It Could Happen Here Weekly 178

It Could Happen Here Weekly 178

Released Saturday, 19th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
It Could Happen Here Weekly 178

It Could Happen Here Weekly 178

It Could Happen Here Weekly 178

It Could Happen Here Weekly 178

Saturday, 19th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

know you've got to come back in here. Comeback

0:03

in you. When you take the

0:05

next step, you're going to make

0:07

it count for your career, for

0:10

your family, for your life. You

0:12

can earn a degree you're proud

0:15

of with Purdue Global. Purdue Global

0:17

is backed by Purdue University, one

0:19

of the nation's most respected and

0:22

innovative public universities. This is your

0:24

chance. This is your opportunity. This

0:26

is your comeback. Purdue Global. Produce

0:29

online university for working adults. Start

0:31

your comeback today. Every morning

0:33

brings a fresh new energy and

0:35

no matter what the day holds

0:38

we come to the Today Show for

0:40

all of it. We get the best

0:42

start to the day because we started

0:44

together. Watch the Today Show weekdays at

0:46

7 a.m. on NBC. Ugh, come

0:48

on. Why is this taking so long?

0:51

This thing is ancient. Still using

0:53

yesterday's tech? Upgrade to the ThinkPad

0:55

X1 Carbon. Ultra -light, ultra -powerful, and

0:57

built for serious productivity with Intel

0:59

Core Ultra processors, blazing speed, and

1:01

AI -powered performance that keeps up

1:03

with your business, not the other

1:05

way around. Whoa, this thing moves. Stop

1:08

hitting snooze on new tech. Win

1:10

the tech search at Lenovo.com. Unlock

1:14

AI experiences with the ThinkPad X1

1:16

Carbon powered by Intel Core Ultra

1:18

processors so you can work, create,

1:20

and boost productivity all on one

1:22

device. This

1:26

is Matt Rogers from Lost Culturistas with

1:28

Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang. Have

1:30

you ever felt that uneasy anxiety when

1:32

the 4 p .m. hour strikes, the

1:34

creeping meal -related distress that happens when

1:36

you don't quite feel prepared? You

1:38

know, dinner dread? Let's get rid of

1:40

that unpleasant feeling forever with one

1:42

word. Stophers. No

1:44

matter what happens, you'll have a dinner

1:46

plan that everyone loves with stoffers. Some

1:48

chicken enchiladas or a cheesy chicken and

1:50

broccoli pasta bake is always welcome whether

1:53

it is plan A or plan D.

1:55

Delicious. Not gonna lie, I eat

1:57

the lasagna once a week.

1:59

And that's a fact. When

2:01

the clock strikes dinner, think stoffers. Shop

2:03

now for family favorites. Hey

2:08

everybody, Robert Evans here, and I wanted

2:10

to let you know this is

2:12

a compilation episode. So every episode of

2:14

the week that just happened is

2:16

here in one convenient and with somewhat

2:18

less ads package for you to

2:20

listen to in a long stretch if

2:22

you want. If you've been listening

2:24

to the episodes every day this week, there's got to be

2:27

nothing new here for you, but you can make your

2:29

own decisions. Welcome

2:32

to It Could Happen Here, a podcast that asks the

2:34

question, what happens when the people who are trying

2:36

to help put things back together are also being exploited

2:38

in the process? I am

2:40

your host, Mia Wong, and today

2:42

we are going to be talking about a

2:44

union that is attempting to do exactly

2:46

that. And with me to

2:48

discuss this are Jess and Jesus, who

2:51

are mentors for Friends of the Children

2:53

PDX and members of the Friends PDX

2:55

Union Network. Yeah, Jess, Jesus, welcome

2:57

to the show. Thank you so much

2:59

for having us. Yeah, thank you. Yeah,

3:01

I'm really happy to talk to you

3:03

both because I think this is a very,

3:05

very unique and interesting union, especially, you know,

3:07

talk about especially right now. But

3:09

to get people sort of rolling, can

3:12

you explain what Friends of the Children

3:14

is and what it is that

3:16

you two do? Yeah.

3:19

So Friends of the Children is,

3:21

it's a national organization, it's

3:23

a nonprofit, but they're

3:25

like... There are individual chapters

3:27

throughout different cities. We

3:29

work out of Portland, which is

3:31

the founding chapter and also the

3:33

largest one. Some of the

3:36

language I'll say that is like used from

3:38

the website and from like the mission statement that

3:40

really encompasses. what our

3:42

role is and also how it

3:44

is told to like our community

3:46

partnerships and the families and youth

3:48

that we work with is that

3:50

we are committing to youth when

3:53

they are typically around kindergarten age

3:55

level and they're being paired with

3:57

a mentor and they will have

3:59

a mentor until they graduate the program

4:01

so that usually ends up being

4:03

a total of 12 and a half

4:05

years. And that like

4:07

within that we were doing a lot

4:10

of like individualized care and support.

4:12

We work with them in the schools.

4:14

We work with them outside the

4:16

schools. We help them get into extracurriculars.

4:18

We help them with like social

4:20

emotional regulation, developing relationships with other youth

4:23

in the program. And really

4:25

just like being a consistently

4:27

reliable human being. And

4:29

one of the big like pillars of

4:31

our organization is the commitment to long

4:33

term, which sometimes can be an issue

4:35

when you are facing a lot of

4:37

high turnover as an organization. We

4:40

both have eight kids on

4:42

our roster as do most

4:45

mentors. And within that,

4:47

we have youth. I personally

4:49

have youth that have been assigned

4:51

to me that have just started

4:53

in the program, meaning that they

4:55

were like maybe first grade when

4:57

I was assigned to them. And

4:59

then I also have youth that

5:02

are middle school level that have

5:04

had several different mentors in the past.

5:06

some that have stayed there for maybe

5:08

a few years and like sometimes there's

5:11

ones that have been there for months. Yeah.

5:14

If I can add to that,

5:16

the kids we work

5:18

with, they're enrolled into

5:21

the program because they

5:23

have some risk factors in

5:25

their lives that would lead them to

5:27

needing a little bit of extra

5:29

support and help. So we work with

5:31

a lot of kids. that

5:34

come from immigrant families,

5:36

from families that have,

5:38

you know, single parent

5:41

households, foster care,

5:43

families and kids, kids

5:45

that like, unfortunately,

5:48

are likely to face some

5:50

challenges that our society and

5:52

the way it's built up

5:54

will deal to them. And

5:57

our goal is to help

5:59

them through those challenges just be

6:01

there for them so

6:03

that they have a

6:06

chance of, you know,

6:08

graduating high school or

6:10

entering adulthood without having,

6:12

you know, having had

6:14

kids or facing like

6:17

the justice system. It's

6:19

kids that we love

6:21

dearly that we

6:23

work with in a similar way

6:25

as like, you know, a program

6:27

like Big Brothers, Big Sisters. But

6:30

we are paid mentors,

6:32

which is the big difference,

6:35

right? We're not volunteer

6:37

based. We are employees, basically

6:39

social workers for all of

6:41

the families that we work with. It's

6:43

honestly like it's a great

6:45

job. And I think right

6:47

now, especially like super necessary

6:50

because things are falling apart. Yeah.

6:52

Yeah. And

6:54

yeah, just adding like

6:56

one. that made me think of how

6:59

within the work like I think

7:01

social work is a very apt choice

7:03

of words because we are paired

7:05

with the youth and it doesn't like

7:07

stop there like we work like

7:09

we work with the families we also

7:12

work with like the siblings too

7:14

because sometimes you'll have a youth that

7:16

maybe is the only child in

7:18

that family that for whatever reason got

7:20

a mentor and then you support all

7:22

I mean it's a choice but

7:25

But I would say that most mentors

7:27

definitely opt in to being there

7:29

for siblings and family members in the

7:31

household and making sure that they're

7:33

also showing up for the caregivers to

7:35

help them create a loving home. Yeah.

7:38

And I mean, you know, I think

7:40

that you can you can look at this

7:43

and see how it's supposed to work structurally. And,

7:45

you know, you were talking about like, I

7:47

mean, this is supposed to be a

7:50

like over a decade

7:52

long commitment to these kids. right

7:54

that ideally you're working with the same person

7:56

and you know you're forming really deep

7:58

emotional attachments because you can't not do that

8:01

if you're doing this kind

8:03

of work but then

8:05

also you know in order for that

8:07

to work and I think this is you know you

8:09

can see this to the outside is like in

8:11

order for this to work this has to be a

8:13

job that you could stay really do for a

8:15

decade, right? Yeah, which

8:21

I will say we do and I

8:23

want to do I want to give

8:25

so many props to one of our

8:27

mentors who has stayed for 12 years

8:29

and has graduated their youth. But

8:32

of all of our

8:34

co -workers, I believe it's only

8:36

one that has currently been able

8:38

to do that and has stayed

8:40

there as long as I have. Yeah.

8:43

And the truth of the fact, for any

8:45

job, 12 and a half years is

8:47

a really long time, right? I mean,

8:49

six years is a really long time.

8:53

with this job, we're like,

8:55

we're an emotional sponge

8:57

for a lot of

8:59

things, right? So our

9:01

kids go through everything

9:04

that you could imagine. And

9:06

within that, like everything good

9:08

and everything bad that you

9:10

could imagine. And our job,

9:12

a lot of times is

9:15

like, we can't solve the

9:17

things that are affecting these

9:19

kids, but we can

9:21

take in some of

9:23

those negative feelings and

9:25

that grief, that anger,

9:27

we can take it in

9:29

and almost dissolve it a

9:31

little bit, right? But within

9:34

that, it can affect

9:36

us so much. And

9:39

that's where, yeah, the sustainability

9:41

part of 12 a half

9:43

years in this job, that

9:45

is a lot. And we

9:47

need a lot for that

9:50

to... at all be

9:52

possible. Yeah, I

9:54

mean, there's this way

9:56

in which you're effectively... What

9:58

this job is, is you're

10:01

the person who is trying to

10:03

mitigate the impact of literally

10:05

all of the structural systems of

10:08

violence that exist in this entire

10:10

country, and how they're

10:12

just targeted down on these

10:14

kids, and your job is

10:16

to try to... protect them

10:18

as much as possible. And that's

10:20

unbelievable amount of physical

10:23

and emotional labor. And then

10:25

also, I don't

10:27

know, it seems pretty bad that there's

10:29

only been one co -worker who's been able

10:31

to graduate their kids. And

10:34

just to clarify for history,

10:36

that's been in our time there. Yeah, yeah.

10:38

There'll be other I don't know if

10:40

over the 30 years, I hope that other

10:42

people have. But yeah, in recent years,

10:44

it's only been the one. And

10:47

also, yeah, this is a

10:49

job where you are not necessarily

10:51

able to undo the systems

10:53

at play, but trying to support

10:55

them. And we,

10:57

as mentors, are

11:00

inevitably also facing those

11:02

systems against ourselves. And

11:04

one of the reasons that

11:06

I think people gravitate towards

11:08

this job. Is there empathy because

11:10

they have those shared experiences? One

11:13

of the things that is kind

11:15

of heavy in the culture of

11:17

friends is being asked your why

11:20

when you start. Like

11:22

why did you choose friends? And for

11:24

a lot of people it is because of

11:26

wanting to be the person that they

11:28

needed when they were going through those periods

11:30

of time. So there's bound

11:32

to be a lot of reactivation

11:34

of feelings inside yourself that I

11:36

think we all, I want to

11:39

say, every mentor I've worked with

11:41

has done an incredible job of

11:43

handling that and taking good care of

11:45

themselves. But it

11:47

is definitely something that takes

11:49

a lot of regulation. I

11:53

think empathy is one of the greatest

11:55

skills in this job, but it also, yeah,

11:58

it also then leads to us needing

12:00

greater needs of self -care and things like that.

12:02

Yeah. And like, I mean, I guess like to

12:04

put this in perspective for like people

12:06

listening to this is like, okay,

12:08

your job is to be the person

12:10

like in the friend group who

12:12

like manages like when someone's like having

12:14

an emotional crisis, like you have

12:16

to like help them and deal with

12:18

it. And that is your job

12:20

for like eight kids. feel

12:23

like the worst shit in the world. Like,

12:26

Jesus Christ. Oh,

12:29

good Lord. It's

12:31

honestly like hearing

12:33

this, it's always really helpful to

12:35

hear someone's outside perspective of our

12:37

job, right? Because we get... So,

12:39

so into it, so into the

12:41

muck of like what this job

12:43

can be. And I think like

12:45

overall, like, like social work, it's

12:47

not just like our job, but

12:49

like I'm sure other social workers

12:51

and people in care industries, like

12:53

we have like continuous like vicarious

12:55

trauma that makes us

12:57

forget like how How

13:01

our job is sometimes and then

13:03

it's helpful to hear other people

13:05

mention it because it's like yeah

13:07

Wow, our job is kind of

13:09

crazy and the work we do

13:11

is like really important and really

13:13

important for society and also Yeah, like

13:16

it's hard. It's

13:18

hard work It's it's hard

13:20

and it doesn't like really have an end point

13:22

like we have the hours we work with

13:24

kids and then We have

13:26

the hours we think about them and

13:28

the things going on in their lives And

13:30

sometimes it's like sweet things like a

13:32

lot of times it's sweet things where I'll

13:34

see something and be like oh my

13:36

gosh You know who would love that and

13:38

like things like that are like oh

13:40

great idea or oh, let's go see this

13:42

movie and a lot of times it's

13:44

like worrying though too and Knowing that there

13:47

is there is only so many things

13:49

we can control and some things

13:51

we just have to be the

13:53

person that's there as they have to go

13:56

through something. Which yeah,

13:58

it's hard because we also obviously

14:00

like develop such loving relationships

14:02

with these kids. It's hard to

14:04

see kids that you care

14:06

about so much that sometimes the

14:08

most you can do is

14:10

just be there. Yeah, it

14:12

definitely is a job that like

14:14

to some degree is sort of always

14:16

with you. Yeah, we have a

14:19

joke about this with this job where

14:21

it's like If you do what

14:23

you love and you'll never be free

14:25

for a single second of your

14:27

entire life, it's because you're just always

14:29

on. Yeah, it's

14:31

so true. Yeah, as

14:33

you say this, I worked till like 9 30

14:35

last night because I was like, you know what?

14:37

I'm enjoying this so much taking out with my

14:39

guys. So I'm just going to keep working. Yeah.

14:42

Yeah. So speaking of

14:44

keeping working, we need to go to ads

14:47

and then we will come back and

14:49

talk about. the ways in which this job

14:51

that requires an incredible amount of structural

14:53

support to keep people there for like over

14:55

a decade is failing to do that. And

15:07

we are back. So,

15:09

okay, now that we've sort

15:12

of talked about what

15:14

this is, let's talk about

15:16

the actual union. Yeah.

15:21

So can you talk about sort of how

15:23

did organizing for this union start and what

15:25

were the sort of issues that could have

15:27

brought everyone to be like, okay, we need

15:29

to do this? Yeah, for

15:31

sure. So we

15:33

first brought about

15:35

our petition to

15:38

unionize in March

15:40

of 2023. So

15:42

that was two years ago, a

15:45

long time ago, right? The

15:48

work for unionization, obviously the

15:50

organizing behind it started like

15:52

much before that when I

15:54

first joined friends, it was

15:56

in September of 22. And

15:59

I knew that the work

16:01

had already been like happening

16:03

the summer before. What

16:05

was the catalyst was

16:07

post COVID A, obviously a

16:09

lot of people left

16:11

given what COVID did to

16:14

a lot of industries

16:16

and especially care work. But

16:18

then likewise, a lot

16:20

of people were fired and

16:22

where many would say like

16:24

fired without like a full

16:26

on like deep process that

16:29

included a program manager. who

16:31

was really listening to

16:33

friends and advocating for

16:35

the mentor role. And

16:37

they were let go, which spurred a

16:40

lot of people to want to start

16:42

organizing some of the issues that we

16:44

face, like the pay obviously, like within

16:46

social work in general and nonprofit work,

16:48

like it's never going to match up

16:50

and never going to really be

16:53

as good as like the cost of

16:55

living, especially here in Portland, but the

16:57

pay compared to like all of the

16:59

emotional work and all the work that

17:01

we do was just not there and

17:03

not sustainable. It's why

17:05

people were not like able to

17:07

stick around because frankly, we

17:09

were looking at the same issues

17:11

that our families were facing

17:13

of like, you know, food insecurity

17:15

and needing to like get

17:18

food stamps or like

17:20

needing like rental and like housing

17:22

assistance because our pay was just

17:24

not up to par. Those are

17:26

a few of the issues. Jess,

17:28

I don't know if you have

17:30

other thoughts. Yeah, I

17:33

think you touched on a lot of them.

17:35

I think it's hard to stay in this

17:37

job. If you are looking to have a

17:39

family, there's been issues with pay, with insurance,

17:42

with other sorts of things that

17:44

have led to mentors leaving rather

17:46

than like staying there, even if

17:48

they like really wanted to

17:50

stay there just wouldn't necessarily

17:52

allow for them to have

17:54

maybe like the life they

17:56

wanted and also just honoring

17:58

I think with like bereavement

18:00

leave and critical issue leave

18:02

has been areas that haven't

18:04

really been addressed. We

18:07

have had very tragic

18:09

things happen in our

18:11

working community with the

18:13

families and that have

18:15

drastically affected Yeah,

18:17

the well -being of mentors and staff members

18:19

alike. Yeah, and I mean,

18:21

you know, this is a job

18:24

that structurally is designed to be

18:26

a kind of like, like

18:28

again, if the goal is to

18:30

have one person from like kindergarten to

18:32

tell they like like a graduating

18:34

high school, right? Like

18:36

that is something that requires

18:39

like 1950s, 1960s style

18:41

fortism. Like you have one

18:43

job for decades. And

18:45

the only way you can do

18:47

that is if people are incredibly well

18:49

supported. And it's like the fact

18:52

that it's like, okay, you're trying to

18:54

do this, but you're not paying

18:56

people enough money to fucking afford food.

18:58

Like, what the hell? Jesus

19:01

Christ. Oh

19:03

my God. Yeah,

19:05

or even, I mean, it's still

19:07

something that we're fighting, but like

19:10

our work. place doesn't provide health

19:12

insurance for dependents, which I think

19:14

is really ironic, giving how much

19:16

we care for kids. And then

19:18

some of our mentors and other

19:20

co -workers that have kids have

19:22

to spend so much money on

19:24

health insurance for their own personal

19:27

kids. Friends of some of the

19:29

kids, apparently. That's how this works.

19:32

The kids, they take. Yeah.

19:34

And honestly, big

19:37

picture thinking, the reason why

19:39

we Like started

19:41

this whole unionizing project was

19:43

because we care so

19:45

much about our kids, right?

19:48

Like I when I first started

19:50

working at friends like I I

19:53

think was the first mask mentor

19:55

to be hired in a fairly

19:57

long time after a lot of

19:59

firings of other mass mentors and

20:01

two of the youth that But

20:03

actually, it's more than two of

20:05

the youth, but the first two

20:08

youth that I was matched up

20:10

with, they hadn't had a mentor

20:12

for over two years, which

20:14

is a really long time.

20:16

Like when you are five,

20:18

six years old and you're

20:20

used to one person consistently

20:23

picking you up every single

20:25

week and hanging out with

20:27

you and spending time with

20:29

you for several hours, four,

20:32

six, over seven

20:34

years and then just like next

20:36

day, next week, maybe even

20:39

that same day you find out

20:41

like oh you no longer

20:43

have a mentor and you're not

20:45

going to have a mentor

20:47

for two more years because people

20:49

keep leaving, people aren't

20:51

wanting to apply for this job

20:53

because the pay isn't high enough,

20:55

right? That then like creates like

20:57

a lot of issues with the

21:00

kids that we're dealing with. It's

21:02

not like we are these like

21:04

saviors or like anything along those

21:06

lines, right? But when someone has

21:08

consistent support and then that support

21:10

is lost for a long time,

21:12

especially when you're a young kid

21:14

where it's been the majority of

21:16

your life you've been having that

21:18

consistent support, that then creates a

21:21

lot of trust issues and overall

21:23

attachment issues that youth could face. For

21:26

me that was the main

21:28

thing like working with these kids

21:30

and having to like regain

21:32

that trust was something that's like

21:34

still to this day is

21:36

like really emotionally like daunting and

21:38

I like I will keep

21:40

saying this I love my kids

21:42

so much like I like

21:44

can't stop thinking about them and

21:46

I want to be with

21:48

my kids until they graduate, which

21:51

would mean me staying at

21:53

this job for another eight years,

21:55

which it's a long time,

21:57

right? But I want to do

21:59

that. So I want to,

22:01

you know, get paid, have time

22:03

off when one of my, sadly,

22:06

this is something that did occur

22:08

where you've passed away that I worked

22:10

with and like didn't have time

22:12

off to like really grieve. Hard

22:15

stuff and I just want to

22:17

be able to stay there till they're

22:20

done with the program Just like

22:22

a litany of horrors. It's like one

22:24

it's like You know what when

22:26

there is like it's it's not you

22:28

know, like turnover in a normal

22:30

job sucks But this is like when

22:32

there's turnover because people can't afford

22:34

to live their lives It's like you're

22:36

just like ripping a hole in

22:38

these kids like the fabric of their

22:40

social lives and then also it's

22:42

like Yeah, one of these kids that

22:45

is literally your job to care

22:47

for dies. Did you just have to

22:49

fucking go to work the next

22:51

day? like it is

22:53

so hideous and it's just

22:55

like yeah, yeah Yeah, yeah,

22:57

no like it makes sense

22:59

that like Yeah, people are

23:01

organizing because it's like, you

23:03

know, like this organization is

23:05

just Systemically failing both the

23:07

people they're trying to help

23:09

and the people whose job

23:11

it is to like help

23:14

them and yeah Yeah Yeah,

23:16

I think one of the things

23:18

that is like hardest to

23:20

see while like working there is

23:22

the ways in which this

23:24

like job that you do like

23:26

that like I care so

23:29

much about and love doing but

23:31

like seeing this like institution

23:33

in a way be like part

23:35

be part of the problem

23:37

because if we aren't like having

23:39

it so that employees feel supported

23:42

in the way that they need

23:44

to like life happens sometimes people leave

23:46

and like move and get a

23:48

different job for various reasons but a

23:51

lot of the times it's it's

23:53

because it's not sustainable and it's really

23:55

hard to leave and like it's

23:57

a heartbreaking thing because I like I

23:59

want to graduate many of my

24:01

youth and it is something that I

24:03

think about of like how feasible

24:05

is that like I want to do

24:08

it and like also okay then

24:10

that means I got to be frugal

24:12

and all these other ways or

24:14

etc and Yeah, and working with youth

24:16

that have already kind of experienced

24:18

loss and wanting to continue to show

24:20

up for them the job itself

24:23

feels so sacred and like I feel

24:25

so lucky to be in these

24:27

kids lives and I think just a

24:29

lot of the turnover has been

24:31

out of like lack of sustainability for

24:33

Yourself like for your well -being. Um,

24:36

yeah Yeah, and I mean,

24:38

the turnover numbers were

24:40

pretty wild. I think one

24:42

time we calculated it

24:44

and mentors were, it was

24:46

like a 40 -something percent

24:48

turnover rate for mentors. Yeah,

24:51

and a lot of that

24:53

happened because in this two

24:56

-year time period where we've

24:58

been fighting for a contract, they

25:01

also froze

25:03

wage increases. I've

25:06

had the same wage for the past two

25:08

years, two and a half years that I've been

25:10

working here. And in

25:12

that same time period, inflation has

25:14

been pretty crazy and rent

25:17

for me has gone up times.

25:19

it's about to get worse. It's

25:21

about to get so much worse. Yeah.

25:25

Yeah. Which, which, you know, gladly

25:27

now we have this fight and we're

25:29

at the two year mark and

25:31

not at the zero year mark

25:33

and not looking forward to two more

25:35

years of doing this. But yeah,

25:37

it's been hard to sustain this

25:39

when everything is increasing in price and

25:42

our wages are completely stagnant. Yeah.

