Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
A reason for the cold today . John is Welcome
0:02
to Internal Use Only . Something
0:06
just came across my desk , john . It
0:09
is perhaps the best thing I've seen in the
0:11
last six months . If you have 60 seconds , I'd
0:13
like to share the idea with you .
0:14
Got a minute A podcast for Wholesalers
0:16
.
0:17
Always be closing , always
0:20
be closing . Buy
0:22
Wholesalers . Blue horseshoe loves
0:24
anacostia . Okay , before we get
0:26
started , I have one question . Anyone here passed a Series
0:28
7 exam ? I have a Series 7 license
0:31
. Good for you , you can get up to it . Let's
0:33
cut to the chase .
0:34
Here's your host , dan Sullivan
0:36
. We've
0:51
got a very special episode on tap today with
0:53
an advisor affiliated with Raymond James
0:55
. When I did the 2023 survey
0:57
, the audience shared that you'd like to hear more
0:59
conversations with advisors , so this one
1:01
is a little bit different than most interviews
1:04
, I would say . When I recorded and edited
1:06
this , it really felt like it was just a conversation
1:09
, as if I was a wholesaler in the field , trying
1:11
to get to know this advisor , as if he was one of my prospects
1:13
. You'll hear this particular
1:15
advisor lay out his entire story about
1:18
how he got into the industry , how he
1:20
manages clients' money and , finally
1:22
, how he interacts with wholesalers . And
1:24
in this case , he has a different background on
1:26
actually how he is using wholesalers , how
1:29
he isn't using wholesalers and what that
1:31
does or what that means for his practice . So I
1:33
hope that you enjoy this conversation . Like I said , it's
1:35
a little bit different . Feel free to give me
1:37
feedback , either on the podcast Instagram
1:39
at internal use only podcast , or
1:42
through email at internal
1:44
use only podcast at gmailcom . Without
1:46
further ado , let's get to today's interview . Welcome
1:57
back , everyone , to another episode of the internal
1:59
use only podcast . My name is Dan
2:01
Sullivan . I am joined today by Tyson
2:03
Ray , cfp certified
2:05
exit planner SEMA . He is the
2:08
form wealth advisors CEO
2:10
, founding partner and senior
2:12
wealth advisor . Tyson , thank you so much for
2:14
being here with us today . It's a Friday afternoon . How's your
2:16
weekend ?
2:18
Dan , it has been great . Thank you
2:20
for having me on . I love you've
2:22
like , took something that was negative the internal
2:25
use only and have turned it into a positive . So
2:27
I'm just excited to be on the podcast
2:30
today and looking forward to sharing .
2:32
So I was very fortunate to get a copy of
2:34
your book , the Total Relationship , which
2:36
we'll talk about the tenants and the core philosophies within
2:38
it . But from the first chapter
2:41
it's very evident that you came up in
2:43
the industry at a time where stock brokers were really
2:45
driving the ship and
2:47
that was commission based sales , and that
2:49
seems like it really fueled the direction of your career
2:52
. So why don't you just tell us a little bit
2:54
about that , how you started in the industry and
2:56
really how that led to where
2:58
you are today at form wealth ?
3:00
I kind of had the upbringing of you know
3:02
, the ad left mom with the four kids and an eviction notice in the refrigerator
3:05
. And when I was like
3:07
12 or 13 , I lied on the work application
3:09
and said I was old enough to basically go work and
3:12
that was to go ride
3:14
my bike about a mile or two to
3:16
a restaurant where
3:18
on Friday night and Saturday night I could work
3:20
my tail off . But it was all
3:22
you . It was a fish fry on Friday night , all you could
3:24
eat . Fish is very popular in the Wisconsin
3:26
area and that means
3:28
I got to eat all I wanted as part
3:31
of like like , fed you like . I even got paid
3:33
to be fed like that . I was like blew my mind . And
3:35
then Saturday was all you could eat peel
3:37
trim , I mean King , right . I
3:40
mean I had to go to the bank and I had to go to the bank
3:42
to eat fish and shrimp Friday and Saturday night . But I started saving
3:44
the hundred bucks I can make on a Friday and Saturday night into
3:47
my chubby , chubby chicken bank account . And
3:49
this is back in the 80s when interest rates are like through the roof , right
3:52
. So also I'm watching the
3:54
bank put money on top of my money . Now
3:56
it was only , you know , dimes and nickels and
3:58
quarters , but every month it was adding
4:00
up as , like , wait a second , this is fantastic , fantastic . And when
4:04
I was 16 , or a
4:07
little bit before I turned 16 , I had been asked
4:09
I had gotten a separate job
4:11
of filling up the gas pump
4:13
at the end of the pier broke , and so basically
4:16
I got hired to carry five gallon gas
4:18
cans in each hand , barefoot , down the
4:20
drive down to basically gas
4:22
up these boats . And at the end of one weekend
4:25
a mastercraft
4:27
pulls up which is a really high end professional
4:29
ski boat and they
4:32
like , hey , kid , can
4:34
you spot for us ? Because you had to have a third
4:36
person right , one in the boat driving , one
4:38
skiing and then one one watching to see if the
4:40
guy fell or gal . So
4:43
I said Sure , so I jumped in . They
4:45
thought it was fun to teach me a little bit about skiing and
4:47
barefooting , which we did . Anyway , it was
4:49
getting dark and I was about to walk
4:51
back to my house and the guy says
4:53
, hey , can I drop you off ? And I'm
4:55
like , yeah , sure , it was
4:57
. In a Ferrari I was . I was like afraid
4:59
to get into it . Right , like my suit
5:01
, my seat . My my swimwear suit was still a little
5:04
damp , but he put a towel down like it was all in care
5:06
, chill . And I lied
5:08
at what house I lived in because I was too embarrassed
5:10
as he pulled into the
5:12
neighbors a couple of doors down nicer house
5:14
. I said you know
5:17
how'd you do it ? Like mastercraft , ferrari
5:19
, like what was it . And he
5:21
talked about you know , I had this business I owned , but I
5:23
really did really well in the stock market . That's
5:25
all I said . And I got out and
5:27
was just like Okay , like check the
5:29
box , right , stock market . Not
5:31
sure what exactly that means , but
5:33
you know , okay , about
5:36
a year or so later in high school they played the stock
5:38
market game where the
5:40
kids in school get phony money to go
5:43
into the , go make stock selections
5:45
and you have like a two month window in the economics class
5:47
where a stock broker came in to talk to
5:49
us about how it worked and you got to kind of pick your investments
5:51
and you got to trade and actually teaches all
5:53
the worst fundamentals of investing , because the whole game is
5:55
trying to make as much money as you can In a two month
5:58
window of time yeah
6:00
, leverage , leverage , right , all the
6:02
margin . Anyway , I
6:06
wanted to buy a stock now also
6:08
, by the way , this is just to date myself , and I don't
6:10
feel I'm that old . This
6:13
was like all done in the newspaper
6:15
, right ? This was not typing into a computer
6:17
with the stock quote was like you're pulling
6:19
it off the Wall Street Journal and you're looking
6:21
for the ups and the downs and the biggest
6:23
movers and little sections , and it was all the symbols
6:26
and the data printed out on these pieces of paper
6:28
from the close the day before . But
6:30
I had signed , I had picked out a stock
6:32
. I didn't know anything about it . I knew the symbol
6:35
was INTC , which was Intel at the time
6:37
. Back then it was before it was inside anything . They were
6:39
just the little startups that
6:41
they were and it had gone from 12 to
6:43
seven for whatever reason I didn't know . I knew it was at
6:45
seven bucks and I'm like , hey , I could buy 100
6:47
shares of that and I
6:50
probably wouldn't be doing what I was , what I'm doing
6:52
now . Had my mom said , yes , son , that's
6:54
a great idea , because then I would have got
6:56
it and you don't have to go after
6:58
what you often get . She said , no , well
7:00
, it's like what ? Like it's
7:02
my money , like wait a minute , I'm busting tables
7:05
, it's my no . And then I was mad . I
7:07
even had to have her permission Because it's
7:09
like , wait , it's mine . So
7:12
I dragged her into the broker's office and
7:14
thank God that broker's a saint , because
7:17
she actually tolerated me coming in with my 700
7:19
bucks that I wanted to invest in my mom who was saying no
7:21
, and we had to wait to do it in the evening
7:23
because my mom couldn't come otherwise . Well , this lady
7:25
took the time Karen
7:27
took the time to talk
7:30
to my mom and convince her . You know what ? All
7:32
right , no individual stocks , but we'll let him put $100
7:35
a month into two different mutual funds . And that's how I got started
7:37
at 16 . When I was 18 , and I didn't need my mom's
7:39
approval anymore , I went off and bought a few individual stocks
7:41
and rode the tech bubble and then blew myself up like everybody
7:43
else did , but in the process
7:46
, came out of college and I
7:48
had spent so much time trying to convince my mom why
7:50
this was working and a good idea that
7:52
I decided this was just kind of a natural fit and by divine
7:55
intervention I got introduced . A couple things came
7:57
into a
7:59
broker dealer office
8:01
and right out of college was pretty rare
8:03
, but same thing . It was
8:06
okay . Here's your 3000 people
8:08
you got to call every day , or
8:10
every month , I should say and it
8:12
was about peddling product and it was about trying
8:14
to make a commission and making a living and trying to figure
8:16
out how you're going to pay your rent but still do what's right
8:18
for the client . That
8:24
I didn't like so
8:26
much , so that when the first email came out and this
8:28
