Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
For a 10-month period from September 1793
0:02
to July 1794, the nation of
0:04
France went through a period which
0:06
could only be called insanity. In
0:08
the aftermath of the French Revolution, a
0:11
small group of radicals took
0:13
control of the Revolutionary French
0:15
government and began eliminating all
0:17
enemies of the revolution, both
0:19
real and perceived. Tens of thousands
0:21
of people were in prison, and
0:23
thousands met their end with what
0:26
the French called Madame Legelotine. Learn
0:28
more about The
0:30
French Revolution's reign
0:32
of terror, why
0:34
it started and how
0:37
it ended, on
0:39
this episode of
0:41
Everything Everywhere Daily.
0:44
This episode is
0:46
sponsored by Quinns.
0:48
Vacation Season is nearly
0:50
upon us. And you've heard me
0:52
talk before about my favorite blanket
0:55
and towels that I got from
0:57
Quince, but did you know that
0:59
they also have a collection of
1:01
great travel products, like lightweight shirts
1:03
and shorts from just $30, pants
1:05
for any occasion, and comfortable lounge
1:07
sets. They also have premium luggage
1:09
options and durable duffel bags to
1:11
carry everything in. The best part? All
1:14
Quince items are priced 50 to 80%
1:16
less than similar brands. By partnering directly
1:18
with top factories, Quinns cuts out the
1:21
cost of the middleman and passes the
1:23
savings on to us. And Quinns only
1:25
works with factories that use
1:27
safe, ethical and responsible manufacturing
1:30
practices and premium fabrics and
1:32
finishes. For your next trip,
1:34
treat yourself to the luxury
1:37
upgrades you deserve from Quinns.
1:39
Go to quinns.com/Daily for 365
1:41
day returns, plus free shipping
1:43
on your order. That's quince.com/Daily.
1:45
to get free shipping and
1:48
365 day returns. quince.com/daily. This
1:50
episode is sponsored by Mint
1:52
Mobile. Do you say data or data?
1:55
Well, I say data. And for the
1:57
longest time I thought paying a
1:59
fortune on my monthly data plan
2:01
was just normal. That wasn't until
2:03
I found out about Mint Mobile
2:05
and their premium wireless plans that
2:07
started just 15 bucks a month.
2:10
With Mint Mobile, I use the
2:12
exact same network, on the exact
2:14
same cell towers I used before,
2:16
with the exact same phone and
2:18
exact same phone number. The only
2:20
thing that isn't the same are
2:22
the monthly fees. All plans come
2:25
with high-speed data, or high-speed data,
2:27
your choice, as well as unlimited
2:29
talk and text, delivered on the
2:31
nation's largest 5G network. No matter
2:33
how you say it. Don't overpay
2:35
for it. Shop data plans at
2:38
mintmobile.com/ED. That's mintmobile.com/ED. Up front payment
2:40
of $45 for a three-month five
2:42
gigabyte plan required equivalent to $15
2:44
a month. New customer offer for
2:46
the first three months only, then
2:48
full-price plan options available. The
2:55
American Revolution and the French Revolution
2:57
occurred next to each other in
2:59
time, and they were each rebellions
3:02
against monarchy. However, the similarities between
3:04
the two don't go too much
3:06
further than that. The French Revolution
3:09
wasn't just a political revolution. It
3:11
was also a cultural revolution. They
3:13
didn't just want to get rid
3:16
of the king, but some more
3:18
radical revolutionaries wanted to change everything
3:20
about French society. In previous episodes,
3:23
I covered some of these extreme
3:25
changes. They included... totally changing the
3:27
calendar from the Gregorian calendar we
3:30
use today to a brand new
3:32
calendar with new months, days, weeks,
3:34
and years. They also tried to
3:37
get rid of not just the
3:39
Catholic Church, but Christianity entirely, and
3:41
replace it with a cult of
3:44
reason or a cult of the
3:46
supreme being. As radical as these
3:48
changes were, they were not the
3:51
peak of extremism during the revolution.
3:53
That would be a 10-month period
3:55
known as the reign of terror.
