Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
when i see the word
0:01
change, what you think?
0:03
do you you think loss do think
0:05
challenges or do you think you
0:08
be thinking which is opportunity
0:10
because change is your
0:13
greatest opportunity?
0:14
as long as you're willing to treat it that way in
0:17
my new book build for tomorrow i
0:19
show you how by diving headlong
0:21
into what change does to you and how
0:23
you can use it to your advantage i
0:26
found that everyone goes through change in
0:28
four phases they are panic
0:30
adaptation new normal and wouldn't
0:33
go back and that the most successful
0:35
people simply move through those faces
0:37
faster so how do they do it that's
0:39
what i spent years studying and came
0:41
away with concrete steps that you can
0:44
take to lessen your panic adopt
0:46
faster define your new normal
0:48
and thrive going forward reinvention
0:51
is not about grit it's a process
0:54
anyone can learn my book
0:56
build for tomorrow can show you show you
0:58
can pre-order it now from anywhere you get you
1:05
the title is easy to remember because
1:07
it's the same name is this podcast build
1:09
for tomorrow this
1:12
is billed for tomorrow a podcast about
1:14
the smartest solutions are most misunderstood
1:16
problems i'm jason cipher and in
1:19
each episode i take something that seems concerning
1:21
or confusing today and figure out where
1:23
it came from what important things were missing
1:26
and how we can create more opportunity tomorrow
1:29
nobody wants to work anymore
1:32
if you've heard anything about work
1:34
in the past year or so than that is probably
1:37
what you've heard people say
1:39
it on it v they say it on social media
1:41
they say it at the office they say it
1:43
in surveys like the one from software
1:45
company tiny paul's which found that
1:47
one in five executives agree
1:50
with the statement nobody wants to work
1:52
any more people also say it on
1:54
you tube like this finance bro
1:56
who really who really you to watches crypto
1:58
investment tips
2:00
videos really about how no one
2:02
wants to work anymore and
2:05
kim kardashians saying it
2:07
it seems like nobody wants to work
2:08
and so are business owners
2:11
like this bar owner on a fox t v affiliate
2:13
in ohio people don't want to work we
2:15
have set of interviews people don't show
2:18
and let's be clear zero is
2:21
a real problems here there is a problem
2:23
for business owners who business speak to all
2:25
the time and who struggled to operate their
2:27
businesses because they cannot feel they're open
2:29
jobs and there is and problem for workers
2:32
who are looked down upon and called lazy
2:34
and not given the opportunities they believe they deserve
2:37
this deserve this problem that impacts everyone
2:39
which means we better figure out how to solve
2:41
it the first do that we
2:44
have to agree on what the problem actually
2:46
is so how do we do that
2:49
the answer seems to be buried right
2:51
there in the phrase nobody wants to
2:53
work any more listen to a closely
2:56
nobody wants to work any more
2:58
the problem is located in the word anymore
3:02
anymore is a dividing line in time
3:04
between when people did one work and
3:06
when people do not the problem
3:08
it seems is now something
3:11
about now the pandemic
3:13
and all the came after has created a moment
3:15
where nobody wants to work which means that if we're going
3:17
to solve this problem we need to figure out how
3:19
to solve the problem of to day
3:23
wait a second before we go too far
3:25
down that path or someone else
3:27
you need to hear from
3:29
the becoming apparent that nobody
3:31
wants to work this hard time
3:34
that quote is from the year eighteen
3:36
ninety four it was written in a newspaper
3:39
called the rooks county record
3:41
and labor is scary as
3:44
ha and very unreliable
3:46
no one wants to work for wages
3:48
that is from the year nineteen
3:50
o five in the edge field advertiser
3:53
and there are many many many
3:56
more just like it people complaining that nobody
3:58
wants to work anymore in night sixteen
4:01
and in nineteen fifty two in nineteen
4:03
eighty one these they were unearthed
4:05
recently by a university of calgary instructor
4:07
named paul theory he posted a thread
4:09
of them on twitter in july and a went super
4:11
viral and then a bunch of people tagged be in the
4:13
responses because they know i love this stuff
4:16
in there right and as soon
4:18
as i saw it saw it started wondering what
4:20
was happening during all those previous times
4:22
in history when people said nobody wanted to work
4:24
anymore because maybe there's something really
4:27
valuable that we can learn from
4:29
the past to help inform our
4:31
understanding of the present so i
4:33
figured what i needed with someone who has
4:35
i dunno written a book on the
4:37
history of work are actually read
4:39
the book on history work bingo my
4:42
name is peter serves i am a university
4:44
professor of history and george mason i
4:46
asked peter if he could take a trip through
4:49
history with me explaining some of
4:51
these quotes and how they might apply to today
4:53
and he said he'd be happy to because
4:55
as he explained when we got on the phone most
4:58
of this judgment about the decline of work
5:00
the represents an oversimplification
5:02
of the past when you really dig
5:05
into the past the nature of our problem
5:07
today becomes a lot clearer by
5:09
the end of our conversation our conversation something
5:12
when someone says nobody wants to
5:14
work anymore they are speaking a
5:16
partial truth part of that
5:18
sentence is correct but it's
5:20
missing a very important part
5:22
and if we cannot identify that missing
5:24
part and speak it out loud and ticket
5:26
very seriously and we will never
5:28
solve this problem we won't
5:30
solve this for businesses and we won't solve for
5:32
workers and we won't solve it for anyone at
5:34
any time including right now so
5:37
what is that missing part it is
5:39
time to take a trip through the history of
5:41
work and discover that no matter of a decade
5:44
