Inside Thomas Jefferson's Complicated Relationship With Slavery

Inside Thomas Jefferson's Complicated Relationship With Slavery

Released Wednesday, 12th March 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Inside Thomas Jefferson's Complicated Relationship With Slavery

Inside Thomas Jefferson's Complicated Relationship With Slavery

Inside Thomas Jefferson's Complicated Relationship With Slavery

Inside Thomas Jefferson's Complicated Relationship With Slavery

Wednesday, 12th March 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

You're listening to an

0:02

airwave media podcast. Hello, this

0:04

is Matt and McKinley from

0:06

History Dispatches. We are

0:08

the father-son duo bringing the

0:10

weird, the wild, the wacky, and

0:13

the craziest tales from across time.

0:15

From the Ice Bowl, to the

0:17

Great Heathen Army, and the head

0:19

of Oliver Cromwell. The same head

0:21

they kept on a pike for

0:24

three years? Yep, all here on

0:26

history dispatches. New episodes every

0:28

weekday. Find out more at

0:30

History Dispatches.com or wherever you

0:33

get your podcast app. In the

0:35

Declaration of Independence,

0:37

Thomas Jefferson famously

0:39

wrote, we hold these truths to

0:42

be self-evident, that all men are

0:44

created equal. They are endowed by

0:46

their creator with certain unalienable

0:49

rights, that among these are

0:51

life, liberty, and the pursuit

0:53

of happiness. But Thomas Jefferson

0:55

also enslaved some 600 people. Jefferson's

0:58

words and Jefferson's actions can be

1:00

hard to reconcile. How can a

1:02

man who believe that all men

1:05

are equal also have owned slaves?

1:07

How could a man who called slavery

1:09

a hideous blot on the United

1:11

States enslave other human beings until

1:14

the end of his life? Though Thomas

1:16

Jefferson's innermost thoughts about slavery are

1:18

impossible to know, his words and

1:20

actions during his life suggest that

1:22

his relationship with the institution of

1:25

slavery was complex, he was born

1:27

into a slave-owning family and would

1:29

come to enslave hundreds of men,

1:31

women, and children at his Monticello

1:33

plantation in Virginia. Yet as a

1:35

young man, Jefferson pushed for the

1:37

abolition of slavery and even penned

1:40

a fiery tirate against it in

1:42

the Declaration of Independence, though this

1:44

passage was ultimately cut. During his

1:46

presidency from 1801 to 1809,

1:48

Thomas Jefferson brought enslaved people

1:50

from Monticello to the White

1:52

House, yet he also ordered

1:54

Congress to abolish the international

1:56

slave trade in 1806, calling

1:58

it a violation. of human

2:00

rights. Jefferson also argued that emancipating

2:03

slaves quickly would not work because

2:05

formerly enslaved people were incapable of

2:07

taking care of themselves. He suggested

2:09

that there was no place for

2:11

formerly enslaved people in the United

2:14

States and that they should be

2:16

deported to Africa or the West

2:18

Indies. Yet Jefferson also had a

2:20

years-long secret relationship with an enslaved

2:23

woman named Sally Hemings. the exact

2:25

dynamics of their relationship are unknown,

2:27

and of course, as an enslaved

2:29

woman, Hemings would have had little

2:31

choice in the matter. But their relationship

2:34

lasted for four decades, and Sally Hemings

2:36

gave birth to six children. Modern science

2:38

has suggested that Jefferson is very likely

2:41

the father of all six of Hemings

2:43

children, and she was seemingly able to

2:45

negotiate with him for their freedom. Ultimately,

2:47

Thomas Jefferson was someone who said he

2:50

abhorred slavery but saw no easy way

2:52

to end it. He once compared slavery

2:54

in the United States to holding a

2:57

wolf by the ear, which could neither

2:59

be held safely nor let go safely.

3:01

And in the end, he left

3:03

the solving of this problem to

3:06

future generations. The story of Thomas

3:08

Jefferson's relationship with slavery helps provide

3:10

an insightful look at the history

3:13

of slavery in the United States

3:15

as a whole. Jefferson disliked slavery,

3:17

but benefited from it. He sought

3:20

to abolish it, yet participated in

3:22

it. Today, we'll look at the

3:24

arc of Jefferson's words and

3:26

actions regarding slavery, an institution

3:28

that he called immoral depravity,

3:31

even as he enslaved hundreds

3:33

of people. You're

3:36

listening to History Uncovered, brought to

3:39

you by the digital publisher All

3:41

that's interesting, where we explore the

3:43

untrarted corners of the natural world

3:45

and the world past. I'm all

3:47

interesting staff writer Colina Fraga. And

3:49

I'm all that's interesting staff

3:51

writer Austin Harvey. Today we're

3:53

untangling Thomas Jefferson's complex

3:56

relationship with slavery. And it

3:58

is indeed complex. It's been a while.

4:00

because situations worked out

4:02

weird. You're in a different state

4:04

and you happen to have lost

4:06

power last week. So we couldn't

4:08

record that. So it feels like

4:11

it's been forever since we did

4:13

the Malcolm X one and keyed

4:15

this one up. I know it's so true

4:17

a lifetime ago. I think it's coming

4:19

out a week late as well because

4:22

we didn't record it last week.

4:24

Right. And that's the reason why.

