD Bean, your message amplified. Ready
0:02
to share your message with the
0:04
world? Start your podcast journey with
0:06
POD Bean. POD Bean. POD Bean.
0:08
POD Bean. POD Bean. The
0:11
AI-powered all-in-one podcast platform.
0:13
Thousands of businesses and enterprises
0:15
trust POD Bean to launch
0:17
their podcasts. Launch your podcast
0:20
on POD Bean today. My school
0:22
uses POD Bean. My church, too. I love
0:24
it. I really do. Best BookBits.com
0:26
brings you the book summary of the
0:29
happiness hypothesis finding modern truth in ancient
0:31
wisdom by Jonathan Hite. The author of
0:33
the number one New York Times bestseller
0:36
The Anxious Generation shows how a deeper
0:38
understanding of the world's philosophical wisdom can
0:40
enrich and transform our lives. The happiness
0:42
hypothesis is a book about 10 great
0:45
ideas. Each chapter is an attempt to
0:47
save a one idea that has been
0:49
discovered by several of the world civilizations
0:52
to question it. in light of what
0:54
we now know from scientific research and
0:56
to extract from it its lessons
0:58
that still apply to where modern
1:00
lives and eliminate the courses of
1:02
human flourishing. A ward-winning psychologist Jonathan
1:04
Hite shows a deeper understanding of
1:06
the world's philosophical wisdom and its
1:08
enduring maximums like to want others
1:10
as you would have others do
1:12
want to you or what doesn't
1:15
kill you makes you stronger. Kenning
1:17
Rich and transform our lives. Before
1:19
we start this summary we at
1:21
Best Bookwits done over 1,000 book
1:23
summaries in video at the audio
1:25
format so follow us at Best Bookbits.com,
1:27
watch us at YouTube and listen to
1:29
us on Apple podcast. On with the book
1:31
summary. We might already have encountered
1:33
the greatest ideas, the insight that
1:36
would have transformed us had we saved
1:38
it, taken it to heart and worked it into
1:40
our lives. The foundational idea of this
1:42
book. The mind is divided into parts
1:44
that sometimes conflict, like a rider on
1:47
the back of an elephant. The conscious
1:49
reasoning part of the mind has
1:51
only limited control of what the elephant
1:53
does. I'm a rider on the back of an
1:56
elephant. I'm holding the reins in my hands
1:58
and pulling one way or the other. I
2:00
can tell the elephant to turn,
2:02
to stop, or to go. I
2:04
can direct things, but only when
2:06
the elephant doesn't have the desires
2:08
of his own. When the elephant
2:10
really wants to do something, I'm
2:12
no match for him." Bouda said,
2:14
Our life is the creation of
2:16
our mind. The Golden Rule, reciprocity
2:18
is the most important tool for
2:20
getting along with people. Human thinking
2:22
depends on metaphor. We understand new
2:24
and complex things in relation to
2:26
things we already know. Desire and
2:28
reason are pulling in different directions.
2:30
I see the right way and
2:32
approve it but follow the wrong.
2:34
Confabulation. When we fabricate reasons to
2:36
explain our own behaviour, the writer
2:38
is a good at inventing, convincing
2:40
explanations for his behaviour, even when
2:42
it has no knowledge of the
2:44
causes of your behaviour. When the
2:46
rest of us look out at
2:48
the world, our emotional brains have
2:50
instantly and automatically appraised the possibilities.
2:52
One possibility usually jumps out of
2:54
this as the obvious best one.
2:57
We need only to use reason
2:59
to weigh the pros and cons
3:01
when two or three possibilities seem
3:03
equally good. Human rationality depends critically
3:05
on sophisticated emotionality. It is only
3:07
because our emotional brains work so
3:09
well that our reasoning can work
3:11
at all. Exposure to words related
3:13
to the elderly makes people walk
3:15
more slowly. Words related to professors
3:17
make people smarter at the game
3:19
of trivial pursuit and words related
3:21
to soccer horgens makes people dumber.
3:23
Automatic processes have been through thousands
3:25
of product cycles and are nearly
3:27
perfect. This difference in maturity between
3:29
automatic and controlled processes helps explain
3:31
why we have inexpensive computers that
3:33
can solve logic math and chess
3:35
problems better than any human beings
3:37
can. Most of us struggle with
3:39
these tasks, but none. of our
3:41
robots no matter how costly can
3:43
walk through the woods as well
3:45
as the average six-year-old child. Our
3:47
perceptual and motor skills are superb.
3:49
Marshmallow experiment. The successful children were
3:51
those who locked away from the
3:53
temptation or were able to think
3:55
about other enjoyable activities. These thinking
3:57
skills are an aspect of a
3:59
emotional intelligence, an ability to understand
4:01
and regulate one's own feelings and
4:03
desires. An emotionally intelligent person has
4:05
a skilled writer who knows how
4:07
to distract and coax the elephant
4:09
without having to engage in a
4:11
direct contest of wheels. It's hard
4:13
for the control system to beat
4:15
the automatic system by willpower alone.