3:58
a time when even the most
4:00
ardent revolutionaries weren't safe. To briefly
4:02
summarize, the French Revolution began in
4:05
1789 as a response to widespread
4:07
social inequality, an economic crisis, and
4:09
the absolute monarchy of King Louis
4:12
XVI. The Estates General, a legislative
4:14
assembly, convened in May of 1789,
4:16
leading to the formation of the
4:19
National Assembly and the storming of
4:21
the best deal in July where
4:24
many political prisoners were held. Over
4:26
the next few years, the monarchy
4:28
was gradually stripped of power, culminating
4:31
in the King's arrest and the
4:33
declaration of the first French Republic
4:35
in 1792. In the aftermath of
4:38
the 1792 insurrection, the top of
4:40
the monarchy, France faced mounting crises
4:42
on multiple fronts. The newly established
4:45
National Convention, which was elected by
4:47
universal male suffrage, was deeply divided
4:49
between two groups, the Durandons and
4:52
the Montignards, also known as the
4:54
Mountain in English. The Girandons represented
4:56
provincial moderate republicanism, whereas the mountain,
4:59
led by figures like Maximilian Robespierre,
5:01
Georges-Dantan, and Jean-Paul-Mirat, advocated more radical
5:03
measures and enjoyed the support from
5:06
the Parisian Saint-Colats, who were the
5:08
more radical, lower-class people of Paris.
5:10
Foreign armies threatened France's borders after
5:13
the declaration of war against Austria
5:15
in April of 1792, and later
5:17
expanded to include Prussia, Great Britain,
5:20
Spain, Spain, Spain, and other powers.
5:22
By early 1793, France faced a
5:24
coalition of European monarchies determined to
5:27
crush the revolution. In addition, France
5:29
suffered economic problems, including rising food
5:31
prices, currency depreciation, and shortages of
5:34
basic necessities, which fueled popular unrest,
5:36
particularly amongst the urban poor. Counter-revolutionary
5:38
activity increase, particularly in the Vandi
5:41
region on the Atlantic coast. In
5:43
March of 1793 a major rebellion
5:45
erupted and then other uprisings followed
5:48
in major cities like Leon, Marseilles,
5:50
and Bordeaux. The political atmosphere grew
5:52
increasingly radical and paranoid with each
5:55
side accusing the other of betraying
5:57
the revolution. The Girondins accused the
5:59
mountain of harboring dictatorial ambitions, while
6:02
the mountain chart... the Girandons with
6:04
being soft on counter-revolution and insufficiently
6:06
committed to defending the Republic. As
6:09
the military and economic crises deepened,
6:11
the National Convention recognized the need
6:13
for a more centralized executive authority.
6:16
The Convention established the first Committee
6:18
of Public Safety on April 6,
6:20
1793. Initially, it consisted of nine
6:23
members who were tasked with supervising
6:25
ministers and taking emergency measures to
6:27
defend the Republic. George Dantan became
6:30
its most influential early member. The
6:32
first committee was relatively moderate, but
6:34
after military setbacks and the outbreak
6:37
of federalist revolts, it was reconstituted
6:39
on July 10th. Maximilian Robes Pierre
6:41
joined the committee on July 27th
6:44
and gradually became its dominant figure.
6:46
The committee's power expanded incrementally, initially
6:48
formed as a temporary expedient for
6:51
crisis management, it evolved into the
6:53
revolution's central governing body with authority
6:55
over military affairs, foreign policy, economic
6:58
measures, and internal security. While power
7:00
was becoming centralized in the Committee
7:02
of Public Safety, things were breaking
7:05
down between the Girondins and the
7:07
Mountain. Political tensions between the factions
7:09
intensified in early 1793. The Drondins
7:12
attempted to prosecute Jean-Paul Morat, a
7:14
radical journalist and mountain deputy, but
7:16
is acquittal by the Revolutionary Tribunal
7:19
on April 24th, represented a major
7:21
political defeat for them. The economic
7:23
situation worsened, with food shortages and
7:26
inflation fueling popular anger. The Girandons
7:28
opposed the price controls demanded by
7:30
the Parisian Sankulats, further alienating them
7:33
from this powerful political force. On
7:35
May 31st, armed Parisians surrounded the
7:37
convention, demanding the arrest of 22
7:40
Girondon deputies and two ministers. The
7:42
convention initially resisted, but on June
7:44
2nd, a larger insurrectionary force of
7:47
up to 80,000 national guardsmen surrounded
7:49
the assembly. Under this pressure, the
7:52
Convention voted to arrest 29 Gerondon
7:54
deputies and two ministers. Some managed
7:56
to escape Paris and fled to
7:59
prevention. cities, but most of them
8:01
were arrested. Many of the arrested
8:03
Girondins were later tried and
8:05
guillotine in October of 1793.
8:07
Their execution removed the main
8:09
moderate opposition within the government
8:11
and solidified mountain control of
8:14
the Convention and the entire
8:16
revolution. With the Girondins removed
8:18
and the Committee of Public
8:20
Safety empowered, several developments accelerated
8:23
the move toward systematic terror.
8:25
The Federalist revolts in cities
8:28
like Leon, Marseilles, Bordeaux, and
8:30
Khan, encouraged by the escaped
8:32
Gerondon deputies, were portrayed as
8:35
treasonous conspiracies rather than political
8:37
opposition, justifying extreme measures. The
8:39
assassination of Jean-Paul Morat by
8:42
Charlotte Corday, a Gerondon sympathizer
8:44
on July 13th, inflamed radical
8:46
sentiment, and strengthened calls for
8:49
vengeance against enemies of the people.