4:26

I'm at my parents' house and

4:28

we lost power for a few days.

4:30

I almost said what state you were in

4:32

and I was like, well I don't

4:35

really want to adopt your parents.

4:37

I mean, yeah, it's a, yeah, it's the country.

4:39

Yeah, sometimes we lose power and

4:42

wind storms. Yeah, but here

4:44

we are, bright-eyed and bushy-tailed,

4:46

so yes. Thomas Jefferson.

4:48

Basically, I mean, the, just

4:50

like to quickly like set this

4:52

up. Thomas Jefferson like has slavery in

4:55

his life from the very beginning

4:57

because he's born on his father's plantation

4:59

and in Virginia and his father had

5:01

60 enslaved people already. So this is

5:03

something that Jefferson grew up with and

5:06

when Jefferson's father died, Jefferson was only

5:08

14, he inherited 30 of these enslaved

5:10

people so basically right off the bat

5:13

like from a very very young age

5:15

he owned other human beings. Yeah that's

5:17

such a weird concept to me. Like I

5:20

know that sounds so like what a nothing

5:22

burger of a statement like wow slavery such

5:24

a weird concept but I think it really

5:26

it really landed home because like I think

5:29

we all know what slavery is and what

5:31

it means to have enslaved people and

5:33

begin to consider other people your property

5:35

but I think what really made it

5:37

registered for me there was like oh

5:39

he inherited people. I was like oh

5:42

that's so Geez, it just puts it, it's

5:44

gross. Yeah, it gets a lot weirder

5:46

with Jefferson in particular. And

5:48

this is a, this next

5:50

point is a really good

5:52

example of that. When he

5:54

gets married, he eventually inherits

5:57

135 more enslaved people from

5:59

his father-in-law. these was a 10-year-old

6:01

girl named Sally Hemings. His father-in-law

6:03

was actually Sally's father, which he

6:05

had Sally with one of his

6:08

enslaved women, which makes Sally Thomas

6:10

Jefferson's wife's half-sister. Wow. So that's,

6:12

I mean, spoiler alert, Sally Hemings

6:15

and Thomas Jefferson have a relationship.

6:17

Ugh. Yeah. Within just a few

6:19

years after this, actually, she was

6:21

his wife's half-sister. and they apparently

6:24

looked alike and you know his

6:26

wife died so like there's some

6:28

weird weird weird stuff about that

6:30

whole thing so that would make

6:32

her what his half-sister-in-law yeah wow

6:35

mhm very strange but you know all

6:37

this is going on in his family

6:39

life and his personal life but at

6:41

the same time Jefferson and his

6:43

political stars like slowly rising

6:45

in colonial America and when

6:47

he's elected to his first

6:50

office in Virginia he writes

6:52

A publication that's called The Summer

6:54

Review of the Rights of British

6:56

America for the First Continental Congress,

6:58

and this is basically arguing that

7:00

the British Parliament has no right

7:02

to govern American colonies, and one

7:04

thing that Jefferson points out in

7:06

particular is slavery. He writes basically,

7:08

I'll kind of summarize this, that

7:10

people in the colonies want the

7:12

abolition of slavery, and was unhappily

7:14

introduced by the British, and the

7:16

British have stopped them from trying

7:18

to like end this institution. which is

7:20

interesting because like he you know comes

7:22

from a slave holding background on slaves

7:24

and yet he's saying this pretty like

7:26

radical thing about like it's a British

7:29

it's their fault and we don't want

7:31

this and you force this on us

7:33

this wasn't ultimately published like it was

7:35

much more moderate version of it was

7:37

published by the Congress but Jefferson like

7:39

he doesn't change his mind about this

7:41

when he goes on to draft the

7:43

Declaration of Independence. The very first draft of

7:46

that also accuses the king of, he

7:48

calls it waging cruel war against human

7:50

nature itself, violating its most sacred rights

7:52

of life and liberty in the persons

7:54

of a distant people who never offended

7:56

him, captivating and carrying them into slavery

7:58

in another hemisphere. So, like, that's,

8:01

again, pretty radical. He's saying

8:03

the king, like, brought this

8:06

horrible, inhumane, like, institution to

8:08

the colonies. Hmm. It does

8:10

feel, not to defend the

8:13

English king, but it does

8:15

feel a bit unfair to put

8:17

it all on him. Yeah, well,

8:19

the king, like, in Jefferson's view,

8:21

is saying, like, we didn't want

8:23

this, you forts it on us,

8:25

we tried to stop it, like,

8:28

like, guilt, like, guilt, almost. It's

8:30

like, look, I have slaves, but like, I

8:32

didn't ask for them. It's the king's fault.

8:34

That's kind of Jefferson's whole

8:36

thing was like, I have them, but

8:38

the nation has them, we don't have

8:40

to do with them, and it's their

8:42

fault. But anyway, ultimately, this was not

8:44

included in the Declaration of Independence. I

8:46

mean, basically because a lot of people

8:49

did not agree with Jefferson and did

8:51

not want to, you know, call slavery

8:53

a war against human nature itself

8:55

or anything like that, because they

8:57

were slaveholders. Obviously, there were a

8:59

lot of them involved in the

9:01

foundation of the country. Ultimately,

9:03

as he continues to become, you know,

9:06

more and more involved in politics and

9:08

everything, he continues to, like, speak

9:10

out against slavery. In 1778, he

9:12

drops along Virginia to prohibit the

9:14

importation of enslaved Africans. In 1781,

9:16

he writes, this pamphlet, the notes

9:18

on the state of Virginia, and

9:20

he writes about the evils of

9:22

slavery. He says, I tremble for

9:24

my country when I reflect that

9:26

God is just cannot sleep forever.