was like the dial up like it
8:30
sounded like a fax machine while your computer was getting
8:32
the email up and going right , and then out
8:35
it comes . The email message was
8:37
like the first email message my family put out
8:39
on AOL that
8:41
grandma was sick and basically
8:43
someone needed to opt to move home and be at
8:45
grandma's farm with her or she's , not
8:47
to go to a care facility . Now , this
8:50
is the woman that basically helped
8:52
me learn how to read . You know , when
8:54
my mom couldn't stand me anymore , I got to go to the farm
8:56
and then I got to go crazy and food and
8:58
running around and playing with it , whatever
9:01
, and there was a tug on my heart
9:03
of wait a minute , you get
9:05
one honorable , go back and honor
9:07
your grandmother and I had
9:10
been away from years , from everything
9:12
family and two , if
9:16
you don't have to have rent and the
9:18
farm always has food , so you can basically
9:20
have the rent and
9:23
lip and food expenses , some major hits
9:25
to living expenses , like all of a sudden I don't have to have this burden
9:27
about how to make enough money to do the right
9:29
thing . So move home , start
9:32
over basically my career
9:34
. I walk into an office
9:36
of this same broker dealer
9:38
. That is an office down the road . In
9:40
that office is a
9:43
senior advisor . I think he was 68
9:45
at the time . I walked into
9:48
the office , kind
9:50
of got started after a month or two , just getting
9:52
started slowly . I went into his
9:54
office one day and basically said hey , dan , like I was
9:56
talking to you , you know , let me see your portfolio
9:58
after 40 years of being a stockbroker , like
10:01
, is this really what I want to do for my career ? I don't know anything
10:03
. I just moved home , I'm living at the farm . I feel like a loser
10:05
, but I'm not having to screw people
10:07
out of trying to figure out this conflict of what's
10:09
best for them and what do I need to do to feed
10:11
myself . And
10:14
he hymned and hawed and basically printed me this statement
10:16
. And here he prints this statement , that seven
10:18
figures . And he had picked some wonderful
10:21
stocks for the whole run of the 80s and 90s
10:23
market and
10:25
he was looking for me to give him information . It's like , wow
10:27
, right , and
10:30
what I said was wait
10:32
a minute , why isn't this in the trust
10:34
? Why do you know what you'd
10:36
pay in estate taxes if you and your wife died ? It'd
10:40
be millions . And he's just like I
10:42
didn't know . Two months before I showed up in that office
10:44
, which they had an empty desk for me to work at
10:46
this is how I started there they
10:48
had sent a million . It was almost exactly
10:50
a million . It's like a million dollars in the dollar . I
10:53
still have a copy of that check to
10:55
the IRS as an estate tax . And
10:58
so he watched the family have to liquidate a significant
11:01
amount of money that they weren't planning on to
11:03
basically go satisfy this bill . So also , when I'm
11:05
saying , hey , you know you don't
11:07
even have this problem , he didn't know how to fix
11:09
it . And I said , well , if you give me access to your account , because
11:11
I'm new and been trained and I know how to do all this
11:13
stuff , but I don't have any clients to do it for , I'll
11:15
help and we put together
11:18
an elaborate estate plan and he
11:20
came back in the end and basically said I'm never
11:22
going to be able to get this done
11:24
. I'm like why he's like I'm never going to get my wife to
11:27
agree to it . Okay
11:29
, well , why don't you let me tell her ? Well
11:31
, I don't think . He's like , I don't think that's a
11:33
good idea . I'm like , well , you've been , you've been married
11:36
for 50 or 60 years to this point she
11:38
doesn't want to listen to you . I said she has no me
11:40
from Adam . So why don't you let her come in and
11:42
I'll try and explain to her . I said , with one rule
11:44
. He's like what's the rule ? I said you can't talk , right
11:47
, if you've been married this long , she's not gonna listen to you . She doesn't want to
11:49
hear your two cents . And really what it was
11:51
is she wanted him to be done and retired and the business
11:53
had kind of come first and it was his career and his success
11:55
and it was just this conflict in their relationship
11:58
and the business was what made the money
12:00
. That made the problem . Anyway
12:02
, she comes in and sits
12:04
down with him and I
12:06
asked I explained
12:09
hey , we have this problem that everything half
12:11
, you're gonna lose half everything you guys have , and I don't
12:13
think you understand that . She said I really not worried
12:15
about it . I said okay . I said I asked
12:17
you a different question . She said sure . I said you
12:19
do you have family China that
12:22
you plan to pass on to your daughter ? She's like , yeah . I
12:24
said how many place settings do you got ? You got eight or
12:26
12 . She said 12 . I said well , you're gonna have six
12:28
because the government's gonna take half . And
12:30
I said let's talk shoes for a second
12:33
. All your left foot shoes are gonna go to
12:35
the IRS and you have two Toyotas
12:37
, so let's just assume one of the Toyotas is going to the IRS . When
12:40
I'm saying you're gonna lose half of the value
12:42
of everything you have , it's gonna be half of the value
12:44
of everything you have financially and
12:47
that's an example . That's how I want you to think about
12:49
it . She looked at the senior advisor
12:52
and said you better fix this
12:54
and got up and walked out and the rest
12:56
was history , because we went , put the whole plan together
12:58
and irrevocable trust and Cheryl Mainer , trust
13:00
to avoid taxes is fantastic
13:03
and that then led to do you
13:05
have other clients we should be doing
13:07
this for , and
13:09
that experience took me on the path that
13:11
I've never gone off of and what the total relationship
13:13
the book we wrote talks about is the difference
13:16
between the conflict of the
13:18
sale or self versus
13:21
the opportunity to speak into someone's situation
13:24
, build a relationship and provide a solution that
13:26
they didn't see and add value
13:28
and may or may
13:30
not even be paid for that . But
13:33
just it's amazing how one
13:36
energizes me to
13:39
write a book , to be excited , to go make a difference , and
13:41
one sucked the life out of me of
13:43
just the struggle , the negativity of just the conflict
13:46
. And the reason we wrote
13:48
the book is I just think there's a lot of advisors or
13:51
a lot of people in the financial services industry that
13:54
just feel like there's gotta be a better way
13:56
to do this , and
13:59
a lot of people say they do some of these things
14:01
that are in this book but in the end they're still talking
14:03
about a portfolio or thinking their value
14:06
add is beating some performance of
14:08
some picket index and
14:11
the industry is the constant here
14:15
we've done better than , or here you gotta have something else
14:17
. You can never be content with what you have and
14:20
I think we've created
14:22
kind of the antithesis of this . That I
14:25
think the last thing about the book
14:27
, maybe before we dive into it , is the other
14:29
, and I didn't write it for this purpose , but it's
14:31
what it became . This industry is regulating
14:34
the whole best interest , what's
14:36
best for the client . They're trying to create checklists
14:38
and FINRA and SEC
14:40
are trying to create these regulations and
14:43
effectively I feel like the book is a how
14:45
to guide to
14:47
do what's best for a client . So
14:51
anyway , that's a long story to the story , but
14:53
there's that , if
14:56
I played that out just a little longer , four
14:59
years or so after that event of
15:02
helping him with his estate plan she
15:04
had passed , he decided to retire
15:07
and I took over a 40 year established
15:09
financial practice and
15:11
the beautiful thing about that was is from when I
15:13
helped him and then we helped do the estate
15:15
planning for all of his clients and in
15:17
what Pandora's box that opened up for opportunities
15:20
to have relationships and learn a ton of things
15:22
, especially
15:24
when he retired and I took that practice over . I
15:26
never and to this day I've never had
15:29
to have another client or had
15:31
to feel like I needed a sale or
15:33
I had to try and cover how I was
15:35
going to pay my team or pay myself . It's
15:38
like we could just do what was good and
15:40
what was right . And a lot of times we do what's
15:42
in conflict . Us Like
15:45
we spend a lot of time in
15:47
our careers convincing clients to
15:49
make , pay off debt or
15:52
go enjoy some of the money that they have . And
15:59
I actually told a CFO of a company
16:01
this morning cause he's frustrated with a defined benefit
16:03
plan that's just a mess and the 5,500s
16:06
all screwed up . And I just looked at him
16:08
. I'm like if this is such a headache and you guys
16:10
don't like it , why don't we just close it ? Or
16:14
if you don't like it cause it's in this brokerage account
16:16
, which is how you had it and how I ended up with it roll it back
16:18
into the TPA so they can consolidate and simplify
16:20
it . And they kind of thought about it . I was like that'd be
16:22
great and I said
16:24
but I said I want you to realize where
16:26
I'm coming from . I said I'm paid to
16:28
manage that account here and if you roll it back into the TPM
16:31
and lose being paid , but if that's what's better for you
16:33
guys , cause this is driving nuts I'm not
16:35
in the business of driving nuts and
16:38
that's the fun part , cause you do that when enough people
16:40
, they refer people . Right
16:43
, you do that , you do . Do it put out enough good
16:45
in the world , it comes back .
