Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:09
Hello. This is
0:11
a special episode. So
0:13
we're starting a little
0:15
differently. That's why
0:17
we didn't do the usual intro. Mr.
0:20
Ridenauer wants everything. Talk to
0:22
Tervy for this show because that's
0:24
kind of the theme of
0:26
his new book, which is what
0:28
this shows about. The
0:31
book is called a season
0:34
of madness, fools,
0:37
monsters, and marvels of
0:39
the old world carnival. And
0:41
it's available in the US on
0:44
May 6th and a bit later
0:46
internationally. But if you're
0:48
listening before then, it's
0:50
also available immediately via
0:52
pre -order. Okay,
0:55
I think that's it. So now
0:57
on to the show. Episode
1:00
140. the
1:03
unknown carnival. Absolutely
1:14
not. Absolutely not what the book is
1:16
about. So don't step up and get
1:18
it out of your head. This
1:20
is that other kind of
1:22
carnival that things celebrated in
1:24
Catholic countries in February or
1:26
March. And why
1:28
write about that? Because
1:31
of my interest in the
1:33
Krampus, the traditions are surprisingly
1:35
interwoven, which I'll get to
1:37
shortly. But back to this.
1:42
That's what many people seem to hear
1:44
when I say the word carnival, when
1:46
I tell them it's what the book's
1:48
about. At least here in
1:50
America, it's all that comes
1:52
to mind. And
1:55
it's sad, really.
1:58
Carnival is like a party to which
2:00
America has not been invited. Yes,
2:03
we have Mardi Gras, but
2:05
New Orleans is a world
2:07
unto itself, so that doesn't
2:09
translate nationally. There's
2:12
something discomforting about being left out
2:14
of the party, so we're wrong -footed
2:16
even in attempts to talk about
2:18
it. We're uncertain even
2:20
how to spell or pronounce
2:22
this carnival. Just
2:24
to be sure people know we're
2:27
not discussing tilt to worlds
2:29
and cotton candy We might decide
2:31
the word needs a more
2:33
international spelling and add an e
2:35
Change some vowels or say
2:37
it kind of funny if you're
2:39
speaking for instance of the
2:41
Italian carnival you can
2:43
say carnival a but Carnival
2:45
is perfectly good for
2:47
describing any of these festivities
2:49
in whatever the country
2:51
it's universal and more
2:53
than acceptable. And
2:56
here's how we got there. Because
2:59
America doesn't do the European Carnival,
3:01
and since the word was
3:03
just sitting there, unused, we
3:06
Americans decided to give it
3:08
a new meaning in the 1890s.
3:10
Carnival began to be applied
3:12
to traveling shows modeled on the
3:14
success of the 1893 Chicago
3:16
World's Fair, Specifically, the
3:18
central area of Midway,
3:20
collection of rides, games, and
3:22
sideshow acts, which they
3:24
christened the Midway Plaisance, giving
3:26
us another generic term,
3:28
Midway, along with the gratuitous
3:31
French Plaisance for Pleasure,
3:33
another example of
3:35
our tendency to arbitrarily
3:37
internationalize things. Maybe
3:39
the transient nature of those Midway,
3:41
set up one day and gone
3:43
the next, suggests it's something analogous
3:45
to Carnival, and it's fleeting season
3:47
of pleasures. Like
3:50
the celebration, the traveling shows
3:52
arrived in town annually at
3:54
roughly the same time, but
3:56
with certain unpredictable variations, just
3:58
as Carnival shifts slightly year
4:00
to year thanks to its date being
4:02
anchored to Lent and, by extension,
4:04
Easter. This
4:07
lack of a fixed date
4:09
also makes Americans uneasy about
4:11
Carnival. The arcane calculations
4:13
by which Easter is
4:15
set It's a relic of
4:17
pre -Reformation Europe. The kind
4:19
of thing our patriotic forefathers
4:22
would have decried as Romish
4:24
Popery. It's
4:26
one thing to submit to the
4:28
fickleness of movable feasts when it
4:30
comes with chocolate eggs and peeps,
4:32
but Lent is altogether different. A
4:34
bridge too far for most Americans. Though
4:38
Lent is ostensibly part of
4:40
all Christian traditions, its role
4:42
is minimal in Protestant churches,
4:44
leaving its most powerful legacy
4:46
in Catholicism. This
4:49
idea of the Catholic's penitential
4:51
starvation is un -American enough,
4:53
but to then proceed it
4:55
with a season of rapacious
4:57