people really do want to work maybe
5:46
just not the way that we think growing
5:49
up after the break if you
5:51
are an entrepreneur really minded person
5:53
if you are always thinking what's the next big
5:55
idea for a business or just even a side
5:57
hustle will then i've got a podcast
6:00
for you, listen to my first
6:02
million the to hosts sean
6:04
perry and sampar have both started
6:06
and sold their own businesses to amazon and
6:08
hubspot every week, they brainstormed
6:11
business ideas that you can start tomorrow
6:13
he can be little side hustles that
6:15
make you ten grand a month or big that could be
6:17
a billion-dollar thing they also
6:19
chat with entrepreneurs and investors celebrities
6:21
and billionaires about business ideas in trend
6:24
they're investigation i recommend checking
6:26
out there recent episode with andrew wilkinson,
6:28
where he talked about white getting rich, slow
6:30
is better than getting rich quick they
6:33
also talked about the pillars of happiness,
6:35
how to identify winners and much more these
6:37
are kinds of of that can get you thinking
6:40
big and then acting big so check
6:42
it out just search for my first
6:44
million on apple podcasts
6:46
spotify or whatever you listen podcasts
6:50
did you know that
6:52
the average podcast listeners subscribes
6:54
to six well,
6:56
assuming you already to to my show than
6:59
i have a great reason for you to add another
7:01
one is called the jordan harbinger
7:03
show and honestly jordan is a friend of mine
7:05
but i would recommend it even if he wasn't because
7:07
i love this show in his interview style
7:10
and just the whole thing stored in dad's
7:12
into the minds of fascinating people
7:14
of athletes authors and scientists to
7:16
mobsters spies of hostage negotiators
7:19
he has a real talent for drawing out never
7:21
heard before stories and thought provoking insights
7:23
and he always pulls out tactical fits of
7:25
wisdom in each episode all with the noble
7:27
cause of making you more informed
7:30
and a better critical thinker there's good
7:32
reason that jordan is the guy i text basically
7:34
every time i have a question about podcasting that's
7:36
because he is the master at it smart funny
7:39
easy to listen to check out his thirties with see
7:41
pain from a little while ago i have never heard
7:43
the guy talk like that you'll be hard pressed
7:45
to find that episode without excellent conversation
7:47
a few laughs and actual advice that you can
7:49
directly used to improve your life see
7:52
can't go wrong with adding the jordan
7:54
harbinger show to your rotation it's
7:56
incredibly interesting and there's never a dull shirts
7:58
search for the george the harbinger
8:00
show that is h a r p as in boy
8:03
i n as in nancy gd
8:05
are on apple podcasts spot
8:07
a fi or wherever you listen to podcasts
8:10
all right we're back so our goal is
8:12
to understand why it seems that nobody wants
8:15
to work anymore today and why that
8:17
isn't exactly right and to
8:19
do this we're going to go back through the
8:21
history of people saying that nobody wants to work
8:23
anymore looking at specific moments
8:25
when people said it and what was going on during
8:27
their time and how it can help us better
8:29
understand today so
8:31
let's start with the earliest clipping from
8:33
that twitter thread it's the article from the
8:35
rooks county her old and eighty ninety four
8:38
which you heard a little bit of before but
8:40
now i'll give you some more context
8:42
the article describes or the mines
8:44
in mines country that are being shut down because of striking
8:47
workers and it wonders what people
8:49
will do for coal when winter comes
8:52
then the article concludes with what you
8:54
heard before
8:54
or is is becoming apparent that
8:56
nobody wants to work this hard
8:58
time
8:59
the last peter what's going on
9:02
here so the
9:04
timing is interesting there really
9:06
were some significant changes in the arrangement
9:08
of work by the later nineteenth century
9:11
we're going to go through two of these significant
9:13
changes because they set up a good understanding
9:16
of like every work conflicts
9:18
that comes after so here's significant
9:20
change number one because of union
9:23
action and legislation the length
9:25
of the work day at the turn of the century was getting
9:27
shorter it was going from twelve hours
9:29
to ten hours and then ultimately eight and
9:31
this was happening at the same time as
9:34
america was becoming more industrialized and
9:36
therefore the work that people were doing was
9:38
changing which sounds good
9:40
in theory you know less backbreaking
9:42
work on the farm and fewer hours
9:44
in the heat but in practice it
9:46
was a her transition is a traditional
9:48
work day particularly during
9:50
the summer when the sun was out the
9:53
additional workday was really long
9:56
except in harvest time he wasn't that intense
9:58
people to apps
9:59
they wanted around they saying
10:02
sometimes they drake well
10:04
modern work in this in this to
10:06
where the into the nineties or truth or rearrange
10:09
so instead of a long but somewhat
10:11
so based work day and
10:14
sleep
10:15
we now have a more intense workday
10:18
a period of non work
10:20
some sleep in this moment something
10:22
happened that has repeated itself ever
10:24
since and that is as the
10:26
nature of work changed workers
10:28
saw an opportunity to participate
10:30
in the shaping of the work they
10:33
didn't just want to be told hey here's
10:35
what work is now and here's what you'll be paid
10:37
and as if they wanted a better deal
10:39
for their hard work and that drove their decisions
10:41
about what work to do and what
10:43
work to refuse to do and you could
10:45
understand why people looked at him says gee
10:47
they just want to work anymore
10:49
there's just not correct do you think
10:52
back then the people who are saying gee
10:54
they don't want to work anymore we're probably people
10:56
who did not have to work
10:59
in the kind of grinding manual
11:01
labor as labor of our part of what's
11:03
your pick it up but it's still true today abby