25:45

Yeah. So let's take one more ad

25:48

break and then we will come back

25:50

to talk about, yeah, how unionization efforts

25:52

are going and yeah. We

26:03

are back. Yes, let's talk

26:05

about how this campaign is

26:07

going. So you said you've

26:09

been in bargaining for like

26:11

two years? So

26:13

we had our petition

26:15

for recognition on

26:17

March 23rd, 2023. So

26:20

that was over

26:22

two years ago. And

26:24

then our employer

26:26

didn't formally recognize us.

26:28

But through the process

26:31

of like voting, we

26:33

got over 93%. Wow. That's

26:36

incredible. That's

26:38

incredible. It's super great.

26:40

And it's also like, wow, we all really

26:42

needed this. Yeah.

26:47

And there were some other barriers,

26:49

including not being formally recognized. We

26:51

also had management contest a

26:54

few positions that I believe

26:56

most, if not all,

26:58

we were able to successfully

27:00

have be part of our

27:02

unit. And then we didn't

27:04

have our first bargaining session

27:06

until September of 2023. So

27:08

almost six months, I think,

27:10

if I did the math

27:12

right, after we formally presented

27:14

our letter for recognition. Yeah. And

27:17

like throughout that process. So now it

27:19

has been like, Jesus is quite good

27:21

at keeping track of it. But I

27:23

think as of today, we're about at

27:27

580 days of bargaining God.

27:29

Yeah Yeah, it's been

27:31

a long one and it

27:33

hasn't been it's been

27:35

like also a choppy journey

27:37

where there has been

27:39

delays in Scheduling delays in

27:41

just getting different articles

27:43

back in time one of

27:46

the biggest ones obviously

27:48

was compensation and I think

27:50

I can't quite remember

27:52

the period of time but

27:54

we presented it and

27:56

a year ago, I think

27:58

maybe. Oh my god.

28:00

I could be wrong. And

28:03

it took several, several,

28:05

several months for us to

28:07

get anything back from

28:09

management, which, yeah, was a

28:11

big bummer amongst other

28:13

things. It sucks. It

28:15

sucks. And obviously

28:18

that's the one that we have

28:20

yet to finalize as we're talking

28:22

right now. Yeah, it is. Insurance

28:24

and compensation are still our

28:26

last two articles left. Yeah.

28:29

And some of the

28:31

difficult things, I mean,

28:34

when you are working on

28:36

a project, I

28:38

wouldn't be surprised given really

28:41

when these conversations started, if

28:43

we're looking at over 900

28:45

or 1 ,000 days of really

28:47

talking about this, but then

28:49

when you're dealing with bargaining

28:52

for 580 days.

28:55

Like it's exhausting. It is so

28:57

exhausting. We have regular meetings

28:59

that we attend to that our

29:01

bargaining meetings were specifically scheduled

29:03

outside of work hours so that

29:05

like the people on our

29:07

bargaining team and other union members

29:09

would have to put in

29:11

the extra time outside of our

29:13

40 hour week. Yeah.

29:17

And within that, like

29:19

the hardest part

29:21

is when you directly

29:24

confront your managers and your

29:26

bosses about the rights

29:28

and the things that you

29:30

need. So much of

29:32

it boils down to respect,

29:34

right? And your respect is

29:36

like a worker and the value that you

29:38

have as a worker in your organization. And

29:41

when there is the pushback on

29:43

that, it honestly is

29:45

Like for me at

29:47

times was debilitating, right? When

29:50

you're doing this work

29:52

and your workplace is stretching

29:54

things out for so

29:56

long. And you're pouring your

29:58

heart out on your kids, like

30:00

really trying to do the best.

30:03

That response from our

30:05

supervisors and managers,

30:08

like it really was

30:10

hard. It was hard for me. It was

30:12

hard for other union organizers in our workplace. And

30:14

it was hard for all of our workers

30:16

where we started thinking like, dang, what

30:18

is the value that we have in this

30:20

workplace? What is the value that we intrinsically

30:22

have in the work that we're doing with

30:24

our kids? And

30:26

it's a lot when you're facing all

30:29

these systems that our kids are facing

30:31

and taking those things in and then

30:33

are trying to change those systems, finally

30:35

able to try to change those systems.

30:37

And we learned that, oh, wait, the

30:39

place that we're working is actually part

30:41

of these systems too. And it's

30:43

doing the same things that we're like

30:45

fighting to have our kids like have

30:47

better lives. Like we're facing it right

30:49

now from inside the house. Yeah.

30:52

Yeah. I wanted to add in

30:54

to, yeah, very much realizing that

30:56

like our management is also in

30:58

a way operating, you know, maybe

31:00

like a corporation, which isn't the

31:02

hope you would have for a

31:04

nonprofit. And one of the steps

31:07

we had to take as

31:09

a union was filing a

31:11

UOP, so unfair labor practice, which

31:14

cited, like I had mentioned

31:16

before, like delays in scheduling

31:18

and also regressive bargaining, which

31:20

just means that like the

31:22

way in which they were

31:24

presenting things would have lessened

31:27

our like quality of conditions.

31:29

So definitely not what you want to be getting, not

31:32

what you want to be handed

31:34

across from the bargaining table. Yeah.

31:37

Yeah, yeah. Yeah, within this

31:39

process, they were currently salaried

31:41

workers, but they tried to change

31:43

us to hourly workers. Oh

31:46

my God. Yeah. Which

31:48

again, like, we're always working, you

31:50

know, we're always working. So

31:53

unless you want to pay me for

31:55

24 hours. You

31:59

know, talking about like, yeah, that they're behaving like

32:01

a corporation is like, oh, yeah This is exactly

32:03

what like by employer did to me which is

32:05

like like one of like one of the largest

32:07

media companies in the world and they dragged out

32:09

negotiations for two years and Like, you know, you're

32:11

talking about this sort of like just like oh,

32:13

they're like the filling of disrespect where they're just

32:16

not getting stuff back to you And it's like

32:18

I remember, you know, like we'd be sitting there

32:20

for a bargaining meeting and they wouldn't and they

32:22

would be an hour late And they'd be an

32:24

hour late because they hadn't like bothered to beforehand

32:26

spend time drafting out what their responses were going

32:28

to be So they were frantically trying to get

32:30

it done before we were there. And we're all

32:32

just sitting there for literally an hour waiting for

32:34

them to show up. And it's like, okay, there

32:36

are people in this unit whose job is to

32:38

stand next to car bombs, like, and you can't

32:40

show up on time to here, to this, to

32:42

this meeting that you have known was going to

32:44

happen for weeks. Like, it's just,

32:46

I say this every single episode is

32:48

like, this is an incredibly common YouTube

32:50

listening tactic is draw out the first

32:52

contract because that's, that's like the second

32:54

point where unions fail after like the,

32:57

after you get like, recognition

32:59

votes is like here. Yeah, for sure.

33:01

You know, like, I mean, I think

33:03

there's something that we expect corporations to

33:05

do this. But it's like, okay, this

33:07

is an NGO that's like the point

33:09

of which is supposed to be like

33:11

helping underprivileged, underprivileged youth. And then

33:14

they're like, we're going to turn around and

33:16

we're going to screw over different underprivileged youth.

33:19

Yeah, it sucks. Yeah. And

33:21

I think that's like, for me, one of the

33:23

things that just like mess with my mind

33:25

the most is that like, We're

33:27

not selling a product, right?

33:29

We're not trying to like

33:31

get revenue or anything along

33:33

those lines, right? So like

33:35

our job is a job

33:37

that we actually like fully

33:39

love and like want to

33:41

stick around like not not

33:43

just for our own like

33:46

financial piece and our own

33:48

financial security, we want to

33:50

stick around this job because

33:52

we care about the job.

33:54

That's not to like other

33:56

businesses and other workplaces that

33:58

unionize. A lot of times

34:00

people want to do that

34:02

because they want financial security.

34:04

I think for a lot

34:06

of NGOs, nonprofits and care

34:08

work, we unionize because we

34:10

want to stick around both

34:12

because of financial security, right?

34:14

But also because we just

34:16

like care so much about

34:18

the work that we're doing

34:21

and to be faced with

34:23

actions by our workplace that,

34:25

you know, tried to dissuade

34:27

us from that, tried to

34:29

like, you know, in a

34:31

sense, like it felt like

34:33

stopping us from wanting to

34:35

stick around. Like that,

34:37

again, really hard, really hard. And I

34:39

think like a really like

34:41

psychologically hard part that comes

34:43

with unionizing in the care

34:45

work field in the like

34:47

nonprofit space. Yeah, like this

34:49

isn't a job that people

34:51

are going to take for

34:53

the money. But we do

34:55

need to be receiving like

34:57

equitable pay and benefits so

34:59

that we stay at this

35:01

job. Like this by all

35:03

means and like still like

35:06

this is the same way

35:08

I feel about it to

35:10

this day. I remember reading

35:12

the little job description for

35:14

this role and was like,

35:16

oh, this is, dude, this

35:18

is my dream job. This

35:20

is 100 % what I want

35:22

to spend my energy towards.

35:26

Yeah, I think that's a huge

35:28

part of why we were able

35:30

to get like that 93 % and

35:33

to have also like routine support

35:35

for different actions and stuff is

35:37

just because we have people that

35:39

care so much about wanting to

35:41

stick around. Yeah. And

35:44

that's the thing that NGOs, you know, and

35:46

you see this in abortion work, you see

35:48

this in like, you see this in nursing,

35:50

you see this in all of these different

35:52

fields, like that's the thing that these NGOs

35:54

use to exploit people. is, you

35:56

know, like, I mean, is the

35:59

basic human empathy and love and care

36:01

that we have for the people

36:03

who are caring for it. And these

36:05

people are like, aha, look at

36:07

this. Aha, these people, they care about

36:09

the thing that they're doing. We

36:11

can underpay them and overwork them. It's

36:13

like, why is there

36:15

just a work like this? What

36:19

a terrible way to

36:21

design an economic system. It's

36:23

just, good Lord. Oh,

36:26

let's talk a little bit about like, you know,

36:28

what kinds of organizing things you all have been able

36:30

to do and the kinds of things you've been

36:32

able to accomplish by, you know, working together even in

36:34

these really kind of like, I

36:36

don't know, structurally difficult conditions.

36:39

Yeah, we've had, um, we've

36:42

had a multitude of different actions

36:44

over the past, you know, over

36:46

the past 580 days. Um, I

36:48

think one of our One

36:51

of our biggest ones by far,

36:53

which was I think also was

36:55

just one of our most beautiful

36:57

in a way was November of

36:59

last year we did an info

37:01

picket and it was one of

37:03

those things too where it Was

37:05

very well planned out, but also

37:07

even with the best of planning

37:09

midway through it. We had a

37:11

shift location based off of just

37:13

changing information we were getting and

37:15

we had One of our

37:17

little bits is because our

37:19

union is called fun. A

37:21

lot of our posters

37:24

were SpongeBob themed, so

37:26

instead of imagination, it's

37:28

compensation. And

37:31

I think it's indicative of

37:34

also how much people that

37:36

work with us are playful

37:38

and sweet and are good

37:40

at our jobs of working

37:42

with kids. Yeah,

37:46

we had very high turnout.

37:48

I think we had 40 -something

37:50

people within our own organization

37:52

that showed up for that.

37:54

We've done smaller actions too

37:56

by just asking for community support.

37:59

We've had caregivers write letters

38:01

of support to different people

38:03

in management. We've also done

38:05

a few pack the rooms for

38:07

bargaining sessions, especially when there have

38:09

been times that have felt like there's

38:11

been some semblance of stalling. Yeah,

38:13

those are just some of them. Hey, Steve, chime

38:15

in with others. Yeah, within that.

38:17

And I think an interesting

38:19

thing about nonprofits, our revenue

38:21

comes from donors. So we have

38:23

to play this fun game of,

38:25

OK, how do we communicate with

38:27

our donors so that we make

38:29

sure that they know that you

38:32

know, this is part of like

38:34

what they're donating to, but then

38:37

within that also like, you know,

38:39

ask for money as well, right?

38:41

Because we do want, you know,

38:43

better pay and better benefits, right?

38:45

So we've contacted donors and we'll

38:47

still plan to do that

38:49

with both that ask of like support the union

38:51

and support our organization, right? Because the thing

38:54

that we care about the most is the work

38:56

that we do with our kids and for

38:58

that to happen. We want

39:00

our organization to like stay afloat,

39:02

truly, right? Yeah, some

39:04

of the wins that we've

39:06

gotten, I mentioned earlier

39:08

that they were trying to

39:10

have us be hourly workers.

39:13

And that was a big

39:15

campaign that we were fighting

39:17

back on for a long

39:19

time. It's also what

39:21

precipitated the ULP filing. I

39:24

made too many buttons.

39:27

That's it. Um,

39:29

you could never have to anybody

39:31

truly, um, that said I work

39:33

40 plus hours a week because

39:35

one of the people on the

39:37

bargaining team for management at the

39:39

bargaining table asked if we even

39:41

work 40 hours a week. Um,

39:44

while we were talking about this

39:46

and that's like one of those

39:48

instances that I mean, like, yeah,

39:50

wow, that's like a little disrespectful

39:52

and like really bites. So we

39:54

all were wearing these pins regularly. We,

39:57

you know, we signed a strike.

39:59

pledge where we had like 80

40:01

something percent of the unit say

40:03

that like if we came to

40:05

voting for a strike people would

40:07

strike and the big win was

40:09

like okay great we get to

40:11

stay a salaried workers because they

40:13

walk back on that on that

40:15

threat we are time off We

40:17

have a time off contract or

40:19

agreement now that like some of

40:22

my co -workers that have been around

40:24

a long time once the contract

40:26

gets ratified, they'll have like two

40:28

more weeks of time off. Hell

40:30

yeah. Hell yeah. Because they haven't,

40:32

they've been around for seven years

40:34

and they're still at the same

40:36

amount of time off basically that

40:38

I'm at and that I've been

40:40

at since the beginning. Yeah. And

40:42

when it comes to wages, like

40:44

we're still Figuring

40:46

that out, but some of the

40:48

gains that we are potentially looking

40:51

at is like incredible like I

40:53

looked at the numbers yesterday of

40:55

like what hopefully given like where

40:57

we're at right now in in

40:59

the agreements like well I would

41:01

hopefully get and I straight up.

41:04

like teared up looking at the

41:06

number because it felt like such

41:08

a big change in my financial

41:10

status right and yesterday like as

41:12

i said i worked on 9

41:14

30 pm with my kids probably

41:17

because i had this like massive

41:19

like weight of you know this

41:21

financial doom that i'm looking at

41:23

somewhat lifted at the hope of

41:25

the wins that we might get

41:28

from this contract. So

41:30

it's been incredibly hard, incredibly long,

41:32

way too long, and all

41:34

of it is going to be

41:36

so worth it, right? I

41:38

hope that's something that the

41:40

listeners really get, that this

41:42

is hard work, but in

41:44

the end, is the change

41:46

that we were hoping for.

41:49

Yeah. Recently,

41:52

one of the things that we did

41:54

do just like a run through of

41:56

just to kind of boost morale since

41:58

the bargaining has gone on for so

42:00

long was compile all the wins that

42:02

we have so far just through TAs.

42:04

So still tentative, but yeah, it did

42:06

map out a lot of huge things.

42:08

One of the things we do a

42:11

lot in this job is drive and

42:13

we don't have many things in policy

42:15

about. Cleaning or

42:17

repairs when something happens in your car

42:19

with the youth like say they

42:21

throw up It happens with kids like

42:23

that isn't necessarily something that would

42:25

have been like covered We would have

42:27

had to just pay for that

42:29

cleaning ourselves and like mileage is a

42:32

huge thing where one of our

42:34

Potential like big wins is that we'll

42:36

get like full mileage covered Rather

42:38

than having to like deduct time from

42:40

like this illusion of having an

42:42

office where we would have to minus

42:44

some mileage in whatever way

42:46

made sense with where our buildings

42:49

were located, despite even

42:51

if our kids were like totally somewhere

42:53

else where we were picking them up. It

42:55

definitely wasn't like the most sensical way

42:57

for us to be like being fully

43:00

reimbursed for what we were doing. And

43:02

those are all huge wins

43:04

that we do have. Like obviously,

43:07

compensation and insurance are two of

43:09

the biggest that we're still

43:11

working on. I think recently, almost

43:13

within this week, we've started

43:16

to tip in a way that

43:18

feels like we may be

43:20

close to having a contract soon,

43:22

which I do want to say, as

43:24

inspiration to everybody out there that

43:27

works for a non -profit, unionize

43:29

and you know what? It

43:31

might farewell for you. I have hope

43:33

for everybody. Right now,

43:35

I think a lot of our Like

43:38

a lot of my co -workers are starting

43:40

to have hope again, because I do

43:42

think, like you said, it is totally

43:44

a manipulation tool to have it drawn

43:46

out so long. And yeah, it is

43:48

exhausting to be basically stalled in your

43:50

wage for two and a half years.

43:53

But we are gaining some traction

43:55

again, which I do think is

43:57

something that we're still being cautious

43:59

with just because... now it does

44:02

feel like management is working with

44:04

us a little bit more, but

44:06

I also think that there are

44:08

Reasonings around that like we're about

44:10

to have in a few weeks

44:12

our biggest Fundraiser for our work

44:14

because like Hsu said we are

44:16

majority donor based and I do

44:18

think there's an appeal to management

44:20

to have a contract by then

44:22

Yeah, it adds to the whole

44:24

we're doing good work and we

44:26

treat our employees well. I hope

44:28

that that is something then that

44:30

is fulfilled by them in an

44:33

honest way, not just a superficial

44:35

way, because we are still pushing

44:37

for a little bit more right

44:39

now and have bargaining coming up

44:41

next week. I'm really

44:43

hoping that what they're showing us

44:45

isn't just performative, that we

44:47

really might be able to get

44:49

to a point where there

44:51

is something that is truly good

44:54

for us, because we're all

44:56

ready for a contract. Yeah,

44:59

as you know, as someone

45:01

who got our contract like it

45:03

doesn't it doesn't magically solve

45:05

everything but like my god It

45:07

is absolutely worth it. Yeah

45:09

Okay, so how can people support

45:11

y 'all both sort of locally

45:13

here and then just like

45:15

broader because most people are not

45:17

here Honestly, most of our

45:20

like People in like management positions

45:22

information is public if you

45:24

want to email them in support

45:26

go for it Also just

45:28

like encouraging either your workplace if

45:30

you work in kind of

45:32

a social work setting or like

45:34

you know if you know

45:36

people that are because this

45:38

whole field of work takes such

45:40

a toll on people and it is

45:42

the most necessary work. And I

45:44

think it's really easy to fall into

45:46

the mindset of I'm doing this

45:48

for the greater good, not, you know,

45:50

not for money, not for these

45:53

things, but like you also deserve to

45:55

feel okay and taken care of

45:57

and like have the things you need

45:59

to be saying. Yeah.

46:01

Hey, say something else. Do you want to

46:03

add? Yeah, I

46:05

mean, I We

46:08

would add that we have

46:10

an Instagram, right? That's friends,

46:12

pdx union network. It's a

46:14

mouthful, but we'll link the

46:16

inscription. Yeah, great. And

46:18

then within that, if

46:21

you're in Portland, make

46:23

sure to follow us and pay

46:25

attention to what we're posting because

46:27

hopefully we do not have to

46:29

get to a point in striking,

46:31

especially The place that

46:33

we're at right now with our contract

46:36

but in truth like we're looking

46:38

at 580 days and that is quite

46:40

a long time Yeah, and then

46:42

also like if if listeners do have

46:44

the ability to donate if they

46:46

could donate some funds for friends of

46:48

the children Portland and somehow in

46:51

their notes be like I support the

46:53

union like I think that could

46:55

also be a really interesting way to

46:57

show the support that like our Supporters

47:00

have like for both the work

47:02

that we're doing on the youth level,

47:05

but then also like in the

47:07

union side of things too. There's

47:09

been a lot of like communication of

47:11

like, oh, this is really going to impact

47:13

like. the development side

47:15

of our organization and like

47:17

all of the things that

47:19

like our fundraising team is

47:21

gonna have to do to

47:23

like meet these, which again,

47:26

I think that would be

47:28

more true if like

47:30

our executive director wasn't making

47:32

like. what like five

47:34

times as much money as I am.

47:37

Jesus Christ. Yeah. But

47:39

yeah, showing that support like it

47:41

doesn't have to be a lot,

47:43

but showing our our bosses just

47:45

how much like the populace like

47:47

is supporting our unionization efforts like

47:49

that power to really don't too.

47:51

And then also like it impacts

47:53

our kids like our kids like

47:55

that's the truth of it all

47:57

like I want my kids

47:59

to have the best life that they could

48:01

possibly have. And sadly, we

48:03

live in a world where

48:06

money really dictates that. Yeah.

48:10

Yeah. Yeah. So

48:12

we will have links in the

48:14

description to all of that. And

48:16

yeah, thank you to both so much

48:18

for coming on the show. And I

48:21

hope you win. And yeah, I hope

48:23

you get to go back to caring

48:25

for these kids and also while not

48:27

having to worry about like being able

48:29

to live your lives. Thank you so

48:31

much. Yeah. Yeah,

48:33

thank you so much for having us. Yeah,

48:36

of course. Honestly, it's been

48:38

great talking about the work because it

48:40

is it is really important work

48:42

and I'm happy we get to do

48:44

it. Yeah, it's it's wonderful. And

48:46

yeah, and so this is yeah, this

48:48

this is been a good happen here.

48:50

And yeah, I'd also go unionize your

48:53

workplace. You can do it. I guarantee

48:55

it. It

49:13

is Ryan and I have a question

49:15

for you. What do you do when

49:18

you win? when you are you a Like

49:20

are you a fist-pumper? hand clap or a

49:22

high fiver. If you want to hone

49:24

in on those winning moves, check

49:26

out If you Choose from hundreds of social

49:28

those games for your chance to redeem

49:30

serious cash prizes. There are new

49:33

game releases of social daily bonuses. So don't

49:35

wait. Start having the most fun redeem

49:37

serious cash prizes. There by Chumba Casino, no

49:39

purchase necessary. weekly plus, prohibited by law.

49:41

18 plus terms and conditions apply. So

49:44

good. Your bill, ladies? I got

49:46

it. No, I got it. Seriously,

49:49

I insist. I insisted first. Oh,

49:51

don't be silly. You don't be

49:53

silly. People with the Wells Fargo

49:55

Active Cash Credit Card prefer to

49:57

pay because they earn unlimited 2

49:59

% cash back on purchases. OK.

50:01

Rock, paper, scissors for it. Rock,

50:03

paper, scissors, shoot! No! The

50:06

Wells Fargo Active Cash

50:08

Credit Card. Visit wellsfargo.com slash

50:10

activecash terms apply. Does

50:12

this podcast make you happy? Of

50:14

course it does. That's why you're

50:16

here. But it only comes out

50:19

once a week. For happiness every

50:21

night? You need Adam and Eve.

50:23

Yes, I'm talking about sex toys.

50:26

It's cool. It's cool. You have earbuds in, right? Adam

50:29

and Eve, America's most trusted source

50:31

for adult products, has been making people

50:33

very happy for over 50 years.

50:35

with thousands of toys for both men

50:37

and women. of toys for both men and women. Just

50:39

go to Adam and eve.com now

50:41

and enter code I heart for

50:43

50% off almost any one item.

50:45

Plus free discrete shipping. That's Adam

50:47

and eve.com code I heart for

50:49

50% off. Company. And

50:55

no matter what the day holds, we

50:57

come to the Today Show for all

50:59

of it. When things are tough, we

51:01

talk about it. When there's something to

51:03

figure out, we dig into it. And

51:05

when there's joy, we celebrate it. Because

51:07

today is where it's all happening. We

51:09

get the best start to every

51:11

morning because we started together. Watch the

51:13

Today Show with Savannah Guthrie and

51:16

Craig Melvin weekdays at 7 a .m.

51:18

on NBC. Hello

51:24

and welcome to the show. It's

51:26

me, James, today, and I am

51:28

joined by Garrison Davis. Hi, Garrison.

