Justice Pending, Episode 3: Arrest Made in UHC Murder

Justice Pending, Episode 3: Arrest Made in UHC Murder

Released Tuesday, 10th December 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Justice Pending, Episode 3: Arrest Made in UHC Murder

Justice Pending, Episode 3: Arrest Made in UHC Murder

Justice Pending, Episode 3: Arrest Made in UHC Murder

Justice Pending, Episode 3: Arrest Made in UHC Murder

Tuesday, 10th December 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

For over 100 years, Schneider Electric

0:02

has provided the equipment and expertise

0:04

to pros to keep the lights

0:06

on. the But in the 21st 21st

0:08

your home demands a symphony of

0:11

energy, digital devices, battery backup, EV

0:13

charging, and and you've got the power

0:15

with help from Schneider Let's Let's

0:17

talk about automated energy control. Why Why

0:19

do your appliances need a connected

0:21

system? It's an investment in real

0:23

money savings because your energy use

0:25

is streamlined using using off-peak battery backup

0:28

to optimize your use and savings,

0:30

which is for the planet planet money

0:32

back in your pocket. in A

0:34

double savings from your friends at

0:36

Schneider your So let's start with

0:38

the basics. let's .com basics. to see

0:40

what tech you may need easy

0:42

be connected with a certified

0:44

local installer to make sure your

0:46

power always stays ahead of

0:48

your needs. your it's flexible. No

0:50

solar, smaller system. Yeah, we got

0:52

you. Design your system at

0:54

SchneiderHome .com today and enjoy Home.com Schneider

0:56

the symphony. got the power. power. The

1:01

most wonderful time of the year, the

1:03

year. let's be honest be the holidays

1:05

the really add up But here's

1:07

the good news only at Verizon good

1:09

can get a single line for

1:11

$50 per month when you switch

1:14

and bring your phone $50 month skating

1:16

for two is definitely costing more

1:18

So, at Verizon you can save

1:20

for your third costing more. Here at Single

1:22

line with Verizon save. so steep your third

1:24

cousin, steep. A single line with Verizon

1:26

less less pricey. to see Mima and Pops, those

1:29

are up per month per month single down.

1:31

Even a down. the San Even a trip to

1:33

the San Francisco will market will cost you

1:35

more. But with Verizon, switch you can switch

1:37

and bring your phone for just per month for a

1:39

month for a single line on Unlimited welcome

1:41

with auto pay taxes and fees. fees. All this

1:43

to say, the the holiday season, when everything

1:45

is costing more, more you can get more a

1:47

less right now monthly a local Verizon store.

1:49

over 36 months monthly promo on applied over 36

1:52

months with a new line on Unlimited Welcome.

1:54

In times of congestion, LTE 5G, 4G, LTE

1:56

may be temporarily slower than other traffic.

1:58

Domestic data roaming at 2G speeds. terms apply. you

2:00

ever have a story that

2:02

you just can't get out

2:04

of your head? One that

2:06

you play the details of

2:09

over and over with your

2:11

friends. Well, you've come to

2:13

the right place. I'm Claire.

2:15

And I'm Susan. And this

2:17

is Justice Pending. A weekly

2:19

true crime podcast where we

2:21

discuss tantalizing crimes with more

2:24

questions and answers. Thanks for

2:26

joining us. Here

2:31

we are. And this has

2:33

been quite the adventure to

2:35

get this episode recorded today.

2:37

We've been going all over

2:39

the world, you and me,

2:41

doing a million things, but

2:44

we had to talk about

2:46

this case because there's finally

2:48

been an arrest. Like so

2:50

many updates and oh my

2:52

goodness, the details that keep

2:54

coming out are just bonkers.

2:57

They really are. And we,

2:59

you know, normally we talk

3:01

like a million times a

3:03

day, as we say, and

3:05

we have not talked so

3:08

that we could have the

3:10

true blue genuine first reactions

3:12

to all of this news.

3:14

Oh my goodness. I mean,

3:16

I have been privately just

3:18

trying to catch the news

3:21

snippets, updates, wherever I can.

3:23

It's, like I said, bonkers.

3:25

So, okay, let's dive in.

3:27

So there's been an arrest

3:29

in the United Health Care

3:31

assassination of Brian Thompson. Luigi

3:34

Mangioni age 26 was arrested

3:36

on December 9th while eating

3:38

at McDonald's in Al tuna

3:40

Pennsylvania. An employee recognized him.

3:42

Wait, can we just pause

3:44

here to commend this McDonald's

3:47

employee? But also, I mean,

3:49

I am thrilled for whoever

3:51

this is to get that

3:53

reward money. I'm thrilled they

3:55

kicked up the reward amount

3:58

and I am I can't

4:00

wait for this person to

4:02

receive it. I am just

4:04

so happy for that person.