9:29

That's like pretty like forceful language.

9:31

Yeah, man, they were so eloquent back

9:33

then. They were so eloquent. Yeah,

9:35

I know. But he also like

9:37

in the same document was like,

9:40

well, like, you know, enslaved people

9:42

are like really limited in their

9:44

abilities. And so maybe like, you

9:46

know, freeing them, I don't know.

9:48

At the same time, he does acknowledge

9:51

that their limitations might be

9:53

caused by being enslaved. So

9:55

yeah, man, he was like almost there. I

9:57

mean, as his political star continues to rise.

10:00

he stopped in this language is

10:02

much more muted. Yeah, you have

10:04

to kind of moderate yourself to

10:06

win over the voters who have

10:08

slaves. The South, which is a

10:10

huge important voting block and segment.

10:12

And they really liked their slavery

10:14

back then. We fought a whole

10:16

war about it. Yes, and it

10:18

was very important to their economy

10:20

at the time. Yeah. So basically

10:22

that's kind of what he's been

10:24

saying in his young adulthood at

10:26

the same time as the last

10:28

couple examples. he begins this relationship

10:30

with Sally Hemings who again is

10:32

an enslaved woman actually she's still

10:34

a girl she was 14 and

10:36

he was 40 not ideal this

10:38

happened when he was in Paris

10:40

with with her and her brother

10:42

and when they were in Paris

10:44

Sally and her brother James like

10:46

were exposed to ideas of freedom

10:48

that they'd never really encountered back

10:50

in the United States if they,

10:52

you know, they're exposed to these

10:54

new ideas in Paris, like what

10:56

was the world philosophy on slavery

10:58

at this point in time? Because

11:00

obviously a lot of European nations

11:02

did it at one point. England

11:04

did abolish slavery before the US

11:06

did. Although I couldn't tell you

11:08

the exact date of that. I

11:10

didn't look it up real quick.

11:12

1833 in England, in France. Oh,

11:14

1794. So after the French... French

11:16

Revolution. Revolution, yeah. And then a

11:18

second time in 1848? That was

11:20

possibly related to like Haiti, I

11:22

think? Yeah. Yeah. So they were

11:24

able to like see a different

11:26

world while they were there, and

11:28

neither wanted to go home. I

11:30

mean, both negotiated with Jefferson, and

11:32

Jefferson negotiated back. He agreed to

11:34

free James, if James taught another

11:36

person what he learned in Paris,

11:38

which he did. Sally refused to

11:40

return, but negotiated quote-unquote extraordinary privileges

11:42

with Jefferson, including the freedom for

11:44

her future children, and she was

11:46

pregnant at the time with his

11:48

child. So, again, 14 years old.

11:50

She ultimately had six children, four

11:52

of him. survived to adulthood and

11:54

they were all freed or simply

11:56

allowed to leave Monticello his plantation.

11:58

Two of her daughters could pass

12:00

his white so they just kind

12:02

of left and you know just

12:04

gave up that heritage and then

12:06

passed his white. Sally Hemings was

12:08

freed after Jefferson's death by his

12:10

daughter and in one sense that

12:12

she and her sons were described

12:14

as white as well. So this...

12:16

suggest that they were white passing.

12:18

Oh, she was half white, so

12:21

yeah. At least half white. I

12:23

mean, we don't know what her

12:25

mother's heritage was and what happened

12:27

to her, so. That's interesting. That

12:29

is a, that is an interesting

12:31

note of like, okay, well, these

12:33

were freed people, but they passed

12:35

as white, so they probably got

12:37

along decently fine after that. But

12:39

if you were like, if they

12:41

were much darker skin tone, I'm

12:43

curious how that would have. They

12:45

would not have gotten along as

12:47

fine. Right. Yeah, they would have

12:49

had a lot more more challenges.

12:51

Because it was like, yeah, you're

12:53

technically free, but also like most

12:55

people don't consider you a person

12:57

still. So how free is that

12:59

freedom? Right. Exactly. And it does

13:01

make this idea. It just kind

13:03

of points the absurdity of slavery

13:05

as it's based on like skin

13:07

color in the United States because

13:09

Sally Hemings and her children like

13:11

apparently could pass as white. and

13:13

yet they were enslaved. Right. So

13:15

yeah, I mean, obviously it's like

13:17

a... Yeah, it's a bad concept

13:19

regardless of why you're doing it.

13:21

It's a bad concept. Yeah, just

13:23

a concept doesn't really make a

13:25

whole lot of sense when you

13:27

look at it closely at all.

