Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
know you've got to come back in here. Comeback
0:03
in you. When you take the
0:05
next step, you're going to make
0:07
it count for your career, for
0:10
your family, for your life. You
0:12
can earn a degree you're proud
0:15
of with Purdue Global. Purdue Global
0:17
is backed by Purdue University, one
0:19
of the nation's most respected and
0:22
innovative public universities. This is your
0:24
chance. This is your opportunity. This
0:26
is your comeback. Purdue Global. Produce
0:29
online university for working adults. Start
0:31
your comeback today. Every morning
0:33
brings a fresh new energy and
0:35
no matter what the day holds
0:38
we come to the Today Show for
0:40
all of it. We get the best
0:42
start to the day because we started
0:44
together. Watch the Today Show weekdays at
0:46
7 a.m. on NBC. Ugh, come
0:48
on. Why is this taking so long?
0:51
This thing is ancient. Still using
0:53
yesterday's tech? Upgrade to the ThinkPad
0:55
X1 Carbon. Ultra -light, ultra -powerful, and
0:57
built for serious productivity with Intel
0:59
Core Ultra processors, blazing speed, and
1:01
AI -powered performance that keeps up
1:03
with your business, not the other
1:05
way around. Whoa, this thing moves. Stop
1:08
hitting snooze on new tech. Win
1:10
the tech search at Lenovo.com. Unlock
1:14
AI experiences with the ThinkPad X1
1:16
Carbon powered by Intel Core Ultra
1:18
processors so you can work, create,
1:20
and boost productivity all on one
1:22
device. This
1:26
is Matt Rogers from Lost Culturistas with
1:28
Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang. Have
1:30
you ever felt that uneasy anxiety when
1:32
the 4 p .m. hour strikes, the
1:34
creeping meal -related distress that happens when
1:36
you don't quite feel prepared? You
1:38
know, dinner dread? Let's get rid of
1:40
that unpleasant feeling forever with one
1:42
word. Stophers. No
1:44
matter what happens, you'll have a dinner
1:46
plan that everyone loves with stoffers. Some
1:48
chicken enchiladas or a cheesy chicken and
1:50
broccoli pasta bake is always welcome whether
1:53
it is plan A or plan D.
1:55
Delicious. Not gonna lie, I eat
1:57
the lasagna once a week.
1:59
And that's a fact. When
2:01
the clock strikes dinner, think stoffers. Shop
2:03
now for family favorites. Hey
2:08
everybody, Robert Evans here, and I wanted
2:10
to let you know this is
2:12
a compilation episode. So every episode of
2:14
the week that just happened is
2:16
here in one convenient and with somewhat
2:18
less ads package for you to
2:20
listen to in a long stretch if
2:22
you want. If you've been listening
2:24
to the episodes every day this week, there's got to be
2:27
nothing new here for you, but you can make your
2:29
own decisions. Welcome
2:32
to It Could Happen Here, a podcast that asks the
2:34
question, what happens when the people who are trying
2:36
to help put things back together are also being exploited
2:38
in the process? I am
2:40
your host, Mia Wong, and today
2:42
we are going to be talking about a
2:44
union that is attempting to do exactly
2:46
that. And with me to
2:48
discuss this are Jess and Jesus, who
2:51
are mentors for Friends of the Children
2:53
PDX and members of the Friends PDX
2:55
Union Network. Yeah, Jess, Jesus, welcome
2:57
to the show. Thank you so much
2:59
for having us. Yeah, thank you. Yeah,
3:01
I'm really happy to talk to you
3:03
both because I think this is a very,
3:05
very unique and interesting union, especially, you know,
3:07
talk about especially right now. But
3:09
to get people sort of rolling, can
3:12
you explain what Friends of the Children
3:14
is and what it is that
3:16
you two do? Yeah.
3:19
So Friends of the Children is,
3:21
it's a national organization, it's
3:23
a nonprofit, but they're
3:25
like... There are individual chapters
3:27
throughout different cities. We
3:29
work out of Portland, which is
3:31
the founding chapter and also the
3:33
largest one. Some of the
3:36
language I'll say that is like used from
3:38
the website and from like the mission statement that
3:40
really encompasses. what our
3:42
role is and also how it
3:44
is told to like our community
3:46
partnerships and the families and youth
3:48
that we work with is that
3:50
we are committing to youth when
3:53
they are typically around kindergarten age
3:55
level and they're being paired with
3:57
a mentor and they will have
3:59
a mentor until they graduate the program
4:01
so that usually ends up being
4:03
a total of 12 and a half
4:05
years. And that like
4:07
within that we were doing a lot
4:10
of like individualized care and support.