16:47
There is an inherent I would say you've mentioned
16:49
the word conflict before like it's
16:52
hard to change overnight
16:54
, and I'm a little bit far from removed exactly
16:56
with how , like , younger advisors
16:58
are transitioning into their , like , the peak of their careers
17:01
. But at the end of the day , even if you're
17:03
a fee based manager , you're still getting paid
17:05
on assets under management , and so there
17:07
is a correlation between how much success that
17:09
you can have and the
17:11
AUM that you've got , regardless of the problems
17:13
you're solving and fees sorry , problems
17:15
that you're solving and the services
17:18
you can offer . From a pure like holistic
17:20
planning standpoint , I know that the industry is definitely
17:22
evolving and changing , but you're correct
17:24
that there's , like there's always going to be a wear and
17:27
tear , unless you're in a position where one you
17:29
are able to join a team that's already
17:31
so established that you kind of have that leeway or
17:33
you've just maybe you've started with you
17:36
know whoever very wealthy individuals that kind of get you
17:38
off your feet quicker , but we don't need to dive into that
17:40
fully . But I think I would agree with
17:42
anybody probably in a sales role , like in
17:45
anywhere like you want to hit a point where
17:47
you're successful enough where you can really take
17:49
a step back and say I'm not here trying
17:51
to hustle and bustle , to like pay my rent or to
17:53
get my basics taken care of . I can
17:55
now think further about what's
17:58
going to be more meaningful . How am I going to be able to
18:00
help clients ? And once you start doing
18:02
that , then you can really put
18:04
out there what will help attract the right people towards
18:06
your practice . And that's obviously what you've done here with
18:09
the total relationship framework . So I
18:11
wanted to carve out some time to just go through a little
18:13
bit more of like the specifics in that , because you did
18:15
mention it's almost like a how-to guide , especially
18:18
in a regulatory era that
18:20
has things like best practice and , you know
18:22
, avoiding those conflicts of interest . So if
18:25
I'm understanding correctly , there's essentially three
18:28
parts of this , like a life plan , a wealth plan
18:30
and a care plan . Can you just dive into that a
18:32
little bit and how that fits to the total relationship
18:34
framework ?
18:36
Yeah , I mean the would
18:38
love to . So the
18:41
yeah , it is three pieces that make up
18:43
the puzzle , and it's if the piece
18:45
starts with the life plan , if
18:47
you're coming to us and you're new , so okay
18:49
, first of all , everyone's got the word process
18:51
right . So everyone's got their steps . They're going to take
18:53
someone through If
18:56
they have their you know , certified
18:58
financial planning practitioners . They're going to do
19:00
the financial plan on the front end , because that gives you
19:02
the roadmap . Or , if you're a Nick Murray fan , you do
19:04
the fan , you do the plan first , and that predicts
19:07
the portfolio . Totally
19:09
agree with all that . What
19:11
we've found , though , is it's
19:15
one thing to basically find out okay , dan
19:18
, you buy a car every five
19:20
years . By the way , people buy automobiles
19:22
in by the time
19:24
they're 30 , they have fallen into a rhythm of
19:26
automobile purchasing Most
19:28
people and it's
19:30
either a number of years , it's a number of miles
19:32
, or you're driving it till it's dead . And
19:36
one of the things in the life plan
19:38
is an example where , early
19:41
in my career , individual
19:44
came to me . They were like ecstatic
19:46
, it might have been an inheritance thing , anyway , they got
19:48
this $100,000 . And I remember
19:50
that because it was a break point on A-share's back
19:52
in the day , right . So I was being paid a little
19:55
bit less , but it was like a bigger ticket and
19:57
this is a great day and it was a
19:59
co-call or whatever it was . Anyway
20:01
, they came in long-term investment
20:03
, setting it aside . They feel like they're adulting
20:05
their money , right that they've
20:07
moved on and made this investment in the stock
20:10
market Anyhow
20:12
. Two years later , they call
20:14
me the tech bubbles , burst the
20:17
hundred grand's , maybe worth 80 , and they bought
20:19
a $60,000 car the day before and
20:22
called me for the money . And
20:24
I'm like , wait a minute . We talked
20:26
that like this was like forever , and
20:29
it's two years since forever and
20:31
now you want $60,000
20:33
of an $80,000 portfolio . That's underwater
20:35
because we started with 100 and the market went down and
20:39
thankfully there was no cost to get them out of it . But I felt like
20:41
crap . It's like okay , so I got paid to
20:43
lose you money that you didn't tell me you needed and
20:46
I didn't know to ask . You needed it . And
20:49
what the life plan is designed to do , it
20:51
is to try and bring
20:54
a lot of clarity to every
20:56
client's relationship , whether
20:58
they're new to us or their existing client
21:00
is to what do you need in the next 12
21:03
to 24 months and
21:05
where's it coming from ? Are you saving
21:07
it ? Is it coming from the portfolio ? What is it ? And
21:10
we go through a process of asking
21:12
questions about things
21:15
that we've found that the answers
21:17
for every client are different . But the questions
21:19
are similar because we found these
21:21
are categories that people just
21:23
surprised us with what
21:25
they needed money for , and I also think , from a litigious
21:28
standpoint or a compliance standpoint . It's
21:30
like these are where the complaints come from . Right , I
21:32
needed money . The market's down , it was my long-term
21:34
portfolio . Now I'm upset because no one knew I needed
21:36
the money , but then wait a minute .
21:39
And so we just want to . That's like the position for
21:42
any fun sales people or wholesalers
21:44
tuning in that are either new or haven't
21:46
really been involved in this industry for longer
21:48
. That's the worst case scenario is when there's either
21:50
a complaint filed with the advisor particularly
21:52
if there was maybe
21:55
out of the blue or just a situation like this
21:58
where it was like caught everybody by surprise and is completely
22:00
the opposite of what was intended when that
22:02
investment was made at the time .
22:04
Yeah , and
22:07
or if you know those dollar amounts and
22:09
you've worked this plan out and you've done this
22:11
process that we're talking about here , the building out
22:13
this life plan , and what we're about to go through , the
22:16
piece of the piece that the clients have
22:18
, because they know the things that they need are set aside in
22:20
cash that's not invested . They
22:23
tolerate volatility that I think a lot of other people
22:25
would call and panic out , and then you're dealing
22:27
with repercussions , that . But so what are
22:29
those things we talk about ? So go back to the highest
22:31
, most important . We ask about family and we
22:33
ask about their parents specifically , because all
22:35
of a sudden , just like grandma got sick and
22:37
I moved home , like there are people out there
22:40
that are going to need to help with the transition of
22:42
mom or dad , or I'm calling to talk
22:44
to them about their investment , but mom just got diagnosed with
22:46
stage four cancer . It's like this is not the time to
22:48
be talking about the long-term investment , because your heart's
22:50
all tied up , the fact that you're finding out your mom's got
22:52
a health issue and you can't fix it . So
22:56
, and that's we
22:58
, the , the . The firm's name is foreign wealth
23:00
, because we start everything in the F as family , we
23:02
, every meeting we have a client and he changes the mom and
23:05
dad , everybody , okay , yeah , great . How
23:07
about your health ? Because
23:09
, again , if your health is bad now , you can't help other people and you can't do anything you want
23:11
to do . How are your kids , the
23:13
people that you love ? That's the F in family . Any
23:17
changes there ? Updates there we
23:19
then transitioned into because I found people
23:21
will actually . So people are going to sacrifice
23:24
for family first or surprise us with needs
23:26
for family first marriage , weddings
23:28
, babies , care facilities
23:31
, vacation excuse me , not vacations well , that's
23:33
second . So the next category Important
23:35
, but maybe less of a priority . Yeah , family
23:38
is great , you know , especially
23:41
post COVID , all of a sudden , like everyone came out of the woodwork
23:43
again with travel or vacation or leisure
23:45
activities Like this is what I'm going to do to
23:47
justify my existence because I work hard
23:49
, or the sacrifices I made . And
23:52
what are those trips ? When are you taking
23:54
them ? When's the deposit needed ? Where's that money coming
23:56
from ? Are you sticking out a credit card and surprising me
23:58
a year from now that you want me to pay off the credit card because
24:00
you took the vacation that you knew you were going to take before
24:02
you spent the money , and
24:04
so it's all like . It's
24:08
interesting . The industry wants us to do financial planning
24:10
for the rest of your life . Let's go project
24:12
to do an auto purchase every five years . You're
24:14
going to work this many years , you're going to have this portfolio , we're going
24:16
to project it with these rates of return and we're going to come up with
24:18
a percentage probability of whether you're going to run out of money
24:20
or not , and there's all kinds of
24:22
variables in that . And yet what
24:25
I found interesting is all the software
24:28
I've ever looked at to use and have access
24:30
to now to use doesn't tell me that
24:32
if you were going to buy
24:34
a house in 2023 and
24:36
now it's 2024 when we're looking at your plan , the
24:39
data just falls off . It's
24:41
like wait . I'd rather ask did you buy the house
24:43
? Like , where are you
24:45
at ? That's part of that relationship . Did you enjoy the vacation
24:47
you took ? And so we're literally tracking
