Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:13
That is Cardinal Kevin Farrell,
0:16
Cameron Lingo, or Cardinal Chamberlain
0:18
of the Holy Roman Church,
0:20
announcing the death of Pope
0:22
Francis I. That was
0:24
followed some 17 hours later by
0:27
the right of ascertainment, the
0:29
formal acknowledgement of Francis' death, a
0:31
few of the many centuries -old rituals
0:33
that will play out over the
0:35
next several days as the church mourns
0:38
Pope Francis I. There will
0:40
be the mourning of the faithful
0:42
as Francis' body lies in St. Peter's
0:44
Basilica, a funeral where Francis
0:46
will be remembered by his fellow
0:48
priests, followers, and world leaders, and
0:50
then the conclave, where the
0:52
College of Cardinal meet to choose
0:55
his successor. Consider
0:57
this, Pope Francis has died at
0:59
the age of 88. Now the
1:01
church has to chart a course
1:03
without his leadership, who will be
1:05
his successor and what path will
1:07
he choose? From
1:11
NPR, I'm Mary Louise Kelly. When
1:19
Malcolm Gladwell presented NPR's
1:21
Throughline podcast with a Peabody
1:24
Award, he praised it
1:26
for its historical and moral clarity. On
1:29
Throughline, we take you back in
1:31
time to the origins of what's
1:33
in the news, like presidential power,
1:35
aging, and evangelicalism. Time travel
1:37
with us every week on
1:39
the Throughline podcast from NPR. Since
1:41
Donald Trump took office in
1:43
January, a lot has happened. The
1:45
White House budget office ordered
1:48
a pause on all federal grants
1:50
and loans. The impact of
1:52
the Trump administration's tariffs is already
1:54
being felt into Trump's efforts
1:56
to radically remake the federal government.
1:58
The NPR Politics covers it
2:00
all. Keep up with what's happening
2:02
in Washington and beyond with
2:04
the NPR Politics Podcast. Listen every
2:06
day. Imagine, if you will,
2:08
a show from NPR that's not like
2:10
NPR. A show that focuses not on
2:12
the important but the stupid, which features
2:14
stories about people smuggling animals in their
2:17
pants and competent criminals in ridiculous science
2:19
studies. And call it Wait, Wait, Don't
2:21
Tell Me because the good names were
2:23
taken. Listen to NPR's Wait, Wait, Don't
2:25
Tell Me. Yes, that is what it
2:27
is called wherever you get your podcasts.
2:38
It's Consider This from NPR.
2:40
Monday was a day of mourning
2:42
for the world's billion -plus Catholics.
2:45
Next, the College of Cardinals will
2:47
oversee the church and the transition
2:49
to a new holy father. That
2:51
process culminates in a conclave. I
2:54
spoke to author and journalist Father
2:56
Thomas Reis of Religion News Service
2:58
about the conclave and the election
3:00
of a new pope. How
3:02
are you remembering him today? I
3:04
remember him as someone who
3:06
really changed the culture of the
3:08
church. This is
3:10
a man who hated
3:13
clericalism. He kept telling
3:15
bishops and priests to not act like
3:17
princes, but to be with their
3:19
people. So, like many people listening to
3:21
us, I feel like I know
3:23
how a conclave works because I saw
3:26
the movie last year. What
3:28
should we know about the process that
3:30
is about to unfold? Well,
3:32
all of the cardinal electors will
3:34
be coming to Rome for the Pope's
3:36
funeral. That's 135 cardinals
3:38
who are under the age
3:40
of 80. 80 % of
3:43
those have been appointed by Pope
3:45
Francis. So they will
3:47
gather in the Sistine Chapel
3:49
and twice a day they will
3:51
have a vote. And that
3:53
will be done in silence and
3:55
prayer. Outside of the Sistine
3:57
Chapel, there will be lots of
3:59
conversations about who should be
4:01
a pope. And give
4:03
us a little bit of
4:05
insight into those conversations. What are
4:07
the priorities supposed to be?
4:10
Well, I think each cardinal is
4:12
looking for three things in
4:14
a future pope. First, he wants
4:16
someone who will be a
4:18
good pope, which of course means
4:20
that the candidate agrees with
4:22
the Cardinal on the future of
4:24
the Church. The second thing
4:26
he wants is someone who he has
4:28
good relationship with, because he wants to
4:30
be able to have someone who will
4:32
listen to him after he becomes Pope.
4:35
And finally, he wants someone elected who
4:37
will go down well in his part
4:39
of the world, in his country. Are
4:42
there already names
4:44
circulating? Frontrunners? There's
4:46
lots of names circulating, but there's
4:48
no real front runners. You know,
4:50
when John Paul II was elected,
4:52
it was a big surprise. When
4:54
Francis was elected, it was a
4:56
big surprise. So it
4:58
may be a surprise.