4:06

Yes, a $50,000 reward announced

4:08

by the FBI. The initial

4:11

reward was only 10,000 from

4:13

NYPD. So this is a

4:15

significant amount of money. Congratulations

4:17

to the McDonald's employee who

4:19

went to work and found

4:21

a fugitive. Maybe you call

4:24

it women's intuition, I don't

4:26

know. I feel like. Would

4:29

you just doubt your, would you look

4:31

at someone randomly in the small town

4:33

of Pennsylvania and be like, oh yeah,

4:36

that's the guy? Like, I don't know

4:38

that I would, I don't know that

4:40

I would trust myself that much to

4:42

look. Do you know what I'm saying?

4:45

Like, I don't, I do. And to

4:47

believe that that was what my eyes

4:49

were showing me, that that was really

4:52

the person. And to make a call,

4:54

because if it's a false alarm and

4:56

you have police officers storming your McDonald's

4:59

to interrogate one of your guests, That's

5:01

a bad look if it's not if

5:03

it's not true. I know and so

5:05

I understand he walked in with a

5:08

mask and so maybe that was his

5:10

downfall because most of the pictures had

5:12

or all the pictures except for the

5:15

one when he was checking into the

5:17

hospital had been with the mask on

5:19

and the hood up so if he

5:22

was still in his uniform let's call

5:24

it like on the run uniform maybe

5:26

that gave it away but. still. I

5:29

mean, so many people have bushy eyebrows

5:31

and brown eyes and look Italian. Plenty

5:33

of people have that look. I was

5:35

even, you know, walking around in my

5:38

life today saying like, you know, that

5:40

could have been the guy, that could

5:42

have been the guy. I mean, I

5:45

just, I'm really impressed that the employee

5:47

trusted herself enough to to make the

5:49

call calmly do it because, you know,

5:52

I'm sure that took a lot of,

5:54

I'm sure she was just shaking. I

5:56

mean, who is wants to make that

5:59

phone call, you know, but it really

6:01

worked out. It did. And I have

6:03

to say that McDonald's seems to be

6:05

a pretty popular choice for fugitives. There

6:08

have been a number of high profile

6:10

fugitives. been caught eating at McDonald's. So

6:12

yeah, you get your murder kit, your

6:15

duct tape, and your shovels at Walmart,

6:17

and you go to McDonald's when you

6:19

need to get some sustenance. So that's

6:22

where Nicholas Cruz, the Parkland shooter, was

6:24

seen at McDonald's after the shooting. There

6:26

were other, I think it was the

6:29

New York. subway shooter who was found

6:31

in a McDonald's, I mean McDonald's has

6:33

come up time and time again. Yeah,

6:35

maybe you could feel like you can

6:38

blend, you know, such such a high

6:40

traffic establishment, right in and out and

6:42

yeah, who's paying attention. But wow, this

6:45

one sure was this employee. And to

6:47

think that in 2024 with all the

6:49

high tech facial recognition software that we

6:52

have, license plate readers, we have cameras

6:54

on every corner. Yeah,

6:56

just the actual face to face

6:58

recognition that gets this guy caught.

7:00

It's incredible. I mean, I just

7:03

think it's wonderful. I think it's

7:05

also a credit to the police

7:07

that they spent all that time

7:09

isolating the images that then this,

7:12

you know, this person was pretty

7:14

confident to make that call. I

7:16

just think the whole operation was.

7:18

wonderful and astounding and yes we

7:21

can have all of the robotics

7:23

and AI and everything else known

7:25

to man and yet it's that

7:27

human eye that that does it

7:30

at the end. Amazing. I love

7:32

the line that the arresting officer

7:34

gave Luigi whenever he was first

7:36

questioning him at McDonald's, whenever he

7:39

responded to the tip, they get

7:41

there, the guys in a mask,

7:43

sitting there about to eat, and

7:45

they ask him to remove the

7:48

mask, and then they say, have

7:50

you been to New York recently?

7:52

I mean, what a statement, right?

7:54

Like, I mean, whenever they make

7:57

the movie, and I'm sure they

7:59

will, that's a moment. It's just

8:01

such a bad-ask. say, have you

8:03

been to New York recently and

8:06

know that that's going to strike

8:08

fear into his heart? And apparently,

8:10

he started to shake whenever the

8:12

officer asked him that question. So

8:15

it was definitely not what he

8:17

was hoping to hear while he

8:19

was chomping down on his McDonald's

8:21

breakfast. Well, the interesting

8:24

thing, and we'll get into, I

8:26

guess, the timeline of this in

8:28

a little bit, but the interesting

8:30

thing to me is that it

8:32

wasn't his first time their reporting.

8:35

He had been in the days

8:37

following, so in the six days,

8:39

he had been back and forth

8:41

between Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and places in

8:44

between. So, and he had visited

8:46

Altoona before, and, you know, maybe,

8:48

I don't know, I mean, he

8:50

clearly felt a little more comfortable

8:52

more comfortable on this, on this

8:55

corridor. And I believe he would

8:57

have been familiar with the area

8:59

since they reported that he had

9:01

been a UPenn student. So I

9:04

mean, that's in that neck of

9:06

the woods. So it's just so

9:08

interesting. He goes back to a

9:10

familiar place. People usually do that

9:12

whenever they commit crimes, they usually

9:15

go within 10 miles to dump

9:17

the body. And you wouldn't think

9:19

that. You would think that they

9:21

would go somewhere far away. But

9:24

something about the human psychology makes

9:26

you go to the familiar whenever

9:28

you're scared, whenever you're running. And

9:30

it's really hard to fight that.