4:17
Once you understand the power of
4:19
stimulus control you can use it
4:21
to your advantage by changing the
4:24
stimuli in your environment and avoiding
4:26
undesirable ones. by choosing to stare
4:28
at something that revolts the automatic
4:30
system, the rider can begin to
4:32
change what the elephant will want
4:34
in the future. Whenever I am
4:36
on a cliff, a rooftop or
4:38
a high balcony, the empt of
4:40
the perverse whispers in my ear,
4:42
jump, it's not a command, it's
4:44
just a word that pops into
4:46
the consciousness. When I'm at a
4:48
dinner party sitting next to someone
4:50
I respect, the imp works hard
4:52
to suggest the most inappropriate things
4:54
I could possibly say. Who or
4:56
what? is the imp. Dan Wickner,
4:58
one of the most perverse and
5:00
creative social psychologists, has dragged the
5:02
imp into a lab and made
5:04
it confess to being an aspect
5:06
of the automatic processing. Moral judgment
5:08
is like aesthetic judgment. When you
5:10
are seen a painting, you usually
5:12
know instantly and automatically with you
5:14
like it. If someone asks you
5:16
to explain your judgment, you confabulate.
5:18
moral arguments are much the same
5:20
two people feel strongly about an
5:22
issue their feelings come first and
5:24
their reasons are invented on the
5:26
fly to throw at each other
5:28
when you refute a person's judgment
5:30
does she generally change her mind
5:32
and agree with you of course
5:34
not because the argument you defeated
5:36
was not the cause of her
5:38
position it was made up after
5:40
the judgment was already made in
5:42
moral arguments the right it goes
5:44
beyond being just an advisor to
5:46
the elephant. He becomes a lawyer
5:49
fighting in court of public opinion
5:51
to persuade others of the elephant's
5:53
point of view. What we are
5:55
today comes from our thoughts of
5:57
yesterday and our present thoughts build
5:59
our life of tomorrow. Our life
6:01
is the creation of our mind.
6:03
To take something philosophically means to
6:05
accept a great misfortune without weeping
6:07
or even suffering, we use this
6:09
term in part because of the
6:11
calmness, self-controlled, encourage that three ancient
6:13
philosophers, Socrates, Seneca, and Bewithius, showed
6:15
while they awaited their executions. Adverse
6:17
fortune is more beneficial than good
6:19
fortune. The latter only makes men
6:21
greedy for more, but adversity makes
6:23
them strong. No man can ever
6:25
be secure until he has been
6:27
forsaken by fortune. Nothing brings happiness
6:29
unless you are content with
6:31
it. Epiphanies can be life altering,
6:33
but most fade in days or weeks.
6:35
The rider can't just decide to change
6:38
and then order the elephant to go
6:40
along with the program. Lasting change can
6:42
only come by retraining the elephant
6:44
and that's hard to do. Whenever
6:47
you see a word that resembles
6:49
your name, a little flash of
6:51
pleasure biases you toward thinking the
6:53
thing is good. People named Dennis
6:55
and or Denise are slightly more
6:57
likely than people with other names
6:59
to become more dentist. Men named
7:01
Lawrence and women named Lori are
7:03
more likely to become lawyers. Lewis and
7:05
Louise are more likely to be moved
7:08
to Louisiana or St. Louis and Georgiana
7:10
and Georgina are more likely to move
7:12
to Georgia. The own name preference even
7:15
shows up in marriage records. People are
7:17
slightly more likely to marry people with
7:19
whose names sound like their own. Even
7:22
if this similarity is just sharing. are
7:24
first initial. Bad is stronger than
7:26
good. Responses to threats and unpleasantness
7:28
are faster, stronger and hard to
7:31
inhibit than responses to opportunities and
7:33
pleasures. This principle called negative bias
7:35
shows up all over psychology. The
7:37
elephant reacts before the rider even
7:40
sees a snake on the path.
7:42
Although you can tell yourself that
7:44
you are not afraid of snakes,
7:46
if your elephant fears them and
7:49
rears up, you'll still be thrown.
7:51
Thoughts can cause emotions. as when
7:53
you reflect on a foolish thing
7:55
you said, but emotions can also
7:57
cause thoughts. Primarily by raising mental
7:59
filters. that bias subsequent information processing
8:01
a flash of fear makes you
8:03
extra vigilant for additional threats. You
8:05
look at the world through a
8:08
filter that interprets ambiguous events as
8:10
possible dangers. A flash of anger
8:12
towards someone raises the filter through
8:14
which you see everything the offending
8:16
person says or does as a
8:18
further insult or transgression. Feelings of
8:20
sadness blind you to all the
8:22
pleasures and opportunities. Genes make at
8:24
least some contribution to nearly every
8:27
trade. Whether the trade is intelligence,
8:29
extraversion, fearfulness, religiosity, political leaning, liking
8:31
for jazz, or dislike of spicy
8:33
foods. Identical twins are more similar
8:35
than for eternal twins and they
8:37
are usually almost as similar if
8:39
they were separated at birth. Genes
8:41
are not blueprints specifying the structure
8:43
of a person. They are better
8:45
thought of as recipes for producing
8:48
a person over many years. Cortical
8:50
lefties are less subject to depression
8:52
and recover more quickly from negative
8:54
experiences. The difference between cortical righties
8:56
and lefties can be seen even
8:58
in infants. Ten month old babies
9:00
showing more activity on the right
9:02
side are more likely to cry
9:04
when separated briefly from their mothers.
9:06
And this difference in infancy appears
9:09
to reflect an aspect of personality
9:11
that is stable for most people
9:13
all the way through adulthood. Babies
9:15
who show a lot more activity
9:17
on the right side of the
9:19
forehead become toddlers. who are more
9:21
anxious about novel situations as teenagers,
9:23
they are more likely to be
9:25
fearful about dating and social activities.