8:51
The law of suspects passed
8:53
on September 17th. vastly expanded
8:55
the categories of people who
8:57
could be arrested for counter-revolutionary
8:59
activities or sentiments. The Revolutionary
9:01
Tribunal in Paris was reorganized
9:04
to expedite trials and similar
9:06
tribunals were established in
9:08
provincial cities. The creation of
9:10
the Committee of General Security,
9:12
working alongside the Committee of
9:14
Public Safety, provided the administrative
9:16
machinery to implement surveillance and arrests.
9:19
By the fall of 1793, all of these factors
9:21
The centralized power of the committees
9:23
of general security and public safety, the
9:25
law of suspects, and the lack of
9:28
gyrand and moderation, created the basis for
9:30
the reign of terror. Under Robes-Pierre
9:32
in the Committee of Public Safety,
9:34
the machinery of state repression expanded
9:37
dramatically. The revolutionary tribunal
9:39
in Paris accelerated its operations,
9:41
often conducting perfunctory trials followed
9:44
by swift executions. Similar tribunals
9:46
function in major cities across
9:49
France. The violence took different
9:51
forms in different regions. In Paris, the
9:53
guillotine became the symbol of revolutionary
9:55
justice with public executions in what
9:57
is now the Place de la Concord.
10:00
In provincial areas facing rebellion, the
10:02
repression was even more severe, mass
10:04
drownings and naught, mass shootings in
10:06
Leon and brutal suppression of the
10:09
Vendy uprising. The scope of people
10:11
targeted began to grow. The former
10:13
Queen Marie Antoinette was guillotined in
10:16
October of 1793, as were other
10:18
leading gerondens. Prominent revolutionaries deemed too
10:20
radical, such as Jacques René Iber
10:23
and his followers, were executed in
10:25
March 1794. Revolutionary is considered too
10:27
moderate, including George Dantan, were executed
10:30
in April 1794. In addition, thousands
10:32
of ordinary citizens were denounced by
10:34
neighbors or local authorities, often for
10:37
petty or personal reasons. The terror
10:39
was accompanied by radical social and
10:41
cultural policies, which I previously mentioned,
10:44
including the decristianization campaigns, the adoption
10:46
of a new revolutionary calendar, price
10:48
controls, and attempts to create a
10:51
new civic festival, and a republic
10:53
of virtue. By the summer of
10:55
1794, despite French military victories reducing
10:58
external threats to the country, Robes-Pier
11:00
pushed for intensified revolutionary purity through
11:02
measures like the law of 22
11:05
prairiale, which removed legal protections for
11:07
the accused and accelerated further executions.
11:09
In total, approximately 16-17,000 people were
11:12
officially executed during the reign of
11:14
terror, with tens of thousands more
11:16
dying in prison or in the
11:19
suppression of rebellions. Rob Pierre, however,
11:21
had gone too far. With the
11:23
law of 22 Prairie Al, everyone
11:26
was worried about their safety. On
11:28
June 8th, 1794, Robes Pierre had
11:30
presided over the Festival of the
11:33
Supreme Being, a civic celebration that
11:35
he had personally championed as part
11:37
of his effort to establish a
11:40
new civic religion. While Rob Pierre
11:42
viewed this as the culmination of
11:44
revolutionary virtue, many people saw it
11:47
as evidence of his dictatorial ambitions
11:49
and messianic self-self image. Ropes returned
11:51
to the convention on July 26th
11:54
and delivered a lengthy rambling speech.
11:56
He spoke of conspiracies against the
11:58
Republic and hinted at the need
12:00
for another purge of treasonous elements,
12:03
but crucially failed to name any
12:05
specific targets. This vagueness caused panic
12:07
amongst the deputies, many of whom
12:10
feared that they might be on
12:12
Robespierre's list. With everyone now potentially
12:14
at risk, self-preservation drove many to
12:17
conspire against him. That night various
12:19
factions in the convention. including more
12:21
moderate allies of Dantan, remaining radical
12:24
followers of Ebert, and even some
12:26
of Robespierre's colleagues on the Committee
12:28
of Public Safety, met to coordinate
12:31
their actions for the next day.
12:33
The conspirators included those who had
12:35
themselves been enthusiastic supporters of the
12:38
terror, but now feared for their
12:40
own lives. The next day, July
12:42
27th, Robespierre attempted to speak again
12:45
at the convention, but was shouted
12:47
down with cries of down-with-the tyrant.
12:49
When Louis Saint-Just, one of Robespierre's
12:52
closest allies began to speak, Jean-Lambert
12:54
Talian interrupted him and denounced Robespierre.