11:05
se lo say this and this don't mean that to
11:08
be tested or basically said we
11:10
want we want of people who work the way we want to tell
11:12
do we don't want to work that way
11:14
we want them to and by the way good enough
11:16
a them too much now let's look at significant
11:19
change number two just
11:21
as people's work lives were shifting
11:23
so where their social lives speak
11:25
as back of the late eighteen hundreds leisure
11:27
was becoming more available
11:29
so you have professional sports
11:31
you have the beginning of the rise
11:33
of movies i'm not talk and eighty
11:35
ninety ninety hundreds you have
11:37
to rise of amusement parks i'm
11:40
on a people still didn't use those things
11:42
but obviously some people did and
11:44
people began to talk about what was
11:46
called the leisure at
11:47
though this made it easy for some
11:49
people to say gee people just want to play around
11:52
it's they don't want to work as much peter says
11:54
that this has been extensively studied
11:56
in the united states and the conclusion is clear
12:00
i did not want to work less
12:02
just because they had access to more leisure in
12:04
fact a can be argued that some people wanted
12:06
to work even more because more work
12:09
meant more money which meant more luxurious
12:11
leisure but because leisure activities
12:13
were so visible this created a perception
12:15
problem
12:16
the we'll be more gentle jet engine to leisure
12:19
than we do to work on that that causes some
12:21
confusion
12:22
which man the people looked lazy
12:24
just because they were spending the money that they
12:26
had earned through their hard work which
12:28
sounds to be a lot like people
12:30
who you know i don't know say today the kids
12:33
don't wanna work they just want to post videos on tic
12:35
toc and it's like node
12:37
their to talks are just more visible than the work that
12:39
they do okay so that covers
12:42
are basic setup that's what was happening
12:44
was happening late eighteen hundreds now let's move
12:46
on to another moment of nobody wants to
12:48
work anymore this one is a scene
12:50
from a newspaper in nineteen sixteen
12:53
back then papers were full of these like
12:55
free floating stories it's not clear who
12:57
wrote them or whether they actually happened
13:00
but they're a good indication of what people
13:02
have the time we're talking and thinking about
13:04
and this one the subtle story published
13:07
in the binghamton press was titled
13:09
nobody wants to work here's the
13:11
whole thing
13:12
what about vegetables
13:14
having been a good yes the vegetables
13:17
to deal with asked well
13:19
as near as i can find out he answered
13:21
the reason for food scarcity is
13:23
that nobody wants to work as hard
13:26
as they used yeah man
13:28
who within here the other day why she didn't
13:30
raise more livestock and make his own
13:32
but
13:33
women don't wanna make got him anymore he
13:35
said and then yeah
13:36
do you know where prices would go
13:38
with we read more cabs and pig the
13:41
made more butter they would go
13:43
way down
13:45
interesting right so i asked peter
13:47
the word now talk about how people don't want
13:49
to work as hard in agriculture so
13:52
they're they're claiming that there was a time i guess before
13:54
nineteen sixteen when people did want to work
13:56
hard in agriculture splitter also identifying
13:59
that
13:59
some of the labor force it used to be
14:02
created butter which would be women are not working
14:04
anymore so what what were they seeing
14:06
in agriculture and to i guess what
14:08
happened to the whims
14:10
okay so it was deal with both parts
14:12
of that they're both interesting and they're mostly
14:14
not the same thing okay ,
14:16
same number one and this has been true and every
14:19
industrial society there
14:21
are certain jobs once
14:23
you read his reach read his level of industrial
14:25
prosperity there are certain jobs
14:28
that people just don't want to do anymore
14:30
says absolutely true solve
14:33
most americans even when they're
14:35
unemployed even when they're relatively poor
14:37
do not want to do
14:39
harvesting work this is why
14:42
harvesting is generally done by immigrants
14:44
they are coming from countries that do not have
14:46
access to the level of industrial prosperity
14:48
that americans have and therefore these immigrants
14:51
are willing to do the work that most americans will not
14:53
this fact has repeated itself across
14:55
time and space is not
14:58
an american saying that this is and everything
15:00
sex so in this story from nineteen
15:02
sixteen when the character says
15:04
no one wants to work as hard as they
15:06
used to
15:07
what he really should have said is no
15:09
one wants to work these very difficult jobs
15:11
as much as they had to because now
15:13
they do not have to again
15:16
this this a question of hard work because people are still
15:18
working hard as a willing to work
15:20
hard it is instead a question of
15:22
better available options now
15:24
let's talk about the other thing in that stories
15:27
remember the men in the peace and they
15:29
were both clearly meant they
15:31
were complaining that women no longer
15:33
wanted to churn butter or that was creating
15:35
all sorts of problems so what
15:37
was up with all the lazy women okay so
15:41
this has been fairly extensively studied
15:44
the for the nineteenth century when america
15:46
had a primarily agricultural
15:48
economy work mostly took place
15:51
at home as a result women
15:53
were very involved in what was classified
15:55
as work but then it
15:57
does work moved out of the home
15:59
we're mostly assigned to own tasks
16:02
so in one sense third overall
16:04
changed and if you were sort
16:06
of simplistic about it and maybe the little
16:08
the such a the state you can say they're networking
16:11
site murray study
16:13
indicates that the women
16:15
who were homemaker so com
16:17
work really hard at this
16:19
because for example do you
16:22
know what it was like washing clothing
16:24
before a washing machine it
16:26
was an insane day long
16:28