51:30

Hello. Hello. Garrison has just said some

51:33

words about something that's happening on

51:35

social media that I don't understand. And

51:38

it's made me feel very old. This

51:40

was happening today in my world. It's

51:42

very sad. We're gathered

51:44

here today to talk about the

51:46

earthquake in Myanmar, right? I

51:48

think most of you will probably have

51:50

been made aware of the earthquake. It's

51:53

somewhat odd that Corporate media has really

51:55

not reported on the revolution in any

51:58

substantial way since 2021. But the earthquake

52:00

apparently justified a lot of networks sending

52:02

people to Myanmar for the first time.

52:04

Very amusingly, people DMing me on Blue

52:06

Sky and Twitter asking how to get

52:08

a visa from the Burmese Hunter, which

52:10

is not a thing I have ever

52:13

done. The last communication I had with

52:15

them came in the form of a

52:17

car bomb that they set off near

52:19

to a place where we were. If

52:22

you're not aware, the earthquake happened

52:25

on the 28th of March this year,

52:27

just before one in the afternoon. It

52:30

was the biggest earthquake in Myanmar

52:32

since 1912, and it registered 7

52:34

.7 on the Richter scale, which

52:36

is huge. Because it's very

52:38

hard for foreign journalists to get

52:40

a visa to enter Myanmar, I

52:42

love the initial reporting focused on

52:44

Bangkok and the damage done in

52:46

Thailand. But the episode

52:48

was in Sargang, which is near

52:50

Mandalay, Mandalay's second biggest city in

52:52

Myanmar. And that was

52:54

where the worst of the destruction

52:56

happened. Almost every street

52:58

in Mandalay has collapsed buildings.

53:01

It's a little difficult for us to

53:03

get a sense of the exact

53:05

scale of the damage because the Hunter

53:07

refuses to allow... Some media has

53:10

been allowed in. The BBC, I saw,

53:12

like, sneaked somebody in. It's very

53:14

difficult for media to move and report

53:16

freely. In addition to

53:18

this, the hunter has continued his

53:20

practice of cutting off internet for

53:22

people in Myanmar, right? Even during

53:24

emergency situations? Yes, especially

53:26

during emergency. They've cut it off

53:28

as a response to this because I

53:30

guess they perceive it to be

53:32

something that makes them look weak. This

53:34

is a tendency that

53:37

the hunter has displayed before.

53:39

So in 2008, Cyclone

53:41

Nargis affected Myanmar and killed

53:43

over 130 ,000 people and

53:45

they blocked international aid. They

53:48

said that people didn't need

53:50

the quote chocolate bars that the

53:52

US and other countries were

53:54

trying to deliver and that they

53:56

could exist by like hunting

53:58

frogs and ditches was their suggestion.

54:01

I don't think people realize

54:03

like how far down

54:05

the North Korea scale that

54:07

the Burmese hunter is.

54:09

But they're very worried that

54:12

any interaction with the

54:14

outside world, specifically with, I

54:16

guess, Western neoliberal powers

54:18

will be damaging for their

54:20

ability to control the

54:23

population. So for

54:25

that reason, we

54:27

don't know how many people have died,

54:29

right? From what I've

54:31

heard on the ground, the death

54:33

toll is substantially higher than the 3

54:35

,600 number being reported. The US Geological

54:37

Survey estimated that an earthquake of

54:39

that magnitude in that region would kill

54:41

between 10 ,000 and 100 ,000 people. Obviously,

54:44

that's quite a big kind of delta there. What

54:47

I can tell you is that

54:49

I've heard firsthand that there are some

54:52

parts of Mandalay and Sagang where

54:54

the stench of rotting bodies is so

54:56

powerful that people have stopped returning

54:58

to their homes. There

55:00

have been so many aftershocks that people

55:02

are still sleeping in the street

55:04

because they're worried about the damage structures

55:06

falling down. The UN

55:09

has an estimate of 17

55:11

million people across 57 townships.

55:13

Townships are like the administrative

55:15

districts that are used in

55:17

Myanmar have been affected with

55:19

over 9 million people facing

55:21

severe hardship. And of

55:23

course, this is all compounded by the fact

55:25

that there were already 20 million people in

55:27

Myanmar who needed humanitarian assistance. And

55:29

there are about three and a half million

55:31

internally displaced people as a result of the fighting

55:33

that's happened after the revolution. So

55:35

it really came at a pretty

55:38

difficult time in a place where

55:40

the government is not willing to...

55:42

They said after the earthquake they

55:44

wanted international aid, but as we'll

55:46

see later in this script, they've

55:48

only accepted it from certain countries.

55:51

I spoke to a friend who has

55:53

family in Mandalay yesterday. He told

55:55

me that The way they're assessing the

55:57

damage is using like open source

55:59

intelligence. They're trying to look in

56:01

the backgrounds of people's videos on Facebook

56:03

to like work out if their childhood

56:05

homes failed out, right? They

56:07

were using satellite imaging software when I

56:09

spoke to them yesterday to try

56:11

and ascertain if their families were okay.

56:15

They told me Saigang has very famous

56:17

pagodas and the pagodas are all on

56:19

a hill and apparently a lot of

56:21

those pagodas have fallen down and even

56:23

the hill itself is like listing. So

56:25

there's been massive cultural damage

56:27

as well. Another

56:30

way in which the damage was

56:32

compounded by Myanmar's politics was the quake

56:34

strike, like I said, at 1

56:36

p .m. on a Friday, which is

56:38

Friday prayers. This happened during Ramadan, specifically

56:40

the day before Idul Fitta, which

56:42

is a very busy day for mosques,

56:44

if you're not aware. Successive

56:46

governments of Myanmar since the

56:49

1960s have refused to allow

56:51

even basic maintenance for mosques.

56:53

That means that these buildings

56:55

were in great states of

56:57

disrepair, right? Myanmar, there

56:59

is an ultra -nationalist Buddhist movement,

57:02

which has been embraced to a

57:04

great degree by the Hunter, but

57:06

also limited even like the National

57:08

League for Democracy, which was the

57:10

relatively neoliberal aligned party that had

57:12

previously been empowering Myanmar or somewhat

57:15

in power, I suppose. ultra

57:17

-nationalist Buddhist monks like Ashin Murathu

57:19

and his 969 movement have kind

57:21

of condemned anything that they did

57:23

as making a pro -Muslim. And they

57:25

have this, essentially they have a

57:27

great replacement theory, right, that Muslims

57:29

are trying to come in through

57:31

Bangladesh to replace Buddhists in Myanmar.

57:33

Yeah, lots of people

57:36

here have this like

57:38

very orientalist perspective of

57:40

like Buddhism, TM, as

57:42

this like, you know, like peaceful

57:44

blah, blah, blah, blah. And like,

57:46

you know, like Buddhism, like every religion has

57:48

a variety of sex. Yes. And

57:51

the Buddhist national sex can

57:53

be particularly nasty. Yeah. I mean,

57:55

as vicious as any other, people,

57:58

I'm sure, will be familiar with the

58:00

Rohingya genocide. And like, there are a lot

58:02

of monks that supported that, including where

58:04

Arthur is the most notable one, but there

58:06

are plenty more, right? And they're part

58:08

of that. I mean, he's literally explicitly expressed,

58:10

like, how much he looks up to

58:12

the English Defense League. Jesus. Yeah,

58:15

these are people who,

58:17

they are part of this

58:19

global nativist movement. People's

58:21

Orientalism, I think, sometimes stops them

58:23

seeing that or appreciating that this extends

58:25

outside of white global North countries. One

58:29

thing that I did think that

58:31

really touched me in the days

58:33

after the earthquake was young Buddhist

58:35

Bama people of the majority ethnicity

58:37

reaching out to me and being

58:40

like, hey, man, This happened

58:42

in Friday prayers during Ramadan, and

58:44

it has devastated the Muslim population. Thousands

58:47

of people, hundreds of mosques have gone, and thousands

58:49

of people are trapped in a rubble, and no one's

58:51

talking about it. Why is no one talking about

58:53

it? This is terrible. And

58:55

it would have been inconceivable

58:58

to hear young Bama Buddhist

59:00

people so concerned with the

59:02

well -being of their Muslim countrymen

59:04

before the coup in 2021.

59:06

This was a country that

59:08

had been manufacturing consent for

59:10

genocide against its Muslim minorities

59:12

for four or five years

59:14

by that point, right? Specifically

59:16

on Facebook, there's a behind -the -bastards episode

59:18

on this. You can also listen. If

59:21

you're new to the show, Robert and I

59:23

have made two scripted series about the revolution

59:25

in Myanmar, which we'll include in the show

59:27

notes. But that

59:29

change to... a

59:32

real genuine solidarity and care between these

59:34

two groups, which was really touching in

59:36

the moments after the earthquake and the

59:38

days after the earthquake. When

59:40

we come back, I want to talk a little bit

59:42

more about the revolution and I want to talk

59:44

about how the revolution has been responding to this and

59:46

the impact it's had on the revolution. We

59:58

are back. And of

1:00:00

course, The revolution hasn't stopped

1:00:02

because of the earthquake. The

1:00:04

conflict is still ongoing, and

1:00:06

the PDFs and their Allied

1:00:09

Ethnic Business Organisations are still

1:00:11

fighting against the Hunter. In

1:00:13

fact, within an hour of the

1:00:15

earthquake, the Hunter began using paramotors

1:00:17

to drop bombs on Hangu Village

1:00:19

in Sugai. This has

1:00:21

been a thing that they've started to

1:00:24

do recently. In a sense,

1:00:26

I guess it's a good sign because it

1:00:28

shows that maybe their jets and other aircraft

1:00:30

are in a poor state of repair, or

1:00:32

that they're struggling to keep enough of them

1:00:34

airborne. Initially, I wondered if

1:00:37

they were using the paramotors because

1:00:39

their runways had been damaged, but that

1:00:41

doesn't seem to be the case.

1:00:43

They've been air striking just as much

1:00:45

as they ever did, which is

1:00:47

unfortunate. Satellite images or reports

1:00:49

from my source on the ground suggest

1:00:51

that they're able to continue carrying out

1:00:54

bombing raids at a pretty similar rate

1:00:56

from when they did before. Despite

1:00:58

this, The national unity government, which

1:01:00

is kind of the shadow government, composed

1:01:02

mostly of people who were elected

1:01:05

and then deposed by the coup in

1:01:07

2021. And the PDF,

1:01:09

who in theory are commanded by

1:01:11

the national unity government, called a two

1:01:13

week ceasefire right after the earthquake

1:01:15

to allow for like a humanitarian pause.

1:01:18

The Three Brotherhood Alliance, which is

1:01:20

an alliance of the three most

1:01:22

powerful ethnic resistance organizations in Myanmar,

1:01:24

also called what they called a

1:01:26

humanitarian pause for a month. In

1:01:28

both cases, They said they wouldn't

1:01:30

undertake offensive operations, but they would defend

1:01:32

themselves, right? Because I think they had a

1:01:35

sense that the Hunter wasn't going to

1:01:37

stop attacking them. The Hunter

1:01:39

did declare its own ceasefire

1:01:41

on April 3rd, and the Kuchin

1:01:43

Independence Army, which is another

1:01:45

ethnic resistance organization, followed shortly thereafter.

1:01:48

Notably, that ceasefire from the Hunter came

1:01:50

the day after its troops fired

1:01:52

on a Chinese Red Cross convoy, which

1:01:55

is not a great look for them. No,

1:01:57

never loved to see that. Yeah, we don't love

1:01:59

to see people firing on the Red Cross. This

1:02:02

is especially bad for the Hunter because China

1:02:04

has been growing closer and closer to the

1:02:06

Hunter and supporting it. China's had

1:02:08

this weird back and forth relationship

1:02:10

with the revolution. At times it supported

1:02:12

the revolution, it seems like, specifically

1:02:14

supporting the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army,

1:02:17

which is a group that broke off

1:02:19

the Communist Party of Burma in the

1:02:21

1980s. Yeah, that makes sense. There's

1:02:23

also the United States Army, which isn't

1:02:25

part of the revolution, which is the which

1:02:28

has the strongest relationship with the PRC,

1:02:30

and they're just chilling. They haven't really entered

1:02:32

the conflict. It's called straight chilling, by

1:02:34

the way, James. Straight chilling? Yeah, there you

1:02:36

go. That's how they use it. I've

1:02:39

marked myself out yet again.

1:02:41

Straight chilling. United Water

1:02:43

State Army. Thank you,

1:02:45

Garrison. Actually,

1:02:48

I spoke to some cadres

1:02:50

from the... Burmese Communist Party

1:02:52

recently. The Communist Party of

1:02:54

Burma re -entered after 2021, and

1:02:57

they're not focusing on proselytizing

1:02:59

the Maoist gospel to people,

1:03:01

they're focusing on fighting the

1:03:03

Hunter and developing alliances. And

1:03:06

it's interesting to see where that

1:03:08

will go given Marxist -Leninist Maoism is

1:03:10

definitely not the majority of

1:03:12

the revolution. Most people are committed

1:03:14

to some form of federal democracy, which

1:03:16

when you speak to different fighters

1:03:19

varies from We want what you guys

1:03:21

have in the US to something

1:03:23

more akin to the democratic confederalism that

1:03:25

people might be familiar with in

1:03:27

Rishabha. China is competing with

1:03:29

Russia in Myanmar. So both

1:03:31

of them are interested in supporting

1:03:33

the Hunter, right? And obviously,

1:03:35

both their ideologies are far from

1:03:37

liberatory. They're interested in propping

1:03:39

up a totalitarian state. So

1:03:42

we have seen both Russia

1:03:44

and China send support. to

1:03:46

the hunters and like rescue

1:03:48

teams after the earthquake. Meanwhile,

1:03:50

the US offered $2 million,

1:03:53

which I was kind of surprised

1:03:55

they offered anything. That is

1:03:57

low key surprising considering Mark Rubio.

1:04:00

Right, yeah. Well, I think Rubio is

1:04:02

more of a like a slightly,

1:04:04

Rubio's a neocon. Yeah, I guess like

1:04:06

it makes sense. Mark Rubio, like

1:04:08

five years ago, it doesn't make sense,

1:04:10

like post like you say to

1:04:13

being gutted. They were like, oh, you're

1:04:15

still doing that kind of stuff,

1:04:17

huh? Yeah, there's like a weird like

1:04:19

mix of things because yes, like

1:04:21

a traditional neocon style rubio, this tracks,

1:04:23

but all of the movements that

1:04:25

the Trump administration's been doing more recently,

1:04:27

this seems like seems like a

1:04:30

Some kind of DEI shenanigans, if you

1:04:32

ask me. Yeah, actually they added

1:04:34

another seven million later. Nine million. Which

1:04:36

is, yeah, it's not a lot

1:04:38

of money compared to what we would

1:04:40

normally expect. And at the same

1:04:42

time they did it, three

1:04:44

USAID workers, at least three I should

1:04:46

say, three that I'm aware of,

1:04:48

were laid off like literally they received

1:04:51

emails telling them that they no

1:04:53

longer had a job while they were

1:04:55

on the ground assisting earthquake survivors.

1:04:57

Department of Government Efficiency strikes again. Highly

1:04:59

efficient. We'll send you the money

1:05:01

and then also pull out our own people who I guess

1:05:03

are supervising how the money is spent or would be. It

1:05:06

definitely shows a strategic shift

1:05:08

in the region. China and Russia,

1:05:11

China obviously is interested in

1:05:13

Myanmar because of its rare

1:05:15

earth metals because of jade. China

1:05:18

has originally had a lot of

1:05:20

jade trade with Myanmar and then because

1:05:23

it controls a large amount of sea

1:05:25

front, right? Which China wouldn't want to

1:05:27

fall into like what it would see

1:05:29

as like someone with adversarial interests. Russia

1:05:31

is still interested in just kind of

1:05:33

projecting itself as a global power even

1:05:35

as it continues to shrink every day

1:05:37

in terms of its global ability to

1:05:39

project power. But there definitely

1:05:41

are both Chinese and Russian

1:05:43

assistance helping the Myanmar Hunter now.

1:05:46

Meanwhile, the US doesn't seem to give

1:05:48

a shit what happens here now. Like

1:05:50

this is kind of Not that the

1:05:52

Biden administration was doing very much either,

1:05:54

but at least we had USAID and

1:05:57

like USIP was very invested in Myanmar

1:05:59

and actually did a really good job

1:06:01

of kind of almost like being the

1:06:03

foreign affairs, not branch, but like

1:06:05

they explained the revolution to the world. Like

1:06:07

whenever a journalist wanted to understand the

1:06:09

revolution in Myanmar was USIP they went to.

1:06:11

Obviously all the countries that have a

1:06:13

USIP have now been doged, which is a

1:06:15

shame. So despite the

1:06:17

ceasefire, Right. I said they

1:06:19

fired on these Chinese troops.

1:06:21

The Hunter has in fact

1:06:24

not stopped bombing earthquakes, drug

1:06:26

areas, since the earthquake. Madeleine

1:06:28

PDF, who I'm in contact with,

1:06:30

they're the revolutionary forces in the area that

1:06:32

was most affected by the earthquake. On April

1:06:34

7th, told me that they were aware of

1:06:36

10 airstrikes in their area of operations. Since

1:06:39

the earthquake, a three -month -old baby and

1:06:41

a 10 -year -old child were killed in

1:06:43

an air raid on Naikav village in

1:06:45

Papuntownship. that was in Korean state. On

1:06:48

April 10th, they bombed a school. It's

1:06:50

something that the hunter likes to do

1:06:52

a lot, and they dropped two 500

1:06:54

pound bombs on a food court. They

1:06:56

then circled back and dropped another bomb

1:06:58

on the people responding to and giving

1:07:00

aid to the people they'd initially bombed

1:07:02

in the food court. By food court

1:07:04

here, just to clarify, I'm not talking

1:07:06

about like at the shopping mall, I'm

1:07:09

talking about like a market where people

1:07:11

can buy like prepared food, right? They've

1:07:14

killed... best I

1:07:16

can collate from various sources at

1:07:18

least 72 people and injured

1:07:20

about 100 people in addition to

1:07:22

thousands who died after the

1:07:24

earthquake. There are also

1:07:26

reports that hunter quote unquote recruiters

1:07:28

here are engaging in forced conscription

1:07:30

in the disaster zone. I read

1:07:32

of at least one person who

1:07:34

was on a search and rescue

1:07:36

team that they were trained search

1:07:39

and rescue volunteer right so they

1:07:41

were moving rubble to rescue people

1:07:43

and they were forcibly conscripted while

1:07:45

they were doing that. Obviously that's

1:07:47

had a chilling effect on people

1:07:49

going out to help others right.

1:07:52

What the country is not doing

1:07:54

is rescuing its citizens the

1:07:56

military is. Detested in

1:07:58

most of me and my even the

1:08:00

areas that it controls and it's failure to

1:08:02

even try and track people rest you

1:08:04

the rubber won't help this there was a

1:08:06

video that went viral recently of hunter

1:08:08

troops like literally a line of soldiers rescuing

1:08:10

bricks. They've gone to a collapsed

1:08:12

building and they're they're inspecting the bricks to see

1:08:14

if the bricks are whole and then passing

1:08:16

them down the line and stacking them up don't

1:08:18

worry the bricks are safe yeah the bricks

1:08:20

are safe the people are not. It

1:08:23

was genuinely infuriating to see it.

1:08:25

I can't imagine for people who have

1:08:28

lost family members how it must

1:08:30

feel. Even rescue workers,

1:08:32

like I said, have been

1:08:34

forcibly conscripted. Equality Myanmar

1:08:36

has noted more than 100 cases

1:08:38

of forced conscription since the earthquake. Myanmar

1:08:41

has a conscription rule law, so anyone...

1:08:43

and now women between certain ages can

1:08:45

be forcibly conscripted into the Hunter's army.

1:08:47

So they're just finding people displaced from

1:08:49

the earthquake and forcing them. Yeah, it's

1:08:51

people who have been hiding in their

1:08:53

homes, right, who now don't have homes

1:08:55

to hide it. Yeah. Or people who

1:08:58

came out in order to save their

1:09:00

neighbors. And now they're forcing them to

1:09:02

be, to fight for them. Just

1:09:04

as the Hunter did with Cyclone

1:09:06

Nargis, they've also delayed and in

1:09:08

cases blocked aid. A team

1:09:10

came from France to assist in a

1:09:12

search and rescue. They spent

1:09:15

24 hours sitting in an airport

1:09:17

waiting for their visa to be

1:09:19

approved, and then they spent

1:09:21

one day working in search and rescue efforts

1:09:23

before being told that search and rescue

1:09:25

efforts had now finished and they were to

1:09:27

go home. They traveled around the entire

1:09:29

world and didn't save a single life. Abundance.

1:09:31

Yeah, it's great. Presumably

1:09:34

because the Hunter wanted to placate China,

1:09:36

a Taiwanese team was straight up refused

1:09:38

entry into Myanmar. that Taiwan

1:09:41

had a search and rescue team that they're

1:09:43

willing to send who could have saved people

1:09:45

lives and that they weren't allowed to enter.

1:09:47

All tourist visas have been suspended so it's

1:09:49

not like the hunter is overwhelmed with visa

1:09:51

applications but they're not allowing search and rescue

1:09:53

teams to enter from countries I guess they're

1:09:55

not politically aligned with. This kind

1:09:57

of horrific indifference to human suffering has

1:09:59

characterized the top of the door for decades

1:10:01

and it's really unlikely to change as

1:10:03

it grows even more desperate and it loses

1:10:05

even more territory, it's just going to

1:10:08

clamp down harder and harder on its people.

1:10:10

B1 in the liberated areas, aid

1:10:12

is being mobilized using the mutual aid structures

1:10:14

which have existed for decades in the absence of

1:10:16

the state. In significant and

1:10:18

growing parts of Myanmar, people

1:10:20

are relying on each other instead

1:10:22

of the government for aid, and

1:10:24

that has its benefit. People have

1:10:26

been out rescuing people from the

1:10:28

rubble, but they're also desperately short

1:10:30

of resources. I spoke to Mandalay

1:10:32

PDF rescue team at the first

1:10:34

week of April, and they

1:10:36

literally sent me, they have a notebook.

1:10:38

of a list of, like, we've run

1:10:41

out of gauze, we've run out of

1:10:43

tourniquets, we've run out of adhesive dressings,

1:10:45

we've run out of elastic bandages, right?

1:10:47

The literal nuts and bolts of saving

1:10:49

people's lives they run out of. We

1:10:51

did a fundraising campaign for them through

1:10:53

Behind the Bastards. We raised nearly $2 ,000,

1:10:55

which is great. So they're restocking their

1:10:57

supplies, which is fantastic, but that's just

1:10:59

one township all across the country. People

1:11:01

are struggling for the basic supplies that

1:11:03

they need to save lives. The

1:11:05

military has also blocked Ada Medicine from

1:11:07

entering their areas, right? So the military

1:11:10

controls a lot of roadblocks and it

1:11:12

uses its control of those roadblocks to

1:11:14

stop Ada Medicine. Often it's kind of

1:11:16

hoarding it in the capital city, which

1:11:18

is Napidore. People aren't familiar, Napidore is

1:11:20

a city that they've come to build

1:11:22

for itself to govern from, the seat

1:11:24

of kings. Also in

1:11:26

Napidore right now is the US

1:11:29

aid agency Samaritan's Purse. You familiar

1:11:31

with Samaritan's Purse, Garrison? I don't

1:11:33

think so. It sounds vaguely familiar,

1:11:35

but all of these humanitarian organizations

1:11:37

all have like the same like

1:11:39

four words that they shuffle around

1:11:41

in different ways, so... Yeah, yeah,

1:11:43

yeah. Samaritan's Purse, perhaps most famous

1:11:45

for being run by Franklin Graham.