9:32

Whenever I was a producer for

9:35

48 hours on CBS, we would

9:37

always see the bodies are found

9:39

in these seemingly random locations. And

9:41

then it turns out that whenever

9:44

you expand the map, The main

9:46

suspect lives in close proximity or

9:48

has a family member that lives

9:50

there or works in the area.

9:52

There's always some connection and it

9:55

it's all about getting that comfort

9:57

zone as strange as that sounds

9:59

for committing a terrible crime but

10:01

I think it was the same

10:04

for Luigi that he wanted to.

10:06

somewhere where he felt comfortable and

10:08

it was the East Coast. I

10:10

mean, he could have very easily

10:12

from New York gotten almost anywhere.

10:15

And I know they had the

10:17

look out, you know, the Canadian

10:19

border, the Mexican border, and turns

10:21

out, you know, he didn't go

10:24

too far. So let's talk about

10:26

what he had on him at

10:28

the time of his arrest. Yes.

10:30

Well, he had a backpack. He

10:32

was typing on a laptop. He

10:35

had about $8,000 cash on him,

10:37

which that's interesting. We should talk

10:39

about that in a moment as

10:41

well. And a manifesto. Oh, sorry.

10:44

And how about a gun? How

10:46

about a homemade 3D printed gun

10:48

and silencer with bullets in the

10:50

chambers? I mean, yes, and it

10:52

appears to be the very same

10:55

gun that killed Brian Thompson. And

10:57

yeah, it's what they're calling a

10:59

ghost gun. So the company, what

11:01

a name, yeah, can be printed

11:04

from a 3D printer and assembled

11:06

all without having to register it,

11:08

which is just another new terrifying

11:10

fact about how we have access

11:12

to guns in America. So this

11:15

is just a new thing that

11:17

I was unaware that you could

11:19

actually make your own weapons at

11:21

home and so effectively use them.

11:24

I gotta say I'm a little

11:26

upset with the news because on

11:28

a number of cable networks all

11:30

say they had experts who I

11:32

got it. Everyone wants a moment,

11:35

but they had experts who basically

11:37

described to all of America how

11:39

to make your own ghost gun,

11:41

and I thought that was such

11:44

a disservice to the world. So

11:46

I do take issue with people

11:48

getting on these news networks and,

11:50

you know, sort of explaining how

11:52

to do it. Terrible. That does

11:55

seem a bit troubling. Like we

11:57

don't really need to give a

11:59

step-by-step how-to- anyone out there is

12:01

listening, please think twice before booking

12:04

those experts and giving the how

12:06

to to would be criminals out

12:08

there, although I'm sure they do

12:10

know how to do it themselves,

12:12

we just don't need to plant

12:15

the seed for future ones who

12:17

hadn't thought about it. So something

12:19

else that Luigi had on him

12:21

when he was arrested was a

12:24

number of fake IDs, including the

12:26

fake New Jersey ID that the

12:28

suspect used to check into the

12:30

hostile. So that is another really

12:32

big piece of evidence that as

12:35

if we needed more shows that

12:37

Luigi Mangioni and the shooter of

12:39

the United Health Care CEO are

12:41

one in the same. I

12:44

know and don't you think that's

12:46

just a rookie mistake I mean

12:48

for as much as I mean

12:51

I know I you we all

12:53

thought this wow when we first

12:55

saw that video we were like

12:57

wow what a professional wow the

13:00

monopoly money in the backpack oh

13:02

I don't even know if we

13:04

you know you have not talked

13:06

about that in some ways he

13:08

was very professional very thoughtful and

13:11

in others it seems completely clueless

13:13

and that was his undoing but

13:15

one of the ways that added

13:17

major intrigue to this and was

13:20

just a complete middle finger to

13:22

investigators is once they found the

13:24

backpack the distinctive gray peak design

13:26

backpack in Central Park. Inside

13:29

was Monopoly money and a

13:31

Tommy Hill figure jacket, which

13:33

was not described as being

13:35

the jacket that the shooter

13:37

wore. So it appears to

13:39

be just total nonsense that

13:41

he put in this backpack

13:43

and ditched in Central Park.

13:45

Yeah, I mean, I have

13:48

to admit I was laughing

13:50

and almost that moment

13:52

in the movie. I just felt like

13:54

it was such a Thomas Crown affair

13:56

moment where I'm like, oh good, you

13:59

know, it's sort of one of those

14:01

moments where you're like, that's funny. And

14:03

you don't you don't want to laugh

14:06

in a situation like this, but you're

14:08

like, okay, Tuesday, you know, you got

14:10

to give it to him. Absolutely. The

14:12

monopoly money is an amusing choice and

14:15

You just you can picture those

14:17

officers unzipping that backpack thinking are

14:19

we going to have the gun?

14:21

Are we going to have you

14:24

know other forensic evidence and it's

14:26

brightly colored monopoly money that just

14:28

had to be a real headscratcher.