13:29

Yeah, it is really dumb. It's

13:31

really dumb. Thomas Jefferson, though, continued

13:33

to engage, you know, with this

13:35

institution. He ultimately enslaved 600 people

13:37

during his life. At any given

13:39

time, there were 130 enslaved people

13:41

at Monticello. And while he spoke

13:43

about improving conditions for enslaved people

13:45

or, you know, slowly ending slavery

13:47

or curbing the practice somehow, like

13:49

conditions at his plantation were pretty

13:51

typical for the time. That was

13:53

what I was about to ask

13:55

if he was like, well, he

13:57

treats him better or something, but

13:59

it doesn't seem like that's the

14:01

case. I mean... Thomas Jefferson was

14:03

probably not like involved in like

14:05

the day-to-day stuff on his plantation

14:07

But he had overseers and they

14:09

had a reputation for cruelty and

14:11

violence There's like no evidence that

14:13

he Jefferson like beat his slaves

14:15

But the overseers certainly did and

14:17

he certainly ordered them to be

14:19

beaten and they like enslaved people

14:21

in like almost any plantation phase,

14:23

you know, terrorists of violence family

14:25

separation emotional psychological and sexual abuse

14:27

so this like for them wasn't

14:29

much better even though you know,

14:31

he spoke about all these like

14:33

grand ideas. Yeah, God, how angry

14:35

would you be? Unfortunately, a lot

14:37

of enslaved people were never taught

14:40

to read. But imagine if you

14:42

were like someone who was enslaved

14:44

on Thomas Jefferson's farm and you

14:46

heard the things he was writing

14:48

about and you were like, wait,

14:50

the guy who owns this plantation

14:52

is saying that we shouldn't even

14:54

be here. I'd be delivered. Yeah,

14:56

yeah. I mean, people were livid

14:58

enslaved people. Of course, if they

15:00

had access to those ideas, which

15:02

most of them didn't. Well, I'm

15:04

sure they were all thinking it

15:06

too, privately, right? Yeah. Yeah. In

15:08

his life, he sold 110 slave

15:10

people, so this is sending them

15:12

to other plantations, you know, often

15:14

further into the South, where conditions

15:16

were worse. In his life, he

15:18

freed just 10, member he owned

15:20

600, and they were all members

15:22

of the Hemings family. So, yes.

15:24

Which also means they were kind

15:26

of members of members of his

15:28

own family. That's right. So a

15:30

little nepotism there? A lot of

15:32

nepotism. He clearly spoke out against

15:34

slavery in some ways, but he

15:36

saw its power and its benefits.

15:38

in Virginia between 1790 and 1830

15:40

the slave population grew about 60%

15:42

he he discouraged crops that relied

15:44

on slave labor like tobacco but

15:46

ultimately Virginia's most valuable commodity was

15:48

enslaved people like not crops right

15:50

and Jefferson knew that in 1792

15:52

he wrote to George Washington whose

15:54

name should ring about for everybody,

15:56

that he was making a 4%

15:58

profit every year based on the

16:00

birth of enslaved children. And in

16:02

1830 he also wrote, I consider

16:04

a woman who brings a child

16:06

every two years as more profitable

16:08

than the best man on the

16:10

farm and enslavement. What she produces

16:12

is in addition to the capital

16:14

while his labors disappear in mere

16:16

consumption. So that's all pretty, yeah,

16:18

well put. Very well put. Although

16:20

he initially didn't want to, he

16:22

resisted it, he brought enslaved people

16:24

to the White House, which makes

16:26

him the first president to do

16:28

that, although that, the only president

16:30

to live in the White House

16:32

before him was John Adams, and

16:34

John Adams didn't own slaves. He

16:36

didn't want to do it. I

16:38

mean, it didn't look great, but

16:40

also he didn't want them to

16:42

be exposed to new ideas about

16:44

freedom and in Washington DC. But

16:46

as president, he also banned the

16:48

international slave trade. So there was

16:50

that, I guess. He told Congress

16:52

the ban was needed to withdraw

16:54

the citizens of the United States

16:56

from all further participation in those

16:58

violations of human rights. Again, interesting

17:01

and forceful, but um... Right. It's

17:03

kind of hard to, it's hard

17:05

to like look at Thomas Jefferson

17:07

saying this in Congress and then

17:09

like, I'm imagining being like a

17:11

member of Congress as he saying

17:13

this and you like look over

17:15

his shoulder and there is like...

17:17

to enslave people standing behind him.

17:19

You're like, hmm. Yeah, most of

17:21

them had slaves. They're probably like,

17:23

angry he was even doing this.

17:25

I don't know. Yeah. But this

17:27

did ban the importation of slaves

17:29

from abroad. By this point, you

17:31

know, there were millions already in

17:33

the United States and this only

17:35

solved one part of the problem.

17:37

And the slave trade did continue

17:39

illegally after this. It wasn't totally

17:41

stopped. Plus, like, it doesn't do

17:43

that much when... slavery is already

17:45

falling out of fashion in other

17:47

parts of the Western world. Well,

17:49

I mean, but it was very

17:51

fashionable in the United States. Wow,

17:53

true. Yeah. In certain circles, like

17:55

it was still very important to

17:57

southern economy and everything. That's fair.

17:59

But yeah, Monticello, which is like

18:01

they run the website about his

18:03

history and everything, they say his

18:05

basic beliefs never really changed from

18:07

the 1770s until his death, he

18:09

advocated a plan of gradual emancipation.

18:11

So he said, first, abolish the

18:13

transatlantic slave trade as president check.