indulgence does not really sit
4:59
well in a country founded
5:01
upon coolly, rational,
5:04
enlightenment ideals. But
5:09
we are a broad -minded nation,
5:11
so We make the effort to
5:13
squeeze in those foreign words from
5:15
Catholic culture. We've assimilated the
5:17
term Mardi Gras, but the whole
5:20
thing is to tangle up in
5:22
beads and breastflashing for universal application
5:24
and its use is restricted to
5:26
a single day after all. Besides,
5:28
we already have the British
5:31
equivalent, Shrove Tuesday, or
5:33
Shrove Tide for the days
5:35
before Tuesday. But
5:37
Shrove is just as foreign as the
5:39
French. being British disqualifies it
5:41
as her go -to term since
5:44
Britain doesn't really have a carnival. It's
5:47
sad, but eating pancakes on
5:49
Shrove Tuesday doesn't really
5:51
count. As
5:57
you will have guessed, this book will
6:00
be going off the
6:02
beaten path. Beyond festivities
6:04
designated by Latin -derived names,
6:06
we'll explore the Fasnachs
6:08
of Germany, the Zapusta,
6:10
of Poland, the Czech
6:12
Masopost, the Russian Maslenitsa,
6:14
and the Bulgarian Siena
6:16
Zaksena to name just
6:19
a few. Enough
6:22
about the word. What exactly does
6:24
this book cover? Our
6:27
itinerary will begin in
6:29
Italy, looking at Rome's
6:31
influence, then on to
6:33
Venice and finally Germany. You're
6:36
hearing chapter one. Next
6:38
is... Chapter
6:40
2 Sardine
6:42
vs. Sausage
6:44
Here I offer
6:46
a sort of overview examining
6:48
how the Church's imposition of
6:51
Lent shaped Carnival as well
6:53
as some artistic responses this
6:55
engendered along the way you'll
6:57
learn about butter letters and
6:59
the burial of the sardine.
7:02
Chapter 3
7:04
Ancient Roots Here
7:08
we look at Carnival's possible origins
7:10
in the traditions of ancient Rome, both
7:13
pre -Christian and post -Constantine,
7:15
most plausibly in the
7:17
New Year's celebration of
7:19
the January Calumns. This
7:21
holiday, distinguished by raucous behavior,
7:24
grotesque costumes, and mockery of
7:26
those in power, was eventually
7:28
absorbed into the medieval feast
7:30
of fools, which contributed many
7:32
elements to Carnival. We'll
7:42
stay in the Eternal City,
7:44
but move into the High Middle Ages,
7:46
when the Latin term carne navarre
7:48
is first attached to public games and
7:51
spectacles, animal sacrifices in
7:53
the form of bullfights and
7:55
pigs tumbled down hillsides, and
7:57
even more cruel and compulsory
7:59
foot races humiliating those on
8:01
society's fringes. Stuff
8:03
which doesn't really fit how we think
8:05
of Carnival today. But
8:07
almost as old and slightly
8:10
less brutal is the Roman
8:12
tradition of racing wild horses
8:14
through the city streets. It
8:16
survived into the late 1800s. In
8:21
which
8:23
we encounter equally barbaric customs
8:26
and blood sports worlds
8:28
away from those iconic images
8:30
of the city's romantic
8:32
and aristocratic carnival. Moving
8:34
into the early modern period, we'll
8:36
see the birth of Venetian masking
8:38
traditions and along the way, somewhat
8:41
more civilized entertainments, acrobatic shows,
8:43
regattas, religious processions, all unique to
8:45
Venice and its history, and
8:47
we'll see how the use of
8:49
masks was related to the
8:51
throwing of eggs filled with confetti
8:54
or things much worse
8:56
or much better. describes
9:04
the introduction in the mid
9:06
-14th century of the Carnival
9:08
Parade, including early floats,
9:11
the spectacular rolling hells, as
9:13
they were called, along
9:15
with the surreal costumes of
9:17
Nuremberg's Schenbach Lauf. The
9:20
appearance in medieval Germany of
9:22
the iconic carnival fool is discussed,
9:25
along with the figures associated
9:27
with traditions, evolution, and the
9:29
contemporary practices of German fool
9:31
skills. You'll learn
9:33
about the humiliating fool's books
9:35
and the things they do
9:37
with the perfumed calf's
9:39
tail in the city of
9:41
Rottweil. After
9:45
these first, roughly chronological
9:47
chapters have laid a
9:49
historical groundwork, the subsequent
9:51
chapters are thematic. Chapter
9:55
7 Good Luck Visits
9:58
in which we look at house visiting customs
10:00
in Germany and Eastern Europe.