process that would leave your hands are
16:30
all and when one labor
16:33
saving appliance showed up like vacuum
16:35
cleaners instead of taken the time
16:37
off the increase their cleanliness
16:40
standards so
16:41
it really was not true that women
16:43
weren't working they just want working as
16:45
does a plates and sure there were probably
16:48
a few things like butter turning it
16:50
has dissipated in that it was cheaper to buy
16:52
which is so interesting right we
16:54
have the stereotypical image of women
16:57
churning butter but let's remember they
16:59
weren't by running or tis
17:01
little butter shops they were churning butter
17:03
to feed their families but once the economy
17:06
shifted it just didn't make economic sense
17:08
for women to do that anymore butter
17:10
had become cheaper and as cleanliness
17:12
standards rose their time was consumed
17:14
more and more in the home where they were working
17:17
just as hard if not harder than
17:19
ever before but being appreciated
17:21
for it less and less so what
17:23
have we learned so far we've learned
17:26
this the nature of work is
17:28
consistently changing and will it
17:30
change happens people naturally
17:32
adjust the kind of work that they do sometimes
17:35
they are able to seek better working conditions
17:37
sometimes they are not but either way they're
17:39
new work will be compared against what a previous
17:41
generations used to do for work and the previous
17:44
generations work will be considered hard
17:46
work therefore because the new generations
17:48
work does not look like the all generations work the
17:50
new generation will be criticized for not wanting
17:52
to work anymore which isn't fair
17:54
or true but that's what it is
17:58
onward to the mulberry
17:59
those in nineteen twenty two
18:02
what is the cause of unemployment and
18:04
hard times the manufacturer
18:07
and businessmen say it is because
18:09
nobody wants to work anymore
18:12
unless they can be paid enough wages
18:15
to work half of the time
18:17
and
18:17
though half of the
18:19
time so okay
18:22
whatever that
18:23
so he really was true that
18:25
increasingly workers were not willing
18:27
to work as lawyer hours as they had
18:30
been before began to formalize
18:32
to weekend as a non formal wear a period
18:35
but they were work and harder when they
18:37
were already this was after all the period when
18:39
assembly lines were being and stuff and
18:42
the pace were just visibly speeded
18:44
up though the notion that
18:46
somehow the blue collar labor
18:49
force was getting lazy that's
18:51
not right the system was changing
18:55
their willingness to hold
18:57
out for better wages well
18:59
i mean basically for many people
19:02
do the modern work bargain was
19:04
our pretty hard at jobs
19:06
that are not entirely
19:08
the only do it if you get a little
19:10
my give me enough money to have a little
19:12
bit and your of enjoyment outside the job
19:14
and i was obviously being instrumentalized
19:16
by the by the early twentieth century
19:19
for a lot of blue collar workers it's
19:21
interesting because i feel like both what you're
19:23
describing right then in the twenties and
19:26
you know than one hundred years later in
19:28
our modern time is in a way
19:30
something of the same thing here you'd you'd said
19:32
the system was changing back then and the system
19:34
is changing now and
19:37
white i guess we see in both cases
19:39
it is essentially workers seeing
19:42
essentially system change ceiling it because
19:44
they are they are closest to it frankly
19:46
and saying well are
19:48
going to be sure that i find something
19:50
that works for me hear it and so
19:53
that require that that's going to create a kind of shift
19:55
in the jobs of people going
19:57
to take or the way that the going to take them with
19:59
then maybe others who are
20:02
not having to work as blue collar jobs just
20:04
are equating to these people don't want to work
20:06
anymore either yeah
20:08
yeah yeah one other thing that see
20:10
if you don't mind a little
20:12
bit one of the thing that's happening now is
20:14
really interesting and it's been
20:16
exacerbated or or encouraged by the pandemic
20:20
is the increasing numbers are numbered
20:22
people who are able to work at
20:24
least in part from home and this is really
20:26
interesting because it
20:28
needs some people to think well
20:30
if they're working from home they're probably not
20:32
working as hard as they would
20:34
at the office then again
20:37
here you're dealing with a systems change no
20:39
question i believe every
20:41
indication is these people working
20:43
from home or just as productive
20:46
they would have been if they've gone into the office
20:48
they may be doing it in pajamas but that's irrelevant
20:51
to this particular discussion but
20:53
it is confusing right it's
20:55
like you're seeing a new thing
20:58
through an old lands in which the only
21:00
way that you understand hard
21:02
work is if it looks like
21:05
what you've learned hard work looks like
21:07
the air and era and era and it doesn't
21:09
look like that now then you have
21:12
to assume it simply isn't hard work
21:14
not let's jump ahead
21:17
because i want to get out of these major
21:19
industrial changes in the turn of the century and just
21:21
see what you make of somebody insights
21:24
that there's not really a whole lot of contacts year but i'm
21:26
just curious what you think this person might have been sinking
21:28
so in nineteen sixty town arizona
21:30
does this quote the just as
21:32
how many say the other day that everybody
21:34
was getting killed darn ladies and
21:36
nobody wants to work anymore that's
21:39
the truth if i ever did
21:40
that by the way was from a paper
21:42
called the evergreen current so
21:45
all right what was going on the
21:47
nineteen sixties to say that nobody wanted
21:49
work anymore my guess is
21:51
that so this so this beginning to reflect
21:54
and new same
21:55
that obviously still wear this and
21:57
that is well we're very aware
22:00
that the welfare rolls are expanding
22:04
people are taken fitness
22:06