1:11:47

Okay, yes, yes. do know what

1:11:50

this is and who this is,

1:11:52

yes. Yeah, having all their volunteers

1:11:54

sign like a statement of faith

1:11:56

and being extremely homophobic. For

1:11:58

some reason, Samaritan's Purse is establishing a

1:12:00

field hospital in Napidore right now. They're

1:12:02

going to force people to convert to

1:12:04

evangelical Christianity before they give services like

1:12:07

they do in some cases. Yeah. Or

1:12:09

just leave them like they did in

1:12:11

Afghanistan if they're not Christian. I cannot

1:12:13

work out for the life of me

1:12:15

what the fuck they're doing. Because

1:12:17

like the hunter has made a

1:12:19

consistent policy of bombing Christians in Myanmar,

1:12:21

right? In Korean and Korean estate,

1:12:23

there a lot of Christian people on

1:12:26

Christmas Day. The hunter bombed people

1:12:28

going to services because it knew that

1:12:30

Christians would be going to services

1:12:32

at churches, right? The Kareni

1:12:34

Christians this year, I saw celebrated

1:12:36

Christmas in caves because they

1:12:38

were so afraid of big bombed,

1:12:40

right? Like, I have no

1:12:42

idea what logical leap you have

1:12:44

to make. Bizarre. Yeah, it's...

1:12:47

And they're not even at the...

1:12:49

In Segang, the only people, the

1:12:51

only international aid I'm aware of that was able

1:12:53

to make it to Segang was a Malaysian team.

1:12:56

who were able to save some lives. Unfortunately,

1:13:00

there were really strong rains this week, and

1:13:02

that made all the collapse structures even more

1:13:04

unstable, and the Malaysian team I saw have

1:13:06

now returned home. We're going to take another

1:13:08

ad break here. When we come back, we

1:13:10

will talk about what you can do to

1:13:12

help. All

1:13:23

right, and we're back. First,

1:13:25

I want to, I guess, have some good news. Despite

1:13:28

everything, the military has still been taking

1:13:30

massive losses. The Orberma

1:13:32

Students' Democratic Front captured remaining

1:13:34

Hunter positions in Indore. The

1:13:37

Orberma Students' Democratic Front are a

1:13:39

group that's been around since 1988,

1:13:41

right? And they have armed up

1:13:43

and re -entered the revolution since

1:13:45

2021. One of the things

1:13:47

that they captured on Monday was

1:13:49

a underground Japanese field hospital from World

1:13:52

War II. which I guess had

1:13:54

been like an entrenched position. I

1:13:56

guess they're not covered technically by the

1:13:58

ceasefire, but there was a unit under

1:14:01

the National Unity Government's command that operated

1:14:03

with them. And from what I understand,

1:14:06

this began as a defensive

1:14:08

action. They'd surrounded the Hunter, I

1:14:10

think it's called Japan Cave Hill. They'd

1:14:12

surrounded them on Japan Cave Hill for a

1:14:15

long time, and then the Hunter obviously

1:14:17

seeing the earthquake and everything, thereafter decided that

1:14:19

now was the time for them to

1:14:21

break out. of this encirclement. They did not

1:14:23

break out, they took a fat L

1:14:25

and as a result, they've all been captured

1:14:27

now. Meanwhile, in

1:14:30

Chinland, if people haven't listened to

1:14:32

the episode I did a couple of weeks

1:14:34

ago with Azad from the anti -fascist internationalist

1:14:36

front, I would suggest going back and listening

1:14:38

to that to understand Chinland. But

1:14:40

the AIF and a lot of their

1:14:42

allied forces from the Chinland Defense Force

1:14:44

and the Chin Brotherhood had a significant

1:14:46

victory in capturing the rest of the

1:14:48

Hunter's positions in Phalaam last week. And

1:14:50

I think it's very much like on

1:14:52

the table that we will see the

1:14:55

whole of Chinlain liberated in the next

1:14:57

few months or by the end of

1:14:59

the year, which would be great to

1:15:01

see. So people are wondering

1:15:03

like what they can do to help,

1:15:05

right? And I think it's a very

1:15:07

valid question because I saw today that

1:15:09

the UN was meeting with the hunter

1:15:11

in Naipetor. And I just have no

1:15:13

faith that any money that goes to

1:15:16

the hunter is going to get to

1:15:18

people who need it. Yeah, no, absolutely

1:15:20

not. You cannot. They

1:15:22

want them to die. No,

1:15:25

they're like evil. Yeah,

1:15:27

yeah, they are literally genocide or

1:15:29

they have done a genocide that

1:15:32

has been prosecuted international criminal court.

1:15:34

I have no understanding why people

1:15:36

continue to, international organizations continue to

1:15:39

funnel money to them other than

1:15:41

because they have a status quo

1:15:43

bias, I guess. So don't be

1:15:45

doing that, but there are groups

1:15:47

who are making a really big

1:15:49

difference. And one of them that I wanted to highlight, and

1:15:52

Robert and I both very

1:15:54

familiar with their work from the

1:15:56

last time that we were

1:15:58

overreporting is community partners international. CPI

1:16:00

are really cool because they

1:16:02

work by empowering members of the

1:16:04

local community to be health

1:16:06

volunteers, as opposed to dropping in

1:16:09

some doctors from America or

1:16:11

doctors from... Kingdom or whatever. And

1:16:13

then when those people leave,

1:16:15

they take their skills with them.

1:16:17

CPI, the thing is to educate

1:16:19

folks within the community so that

1:16:21

they can take care of one

1:16:24

another. And it's sort of CPI

1:16:26

has a matching donations thing right now, which

1:16:28

is pretty cool. So like

1:16:30

if you donate, someone else will

1:16:32

match your donation and that will

1:16:34

double the amount that you receive.

1:16:37

Otherwise, I will provide a list of

1:16:39

mutual aid funds that have been shared

1:16:41

with me. Most of them are like

1:16:43

GoFundMe's or things like that. I'll put

1:16:45

it all in the show description. They've

1:16:48

all been vetted and like, I

1:16:50

know people are sometimes reluctant to give

1:16:52

to GoFundMe's and they'd rather give

1:16:54

to like a 501c3 or like an

1:16:57

organization which has a little bit

1:16:59

more, I guess like online presence. In

1:17:01

this case, you have to understand

1:17:03

that like a lot. of orgs just

1:17:05

aren't operating in the liberated areas.

1:17:07

The two that I'm aware of, CPI

1:17:09

and FreeBurma ranges. I spoke

1:17:11

to Dave from FreeBurma ranges. They're

1:17:13

trying to get to as many people as

1:17:15

they can as well. That would be another great

1:17:17

place to donate. I would include a list

1:17:19

of vetted GoFundMe's. If you want to have a

1:17:21

look through those and see if any of

1:17:23

them speaks to you more, you can

1:17:25

do that too. What this will

1:17:27

mean for the future of Myanmar, We

1:17:31

don't know yet, right? We

1:17:33

have really no sense of how

1:17:35

many people have died of

1:17:37

what it's done to the hunters

1:17:39

ability to control those areas.

1:17:41

But until the revolution has a

1:17:43

way to stop planes bombing

1:17:45

people, we will continue to see

1:17:47

the same dynamic of the

1:17:49

hunter losing terrain on the ground,

1:17:51

pulling back its soldiers, and

1:17:53

then bombing civilians in the areas that it's

1:17:55

lost. That is its

1:17:57

game plan. It's continuing

1:18:00

to get more drones from

1:18:02

China, it's getting aircraft

1:18:04

munitions and jet fuel from

1:18:06

China. And until there

1:18:08

is an embargo on jet fuel

1:18:10

and munitions to the Hunter, then we

1:18:12

will see this same pattern continue,

1:18:14

right? They lose terrain, they

1:18:16

bomb a school, they lose terrain, they bomb a

1:18:18

hospital. Again, it's the same stuff

1:18:21

that Israel is doing. And they, of

1:18:23

course, previously been armed by Israel as well.

1:18:25

But we don't see as much solidarity

1:18:27

for the people of Burma. If

1:18:30

you want to stay in touch with what's

1:18:32

happening on the ground, I think the Irawari,

1:18:35

I -R -R -A -W -A -D -D -Y does a

1:18:37

really good job of doing daily

1:18:39

summaries right now. So I would suggest

1:18:41

checking out what's happening there. And

1:18:43

of course, we'll keep you updated on

1:18:46

developments in the spring revolution as they come. Looking

1:19:06

for excitement? Chumba Casino is here. Play

1:19:08

anytime, play anywhere. Play on the train, play

1:19:10

at the store, play at home, play

1:19:12

when you're bored. Play today for your chance

1:19:14

to win and get daily bonuses when

1:19:16

you log in. So what are you waiting

1:19:18

for? Don't delay. Chumba Casino is free

1:19:20

to play. Wasn't

1:19:37

that delicious? So good. Your

1:19:39

bill, ladies? I got it. No,

1:19:41

I got it. Seriously,

1:19:43

I insist. I insisted first. Oh,

1:19:46

don't be silly. You don't be

1:19:48

silly. People with the Wells Fargo

1:19:50

Active Cash Credit Card prefer to

1:19:52

pay because they earn unlimited 2

1:19:54

% cash back on purchases. OK.

1:19:56

Rock, paper, scissors for it. Rock,

1:19:58

paper, scissors, shoot! No! The

1:20:00

Wells Fargo Active Cash

1:20:02

Credit Card. Visit wellsfargo.com slash

1:20:04

activecash terms apply. Does

1:20:07

this podcast make you happy? Of

1:20:09

course it does. That's why you're

1:20:11

here. But it only comes out

1:20:13

once a week. For happiness every

1:20:15

night? You need Adam and Eve.

1:20:17

Yes, I'm talking about sex toys.

1:20:20

It's cool. It's cool. You have earbuds in, right? Adam

1:20:23

and Eve, America's most trusted source

1:20:25

for adult products, has been making people

1:20:27

very happy for over 50 years.

1:20:29

with thousands of toys for both men

1:20:32

and women. Just go to

1:20:34

adamaneve.com now and enter code iHeart

1:20:36

for 50 % off almost any

1:20:38

one item. Plus free discreet

1:20:40

shipping. That's adamaneve.com code iHeart for

1:20:42

50 % off. Every

1:20:45

morning brings a fresh new

1:20:47

energy. This is today. And

1:20:49

no matter what the day holds, we

1:20:51

come to the Today Show for all

1:20:53

of it. When things are tough, we

1:20:55

talk about it. When there's something to

1:20:57

figure out, we dig into it. And

1:20:59

when there's joy, we celebrate it. Because

1:21:01

today is where it's all happening. We

1:21:04

get the best start to every

1:21:06

morning because we started together. Watch

1:21:08

the Today Show with Savanica 3

1:21:10

and Craig Melvin weekdays at 7am

1:21:12

on NBC. This

1:21:17

is It Could Happen Here.

1:21:20

I am not going to El

1:21:22

Salvador. It's not going to

1:21:24

happen. No way. No thank you,

1:21:26

Mr. President. I'm

1:21:28

Garrison Davis. I'm joined by

1:21:31

James Stout. Hi Garrison. We're here

1:21:33

to talk about possibly the

1:21:35

most upsetting thing I've seen in

1:21:37

American politics in like the

1:21:39

past six months to maybe even,

1:21:42

I don't know, this really had hit

1:21:44

me for like the past few years.

1:21:46

Like, yeah, what happened on Monday in

1:21:48

the Oval Office was is kind of

1:21:50

the most black pill they've ever been,

1:21:52

which is not a great way to

1:21:54

start an episode. Yeah, like... It made

1:21:56

me feel like I found 2023 very

1:21:59

hard, like going out and seeing people

1:22:01

freezing in the desert and then coming

1:22:03

home and seeing Joe Biden the ice

1:22:05

cream on the timeline. But like this

1:22:07

was different. This was so like blatant.

1:22:09

There's like a level of like intentional

1:22:11

depravity that you're reminded of more blatantly. And

1:22:14

like Bukele's trolling

1:22:16

of everyone. So

1:22:19

we're gonna be talking about

1:22:21

an Oval Office meeting between President

1:22:23

Trump and El Salvador President

1:22:25

Bukele. I guess I could

1:22:27

learn his first name. Naib Bukele?

1:22:30

There you go. You know he's

1:22:32

Palestinian Salvadorian. Are you fucking serious?

1:22:34

No, his dad's an Imam. I

1:22:36

don't even have time for that. This

1:22:39

is just fucking... I'm

1:22:41

sorry if anyone's driving and

1:22:43

has had an accident

1:22:45

upon hearing that. So as

1:22:48

you probably know, Recently,

1:22:50

the United States government has

1:22:52

sent upwards of 300

1:22:54

people, immigrants, to

1:22:56

the El Salvador Terrorism

1:22:58

Confinement Center, this

1:23:00

prison black site that people

1:23:03

never return from. I

1:23:05

guess I could point to, for a

1:23:07

pop culture reference, which feels a little bit

1:23:09

in bad taste, but you

1:23:11

could point to like the prison in

1:23:13

the TV show Andor. as being a very

1:23:15

comfortable facility, frankly, except they turn off

1:23:17

the lights in Andorra. They do not turn

1:23:20

off the lights in Seacot. Lights run

1:23:22

all the time. They put 10

1:23:24

to 20 people per cell. It's

1:23:26

pretty bad. Jameson has done episodes

1:23:28

on Seacot in the past. We'll probably

1:23:30

keep doing more. The lights

1:23:32

thing, by the way, was

1:23:34

a specific policy change by Bukele.

1:23:36

There was a particularly violent

1:23:38

weekend in El Salvador. And

1:23:41

as a result, He stopped letting people

1:23:43

who were detained for gang crimes go outside

1:23:45

and stopped building windows into the prison

1:23:47

and just put the lights on. Like there's

1:23:49

a way of punishing, I guess, the

1:23:51

gangs by punishing the people who were detained

1:23:53

there. Yeah, they can't go outside. They

1:23:55

stay in their cell for almost 24 hours

1:23:57

a day. They might occasionally get 30

1:23:59

minutes outside, but that's not even confirmed because

1:24:01

no one's even allowed inside to see

1:24:04

what's going on in there. And

1:24:06

we've sent upwards of 300

1:24:08

immigrants there. The vast majority

1:24:10

of which have no criminal

1:24:13

record, even if you do

1:24:15

have a criminal record, being

1:24:17

renditioned to a foreign prison

1:24:19

camp is still bad. But

1:24:21

this is something that Trump

1:24:23

hopes to expand on greatly, and

1:24:26

they are currently defending their ability to

1:24:28

do so in the courts. Since it

1:24:30

has been learned that a few people

1:24:32

sent there may have been partially sent

1:24:34

by accident, but the Trump

1:24:36

administration is refusing to return these

1:24:38

people and is instead still trying

1:24:40

to convince the public that these

1:24:42

are dangerous terrorists that deserve to

1:24:44

be disappeared. So let's

1:24:46

kind of start with that

1:24:48

main case. The case

1:24:51

that's receiving the most public

1:24:53

attention right now is of

1:24:55

a Maryland man named Kilmer

1:24:57

Abrego Garcia, who's a subject of

1:24:59

a district court case that has been

1:25:01

sent up to the Supreme Court and

1:25:03

then sent back to the district court

1:25:05

on whether this man can be returned

1:25:07

home to his US citizen wife and

1:25:09

child. And then on

1:25:11

Monday, April 14th, in the Oval Office

1:25:13

meeting, President Bukele said

1:25:15

that he will not return this

1:25:17

Maryland immigrant with protected legal status

1:25:19

back to the United States, who

1:25:22

ICE admits was sent to CCOT

1:25:24

based on a quote, unquote, administrative

1:25:26

error. Bukele said, quote,

1:25:28

how can I smuggle a terrorist into the

1:25:30

United States? Of course I'm not going to

1:25:32

do it. The question is preposterous, unquote. The

1:25:35

El Salvador president also bulked at

1:25:37

the idea of releasing Garcia from

1:25:39

CCOT since he can't have a

1:25:41

quote -unquote terrorist free in his

1:25:43

country. Lying about Garcia

1:25:45

being a criminal. I

1:25:47

am gonna play a few clips in this

1:25:50

episode because I think it is necessary to

1:25:52

listen to these people actually say the words

1:25:54

that they are saying in the tone that

1:25:56

they're saying them and the exact phrasing on

1:25:58

these I think is actually pretty important right

1:26:00

now. So unfortunately you are gonna have to

1:26:02

hear the voices of a few people who

1:26:04

you might not rather hear from, including the

1:26:07

president of El Salvador. So I'll play this

1:26:09

first clip. Can

1:26:12

President Bukele weigh in on this? Do you

1:26:14

plan to return him? Well, I guess. I'm

1:26:16

supposed to have suggested that I smuggle terrorists

1:26:18

into the United States, right? How can I

1:26:20

smuggle? How can I return him to the

1:26:22

United States? It's like, could I smuggle him

1:26:25

into the United States? Or what do I

1:26:27

do? Of course, I'm not going to do

1:26:29

it. It's like, I mean,

1:26:31

the question is for busters. How can

1:26:33

I smuggle a terrorist into the United States?

1:26:35

I don't have the power to return

1:26:37

him to the United States. It's

1:27:05

just insane. like the whole pretense

1:27:07

of any serious engagement with reality there.

1:27:10

It's just gone. Yeah, and they're

1:27:12

both like miming that neither of them

1:27:14

have the ability to make any

1:27:16

kind of deal between each other, to

1:27:18

send people back, even though they

1:27:20

have the ability to make a deal

1:27:22

to send people there. Yeah, as

1:27:24

they sit in the same room. The

1:27:26

whole time Bacala is talking, Trump

1:27:28

has like this growing smirk on his

1:27:31

face. Yeah. But Kaley is talking

1:27:33

about this this preposterous notion of smuggling

1:27:35

a US immigrant back into the

1:27:37

United States Despite a Supreme Court order

1:27:39

to facilitate the return of this

1:27:41

immigrant back into the country The whole

1:27:43

smuggling framing is is obviously absurd

1:27:45

with him saying like I don't have

1:27:47

the power to return him to

1:27:49

the United States All he needs to

1:27:52

do is release him from Seacaw

1:27:54

and the US can fly him back

1:27:56

right just as we flew him

1:27:58

to El Salvador Like the two

1:28:00

heads of state are sitting right next

1:28:02

to each other. They could agree to

1:28:04

do this at any time. But now

1:28:06

everyone's pretending that suddenly they don't have

1:28:08

the power to undo what they seemingly

1:28:10

had the power to do in the

1:28:12

first place. Like Bukele has ruled and

1:28:14

we're going to do a whole episode

1:28:17

of Bukele and like his rise to

1:28:19

power and then his use of power.

1:28:21

But like he's ruled under a state

1:28:23

of exception for years in El Salvador,

1:28:25

which allows them to detain people without

1:28:27

warrants, without trials, right? And like It's

1:28:29

that state of exception that is now

1:28:31

the norm there. And that's kind of

1:28:33

what he seems to be referring to,

1:28:35

right? Like, we just

1:28:37

get to lock people up. Why

1:28:39

would I not do that? In effect,

1:28:41

they are arguing that every single

1:28:44

human being that is sent to sea

1:28:46

caught by the United States is

1:28:48

unable to ever leave the prison alive.

1:28:51

That's basically what they're saying. They're saying both

1:28:53

parties, both Trump and Bukele, are unable. to

1:28:55

have someone who's been sent there to

1:28:57

return. So they're just saying no one's able

1:28:59

to do anything. They're just stuck there

1:29:01

until they die. And this is part of

1:29:03

the design of Seacot. The

1:29:05

person who runs the Seacot security has

1:29:07

said that they do not intend

1:29:10

in any person ever being released from

1:29:12

Seacot. You are not designed to

1:29:14

get out. You are stuck there forever.

1:29:16

No one's ever left there. It's

1:29:19

just where you get disappeared. And

1:29:21

that's all that it is. And I

1:29:23

think part of why... They're so unwilling

1:29:25

to send Garcia back because then you

1:29:27

have someone like the first person who's

1:29:29

ever gotten out and can talk about

1:29:31

what it's actually like in there when

1:29:33

you don't have like Christina and propaganda

1:29:35

cameras pointed at at the prison bars.

1:29:37

Yeah. Bukele is very resistant

1:29:40

to release anyone for that reason. And

1:29:42

like there are plenty of allegations and

1:29:44

like I think time magazine has published

1:29:46

this. It's not usually controversial that he

1:29:48

made deals with gangs in the past

1:29:50

in El Salvador to get them to

1:29:52

reduce the murder rate. And like,

1:29:54

he certainly wouldn't like to hear

1:29:56

that testified to certainly not in the

1:29:59

United States Court, right? So like,

1:30:01

he doesn't want people to be released

1:30:03

from there either. Like you

1:30:05

say, they don't want anyone to be able

1:30:07

to go to any international human rights courts

1:30:09

and testify as to what happened to them

1:30:11

there. So it's kind of in his interest

1:30:13

to never have anyone be released. It's

1:30:15

not just also, I guess, like in

1:30:17

his interest, he's also being paid, right? $20

1:30:19

,000 per detainee per year by the United

1:30:21

States right now. So he also has

1:30:23

a financial interest in keeping people in there.

1:30:25

Even this per year deal makes, now

1:30:27

kind of makes zero sense because both of

1:30:29

them are arguing that there's no way

1:30:31

to send anyone back. Right. So like, it's

1:30:33

not that it's even like, oh, they're

1:30:35

only going to be there for one year.

1:30:37

It's like, they're just, they're

1:30:40

just there. And like, who

1:30:42

knows if they're going to like still

1:30:44

be alive. by the time that some

1:30:46

of these people would be able to

1:30:48

get out, whether that's through the miraculous

1:30:50

Donald Trump impeachment of 2026, which will

1:30:52

never happen. Or like, however, like these

1:30:54

people are they they are to stuck

1:30:56

there because he's not going to release

1:30:58

them into his country. We

1:31:00

are seemingly unable to take

1:31:02

anyone back from there. I

1:31:05

think unwilling, right? Like the

1:31:07

US is theoretically able. It's argued

1:31:09

that we're unable as as

1:31:11

as as people get into more

1:31:13

after this. bad break. Okay,

1:31:25

we are back. One

1:31:27

thing that we've seen across the

1:31:29

Trump administration the past 80 days

1:31:31

or so, something that we saw

1:31:33

very evident in this meeting, is

1:31:36

that whenever a single person is

1:31:38

asked a question about the outrageous,

1:31:40

possibly illegal possibly not but just

1:31:42

immoral or evil things that are

1:31:44

being done. The first instinct is

1:31:46

always to pass the bell count to someone else.

1:31:48

We saw this a lot with SignalGate, how it

1:31:50

was always someone else's faults. No

1:31:53

single person could get hammered down of being like,

1:31:55

okay, you are the person that's gonna be accountable

1:31:57

for this. And throughout this Oval

1:31:59

Office meeting, eventually they started taking questions

1:32:01

from journalists and reporters and propagandists who

1:32:03

were in the room. And you saw

1:32:05

this trend of... if someone asks Trump

1:32:07

about what's going on, he passes the

1:32:09

buck to Stephen Miller, who passes the

1:32:12

buck to Bukele, who then passes the

1:32:14

buck to Mark Rubio. And it's

1:32:16

like this big circle of like, everyone's just

1:32:18

talking around each other because no one really has

1:32:20

the authority to speak on what's going on

1:32:22

or how to fix this problem because they don't

1:32:24

see it as a problem. So instead, they

1:32:26

just talk in a circle. And I

1:32:28

think Miller was one of the most

1:32:30

effective at this. And unfortunately, we're going to

1:32:32

play the longest clip in

1:32:34

this episode, just under two minutes

1:32:36

from Stephen Miller, where he lays out

1:32:39

the Trump admin thought process and

1:32:41

strategy behind what they are doing. And

1:32:43

I apologize for this, but

1:32:45

it is useful to hear

1:32:47

from Himmler too. So

1:32:50

here we go. With

1:32:52

respect to you, he's a

1:32:54

citizen of El Salvador. So...