14:30

I know. And and so then

14:32

you think back to the footage

14:34

of him leaving the park without

14:36

the backpack. Clearly now we know

14:38

he had. the gun, the homemade

14:40

gun somewhere on him. I mean,

14:42

where? Who knows? It wasn't, you

14:44

know, super close up, but there

14:46

were certainly no outlines of that

14:49

in that video. We saw him

14:51

riding a bike. You know, he

14:53

retained all kinds of things, right?

14:55

Like he had been on the

14:57

run. So. Yeah, the monopoly

14:59

money, the backpack. I mean, I thought

15:01

for sure that was going to be

15:03

a red herring. I guess it really

15:05

was the backpack. I don't know if

15:07

he had multiples of these things. When

15:09

he was arrested, they said he had

15:11

a backpack. I don't know if it

15:13

was the same one or somehow he

15:15

had different one that he had changed.

15:18

But yeah, there were so many, he's

15:20

such a dichotomy because on one hand,

15:22

this was so produced right like it

15:24

was so thought out it was so

15:26

planned it was well executed he certainly

15:28

was getting away with it until he

15:30

didn't you know until someone identified him

15:32

but i if that employee hadn't done

15:34

that i don't know how much longer

15:36

i mean i think he could have

15:38

gone on a lot longer without being

15:40

identified clearly no one had gotten him

15:42

since then but Yeah,

15:44

I mean, his, well, let's

15:47

talk about who Luigi Mangioni

15:49

is. What do you know

15:51

about this young man? So

15:53

we know that he's 26.

15:55

And what I personally find

15:57

interesting is I grew up

15:59

not too far from where

16:02

he's from. So I had

16:04

heard of the family. I

16:06

had heard of the family.

16:08

They are pretty prominent in

16:10

the area. They own a

16:12

bunch of real estate, including

16:14

country clubs, they're sort of

16:17

high end like that. They

16:19

own a number of I

16:21

believe it's like elderly assisted

16:23

living type places. I know

16:25

the patriarch of the family

16:27

is the grandfather. you

16:30

know there were 10 kids and

16:32

you know lots of grandkids and

16:34

he's one of those grandkids in

16:36

this in this family and they're

16:38

calling him a news a sion

16:40

of Baltimore's wealthiest one of Baltimore's

16:43

wealthiest families and it's they're not

16:45

wrong I mean part of me

16:47

was like I know they were

16:49

that wealthy and seems they are

16:51

and so here you have a

16:54

kid I'll call him a kid

16:56

I know he's 26 but a

16:58

kid who grew up wanting for

17:00

nothing you know the family It

17:02

definitely instilled a good work ethic.

17:04

I believe all of the children

17:07

work at the family business. They

17:09

do fun community events. I happen

17:11

to know every year his father

17:13

throws a, you know, Italian open

17:15

golf outing and, you know, that's

17:18

one of the country clubs and

17:20

it's very community driven and, you

17:22

know, it just seems like a

17:24

really good solid family. And so

17:26

it's so interesting that But Luigi

17:28

comes from this background once for

17:31

nothing, goes to the best schools,

17:33

goes to, you know, it's valedictorian

17:35

of Gilman Prep School, which is

17:37

a very good school in the

17:39

Baltimore area, goes on to the

17:41

University of Pennsylvania where he earns

17:44

multiple master's degrees. I mean, he's

17:46

a smart kid. He was a

17:48

scholar athlete. I believe he was

17:50

even featured in sports illustrated for

17:52

something. I mean, this guy really

17:55

has it all together and has

17:57

such a bright future. And so

17:59

where this all falls down is

18:01

anyone's guess. Yes. So. does seem

18:03

like he had the world on

18:05

a silver platter and he decided

18:08

that this was the move that

18:10

he wanted to make. Now, I

18:12

know that we've talked about him

18:14

being the val Victorian, going to

18:16

UPenn. Everything was lining

18:19

up for him. And then

18:21

it seems like in the

18:23

past six months, there's something

18:25

going on where he stopped

18:28

communicating with his family, he's

18:30

not responding to friends. People

18:32

are wondering what happened to

18:34

him. He's kind of dropped

18:36

off the radar. I was

18:39

looking into some reports that,

18:41

you know, he had undergone

18:43

spinal fusion surgery. And that

18:45

was interesting to me because

18:47

I also underwent spinal fusion

18:50

surgery recently and it is

18:52

quite the experience. It is

18:54

definitely a very serious surgery.

18:56

It is one of the

18:58

most painful surgeries that you

19:01

can have. as someone who's

19:03

gone through both childbirth and

19:05

spinal surgery, I would rank

19:07

spinal surgery ahead of childbirth

19:09

in terms of pain and

19:12

just an experience I would

19:14

not want to repeat. So

19:16

that seems to be the

19:18

only sort of difficulty that

19:20

we know of in Luigi's

19:23

life. And it's fairly recent.

19:25

I haven't seen exact dates,

19:27

but it seems like it

19:29

might have happened in 2023

19:32

where he had the spinal surgery

19:34

and he's posting photos of the

19:36

hardware. As all spinal fusion surgery

19:39

patients do you are proud of

19:41

the fact that you now are

19:43

bionic and you have titanium in

19:46

you. So he posted that photo

19:48

showing that he had titanium screws

19:50

and plates in his back now.