9:28
And finally, as adults, they are
9:30
more likely to need psychotherapy to
9:32
loosen up. Having lost out in
9:34
the cortical lottery, they will struggle
9:36
all their lives to weaken the
9:38
grip of an overactive withdrawal system.
9:40
John Milton's paraphrase of Aurelius, the
9:42
mind is its own place and
9:44
in itself can make a heaven
9:46
of hell, a hell of heaven.
9:49
You can change your effective style
9:51
too, but again, you can't do
9:53
it by sheer force of will,
9:55
you have to do something that
9:57
will change your repertoire of available
9:59
thoughts. Here are the three the
10:01
best methods for doing so. meditation,
10:03
cognitive therapy and Prozac. All three
10:05
are effective because they work on
10:07
the elephant. There are many kinds
10:10
of meditation but they all have
10:12
in common a conscious attempt to
10:14
force attention in a non-analytical way.
10:16
He mapped out the disorder thought
10:18
process characteristics of the repress people
10:20
and trained his patients to catch
10:22
and challenge these thoughts. Depress people
10:24
are caught in a feedback loop
10:26
in which distorted thoughts cause negative
10:29
feelings. which then distort thinking further.
10:31
Beck's discovery is that you can
10:33
break the cycle by changing the
10:35
thoughts. A big part of cognitive
10:37
therapy is training clients to catch
10:39
their thoughts, write them down, name
10:41
the distortions, and then find alternative
10:43
and more accurate ways of thinking.
10:45
Cognitive behavioral therapy. Prost wrote that
10:47
the only true voyage is not
10:50
to visit strange lands, but to
10:52
possess other eyes. horror fascinates me
10:54
particularly when there is no victim.
10:56
I study moral reactions to harmless
10:58
taboo violations such as the consensual
11:00
incest and private flag desecration. These
11:02
things just feel wrong to most
11:04
people even when they can't explain
11:06
why. Prozac, it's easy for those
11:09
who did well in the cortical
11:11
lottery to preach about the importance
11:13
of hard work and the unnaturalness
11:15
of chemical shortcuts. But for those
11:17
who, though no fault of their
11:19
own, ended up on the negative
11:21
half of the effective style spectrum.
11:23
Prozac is a way to compensate
11:25
for the unfairness of the cortical
11:27
lottery. Tit for TAT strategy is
11:30
to be nice on the first
11:32
round of interaction, but after that,
11:34
do to your partner whatever your
11:36
partner did to you on the
11:38
previous round. Gratitude and ventfulness are
11:40
big steps on the road that
11:42
led human to ultra-sociality and it's
11:44
important to realize that these are
11:46
two sides of the one coin.
11:48
It will be hard to evolve
11:51
one without the other. An individual
11:53
who had gratitude without ventfulness. would
11:55
be an easy mark for exploitation
11:57
and eventually an ungrateful individual. would
11:59
quickly alienate all possible cooperative partners.
12:01
Human beings ought to live in
12:03
groups of around 150 people. Judging
12:05
from the logarithm of our brain
12:07
size, and sure enough, studies of
12:10
a hundred gatherer groups, military units,
12:12
and city dwellers address hooks suggested
12:14
at 100 to 150 is the
12:16
natural group size within which people
12:18
can know just about everyone directly,
12:20
by name and face, and know
12:22
how each person is related to
12:24
everybody else. When you pass on
12:26
a piece of juicy gossip, What
12:28
happens? Your friends' reciprocity reflex kicks
12:31
in and she feels a slight
12:33
pressure to return the favour. If
12:35
she knows something about the person
12:37
or the event in question, she
12:39
is likely to speak up. Oh
12:41
really? Well I heard that he...
12:43
Gossip is overwhelmingly critical and it
12:45
is primarily about the moral and
12:47
social violations of others. When people
12:49
pass along high quality juicy gossip,
12:52
they feel more powerful, they have
12:54
better shared sense of what is
12:56
right and what is wrong and
12:58
they feel more closely connected to
13:00
their gossip. partners. Gossip is a
13:02
policeman and a teacher. Without it
13:04
there would be chaos and ignorance.
13:06
Gossip paired with reciprocity allows karma
13:08
to work here on earth, not
13:11
in the next life. Scandal is
13:13
a great entertainment because it allows
13:15
people to feel contempt a moral
13:17
emotion that gives feeling of moral
13:19
superiority while asking nothing in return.
13:21
With contempt you don't need to
13:23
be right or wrong as with
13:25
anger or flee the scene as
13:27
with fear or disgust and best
13:29
of all contempt. is made to
13:32
share. Stories about the moral failings
13:34
of others are among the most
13:36
common kinds of gossip. The great
13:38
majority of mankind are satisfied with
13:40
appearances as though they were realities
13:42
and are often more influenced by
13:44
the things that seemed than those
13:46
that are so convenient a thing
13:48
is it to be a reasonable
13:51
creature since it enables one to
13:53
final make a reason for everything
13:55
one has a mind to do.
13:57
Benjamin Franklin People will hold pervasive
13:59
positive illusion. about themselves, their abilities
14:01
and their future prospects are mentally
14:03
healthier, happier and better liked than
14:05
people who lack such illusions. People
14:07
really are open to information that
14:09
will predict the behaviour of others,
14:12
but they refuse to adjust their
14:14
self-assessments. Naive realism. Each of us
14:16
thinks we see the world directly
14:18
as it really is. We believe
14:20
that the facts as we see
14:22
them are there for all to
14:24
see. Therefore, others should agree with
14:26
this. If they don't agree, it
14:28
follows either that they have not
14:30
yet been exposed to the relevant
14:33
facts or else they have been
14:35
blinded by their interest and ideologies.