1:32:56

very arrogant even for American media to

1:32:58

suggest that we would even tell El

1:33:00

Salvador how to handle their own citizens

1:33:02

as a starting point. As two immigration

1:33:04

courts found that he was a member

1:33:06

of MS -13, when President

1:33:09

Trump declared MS -13 to be a

1:33:11

foreign terrorist organization, that

1:33:13

meant that he was no longer eligible under federal

1:33:15

law, which I'm sure you know, you're very

1:33:17

familiar with the INA, that he was

1:33:19

no longer eligible for any form of immigration

1:33:21

relief in the United States. So he

1:33:23

had a deportation order that

1:33:25

was valid which meant that under our

1:33:27

law he's not even allowed to be

1:33:30

present in the United States and had

1:33:32

to be returned because of the foreign

1:33:34

terrorist designation. This issue was

1:33:36

then by a district court judge

1:33:38

completely inverted and a district court

1:33:40

judge tried to tell the administration

1:33:42

that they had to kidnap a

1:33:45

citizen of El Salvador and fly

1:33:47

back here. That issue was raised

1:33:49

to the Supreme Court and the

1:33:51

Supreme Court said the district court

1:33:53

order was unlawful and its main

1:33:55

components were reversed 90 unanimously, stating

1:33:58

clearly that neither Secretary of State

1:34:00

nor the President could be compelled

1:34:02

by anybody to forcibly retrieve a

1:34:04

citizen of El Salvador from El

1:34:06

Salvador, who again is a member

1:34:08

of MS -13, which as

1:34:10

I'm sure you understand, rapes little girls, murders

1:34:13

women, murders children, is engaged in the most

1:34:15

barbaric activities in the world, and I can

1:34:17

promise you, if he was your neighbor, you

1:34:19

would move right away. And

1:34:23

what was the ruling in the Supreme

1:34:25

Court, Steve? Was it 9 -0? Yes, it

1:34:27

was a 9 -0. In our

1:34:29

favor. In our favor against the District

1:34:31

Court ruling, saying that no district court has

1:34:33

the power to compel the foreign policy

1:34:35

function of the United States. As Pam said,

1:34:38

the ruling solely stated that if this

1:34:40

individual at El Salvador's sole discretion

1:34:42

was sent back to our country, that

1:34:44

we could deport him a second

1:34:46

time. So

1:35:00

there's a lot there. Yeah, I

1:35:02

think I'm gonna start with I can

1:35:04

promise you if he was your

1:35:06

neighbor you would move right away and

1:35:08

I think that is really the

1:35:10

heart of what this Trump administration is

1:35:12

is doing like it's appealing to

1:35:15

this most basic like suburban crime panic

1:35:17

fear racism of well if he

1:35:19

was your neighbor you wouldn't want him

1:35:21

living next to you. Yeah like

1:35:23

if that goes to neighborhood kind of.

1:35:25

Well, just completely lying about like

1:35:27

the the context of this case yeah

1:35:29

with you know Miller saying it's

1:35:31

arrogant suggest that we the most powerful

1:35:34

country in the world are used

1:35:36

to be before the tariffs can tell

1:35:38

El Salvador how to handle its

1:35:40

citizens Falsely claiming that immigration courts deemed

1:35:42

him a member of MS -13, which

1:35:44

just just is not true Yeah

1:35:46

talking about kidnapping him from Seacot to

1:35:48

return him to the United States

1:35:51

as if ice didn't just kidnap hundreds

1:35:53

of people with no criminal records

1:35:55

and send them to a foreign gulag

1:35:57

And then also lied about the

1:35:59

Supreme Court ruling saying they found

1:36:01

the District Court order to return

1:36:03

Garcia unlawful and grossly mischaracterizing the

1:36:05

scope of what the Supreme Court

1:36:07

ruling was and how it was

1:36:09

sent back to the District Court

1:36:11

to work on the details on

1:36:14

what facilitate the return actually means. And

1:36:16

again, I think like the one of

1:36:18

the most telling parts is how he

1:36:20

ends by saying, quote, no version of

1:36:22

this ever ends up with him living

1:36:25

here. And yeah, they're gonna

1:36:27

look for any way to make this

1:36:29

test cased work, right? And if they

1:36:31

can do this to someone with protected

1:36:33

legal status who is not a terrorist,

1:36:35

who is not an actual MS -13 gang

1:36:37

member, right? This is kind of ideal

1:36:40

for them, because that means they can

1:36:42

paint anybody as a foreign policy threat

1:36:44

enough to be sent to a foreign

1:36:46

gulag. Then at the very end of

1:36:48

the clip, he passes the buck off

1:36:50

to Bukele. to have

1:36:52

him answer this question, again, perfectly

1:36:55

laying out their strategy. There's

1:36:57

a lot to break down in what

1:36:59

minister. It's also just kind of interesting how

1:37:01

Miller is like amongst the press. He's

1:37:03

not one of the people like sat on

1:37:05

the couches supposed to be giving the

1:37:07

press conference, right? He just kind of wades

1:37:09

in to, I guess, like, like offer

1:37:11

this opinion and kind of like be the

1:37:14

kind of embassy of this, of their

1:37:16

response, I guess, in a sense. I think,

1:37:18

crucially, like, Abrago Garcia's protection was from

1:37:21

being returned to El Salvador, right?

1:37:23

Because he had been harassed by gang

1:37:25

members when leaving El Salvador and

1:37:27

when living in El Salvador. He's lived

1:37:29

in the States since 2011, and

1:37:31

he left El Salvador to flee harassment

1:37:33

and abuse from gang members. Yeah,

1:37:35

the gangs that he's been accused of

1:37:38

being a part of. But like, it

1:37:40

then follows that like it would be

1:37:42

legal for them to deport him to

1:37:45

a third country, right? And that is

1:37:47

the path that they followed with all

1:37:49

the Venezuelan migrants, right? They've accused them

1:37:51

of being members of Trenderagua. I have

1:37:53

not seen a compelling case made that

1:37:55

any of them are yet. I'm

1:37:58

sure people from Trenderagua have come to this country,

1:38:00

but no, they have not provided any evidence that

1:38:02

the people they have sent to say, God, are

1:38:04

those people? No, like we said, like 14 people

1:38:06

are like accused of some kind of like violent

1:38:08

crime, like murder or rape. And

1:38:10

the other like 275 do not

1:38:12

have a criminal record whatsoever. Yeah,

1:38:14

and the bulk of this is reliant

1:38:16

on some kind of idea that they have

1:38:19

entirely created from fiction, that there are

1:38:21

tattooing practices when one enters Trenderagua. And

1:38:23

for them, right, even if they can't be

1:38:25

returned to Venezuela, they feel that they have

1:38:27

this end realm, which is, okay, we'll send

1:38:29

them to El Salvador, but for the Salvadorans,

1:38:31

that's a different question, right? And

1:38:33

that is what they're trying to find

1:38:35

here. And that is worrying because the

1:38:38

case here that it's getting the most

1:38:40

publicity that seems to be the one

1:38:42

that the Supreme Court has taken up.

1:38:44

It's about the Salvadoran man. And I

1:38:46

hope that doesn't mean that like the

1:38:48

ship has sailed for the Venezuelans, right?

1:38:50

That essentially, like they don't have a

1:38:52

case because that was the vast bulk

1:38:55

of them. I think there was only

1:38:57

like 60 Salvadoran citizens and the rest

1:38:59

Venezuelans. No, hundreds of people have been

1:39:01

like forgotten in this. After

1:39:04

Miller's rant there, Mark Rubio jumped

1:39:06

in. to state that, quote, no court

1:39:08

in the United States has the

1:39:10

right to conduct the foreign policy of

1:39:12

the United States, unquote. And

1:39:14

Stephen Miller hopped back in to talk

1:39:16

about this Supreme Court case that they're

1:39:18

falsely saying they won nine to zero,

1:39:20

which is not how that case went.

1:39:23

And they start talking more broadly about what

1:39:25

can be allowed if it has to do

1:39:27

with the foreign policy of the United States

1:39:29

and how the courts don't have the ability

1:39:31

to intervene in that process. No,

1:39:34

the foreign policy of the United States is conducted

1:39:36

by the President of the United States, not by

1:39:38

a court. And no court in the

1:39:40

United States has a right to conduct the foreign

1:39:42

policy of the United States. It's that simple. Part

1:40:03

of what I find so

1:40:05

disturbing about this idea of, you

1:40:07

know, no habeas corpus, no

1:40:09

due process. if you aren't

1:40:11

on foreign soil, is that this

1:40:13

idea of the courts having no

1:40:16

jurisdiction over foreign policy decisions means

1:40:18

that as long as you, whether

1:40:20

you're a citizen, whether you're a

1:40:22

permanent resident, documented or undocumented immigrant,

1:40:24

as long as you are forcibly

1:40:26

removed from the United States soil,

1:40:29

your rights and your due process

1:40:31

has been forfeit and the US

1:40:33

has neither the obligation nor sometimes

1:40:35

the ability to return you to

1:40:37

US soil if that is their

1:40:39

foreign policy interest. And this is

1:40:42

such a troubling broad concept that

1:40:44

the portions of the courts are

1:40:46

kind of allowing them to claim

1:40:48

right now. And the complete removal

1:40:50

of due process is like slowly

1:40:52

getting encroached upon at first with

1:40:55

undocumented immigrants and green card holders.

1:40:57

But as we will see in

1:40:59

the next section, they

1:41:01

are also absolutely going to be

1:41:03

targeting US citizens. Yeah, I think

1:41:05

we should just point out, obviously, the

1:41:07

court is not conducting the foreign policy

1:41:09

of the United States. It's ruling on

1:41:11

the legality of the action taken by

1:41:13

the president, which is exactly what it's

1:41:15

supposed to do. Yeah, and as it

1:41:17

relates to your rights for due process,

1:41:19

if you are in the United States.

1:41:21

Yeah, like every single US person, right,

1:41:23

US person, would be anybody

1:41:25

who resides in the US be they

1:41:27

documented or done documented migrant citizen will

1:41:29

have you like has a stake in

1:41:32

this. We're going to go

1:41:34

on break and then come back

1:41:36

to discuss the expansion of the

1:41:38

CCOT detention program and the possible

1:41:40

targeting of US citizens. Okay,

1:41:52

we're back. So on

1:41:54

April 7th a few weeks ago

1:41:56

while on Air Force One President

1:41:58

Trump told reporters that he would

1:42:01

be quote -unquote honored for the president

1:42:03

of El Salvador to take a

1:42:05

US citizens quote -unquote American grown

1:42:07

and born criminals and Put them

1:42:09

in C cot the terrorism confinement

1:42:11

Center prison black site saying quote

1:42:13

Why should it stop just at

1:42:15

people that cross the border illegally

1:42:17

unquote? A few days later, the

1:42:19

White House Presbyterian reiterated that this is

1:42:21

something that Trump is discussing both publicly and

1:42:23

privately. And later, during

1:42:25

the April 14th Oval Office meeting,

1:42:28

Trump said that if Salvador was

1:42:30

to build more of these

1:42:32

torture mega -presidents, the United States

1:42:35

would quote -unquote help them out

1:42:37

if the Trump administration could disappear

1:42:39

more American immigrants and U .S.

1:42:41

citizens. to these prison black

1:42:43

sites. I'd

1:42:47

do something. We'd help them out. They're

1:42:50

great facilities, very

1:42:52

strong facilities, and they

1:42:54

don't play games. I'd

1:42:57

like to go a step further. I

1:42:59

said it to Pam. I don't know what

1:43:01

the laws are. We always have to

1:43:03

obey the laws, but we also have homegrown

1:43:05

criminals that push people into subways. Hit

1:43:09

elderly ladies on the back

1:43:11

of the head with a

1:43:13

baseball bat when they're not

1:43:15

looking that are Absolute monsters.

1:43:17

I'd like to include them in the group of

1:43:19

people to get them out of the country But

1:43:21

you'll have to be looking at the laws on

1:43:23

that state, okay? So

1:43:27

this is just the start

1:43:29

of a long process that is

1:43:31

going to be deeply Troublesome

1:43:34

and worrying and again like this

1:43:36

is something that they keep

1:43:38

talking about. I think they're

1:43:40

still looking for some kind of legal

1:43:42

justification or they're looking for something

1:43:44

that maybe, if not allows for this,

1:43:46

explicitly prohibits this in a way

1:43:48

that they can't get around. Yeah,

1:43:50

did you notice he called out Miller, he

1:43:52

said you'll have to look at the laws

1:43:54

and let's see if obviously Miller is not

1:43:56

the attorney general. He also did mention attorney

1:43:58

general Pam Bondi, who's also

1:44:00

looking into this option right now.

1:44:02

Right, but Miller is often credited

1:44:04

with being the kind of mastermind

1:44:07

behind Title 42, which was an

1:44:09

extremely obscure piece of public health

1:44:11

law that was immobilized by the

1:44:13

first Trump administration to immediately return

1:44:15

migrants to Mexico without giving them

1:44:17

their right to an asylum hearing.

1:44:20

And that's what I'm wondering if they're

1:44:22

going for again. Steve Miller has

1:44:24

been very good at this, at finding

1:44:26

obscure justifications in the United States

1:44:28

federal law. for shit that they want

1:44:30

to do. I think this is

1:44:32

why they're definitely trying to stretch this

1:44:34

foreign policy claim as far as

1:44:36

they can. That if it's if it's

1:44:38

outside US soil, there's a limited

1:44:41

way US courts can actually interfere or

1:44:43

undo things that have already been

1:44:45

done. And again, like the

1:44:47

idea that we're going to like

1:44:49

fund the construction of even more

1:44:51

of these El Salvador mega prisons

1:44:53

just to house American grown and

1:44:55

born criminals as well as immigrants.

1:44:57

like you we're just funding like

1:44:59

gulag camps on foreign soil to

1:45:02

send the undesirables to and no

1:45:04

matter how much Trump talks about

1:45:06

how we're old legalists and quote

1:45:08

-unquote like American criminals there uh

1:45:10

as we've seen with with secot

1:45:12

so far like no like they

1:45:14

the majority of people they are

1:45:16

sending do not have criminal criminal

1:45:18

histories i don't think anyone can

1:45:20

trust the Trump administration's definition of

1:45:23

what is and isn't a criminal

1:45:25

to this extent anymore. Later

1:45:27

in the same meeting, Trump

1:45:29

reiterated the same idea about sending

1:45:31

US citizens who his administration

1:45:33

deems criminals to this foreign black

1:45:35

site. Here's another clip. Just

1:45:38

a follow -up question on clarification. You

1:45:41

mentioned that you're open to deporting

1:45:43

individuals that aren't foreign aliens but

1:45:45

are criminals to El Salvador. Does

1:45:47

that include potentially U .S. citizens

1:45:49

fully naturalized in America? If

1:45:52

they're criminals and if they

1:45:54

hit people with baseball backs over

1:45:56

their head that happen to

1:45:58

be 90 years old and if

1:46:00

they rape 87 -year -old women

1:46:02

in Coney Island, Brooklyn, Yeah,

1:46:05

yeah, that includes them. Why do you

1:46:07

think there's special category of person there

1:46:09

as bad as anybody that comes in?

1:46:11

We have bad ones, too. And

1:46:13

I'm all for it. We

1:46:15

have others negotiating with you. But

1:46:18

no, if it's if it's if

1:46:20

it's a homegrown criminal, I have no

1:46:22

problem. He's really obsessed with the

1:46:24

baseball bats thing. I don't quite know

1:46:26

what that's about. It seems like

1:46:28

a specific case that he's referring to.

1:46:30

Maybe it's something he remembers like

1:46:32

30 years ago, like it really got

1:46:35

stuck in his head. Right. But

1:46:37

also later, he says that they're negotiating

1:46:39

with other countries to send US

1:46:41

citizens to, not just El Salvador. Yeah.

1:46:45

I mean, they've sent migrants, third

1:46:47

country migrants to Panama before,

1:46:49

right? And detained them there.

1:46:51

Honduras, I believe, is building like

1:46:53

a prison that's not dissimilar to Secort.

1:46:55

Like... be guessing this

1:46:57

will be their sort of way

1:47:00

of courting allies in the hemisphere.

1:47:02

Like they'll sort of pay them

1:47:04

a relatively large amount in order

1:47:06

to attempt to offshore people they

1:47:08

don't like. Yeah. And again, like

1:47:10

as we've seen the past few

1:47:12

years and increasingly so now the

1:47:14

the efforts to label like activists

1:47:16

or people who are vocally opposed

1:47:18

to the United States, foreign policy,

1:47:20

the United States and the state

1:47:23

of Israel, deeming them terrorists. And

1:47:25

then by extension, if you charge them

1:47:27

with a crime, then criminals, the

1:47:29

idea that they can be housed

1:47:31

in a place like Seacot now,

1:47:33

with very, very limited to no

1:47:36

due process, the whole due process

1:47:38

question is still very up in

1:47:40

the air for how they're going

1:47:42

to handle that aspect. But you

1:47:44

can't just take this as like,

1:47:46

oh, you know, that that's just

1:47:48

Trump talking like, no, this is

1:47:50

something they really want to do.

1:47:52

And it's like one of the

1:47:54

freakiest things that I've seen in

1:47:56

like domestic U .S. politics in

1:47:58

a long time. Earlier, Trump was

1:48:00

recorded half whispering to Bukele, telling

1:48:02

him that El Salvador needs to

1:48:04

build five more sea -caught -style torture

1:48:06

prisons to house U .S. citizens, as

1:48:08

Trump says, homegrown criminals. Bukele

1:48:10

replies that they will have

1:48:12

enough room, and then the entire

1:48:15

Oval Office laughs. It's

1:48:30

the bleakest clip I've ever

1:48:32

seen before. Yeah. Talking about

1:48:34

how home groans are next. Got to build

1:48:36

five more places. Oh, we have enough

1:48:38

space. Everyone laughs. And then Trump shows off

1:48:40

the new gold frames for the portraits

1:48:42

in the Oval Office. Yeah. It's

1:48:44

like a dinner party joke

1:48:46

for them. It might just be

1:48:48

worth noting that like every

1:48:50

totalitarian regime has housed its dissidents

1:48:53

outside of the imperial core,

1:48:55

right? Like Germany did this in

1:48:57

the east, right? Russia sent

1:48:59

people to Siberia for Russia, Soviet

1:49:01

Union. Creating these like stateless

1:49:03

zones where like the regular laws

1:49:05

of your like fatherland state

1:49:07

do not apply. Right. And

1:49:09

where the horrors are so far

1:49:11

from the populace that the populace

1:49:13

can't really grasp them. Yeah. No,

1:49:15

this is like elementary school stuff.

1:49:18

It says like, like the first thing you learn about

1:49:20

is concentration camps and gulags and how that's like

1:49:22

this symbol of evil. And now

1:49:24

it's something you laugh about

1:49:26

in the Oval Office to

1:49:29

send home groans to five

1:49:31

disappearing torture camps. Yeah. And

1:49:33

like, just to be like

1:49:35

even clearer, guess what distinguishes a concentration camp

1:49:37

from a prison is that There is no

1:49:39

due process, right? People are sent there because

1:49:41

of who they are, not because of what

1:49:43

they did. Like if you're a Venezuelan man,

1:49:45

who may or may not have a tattoo. Yeah,

1:49:48

like we are, I

1:49:50

don't know what it will take for

1:49:53

some people to realize what's happening here.

1:49:55

And like the president of El Salvador

1:49:57

is so on board for this. Yeah,

1:49:59

I mean, he doesn't hide from that

1:50:01

reputation, right? He embraces it. His Twitter

1:50:03

for a while had world's coolest dictator

1:50:05

in the bio. I don't know if

1:50:07

it still does. And like both him

1:50:09

and Trump have openly align themselves with

1:50:11

quote -unquote nationalism and nationalists. They're openly

1:50:14

saying this. Trump said, dictator on day

1:50:16

one, that wasn't just a rhetorical device,

1:50:18

that was literal. This is what he's

1:50:20

doing. The El Salvador president told

1:50:22

Trump, you have 350 million people

1:50:24

to liberate, but to liberate 350 million

1:50:26

people, you have to imprison some. And

1:50:29

he followed that up by saying that he is

1:50:31

eager to help with that. In

1:50:33

fact, Mr. President, you

1:50:36

have 350 million people to

1:50:38

liberate you. But

1:50:40

to liberate 350 million people, you have

1:50:42

to imprison some. That's the

1:50:44

way it works, right? You cannot just free

1:50:46

the criminals and think that crime is

1:50:48

going to go down magically. You have to

1:50:50

imprison them so you can liberate 350

1:50:52

million Americans that are asking for the end

1:50:54

of crime and the end of terrorists.

1:50:57

Many can be done. I mean, you're doing

1:50:59

it already. So

1:51:01

I'm really happy to be here

1:51:03

honored and eager to help. This

1:51:05

whole liberation through imprisonment thing is elementary

1:51:08

school stuff here. You don't have to

1:51:10

have a PhD in the history of

1:51:12

the 1930s to have someone tell you

1:51:14

that liberation of the chosen nation by

1:51:16

purging of the undesirables is fascist shit.

1:51:18

But I'm here with one to tell

1:51:20

you if that's what you need. This

1:51:24

is textbook stuff like Garrison's

1:51:26

saying, this is not debatable. I

1:51:29

know we spent the last four years

1:51:31

debating is Trump a fascist or not.

1:51:33

I don't think that matters hugely. This

1:51:35

is a fascist thing. It's so much

1:51:37

more disturbing that now, according to polls,

1:51:40

around half the population, maybe a

1:51:42

little bit less, just agree with

1:51:44

the current way that deportations are

1:51:46

happening and Trump's immigration policy on

1:51:48

a completely flat basis. And if

1:51:50

you spend any time on X,

1:51:52

the Everything app, watching videos of

1:51:54

these press conferences, it's full of

1:51:56

people just like, cheering this on

1:51:58

completely, like completely blankly. I think

1:52:00

that's a very skewed sample of

1:52:02

people who paid for Elon Musk's

1:52:04

payout. Of course, of course. But

1:52:06

like the number of people. Yeah,

1:52:09

it's real humans. Like these are real

1:52:11

people who just just completely, completely blankly

1:52:13

think this is a this is this

1:52:15

is a net good and like this

1:52:17

is this people are unreachable. You cannot

1:52:19

come back from that. Like you is

1:52:21

there is no coming back from that

1:52:23

if you believe that the way deportations

1:52:25

are currently happening is fair, just and

1:52:28

right. Like, I cannot understand you as

1:52:30

a human anymore. That is so, like,

1:52:32

divorced and, like, alien. Yeah, you've

1:52:34

gone past the point of no return, right? Like...

1:52:36

Liberals who, like, shield their eyes from,

1:52:38

like, the horrors at the border. Like, I

1:52:40

don't agree with that, but in some

1:52:42

ways, I can, like, understand it. The open,

1:52:44

like, cheering on of this is, like,

1:52:46

a whole other level. Yeah, it's not like

1:52:48

I can't bear to see it. I'm

1:52:50

gonna ignore it because it'll cause me to

1:52:52

confront the contradictions. It's... I'm seeing it,

1:52:54

I'm watching it, and I think it's fucking

1:52:56

great. The last thing I'm gonna play

1:52:58

here, a CNN reporter asked

1:53:00

Trump if he would obey a

1:53:03

Supreme Court order to return someone

1:53:05

to the United States. Instead of

1:53:07

answering this question, Trump attacked the

1:53:09

reporter and complained about how she

1:53:11

wasn't praising him for deporting criminals. Yeah,

1:53:37

mad. Very

1:53:39

textbook authoritarian like blanket stuff like

1:53:41

there's nothing to like commentate about

1:53:43

that. It just is what it

1:53:46

is I guess we do have

1:53:48

some breaking news because we're recording

1:53:50

this on Tuesday James want to

1:53:52

do want to in possibly five

1:53:54

minutes or less Fill us in

1:53:56

about the the update from it

1:53:58

from the district court on Garcia's

1:54:00

since it was sent back to

1:54:02

the district court from the Supreme

1:54:04

Court last week regarding his possible

1:54:06

facilitated return to the United States

1:54:08

Right. So much of this has

1:54:10

hinged over what facilitate means, right?

1:54:12

Like they found a legal concept

1:54:14

that they can argue ad nauseam.