10:03
Includes the Czech killing of
10:05
the mayor ritual and
10:07
the Polish folk play
10:09
The Execution of Death. In
10:18
which we explore the
10:20
plough and log -filling
10:22
rites of Germany, Austria,
10:24
Italy, Slovenia, Croatia, Poland,
10:27
and Ukraine. Mock
10:29
weddings are discussed, including derisive
10:31
rituals binding together unmarried
10:33
young people and logs. And
10:36
my personal favorite, the
10:38
insanely chaotic Egitmon Festival
10:40
of Tarmine in South
10:43
Toul. Another
10:48
theme is monsters. Interspersed
10:51
throughout the book's second half
10:53
are chapters devoted to carnival
10:55
figures of a monstrous,
10:58
special, or otherwise
11:00
extraordinary nature. Chapter
11:03
9 The
11:05
Courant and the Plough Now,
11:08
nearly exclusively showcased in celebrations
11:10
in the town of Pew,
11:12
Slovenia, the Courant was
11:14
once part of a house visiting
11:16
tradition involving a magic plough that
11:19
imparted good luck and fertility. He's
11:21
recognizable by his voluminous
11:23
sheepskin tunic the ribboned
11:25
headpiece and mask with
11:27
dangling tongue. Which
11:37
introduces a Hungarian figure
11:39
also formally involved in
11:41
house visits, but now restricted
11:43
to public parades in the town of
11:45
Mohac on the Danube. He
11:48
wears a massive sheepskin coat,
11:50
horned hood, and comically fierce
11:52
wooden mask. and is armed
11:54
with a ratchet noisemaker. And,
11:59
with like bowl -pizzle, said to
12:01
convey fertility naturally, tradition
12:03
holds that the costume and
12:05
noisemakers are once used to drive
12:08
Turkish invaders from Mohac and
12:10
that Basques were once painted with
12:12
blood from slaughterhouses. Chapter
12:16
11. The
12:19
Kukeri. The
12:21
Bulgarian Kuker. plural
12:23
kukeri is perhaps the strangest
12:25
carnival figure of all, given
12:27
its bewildering variety of regionally different
12:30
forms. Performers representing
12:32
kukeri might wear towering headdresses,
12:34
costumes, and cloth masks
12:36
clustered with fringes, ribbons, beads,
12:38
and mirrors, or
12:40
appear ensconced in rustic
12:42
conglomerations of animal hides, horns,
12:44
skulls, tails, and feathers, sometimes
12:47
mounted in vertical configurations like
12:50
totem poles. Or
12:52
they might be nearly featureless
12:54
walking mound -like figures buried
12:56
in extravably long sheep
12:58
fur. All these variants may
13:00
be seen gathering in the Bulgarian
13:02
town of Panik for the Surva
13:04
Festival. In western Bulgaria,
13:06
Surva, beginning in January, blends
13:08
the festivities of carnival with
13:10
New Year's customs and celebrates
13:12
with house visits styled as
13:14
mock weddings. While in the
13:17
east of Bulgaria on Shrove Tuesday, Kukeri
13:19
perform folk play. the
13:21
plough ritual, destroying luck and
13:23
fertility on the community. The
13:31
Bears, awakening from winter's
13:33
hibernation, associates him
13:35
with that seasonal rebirth
13:38
celebrated by Carnival. In
13:40
the French and Spanish parodies, a
13:43
costumed bear becomes the hero of
13:45
folk plays, loosely enacted by the
13:47
communities in the Vale Spir region.
13:50
We also learned a bit about
13:52
magical Romani bear medicine and of
13:54
the particularly anarchic carnival celebrations in
13:56
Basque Country in which bears play
13:58
a supporting role. Describes
14:08
the unique carnival performances of
14:10
the Italian Islands Noires region,
14:12
where performers more often than
14:15
not cloak themselves in black,
14:17
and darkened in an exposed
14:19
flesh with burnt cork, and
14:21
acting mysterious at somber scenes,
14:23
often involving a control figure,
14:25
hurting, fighting, or killing
14:28
performers, representing beasts. Most
14:30
well -known are the Mamotons
14:32
of Mamiodas, hunched down
14:34
under massive loads of cowbells
14:36
and wearing black costumes, along
14:39
with grimacing angular masks.