14:37
People acknowledge that their own backgrounds
14:39
have shaped their views, but such
14:41
experiences are inevitably seen as deepening
14:43
one's insights. For example, being a
14:45
doctor gives a person special insight
14:47
into the problems of their health
14:49
care industry. But the background of
14:52
other people is used to explain
14:54
their biases and convert motivation. For
14:56
example, doctors think that lawyers disagree
14:58
with them about tort reform, not
15:00
because the work with their victims
15:02
or malpractice, and therefore have their
15:04
own special insights. But because their
15:06
self-interest biases, they're thinking, it seems
15:08
plain as day to the naive
15:10
realist that everyone is influenced by
15:13
ideology and self-interest, except for me,
15:15
I see things as they are.
15:17
If I could nominate one candidate
15:19
for the biggest obstacle to world
15:21
peace and social harmony, it would
15:23
be naive realism, because it is
15:25
so easily wretched up from the
15:27
individual to the group level, my
15:29
group is right because we see
15:32
things as they are. Those who
15:34
disagree are obviously biased by their
15:36
religion, their ideology or their self-interest.
15:38
Nyeivism gives us a world full
15:40
of good and evil, and this
15:42
brings us to the most disturbing
15:44
implication of the sages advice about
15:46
hypocrisy, good and evil, do not
15:48
exist outside our beliefs about them.
15:50
People want to believe they are
15:53
on a mission from God or
15:55
that they are fighting for some
15:57
more secular good animals, fetuses, women's
15:59
rights. and you can't have much
16:01
of a mission without good allies
16:03
and a good enemy. If God is
16:05
all good and all powerful either he
16:08
allows evil to flourish which means
16:10
he is not all good
16:12
or else he struggles against
16:14
evil which means he is
16:16
not all powerful. A 3,000
16:18
year old question had been
16:20
given a complete and compelling
16:22
psychological explanation the previous year
16:25
by Roy. Baumister, one of
16:27
today's most creative social psychologists
16:29
in evil inside human cruelty
16:31
and aggression, the myth of pure
16:33
evil is the ultimate self-serving
16:35
bias. When someone's higher esteem
16:37
is unrealistic and nastistic, it
16:39
is easily threatened by reality.
16:41
In reaction to those threats,
16:43
people often lash out violently.
16:45
Baumister's questions to the usefulness
16:47
of the programs that try
16:49
to raise children's self-esteem directly
16:51
instead of by teaching them skills
16:54
that they can be proud of.
16:56
Such direct enhancement can potentially foster
16:58
unstable narcissism. To really get a
17:00
mass atrocity, going you need, idolism.
17:02
The belief that your violence is a
17:04
means to a moral end. The major
17:07
atrocities of the 20th century were carried
17:09
out largely by men who thought they
17:11
were creating a utopia or else by
17:13
men who believed that they were defending
17:16
their homeland or tribe from attack. Idolism
17:18
easily becomes dangerous because it brings with
17:20
it, almost inevitably the belief that the
17:22
end justifies the means. If you are
17:25
fighting for good or for God, what
17:27
matters is the outcome, not the path.
17:29
The world we live in is
17:31
not really one made of
17:33
rocks, trees or physical objects.
17:36
It is a world of
17:38
insults, opportunities, status symbols, portrayals,
17:40
saints and sinners. And this
17:42
moralism, righteousness and hypocrisy, it's beyond silly.
17:44
It is tragic for it suggests that
17:46
human beings will never achieve a state
17:49
of lasting peace and harmony. So what
17:51
can you do about it? The first
17:53
step is to see it as a
17:55
game and stop taking it so seriously.
17:57
Write down your thoughts, learn to recognize the
17:59
story. in your thoughts and then
18:01
think of a more appropriate thought.
18:03
You will see the fault in
18:05
yourself only if you set out
18:08
on a deliberate and effortful quest
18:10
to look for it. Try this
18:12
now. Think of a recent interpersonal
18:14
conflict with someone you care about
18:16
and then find a way in
18:18
which your behaviour was not exemplary.
18:21
Finding fault with yourself, it is
18:23
also the key to overcoming the
18:25
hypocrisy and judgmentalism that damages so
18:27
many valuable relationships. Do not seek
18:29
to have events. happen as you
18:31
want them to, but instead want
18:33
them to happen as they do
18:36
happen and your life will go
18:38
well. When it comes to goal
18:40
pursuit, it really is the journey
18:42
that counts, not the destination. Set
18:44
for yourself any goal you want.
18:46
Most of the pleasure will be
18:49
had along the way. With every
18:51
step that takes you closer, the
18:53
final moment of success is often
18:55
no more thrilling than the relief
18:57
of taking off a heavy backpack
18:59
at the end of a long
19:01
hike. If you went on a
19:04
hike only to feel that pleasure,
19:06
You are a fool. People's judgments
19:08
about their present state are based
19:10
on whether it is better or
19:12
worse than the state to which
19:14
they have become a custom. Adaptation
19:17
is in part just a property
19:19
of neurons. Nerve cells respond vigorously
19:21
to new stimuli, but gradually they
19:23
habituate. Firing less to stimuli, that
19:25
they have become used to. Todd
19:27
Bean, your message amplified. Ready to
19:30
share your message with the world?
19:32
Start your podcast journey with Podbin.