12:56
The president of the convention, who
12:59
had once been Robespierre's ally, gave
13:01
the floor to Robespierre's enemies. They
13:03
accused him of plotting to murder
13:06
the entire convention. After hours of
13:08
chaotic debate, the convention voted for
13:10
the arrest of Robespierre, his younger
13:13
brother, Sanjust, and the mayor of
13:15
Paris. Initially, the coup appeared to
13:17
fail. When officers of the convention
13:20
attempted to arrest Robespierre and the
13:22
others, the Paris Commune, aka the
13:24
city government, refused to accept the
13:27
arrest. The prisoners were taken to
13:29
various government buildings rather than prisons.
13:31
The Commune, still loyal to Robespierre,
13:34
called out the National Guard and
13:36
prepared to march on the convention
13:38
to free him. For a few
13:41
hours that night, the outcome hung
13:43
in the balance. Had the commune
13:45
acted decisively, it may have repeated
13:48
the past when armed Parisians had
13:50
effectively intimidated the national legislature. However,
13:52
the convention declared the commune and
13:55
Robespierre supporters to be. outlaws, a
13:57
status that meant that they could
13:59
be executed without trial upon identification.
14:01
As rains fell over Paris that
14:04
night, much of the National Guard
14:06
that was summoned by the commune
14:08
drifted away. The decisive moment came
14:11
when the convention forces arrived at
14:13
the Hotel de Ville where Robespierre
14:15
and his supporters had gathered. Finding
14:18
the building nearly undefended, they easily
14:20
took control. In the confusion, Robespierre
14:22
suffered a shattered jaw from a
14:25
gunshot. Whether this was a suicide
14:27
attempt or inflicted by one of
14:29
his captors remains debated by historians
14:32
His brother Augustine attempted to escape
14:34
by jumping out of a window,
14:36
but broke his legs others were
14:39
captured without resistance on July 28th
14:41
Robes Pierre and 21 of his
14:43
closest associates were guillotined without trial
14:46
having been declared outlaws Despite his
14:48
terrible jaw wound Robes Pierre was
14:50
executed last amongst his group When
14:53
the executioner tore off the bandage
14:55
on his jaw before placing him
14:57
under the blade, Robes Pierre reportedly
15:00
let out a terrible scream. His
15:02
only sound that entire day. The
15:04
day after, 71 members of the
15:07
Paris Commune followed them to the
15:09
guillotine, and within a following week,
15:11
another 12 were executed as Robes
15:14
Pierre. The fall of Robes Pierre
15:16
marked the end of the reign
15:18
of the reign of terror. The
15:21
period that followed, known as the
15:23
Thermidorian reaction, saw the release of
15:25
many prisoners, the expulsion of radicals
15:28
from the convention, and a general
15:30
relaxation of the revolutionary fervor. Power
15:32
shifted to the more conservative property
15:35
owning classes, and a new constitution
15:37
established the directory government in 1795.
15:39
The dramatic events of July 1794
15:42
demonstrated how quickly revolutionary politics could
15:44
shift. Rose Pierre, who had been
15:46
virtually untouchable as the embodiment of
15:49
revolutionary virtue, fell in just three
15:51
days, brought down by fear political
15:53
factions, and his own unwillingness to
15:55
compromise. His fall marked not just
15:58
the end of the terror. but
16:00
a fundamental recalibration of the entire
16:02
French Revolution itself, away from radical
16:05
virtue towards pragmatic stability, setting the
16:07
eventual stage for the rise of
16:09
Napoleon Bonaparte. The executive producer of
16:12
Everything Everywhere Daily is Charles Daniel.
16:14
The associate producers are Austin Oaken
16:16
and Cameron Kiefer. Today's review comes
16:19
from listener Real Mao Man over
16:21
on Apple Podcast in the United
16:23
States. They write, Wonderful Podcast. I've
16:26
been enjoying your podcast every single
16:28
day for a while. It's a
16:30
valuable contribution to my daily sapien
16:33
elucidation and domestication project that I
16:35
call my life. Thanks, Mauman. With
16:37
the utmost profundity of gratitude and
16:40
an effusive appreciation that transcends the
16:42
bounds of ordinary expression, I extend
16:44
my sincerest and most magniloquent thanks
16:47
for your gracious and benevolent indulgence
16:49
in lending your auditory faculties to
16:51
the humble sonic endeavor that is
16:54
my podcast. Your attentive presence amidst
16:56
the sonorous tapestry of my verbal
16:58
meanderings is both an ineffable honor
17:01
and an inestimable privilege. Remember if
17:03
you leave a review or send
17:05
me a boostogram? You too can
17:08
have it right on the show.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More