24:50
these things within the software that we
24:52
built to basically identify how's mom
24:54
and dad mom's in the care of silly dads , okay , or
24:56
dad's deceased , or how are the kids
24:58
? Hey , you said you're going to go to
25:01
Napa for two weeks last month . How was the
25:03
trip ? What are you planning in the next three
25:05
to six months , because the closer in
25:07
the timeframe , the more certain
25:09
clients know what they're doing . Most
25:12
people have no idea what they're doing three years from now . They
25:14
have a general idea , they might be on a rhythm
25:16
of life , but specifically like
25:19
are you taking a summer vacation ? You're
25:22
going to get a , yes or no ? Where exactly are
25:24
you going ? How much is it exactly going to cost ? Do you
25:26
need money from the account to do that ? How about Christmas
25:28
? You know , we just started asking questions 12
25:30
months out to find out what are these activities
25:32
. So , family travel
25:34
and leisure , how's the house ? Specifically
25:38
, home improvements , what is it ? The
25:40
bathroom that , like , what's going to be the thing that goes bad ? That you
25:43
didn't tell me ? It's the roof and it's leaking in . The next
25:45
, you know , hail storm , we got to get a $20,000
25:47
new roof , or the septic's
25:50
got to get redone , or the furnace is going to go
25:52
out or the windows or whatever . Because in
25:54
life that happens . And
25:57
had someone asked it's like , well , yeah , no , I'm that
25:59
furnace man , I'm just holding
26:01
on Like I don't want to wait , but that's going to be
26:03
maybe 10 grand when it all comes . And it's like all
26:06
these little five , 10 , 15
26:08
, $20,000 increments add up when
26:10
all of a sudden , out of the blue , they call and they need it . And
26:12
then the advisor has got to be surprised
26:15
that the client needs money that
26:17
no one bothered to ask when you were
26:19
going to need that and now you're at the
26:21
mercy of the market . Not any value , only
26:24
travel , leisure , home
26:26
, home improvements , vehicles , homes
26:29
and vehicles in financial planning are
26:31
the biggest areas where clients
26:33
can make the biggest mistakes , because it's so easy
26:35
to just add five or $10,000 to the purchase
26:38
of a house or even a car , and
26:41
in the cars it's finding out what's the rhythm of the cars
26:44
. Is the ears , miles ? We actually track clients
26:46
. The vet , the year of clients cars and the
26:48
mileage on clients cars , just for the simple stack
26:51
, is like , hey , if your car is 10 years old and you got 200,000
26:53
miles on it , like I'm like
26:56
, when are we buying the next one ? Or
26:58
I may encourage you , hey , the markets are all time highs
27:00
. These were up on a trend . We got extra profits here
27:02
. Why don't we carve out that 50 or 80
27:04
grand to buy that next car now and
27:06
you can then figure out when you want to go get it Instead
27:09
of when you finally need it . Now we're
27:11
going to be at the mercy of what the markets are at and
27:14
I don't know what that's going to look like . So the life plan
27:16
is taking kind of the concept of
27:18
long-term financial planning but bringing
27:20
it to the where the rubber meets the road
27:22
, which is really is it going to hit the
27:24
client's bank account and is the money going
27:26
to be in that bank account when they want it and who's
27:28
responsible for that ? And when clients start
27:31
realizing that we're kind of raising our hand to be responsible
27:33
for that part of funding their retirement , beyond
27:35
just the cash flow month to month stuff , one
27:40
we get to participate in their life in ways you don't normally
27:42
. That's the whole relationship , part of it , right Either
27:44
for empathizing with their situation
27:46
is with their parents or what's going on with kids in college
27:49
and what have you are just celebrating vacations or
27:51
sometimes just encouraging them hey , you got the
27:53
money . Go like , enjoy this . So
27:56
that's the life plan part
27:58
of the total relationship . And
28:01
again , I think a lot of people's
28:03
websites , a lot of TV commercials
28:05
try and hint to that . They do some
28:07
of this , but I know so few
28:10
that actually will like
28:12
put out there on a task or put out there
28:14
and track that in July
28:17
of next year you're planning to buy $100,000
28:20
or something , or rather , you're going to take that vacation
28:24
that you want and $80,000
28:26
needs to come from the non
28:28
qualified account and
28:30
the advisor's job is to pre fund that over
28:33
the next 12 months . I think not
28:35
every . I think the vast majority of advisors
28:37
are just waiting for clients to call , ask for
28:39
the money and then send them the money and appease
28:41
them , whatever that looks like , at
28:43
the mercy of wherever the markets are at . And the more volatile
28:45
the markets have gotten , the less value that advisor
28:48
adds when they're allowing the randomness
28:50
of that withdrawal versus hey
28:53
, if you know six to 12 months in advance , you
28:55
have a greater likelihood of trying to carve that profit
28:58
out when the markets are at an all time high . It's
29:01
not timing the markets . We're trying to time clients
29:04
needs , and you
29:06
can . You don't know what the markets are going to
29:08
do , but you can find out what your clients
29:10
are going to do and all I tell clients
29:12
is the number one goal is to don't sell shares
29:15
if we don't have to in the markets down . The
29:17
only way you do that is when the markets are up , which is I
29:19
don't know if a market's going to go higher than
29:21
it's all time high , but you know a certainty
29:23
if it's at its all time high or near it , and
29:26
you know a certainty if it's 20% off , it's all time
29:28
high . And the whole goal to building wealth is don't
29:30
sell when it's down . And
29:32
so when the markets are all up , we built technology
29:34
that we can go for every client pull the dollar
29:36
needs for the next , whatever timeframe we ask
29:39
, and if we want to say here , most
29:41
recently I said , pull
29:43
the cash flow requirements that
29:45
clients have given us so we get out into
29:47
the February of 2025 , we'll just post
29:49
the presidential election , post the inauguration
29:52
of the new president . And so I know that
29:54
everything our clients have told us they need , has
29:56
we actually raised it ? When the markets tipped over
29:59
here at the higher levels , different
30:01
from where they were in October , when they were down 20
30:03
or 30% from where they are now , and we just added
30:05
a ton of value ? And if the markets keep going higher , so
30:07
be it . I'm willing to accept that and
30:10
, at the same time , if they sell off , we've
30:12
raised it . That's what the life plan gives
30:15
us the data and the opportunity to do in the conversation
30:17
with the client , the
30:20
wealth plan becomes some of what I just talked
30:22
about with regards to the cash management putting
30:24
it in the system , identifying where it's going to come from and
30:27
then being able to act as a whole
30:29
. So , instead of randomly
30:31
deciding when to pull money out , we
30:34
as a firm , I
30:37
sleep and I have peace
30:39
of mind because I know that , unless
30:41
a client didn't tell me we have raised
30:43
what our clients have told me , and that it's usually six
30:46
to 12 months . In some cases we'll
30:48
go out two years in advance and
30:50
we park it . We pull it from a separate account . Usually
30:53
we'll park it in the money market and earn some interest , which is finally
30:55
getting back to being more significant . We
30:57
point to it that the clients can see it and
31:00
then the rest of the portfolio can fluctuate . Because
31:03
what we found with the wealth plan side of things
31:05
is , if you don't start defining how we're
31:07
funding things or what , or
31:09
maybe not in accumulation phase of life
31:12
, maybe not adding to things , because we need to build up
31:14
this reserve before we add to it . So that's just cash
31:16
management planning . If
31:18
you don't do that , we
31:20
had the client come in . That's just like the million dollar
31:22
account drop 10% , it's 100 grand and they
31:24
started telling me that was the car I was going to buy . You
31:26
just lost my car in the market because
31:29
they tangibly are equating it to something
31:31
that they're looking out in the future that they need . And
31:33
what dawned on me is hey , if we can take
31:36
what you're tangibly looking out in the near
31:38
term and needing and funding
31:40
it now when your million dollar account becomes
31:42
$900,000 , if you're not attaching
31:44
it to something tangible you thought you
31:46
needed , you tolerate
31:48
that more that . Actually the behavioral finance
31:51
shows that the person that thinks
31:53
that attaches a loss to a need
31:55
will actually go liquidate the portfolio and buy
31:58
what they thought they lost . So
32:00
that's a double hit . If I needed the $50,000
32:02
car in two months and I lost it in the market
32:04
, I'm going to go buy it now and it's
32:06
a double hit to the portfolio often .
32:08
So the bottom line is we're managing
32:11
behavior here just as much as people's taxes
32:14
and investments .
32:15
Right ? Yes , nick
32:17
Murray got it right years ago about the behavioral finance and
32:19
, ironically , the education system has come up
32:21
behind them is it is
32:23
trying . The number one job of
32:25
a financial advisor is to protect the client
32:27
from themselves , and I'll go one
32:30
step further it's also to protect the advisor
32:32
for themselves . I think way too many financial
32:34
advisors panic faster or
32:37
do more damage to their clients because they're as scared
32:39
as a client is . And
32:42
the wealth ? So the wealth plan , outside
32:46
of taking the information from the life plan and the
32:48
cash flow needs , the wealth plan is
32:50
on our end , you
32:53
know . Going back to designations
32:55
, I got somewhere in this neck
32:57
of the somewhere in the years I got the SEMA
32:59
, the Certified Investment Management
33:02
Analyst .