19:52

And so was that the event?

19:55

Was that what caused him to

19:57

realize how much care costs in

19:59

America. It's about $100,000 surgery, give

20:02

or take, depending on how many

20:04

levels of fusion you have. And

20:06

so that raised a red flag

20:09

for me that maybe that event

20:11

had some worse to do with

20:13

his decision to assassinate the CEO

20:15

of United Health Care than perhaps

20:18

other events in his life. It

20:20

was also interesting to me that,

20:22

you know, whenever I was going

20:25

through leading up to the surgery

20:27

and then post surgery, the amount

20:29

of muscle relaxers painkillers, you know,

20:31

things that they would prescribe for

20:34

you is is almost unlimited. This

20:36

is a very painful surgery. So

20:38

I do wonder if perhaps he's

20:41

under the influence of something that's

20:43

not an excuse in any way,

20:45

but it could be a factor.

20:48

And I wonder if possibly that

20:50

has something to do with this

20:52

major shift in, you know, his

20:54

choices. I also, yeah, I mean,

20:57

when I saw the that he

20:59

had had this back surgery, I

21:01

instantly thought of you and everything

21:04

you went through and you, you

21:06

know, luckily don't have an addictive

21:08

personality or anything to concern yourself

21:11

with, but yeah, the medicines are

21:13

strong. I mean, they can affect

21:15

you psychologically. They had his roommate

21:17

from Hawaii during the time when

21:20

he lived in Hawaii on who

21:22

mentioned that because he was in

21:24

so much pain all the time,

21:27

he had dabbled in psychedelics to

21:29

help ease the pain. So I

21:31

do think he wasn't above an

21:33

illicit drug just to help the

21:36

pain. The cost of the surgery

21:38

and insurance coverage and all that,

21:40

again, the family is so wealthy,

21:43

I doubt that was a driver,

21:45

although we don't know what kind

21:47

of relationship he had with his

21:50

family, if you know, I know

21:52

I believe it's after 25, you're

21:54

off your parents insurance, if you

21:56

don't have a job and he

21:59

was. I was going to say.

22:01

So he was 26 and that's

22:03

when you typically get cut off.

22:06

You can stay on. I looked

22:08

it up in Pennsylvania until 29

22:10

or even 30 if you are

22:12

unmarried and a full-time student. So

22:15

possibly, but he wasn't no longer

22:17

going to school. So he had

22:19

graduated. He had worked for a

22:22

little while in tech. And then

22:24

it appeared that he went to

22:26

Hawaii and was living like in

22:29

some type of communal housing, but

22:31

he was very well-liked and social

22:33

at that time. But perhaps that

22:35

was a period of time where

22:38

he started to become radicalized. I

22:40

know people have made a lot

22:42

about his good reads and his

22:45

choice of reading material. Right. I

22:47

mean, that does say something, right.

22:49

I mean, he's seeking out. A

22:52

Ted Kazinsky manifesto, he has a

22:54

manifesto on him when he's caught.

22:56

You know, there is, it's interesting,

22:58

the line that stands out to

23:00

everyone is it had to be

23:02

done. he writes, it had to

23:04

be done. And prior to that,

23:06

he does apologize. So there's a,

23:08

a reference to like, you know,

23:10

him knowing this is wrong. I

23:12

mean, fundamentally murder is wrong. And

23:14

he knows it, but it had,

23:16

so he has this justification. And

23:18

I think he does feel justified

23:20

because those two have come before

23:22

him have done it and made

23:24

their statement and impact on the

23:26

world. And he felt responsible for

23:28

doing this somehow. Yeah,

23:31

it's really fascinating just to

23:33

think that in his mind,

23:35

this was somehow the best

23:37

choice that he could make

23:39

because he seems to have

23:41

actually thought it through, which

23:43

is even more disturbing. It's

23:45

almost like with his life

23:47

of privilege, like he was

23:49

looking to do something hard

23:51

to have a difficult experience

23:53

and the idea that he

23:55

would choose to commit murder

23:57

when he could have, you

23:59

know, Peace Corps, if you

24:01

want to have a experience

24:03

that's difficult and you've had

24:05

a privileged life, speaking for

24:07

personal experience, it's, you know,

24:09

there's so many different ways

24:11

to add distress into your

24:13

life that can be positive,

24:15

right? If you really are

24:17

trying to break out of

24:19

your sheltered upbringing, but this

24:21

is so far out of

24:23

the realm of normal behavior,

24:26

it's It's just really shocking.

24:28

And I know he said

24:30

in the manifesto to save

24:32

a lot of trouble and

24:34

a lot of time, that's

24:36

a paraphrase, but I acted

24:38

alone. And I

24:40

think that's really interesting because, I

24:42

mean, are we taking his word

24:45

for it that he acted alone?