insurance unemployment insurance etc
22:09
there really wasn't available until the thirties
22:12
the you begin to have a category of people
22:14
who are welfare recipients
22:16
and as you will know cause it's
22:18
still true a lot of prejudice
22:21
developed about these people they're
22:23
goofing off their taken taxpayer money
22:26
and they're just unwilling to work every
22:29
evidence he is and again i'm not talk
22:31
about every individual every
22:33
evidence is that most of the
22:35
people who take welfare would
22:37
much prefer to work if
22:40
they were physically able to do so
22:42
he's jobs were available that were relevant
22:45
for them
22:46
there is a category of
22:48
people who at least for extended periods
22:51
of their lives do take welfare
22:53
and of course this exact issue
22:56
played out in the last few years there was a belief
22:58
that when the government started giving people money
23:00
during the pandemic it disincentivize
23:02
them to work so the calls
23:04
went out for many politicians saying cut off
23:06
the subsidies the people will get back to work
23:09
and of course now we know the result of that
23:11
i've , there were some people surely
23:13
that didn't work because of the subsidies but
23:15
when the subsidies expired the labor shortage
23:18
remained so that was not
23:20
the solution as peter was explaining
23:23
this he said something that really struck me
23:25
some people to believe there's a speech
23:27
of the people big chunk of people that
23:29
are simply freeloader that
23:32
different from the past because in the past
23:34
everybody had to work has obviously truth
23:36
that in the past we didn't have those guns welfare
23:38
systems and therefore the people
23:40
who were
23:41
riding on what is
23:44
visible as a category
23:46
i heard that and thought that's
23:48
really interesting way to look at it because
23:50
before wealthier it's not like everyone
23:53
was an able bodies and prosperous worker
23:55
so what happened to the people who
23:57
would have been on welfare before
23:59
there was well they're like people who are
24:01
sick or injured or could not work for some
24:03
reason what do they do i mean
24:05
in some cases they just wouldn't i
24:08
media would have started they would you got sick they
24:10
wouldn't die or he said they would have
24:12
begged on the street or picked through garbage
24:15
but he short no matter what the important thing to
24:17
recognizes that they would have been invisible
24:20
they would have been very easy for the average
24:22
working person to ignore then
24:24
when welfare began the system made these
24:27
people visible and once they were visible
24:29
they were labeled not as people who needed help
24:31
but as people who didn't want to work
24:34
anymore
24:35
right
24:36
now it's time to get into are more modern
24:39
version of this conversation we're gonna look
24:41
at why kids these days suppose we
24:43
don't want to work hard what happened when
24:45
we all started working on computers and
24:47
what this can all ultimately tell us
24:49
about how to solve our problem now
24:52
i've also got a really awesome
24:54
hand intimate insight into what that
24:56
conversation is looking like in an industry
24:59
that has been super hard hit
25:01
with labour shortages today so
25:03
that and more is coming up
25:05
after the break
25:08
when you are looking to improve look
25:10
for the improvements that build on themselves
25:13
like hiring for your business you
25:15
get better at hiring you hire great people
25:17
faster your business grows and you get
25:19
to keep on hiring so how
25:21
do you get better at hiring you
25:23
need indeed indeed
25:26
is the hiring platform where you can attract
25:28
interview and higher all in one place
25:31
instead of spending hours on multiple job sites searching
25:33
for candidates with the right skills indeed is a
25:35
powerful hiring partner that can help you
25:37
do it all find great count faster
25:39
through timesaving tools like indeed instant
25:42
match assessments and virtual interviews
25:44
with instant match for example over eighty
25:46
percent of employers get quality candidates
25:48
whose resume on indeed matches their
25:51
job description the moment the
25:53
sponsor a job according to indeed data
25:55
us so you ready to
25:57
get going start hiring now
25:59
the seventy five dollars sponsored job
26:02
credit to upgrade your job post at
26:04
indeed dot com slash archive
26:06
offer good for a limited time clean
26:09
your seventy five dollar credit now
26:11
at indeed dot com slash archive
26:14
indeed dot com slash archive terms
26:16
and conditions apply need to hire you need
26:18
indeed
26:22
okay we're back so it's time to skip
26:24
a few decades we're going to land in nineteen
26:26
eighty one where we find this complaint
26:29
printed in the miami herald i hired
26:31
two boys
26:32
cleared the rocks off the land this week
26:35
but they just fooled around they didn't
26:37
want to work
26:39
anymore so
26:41
you don't have been complaining the kids don't want
26:43
to work hard as far as you know
26:45
ever since people started having kids okay
26:49
, there's a theme here that a new
26:52
new don't know what's happening since i retired
26:55
but beyond the obvious pure says there
26:58
are actually are few interesting things
27:00
to know here because the expectations
27:02
we have for children have drastically changed
27:04
in the last century and last half child labor
27:06
laws began being passed and eighteen forties
27:09
though they weren't well and forth for and while
27:11
but by the late nineteenth century and
27:13
especially after nineteen sixteen the amount of child
27:15
labor really went down then people
27:17
believed that the basic purpose of childhood
27:20
is to go to school instead of go to
27:22
work and that can be confusing
27:25
to everybody because some
27:27
while school involves work it's not
27:29
the same kind of work is not
27:31
as visible it's not productive in the
27:33
short run
27:34
so kids started to get this reputation
27:36
as being lazy because we were asking
27:39
them to do more work that we don't count