33:03
Yeah , I was going to ask you about that because I know you've got SEMA
33:05
, cfp I think , the Certified Exit
33:07
Planner . So obviously you're brushing up
33:09
on various industry certifications
33:12
, so you'll get through how
33:14
you're applying today . But I was going to ask , I wanted to see , which
33:16
of those three are most applicable or which ones
33:18
you've you've found yourself actually implementing
33:20
the most in your career , because a
33:22
lot of young people are taking these exams , I think , just because
33:25
they need some extra education , but it's not
33:27
meeting where they're practicing at the moment . So I'd be
33:29
curious for someone in your shoes which of the
33:31
designations is actually like making its way into
33:33
your practice the most . But you're going through SEMA now
33:35
, so let's hear on that .
33:36
Yeah . So I think my answer to that
33:39
is and I'll come back to the SEMA
33:41
real quick I think my answer to that is
33:43
all these certifications are any type
33:45
of education . Quite frankly , like
33:48
you can ace driver's
33:50
ed , it doesn't mean you're going to be a good
33:52
driver . The
33:54
real hard part of
33:57
any of these designations is
33:59
how the application of that knowledge
34:01
works and how it's communicated to a client
34:03
. Going back to losing place
34:06
settings or losing shoes meant more
34:08
to her than losing millions of dollars . The
34:10
dollars didn't mean anything , but when you tied
34:12
it back to something that like where
34:14
that value is , that's where the rubber
34:17
meets the road with these designations and
34:19
trying
34:21
to discern what's noise in the financial
34:23
services industry and what's important . And
34:27
so the SEMA . I
34:29
signed
34:33
up . There's only certain universities that
34:35
will teach it . I signed up at
34:37
Yale just to get my oldest kid a hard time thinking
34:39
I got into Yale . I'm like it's an executive program , but
34:41
technically , yes , it's Yale .
34:43
They get you that with your LinkedIn certifications . They'll
34:45
be like it's like . Well , no , none of the wholesalers
34:47
or advisors went to Yale and
34:50
bought in , or I think they do . Booths
34:52
in Chicago is like the three big ones . It's like booths
34:55
. We paid for a week . We may
34:57
or may not stay there , depending on when you took the exam , and it
34:59
was cool and it's a nice little nugget
35:01
here , but , yes , executive education program
35:03
.
35:04
Yeah , so the short version is
35:06
Yale , first class
35:08
and first chapter
35:11
and like first page it's like
35:13
, okay , real returns are
35:15
unknown because they're in the future , right
35:18
, so what's really going to happen , no one knows . Okay
35:21
, we got that and so now we're
35:23
going to go study expected returns about what
35:26
people think are going to happen . So
35:28
like , okay , and I say to people with that , what the
35:30
SEMA means is I said it means I got a certification and no
35:32
one knows what's going to happen .
35:35
Unpredictable , can't be held accountable for what happens
35:37
in the future . Past performance is no guarantee of
35:39
future results .
35:41
Yeah , it is , but some of my you know
35:43
. It's like you don't know what you don't know until you
35:45
know it , and like the scales
35:47
fell off my eyes when I started getting
35:50
in that first class about expected
35:52
returns and something about
35:54
capital market assumptions , which in all the financial
35:56
planning software we're all clicking off . Yeah
35:59
, they updated the capital market assumptions . I just want to get
36:01
to the plan that I need to do the work on and the Monte Carlo
36:03
system that I'm working on or whatever the planning software
36:05
is that someone's using . But
36:08
capital market assumptions is where a firm is
36:10
taking the past rates of return
36:12
and volatility and projecting it some point in the
36:14
future what they think those returns are going to be . What
36:18
we've built and what we're encouraging
36:20
in the wealth plan is we
36:23
take four different companies
36:25
capital market assumptions , so
36:27
we're not hanging our hat in any one because there's every
36:30
firm's got bias , people have bias and
36:32
so what we found is , if you go and grab institutional
36:35
your vanguard , your Fidelity's , your Schwab's
36:38
, your Black Rock's , your I-Share's , your
36:40
Invesco's you know it's like that's
36:42
more than four . It doesn't matter
36:44
which one you grab , but grab different
36:47
ones and we blend both time
36:49
frames . So we blend 10 and 20
36:51
year time frames , with one to 10 year time
36:53
frames from four different firms , and
36:55
pull an average , we
36:57
pull inflation out of that and
36:59
then it's like , okay , what's your real expected return
37:01
of different asset classes going forward ? And what was
37:03
mind blowing to me is , had you done that
37:06
in 2019 , with
37:08
the markets getting toppied , before COVID hit
37:10
? That was telling you
37:13
, hey , the future expected return was
37:15
not very high because of how well
37:17
the market had done for 10 years , much less , a
37:19
little better on fixed income Post COVID
37:22
. So fast forward , six months later
37:24
, markets are shellacked , interest rates have
37:26
gone to zero . That capital market assumption
37:29
shift that our asset allocation almost
37:31
entirely out of fixed income , almost
37:33
entirely for everybody , because
37:35
it was basically predicting you're , you are going
37:37
to have negative real returns in every
37:39
, at every fixed income class . And
37:42
guess what , by avoiding it
37:45
also showed that by the the run up in 2021
37:47
, in 2022 , hey , take
37:50
some profit off the table on the fixed , you know
37:52
, on the equity side and go back into the fixed income
37:54
side because the interest rates were starting
37:56
to go back up or the expectation of future rates were going
37:58
to go back up . So it's , it's just a guide , but
38:01
if you're trying to get a client a five , six , seven
38:03
, eight percent you know net real return
38:05
, hey , why don't you look at a roadmap
38:07
of a bunch of firms that are guessing where that's going to
38:09
be as a as a compass , so just
38:11
guessing , like people are filling out these questionnaires
38:14
, and based on the client's question
38:16
or answer to the question , or based on
38:18
the bias of how the questions were stacked ? Like
38:21
you know , there's a difference response
38:23
between you know , how do you feel about losing
38:25
20% of your portfolio value versus how
38:27
do you feel about running out of money if you don't subject
38:29
your portfolio to a 20% loss ? Right
38:33
, you're going to get a different answer depending on the questions
38:35
are spelled out , but we're going to take
38:37
these questions . They're going to tell us what these answers
38:39
are . The answers are going to spit us into some formulas . Form
38:41
is going to spit us into some asset allocation and
38:44
that's what the client's supposed to have . And
38:46
I'm going time out because what I
38:48
found for the last 20 years plus of my career
38:50
is , depending on where interest rates were at or
38:52
the valuations of equity is we're at , that
38:55
should be driving the asset allocation , because
38:57
that has a lot more to do with the volatility and where the returns
38:59
are going to come from than what
39:01
these textbooks are averaging out for 50
39:03
or 100 years . Right , the entry and
39:05
exit point of how capital gets put to work or
39:07
gets taken out should be considered , and
39:09
what we found is like there isn't a secret
39:12
sauce out there , but if you take the average
39:14
of four different firms , you're more likely going
39:16
to get closer to what the averages are , and then we do the
39:18
same thing for
39:20
different , for how we actually go build our model
39:23
. So how we're going to go build our model is we're going to go take the asset
39:25
allocation 60 , 40 or 80
39:27
, 20 of all these same four different firms
39:29
, put them in a blender and pull out and just see what
39:31
are the assets they're putting in there , what are the positions
39:34
, what's the percentage , how do they change ? And
39:36
all I found is that if you follow the
39:38
flow of how money gets put in the market , you
39:41
participate with those flows , which
39:43
tends to return back into
39:45
performance , right , too much money is coming out
39:47
of something that's probably not going up in price or
39:50
vice versa , and so it's taking
39:52
me out of it . That's the first thing I want to do , because
39:54
I have emotions and I have biases and I have my
39:56
opinions and things and I can be wrong , and
39:58
it's taking and applying a bunch of what I think
40:00
history has to say . And then , if they're
40:03
guessing about the future , rather than putting my hat
40:05
on one firm or one person's guess
40:07
by blending it . And I laugh
40:09
every time stuff comes out , and so does my team
40:11
, because nine times out of 10 , the
40:15
research report is going to come out and
40:17
one company says go left . One company
40:20
says go right . One company goes straight . One company
40:22
says stop . And you put them in a blender and it says
40:24
don't do anything , leave it where it is . And
40:26
what I have found is had
40:28
the less you do to portfolios
40:31
, the better they grow . In a world
40:33
that tells you you should be doing all kinds of things
40:35
to these portfolios , I could go
40:37
on a rant for that for like hours , because
40:39
it's kind of- . Yes , go on your turn .