24:47

This is a guy who gave

24:49

a murder. I'm not really sure

24:52

he's going to be completely truthful

24:54

here. And the idea that we

24:56

still don't know who he called

24:59

after these minutes, I was thinking

25:01

the same thing, who's at least

25:03

I was talking to at 6.40

25:06

in the morning, right after he's

25:08

killed the CEO of United Health

25:10

Care. To me, I don't buy

25:12

that there's not one other person

25:15

who was aware that he was

25:17

planning this and that he bragged

25:19

to afterwards. That seems impossible. I

25:22

mean, there has to be some

25:24

narcissistic personality at play here, just

25:26

the idea that he thinks he's

25:29

going to change the health care

25:31

industry himself. One guy is going

25:33

to go out and do something,

25:36

you know, talk about grandiose thinking,

25:38

he's going to go make his

25:40

mark and change the landscape of

25:43

the country's health care industry with

25:45

one shot, right? That's just completely

25:47

absurd. But in his mind, he

25:50

was doing, you know, this. brave

25:52

bold thing and you know you

25:54

could see my air quotes right

25:57

now it's it's completely cowardly to

25:59

shoot someone in the back there's

26:01

nothing brave about it and he

26:04

has basically ended his own life

26:06

in that he's going to be

26:08

lucky to ever see the outside

26:11

of a prison. I mean they

26:13

have to you know I've saw

26:15

that it's second-degree murder and my

26:17

first thought was how in the

26:20

world is this not first-degree murder

26:22

because in Texas that just means

26:24

that's premeditated murder. is

26:27

it qualifies for first degree murder.

26:29

Also, if you're in the commission

26:31

of another felony, whenever you commit

26:33

the murder, then it's first degree

26:35

murder. It's also in Texas eligible

26:38

for capital murder, which is eligible

26:40

for the death penalty if you

26:42

are committing another felony, which using

26:44

a illegal gun to commit murder

26:47

would would be that double felony

26:49

but I looked it up in

26:51

New York it seems like the

26:53

only one that he qualifies for

26:55

a second-degree murder their their statute

26:58

is just different and I was

27:00

really surprised that shooting someone in

27:02

cold blood on the streets with

27:04

premeditated. Yeah. that that is not

27:07

first degree murder to me that

27:09

makes zero sense and I don't

27:11

understand why there's lots of things

27:13

that are first degree murder in

27:15

New York it's killing a police

27:18

officer it's you know killing more

27:20

than one person at the same

27:22

time but for some reason it's

27:24

not this so maybe that's why

27:27

he chose to do it in

27:29

New York maybe he knew all

27:31

this because New York also does

27:33

not have a death penalty. Oh

27:35

interesting. So worst case he'll get

27:38

life in prison with you know

27:40

parole is or a possibility maybe

27:42

I don't know parole yes or

27:44

no who knows how that goes

27:47

but yeah so because we were

27:49

wondering right like why didn't he

27:51

do this where the guy lives

27:53

or you know anywhere else but

27:55

maybe that's a reason then to

27:58

do something like this in New

28:00

York state and I think like

28:02

we discussed previously the hiding in

28:04

plain sight having many people, I

28:07

mean, it's definitely more of a

28:09

challenge, but it's also you can

28:11

use it to your advantage. And

28:13

he almost got away with it.

28:15

He got away with it for

28:18

six days, six day man hunt.

28:20

That's, that's not nothing. You know,

28:22

he did make his getaway. I

28:24

think it's impressive, actually, that he

28:27

got out on his own. And

28:29

it's only through just the continued.

28:31

joggedness of the public, you know,

28:33

the alertness that he was that

28:35

he was captured. I want to

28:38

just talk for a minute about

28:40

the capture for a moment when

28:42

the $8,000 that he had on

28:44

him. I mean, clearly we know

28:47

he comes from money, but he

28:49

had an additional $2,000 in foreign

28:51

currency that I don't think they're

28:53

saying what countries it was from

28:55

yet. And he said. That

28:58

was planted. So it's just so interesting

29:00

to me, he basically all but admits

29:03

he was in New York. They find

29:05

the gun he had denied it. He

29:07

admits his real name after handing off

29:10

the fake ID that was the same

29:12

one used to check into the hostile.

29:14

So he's giving up information. Why? Why

29:17

do you like what makes him lie

29:19

about something as casual as money? It's

29:21

not illegal to have money on you.

29:25

Yeah, that is really strange that

29:27

he would draw the line there

29:29

and say no, that's not mine.