14:42
Figures from roughly a dozen towns
14:44
are introduced, including the Colunganos,
14:46
dressed in green leaves and clattering
14:48
bones. Others who wear
14:50
goat or boar heads as hats,
14:52
and the Ayunod Oriodore, whose mask
14:54
is made from the pelvis of
14:56
a donkey, as seen on the
14:58
book's cover. Chapter
15:03
14 Killing
15:05
Carnival Appropriately
15:07
ends our tour providing a
15:10
wide -ranging look at the
15:12
mock executions and funerals of
15:14
figures embodying carnival, and
15:16
the relation of these customs
15:18
to German and Eastern European
15:20
traditions of driving out winter
15:22
or carrying out death, as
15:24
well as the burning of
15:26
the effigy of Muslimites by the
15:28
East Slavs. The drowning of
15:30
the effigy of Maidan and Poland
15:32
received special attention as a
15:34
genuinely pagan practice consistently documented back
15:36
to the century. The
15:45
preponderance of
15:47
Eastern European culture surveyed reflects
15:49
my interest in presenting the forgotten
15:51
carnival, not simply for the
15:53
sake of novelty, But because I
15:55
believe these countries offer the
15:58
best examples of an earlier form
16:00
of carnival's evolution throughout Europe,
16:02
specifically house -fitting customs, which
16:04
over time were supplanted and
16:06
standardized into a single municipal
16:09
parade. I
16:11
have neglected many larger parades, some
16:13
of which nonetheless have important
16:15
and interesting histories. The carnivals
16:17
of Cologne, Germany, Nice France,
16:19
and Basch, Belgium, are all
16:21
very old and significant, but,
16:23
like other omissions, didn't serve
16:25
the book's thematic or historical
16:27
narrative. At
16:30
least, that partially explains
16:32
my selectivity. But
16:34
there are other reasons. To
16:37
be honest, I
16:39
always considered carnival
16:41
a bit boring.
16:44
You may too and for
16:46
perfectly understandable reasons, but I've
16:48
come around and have high
16:50
hopes of helping like -minded readers
16:52
beyond this hurdle. Allow
16:55
me to first lay out some
16:57
of my own ugly prejudices. Perhaps you
16:59
share some of these sentiments. I
17:02
don't like plastic. I
17:05
don't like fluorescent colors. I
17:09
don't like crowds. There's
17:13
something soulless and plastic, but
17:15
all the most famous carnivals,
17:17
barring that of Venice, rely
17:19
on plastic. Fiberglass for the
17:21
construction of floats and sometimes
17:23
masks. Fiberglass is
17:25
no good at representing texture or
17:28
detail, so this is approximated through
17:30
the heavy use of airbrushed colors
17:32
that probably should have included airbrush
17:34
on my list, but I didn't
17:36
claim it was exhaustive. Fluorescent
17:38
colors perhaps don't dominate the palette
17:41
of every large carnival, but they
17:43
needn't. Even a moderate use of
17:45
fluorescent colors is enough to cause
17:47
a crippling distrust of carnivals across
17:49
the board. As for
17:51
crowds, this is universal with
17:53
any carnival of note, as well
17:55
as any unremarkable but large
17:57
urban carnival. It necessitates arriving
17:59
too early and taking too long to
18:01
get your ride when it's over. In
18:04
between, there's a lot of
18:06
standing, at least five deep, usually
18:08
more, and straining to see
18:10
over and around heads is plastic,
18:12
fluorescent, airbrushed, monstrosities creep by. All
18:15
while enduring a crowded numbness
18:17
in your feet and considering the
18:19
obstacles faced in negotiating a
18:21
path to a public restroom. There
18:23
is such a thing. Also,
18:27
no one likes marching bands. No
18:30
one. And
18:36
finally, a more
18:38
ideological issue. If
18:40
Carnival represents a
18:42
seasonal spree of madness,
18:45
is that best expressed in the
18:47
form of these large parades
18:50
with celebrants regimented into identical costumes
18:52
marching with fife and drum? It's
18:55
all a bit militant. It
18:57
feels miserably at the topsy
18:59
-turvy ideals of Carnival. The
19:06
sort of celebrations I've been describing
19:08
are not universal to Carnival. This
19:11
book focuses largely on smaller
19:13
scale festivities in smaller towns
19:15
and villages, in
19:17
part because these have received less
19:19
attention elsewhere, and in part because
19:21
they illustrate that earlier stage in
19:23
Carnival's evolution, but
19:25
also as a purely
19:27
aesthetic choice. In
19:30
these folk carnivals, costumes worn
19:32
or made by hand improvised
19:34
from hides, horns, and straw.
19:36
Faces are often blacked with
19:38
soot or hidden under wooden
19:40
masks with sheepskin hoods. Figures
19:42
wearing these costumes gather in
19:44
town squares and central streets
19:46
and village ins and halls.