40:41
And no , I'd say it's just
40:43
kind of hilarious to think about how we have an industry
40:46
of professionals whose responsibilities to be
40:48
more aware of these things , but yet if
40:50
somebody were less at
40:53
, let's say , 85%
40:56
of moments of time , maybe even higher some quant
40:58
has better information than me If you essentially
41:00
did nothing , never touched it and just continuously
41:03
added to a broad base
41:05
of like asset classes , like you're going to be fine , so that
41:07
we don't necessarily need to get to that on
41:09
this podcast . But having provided
41:12
that overview that you've got for your
41:14
firm and how you manage clients assets
41:16
, I did want to carve out a moment here because
41:19
I know we're going to be on the clock here up at five
41:21
, but I wanted to talk about , obviously , the rubber
41:23
meets the road at some point with the
41:25
investments that you're actually making . So
41:27
, being a part of the broker dealer , you obviously
41:29
will have your selected funds and
41:31
fund families and investment options that are available
41:34
on the various platforms . Maybe there's some direct
41:36
investing that your team is doing yourself , maybe
41:38
it's just ETFs , but why don't you describe
41:40
and share with the audience like , how are you
41:42
actually leveraging asset
41:45
managers , maybe the wholesalers , or I
41:47
know some advisors ? They honestly just don't . So
41:49
I'd be curious like how do you manage that and what's
41:52
the rationale behind that ?
41:54
Yeah , so I
41:58
don't anymore . I did
42:01
. I found the mistake of doing it , meaning
42:03
I had I was a branch
42:06
manager back in the day and had what
42:08
I have . I had like five or six teams
42:11
, including my own , in the branch and
42:13
part of the requirement of being a branch manager
42:15
of the broker dealer was you facilitated the
42:17
meetings of the firms that we wanted
42:19
to come in and present the product and it was educational
42:22
right and you'd meet some wonderful
42:24
people that are presenting this wonderful
42:26
information and maybe they took you to lunch
42:28
or they brought donuts to the office or whatever
42:30
. They gave you a nice pen when they
42:33
left or a pad of paper
42:35
, whatever it was , and all
42:37
this and then the yeah
42:40
, a packet of some type of information
42:42
that now I'm trying to decide what , what I should do
42:44
for the large cap money manager . And here's
42:47
the large cap money manager packet of the guy
42:49
that brought me donuts the other day , and
42:51
again , it's
42:53
all shelf life and what's on top of your shelf
42:55
, of your head and where the information is sitting , is what
42:57
you're going to act on . What I realized
43:00
was simultaneously
43:02
one of my mentors back in the day , named
43:04
Bob Dunwoody , who I don't think
43:06
is with us anymore . He
43:08
had a saying . It's like hey , financial advisor
43:11
, take
43:13
your AUM . What's the value of all your
43:15
assets , of your clients , right ? What's
43:17
that dollar amount ? Is it 100 million ? Is it 200
43:19
million ? Is it 500 million ? Whatever it is , put
43:22
it in cash . So now see it as dollars
43:24
, literally liquid cash
43:26
. Now
43:29
ask yourself , where should it be invested
43:31
? Not where is it . What should it be in
43:33
? I wrote a
43:35
book in 2012 , which was my first crack
43:37
at trying to help financial advisors , called
43:39
your World Impact as a financial advisor . It's
43:42
in there . It's expanded on a little bit
43:44
in the total relationship
43:46
. What do we do
43:49
? Our philosophy is we have a predetermined
43:51
investment strategy and approach based
43:53
on the client's need . In other words
43:56
, it's a long term or short term . Is
43:59
it beyond three years or less than three years ? If it's
44:01
beyond three years , it's long termed to us and we
44:03
have a solution for that . Are
44:05
you going to be living off of that portfolio
44:07
? Are you accumulating ? So that'll be another differentiator
44:10
. But the bottom line is it is a predetermined
44:12
portfolio strategy set up ahead of
44:14
time that money goes into . It's
44:16
not created for the client . The idea
44:19
that you can create all these different custom portfolios
44:21
for the client is a facade , unless you only have one
44:23
client . Because Bob Dunwoody , going
44:25
back to this mentor , his point was if it's
44:27
all in cash and it should
44:29
be why isn't it where it should be ? And
44:32
if it was all in cash , it kind of freed your mind up
44:34
. Wait a second . And I think back in the day the average
44:36
advisor had over 1,000 positions . They
44:38
can't track 1,000 positions , they
44:41
can't stay on top of 1,000 positions . They
44:43
don't know what happens to the money manager or
44:45
the individual stock or whatever it is
44:47
. And yet the clients are all expecting
44:49
you to pay attention to that and part
44:52
of the wealth plan is building
44:54
predetermined custom portfolios
44:56
. I'm a believer that the actual investment
44:58
it doesn't matter Over
45:01
the next 10 , 20 , 30 year timeframe
45:03
that these clients are asking us to help them in their
45:05
lives and the generational wealth that is this business
45:07
. It does not matter what
45:10
large cap fund you have , what small cap
45:12
fund you have . What matters per vanguard
45:14
is keep costs low , keep
45:17
turnover low , purify it so
45:19
it can't drift and all of a sudden start owning something
45:21
it wasn't supposed to own , and follow
45:23
the stewardship principles of asset allocation , diversification
45:26
and maybe rebalancing . Actually , I'm starting to find
45:28
that rebalancing doesn't have a lot to do with anything in
45:30
the grand scheme of things , other than it sounds good . It's
45:34
definitely a way to take money in and out of a portfolio
45:36
, but just to do it for the fun of it , I think we're
45:38
just creating more tax consequences . So we're building
45:41
and have been for 20
45:43
years now , no , not quite 18
45:46
years discretionary
45:48
portfolios
45:50
that money goes into . That we've identified
45:53
, and that's where the difference is . Instead of
45:55
trying to build a portfolio that that fuels all
45:57
these clients needs and wants together into some
45:59
asset allocation , we're just
46:01
carving out what do you not need
46:03
into the future , that's long term
46:05
, with what you need now and
46:08
the customization is what doesn't go in the
46:10
model . We created models and
46:12
, instead of customizing for the client , we allowed
46:14
ourselves to add scale and
46:17
accountability , meaning every client's getting
46:19
about the same experience , which the other thing that drove me
46:21
nuts is . I'd show up at the dinner table and
46:23
a family get together and it's like , depending
46:25
on when I talk to somebody is what portfolio
46:28
they got or what their experience was
46:30
in the market is depending on how they added to the portfolio
46:32
and without having a predetermined portfolio
46:34
strategy . I wanted to fix the now
46:37
with this wealth plan and this philosophy
46:40
we've come up with . It's like I want to sit at the table and know everybody's
46:42
returns are the same for the long term
46:44
money . The customization came into
46:46
what they need in the next three six
46:49
, 24 , 36 months .
46:52
So , like with that , with those portfolios underneath
46:54
the hood , is that like ETF based ? Is it mostly
46:56
yes ? We've gone ETF
46:58
based because the mutual fund it's
47:01
been a tough go honestly with , like the funds , mutual
47:04
funds- are doomed .
47:05
I was told that a decade ago and it's just
47:07
. Mutual funds are doomed for the fact that technology
47:09
came to the place that allows things to just
47:12
there's efficiencies . It's efficiency .
47:14
You know like a large growth . It's like
47:17
I'm sure there's three or four funds that have outperformed
47:19
significantly , but if you like , throw any performance
47:21
metric on . Basically
47:23
, I mean , things change but like 2009
47:26
forward , it's kind of like sure
47:28
you , maybe a few active managers
47:30
hit some home runs , but like by and large it
47:33
does not make up for the ones that underperformed
47:35
. I think the most recent report I saw on active
47:37
manager flows was like only
47:39
40% of last year's managers outperformed
47:41
the S&P and I think that was large growth
47:43
. So , like sure , that's an asset class where you can just
47:45
set it , forget it , etf it .
47:47
But well , and Russell did a study . Russell
47:49
did a study years ago that it's like the top performing
47:51
money managers over a 10 year timeframe underperformed
47:55
70% of the time , which means you can identify
47:57
them in the 10 years . You can see what they are when you look backwards
47:59
.
48:01
Right , yeah , it's so easy when you see the
48:03
sheet right , it's so easy . When you see a fact sheet , it's
48:05
like every calendar year or whatever
48:07
, but it doesn't really necessarily mean this
48:10
pull , it doesn't account for that experience
48:13
and that is kind of what happens whenever
48:15
you're making an investment choice
48:17
for your clients , which , if there's
48:19
any takeaway from a lot of what you've talked about
48:21
, I know I mentioned upfront , like before
48:24
we started recording , that a lot of this audience is the sales
48:26
people and the fund wholesalers out there . They
48:30
only see we only see like
48:32
a net flows of money into our funds and money
48:34
out from your funds . And I remembered
48:36
when I was working with financial advisors like
48:38
it never occurred to me until I was sitting in meetings with their
48:40
clients that this is money that's just
48:42
funding their lifestyle . So like they
48:44
may have put in $500,000 into my
48:47
equity SNA five
48:49
years ago . And now my managers like
48:51
, well , why do they redeem ? And I'm like because
48:53
the person whose money it was just had
48:55
like sold their house and is buying a vacation . It
48:58
was like it has nothing to do with them being mad at
49:00
the performance of the fund . It's just like we are . Our
49:02
instrument is a vehicle for them to build wealth over
49:05
their lifetime and at some point they cash it out like
49:07
has nothing to do with the fund . It's just the way the world is .