18:15

Second, improve the lives of enslaved

18:17

people by improving living conditions and

18:19

scale down physical punishment, unclear how

18:21

we did that. Third, all enslaved

18:23

people born after a certain date

18:25

would be freed, followed by total

18:27

abolition. But... He did not believe

18:29

that white and black Americans could

18:31

live together in the same nation.

18:33

He thought they needed to be

18:35

in two separate nations because he

18:37

believed enslaved people were limited and

18:39

likely to bear grudges against their

18:41

owners. Well, yeah. So he thought

18:43

the deportation to Africa or the

18:45

West Indies was the ideal solution

18:47

to this. Interesting. I think if

18:49

you really think about this, there

18:51

are like black Americans who have

18:53

been in the nation longer than

18:55

a lot of white Americans because

18:57

they were here from the very

18:59

very beginning. somewhere else just makes

19:01

like yeah yeah like we picked

19:03

you up in Africa keep you

19:05

here for like four generations then

19:07

send your kids back but it's

19:09

like well they don't they don't

19:11

know what Africa's like yeah there

19:13

are Americans I mean yeah so

19:15

anyway that was kind of his

19:17

how he thought this this could

19:20

be resolved yeah that is fascinating

19:22

it is yeah it's weird like

19:24

anyone who's not of British or

19:26

like African-American ancestry is like pretty

19:28

new to the country still like

19:30

Italian Americans aren't that far back

19:32

and there was a lot of

19:34

racist pushback against Italians when they

19:36

first started coming over the Irish.

19:38

Those are both probably in like

19:40

the 19th century Germans. Yeah. As

19:42

a long time foreign correspondent I've

19:44

worked in lots of places nowhere

19:46

as important to the world as

19:48

China. But these days, few journalists

19:50

are able to get the inside

19:52

story. That's because... has shut the

19:54

door to much of the media.

19:56

Authorities have far more efficient tools

19:58

to control the press and they're

20:00

far less reluctant to use them.

20:02

I'm Jane Perles, former Beijing Bureau

20:04

Chief for the New York Times.

20:06

On face-off, the US versus China,

20:08

we're trying to breakthrough. We'll talk

20:10

about Trump and Cijian Ping, AI,

20:12

Tik-Tok and even Hollywood. New episodes

20:14

of face-off are available now. wherever

20:16

you get your podcasts. As Jefferson,

20:18

even as he was dying, he

20:20

was thinking about slavery and his

20:22

legacy and everything. He dies in

20:24

the spring of 1826, or as

20:26

he lay dying in the spring

20:28

of 1826, of course he died

20:30

on the 4th of July. Oh,

20:32

did he? I didn't know that.

20:34

Oh, yeah, he and Thomas, or

20:36

he and John Adams both died

20:38

on the 4th of July, on

20:40

the 50th anniversary. of the Declaration

20:42

of Independence. Whoa! I had no

20:44

idea about that. That's crazy. John

20:46

Adams' last words were, Thomas Jefferson

20:48

lives, although Jefferson had died a

20:50

few hours earlier. Wow. I know.

20:52

Wow. Yeah, it's not wild. For

20:54

enemies, Jefferson and Adams, but it's

20:56

a different podcast. Yeah, he wrote

20:58

on slavery. Well, he was writing

21:00

a letter kind of defending his

21:02

inaction on slavery, and he said...

21:04

A good cause is often injured

21:06

more by ill-timed efforts of its

21:08

friends than by the arguments of

21:10

its enemies. My sentiments have been

21:12

40 years before the public. Had

21:14

I repeated them 40 times, they

21:16

would only become the more stale

21:18

and threadbare. I mean, it's like,

21:20

I don't know. I will say.

21:22

Maybe. I will say. He got

21:24

the number of years right. 1826,

21:26

he says this. I think so,

21:28

yeah. That his sentiments were 40

21:30

years ahead of the nations. And

21:32

then 40 years later. I think

21:34

he's he's meaning 40 years for

21:36

four years. Yeah. Yeah, damn. I

21:38

thought he was saying, like, my

21:41

ideas are so good on this.

21:43

They're 40 years ahead. And I

21:45

was like, that's kind of eerie,

21:47

because 40 years after that, we

21:49

were fighting a war about this.

21:51

So. Yeah, not quite, but I

21:53

mean, the Civil War is very,

21:55

like, soon after this, really, the

21:57

scope of things. His granddaughter also

21:59

writes him about slavery in the

22:01

South, she calls it, she calls

22:03

it, she calls it, she calls

22:05

it, she calls it, she calls

22:07

it, He responded, one fatal stain

22:09

to forms, but nature had bestowed

22:11

on us of her Paris gifts.

22:13

So in private, he was pretty

22:15

radical. He did keep this, really

22:17

throughout his life, he said radical

22:19

things about slavery for the time.

22:21

Yeah, for sure. But that's really

22:23

hard to like balance with what

22:25

he actually did about slavery, his

22:27

own slaves. Like he owned slaves.

22:29

He could have acted on this.

22:31

That's the part that's more of

22:33

a hicup, because it's like there's

22:35

only so much you can do

22:37

as the president. like take into

22:39

consideration the interests of like everybody.

22:41

Well and your your Congress is

22:43

you know a lot of the

22:45

Congress is the South right that's

22:47

a hard you're from the South

22:49

that's a hard thing to do.