19:49
But also visit homes and isolated
19:51
farmhouses, sometimes in groups no
19:53
larger than a handful. Such
19:56
celebrations generally exist alongside
19:58
much larger ones. In
20:01
these, participants from the Hinterlands come
20:03
together to demonstrate their local customs
20:05
in regional exhibitions. In
20:07
recent years, most of these have become
20:09
quite large, even drawing visitors from overseas.
20:12
But the style of celebration of
20:15
the costumes worn has retained
20:17
its original look, as the cultures
20:19
hosting these gatherings tend to
20:21
be more bound by tradition and
20:23
heritage. I'll
20:35
happily confess that my interest in
20:37
such things has grown side by side
20:40
with an interest in a genre
20:42
which only recently received a name, Folk
20:45
Horror. This probably
20:47
accounts for my predisposition to
20:49
focus on certain darker aspects
20:51
of Carnival and its history,
20:54
I notice this is quantitatively
20:56
evidenced in the text
20:58
discovering a telling frequency of
21:00
certain words, blood,
21:02
or bloody, appearing 25
21:04
times, pagan 24, and
21:07
the word devil showing up 43
21:10
times. In particular, the
21:12
chapters examining the roots of
21:14
Carnival in Rome and Venice contain
21:16
genuinely horrific elements, as mentioned
21:18
above. These are
21:20
not, however, sacrifices
21:22
offered to pagan gods, as imagined
21:24
in folk horror tales. The
21:27
paganism presented in this book
21:29
is comprised of a body
21:31
of rural superstitions and beliefs
21:33
that largely coexisted with Christian
21:35
practice, undifferentiated in the common
21:37
person's world, perhaps condemned by
21:39
more exacting Catholic or Orthodox
21:42
clerics. The
21:44
uncovering of pre -Christian roots and
21:46
carnival traditions, which might be expected
21:48
of this book, is very
21:50
difficult to prove, no matter
21:52
how often connections to Dionysus might
21:54
be suggested. In
21:56
the final chapter on
21:58
killing carnival, however, I
22:00
explore some Slavic customs which
22:02
possibly could be said to
22:05
derive from pre -Christian traditions. My
22:15
previous book, The Krampus and the
22:17
Old Dark Christmas, was
22:19
inspired in part by this enthusiasm
22:21
for folk horror, but also by
22:23
my interest in German culture, which
22:25
accounts for any disproportionate treatment German
22:27
customs in this book. When
22:30
I first encountered Krampus customs, I was
22:32
not aware to what extent they borrowed
22:34
from older carnival tradition. The
22:36
bells warred being a prime example.
22:39
Nor, to what extent, the predecessor of
22:41
the Krampus, the folkloric parish, itself
22:43
would be considered a carnival figure,
22:45
thanks to its association with the
22:47
Piphany on January 6. Many
22:50
aspects of both Krampus and
22:52
parish customs are common within Carnival,
22:55
throughout Europe, as far away
22:57
as Bulgaria and Greece, as we'll
22:59
see. In
23:01
this volume, you'll notice a persistent
23:03
emphasis on the interplay between carnival
23:05
traditions and those of the Christmas
23:07
season. Epiphany is central to
23:09
this as it's regarded both as the
23:11
end of one season and the beginning
23:13
of the other. At
23:15
times it may seem I'm
23:18
describing Christmas as when Eastern European
23:20
carnival carols are mentioned, or
23:22
in reference to snow still being
23:24
on the ground during many
23:26
of the festivities discussed. A
23:30
strange and fearsome
23:32
world. You
23:34
probably didn't expect Christmas in
23:36
your carnival. nor snow and
23:38
bloody sacrifices. The
23:40
book you're holding will push aside
23:42
all that festive fiberglass to
23:45
show you an unknown carnival, where
23:47
inflated pig bladders are commonly
23:49
carried by clowns, and clubs covered
23:51
in hedgehog spines are carried
23:53
by monsters. The blood of
23:55
costume bearers is drunk as wine, plows
23:58
are dragged over cobblestone
24:00
streets sawdust scattered as sea,
24:03
where masks are painted in blood and
24:06
bones wore in
24:08
costumes, where Basque men in
24:10
their underwear take sledgehammers to hold
24:12
cars, and Sardinians wail
24:14
over plastic baby dolls making
24:16
lewd jokes or push filled
24:19
with burning hair toward the
24:21
crotches of onlookers to induce
24:23
fertility. Carnival
24:26
can be very strange.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More