49:09
Yeah , and the whole problem with I have
49:11
so much empathy for the
49:13
wholesaling industry it's
49:17
because the whole industry is renting other
49:19
people's money . They're
49:23
charging a fee to have access , to add value
49:25
and to turn and that asset is going to go to another generation
49:27
or it's going to go to a purpose because the
49:29
money flows and
49:32
thank God there's a ton of money out there . And
49:34
again , I think everybody's trying to add value and
49:36
not necessarily . There's obviously good and bad
49:38
in the world , just in general . But the
49:42
problem is there
49:45
when you try and drive costs
49:47
low on the ETF side
49:49
especially , you pay attention to trading
49:51
, daily trading volumes that you
49:53
don't get a put . You don't want to own more
49:55
shares in your practice than the daily trading
49:57
volume , which means you're going to move the market on your own
49:59
shares , trying to get out of them , which
50:01
nobody pays attention to . Or
50:04
the bids and the asks . You know you got to put limits
50:06
, orders in on everything you do . It's
50:08
just technology
50:11
is making more and I'm not saying it's good
50:13
, I'm just saying it's the reality that the ETF
50:15
space is making money
50:17
management more and more easier
50:19
to build what
50:22
has been asset allocation , diversification
50:24
, low cost and participation . I
50:27
think there's also trade offs , that it also creates
50:29
rallies
50:31
and falls in the market because the
50:33
human race can click their mouse
50:35
and all panic at the same time . And
50:38
that's also the undoing in the mutual fund world , because
50:40
those mutual funds and markets that are down and
50:43
they're dealing with those redemptions at the end of the day
50:45
they have to go sell often when you get what
50:47
they don't want to sell to meet the redemptions . Because
50:51
, as I explained to the client which is my favorite way of
50:53
explaining a mutual fund
50:56
to an ETF is , if you have a mutual fund
50:58
house and you have an ETF house and you're
51:00
going to buy the house , a mutual
51:03
fund , they build the house for you , the
51:05
ETF . You buy the house . It's finished
51:07
. When you go to sell the house , the mutual fund
51:10
they start ripping the windows off and the roof off and they dismantle
51:12
, they redeem all
51:14
the pieces of your shares in to give
51:16
you back your money . The ETF just
51:19
sells the house . And so it's
51:21
the efficiencies of those two worlds . One
51:23
was the only way to do it in the 1940s
51:27
and it's just it
51:29
is what it is .
51:29
I know I've tried to think
51:32
of a good comparison
51:35
, either with a relevant like business or
51:37
some other example to use , as far as
51:39
what will eventually be like that shift
51:41
and takeover between the ETFs
51:43
and like those active flows . But
51:45
it's a competitive industry . A lot of sharp
51:47
people are in the space . So things like
51:49
active ETFs and vehicles that are more
51:52
you know , they're less expensive but still
51:54
add value . Obviously we've got a lot of these tax
51:56
efficient vehicles coming . But
51:58
this is this is an interesting and a good
52:01
conversation . Why I love being able to have these
52:03
discussions with advisors is because , sort
52:05
of like , at the end of the day , I just like trajectory
52:07
wise . 15
52:10
to 20 years ago it seemed like there was a lot more
52:12
importance on the singular investment of any
52:15
given client and whereas now
52:17
it's sort of like this is just a sum of its
52:19
parts that the advisor is managing and
52:21
so sure , like I could give you a $500,000
52:24
for a tax efficient separate account , that
52:27
big , big whoop that does that , that saves
52:29
that tax on maybe 5%
52:31
of a $500,000 account . I'm thinking about like
52:34
this person's life and their holistic
52:36
picture , so I feel like that's kind of a trend
52:38
.
52:38
And that's so . That's right . Yeah , we put no
52:40
value because I don't think there's any to be
52:42
put on a diversified portfolio
52:45
of exchange traded funds . The value
52:47
is on the total relationship of paying
52:49
attention to when the money comes in and out
52:51
of those , where I think you can add a ton of value
52:53
. With markets that bounce around 5
52:55
, 10 , 20 , 30% in
52:57
weeks and months over the last
52:59
couple of years , when you're adding and , more
53:02
importantly , when you're redeeming those shares
53:04
, when you do that matters
53:06
. It actually locks in
53:08
the return . I think there could be a lot of value added to
53:10
that . And by not by
53:12
using blending multiple pieces
53:14
of research together , I'm removing my
53:17
ability to go guess , because
53:19
I found most people's guesses is wrong . Now
53:21
, everybody that's doing this and
53:24
the industry that's doing this is also creating the opportunity
53:26
. And , by the way , I'm a proponent of
53:28
the reason wealth is made in the marketplace
53:31
is because humans are irrational
53:33
. If everybody was rational
53:35
, the markets would only grow based on the company's
53:38
earnings . Grow like it would grow like a straight line
53:40
or fluctuate right to line with the
53:42
fundamentals , and the reality is that's not what happens . The
53:45
greatest returns happen because people panic and
53:47
then people that have the guts to take
53:49
, you know , plug their nose and take advantage of that
53:51
do , or the very
53:53
companies themselves do . And that volatility
53:55
of people's emotions is what I think gives
53:58
us these return potentials , because everything just keeps
54:00
swinging in and out of its trend
54:02
line , at the expense
54:04
of some , for the benefit of others . And by
54:06
taking a approach of taking my emotions
54:09
, taking my team's emotions , my
54:11
bias , my team's bias , anyone firms bias
54:13
and using blended research
54:16
I don't care what research you use , but
54:18
using several , I think has
54:20
done a wonderful job of giving us more of the average
54:22
return that we're looking for . Ironically , you
54:24
start getting an average return of the institutional
54:26
models that are out there , because that's what you're deriving
54:28
your portfolio from and that's what you're trying to do for
54:31
a client in the first place . And , lastly
54:33
, I can stand in front of an arbitration panel and raise
54:35
my hand and explain this is why I
54:37
did what I did , this is why I have that ETF
54:40
, this is why it was in this percentage and it was
54:42
the blending of these four firms research . Now
54:44
, they may not like that's what I did , but it's like
54:46
I can defend the snot out of that . But
54:49
if in Dan's portfolio , I bought XYZ
54:51
fund because the other guy took me out to lunch
54:53
and it was a great day and I forgot about it and that was
54:55
your fund . And now something went wrong and I'm
54:58
in the panel . Do
55:00
I have the documentation to justify why
55:03
I earned my fee for that advisory portfolio
55:05
? That's the risk I don't want to take .
55:07
It'd be like your honor . The wholesaler came
55:09
in great doughnut , great suit . We
55:11
had an awesome dinner that night , and so I made the purchase
55:14
outside as part of my portfolio the next
55:16
day . I solemnly swear
55:18
but yeah , that's super helpful . And
55:20
you've actually mentioned the planning
55:23
software a couple of times . Is that something that's internally
55:25
available through Raymond James ? Is it like an e-money
55:27
of sorts , because I feel like it seems like
55:29
it's worked well for you . So if you want to give it a nod , understanding
55:32
the tools that advisors use is always helpful .