27:41
as work and as you're
27:43
about to see the situation becomes
27:45
really given take the we
27:48
give them more of one kind of work we take
27:50
another kind away and then we just gotta keep
27:52
judging them for example the amount of chores
27:54
that kids do at home has steadily declined
27:57
since the nineteen twenties now part
28:00
because there aren't as many things
28:02
that kids can do in the home when
28:05
i was a kid and i'm obviously older
28:08
one ensure that was pretty common
28:10
was you helped take ashes
28:12
out of the furnace but we don't do that anymore
28:14
because we don't have as isn't the first it
28:16
is also all sorts of other things that they don't have to do
28:18
anymore for example kids used to take care
28:20
of their younger siblings but smaller families
28:23
means a smaller age differential between oldest
28:25
and youngest which is why for example it
28:27
is totally unrealistic for me to
28:30
expect my seven year old to take care of my three year
28:32
old and also kids used to
28:34
wash dishes more but now we have a dishwasher
28:36
for that and also teenagers
28:39
now take fewer low paying part time
28:41
and summer jobs today than they did before
28:43
a vote that's at least in part because those jobs
28:46
which were once held by teenagers have been steadily
28:48
and increasingly held by full grown
28:51
adults so did we turn
28:53
kids into spoiled brats know
28:55
because as traditional children's ware activities
28:57
declined we increase their demands in other areas
29:00
kids are expected to work harder at school that
29:02
he did fifty years ago there's a greater emphasis
29:05
on getting into college which means high academic
29:07
standards which means more time and stress
29:09
associated with school work we'll so pile
29:11
on tons of extracurricular activities which
29:13
means asking your kids to constantly learn
29:16
and refine and perform new skills and
29:18
volunteering among kids has also gone
29:21
though the difficulty of measurement
29:23
here is it's not necessarily
29:25
true the kids are willing to work close hard
29:28
they're not work and at the same sex
29:30
and yet some people will always equate
29:33
that too
29:34
nobody wants to work anymore
29:36
right let's jump another decade ahead
29:39
to nineteen ninety nine where this
29:41
complaint from the st petersburg times
29:43
really puts everything we've talked about into stark
29:45
relief nobody wants to work
29:47
anymore see
29:48
say and they all wanna
29:50
work in front of a computer and
29:52
make lots of money
29:55
which held so funny now but also
29:57
of course they say that ninety nine
29:59
nine i know lots of people who
30:02
work very very hard myself included a
30:04
but spend the majority of our time in front of a computer
30:07
so i will grant that that
30:09
is i'm physically easier than
30:11
manual labor but i it it it doesn't
30:13
mean that people aren't working hard what do you make
30:16
look i'm a duty basically set correctly
30:19
again is a situation where work
30:21
technology changes which means
30:23
that people who were accustomed to an
30:25
owner method of doing things a little
30:27
trouble interpreting of there's
30:29
every indication and you know this party
30:32
or application very own experience people
30:34
who work on computers end up frequently
30:37
working very stressful a one
30:39
of the you know one of the laments about
30:41
computers is that
30:43
they're so ubiquitous that you end
30:46
up working pretty much all the time and
30:48
oh yeah i know that very well i
30:50
hope you're enjoying this podcast for example
30:52
because i finished the editing for this script
30:54
at eleven pm the night before i recorded it
30:57
anyway once you get past the computer complaints
30:59
of ninety ninety nine complete start
31:01
to sound pretty identical to to days
31:04
so now that we've heard decades
31:06
worth of the stuff and he gets his it's
31:08
time to step back and ponder something
31:10
a little philosophical is
31:12
, a way to understand the
31:14
very nature of hard work
31:17
work is that are tractable
31:19
things can we say yes the
31:22
people of nineteen twenty two and the people
31:24
of twenty twenty two did different
31:26
works but the measurement of their hard
31:28
working this was the was so
31:31
i ask peter what do we actually
31:33
know about people's devotion over
31:35
time to the very concept of
31:37
work
31:38
that he said okay interesting
31:40
question several several
31:42
responses the first point
31:45
is most people never
31:47
bought into the middle class working was
31:50
this is classic nineteenth century stuff
31:52
for benjamin franklin stuff you
31:54
know if you work hard work
31:56
will be it's own reward you will automatically
31:58
make your fortune
31:59
this is a way to organize you
32:02
americans got this more extensively
32:04
than most people did and we still
32:06
have more this funny strong
32:09
remnants of the work ethic scenario
32:11
been a student we really do and
32:14
this may be good maybe bad as she's just
32:16
as just true
32:17
okay but
32:18
this work ethic was never shared
32:20
by the all of society
32:22
and to be clear that is not
32:25
to say that people are lazy it's it's
32:27
just to say that they did not buy into the
32:29
narrative that work by itself
32:31
in the abstract is a seal mint
32:33
of purpose i mean some people
32:35
do i for example very much to
32:37
find myself by my work and maybe
32:39
you do too but i also have
32:42
the great fortune of doing work that i love and
32:44
that i have a lot of control over and that
32:46
provides me and my family with a comfortable life
32:49
not everyone can see that i mean just
32:51
listen to how judgmental this could be
32:53
here is a complete printed in the ventura
32:56
county star in two thousand and six
32:59
i can't believe the padlock i
33:01
have had into ryan to find
33:03
someone to do some needed home improvement
33:06
it almost seems like nobody wants to work
33:08
anymore and when i do they take
33:10
no pride in what they do
33:12
consider who is writing this it
33:15