22:51

But yeah it's his own personal

22:53

like the fact that he regularly

22:55

kept slaves like makes sense when

22:57

he was younger and his father

22:59

died and he inherited a bunch

23:01

of people was like well sure

23:03

but then you kept doing it

23:05

for years. you very much engage

23:07

with it, you acknowledge the profit

23:09

of it, how you were benefiting

23:11

personally from it, you had a

23:13

relationship with an enslaved woman for

23:15

like most of your life. Yeah,

23:17

which I know that wasn't bad.

23:19

Children with her and still, yeah,

23:21

it's really really hard to balance

23:23

those two things. Yeah, complicated is

23:25

definitely the word for it. Yes,

23:27

for sure. Do you think it

23:29

was exhausting to talk like that

23:31

all the time? Like, I don't

23:33

know. Like, it's kind of, it's

23:35

nice, it's elocated, but it's like,

23:37

whoa, putting a lot of thought

23:39

into it, huh? I think. Jefferson

23:41

was like, you know, especially like

23:43

educated and wealthy and of this

23:45

like plantation class. So he probably

23:47

spoke in a certain way that

23:49

wasn't like the way everyone spoke.

23:51

But now we're just firing off

23:53

text like L-O-L, look at this

23:55

sandwich I'm eating. In any case,

23:57

you know, Jefferson does die on

24:00

July 4th. He's widely mourned. He's

24:02

seen as an American hero, a

24:04

formative founding father, and his presidency

24:06

was seen as very, very, very

24:08

important as well. He became president

24:10

of President. And it was seen

24:12

as a revolution of kind of

24:14

like a new chapter, a new

24:16

better chapter of American history because

24:18

he was followed, you know, by

24:20

his friend Madison and so forth.

24:22

So that's kind of how he

24:24

was seen when he died and

24:26

how he was seen I would

24:28

say probably for the next 100

24:30

years, 150 years. And it's only

24:32

really recently that people have been

24:34

like... Let's reevaluate maybe a little

24:36

bit. Well, these rumors about Sally

24:38

Hemings existed in his lifetime, but

24:40

it wasn't confirmed through DNA until

24:42

I think in the 90s that...

24:44

the children were very very likely

24:46

Jeffersons. You know, the family, her

24:48

family lore all said they were

24:50

and they finally got this DNA

24:52

analysis. So that's like very very

24:54

recent. Yeah, that is very interesting.

24:56

Yeah. So now it's like, you

24:58

know, people are reconsidering him. I

25:00

think, you know, it's so easy

25:02

often in our current times and

25:04

in looking at history to be

25:06

like someone's bad or good or,

25:08

you know, black or white or

25:10

whatever. And it's just complicated, like

25:12

he did some really bad things.

25:14

He has some really interesting and

25:16

progressive and radical ideas, like those

25:18

two things exist, I guess, but

25:20

to kind of evaluate both of

25:22

them. Yeah, well, and I think

25:24

there's also been a significant change

25:26

in the way that Americans talk

25:28

about American politics. I feel like

25:30

there used to be a lot

25:32

more like reverence for the title

25:34

of president, and I think that

25:36

kind of started to fall apart

25:38

with Nixon, where it was like,

25:40

like the first kind of really

25:42

big rock the boat of the

25:44

boat of the institution scandal. with

25:46

Watergate where it was like, ooh,

25:48

hmm. Yeah, right, definitely lost trust

25:50

in the office after that. I

25:52

don't think they ever really, well,

25:54

and you know. I will say

25:56

too, that's around the same time,

25:58

S&L started premiering. And there was

26:00

a regular feature of them to

26:02

like poke fun at presidential candidates

26:04

and presidents and stuff. Yeah, yeah,

26:06

I mean, yeah, it's fascinating. Television,

26:08

I think, really changed the presidency

26:10

as well. I mean, I grew

26:12

up in like an age where

26:14

Will Farrell was playing George Bush

26:16

on TV. So I always was

26:18

just like, George Bush as an

26:21

idiot, because that's how I, as

26:23

a kid, saw him portrayed, saw

26:25

him portrayed. And it sort of

26:27

made me be like, why should

26:29

I give a shit what the

26:31

president thinks ever? Yeah, because it

26:33

mocked so much. Right. From personal

26:35

standpoint, but I'm sure like, in

26:37

1850, people were talking about Thomas

26:39

Jefferson. They were, you know, he

26:41

was a great man. You watch

26:43

your mouth. Oh, for sure. Yeah,

26:45

I mean, unless they were, you

26:47

know, of the other party, maybe,

26:49

but not really, because he was

26:51

the sounding father or everything. and

26:53

then it was the federalist being

26:55

on the opposition party at that

26:57

point. Right, yeah the parties have

26:59

really changed. Yeah, it's almost like

27:01

it doesn't even really matter what

27:03

you call it anymore. Like we

27:05

just kind of landed on Democrats

27:07

and Republicans, but it's like it

27:09

doesn't, it's not like Democrats are

27:11

out here saying we should vote

27:13

like a real democracy, like every

27:15

person votes, every citizen votes on

27:17

something. Like we're still a republic

27:19

at the end of the day.