1:54:16

And in this case, it's the

1:54:18

word facilitate. DOJ didn't

1:54:20

present any new information

1:54:22

today, but we see that like

1:54:24

there's some hopeful things from a district

1:54:26

court judge, and then it kind of all

1:54:28

goes up in flames. But I think

1:54:31

genus is XI and I. S is how

1:54:33

the name is spelled. I

1:54:35

believe it's genus. I said that every day

1:54:37

that he's there, it's a day of

1:54:39

further irreparable harm. She talks

1:54:41

about the process being at the roots of

1:54:43

the Constitution. She's ordered for

1:54:45

two weeks more of discovery, which

1:54:48

is going to mean that both sides have

1:54:50

more time to repair their cases. She wants people

1:54:52

to testify in front of the court. So

1:54:54

the administration has argued that

1:54:57

facilitating his return would consist of

1:54:59

them allowing him to enter

1:55:01

the United States if Bukele released

1:55:03

him, and possibly providing a

1:55:05

flight for that to happen, but

1:55:07

not crucially ensuring his release

1:55:09

from Secord, right? And so

1:55:12

anything else subsequent to that doesn't matter. Ginny

1:55:14

said that their interpretation of the

1:55:16

word flies in the face of the

1:55:18

plain meaning of the word, quote,

1:55:21

when a wrongfully removed individual is And

1:55:23

then I'm adding to the quote here, I

1:55:25

guess, or context. She means when

1:55:27

a wrongfully removed individual is taken outside the

1:55:29

US, it's not so cut and dried that

1:55:31

all you have to do is remove obstacles

1:55:33

domestically. She also said, quote, to

1:55:35

the Department of Justice here, you made your

1:55:37

jurisdiction or arguments, you made your venue arguments,

1:55:39

you made your arguments on the merits, you

1:55:41

lost. This is now about

1:55:43

the scope of the remedy, right? This

1:55:46

is the case that Miller is claiming

1:55:48

they won. That's pretty unequivocal for a

1:55:50

justice. However, She does

1:55:52

not seem to think that it

1:55:54

is within her power to

1:55:56

request his return from El Salvador.

1:55:59

She's calling for things to move

1:56:01

quickly. They want to

1:56:03

conduct depositions by the 23rd of April.

1:56:06

She said, quote, cancel vacations, cancel other appointments. I'm

1:56:08

usually pretty good about it, not this time.

1:56:10

I'm going to be available if you need to

1:56:12

do it odd hours or weekends. That's what

1:56:14

I'm talking about. Anything

1:56:18

short of a judge saying you have

1:56:20

to go to secote remove him from the

1:56:23

cell put him on the plane and

1:56:25

bring him back to America It's going to

1:56:27

be interpreted by the Trump administration to

1:56:29

mean that they don't have to do that

1:56:31

Yeah, they're gonna weasel their way around

1:56:33

it the same way you heard Stephen Miller

1:56:35

weasel his way around every question and

1:56:37

with truth being used as a flexible medium

1:56:39

to shape a sculpture of their choosing.

1:56:41

And they've done that right. The word facilitate,

1:56:43

I think most people who are first

1:56:45

language English speakers have a fairly good grasp

1:56:47

of what that means, and it doesn't

1:56:49

mean like remove barriers domestically. That's

1:56:51

what they've gone for. The

1:56:53

only way that he is getting

1:56:55

out is a majority Supreme Court

1:56:57

decision that is extremely explicit, that

1:56:59

directs. the Trump administration to go

1:57:01

to El Salvador and remove him

1:57:04

from that prison. I haven't

1:57:06

seen anything to indicate that

1:57:08

we're getting that anytime soon. And

1:57:10

as the judge said, every day he's there.

1:57:12

He's a reputable harm is done to him.

1:57:15

And that's where we're at right

1:57:17

now, right? With people arguing over

1:57:19

the definition of a word, as

1:57:21

hundreds of people are locked up

1:57:23

having done nothing wrong in a

1:57:26

giant torture prison. And this is

1:57:28

not the only person who We

1:57:30

believe it was was quote -unquote mistakenly

1:57:32

sent others reporting today coming out

1:57:34

of documented New York Yeah, good

1:57:36

outlet by the way a father

1:57:38

of a 19 year old legal

1:57:40

legal immigrant from Brooklyn this 19

1:57:42

year old with with no no

1:57:44

tattoos Was kidnapped off the streets

1:57:46

of New York the quote from

1:57:48

his father reads quote the officers

1:57:51

grabbed him and two other boys

1:57:53

right at the entrance to our

1:57:55

building one said no He's not

1:57:57

the one like they were looking

1:57:59

for someone else. One officer to

1:58:01

be clear. Correct. Yeah. But

1:58:03

the other officer said,

1:58:05

take him anyway, unquote.

1:58:08

And now this father exactly

1:58:10

a month later is still

1:58:12

looking for his missing son

1:58:14

who is disappeared into an

1:58:16

El Salvador torture prison. Yeah,

1:58:18

Jesus. Like I've said before

1:58:21

on this show, like one of the

1:58:23

things that I learned and the daring

1:58:25

gap was how much people can care

1:58:27

about their kids and like this shit

1:58:29

that I saw people do to ensure

1:58:31

their kids have a better life like

1:58:33

broke my heart in a way that

1:58:36

war hasn't they're like anything else I've

1:58:38

seen in my life hasn't and it's

1:58:40

like honestly really hard for me to

1:58:42

hear stuff like that and and like

1:58:44

not react just being really sad or

1:58:46

really angry like it's fucking brutal. Things

1:58:49

are looking a lot more grim in my

1:58:51

mind than they were when we recorded that.

1:58:53

Should you leave the United States episode? I

1:58:56

still think the things I

1:58:58

said there, I stand by and

1:59:00

I stand by the only

1:59:02

recommendation I have is to create

1:59:04

options for yourself. And I

1:59:06

think those options should be created

1:59:08

as soon as possible, especially

1:59:10

if your citizenship is a topic

1:59:12

of debate according to the

1:59:14

United States government. But even

1:59:17

that will not keep you safe

1:59:19

as we've talked about today. Your options

1:59:21

include creating networks to take care

1:59:23

of one another. The

1:59:25

things that will probably affect

1:59:27

more of you than

1:59:29

direct state violence, our economic

1:59:31

downturns, our recessions, things

1:59:34

like this, those are things that you

1:59:36

can take care of one another through. You

1:59:39

should plan to do that too. You

1:59:41

should think about... are you going to pay your bills?

1:59:43

How are you going to feed each other? How are you

1:59:45

going to take care of your medical needs? Because

1:59:48

I don't think that the world

1:59:50

is going to want to keep

1:59:52

doing business with a country that

1:59:54

acts like this. Both

1:59:56

economically and in terms of its

1:59:59

conduct towards migrants. So your

2:00:01

plans don't have to be to

2:00:03

leave. Your plans should

2:00:05

also include what to do if

2:00:07

things get really bad in an

2:00:09

economic sense. I'm not going to

2:00:11

tell you what that means, but...

2:00:13

It's all the stuff we've already

2:00:15

talked about, right? It's mutual aid.

2:00:17

It's all the basic preparedness stuff

2:00:19

that is not as big and

2:00:21

scary as leaving the country, but

2:00:23

is nonetheless vital. We

2:00:26

will continue to report on the

2:00:28

Garcia case, other court cases

2:00:31

regarding these 300 people

2:00:33

renditioned to El Salvador and

2:00:35

CCOT in the next

2:00:37

few weeks. Yeah. Just

2:00:39

to finish up. As things

2:00:41

continue to get worse, people keep

2:00:43

reaching out to us, which

2:00:45

we appreciate. If you would like

2:00:48

to, you can email us

2:00:50

coolzontipsatproton .me. We will read it.

2:00:52

We might not get back to you. Your

2:00:54

email is not end to end encrypted unless the

2:00:56

email that you're sending from is also encrypted. But

2:00:59

you can reach out to us there. See you

2:01:01

on the other side. Wasn't

2:01:19

that delicious? So good. Your

2:01:21

bill, ladies? I got it. No,

2:01:23

I got it. Seriously,

2:01:25

I insist. I insisted first. Don't

2:01:27

be silly. You don't be silly.

2:01:29

People with the Wells Fargo Active

2:01:31

Cash Credit Card prefer to pay

2:01:33

because they earn unlimited 2 %

2:01:36

cash back on purchases. OK. Rock,

2:01:38

paper, scissors for it. Rock, paper,

2:01:40

scissors. Shoot. No! The

2:01:42

Wells Fargo Active Cash Credit

2:01:44

Card. Visit wellsfargo.com slash activecash.

2:01:46

Terms apply. Does

2:01:48

this podcast make you happy? Of

2:01:51

course it does. That's why you're

2:01:53

here. But it only comes out once

2:01:55

a week. For happiness every night? You

2:01:57

need Adam and Eve. Yes,

2:01:59

I'm talking about sex toys. It's

2:02:02

cool. It's cool. You have earbuds in, right?

2:02:05

Adam and Eve, America's most trusted source

2:02:07

for adult products, has been making

2:02:09

people very happy for over 50 years,

2:02:11

with thousands of toys for both

2:02:13

men and women. Just go

2:02:15

to adamandve.com now and enter code

2:02:17

iHeart for 50 % off almost

2:02:19

any one item, plus free,

2:02:21

discreet shipping. That's adamandve.com code iHeart

2:02:24

for 50 % off. Every

2:02:26

morning brings a fresh new

2:02:28

energy. This is today. And

2:02:31

no matter what the day holds we

2:02:33

come to the today show for all

2:02:35

of it. When things are tough, we

2:02:37

talk about it. When there's something to

2:02:39

figure out, we dig into it. And

2:02:41

when there's joy, we celebrate it. Because

2:02:43

today is where it's all happening. We

2:02:45

get the best start to every

2:02:48

morning because we started together. Watch

2:02:50

the Today Show with Savannah Guthrie

2:02:52

and Craig Melvin weekdays at 7am

2:02:54

on NBC. Get this,

2:02:56

adults with financial literacy skills have

2:02:58

82 % more wealth than those who

2:03:00

don't. From swimming lessons to piano classes,

2:03:02

us parents invest in so many

2:03:04

things to enrich our kids' lives, but

2:03:06

are we investing in their future

2:03:08

financial success? With Greenlight, you

2:03:10

can teach your kids financial literacy

2:03:13

skills like earning, saving, and

2:03:15

investing, and this investment costs less

2:03:17

than that after -school treat. Start

2:03:19

prioritizing their financial education in

2:03:21

future today with a risk -free

2:03:23

trial at greenlight.com slash iHeart, greenlight.com

2:03:26

slash iHeart. We

2:03:47

haven't really done much coverage of just

2:03:49

straight up, how do you do a

2:03:51

strike? So today we are

2:03:53

going to be covering a pretty long running

2:03:55

strike. We're going to say how many days

2:03:57

it's been going. It's unclear when this episode

2:03:59

is going to come out. So who fucking

2:04:02

knows how long it'll be when you hear

2:04:04

it. But yeah, with me to talk about

2:04:06

this strike is Spencer Jordan, who is a

2:04:08

rank and file member of the Urban Orworkers

2:04:10

Union. Spencer, welcome to the show. Hey, thank

2:04:12

you so much for having me. Yeah. Yeah,

2:04:14

I'm excited to talk to you about this.

2:04:16

So this is what day is it today?

2:04:18

I should know this. April 15th.

2:04:20

And as of April 15th, you've been

2:04:22

on strike for 25 days. Yeah, that's

2:04:24

just about right. Yeah, it started on

2:04:26

the of March. We

2:04:29

held our strike vote

2:04:31

like a solid 12 days

2:04:33

before we actually went

2:04:35

out on the picket line

2:04:37

and One that

2:04:39

strike vote with 14 yeses

2:04:41

a single no and I think

2:04:43

four four abstentions Yeah, yeah,

2:04:45

so 93 % of those voting

2:04:47

voted yes. Yeah, which good good

2:04:49

ratios good ratios. I think

2:04:51

like Typically you want at least

2:04:54

like mid 70s. Mm -hmm if

2:04:56

we're gonna do this kind

2:04:58

of thing But you know as

2:05:00

listeners of the show hopefully

2:05:02

understand by now you can't just

2:05:04

like call a strike and

2:05:06

have it happen you know,

2:05:08

you have to do a whole bunch of

2:05:10

organizing. So I want to kind of start

2:05:12

at the dynamics of the organizing of how

2:05:14

the shop got going because this is a

2:05:16

pretty small shop from the sounds of it. And

2:05:19

yeah. Yeah. So do you want to talk

2:05:21

a bit about what the basic process of

2:05:23

getting this organizing started was like and what

2:05:25

the sort of like social mapping looked like

2:05:27

and stuff like that? Yeah.

2:05:29

So the organization process

2:05:31

started around like

2:05:33

a year and a

2:05:35

half before We actually

2:05:37

had our unionization vote, which was

2:05:40

actually, we had the vote in

2:05:42

March and we got our win

2:05:44

on April 7th two years ago.

2:05:46

So we actually just had

2:05:48

our union two year birthday. Oh, happy

2:05:51

birthday. But

2:05:53

yeah, so preceding that was like,

2:05:55

like I said, about a year

2:05:57

and a half of organizing that

2:05:59

involved, you know, the typical thing

2:06:01

of like one -on -one conversations with

2:06:04

like all the staff making the,

2:06:06

you know, color coded spreadsheet and

2:06:08

everything, which all of

2:06:10

this was not my my purview.

2:06:12

I'm a lot more involved now

2:06:14

than I was at the start

2:06:16

of the process. And I was

2:06:18

approached by like one of our

2:06:21

lead organizers really shortly after being

2:06:23

hired just to kind of, you

2:06:25

know, read the dipstick as to

2:06:27

like my sentiments about it and

2:06:29

whatnot. I was pretty on

2:06:31

board right away. I mean, you

2:06:33

know, like I'm from the Bay

2:06:36

Area, so... There are only two

2:06:38

types of people from the Bay

2:06:40

Area. We wouldn't be having one

2:06:42

of them on the show. Yeah,

2:06:44

exactly. So I'm of

2:06:46

the latter type. So, you know,

2:06:48

being pro -union isn't like a foreign

2:06:50

thing to my background. Uh -huh.

2:06:52

Uh -huh. You don't look like a

2:06:54

tech worker. Yeah, no. Yeah,

2:06:57

especially like my family's from the Midwest

2:06:59

and everything. So there's my... My aunt actually

2:07:01

just learned that she was like a

2:07:03

clerk working for the railroads back in the

2:07:05

day when like railroad jobs were still

2:07:07

like a big thing you could have. Anyways.

2:07:11

But yeah, so I had had my

2:07:13

like own sort of like just

2:07:15

observations of like, whoa, like what's what's

2:07:17

going on in the workplace? Aside

2:07:19

from like my own just like

2:07:21

predilection to thinking, you know, more

2:07:24

worker power is better. Yeah. Also

2:07:26

kind of seeing like some of

2:07:28

the factors that precipitated it. Like

2:07:30

for instance, like When I was

2:07:32

hired here, I was hired

2:07:34

in my interview. It was

2:07:36

one of the owners and

2:07:38

the manager of my department,

2:07:40

my department being Salvagen Recycling

2:07:42

Department of Urbanor, which is

2:07:44

kind of like not super

2:07:46

public facing. We go to

2:07:48

the dump and like root

2:07:51

around through the garbage like, you

2:07:54

know, whatever, get to get stuff for the store. But

2:07:57

that manager, You

2:07:59

know, he was there in

2:08:01

the interview and we got

2:08:03

to the portion where the

2:08:05

owner explained what at will

2:08:07

employment is. Oh, and she

2:08:09

and she went. So we're

2:08:11

at will here. So,

2:08:13

um, Sam. Well, Sam was

2:08:15

my manager. Sam. Well, how long have

2:08:18

you been here? 21 years. He's there.

2:08:20

Hands folded on the table. Yes.

2:08:22

What that will means is, uh, it

2:08:25

could be tomorrow. I could say,

2:08:27

you know, Sam. Well, It's been a

2:08:29

great 21 years. I really

2:08:31

appreciate all the work you've done. Today's your last day. Why

2:08:34

would you say that? And he has to

2:08:36

sit there and go, hmm. Jesus

2:08:39

Christ. And then she says, of

2:08:42

course, likewise, tomorrow someone could

2:08:44

come to me and say, hey, Mary

2:08:46

Lou, it's been 21

2:08:49

years. I've enjoyed it.

2:08:51

I'm quitting. So, you

2:08:53

know, the sort of sword over his

2:08:55

neck. It's being cast as

2:08:57

somehow equal to him not

2:08:59

being like indentured. Yes.

2:09:02

What are we doing here? This also

2:09:04

just, I mean, like, you know, yeah,

2:09:06

on the basic level, yeah, it's like,

2:09:09

okay, your opponent, I guess they are

2:09:11

your opponent. Your boss can just instantly

2:09:13

fire you for any reason whatsoever, for

2:09:15

any amount of time. And then also

2:09:17

you could quit the job. And

2:09:20

then I'll say it, I feel

2:09:22

like just as a management tactic,

2:09:24

like, Are you, like,

2:09:26

trying to piss off your support units? Like,

2:09:29

what? I

2:09:31

have never had a boss, like,

2:09:33

just do that in a hiring

2:09:35

meeting. What? Yeah,

2:09:37

I mean, have you worked

2:09:39

at, like, a

2:09:41

sort of small, like, mom and

2:09:44

pop, quote unquote, business before?

2:09:46

Yeah, I mean, that's probably why,

2:09:48

because I've usually had, like,

2:09:50

larger E. My shitty jobs

2:09:52

have either been like government jobs or

2:09:54

like, like larger companies. So there

2:09:56

was less of the like, I

2:09:58

heard a line recently that I wish

2:10:01

I remember where it was from. It might

2:10:03

be a line from Star Trek. Like

2:10:05

one of the Ferengi rules is just

2:10:07

like treat your employees like family, exploit them

2:10:09

ruthlessly, which I

2:10:11

like. You know, that's a,

2:10:13

that's a traditional line in

2:10:15

business, especially in small business.

2:10:17

And it's a, it's no

2:10:20

stranger here. Yeah, that question

2:10:22

of like, wanting to piss

2:10:24

off your subordinates or whatever, it's,

2:10:26

I don't know if

2:10:28

pissing off is necessarily like

2:10:30

the concern, but ownership

2:10:32

here, definitely, I've

2:10:35

gotten the impression that they

2:10:37

enjoy showing their power. And

2:10:39

I've gotten the impression that

2:10:41

the sort of like uncertainty

2:10:43

and like, yeah, my mom

2:10:45

would call it jockeying for

2:10:47

position that you have to

2:10:49

do is a dynamic that

2:10:51

they... I really can't say

2:10:53

they honestly because the other

2:10:55

owner, he hasn't been very

2:10:57

active in the business since

2:10:59

my hiring, but at

2:11:01

least Mary Lou tends to

2:11:03

lean on. That's kind of

2:11:05

like the special quality that

2:11:08

you get with a small business

2:11:10

and organizing in a small

2:11:12

workplace. You can see

2:11:14

sort of in their public

2:11:16

communications the way that... The

2:11:18

zucks and the basis is

2:11:21

the rest of them feel

2:11:23

about their employees and you

2:11:25

know You can get a

2:11:27

sense of perhaps how them

2:11:30

might act towards their employees

2:11:32

if they like interact with

2:11:34

them on a daily basis

2:11:36

But it in a small

2:11:38

business setting you really get

2:11:41

a keen view into how

2:11:43

like the power of the

2:11:45

employer mixes very readily with a

2:11:49

person's predilection

2:11:51

towards discipline, predilection

2:11:53

towards personal, what

2:11:57

did you call it? Personal

2:11:59

battling, almost. Yeah. And

2:12:01

it's also like, it's inescapable in a way

2:12:03

that it isn't with, if you're

2:12:05

dealing with people who are, you're at a larger company,

2:12:07

you're not dealing with the person. There's

2:12:09

an old Chinese expression that it's like, heaven

2:12:12

is high and the emperor is far away. So,

2:12:15

you know, it's like, you know, like a lot

2:12:17

of times you're dealing with, okay, yeah, there is

2:12:19

like, you know, your Zuckerberg is there, but he's like,

2:12:21

he never interacts with you. But with this, it's

2:12:23

like, no, the small business tyrant is right there

2:12:25

in your face all the time, and all of

2:12:27

the weird petty shit that they want to do,

2:12:30

and all of this sort of like, you

2:12:32

know, and I would say this isn't just like a

2:12:34

unique thing of like small business owners, like people in

2:12:36

all positions, like in all

2:12:38

portions of like the class society, have

2:12:41

in them kind of like the capacity

2:12:43

for cruelty and there's just people like that.

2:12:45

But they don't normally have the ability

2:12:47

to just do it to you directly

2:12:50

in your face. And that's, yeah, and

2:12:52

that's like, you know, this is what you've been

2:12:54

talking about is like, yeah, you have like these small

2:12:56

business tyrants like every suddenly in the same way

2:12:58

that like, I don't know, you're dealing with like. Like

2:13:01

one of the random King

2:13:03

Louis and you're like in the

2:13:05

court and suddenly just like

2:13:07

the fact that this guy doesn't

2:13:09

like people going to the

2:13:11

bathroom means that everyone around him

2:13:14

doesn't get a doesn't get

2:13:16

a shit, right? Like it's just

2:13:18

like yeah No, exactly. It's

2:13:20

like it's actually an argument that

2:13:22

She's deployed in her reddit

2:13:24

correspondence, which has been seemingly a

2:13:26

pretty active part of her

2:13:29

spare time that she's not spending

2:13:31

at the bargaining table with

2:13:33

us You know made this comparison

2:13:35

of like this isn't a

2:13:37

question about oligarchs or whatever and

2:13:39

it's true like the small

2:13:41

businessman is not an oligarch but

2:13:44

the small business is a

2:13:46

microcosm of like the larger capitalist

2:13:48

social order and while the

2:13:50

small business man might not have

2:13:52

the scope of power of

2:13:54

the oligarch or like the actual

2:13:57

capital resources of an oligarch,

2:13:59

the behavior certainly rhymes at least.

2:14:01

Yeah. And again, it's a

2:14:03

lot of it is about, it's

2:14:05

just how much power you

2:14:07

have access to, right? Lots

2:14:10

of people can be like this,

2:14:12

but only the few, the proud, the

2:14:14

small business type get to do it. Yeah,

2:14:17

totally. And ultimately,

2:14:20

the employer, wherever they are, they're

2:14:22

in this privileged position of being

2:14:24

able to, you spend

2:14:27

most people more than like a third of your life

2:14:29

at work. The employer has

2:14:31

this unique power to dictate what that

2:14:33

third of your life looks like. We

2:14:36

talk about, I mean,

2:14:38

shit, we don't. People are

2:14:40

not so much talking about democracy

2:14:43

writ large in the US

2:14:45

in the same way now that

2:14:47

they used to, but

2:14:49

you talk about this idea of

2:14:51

like living in a democracy, but

2:14:54

democracy ends at the shop door.

2:14:56

yeah and and like the the

2:14:59

kind of power that these people

2:15:01

have is something that like these

2:15:03

people get to control when you

2:15:05

can go to the bathroom like

2:15:07

what clothes you wear like literally

2:15:09

what you can do what you

2:15:12

can say at any given time

2:15:14

if you employed the exact level

2:15:16

of control that your boss has

2:15:18

over you on a state, it would be

2:15:20

a totalitarian state. And yet, everyone

2:15:22

seems to think that this is sort of

2:15:24

like, you know, and this is

2:15:26

an argument I've been making about, like,

2:15:28

Trump, is that like, yeah, this is,

2:15:30

this is, this is what sort of Trump and Elon

2:15:32

and like that whole cadre and, you know, know, and,

2:15:34

know, if you want to go into this sort of

2:15:37

ideologues behind it too, this is what people like Peter

2:15:39

Thiel Want when they say

2:15:41

run the government like a business what

2:15:43

they mean is that they want

2:15:45

to like to import the sort of

2:15:47

like just the pure tyranny of

2:15:49

the workplace and Expand it into the

2:15:51

entire political system so that they're

2:15:53

there like sort of pure like Totalitarian

2:15:55

corporate rule can't be challenged. Yeah.