19:34
Podbin. The AI-powered all-in-one podcast platform.
19:36
Thousands of businesses and enterprises trust
19:38
Podbin to launch their podcasts. Use
19:40
Podbin to record your podcast. Use
19:42
Podbin AI to optimize your podcast.
19:45
Use Podbin AI to turn your
19:47
blog into a podcast. Use Podbin
19:49
to distribute your podcast everywhere. Launch
19:51
your podcast on Podbin today. Voluntary
19:55
activities on the other hand are
19:57
things that you choose to do
19:59
such as meditation. exercise, learning a
20:01
new skill or taking a vacation,
20:03
because such activities must be chosen
20:05
and because most of them take
20:07
effort and attention, they can't just
20:09
disappear from your awareness the way
20:11
conditions can. Voluntary activities therefore offers
20:13
much greater promise for increasing happiness
20:15
while avoiding adaptation effects. Noise especially
20:17
noise that is variable or intermittent
20:19
interviews with concentration and increases stress.
20:21
It's worth striving to remove sources
20:23
of noise in your life. Conflicts
20:26
in relationships. Having an annoying office
20:28
mate or roommate or having chronic
20:30
conflict with your spouse is one
20:32
of the surest ways to reduce
20:34
your happiness. You never adapt to
20:36
interpersonal conflict. It damages every day.
20:38
Even days when you don't see
20:40
the other person but ruminate about
20:42
the conflict nonetheless. People who report
20:44
the greatest interest in attaining money,
20:46
fame or beauty, are consistently found
20:48
to be less happy and even
20:50
less healthy than those who pursue
20:52
less materialistic goals. There is a
20:54
state many people value even more
20:56
than chocolate after sex. It is
20:58
a state of total immersion in
21:00
a task that is challenging yet
21:03
closely matched to one's ability. It
21:05
is what people sometimes call being
21:07
in the zone. The keys to
21:09
flow. There's a clear challenge that
21:11
fully engages your attention. You have
21:13
the skills to meet the challenge.
21:15
You get immediate feedback about how
21:17
you are doing at each step.
21:19
Pleasures are the lights that have
21:21
clear sensory and strong emotional clean
21:23
parts, such as being derived from
21:25
food, sex, backrubs and cool breezes.
21:27
Gratifications are activities that engage you
21:29
fully draw on your strengths and
21:31
allow you to lose self-consciousness. Arrange
21:33
your day and your environment to
21:35
increase both pleasures and gratifications. Pleasures
21:38
must be spaced to maintain their
21:40
potency. Because the elephant has a
21:42
tendency to overindulge, the rider needs
21:44
to encourage it to get up
21:46
and move to another activity. The
21:48
key to finding your own gratifications
21:50
is to know your own strengths.
21:52
Buddhist detachment. What would have happened
21:54
in the young Sudatha had actually
21:56
descended from his gilded chariot and
21:58
talked to the people he assumed
22:00
was so miserable? What he had
22:02
interviewed the poor, the elderly, the
22:04
crippled, and the sick, Buddhist emphasis
22:06
on detachment, may have been the
22:08
turbulent times he lived in, then
22:10
it was foolish to seek happiness
22:13
by controlling one external world. But
22:15
now it is not. People living
22:17
in wealthy democracies can set long-term
22:19
goals and expect to meet them.
22:21
We are immunised against disease, sheltered
22:23
from storms, etc. Although all of
22:25
us will get unwanted surprises along
22:27
the way, we'll adapt and cope
22:29
with nearly all of them, and
22:31
many of us will believe we
22:33
are better off having suffered. So
22:35
to cut off all attachments, to
22:37
shun the pleasures of sensuality and
22:39
triumph in an effort to escape
22:41
the pains of loss and defeat,
22:43
this now strikes me as an
22:45
inappropriate response to the inevitable presence
22:47
of some suffering in every life.
22:50
Calm. Non-striving advocated by Buddha is
22:52
designed to avoid passion and a
22:54
life without passion is not a
22:56
human life. Yes, attachments bring pain
22:58
but they also bring our greatest
23:00
joys. Giving monkeys reasons as a
23:02
reward for each correct step in
23:04
solving a puzzle such opening a
23:06
mechanical latch with several moving parts
23:08
actually interferes with dissolving because it
23:10
distracts the monkeys they enjoy the
23:12
task for its own sake. If
23:14
you want your children to grow
23:16
up to be healthy and independent,
23:18
you should hold them, hug them,
23:20
cuddle them and love them. Give
23:22
them a secure base and they
23:25
will explore and then conquer the
23:27
world on their own. If the
23:29
model says that Mum is always
23:31
there for you, you'll be bolder
23:33
in your play and explorations. If
23:35
the metaphor for passionate love is
23:37
vines growing, intertwining and gradually binding
23:39
two people together. People are not
23:41
allowed to sign contracts when they
23:43
are drunk and I sometimes wish
23:45
we could prevent people from proposing
23:47
marriages when they are high on
23:49
passionate love. If you are... in
23:51
passionate love and want to celebrate
23:53
your passion, read poetry. If you're
23:55
a dual has come and you
23:57
want to understand your evolving relationship,
23:59
read psychology. If you just enter
24:02
the relationship with what to believe
24:04
you are better off without love,
24:06
read philosophy. People in all cultures
24:08
have a pervasive fear of death.