27:21

So it's... Just funny how much

27:23

language can change, but like not

27:25

even matter at all that it

27:27

changed Yeah, yeah, and it'll be

27:29

interesting to see like I mean

27:31

our parties haven't really changed In

27:33

terms of like the two-party system

27:35

and you know in the 19th

27:37

century there were so many Or

27:39

there were lots of different parties

27:41

like the Republican parties only born

27:43

in the 1850s or the maybe

27:45

not even 1860. I guess 1850s

27:47

late 1850s late 1850s, but um

27:49

You know, just like stuff changed

27:51

a lot back then who've been

27:53

on kind of the same course

27:55

ever since. That's how it is

27:57

in England today is they just

27:59

they have like 30 parties that

28:01

all actually have a decent shot

28:03

at winning elections. I think the

28:05

binary option has really felt limiting

28:07

for a lot of people. They're

28:09

really split into different factions, but

28:11

they're not called that faction. They're

28:13

not their own party or anything.

28:15

But they could be. I mean,

28:17

that could be an interesting experiment.

28:19

I think that's a change a

28:21

lot of people would like to

28:23

see. Yeah, I do too. I

28:25

think the binary option has really

28:27

felt limiting for a lot of

28:29

people. I think you see that

28:31

in voter turnout numbers. Yeah, I

28:33

think that's true. I mean in

28:35

Europe as well that you see

28:37

a lot of like stalemate and

28:40

you know coalitions that don't work

28:42

and I don't know. I can't

28:44

remember who said it. Someone said

28:46

this and I can't remember who

28:48

it was. Maybe it was Benjamin

28:50

Franklin. But he said democracy is

28:52

the worst form of government except

28:54

for all the others. Yeah. But

28:56

yeah, Jefferson, interesting. Interesting, interesting guy.

28:58

The one person I would love

29:00

to talk about in the podcast,

29:02

but I think it's Tunisian, John

29:04

Adams' son, because he was like

29:06

a flamethrower. He did all sorts,

29:08

he was president, but he also

29:10

did all sorts of other things

29:12

in his life. And I think

29:14

after he was president, he went

29:16

back and served in the house,

29:18

and he was against slavery, like

29:20

just against it at a time

29:22

so unpopular so unpopular to do

29:24

that. But yeah, really interesting. Yeah,

29:26

and John Adams didn't have any

29:28

slaves either, right? You said, so.

29:30

No, no. I mean, they were

29:32

both from, you know, Boston and

29:34

Plantations up there. Yeah, that is

29:36

really interesting. Yeah, I find this

29:38

stuff fascinating. It's always, it's always

29:40

fun to look back and see

29:42

what was considered radical at a

29:44

certain point in time. Yeah. How

29:46

like, like, now, if you were

29:48

like, if someone today was like,

29:50

we should bring back slavery, we'd

29:52

be like, like, what? But yeah,

29:54

it's fascinating that there was at

29:56

one point in time like this,

29:58

like, if you said that, that

30:00

was like a radical thing to

30:02

say. It's interesting because... like the

30:04

institution of slavery as an institution

30:06

maybe is gone, but there is

30:08

like slavery like around the world,

30:10

people who are maybe like tricked

30:12

into slavery, tricked into like taking

30:14

a job that's actually like working,

30:16

you know, 20-hour days and things

30:18

like that, but the way it

30:20

was back then, yeah, very different.

30:22

Yeah, and because I've been doing

30:24

a lot of stuff this week

30:26

about the Gilded Age. Yeah, that's

30:28

1870. It's interesting to me that

30:30

right after the abolition of slavery,

30:32

we entered a period of like

30:34

disastrous overwork, terrible working conditions like

30:36

people be like not officially slavery

30:38

but subjugation that's not far off.

30:40

Very close. Yeah, right. Working six

30:42

days a week and can't take

30:44

time off and just disease spreading

30:46

and No one cares because social

30:48

Darwinism was like a thing. Yeah,

30:50

it's interesting. I think the post-civil

30:52

war years are often so overlooked.

30:54

We discussed this before because it

30:56

goes civil war, lots of stuff,

30:58

World War One, but like that

31:01

period is sort of like lost

31:03

in the mix a bit. Yeah,

31:05

I think it kind of just

31:07

gets boiled down to like life

31:09

sucked. for the average person. Yeah,

31:11

it yeah, but it's also like

31:13

so interesting because like after the

31:15

Civil War, like reconstruction had all

31:17

these like grand ideas and promises

31:19

and like and then it all

31:21

just like collapsed. And yeah, those

31:23

Rutherford, Rutherford B. Hayes was the

31:25

one who like really put an

31:27

end to that. That's right. Yeah,

31:29

Rutherford B. Hayes. We don't have

31:31

names like that anymore, Rutherford. No,

31:33

some old names are coming back.