2:15:57

Yeah, I mean wasn't it Mussolini who

2:15:59

coined the term the corporate state? Probably

2:16:02

although it would not surprise me if

2:16:04

it was like some other fascist theorist

2:16:06

and Mussolini just started saying it because

2:16:10

Yeah, but yeah, like that's you know, that's

2:16:12

a substantive thing here and what this

2:16:14

also means is that like Even in ways

2:16:17

that are sort of hard to see

2:16:19

like a fight over democracy in the workplace

2:16:21

Right is a is a part of

2:16:23

the larger struggle against all of all the

2:16:25

thing that's happening because if you know

2:16:27

if we're gonna survive this and if we're

2:16:29

gonna make sure that We don't all

2:16:31

live in a world where like if you

2:16:34

say the wrong thing you can be

2:16:36

sent to a prison camp Democracy,

2:16:38

if you want this to survive, is going

2:16:40

to have to march into the layer of

2:16:42

the beast. It is going to have to

2:16:44

go into the source of this tyranny itself,

2:16:46

which is the workplace, and it's going to

2:16:48

have to crush it there. Yeah,

2:16:51

I mean, you said it

2:16:53

very aptly there, like the

2:16:55

corporate structure mirrors the totalitarian

2:16:57

structure. And

2:17:00

not only does fighting

2:17:02

the corporate structure at

2:17:04

the level of labor

2:17:06

make sense, And that,

2:17:08

right, labor is what

2:17:10

enables the flow of

2:17:13

capital that sustains the

2:17:15

totalitarian state. But also, like

2:17:18

you said, you're addressing the

2:17:20

structure in its, I don't

2:17:22

know, I almost think of

2:17:24

it as like the, you

2:17:26

know, like Grendel's mother in

2:17:28

the Fenn or whatever. And

2:17:30

like, you know, the...

2:17:32

The authoritarian thing is

2:17:35

like, is like Grendel maybe

2:17:37

and like Grendel's mother

2:17:39

is like this capitalist hierarchical

2:17:41

structure. Yeah. You know,

2:17:43

you take it on with

2:17:45

an insistence on workplace

2:17:47

democracy as kind of Libby

2:17:49

as that's that sounds. Okay,

2:17:53

speaking of capitalist utilitarianism, I

2:17:55

hear the ads that we are

2:17:57

required to run by our

2:18:00

corporates. Oh, beautiful, beautiful. Let's

2:18:02

hear them. And

2:18:14

we are back.

2:18:18

So let's get back a little

2:18:20

bit towards the more concrete parts

2:18:22

of the Union, although I do

2:18:24

have more to say eventually at

2:18:26

some point about the way

2:18:28

that sort of labor liberalism co -opted democracy

2:18:30

in the workplace from like, you know,

2:18:32

the old sort of like anarchist idea

2:18:34

of workers control, right? But, okay, so

2:18:36

one thing I wanted to talk about

2:18:39

before we sort of get into the

2:18:41

more formal stuff about the strike is

2:18:43

I'm really interested to hear you talk

2:18:45

about what the process of kind of

2:18:47

onboarding you to get more involved in

2:18:49

the union is because this is something

2:18:52

that like, okay, every functional

2:18:54

union wants to do this. Like if

2:18:56

your union is not trying to bring

2:18:58

People like its members like more to

2:19:00

get more involved in the union and

2:19:02

become more of the people becoming like

2:19:04

core organizers and becoming You know like

2:19:06

there's people who are doing your bargain

2:19:08

people are doing anything like your union

2:19:10

is There's weird shit about it and

2:19:12

you should probably like be looking into

2:19:14

that But it's pretty hard. So yeah,

2:19:16

can you talk a bit about the

2:19:18

process of like how you were brought

2:19:20

in and What sort of worked and

2:19:22

what didn't? Well, I

2:19:24

think Ultimately,

2:19:26

the easiest thing is

2:19:29

a sort of ramping

2:19:31

up degree of responsibility

2:19:33

within the organization. So

2:19:35

at the start, I would come

2:19:37

to some of the meetings. I

2:19:40

would miss some of them. I'd be

2:19:42

like, oh, I'm fucking so busy with

2:19:44

whatever is going on in my life.

2:19:46

And I was supportive and sort of

2:19:48

involved, but I wasn't

2:19:50

like... master wasn't doing things

2:19:53

like this. And,

2:19:56

you know,

2:19:58

eventually, one,

2:20:00

we kind of persisted as a union

2:20:03

over a longer period of time. The

2:20:05

necessity of involvement

2:20:08

became more obvious

2:20:10

to me, right?

2:20:13

And that's a hard ask,

2:20:15

you know, like, you're organizing, you

2:20:18

want momentum and you want

2:20:20

Yeah, you want to be able

2:20:23

to change your conditions for the

2:20:25

better as soon as possible. Yeah,

2:20:27

and with with urban or You

2:20:29

know Lots of workplaces that need

2:20:31

unionization have high turnover, right? And

2:20:33

urban or is no different

2:20:35

and so I saw you know,

2:20:37

like some of the more

2:20:39

committed elements of the bargaining unit

2:20:41

fired or quit or whatever

2:20:44

and You know, they'd be replaced

2:20:46

with other people and you

2:20:48

have to begin the work of

2:20:50

organizing over again and with

2:20:52

some of them you succeed with

2:20:54

something you don't. You have

2:20:56

different dynamics. I feel like

2:20:58

the hiring procedures may have changed a little

2:21:00

bit after one of our elections. But

2:21:03

I can't say that for certain. So

2:21:06

the necessity of keeping that

2:21:08

flame going, especially after we had

2:21:10

won the election, we were

2:21:12

in contract bargaining for a long

2:21:14

period of time, made

2:21:16

me feel a sense of

2:21:19

I need to be more active

2:21:21

in this because this is an

2:21:23

important struggle. And I

2:21:25

see our main organizers

2:21:28

taking on a fuckload

2:21:30

of work and needing

2:21:32

more voices at the

2:21:34

table, needing more people

2:21:36

to be more involved.

2:21:39

And so I volunteered

2:21:41

to run for

2:21:44

treasurer. I was the

2:21:46

only candidate. But

2:21:48

theoretically, I could have been voted down. They could have

2:21:50

been like, I don't know about Spencer. And

2:21:54

I ended up having a little

2:21:56

bit more direct responsibilities. I was

2:21:58

receiving some of the donations to

2:22:00

our strike fund. Once we started

2:22:02

fundraising for the strike, I had

2:22:04

to keep track of those and

2:22:06

put them in a special bank

2:22:08

account. And then eventually, take that

2:22:10

money, get it to the IWW

2:22:12

branch, hand it.

2:22:14

Hand a big check to

2:22:16

Dino That kind of

2:22:19

stuff and just like having

2:22:21

like little things to

2:22:23

be doing like spurs involvement

2:22:25

Other people, you know

2:22:27

became responsible for like parts

2:22:29

of social media outreach

2:22:32

make graphics stuff like that

2:22:34

and Also like sort

2:22:36

of I guess giving people

2:22:38

the opportunity to Leverage

2:22:41

their individual connections within the work

2:22:43

because every workplace is like clicks and

2:22:45

groups and subgroups and all that

2:22:47

To leverage those connections in like service

2:22:49

of bettering everyone's conditions So like

2:22:52

to a certain degree I've I've been

2:22:54

like important as like an envoy

2:22:56

to my particular department because it's our

2:22:58

Job takes us away from the

2:23:00

job site or like from like the

2:23:02

main the main work site often

2:23:04

and stuff like that so there's

2:23:07

less of a direct avenue for communication

2:23:09

there. So I can say

2:23:11

that's my experience. As far

2:23:13

as organizing goes, I'm easy.

2:23:16

I was already believing in

2:23:18

it. And there

2:23:20

are others that

2:23:22

it's been harder. I

2:23:25

will say, though,

2:23:27

that the strike itself

2:23:29

is, I mean, a

2:23:32

strike is a conflict. And

2:23:34

when you're in conflict together, it's

2:23:36

an extremely co -hearing force Yeah,

2:23:38

which doesn't just say that

2:23:40

like necessarily you want your unionization

2:23:43

to come to a strike

2:23:45

but Perhaps like raising a sort

2:23:47

of consciousness of like the

2:23:49

fact that like you are ultimately

2:23:51

like in conflict with the

2:23:53

boss Yeah, the boss doesn't want

2:23:55

you to unionize The boss

2:23:57

doesn't want you to force concessions

2:23:59

out of them and that

2:24:01

like as a union we are

2:24:03

taking on this responsibility to

2:24:05

look after each other's interests and

2:24:07

to support each other tangibly

2:24:09

in terms of what we do

2:24:11

and also intangibly in terms

2:24:14

of the kind of conversations we

2:24:16

have around morale, planning

2:24:18

and stuff like that to

2:24:20

succeed together. I think

2:24:22

those are really potent,

2:24:24

coherent forces and it

2:24:26

helps to have a

2:24:28

good opponent. The boss

2:24:30

is the best organizer. At

2:24:33

Urbanor, you don't

2:24:35

go along without

2:24:37

coming head to

2:24:39

head with conflict

2:24:41

with ownership or

2:24:43

with ownership through

2:24:45

the mediator of

2:24:47

management. Although

2:24:49

support for the union

2:24:52

might be divided

2:24:54

a bit at the

2:24:56

workplace. One thing

2:24:58

that's pretty universal is frustration

2:25:00

with ownership. Yeah. So,

2:25:02

okay, speaking of, speaking of a frustration

2:25:04

with ownership, it is time for us

2:25:06

to go to ads one last time.

2:25:09

Oh, beautiful. But then after we come

2:25:11

back, strike, strike, strike, strike, strike, strike,

2:25:13

strike. Just after this message. Oh,

2:25:15

God. Okay,

2:25:26

we are back from a bunch of people who

2:25:28

almost assuredly do not want you to go on

2:25:30

strike, but Yeah, so

2:25:33

let's get into the

2:25:35

process of how you

2:25:37

actually organize a strike.

2:25:40

Yeah, let's start from just like the

2:25:42

very beginning. What are the kind

2:25:44

of things that were happening that made people think that

2:25:46

you needed to do this in the first place? So

2:25:49

the strike itself is

2:25:51

a result specifically like

2:25:53

this is a ULP

2:25:55

strike. So it's

2:25:57

in response to something

2:26:00

that falls under the category

2:26:02

of unfair labor practice, according to

2:26:04

the National Labor Relations Act.

2:26:06

And it's backed up by charges

2:26:08

filed with the board, as

2:26:10

opposed to what's called an economic

2:26:13

strike, which is a strike

2:26:15

that is specifically about economic issues

2:26:17

at the workplace. So

2:26:19

the specific ULP that's being cited

2:26:21

for our strike is bad faith bargaining.

2:26:24

And for us, what that's

2:26:26

looked like is two

2:26:28

years of completely stalled negotiations

2:26:30

where we are basically

2:26:32

being faced with a take

2:26:34

it or leave it

2:26:36

offer of the status quo

2:26:38

in the vast majority

2:26:41

of our proposals. Bargaining

2:26:43

is very, very slow

2:26:46

and ownership has held

2:26:48

tightly to the offense

2:26:50

at us having unionized

2:26:52

at all, which to

2:26:55

my understanding is pretty

2:26:57

typical of small workplaces.

2:27:00

The ownership takes it very personally

2:27:02

and that personal feeling of the

2:27:04

trail or whatever becomes like a

2:27:06

like like a stumbling block in

2:27:09

the negotiation process. I know that

2:27:11

was the case with Moe's another

2:27:13

is a bookshop in Berkeley

2:27:15

that also unionized with the IWW. So,

2:27:19

you know, we've had our whole

2:27:21

proposal on ownership's table for a

2:27:23

year and a half now. We

2:27:25

had started with bargaining

2:27:27

proposal by proposal. They

2:27:29

said, well, how can we possibly

2:27:31

agree to any of this without understanding

2:27:33

the full context, especially the economic

2:27:35

context? And so we gave them

2:27:37

a full proposal and they said, oh my

2:27:39

God, how do you expect us to

2:27:41

read all of this in time to bargain?

2:27:44

This is way too much. How are we going

2:27:46

to evaluate this all? We

2:27:48

got to do a proposal by proposal. So

2:27:50

it's been really unclear to

2:27:52

us. If ownership has even actually

2:27:55

read the entirety of our collective

2:27:57

bargaining agreement that we put on

2:27:59

their desk, I know that

2:28:01

in the past, the lawyers have

2:28:03

said things like, oh, my eyes

2:28:05

glazed over when I read your

2:28:07

email, so I missed such

2:28:09

and such part of it. This

2:28:11

is literally your job! You're

2:28:14

a contract worker! You have

2:28:16

one job! Yeah, you

2:28:18

would think a lawyer would have

2:28:20

a little bit more than beyond

2:28:22

a tweet -sized reading capacity. Well,

2:28:24

they give anyone law degrees. Yeah.

2:28:28

Or, like, ownership saying, like,

2:28:31

well, I just thought it was so ridiculous I didn't feel

2:28:33

the need to read all of it. Stuff

2:28:35

like that. Oh, my God. Does this

2:28:37

read as bad faith bargaining? Yeah,

2:28:39

that's bad by, like, the

2:28:41

standards of, like, normal.

2:28:44

It takes two years to do a fucking

2:28:46

contract because they're just not doing shit.

2:28:49

Like, good lord. Usually...

2:28:51

long contract negotiations by two years

2:28:53

at least there's like been some

2:28:55

progress. Yeah, they've read

2:28:58

the proposals. Like,

2:29:00

yes, okay, will your boss show up to

2:29:02

your meeting an hour and a half late

2:29:04

because they didn't bother to look through the proposals

2:29:06

until literally right the time the meeting was

2:29:08

going to start? Yes, but will they have

2:29:10

done it? Usually, yes. In

2:29:13

fact, in the company

2:29:15

propaganda, where they're claiming that

2:29:17

this like bad faith

2:29:19

bargaining charge has no grounds.

2:29:21

They're like, ownership has

2:29:23

come to like 25 to

2:29:25

30 bargaining sessions, neglecting

2:29:27

dimension. There have been somewhere in the range of

2:29:30

like 50 to 60. And

2:29:32

of course, maybe

2:29:35

they've shown up to more than

2:29:37

half. I don't want to be libelous,

2:29:39

but yeah, but still like.

2:29:41

If at the point at which you

2:29:43

are failing to show up for

2:29:45

any bargaining session I think you can

2:29:47

like look I have always advocated

2:29:49

that if that if that if management

2:29:51

doesn't show up to a bargaining

2:29:53

session You should just be allowed to

2:29:55

take the company because clearly they're

2:29:57

not serious about it, but huh Hey,

2:29:59

you know, they've been talking about

2:30:01

a worker cop for 20 years non

2:30:04

-reformist reforms But yeah, so those kind

2:30:06

of things and then like finally

2:30:08

like one of the bigger precipitating factors

2:30:10

is like We've been trying to

2:30:12

bargain over economics. Ownership

2:30:14

has implied a lot of times

2:30:16

that they cannot afford to pay

2:30:18

what we're asking. They

2:30:20

say it'll ruin the company. They say a company

2:30:23

will go bankrupt. They say it's unsustainable. They say

2:30:25

this and that. And then when they get to

2:30:27

the table, they say we have never and will

2:30:29

never argue inability to pay. Because

2:30:31

the thing is, is that to say inability

2:30:33

to pay, right? It

2:30:35

obligates you to furnish information

2:30:37

and prove that. And they, for

2:30:39

whatever reason, do not

2:30:42

want British financial

2:30:44

information. So these have

2:30:46

been some of the sticking points,

2:30:48

and that's why we've been out on

2:30:50

the picket line for about three

2:30:52

weeks now. Still waiting for them to

2:30:54

come to the table. God damn

2:30:56

it. So, okay, let's talk about the

2:30:58

process of how the discussions went

2:31:01

for doing this. What did those look

2:31:03

like and how did you plan

2:31:05

this thing out? Well, I guess the

2:31:07

process towards like deciding that I

2:31:09

needed to come into a strike was

2:31:11

like, you know, that is a

2:31:13

sort of thing that builds over a

2:31:15

long period of time. You know,

2:31:17

you see ownership doing bad faith bargaining,

2:31:19

you go, what more conciliatory approaches

2:31:21

can we take first? You

2:31:23

know, can we try this? Can we

2:31:26

try offering this to make, you know, can

2:31:28

we try this display of good faith?

2:31:30

Can we offer this compromise? One

2:31:32

of the things that was a

2:31:34

big part was of a some of

2:31:36

the not exactly contract related discussions, but

2:31:39

like I should have been talking for

2:31:41

a long time about a co -op

2:31:43

transition that has never happened. It's been

2:31:45

20 years. And

2:31:47

now that we've unionized, they're like, are people

2:31:49

who we were talking to about doing the co

2:31:51

-op thing, they don't work with unions. And

2:31:54

so the only way that there were going

2:31:56

to be a co -op is if the

2:31:58

union goes away. And so in response to

2:32:00

that, we said, well, we're totally open to

2:32:02

a transition to a co -op that involves the

2:32:04

union. And here is such -and -such organization. It

2:32:07

was our leading negotiator who

2:32:09

actually provided information somewhere in the

2:32:11

name of the organization. But,

2:32:13

you know, here's such -and -such organization

2:32:15

that actually specifically deals with

2:32:18

union co -op workplace transitions was

2:32:20

not received with interest. So

2:32:23

it's like, you master this catalog

2:32:25

of bad faith bargaining, and you

2:32:27

end up in your strategy discussions

2:32:29

with the whole unit, testing the

2:32:31

wires of like, when is

2:32:34

too much what's our red line

2:32:36

that we need to take more

2:32:38

direct action. And

2:32:40

what that began with for

2:32:42

us was first, well, if

2:32:45

we're gonna have a strike, we

2:32:47

need funds for it.

2:32:49

The IWW is an organization

2:32:51

that affords its unions

2:32:53

a lot of freedom and

2:32:55

a lot of mutual

2:32:57

support and solidarity is not

2:32:59

an organization with a

2:33:01

huge amount of money. And

2:33:04

so we did start

2:33:06

with trying to get

2:33:08

a sense of what

2:33:10

we could get from

2:33:12

the branches reserve. And

2:33:15

we moved on from that to

2:33:17

how we were going to fundraise

2:33:19

and stuff like that. So we

2:33:21

held informational pickets that had donations.

2:33:24

We sold shirts, posters, stuff

2:33:26

like that. We held a

2:33:28

big strike fundraiser. Hell yeah. I think

2:33:30

something around like a month in advance

2:33:32

of our, or it was maybe like

2:33:34

a month and a half in advance

2:33:36

of our strike. We also

2:33:38

gave management like a courtesy

2:33:40

notice about this as they could

2:33:43

pass it on to ownership

2:33:45

saying, hey, we've started fundraising for

2:33:47

a strike. In the hopes

2:33:49

that like being aware that we're

2:33:51

taking active preparations to go

2:33:53

on strike would facilitate bargaining. Sometimes

2:33:55

it works. I've seen it

2:33:57

before. I've seen it before. Sometimes it works.

2:34:00

Yeah. And sometimes, you know,

2:34:02

sometimes you end up on

2:34:04

a podcast talking about how

2:34:06

it didn't. You

2:34:09

never know until you try. Yeah,

2:34:11

you never know. But

2:34:14

we did, yeah, we did give

2:34:16

them that sort of early warning.

2:34:19

And our readiness to strike kind of

2:34:21

like depended then on like where

2:34:23

we were at in the fundraising process.

2:34:26

So we continue soliciting donations, reaching out

2:34:28

to various organizations in the area

2:34:30

that are, you know, pro

2:34:32

-labor, you know,

2:34:34

we've talked to like DSA and

2:34:37

whatever, because, you know, they have

2:34:39

their like a workplace organizing committee.

2:34:41

Yeah, you walk. Yeah. Yeah.

2:34:43

And various other, you

2:34:45

know, yeah, organizations that are

2:34:47

pro -labor. And once we

2:34:49

got to a point where

2:34:51

we felt like we were reasonably

2:34:53

like prepared to sustain a

2:34:55

open -ended strike because that's what we're

2:34:58

doing. This is a strike with

2:35:00

no set end date. Then we

2:35:02

announced our intention to hold a

2:35:04

strike vote. We held a strike vote.

2:35:06

Strike vote passes. The

2:35:08

ownership was made aware at the bargaining

2:35:10

session before the strike vote. So it

2:35:12

was like the Monday before the strike

2:35:14

vote, which is on, I think, I

2:35:16

guess Saturday. So in

2:35:19

total, it was around maybe

2:35:21

two weeks in change that

2:35:23

they knew definite

2:35:25

possibility. Pass the

2:35:27

strike vote. 12 days later, the

2:35:29

strike begins with unfortunately no bargaining

2:35:31

in between. Good Lord. Yeah.

2:35:33

The whole way, you hope that they'll

2:35:36

come to the table. You hope that they

2:35:38

will come to their senses. Yeah.

2:35:40

Take it. Take the risk

2:35:42

seriously. Take the risk seriously. And

2:35:45

unfortunately, this is not what's happened

2:35:47

here. Yeah. And I think part

2:35:49

of that is maybe an age

2:35:51

thing here. Ownership is is in

2:35:53

their 80s and they pretty consistently

2:35:56

held the view that like the

2:35:58

union is like a bunch of

2:36:00

young people who don't know what

2:36:02

the hell they're talking about, you

2:36:04

know, even though like

2:36:06

the age range of our union

2:36:08

spans the age range of

2:36:10

the workplace. We've got people in

2:36:13

their 50s and 40s and

2:36:15

30s and 20s, you know, which

2:36:17

is of course the problematic

2:36:19

group. But yeah, the unraticals. Yeah,

2:36:23

so there's there's been this sort of

2:36:25

patronizing attitude that I think has resulted

2:36:28

in like a real strategic failure on

2:36:30

their part to seriously prepare for the

2:36:32

strike or You know bargain to avoid

2:36:34

it. Yeah one more fundraising thing that

2:36:36

I just I just want to mention

2:36:38

this for people if you're if you're

2:36:40

trying to fundraise for your own thing

2:36:43

something that's actually we've had a lot

2:36:45

of success with up in Portland is

2:36:47

Getting bands to do benefit shows So

2:36:49

like because it's Portland, right? Like the

2:36:51

local hardcore scene has a lot of

2:36:53

bands that, you know, are just

2:36:55

supportive of stuff. And we've done this for a

2:36:57

whole bunch of different causes. And

2:37:00

this can also be a good way to

2:37:02

just sort of do fundraising things that

2:37:04

are fun and also raise morale because, yeah,

2:37:06

you're doing the show. Yeah, I was...

2:37:08

I was I was hoping to have that

2:37:10

be more of a thing with our

2:37:12

fundraiser. But yeah, it can be hard to

2:37:15

organize sometimes. Yeah, the people I knew

2:37:17

were didn't get quite the response. I was

2:37:19

hoping from the community. If

2:37:21

you are a hardcore band, if

2:37:23

you are a band Berkeley, there's

2:37:26

still time. I

2:37:29

believe in you. That is that is

2:37:31

totally a good option. What we did,

2:37:33

but we ended up doing that. There

2:37:35

was music, but it's also like one

2:37:37

of our organizers is really into cooking,

2:37:39

like a barbecue thing, sold

2:37:42

food, stuff like that,

2:37:44

and had a raffle.

2:37:46

A raffle is a great way

2:37:49

to fundraise. For us, we

2:37:51

raffled off stuff we have. But

2:37:54

honestly, you can even do

2:37:56

a straight, monetary raffle is still

2:37:58

a great fundraising tool where

2:38:00

everyone puts in money, the

2:38:03

top three winners or whatever get a

2:38:05

certain percentage of the total pool and

2:38:07

the rest of the pool is is

2:38:09

to the cause. It's really simple, really

2:38:12

effective. Yeah. There's a

2:38:14

reason, it's not good, but there is a reason

2:38:16

why a whole bunch of state education budgets are

2:38:18

funded by the lottery. It does

2:38:20

work. The people

2:38:22

love to gamble. Much better. Yeah.