29:31

Yeah, all the things. The laptop,

29:34

I mean, you have like all

29:36

of the problems that this guy

29:38

has at that moment of the

29:40

arrest, I do not believe having

29:43

under $10,000, which I think is

29:45

the cutoff for things like customs

29:47

and all that. is illegal. I

29:49

mean, I just found that so

29:52

odd. I feel like there's something

29:54

we don't know that we will

29:56

find out that he will divulge

29:59

that will be. and

30:01

I don't know why. Yeah, it is

30:03

extremely. surprising that that

30:05

that would even come up and

30:07

yeah I'm curious to see where

30:09

that goes. So final thoughts. I

30:12

want to shout out to a

30:14

listener Janice who sent us a

30:16

link to something on TikTok talking

30:19

about how people are roasting United

30:21

Health Care for posting a job

30:23

opening for their CEO just 24

30:26

hours after the assassination. Is that

30:28

a real job posting or did

30:30

someone? As far as I know,

30:33

it's real. I didn't, I'll be

30:35

honest, I didn't go down and

30:37

verify, but it is, but as

30:39

far as I know, it's a

30:42

real job posting and the tick

30:44

talker was saying, your job does

30:46

not care about you. Even if

30:49

you make, you know, millions of

30:51

dollars, even if you're the CEO,

30:53

your job does not care about

30:56

you. This is how quickly you'll

30:58

be replaced. Yeah, it's a good

31:00

reminder. I mean, if that's true,

31:03

I mean, who wants that job

31:05

now? Nobody really, right? I mean,

31:07

just that that would be their

31:10

priority. Our see down cold blood

31:12

on the streets of New York.

31:14

Well, we got to find somebody

31:17

else to fill a shoes. Let's

31:19

let's go ahead and post that

31:21

job A. S. A. B. I

31:23

mean, yeah, I am going to

31:26

maybe say that's a fake posting

31:28

because I feel like CEO jobs

31:30

are usually head hunted or promoted

31:33

within. I think it's more a

31:35

statement someone was making, but if

31:37

it's real, oh my goodness, that

31:40

would be crazy. So he was

31:42

indicted, Luigi was indicted, and then

31:44

he was extradited or had another

31:47

hearing today. I believe.

31:49

Yeah, I think it might actually be

31:51

going on now. Yeah. And it

31:53

was funny. I don't know if you,

31:55

sorry, nothing about this is funny. If

31:58

you watch the video of him being

32:00

escorted by the police to the courthouse

32:02

in Pennsylvania, the police officer hops out

32:05

of the car and opens the door

32:07

and he had scoots to the other

32:09

side so the cameras caught nothing, like

32:12

it almost as if he had

32:14

disappeared, which... Oh my gosh. Kind of.

32:16

I mean, the guy is playing with

32:18

them still. He's still playing with the

32:21

cops. And so, you know, the guy

32:23

then has to go around the other

32:25

side and, you know, he comes out

32:28

and I didn't realize this guy's very

32:30

tall, so he's actually quite, you know,

32:32

noticeable and he's lengthy, but he's tall,

32:35

he's much taller than all of

32:37

the police officers that are surrounding him.

32:39

And he makes a comment of, I

32:41

don't know exactly what he said, but

32:44

he was sort of fighting to get

32:46

away and making comments and I was

32:48

wondering if somebody had tapped him on

32:51

the shoulder and said, hey, play a

32:53

little insane. I think we could use

32:55

that in your defense. What do

32:58

you think about that? Interesting. I mean,

33:00

I don't know who could have tapped

33:02

him on the shoulder. Yeah, I don't

33:05

think he has a lawyer yet. He's

33:07

refused public counsel. Yeah

33:09

so I mean just the idea that

33:11

someone would be that close to him

33:14

to be able to say that it

33:16

might just be an idea that popped

33:18

into his own deranged brain to to

33:21

start doing that but yeah the insanity

33:23

defense I think we're going to see

33:25

the best defense money can buy with

33:27

this guy so it will be interesting

33:30

to see if you know there ends

33:32

up being a trial if there's a

33:34

plea deal. there could be any number

33:37

of things that happened between now and

33:39

then trials take sometimes years to get

33:41

on the docket so we might not

33:44

get many more answers soon but at

33:46

some point it's all going to come

33:48

out. Yeah I mean it was certainly

33:50

it was certainly a site if you

33:53

can you know I'm sure the video

33:55

will be circulating online if I'm getting

33:57

out of that police car but I

34:00

caught a I caught a brief of

34:02

it and thought, oof, like he's, he

34:04

is acting a little crazy. And of

34:06

course, you have to be crazy to

34:09

commit cold-blooded murder. But the cool common

34:11

collected guy that we saw in that

34:13

assassination video was not this guy that

34:16

came out of the, I mean, he's

34:18

kind of little all over the place,

34:20

that from what I can see. Yeah,

34:23

I mean, the jig is up. I

34:25

remember that was something that was always

34:27

interesting when I was at 48 hours

34:29

and I'd be covering these murder trials.

34:32

The person who committed the crime, you

34:34

know, what they looked like when they

34:36

were brought in for questioning and what

34:39

they looked like by the time the

34:41

trial started. usually almost unrecognizable. They would

34:43

have aged so much, they would either

34:45

gain a bunch of weight or lose

34:48

a bunch of weight. If they were

34:50

clean shaven, they'd grow beard, you know,

34:52

vice versa. It was like, oh, that

34:55

guy that committed the crime, that's not

34:57

me. You know, it was always this

34:59

extremely stark contrast between how they looked

35:02

when they were committing the crime and

35:04

how they looked. whenever they were on

35:06

trial for it. So I know a

35:08

lot of people are talking about how

35:11

Luigi Mangioni looks. He's he's getting some

35:13

sort of Ted Bundy, um, fandom in

35:15

terms of the sick attraction to a

35:18

murder. Yeah, yeah, they're calling him a

35:20

hot hero on social media, which is

35:22

just terrible. It really is. So terrible.