31:35

Bring it back. I like old

31:37

names. I like old names. I

31:39

do too. I

31:45

guess the next one then is mine

31:48

again, which is going to be on

31:50

this is actually this idea came from

31:52

someone who wrote in about wanting to

31:54

hear something about tsunamis. So we're doing

31:56

an episode on the 2004 tsunami. The

31:59

boxing day tsunami, Indian Ocean tsunami, it's

32:01

called really devastating, one of the worst

32:03

natural disasters of all time, that's our

32:05

next one coming out. Yeah, fun. Yeah,

32:07

I know. I know. My parents, they

32:10

do live on an island and, you

32:12

know, we're in an earthquake prone region

32:14

and sometimes it's like, hmm, I wonder

32:16

what would happen. Yeah, really. I wonder

32:18

what would happen. But anyway, that's the

32:21

next one coming out. That's true, but

32:23

very dramatic. It's important most of the

32:25

time. Yeah, that'll be interesting. So stay

32:27

tuned for that. There's another one that

32:29

I don't really know too much about

32:32

it despite having been alive when it

32:34

happened. Because I was eight. I remember

32:36

I was like in the airport. I

32:38

think my parents, we were all somewhere

32:40

for Christmas and we were flying home

32:43

because this happened on December 26. and

32:45

all the newspapers, like all the kiosks

32:47

were about it. And it was really

32:49

left like an impression on me, because

32:51

it was so many people and all

32:54

the stories. And I was old enough,

32:56

I guess I was 14, I was

32:58

old enough to like, kind of absorb

33:00

what the tragedy was, and it really,

33:03

really stuck with me. So I'm interested

33:05

to talk about this more. Yeah, that'll

33:07

be interesting. Yeah, I was eight years

33:09

old, so I was not paying much

33:11

attention. Not quite absorbing the tragedy. Yeah,

33:20

if you want to read more

33:22

about our stories about history, Jefferson,

33:24

Civil War, basically anything. Anything else

33:26

interesting. You can do that at

33:28

all the interesting.com. You can also

33:31

join our newsletter by going to

33:33

all the interesting.com/sign-up, or you can

33:35

even become a member at all

33:37

the interesting.com/membership. And if you do

33:39

that, you'll get access to this

33:42

next part of this episode, which

33:44

will be History Happy Hour. for

33:46

February. Yeah, right. Over a little

33:48

behind this time, but a little

33:51

behind. Yeah, history app hour is

33:53

fun though. We go over like

33:55

our top news stories from the

33:57

month and some historical anniversaries that

33:59

passed and you know, it's a

34:02

cool way. of diving into the

34:04

history that is still happening. Yeah,

34:06

absolutely. You can also find us

34:08

on social media platforms, on YouTube,

34:10

the full episode. The shorts are

34:13

posted there on Instagram History and

34:15

Govern podcast on Tik Talk at

34:17

Real History Uncovered. For as long

34:19

as that last, thought we were

34:21

gonna be over the Tik Talk

34:24

thing by now, but I guess

34:26

not. Oh, that's right. Yeah. Yeah.

34:28

Yeah. Still kicking. Still kicking. We're

34:30

still posting there. Yeah, and if

34:32

you do have a question about

34:35

the show, a story idea, like

34:37

the tsunami idea, want to say

34:39

hi, have a comment, whatever, you

34:41

can either call us and leave

34:44

a voicemail at 929-526-3029, or you

34:46

can email us at podcast at

34:48

all the interesting.com. Yeah, we've done

34:50

a couple episodes now that we're

34:52

right in. Yes, we did the

34:55

Soviet One. I feel like there

34:57

was one more that I'm forgetting,

34:59

but yeah, we love getting those.

35:01

It's really interesting. Yeah, it is.

35:03

It's very fun to hear what

35:06

people have to say about different

35:08

topics that we cover or like

35:10

ideas that they have for things

35:12

they want to hear about because,

35:14

I don't know, there's so much

35:17

history to go over. Yeah. And

35:19

we talk about a lot of

35:21

it, but it's not always easy

35:23

to be like, hmm, what should

35:25

we talk about this month? What

35:28

do people want to hear about?

35:30

What do you guys think? It's

35:32

like, it's like, it's like, it's

35:34

like, we write about it every

35:36

day and then when we're asked

35:39

to choose a story, it's like,

35:41

it's so overwhelming. There's so much

35:43

to choose from. Yeah, because my

35:45

thing is always like, I don't

35:48

know, is there a new alien

35:50

abduction we haven't talked about? Right,

35:52

yeah. Let's talking about this. What

35:54

are their names? Oh, Betty Barney

35:56

Hill. Yeah, Betty and then I

35:59

edited it. Okay, yeah. That'd be

36:01

a good podcast. I think that

36:03

one would be the one. I'm

36:05

surprised we didn't talk about that

36:07

during our UFO series. Me too.

36:10

Me too. Me too. It was

36:12

an oversight on our part, but

36:14

maybe we had that into the

36:16

running. That'd be a cool one,

36:18

but. Anyway, we're going to switch

36:21

over to History Happy Hour now.

36:23

If you remember, you'll hear it.

36:25

If you're not, you should become

36:27

a member. Yeah. Yeah. And we'll

36:29

be back soon with that tsunami

36:32

episode. Yeah. See you for now.

36:34

Bye. Then the Sleep Cove podcast

36:36

can help you. Hi, I'm Christopher

36:38

Fitton, the voice and clinical hypotherapist

36:40

behind Sleep Cove. Sleep Cove features

36:43

sleep hypnosis, meditations and bedtime stories,

36:45

all designed to help those of

36:47

you who struggle at night to

36:49

achieve a restful and peaceful night

36:52

sleep. Search for Sleep Cove. on

36:54

Apple podcasts or Spotify and see

36:56

why Sleep Cove helps millions of

36:58

people sleep deeply all night.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features