55:35
So we built it inside of Salesforce
55:37
and
55:40
have recently grown it into a financial
55:42
services cloud . We're working currently
55:44
with , and part of the resources at , the TotalRelationshipcom
55:47
, which there'll be a link for the podcast for you
55:50
here , but where we've built a website to build a
55:52
community behind . Hey , here's how to do this . We're
55:55
building , or we're trying to build , a
55:57
tool
55:59
that , basically , will be just the way of
56:01
this data capture . How do you capture
56:03
some of this data that's consistent
56:06
. It's a place that also
56:08
here's the different questions to ask , because the client
56:11
, the customization , is the client's answers to their
56:13
lives and it's the client that has the answers . The
56:15
best advisors are the ones that know how to ask the question
56:18
and listen and find out the why behind the question
56:20
and help prioritize . Hey , you can't do everything
56:22
, but in this order you can do these things , and
56:24
the whole goal is to try and avoid future regret and
56:27
part of that whole third part of care
56:30
, is just caring enough to basically
56:32
say , hey , I want to sign up to monitor your life
56:34
, I want to sign up to be responsible for
56:36
the things you want to do in life . I want to be responsible
56:38
, remind you , I want to be the person that gives
56:41
you permission to enjoy your life
56:43
, because I think a lot of clients have shown me they're afraid
56:45
to spend the money and it was literally not until I took
56:47
out the 50 grand and put
56:49
it in the bank account that they actually would go buy the car , because
56:51
otherwise they think that's the portfolio and that's for later
56:53
and I can't touch that and I don't want to touch that . And
56:56
what do you mean ? I'm going to take money from that and it's just like
56:58
no , here , boom , there's the extra
57:01
. It's
57:03
just such a it's
57:06
a different way to go about a job that
57:08
otherwise is trying to outperform a portfolio
57:11
, trying to do better than some other
57:13
guy , and there's plenty of people out there that want to try and do that
57:15
, and I just think the world's getting set up more and more . It's
57:17
like if you want to do that , there's too many people that want to do
57:19
that themselves . Like I want to be the
57:21
solution of the do it yourself , or that got sick of doing
57:23
it or blew themselves up , or the widow of
57:25
the do it yourself , because I think there's
57:28
way more people . It's just like I just want to be protected for
57:30
myself from my life savings and I want someone
57:32
else to be responsible to help me spend and
57:34
not run out of that which I have , and
57:36
can I enjoy a little bit of it along the
57:38
way and get decent returns and
57:40
beat inflation right ? This isn't it's like
57:42
hey , yes , I can do that . You
57:45
may not like it . It's volatile at times , but we're going to try
57:47
and set it aside and we put a little system together
57:49
. And it's not pie charts
57:51
and 100 page
57:53
perspectives and
57:55
portfolio management . It's a discretionary
57:58
portfolio . We'll decide what's in it . You got to tell
58:00
us when you're going to need money in and out of it and
58:02
we're going to work together and have this relationship . And so let's talk
58:04
about your family and talk about your occupation and
58:06
talk about your hobbies and travel and your
58:09
home and your car , and how are the kids and how are the
58:11
pets and how is life and
58:14
in its day and age . Like , all of a sudden , that's a value
58:16
add In a social
58:18
media , like everyone's looking through computer
58:20
screens and we're trying to like understand people's
58:22
hopes and dreams and lives in ways
58:24
that it's coming down to which vacation they're
58:26
taking next , or an asking them to
58:28
enjoy it , or asking them
58:30
the mileage on their car , because I will you know , it's funny
58:33
ones . I only have to ask them that once . And
58:35
when they want to ask why , I'm like well , guess what , the
58:37
more miles you have , more likely you're going to need another car . Those
58:39
things are expensive , so I want to pay attention when that's coming
58:41
, so we're not surprised . It's like okay , so
58:45
it's just , it's just , it's so
58:47
. It
58:50
seems crazy that you know
58:52
, in the NFL , which I don't follow all that much , there's
58:54
professional coaches to coach
58:56
professional athletes how to block or
58:58
tackle , like they're in the NFL or
59:01
to teach a professional golf ride a putt , and
59:04
it's like . It seems like that's this way too , like they
59:06
still need to do those basic things , and it's just like I think
59:08
the financial industry has gotten so lost in trying to add
59:10
value in some other way that just doing the basic
59:12
things about how was mom and dad doing and
59:14
are you responsible for them when they go into the care facility
59:16
? And do you know that ? Do you know where the documents are
59:19
? Are you going to have to fund any of those
59:21
expenses ? Are we going to get parents or one of three
59:23
things . They're going to basically die with their last penny
59:25
. You're going to need to help them or they're going to leave you inheritance
59:27
. Which one of the three is it ? And
59:31
just asking the right question . It's just , it's it
59:33
. We're having a lot of fun with it . It's
59:35
like the whole .
59:36
We got a lot of problems to solve . But you're right , it's
59:39
the simple ones . But that never , that
59:42
never makes its way into . But I'm the wholesaler's nightmare .
59:44
I'm the wholesaler's nightmare because , like I , I've
59:47
removed the whole reason why any one of them mattered
59:50
to me . And yet they're all great people .
59:52
Let's we can , we can wrap on this one because it's been fun
59:54
and , like I said , there's no hurt feelings
59:57
out here , because I think I think anyone
59:59
who is a good wholesaler like understands that , one
1:00:01
, they're not going to work with every potential advisor
1:00:04
out there and two , if they're paying
1:00:06
attention to what's happening in the industry , they're
1:00:08
probably not disagreeing with you at all . So
1:00:11
so there's probably some that are like yep , I
1:00:13
actually get it . But I do want to close on this . Are you , are
1:00:15
you swatting away emails and phone calls
1:00:17
from them all the time ? Are they like , are they hitting you up
1:00:19
and trying to get in touch with you or someone else at your
1:00:21
firm , like on blast ? Is that like
1:00:23
a problem that you're trying to deal with or that you are dealing
1:00:25
with ?
1:00:28
Yeah , they , they . There's different
1:00:30
. I think we actually have a policy and procedure
1:00:32
for gatekeepers of how they , how they , get access
1:00:35
to me , or don't ? The four companies that we use
1:00:37
their research ? I will , I will interact
1:00:39
with . The hard part is I basically say I need nothing
1:00:41
from you other than the research . I don't want to go
1:00:43
to lunch , I don't want to have , I don't want to
1:00:45
pen , I don't want . You know , I just
1:00:47
, I just give me the research , or here's
1:00:49
the criteria that we use , of the puzzle , the pieces
1:00:51
that could go into our portfolio , which are quite
1:00:54
limiting , ironically , between
1:00:56
cost trading , volume and track
1:00:59
record . But
1:01:02
you know , I was , I was
1:01:04
at a strategic coach event and one of the participants
1:01:07
at the coaching was a wholesaler and
1:01:09
he was talking about the struggle that he was having
1:01:11
of coming up with an event , and the
1:01:13
purpose of the event was to solely
1:01:15
was to give the advisors a good time
1:01:17
and allow him to share a little bit about the product
1:01:20
, with the hope that
1:01:22
they somehow would come around and do a sale
1:01:24
in in the product
1:01:26
that they sold . And it was just like it
1:01:31
. It , you know , and that's that's
1:01:33
how that industry has been working forever , and it's just
1:01:36
like man .
1:01:36
I just want to use good products that have
1:01:38
low cost , that don't need to have a commercial
1:01:40
or don't have to take me out
1:01:42
to lunch to find them , find the way into my portfolio
1:01:45
and
1:01:48
yeah it's
1:01:50
, that's what keeps , that's what's keeping
1:01:52
today's wholesaler up at night is because once
1:01:55
you strip away the wholesaler being the conduit
1:01:57
for fund information like I
1:02:00
, like individuals used to show up
1:02:02
needing to present information that
1:02:05
was on the fact sheet or whatever else you
1:02:07
just you just don't need that anymore and like , and you can
1:02:09
look up anything you need to look up on a
1:02:11
fund at your own , on your own
1:02:13
time , with your own tools , and so it really
1:02:15
just makes it makes for . It
1:02:17
, makes it difficult for someone who is not thinking that way
1:02:19
to like go
1:02:21
about maybe running an event
1:02:23
. That's like really , that's like actually impactful and
1:02:25
valuable when they're supposed to focus on products
1:02:28
, but lo and behold , the people they're trying
1:02:30
to invite like they don't need that information in that
1:02:32
forum . Like that's , that's really where the tide is shifting
1:02:34
and that's where I , that's where I
1:02:36
felt it , it's where everyone out there in the field has
1:02:38
felt it , and it's it's just there's
1:02:41
going to be a path forward , but I think it's still getting ironed out
1:02:43
and it's still going to be a little choppy until it does .
1:02:46
Yeah , I had a relationship with a wholesaler
1:02:48
back in the beginning part of my career in the 2000
1:02:50
, the 2008 realm and we switched to go
1:02:52
to discretionary and I realized
1:02:55
that that product was it wasn't going to be a fit
1:02:57
for the direction that we were going and
1:03:00
I called him and told him I was doing it . But we pulled
1:03:02
a hundred million dollars out on a day
1:03:04
in a day because we went to scratch area and then
1:03:06
sold the models .
1:03:07
Well , bad day for the wholesaler in the office probably
1:03:09
.
1:03:10
Oh , it was just I ruined his year . I
1:03:12
, like I , to this day still
1:03:15
feel bad and
1:03:17
yet to this day , have said to myself I am never going
1:03:20
to put myself in a relational position that again
1:03:22
, that I have to feel
1:03:24
bad for doing what's right for hundreds or thousands
1:03:26
of people that entrusted
1:03:28
me with their life savings . I don't want that conflict .
1:03:32
Because there was a great relationship there and there was nothing the
1:03:34
wholesaler did wrong .
1:03:35
I love the guy . Still do we
1:03:38
have and we have and we there's a , there's some . It's kind
1:03:40
of a joke and it's kind of not a joke , but
1:03:43
he got crushed in
1:03:45
his business that year and it was my
1:03:47
fault . But I bring
1:03:49
him on the show , we'll get him on the show .
1:03:51
We're going to run back an episode with him about the worst
1:03:53
year of his career
1:03:55
because of Tyson . How about that ? We'll
1:03:58
facilitate that , yeah , yeah . Awesome he
1:04:00
might hear this episode and I might get a phone
1:04:02
call because
1:04:04
he knows who he is . Let
1:04:07
me know We'll get it over to him . But there it is . Yes , tyson
1:04:10
, thank you so much for for spending some time with us this afternoon . I
1:04:12
have so obviously we have the total relationship
1:04:14
. We'll make the link available . We talked about
1:04:16
the framework . This is both for advisors
1:04:18
, obviously out there , and for any wholesalers
1:04:20
that might want to check this out just to get a perspective
1:04:23
about what advisors are dealing with today . Certainly
1:04:26
, check it out and , tyson , we welcome you back
1:04:28
whenever . Feel free to be at your . Your officially
1:04:31
a friend of the show , so
1:04:33
thank you so much for joining the internal use only . Thanks
1:04:36
for listening . Find
1:04:38
us on Instagram at internal use only podcast or email
1:04:42
us at internal use only podcast
1:04:44
at gmailcom .
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More