35:24

You know what I was Well

35:28

I was thinking he's almost like

35:30

the Robert Durst of this generation.

35:32

I mean a kid who had

35:34

all that is a really good

35:36

analogy. Right went off the deep

35:38

end now obviously you know Robert

35:40

Durst clearly had well he clearly

35:42

had mental issues too and admitted

35:44

to killing people and on a

35:46

hot mic as we'll recall and

35:48

during the jinks recording and you

35:50

know this was I feel like

35:52

his murders were you know more

35:54

personally well I guess all murder

35:56

well this murder is too personal

35:58

motivated, but less of a I

36:00

need to save the world, less

36:02

of a God complex almost, and

36:04

more of a, I need to

36:06

just kill this person to get

36:08

them out of my way to

36:10

sort of self-preservation. And I think

36:12

the difference here with Luigi Mangioni

36:14

is more of a God complex

36:16

almost, of I need to save

36:18

the world and rid it of

36:20

these parasites as he called them.

36:22

But the family, the things he

36:24

would have been entitled to, the

36:26

legacy, the scionism, all that's there.

36:28

I mean, that's why I think

36:31

we're all going to stay really

36:33

fascinated with this case. Yes,

36:35

I agree and just, you know,

36:37

I think maybe we can close

36:40

on the Mangioni family statement, you

36:42

know, they have come out, obviously

36:44

they don't have a ton that

36:47

they want to say, but they

36:49

are sharing that they're shocked and

36:52

devastated by Luigi's arrest. And they

36:54

offer, we offer our prayers to

36:56

the family of Brian Thompson and

36:59

all involved. And so that is

37:01

where we'll leave it today. And

37:04

thank you so much for tuning

37:06

in to our third episode of

37:08

Justice Pending. We didn't anticipate releasing

37:11

the podcast this early, but because

37:13

of breaking news, because this case

37:15

is so unusual, we just had

37:18

to jump out there and tell

37:20

you about it. we will release

37:23

our actual intended first episode that

37:25

we recorded to sort of introduce

37:27

ourselves and talk about how we

37:30

became such good friends and so

37:32

obsessed with true crime because there's

37:35

a pretty great backstory there. Yeah,

37:37

I know it is. Leave it

37:39

to us to do things in

37:42

a different way, a different path.

37:44

Well, we accidentally started a breaking

37:47

news podcast that was not the

37:49

plan, but that's what this is

37:51

now. Well, there are plenty of

37:54

other cases that are by now

37:56

very, very frigidly cold that still

37:58

have justice pending for them. we

38:01

will definitely circle back and bring

38:03

you this. We will. And we'll

38:06

keep our eye on this one

38:08

and we'll look out for any

38:10

new interesting cases. And yeah, stay

38:13

tuned. There's lots more coming. If

38:15

you are looking for even more

38:18

true crime content, check out my

38:20

upcoming book, Killer Story, The Truth

38:22

Behind True Crime Television. A limited

38:25

number of copies are available for

38:27

preorder now at killer storybook.com. Justice

38:30

Pending is produced in

38:32

Dallas Texas for Rebel

38:35

Studios. Executive producers and

38:37

hosts are me, Claire

38:39

Santa Monica, and Susan

38:41

Passoni. Our theme music

38:43

is Bending Truth, licensed

38:45

at premiumbeat.com. For

38:49

over 100 years, Schneider Electric has

38:51

provided the equipment and expertise to

38:53

pros to keep the lights on.

38:55

But in the 21st century, your

38:57

home demands a symphony of energy.

38:59

Digital devices, battery backup, EV charging,

39:01

and you've got the power, with

39:03

help from Schneider Home. Let's talk

39:05

about automated energy control. Why do

39:07

your appliances need a connected system?

39:10

It's an investment in real money

39:12

savings. Because your energy use is

39:14

streamlined, using off-peak draw or battery

39:16

backup to optimize your use and

39:18

savings. which is better for the

39:20

planet and puts money back in

39:22

your pocket. A double savings from

39:24

your friends at Schneider Home. So

39:26

let's start with the basics. At

39:28

Snyder Home.com it's easy to see

39:30

what tech you may need and

39:32

be connected with a certified local

39:34

installer to make sure your power

39:36

always stays ahead of your needs.

39:38

And it's flexible. No solar, smaller

39:40

system. Yeah, we got you. Design

39:42

your system at Schneider Home.com today

39:44

and enjoy the symphony. You've got

39:46

the power. At

39:49

Arizona State University, we're bringing world-class

39:52

education from our globally acclaimed faculty

39:54

to you, ranked number one in

39:56

innovation for 10 consecutive years, and

39:58

number two among public for

40:00

employability. ASU isn't just

40:02

ahead of the curve, of it's

40:04

creating new paths to success. to Earn

40:07

your degree from the nation's most

40:09

innovative most innovative that's a

40:11

degree better. a Explore more

40:13

than 300 undergraduate, 300 graduate, and

40:15

certificate programs at certificate .edu.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features