24:10
Human beings all know that they
24:12
are going to die. And so
24:14
human cultures go to great lengths
24:16
to construct systems of meaning that
24:18
dignify life and convince people that
24:20
their lives have more meaning than
24:22
those of the animals that die
24:24
all around them. The extensive regulation
24:26
of sex in many cultures, the
24:28
attempt to link love to God,
24:30
and then to cut away the
24:32
sex is part of the elaborate
24:34
defence against the gaunting fear of
24:37
mortality. Adversity may be necessary for
24:39
growth because it forces you to
24:41
stop speeding along the road of
24:43
life, allowing you to notice the
24:45
paths that were branching off all
24:47
along, and to think about where
24:49
you really want to end up.
24:51
At an intuitive level, we all
24:53
believe in Kama, the Hindu notion
24:55
that people reap what they sow.
24:57
The psychologist Mallana had demonstrated that
24:59
we are so motivated to believe
25:01
that people get what they deserve
25:03
and deserve what they get, that
25:05
we often blame the victim of
25:07
a tragedy. Letting off steam. makes
25:09
people angrier, not calmer. When people
25:12
older than 30 are asked to
25:14
remember the most important or vivid
25:16
events of their lives, they are
25:18
disproportionately likely to recall events that
25:20
occurred between the ages of 15
25:22
and 25. This is the age
25:24
when a person's life blooms, first
25:26
love, college and intellectual growth, living
25:28
and perhaps travelling independently, and it
25:30
is the time when young people,
25:32
at least in Western countries, make
25:34
many of the choices that would
25:36
define their lives. If there is
25:38
a special period for our identity
25:40
formation, a time when life offense
25:42
are going to have the biggest
25:44
influence on the rest of the
25:46
life story. This is it. Marcel
25:49
Prost said, would not receive wisdom,
25:51
we must discover it for ourselves.
25:53
After a journey through the wilderness,
25:55
which no one else can make
25:57
for us, which No one can
25:59
spare for us, for our wisdom
26:01
is to point a view from
26:03
which we come, at last, to
26:05
regard the world. First, wise people
26:07
are able to balance their own needs,
26:09
the needs of others, and the needs
26:11
of people or things beyond, the immediate
26:14
interaction, e.g. institutions, the environment,
26:16
or people who may be
26:18
adversely affected later on. Ignorant
26:20
people see everything in black and white.
26:23
They rely heavily on myth of pure
26:25
evil and are strongly influenced by their
26:27
own self-interest. The wise are able to
26:30
see things from others' points of view,
26:32
appreciate shades of grey, and then choose
26:34
or advise a course of action that
26:37
works out best for everyone in the
26:39
long run. Second, wise people are
26:41
able to balance three responses to
26:44
situations. Adaptation, changing the self to
26:46
fit the environment. Shaping the environment.
26:48
and selection, choosing to move to
26:51
a new environment. This second balance
26:53
corresponds roughly to the famous Serenity
26:56
Prayer. God give me the strength
26:58
to accept things I cannot change,
27:00
courage to change the things I
27:03
can, and the wisdom to know the
27:05
difference. Frugality, make no expense
27:07
but to do good. To others, or
27:10
yourself, Brenchman Franklin, moral education must
27:12
also impact Tacked knowledge, skills of
27:14
social perception and social emotions, so
27:16
finally tuned that one automatically feels
27:19
the right thing in each situation,
27:21
knows the right thing to do
27:23
and then wants to do it.
27:25
Morality for the ancients was a
27:27
kind of practical wisdom. Many moral
27:30
education efforts since the 1970s takes the
27:32
writer off the elephant and trains him
27:34
to solve problems on his own. After
27:36
being exposed to hours of case studies,
27:39
classroom discussions about moral dilemmas and videos
27:41
about people who face dilemmas and make
27:43
the right choices. The children learns how,
27:46
not what to think, then class ends,
27:48
the rider gets back on the elephant
27:50
and nothing changes at recess. Trying to
27:52
make children behave ethically by teaching them
27:55
to reason well is like trying to
27:57
make a dog happy by wagging its
27:59
tail. it gets causality backwards. A wonderful
28:01
book, Practical Ethics, by the Princeton
28:04
philosopher Peter Singer. I've been morally
28:06
opposed to all forms of factory
28:08
farming, morally opposed, but not behaviourally
28:10
opposed. I love the taste of
28:12
meat and the only thing that
28:15
changed in the first six months
28:17
after reading Singer is that I
28:19
thought about my hypocrisy each time
28:21
I ordered a hamburger. But then,
28:23
during my second year of graduate
28:25
school, I began to study the
28:28
emotion of disgust. I watched in
28:30
horror as cows moving down a
28:32
dripping, dissembling line, were bludgeoned, hooked
28:34
and sliced up. The sight of
28:36
red meat made me queasy. My
28:38
visceral feelings now matched my beliefs.