2:38:27

Mia says, having turned

2:38:29

off her path of exile

2:38:31

to lunch break to come

2:38:33

to this interview, it's

2:38:36

pretty such cases. Okay,

2:38:38

so let's, let's, speaking of, I guess this is something

2:38:40

that's been tied in to sort of all of

2:38:42

what we've been saying here, but yeah, let's talk about,

2:38:44

you know, sort of maintaining the strike when it

2:38:46

starts and sort of, yeah, what would have been

2:38:48

the processes of like keeping morale up and keeping people

2:38:50

engaged and yeah. Yeah,

2:38:52

I mean, definitely when you go

2:38:55

into a strike, you want to

2:38:57

go in with a militant core

2:38:59

group. You want to basically be

2:39:01

sure that everyone is committed to

2:39:03

holding the line until a collective

2:39:05

decision is made otherwise. You

2:39:07

don't want people like peeling off. That's

2:39:10

really bad PR for your strike. Yeah.

2:39:12

And like the bosses will grab

2:39:14

on that. So like,

2:39:17

for instance, like, you know,

2:39:19

we have some people who are respecting

2:39:21

our picket line, but chose not to

2:39:23

pick it with us, which is fine

2:39:25

as far as I'm concerned. But the

2:39:27

issue with that PR wise is that

2:39:29

now the bosses are saying and they're

2:39:31

like tallying up of who's working and

2:39:33

who's not working. They're counting them as

2:39:35

working, you know. They're like, oh, there's

2:39:37

only whatever. They've been

2:39:39

saying eight people. I think

2:39:41

it's more like nine or 10 who are

2:39:43

on the picket line. But the

2:39:45

rest of the employees are working. They

2:39:47

count themselves as employees in that count, of course.

2:39:51

And they count these people who are

2:39:53

not crossing the picket line but

2:39:55

not on it also as among that

2:39:57

count of the rest of the

2:39:59

employees that are working. And

2:40:02

they've had the opportunity

2:40:04

to really inflate that

2:40:06

count because and a classic

2:40:08

move. Really, all the

2:40:11

moves are classic. You read your organizing

2:40:13

books and you're like, can it happen

2:40:15

here? It does. We

2:40:18

got a lot of new assistant

2:40:20

managers after we won our election.

2:40:22

God. Right now, the composition of

2:40:24

the workplace, right? Got 34 people,

2:40:27

15 managers. I really wonder when

2:40:29

we're going to see the day

2:40:31

where you have companies that have

2:40:33

six like, non -managers and 55

2:40:35

managers. Like, I feel like we're

2:40:37

not that far out. Well, we're leading the

2:40:39

charge here. We have a department that's two people,

2:40:41

a manager and an assistant manager. Who's

2:40:44

the assistant manager managing? Oh, God.

2:40:51

So, yeah, you know, they've had

2:40:53

these particular angles to, you

2:40:55

know, sort of do their

2:40:57

propaganda from and... honestly, I

2:41:00

think a big part of,

2:41:02

again, the boss is the

2:41:04

best organizer. And

2:41:06

like a thing that keeps you committed on

2:41:08

the line is like reading all this

2:41:10

bullshit they say about you and knowing otherwise

2:41:12

and being able to talk to each

2:41:14

other and be like, have you seen this?

2:41:16

Isn't this crazy? Like, what the hell?

2:41:18

Yeah. Also, you

2:41:20

know, is this is where

2:41:22

the sort of like

2:41:25

seeds of organizing All

2:41:27

the way that you start all the way

2:41:29

back at the beginning of your union

2:41:31

campaign become you know show themselves like really

2:41:33

important again because like the start right

2:41:35

anyone will tell you is like getting to

2:41:37

know people like being like you know

2:41:39

being on like a hey how's it going

2:41:41

kind of level you know and having

2:41:43

like a personal rapport with the people you're

2:41:45

on the line with is vital just

2:41:47

in the sense that you know obviously like

2:41:49

you know each other you're sort of

2:41:51

friends you're gonna be more likely to stick

2:41:53

up for each other. But also,

2:41:56

you're out there nine hours walking

2:41:58

in a circle with these people. You

2:42:01

got to have positive, strong relationships

2:42:03

with them. You want to be able

2:42:05

to have the kind of rapport

2:42:07

where you can talk to people about

2:42:09

what they're feeling anxious about, where

2:42:12

they're worried in the

2:42:14

strike strategy. You

2:42:16

need to have that trust between each other that

2:42:18

you can have an open dialogue about how it

2:42:20

feels to be on the picket line. You're

2:42:23

not going to maintain morale if

2:42:25

everyone feels like they've got things they

2:42:28

got a hold in about it. There's

2:42:30

room to be like, shit, are they going

2:42:32

to close the business? And what are we

2:42:34

going to do? And sort

2:42:37

of talk through that from a

2:42:39

place beyond, you're not letting

2:42:41

it speak into a crowd of

2:42:43

a million people or whatever. You're

2:42:45

just two people. And

2:42:48

going through a stressful experience together. Yeah.

2:42:50

Yeah, and you have to actually

2:42:52

grapple with that in a way that's

2:42:54

not the sort of like weird

2:42:56

corporate like we got to improve morale

2:42:58

things like that's not what that

2:43:00

means it means like you know it

2:43:02

means actually grappling and engaging with

2:43:04

people's feelings and how and what they

2:43:06

need in a moment and yeah

2:43:08

and their fears and their concerns and

2:43:11

Yeah, you can't just sort of

2:43:14

brush them aside. You have to

2:43:16

actually grapple with it because that's

2:43:18

that's that's what doing this stuff

2:43:20

means Yeah, exactly having like these

2:43:22

authentic conversations with people because like

2:43:24

like yeah, that's like a totally

2:43:26

great point you bring up there

2:43:28

like the HR speak That's the

2:43:30

bosses tool and it's the bosses

2:43:32

tool To divide and create disunity

2:43:34

so you can't lean on that

2:43:36

model for morale within your union.

2:43:38

It just creates distrust Yeah,

2:43:41

and mean, I've seen that happen with

2:43:43

unions where it's like, you guys did

2:43:45

not do a good job of like

2:43:47

talking to people about this and like, yeah,

2:43:50

and it can be really disruptive to attempts to

2:43:52

do this. But on the other hand, if you

2:43:54

do it well, it's the

2:43:56

most powerful single thing that

2:43:58

you can like possibly do is

2:44:00

like forging relationships that are

2:44:02

based on like the actual experience

2:44:04

of having gone. through struggle

2:44:07

together and having had to like literally

2:44:09

had to face your feels on the picket

2:44:11

line. Yeah. Yeah. Like

2:44:13

ideally, you know, the union is

2:44:15

a community and it's a community

2:44:17

of interest, right? It's a community

2:44:19

of work interest, but it is

2:44:21

ideally a community. It's not a

2:44:23

family, right? And it's certainly

2:44:26

not a family in the way that

2:44:28

the bosses will tell you the workplaces, but

2:44:30

it is a community and

2:44:33

it's a community in the

2:44:35

way that that an employer's

2:44:37

idea of a community is

2:44:39

fundamentally like incompatible with. Yeah.

2:44:43

this Vicky Osterwald line that I think

2:44:45

about a lot from her book in

2:44:47

defensive fluting where she talks about how

2:44:49

I feel like it was Ferguson that

2:44:51

this is about where like the police

2:44:53

chief is talking about the damage to

2:44:55

the community and they keep saying our

2:44:57

Walmart. It's like going

2:44:59

into a Walmart and buying something

2:45:01

is not a community, right? Like

2:45:04

you know, they like that, like

2:45:06

those, those kind of relations are not

2:45:08

actual community relations. But when

2:45:10

the bosses talk about community, that's

2:45:12

what they mean. They mean like, like

2:45:14

our collective community Walmart. They

2:45:16

mean preserving the relation of extraction that

2:45:18

they have. And

2:45:20

we are, you know, using the

2:45:22

same word and reading something

2:45:25

literally so radically different than that.

2:45:27

And you have to make sure in

2:45:29

your, in the way that you're

2:45:32

acting that That radically different meaning is

2:45:34

clear. Yeah, and yeah, it's funny

2:45:36

you bring that up because that's just

2:45:38

bringing to mind like You see the difference

2:45:40

in those attitudes like when you're out

2:45:42

there on the picket line like interact because

2:45:44

you know our picket line a really

2:45:46

pivotal part of it because there are so

2:45:48

many managers in there that they're able

2:45:50

to maintain this like skeleton crew is the

2:45:52

community outreach part is like talking to

2:45:54

every single person who's coming up and being

2:45:56

like Hey, how's it going? Did a

2:45:58

guy been on strike such such and such

2:46:00

long? This is what's up? Please don't

2:46:02

cross my picket line. And,

2:46:04

you know, I've noticed you get this real funny

2:46:07

situation where there are the people who are like,

2:46:09

I've shopped here for 20 years. You don't know

2:46:11

what the hell you're talking about. I don't know

2:46:13

you. And I have to be like, well, I'm

2:46:15

normally at the dump getting the merchandise you're buying.

2:46:17

But and who attribute the

2:46:20

entire attribute everything they like

2:46:22

about the business to the

2:46:24

bosses. And then there's the

2:46:26

other part of the community

2:46:28

that is coming by frequently. and

2:46:31

like hanging out with us on on

2:46:33

the picket line. You know, I pet the

2:46:35

dog and we chat about what's going

2:46:37

on. They're like, how's the strike going? They're

2:46:39

like, you know, I know it's been

2:46:41

rough on you guys for such and such.

2:46:43

And like, these people are our shoppers

2:46:45

too, right? But they like, they, it highlights

2:46:47

that like, sort of divide in like, what

2:46:50

you think of as like community and

2:46:52

your responsibility or community. Because like, these people

2:46:54

also love Urban Order and come here

2:46:56

all the time. But they

2:46:58

recognize that like, it's

2:47:00

the workers at Urbanor that

2:47:03

create it every day. And

2:47:05

it is a company that

2:47:07

was founded by an individual. The

2:47:10

individual still owns it. He did found

2:47:12

it with his labor and all that.

2:47:14

He did the labor back when it

2:47:16

was only a few people and stuff

2:47:18

like that. But ultimately, a

2:47:21

business like any social phenomenon has

2:47:23

to be constantly recreated in order

2:47:25

to exist. And the people

2:47:27

who do the work that makes it.

2:47:29

more than just like a room full of

2:47:31

garbage, RS. And a

2:47:33

lot of the like regulars recognize that.

2:47:35

And a lot of them, you

2:47:38

know, flip me off as they cross

2:47:40

the text line, whatever. I

2:47:45

think this is a good place to

2:47:47

sort of start coming to a close.

2:47:49

This is a fundamental question about what

2:47:51

the nature of our society is going

2:47:53

to be, right? Like, is

2:47:55

the fundamental nature of our society

2:47:58

that a community is a bunch of people

2:48:00

who buy things and a bunch of people

2:48:02

who make money from you buying things and

2:48:04

who make money from the labor that you

2:48:06

do, right? And then take credit

2:48:08

for the labor and take credit both financially for

2:48:10

the labor and in public for the labor, right? Is

2:48:13

our society going to just be a bunch

2:48:15

of pure commercial relations where a bunch of

2:48:17

people get very, very rich off the labor

2:48:19

of everyone else in the society and get

2:48:21

to rule them as sort of like these

2:48:24

petty tyrant kings? Or is

2:48:26

it going to be a society where

2:48:28

the people who produce the society control

2:48:30

it, right? And that society

2:48:32

is a democratic society, is a

2:48:34

egalitarian society, is a society where people

2:48:36

are free to do the things that

2:48:38

they need to do and people are

2:48:40

free to have a life where they

2:48:43

can fucking pay for their groceries, right?

2:48:45

Where they're not forced to go

2:48:47

to the market for all of the

2:48:49

things that they need to... live where

2:48:51

you can survive in a way that

2:48:53

doesn't involve like subjecting yourself to

2:48:55

just a tyrant for like a third

2:48:57

of your life. Yeah, where like the

2:48:59

place that you spend like a third

2:49:01

of your life is a place

2:49:03

where you actually have like dignity. Yeah,

2:49:05

dignity and freedom and where you don't

2:49:07

have to go home at the

2:49:09

end of a day of making your

2:49:12

boss money, worrying about whether you're going

2:49:14

to be able to eat or not.

2:49:17

And that's also a society that

2:49:19

does not involve, again, at

2:49:21

the very highest level, like

2:49:23

you getting thrown into prison camps

2:49:25

because your God King hates you. And

2:49:28

we can do this. We can

2:49:30

live in that society. Yeah. The demands

2:49:32

are not that crazy. No.

2:49:35

And that's like the thing that

2:49:37

we've encountered over and over

2:49:39

again is this constant push and

2:49:41

pull of people saying that

2:49:43

like the expectation of bettering our

2:49:45

conditions whether it be like

2:49:47

us on the picket line, just trying

2:49:50

to get like a stable wage and

2:49:52

just cause employment and stuff like that,

2:49:54

or whether it be, you know, those

2:49:56

larger societal changes that like you're talking

2:49:58

about, you just butt up against these

2:50:00

people who have such like a paucity

2:50:02

of imagination about what's possible. Yeah. And

2:50:04

like about the legitimacy of

2:50:06

trying to make something better. The

2:50:09

legitimacy of saying, sure,

2:50:11

I can subsist on this,

2:50:13

but yeah. There's so

2:50:15

much more that's possible. Yeah. So

2:50:18

I maintain that there's something more

2:50:20

that's possible. Yeah. I think

2:50:22

it's possible too. And that's the thing about

2:50:24

this world, right? Is that our enemies

2:50:26

have figured out that it actually can change.

2:50:28

Mm -hmm. That's why they have to fight

2:50:30

so hard. Yeah. But the thing is, the fact that it can

2:50:32

change for the worse also means that it can change for

2:50:34

the better. Oh, beautiful stuff. Okay. Where

2:50:36

can people find your strike fund to also

2:50:38

put it in the description? Oh, yeah.

2:50:40

Great. So it's on GoFundMe. I'll

2:50:42

send you the link and it'll

2:50:45

be down there. But also

2:50:47

people can hit up our

2:50:49

union Instagram. It's

2:50:51

a urban or workers with underscores between

2:50:53

the words urban underscore or underscore worker

2:50:55

that we've got the link to like

2:50:57

strike fund and also hey if you're

2:50:59

if you're in Berkeley you can sign

2:51:01

up for a big shift and you

2:51:03

get to enjoy listening to me discourse

2:51:06

for nine hours instead of One. It's

2:51:08

great. It's fun. Pickets are cool and

2:51:10

good. If you haven't been on one,

2:51:12

you should go on one. They're great.

2:51:14

They're great. Yeah. It's

2:51:16

a good time. Wasn't

2:51:35

that delicious? So good. Your

2:51:37

bill, ladies? I got it. No,

2:51:39

I got it. Seriously,

2:51:41

I insist. I insisted first. Oh,

2:51:43

don't be silly. You don't be

2:51:45

silly. People with the Wells Fargo

2:51:47

Active Cash Credit Card prefer to

2:51:49

pay because they earn unlimited 2

2:51:51

% cash back on purchases. OK.

2:51:53

Rock, paper, scissors for it. Rock,

2:51:55

paper, scissors. Shoot. No! The

2:51:57

Wells Fargo Active Cash

2:52:00

Credit Card. Visit wellsfargo.com slash

2:52:02

activecash terms apply. Does

2:52:04

this podcast make you happy? Of

2:52:06

course it does. That's why you're

2:52:08

here. But it only comes out

2:52:10

once a week. For happiness every

2:52:13

night, you need Adam and Eve.

2:52:15

Yes, I'm talking about sex toys.

2:52:18

It's cool. It's cool. You have earbuds in, right? Adam

2:52:21

and Eve, America's most trusted source

2:52:23

for adult products, has been making

2:52:25

people very happy for over 50

2:52:27

years, with thousands of toys for

2:52:29

both men and women. Just go

2:52:31

to adamany.com now and enter code

2:52:33

I heart for 50 % off

2:52:35

almost any one item plus free

2:52:37

discreet shipping that's adamany.com code I

2:52:39

heart for 50 % off. Because

2:52:59

today is where it's all happening. We

2:53:01

get the best start to every

2:53:03

morning because we started together. Watch the

2:53:05

Today Show with Savannah Guthrie and

2:53:07

Craig Melvin weekdays at 7 a .m.

2:53:10

on NBC. You're a

2:53:12

hustler. You get things done, but you don't

2:53:14

always do things for yourself. With

2:53:16

JLo Beauty, it takes just a few

2:53:18

minutes a day to look like facials

2:53:20

are a regular part of your routine.

2:53:22

JLo Beauty's fresh and flawless skincare kit

2:53:24

includes six skincare products that work as

2:53:27

hard as you do. They'll hustle to

2:53:29

brighten, firm, and hydrate your complexion morning

2:53:31

and night. This skincare kit is a

2:53:33

one and done solution that is clinically

2:53:35

proven to visibly tighten and lift for

2:53:37

instant and long lasting results. Cleanse,

2:53:39

treat, moisturize, protect. The fresh and

2:53:42

flawless skincare kit does it all.

2:53:44

See why the kit's a best

2:53:46

seller today. Visit JLObeauty.com slash Deluxe

2:53:48

and get an extra 25 %

2:53:50

off your first shipment plus free

2:53:52

gifts with code Deluxe. If you're

2:53:54

not satisfied, return the bottles within

2:53:56

60 days for your money back.

2:53:59

See the website for details. That's

2:54:01

JLObeauty.com slash Deluxe to get

2:54:03

that J -LowGlo. This

2:54:10

is, it could happen here, Executive

2:54:12

Disorder, our weekly newscast covering what's happening

2:54:14

in the White House, the crumbling

2:54:16

world and what it means for you.

2:54:19

I'm Garrison Davis. Today I'm

2:54:21

joined by Dr. James Stout

2:54:23

and Reverend Dr. The Honorable

2:54:25

Robert Evans. That's right.

2:54:27

That's right. Reverend Dr. The Honorable

2:54:29

Evans, who is currently hacking up

2:54:32

a fucking lung. No

2:54:34

idea why. I feel otherwise

2:54:36

fine. Well, I'm sure you

2:54:38

feel otherwise fine due to this great

2:54:40

week in American history we've all

2:54:42

been through together. Yeah. Which

2:54:44

started... with a meeting between

2:54:47

President Donald Trump and El

2:54:49

Salvador President Buquele on Monday

2:54:51

morning in the Oval Office,

2:54:53

where they discussed the possibility

2:54:55

of the United States helping

2:54:57

to build more Seacot -style facilities

2:54:59

to disappear U .S. citizens

2:55:02

and immigrants that the Trump

2:55:04

administration deems criminals or terrorists. Yes.

2:55:08

I mean, I keep getting asked, is

2:55:10

this the panic moment? And I

2:55:12

don't think panic. is particularly productive. But

2:55:14

like, yeah, this is the worst

2:55:16

case scenario. The worst case scenario is

2:55:18

happening. The president's talking about sending

2:55:20

citizens overseas to a concentration camp. Honestly,

2:55:23

I'm on the verge of thinking it's

2:55:25

okay to call it a death camp, but

2:55:27

we just don't have the data yet.

2:55:29

There's some very concerning satellite shots that appear

2:55:31

to show piles of bodies. Yeah,

2:55:33

that's from March of 2024. Yeah.

2:55:35

Yeah. I mean, yeah, but it won't have

2:55:37

gotten better. No, no. Yeah.

2:55:39

Yeah. So, I don't know.

2:55:41

This is about as bad as it could

2:55:43

be, folks. We're in

2:55:45

it. During that meeting, both President

2:55:47

Bukele and the Trump Cabinet argued that

2:55:50

there is simply no way for

2:55:52

people sent to see God to ever

2:55:54

return to the United States, coming

2:55:56

up with a whole bunch of absurd

2:55:58

reasons for why is impossible due

2:56:00

to foreign policy and safety of both

2:56:02

El Salvador and the United States.

2:56:04

Me and James did a whole episode

2:56:06

on this earlier this week that

2:56:08

you can check out on the It

2:56:11

Could Happen Here feed. I'm

2:56:13

going to move on to

2:56:15

an update on the student crackdowns.

2:56:18

So ICE has targeted a

2:56:20

third green card holder

2:56:23

for deportation based on pro

2:56:25

-Palestinian activism. Mohozen

2:56:27

Marui is a Palestinian from the West

2:56:29

Bank who has lived in the US

2:56:31

with a green card for a decade.

2:56:34

While studying philosophy at Columbia,

2:56:36

he co -founded the Columbia -Palestinian

2:56:38

Student Union in 2023 with

2:56:40

Mahmoud Khalil. Madawi

2:56:43

was arrested by ICE last

2:56:45

Monday, April 14th, at

2:56:47

his citizenship interview in Vermont.

2:56:50

Now, after Khalil was arrested last

2:56:52

month, Madawi went into hiding,

2:56:54

and he suspected that this citizenship

2:56:56

interview could be a honeypot, but

2:56:58

decided to go anyway after waiting

2:57:00

a long time for this appointment.

2:57:03

His lawyers quickly filed a habeas corpus

2:57:05

petition, arguing his detention is unlawful and

2:57:07

violates the First Amendment. A

2:57:09

U .S. district judge issued an order

2:57:11

hours later that he was, quote,

2:57:13

not to be removed from the United

2:57:15

States or moved out of the

2:57:17

territory of the district of Vermont, pending

2:57:19

further order of this court. Zionist

2:57:22

doxing accounts targeted Marui

2:57:24

in recent weeks. I'm

2:57:27

going to play, actually, this

2:57:29

two -minute clip of Marui talking. This

2:57:32

is from December of

2:57:34

2023 on the program

2:57:36

60 Minutes. What was

2:57:38

your initial reaction when

2:57:40

you heard about the

2:57:42

Hamas attack on October

2:57:44

7th? I could not

2:57:46

believe what my eyes

2:57:48

were seeing. Where I

2:57:50

see Hamas members getting

2:57:52

into settlements and so

2:57:54

on. But also the

2:57:56

first moment I saw that I put my

2:57:58

hand on my heart. And

2:58:02

I started praying knowing

2:58:04

that there will be a

2:58:06

huge level of revenge

2:58:08

from the Israelis. And

2:58:10

I was praying that this

2:58:12

will not be the result

2:58:15

because it would be disastrous.

2:58:18

The night of the rally,

2:58:20

I believe someone in

2:58:22

the crowd said something very

2:58:24

anti. Jewish, not

2:58:27

just anti -Israeli, but

2:58:29

anti -Jewish. Yes. This

2:58:31

was a walkout on

2:58:33

November 9th. And

2:58:35

a person who's not

2:58:37

affiliated with Colombia,

2:58:39

we've never seen him.

2:58:42

We don't know who is

2:58:44

this guy, comes down

2:58:47

the stairs, yelling, death to

2:58:49

Jews. I

2:58:52

was shocked. And

2:58:54

they walked directly to the

2:58:56

person and they told him,

2:58:58

you don't represent us because

2:59:00

this is not something that

2:59:02

we agree with. And directly

2:59:04

what I've done, I

2:59:06

took the megaphone and they

2:59:08

gave a speech and they

2:59:10

said, we here are conscious,

2:59:12

educated students and we know

2:59:14

how to separate right from

2:59:16

wrong. And what this

2:59:18

guy has said

2:59:21

is wrong. What

2:59:23

this guy has

2:59:25

said is clearly anti

2:59:27

-semitic against Jews anti

2:59:29

-semitic to be anti

2:59:31

-semitic is unjust is

2:59:33

unjust and the

2:59:35

fight for the freedom

2:59:37

of Palestine and

2:59:39

the fight against anti

2:59:41

-semitism go hand in

2:59:43

hand because injustice

2:59:45

anywhere is a threat

2:59:47

to justice everywhere

2:59:49

Yeah, I mean He

2:59:51

said everything That would make

2:59:53

him a respectable Protester at

2:59:55

least based on like what

2:59:57

the fucking dims were saying

2:59:59

last

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features