is at the very least someone
33:17
who does not do home improvements themselves
33:19
and yet cannot understand why someone doesn't
33:21
take the pride and patching the holes in
33:23
this person's walls for a small amount of money but
33:26
also the writer here isn't stopping to
33:28
understand the person they want to hire who frankly
33:30
may take quite a lot of pride in their works
33:33
but who has a very good reason to not
33:35
show up and patch this person's walls because
33:37
first of all you've had decades of messaging
33:40
about how college is the path to upward mobility
33:42
which is led to a decline in people attending
33:44
trade schools which has created a nationwide shortage
33:47
of skilled trades people according to the
33:49
staffing company a deco for example
33:51
sixty two percent of firms are
33:53
now struggling to fill these trade rules which
33:56
means that the people who are doing this work are
33:58
inundated with large it better paying
34:00
projects which we there just isn't that
34:02
much of a marketplace for people to do small
34:05
odd jobs for random amounts of money to
34:07
help people who bitch about it in the local paper
34:09
nobody wants to work anymore oh stuff that
34:12
crap and assholes in your wall because they
34:14
are working not for
34:16
you how do these
34:18
workers feel about that work this
34:21
that's up to them like leader said they probably
34:23
don't buy into the idea that work by itself
34:25
is a virtue because most people don't buy into
34:27
that bad off but that's okay doesn't
34:29
mean they're lazy it is means they work hard
34:32
and for and fulfillment elsewhere which brings
34:34
us to the second point the peter wanted
34:36
to make about tracking hard work
34:38
overtime
34:39
the notion that work should be the whole
34:41
our life the is harder
34:44
to sustain today than it was
34:46
a century and a half ago speakers
34:48
we have this leisure component we talked about
34:51
though almost nobody
34:53
would say i'm gonna work
34:55
all the time that is the only thing i want to do
34:59
because the money other things we now viewed
35:01
as unhealthy we do isn't
35:03
that funny we talk about work life balance
35:05
is self care for ourselves and yet we also
35:07
do not make room for older people
35:10
to have a work life balance and enjoy some self
35:12
care which really brings us
35:14
back to today so i know
35:16
where's my you to finance broke his videos
35:18
really about how no one wants
35:20
to work anymore and this podcast
35:23
is about how done that is so
35:25
what's going on today wealth it's simply
35:27
the latest version of what happened over
35:30
and over and over again in everything
35:32
we covered something created
35:34
a shift in the way we work in this case the
35:36
pandemic that new ideas of a where
35:38
and how work should happen and also exacerbated
35:41
existing tensions about the kinds of work that people
35:43
were willing to do and pay they were willing
35:45
to accept and yes people
35:47
left the workforce but they didn't disappear
35:50
spear says they just re entered the workforce
35:52
in different places and in different ways
35:54
so i don't mean nobody is decided
35:57
well i'm just gonna baggott but collectively
35:59
that's just not happening what is happening
36:02
is really i think rather different and that
36:04
is people are saying there are certain
36:06
jobs situations that i would
36:09
rather not have to tolerate
36:11
and i'm gonna not that i don't want to work
36:13
i'm gonna look for work that's more
36:15
congenial
36:16
the either because the is better on the situation
36:19
is better and yes that's creating
36:21
some challenges as industries adjust
36:23
to do expectations but that's a pretty
36:26
useful conversation to have and
36:28
if you want to hear with that conversation sounds like
36:30
in real time well this
36:32
is pretty amazing actually i was recently
36:34
talking to a guy named matt who
36:37
is the ceo of a company called america's
36:39
best restaurants it's restaurants marketing
36:41
company that helps independent restaurants tell
36:44
their stories and grow their sales we
36:46
work with hundreds or extras nationwide and
36:48
men nationwide were talking about the labor shortage
36:50
which is shortage big seeing impacting his clients
36:53
right now it's really hard for them to hire
36:55
and retained good people which means that they can't
36:57
operate they restaurant operate full capacity said
37:00
because that is in the business of helping restaurants
37:02
you would think that he would say yeah this is
37:04
terrible nobody wants to work anymore
37:06
these lazy people but that
37:09
is not what he's saying to his clients instead
37:12
he saying this is it saying day a lot of restaurants
37:14
offer crappy job
37:17
and he's trying to get to their faces to
37:19
i had this exact conversation about four months
37:21
go with a guy that customer and a friend that
37:23
he was haven't labor shortage problem as i said
37:25
the bomb would take a shag you wouldn't
37:27
heavy late as as big a labour short
37:30
problems because everybody adam you are never
37:32
as big a problem right now
37:33
if number one you had created and
37:35
inviting atmosphere that people are attracted
37:38
to which is to say the guys restaurant
37:40
just wasn't a nice place to work
37:42
the other poor that is actually make and where people
37:44
can have a career as to do
37:46
you've been trying to find
37:48
eight nine ten dollar our people like
37:50
it's not a career like you've had a bunch of
37:52
stopgap like those like university
37:54
of cincinnati
37:56
lol because
37:57
that every time they get a good football coast to coast
37:59
leafs
38:00
gather doesn't am waiting there's
38:02
no you wherever the big universe is because
38:04
you see a stopgap for football
38:06
it it doesn't have to be that way
38:09
it again i want to be super clear matt is not
38:12
the guy sitting around saying screw the
38:14
owner of this restaurant he loves the
38:16
owner of this restaurant he is a champion of
38:18
restaurant owners but he also knows
38:20
that when you pay people more and give them
38:22