28:41
Singer had given me. The elephant
28:43
now agreed with the writer, and
28:45
I became a vegetarian. I saw
28:47
the right way. and approved it
28:49
but following the wrong until an
28:51
emotion came along to provide some
28:54
force. The modern requirement that ethics
28:56
ignored particularly is what gave us
28:58
the weaker morality, applicable everywhere but
29:00
encompassing nowhere. Work on your strengths
29:02
not your weaknesses. How many of
29:04
your New Year's resolutions have been
29:07
about fixing a flaw and how
29:09
many of those resolutions you made
29:11
several years in a row. Cognitive
29:13
behaviour therapy really does work. Religion
29:15
and science each begin with an
29:18
easy and unsatisfying answer, but then
29:20
move to the more subtle and
29:22
interesting explanations. Psychologist Alice Isen went
29:24
to the Philadelphia leaving dimes in
29:26
pay phones. The people who used
29:28
those phones and found the dimes
29:31
were more likely to help a
29:33
person who dropped a stack of
29:35
papers. Happy people are kinder and
29:37
more helpful than those in the
29:39
control group. A normlessness. A normy
29:41
is a condition of society in
29:44
which there are no clear rules,
29:46
norms or standards of values. In
29:48
an anormy society, people can do
29:50
as a please, but without any
29:52
clear standards or respected social institutions
29:54
to enforce those standards. It's hard
29:57
for people to find things they
29:59
want to do. Ask in children
30:01
to go... grow virtues? Looking only
30:03
within themselves for guidance is like
30:05
asking each one to invent a
30:07
personal language, a pointless and isolating
30:10
task, if there is no community
30:12
with whom to speak. Would you
30:14
prefer that there be a wide
30:16
variety of opinions and no dominant
30:18
ones? Or would you prefer that
30:21
everyone agree with you and the
30:23
wars of the land reflect that
30:25
agreement? If you prefer diversity on
30:27
an issue, the issue is not
30:29
a moral issue for you, it
30:31
is a matter of personal taste.
30:34
The metaphor has helped me to
30:36
understand morality from religion and the
30:38
human quest for meaning in Flatland,
30:40
a charming little hook written in
30:42
1884 by the English novelist and
30:44
mathematician Edwin Abbott, the ethic of
30:47
autonomy. the ethic of community and
30:49
the ethic of divinity. When people
30:51
think and act using the ethic
30:53
of autonomy, their goal is to
30:55
protect individuals from harm and grant
30:57
them the maximum degree of autonomy
31:00
which they can use to pursue
31:02
their own goals. When people use
31:04
the ethic of community, their goals
31:06
to protect the integrity of groups,
31:08
families, companies or nations, and they
31:10
value virtues such as obedience, loyalty
31:13
and wise leadership. When people use
31:15
the ethic of divinity, their goals
31:17
to protect from degradation the divinity
31:19
that exists in each person and
31:21
they value living in a pure
31:23
and holy way free from moral
31:26
pollutants such as lust greed and
31:28
hatred. Cultures vary in their relevant
31:30
reliance on these three ethics. Man
31:32
is possessed of two natures a
31:34
lower in common with the animals
31:37
and a higher peculiar to himself.
31:39
The whole meaning of sin is
31:41
the humiliating bondage of the higher
31:43
to the lower. The modern West
31:45
is the first culture in human
31:47
history that has managed to strip
31:50
time and space of all sacredness
31:52
and to produce a fully practical,
31:54
efficient, and profane world. This is
31:56
the world that religious fundamentalists find
31:58
unbearable. The great historian of religion,
32:00
Mercy Elder, wrote The Sacred of
32:03
the Profane. Even a person committed
32:05
to a profane existence, has privileged
32:07
places. different from all others, a
32:09
man's birthright, or the scenes of
32:11
his first love, or certain places
32:13
in the first foreign city he
32:16
visited in his youth. Even for
32:18
the most frankly non-religious man, all
32:20
these places still retain an exceptional,
32:22
a unique quality. They are the
32:24
holy places of his private universe,
32:26
as if it were in such
32:29
spots that he had received the
32:31
revelation of a reality other than
32:33
that in which he participates through
32:35
his ordinary daily life. Even atheist...
32:37
have imitations of sacredness, particularly when
32:40
in love or in nature, which
32:42
is don't infer that God cause
32:44
those feelings. Or is the emotion
32:46
of self transcendence. The self is
32:48
the main obstacle to spiritual advancement
32:50
in three ways. One, the constraint
32:53
stream of trivial concerns and egocentric
32:55
thoughts keeps people locked in the
32:57
material and profane world, unable to
32:59
perceive sacredness and divinity. This is
33:01
why Eastern religions rely heavily on
33:03
meditation and effective means of quieting
33:06
the chatter of the self. Two,
33:08
spiritual transformation is essentially the transformation
33:10
of the self, weakening it, pruning
33:12
it back, in some sense killing
33:14
it. And often, the self objects
33:16
give up my possessions about the
33:19
prestige they bring. No way. Love
33:21
my enemies. After what they did
33:23
to me, forget about it. Following
33:25
a spiritual path is inevitably hard
33:27
work, requiring years of meditation, prayer,
33:29
self-control, and sometimes self-denial. The self
33:32
does not like to be denied,
33:34
and it is apt at finding
33:36
reasons to bend the rules or
33:38
cheat. Many religions teach that egotistic
33:40
attachments to pleasure and reputation are
33:43
in constant temptations to leave the
33:45
path of virtue. In a sense,
33:47
the self is Satan, or at
33:49
least, Satan's portal. Only by seeing
33:51
the self in this way can
33:53
one understand or even respect the
33:56
moral motivations of those who want
33:58
to make society conform more closely
34:00
to the particular religion they follow.
34:02
Love and work for people are
34:04
obvious analogies to water and sunshine
34:06
for plants. When Freud was asked
34:09
what a normal person should be
34:11
able to do well he is
34:13
repted to have said love and work.