5:02
Does the fact that, as you just
5:04
said, the majority of the cardinals
5:06
who will be eligible to choose the
5:08
next pope, that they themselves were
5:10
appointed by Pope Francis, does...
5:13
influenced the outcome? Does that suggest
5:15
they may want someone in
5:17
his mold? I think it
5:19
certainly is going to influence the
5:21
outcome. We're not going to see someone
5:23
elected who stands up and says
5:25
that the papacy of Francis was a
5:27
disaster and we're going back to
5:29
the old church. That's just not going
5:31
to happen. We will see
5:34
someone who will talk about
5:36
continuity with the legacy of
5:38
Pope Francis. I mentioned the
5:40
movie, Conclave. It includes a
5:42
scene. where we
5:44
see two factions of the church,
5:46
two wings, liberals versus traditionalists, and
5:48
they are vying for control, and
5:50
vying is putting it politely. Is
5:53
that real? Is that divide real amongst
5:55
the cardinals? Well, there are
5:57
some cardinals who are very conservative
5:59
and would like to bring
6:01
the church back to the way
6:03
it was a long time
6:05
ago, but they're in a minority
6:07
today. They make a lot
6:09
of noise, but they are
6:11
not a majority in
6:13
the College of Cardinals, not
6:15
today. How big a
6:17
factor is geography? Much has been
6:19
made of the fact that Francis was
6:21
the first non -European to hold that
6:23
role in a thousand years. Geography
6:25
is extremely important because different parts of
6:27
the world have different concerns. The
6:30
global south is very concerned
6:32
about poverty about the
6:34
economic system, about globalization,
6:36
about wars, and they're concerned
6:38
about migrants and refugees
6:40
trying to find safe places
6:42
to live. On the other
6:44
hand, you know, the people in the North, we're
6:47
very strong on ecumenism. We're
6:49
very strong on having good relations
6:51
with the Jewish community. These
6:53
are important things to us. We're
6:55
very strong on taking care of
6:58
the sex abuse crisis, making sure
7:00
that this does not happen again.
7:02
So there are different priorities
7:04
in different parts of
7:06
the world, but we may
7:08
see how that plays
7:11
out. This selection process
7:13
is about as far from transparent
7:15
as it feels possible to
7:17
get. They will be sealed inside
7:19
the Sistine Chapel. Will we
7:21
ever get visibility into why whoever
7:23
is chosen the next pope
7:26
was chosen? Well, of course,
7:28
when the Cardinals come out, each
7:30
one of them will can talk about
7:32
why he likes the new pope
7:34
or doesn't like the new pope. So
7:36
we'll get that, but we certainly
7:38
will not know how each person votes.
7:41
The Cardinals themselves will not even know
7:43
that. It's a secret ballot and the
7:45
ballots are burned after they're counted. Timing.
7:50
I mean, choosing the next pope will take as long
7:52
as it takes, I guess, but are we likely
7:54
talking what, weeks? We haven't had
7:56
a conclave last more than...
7:58
three days for a hundred
8:00
years. So we would
8:02
expect them to be able
8:04
to get their work done, especially
8:06
because they will have time
8:08
before the conclave to talk over
8:10
dinner and over coffee and,
8:12
you know, in small groups
8:14
about who they think the
8:16
Pope should be. So there's a
8:19
lot of, well, let's call
8:21
it politicking, happening before the Cardinals
8:23
actually gather in the Sistine
8:25
Chapel. Father Tom Reese.
8:27
He's a journalist, author, and Jesuit
8:29
priest. He writes The Signs of
8:31
the Times column for Religion News
8:33
Service. Father Reese, thank you. Good
8:36
to be with you. This
8:40
episode was produced by Tyler
8:42
Bartlem. It was edited by Courtney
8:44
Dornig. Our executive producer is
8:46
Sammy Yenigan. It's
8:50
Consider This, from NPR. I'm
8:52
Mary Louise Kelly. At
9:04
Planet Money, we'll take you from a
9:06
race to make rum in the Caribbean.
9:08
Our rum from a quality standpoint is
9:10
the best in the world. To the
9:13
labs dreaming up the most advanced microchips.
9:15
It's very rare for people to go
9:17
inside. To the back rooms of New
9:19
York's Diamond District. Planet
9:23
Money from NPR. We go to
9:25
the story and take you along with
9:27
us wherever you get your podcasts. Donald
9:30
Trump has an extraordinary approach
9:32
to the presidency. At the
9:34
NPR Politics Podcast, we're recapping the
9:36
first 100 days of Donald Trump's
9:38
second term from his early promises
9:40
to his policy decisions and what
9:42
it all means for you. Politics
9:45
may not always make sense, but
9:47
we'll sort it out together over on
9:49
the NPR Politics Podcast. Or
9:58
you can also support
10:00
NPR's vital journalism and get
10:02
considered this plus at
10:04
plus .npr .org, that's plus .npr .org.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More