a better place works they stick around longer
38:25
which actually saves the restaurant owner money
38:27
because now the restaurant doesn't have to recruit
38:29
and train new people as often
38:31
which makes the whole operation more efficient this
38:34
, the shift that we're seeing it's not
38:36
that people don't wanna work anymore
38:39
it's that we're having a conversation
38:41
and this is a continuation of a conversation
38:43
that we've been having for a very long time
38:45
literally since the creation of newark as
38:47
we know it and i am sure we'll keep having
38:49
this conversation for as long as work exists
38:52
because is not perfect and
38:54
not everyone agrees not what works and
38:56
look like and some people see work
38:58
as a core part of their lives and other people see
39:00
work as a means to a end and that's all fine
39:03
all of it's because what we must remember
39:05
is that no matter the change in no
39:07
matter the time the one saying that his
39:09
remained consistent his remained people work
39:12
hard and they do it even when
39:14
they're being accused of not wanting to work
39:16
anymore at the beginning of this
39:18
episode i said that the phrase
39:20
nobody wants to work anymore contained
39:22
a partial truth that said
39:24
it was missing apart and will
39:26
we could finally speak that part out
39:28
loud and take it seriously we'd be
39:31
able to start solving some real problems
39:35
what is it what is that part you
39:38
probably know the answer by now but i'll
39:40
just stayed it plainly to be sure it
39:42
is not true to say that nobody
39:44
wants to work anymore so what we need
39:46
to do is add the phrase the way
39:48
they once felt they had to so
39:50
let's put it altogether nobody wants to
39:52
work the way they once felt they had to
39:55
anymore and that is a perfectly
39:57
reasonable thing to say it's it is a problem
40:00
solving and the closer we get to
40:02
solving it the more we can all accomplished
40:05
let's get
40:08
to hard work and
40:10
that's our episode but hey we
40:13
have talked a lot about defining
40:15
the problem with work today but
40:17
what does it actually looks like to solve
40:19
that problem on a very human
40:21
level i have one heartwarming
40:24
story of a restaurant owner who did it for one
40:26
of his best employees which i will share in a moment
40:29
but , if you love build
40:31
for tomorrow the podcast you're listening to to right
40:33
now then you will totally love builds for
40:35
tomorrow the book eat is written for
40:37
anyone going through a big change in
40:39
their life or work and it will help
40:41
you see that change as opportunity
40:44
and then help you maximize
40:46
it because big things are waiting as
40:48
long as you're able to see them the
40:50
book combines the smartest insights from
40:52
this podcast with the smartest lessons
40:55
that i have learned from entrepreneurs of today you can
40:57
get your copy now just go
40:59
anywhere that sells books or if for
41:01
some reason you're drawing a blank and you can't think of a place that
41:03
sells books then go to jason pfeiffer
41:05
dot com book and
41:08
if you want even more advice and encouragement
41:10
on how to adapt fast sign up for
41:12
my newsletter you can find if find going to
41:14
jason for me for dot com slash dot
41:16
com you can also get in touch with be directly
41:18
at my website jason dot com
41:20
or follow me on twitter or instagram
41:23
i am at have viper this
41:25
episode was reported by me jason favor
41:27
with help from emily homes the voice you
41:29
heard reading all of our historical complaints
41:31
was jailed mora you can find her
41:34
at gm more a dot com sound
41:36
editing by alex bayless or theme music
41:38
is by cast of baby pants learn [unk] navy
41:40
pants music dot com thanks to adam
41:42
cycle it's poor production health and again
41:44
major kudos to paul theory of
41:46
the university paul calgary who originally
41:48
found and tweeted all those historical quotes
41:51
thanks also historical troy petrie for tweeting
41:53
the attributions this show is supported
41:55
in part by the stand together trust the stand
41:58
together trust believes that advances in [unk] ecology
42:00
of transform society for the better it is looking
42:02
to support the scholar's policy experts in other
42:04
projects and creators who focus on a bracing
42:06
innovation creating a society that fosters
42:09
innovation and encouraging people to engineer
42:11
with the next great idea if that's you
42:13
then get in touch with them proposals
42:15
for projects in law economics history
42:17
political science and philosophy are encouraged
42:20
to learn more about their partnership criteria visit
42:22
stand together trust dot
42:24
cork cari now
42:27
as promised let's worms some horns
42:29
when i talked with matt plop of america's best
42:32
restaurants he told me this great story
42:34
of a restaurant owner the he'd met the guy
42:36
had a great employee who abruptly put
42:38
in his two weeks notice sent and the owner
42:40
just couldn't figure out why
42:42
today i'm curious when you're great worker here
42:44
we we value i feel like you enjoy
42:46
your job are you leaving said
42:48
well the the route change
42:50
the bosses and the bus no longer comes here at will
42:52
have car
42:53
right
42:55
the me like you been working like seventy year
42:57
like i don't i take the bus or i walk
42:59
i just can't do anymore anything
43:01
i want you to say here the have a license
43:03
yeah i'll buy your car
43:06
they were gonna be car i was blown
43:08
away because like that right there like if he
43:10
would have just taken the two weeks okay cool
43:12
see a so yes question i
43:14
think that to me
43:16
we're same off air we are talk as i
43:18
say
43:18
the pandemic shined a light
43:21
that a lot to read the people are out there to work
43:24
now can every employer by
43:26
every employee a car know
43:28
of course not but can everyone sink
43:30
more about how to invest in their best talent
43:33
because that investment will pay off for everyone
43:35
yes
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More