34:15
We get more pleasure from making
34:17
progress towards our goals than
34:19
we do from achieving them. Most
34:21
people approach their work in one of
34:23
three ways as a job, a career
34:26
or a call in. If you see your
34:28
work as a job, You do it
34:30
only for the money. You look at
34:32
the clock frequently by dreaming about the
34:34
weekend ahead, and you probably pursue hobbies
34:36
which satisfy your needs more thoroughly than
34:38
does your work. If you see your
34:40
work as a career, you have larger
34:42
goals of advancement, promotion, and prestige. If
34:44
you see your work as a calling,
34:46
however, you find your work intrinsically fulfilling,
34:48
you are not doing it to achieve
34:50
something else. You see your work as
34:52
contributing to the greater good or as
34:54
playing a role in some larger enterprise,
34:56
the worth of which seems obvious to
34:58
you. You have frequent experiences of flow
35:00
during the workday and you neither look
35:03
forward to quitting time nor feel the
35:05
desire to shout thank God it's Friday.
35:07
You would continue to work perhaps even
35:09
without pay if you suddenly became very
35:11
wealthy. You might think that blue
35:14
collar workers have jobs, managers have
35:16
careers and more respected professionals, doctors,
35:18
scientists and the clergy have coins.
35:21
But all three orientations represented in
35:23
almost every occupation examined. Those
35:25
janitors who worked this way saw their work
35:27
as a coin and enjoyed it far more than
35:30
those who saw it as a job. Work at
35:32
its best, then, is about connection,
35:34
engagement and commitment. Work is love
35:37
made visible. Love and work are
35:39
crucial for human happiness because when
35:41
done well they draw us
35:43
out of ourselves and interconnection
35:45
with people and projects beyond ourselves.
35:47
Happiness comes from getting these
35:49
connections right. When doing good,
35:51
doing high quality work that produces
35:54
something to us, to others,
35:56
matches up with doing well,
35:58
achieving wealth and professional advancement. A
36:00
field is healthy. Genetics, for example,
36:02
is a healthy field because all
36:04
parties involved respect and reward the
36:06
very best science. Journalism into just
36:08
another profit center where the only
36:10
thing that mattered was, will it
36:12
sell? And will it outsell our
36:15
competitors? Good journalism was sometimes bad
36:17
for business. Journalists who worked for
36:19
those empires confessed to having a
36:21
sense of being forced to sell
36:23
out and violate their own moral
36:25
standards. Their world was unaligned and
36:27
they could not become vitally engaged
36:29
in the larger but ignoble mission
36:31
of gaining market share at any
36:33
cost. A coherent profession such as
36:35
genetics can get on with the
36:37
business of genetics, while an incoherent
36:39
profession like journalism spends a lot
36:41
of time on self -analysis and
36:44
self -criticism. If you lower level trait
36:46
match up with your coping mechanisms,
36:48
which in turn are consistent with
36:50
your life story, your personality is
36:52
well integrated and you can get
36:54
on with the business of living.
36:56
When these levels do not cohe,
36:58
you are likely to be torn
37:00
by internal contradictions and neurotic conflicts.
37:02
You might need adversity to knock
37:04
yourself into alignment. And if you
37:06
do achieve coherence, the moment when
37:08
things come together may be the
37:10
one of the most profound of
37:12
your life. If evolution is all
37:15
about survival of the fittest, then
37:17
why do people help each other
37:19
so much? Why do they give
37:21
to charity, risk their lives to
37:23
save strangers and volunteer to fight
37:25
in wars? Darwin thought the answer
37:27
was easy. Ultrism evolves for the
37:29
good of the group. There can
37:31
be no doubt that a tribe
37:33
including many members who from possessing
37:35
a high degree of spirit of
37:37
patriotism, fidelity, obedience, courage and sympathy
37:39
were always ready to aid one
37:41
another and to sacrifice themselves for
37:44
the common good would be victorious
37:46
over most other tribes and this
37:48
would be natural selection. The word
37:50
religion literally means in Latin to
37:52
link or bind together. It
37:55
is worth striving to get
37:57
the right relationship between yourself and
37:59
others, between yourself and your
38:01
work. and between yourself and something larger than yourself, if you
38:03
get these relationships right, a sense
38:05
of purpose and meaning will in
38:07
merge. Liberals are experts in thinking
38:10
about issues of victimisation, inequality, autonomy
38:12
and the rights of individuals, particularly
38:14
those of minorities and non-conformist. Conservatives
38:16
are experts in thinking about loyalty
38:19
to the group, respect for authority
38:21
and tradition and sacredness. When one
38:23
side overwhel the other, the results
38:26
are likely to be ugly. A
38:28
society without liberals would be harsh
38:30
and oppressive to many individuals. A
38:32
society without conservatives would lose
38:35
many of the social structures
38:37
and constraints. A good place to
38:39
look for wisdom is where you least
38:41
expect to find it, in the minds
38:43
of your opponents. You already know the
38:45
ideas common on your own side. If
38:47
you can take off the blinders of
38:49
the myth of pure evil, you might
38:51
see some good ideas for the first
38:54
time. And that's a wrap on this
38:56
book's summary, The Happiness Hypothesis. If you
38:58
like the book's summary, click the link
39:00
to download this, where you have best
39:02
book bits again, and then over 1,000
39:04
book summaries in video in the audio
39:06
format. So check us out at Best
39:09
Bookbiz.com, like, comment, share and subscribe
39:11
to our YouTube channel, and listen
39:13
to us at Apple Podcast, Apple
39:15
Podcast. If you want to help
39:17
support the channel, we have put
39:20
together on Amazing Day. Take it,
39:22
bye bye now.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More