4:12
We work with them in the schools.
4:14
We work with them outside the
4:16
schools. We help them get into extracurriculars.
4:18
We help them with like social
4:20
emotional regulation, developing relationships with other youth
4:23
in the program. And really
4:25
just like being a consistently
4:27
reliable human being. And
4:29
one of the big like pillars of
4:31
our organization is the commitment to long
4:33
term, which sometimes can be an issue
4:35
when you are facing a lot of
4:37
high turnover as an organization. We
4:40
both have eight kids on
4:42
our roster as do most
4:45
mentors. And within that,
4:47
we have youth. I personally
4:49
have youth that have been assigned
4:51
to me that have just started
4:53
in the program, meaning that they
4:55
were like maybe first grade when
4:57
I was assigned to them. And
4:59
then I also have youth that
5:02
are middle school level that have
5:04
had several different mentors in the past.
5:06
some that have stayed there for maybe
5:08
a few years and like sometimes there's
5:11
ones that have been there for months. Yeah.
5:14
If I can add to that,
5:16
the kids we work
5:18
with, they're enrolled into
5:21
the program because they
5:23
have some risk factors in
5:25
their lives that would lead them to
5:27
needing a little bit of extra
5:29
support and help. So we work with
5:31
a lot of kids. that
5:34
come from immigrant families,
5:36
from families that have,
5:38
you know, single parent
5:41
households, foster care,
5:43
families and kids, kids
5:45
that like, unfortunately,
5:48
are likely to face some
5:50
challenges that our society and
5:52
the way it's built up
5:54
will deal to them. And
5:57
our goal is to help
5:59
them through those challenges just be
6:01
there for them so
6:03
that they have a
6:06
chance of, you know,
6:08
graduating high school or
6:10
entering adulthood without having,
6:12
you know, having had
6:14
kids or facing like
6:17
the justice system. It's
6:19
kids that we love
6:21
dearly that we
6:23
work with in a similar way
6:25
as like, you know, a program
6:27
like Big Brothers, Big Sisters. But
6:30
we are paid mentors,
6:32
which is the big difference,
6:35
right? We're not volunteer
6:37
based. We are employees, basically
6:39
social workers for all of
6:41
the families that we work with. It's
6:43
honestly like it's a great
6:45
job. And I think right
6:47
now, especially like super necessary
6:50
because things are falling apart. Yeah.
6:52
Yeah. And
6:54
yeah, just adding like
6:56
one. that made me think of how
6:59
within the work like I think
7:01
social work is a very apt choice
7:03
of words because we are paired
7:05
with the youth and it doesn't like
7:07
stop there like we work like
7:09
we work with the families we also
7:12
work with like the siblings too
7:14
because sometimes you'll have a youth that
7:16
maybe is the only child in
7:18
that family that for whatever reason got
7:20
a mentor and then you support all
7:22
I mean it's a choice but
7:25
But I would say that most mentors
7:27
definitely opt in to being there
7:29
for siblings and family members in the
7:31
household and making sure that they're
7:33
also showing up for the caregivers to
7:35
help them create a loving home. Yeah.
7:38
And I mean, you know, I think
7:40
that you can you can look at this
7:43
and see how it's supposed to work structurally. And,
7:45
you know, you were talking about like, I
7:47
mean, this is supposed to be a
7:50
like over a decade
7:52
long commitment to these kids. right
7:54
that ideally you're working with the same person
7:56
and you know you're forming really deep
7:58
emotional attachments because you can't not do that
8:01
if you're doing this kind
8:03
of work but then
8:05
also you know in order for that
8:07
to work and I think this is you know you
8:09
can see this to the outside is like in
8:11
order for this to work this has to be a
8:13
job that you could stay really do for a
8:15
decade, right? Yeah, which
8:21
I will say we do and I
8:23
want to do I want to give
8:25
so many props to one of our
8:27
mentors who has stayed for 12 years
8:29
and has graduated their youth. But
8:32
of all of our
8:34
co -workers, I believe it's only
8:36
one that has currently been able
8:38
to do that and has stayed
8:40
there as long as I have. Yeah.
8:43
And the truth of the fact, for any
8:45
job, 12 and a half years is
8:47
a really long time, right? I mean,
8:49
six years is a really long time.
8:53
with this job, we're like,
8:55
we're an emotional sponge
8:57
for a lot of
8:59
things, right? So our
9:01
kids go through everything
9:04
that you could imagine. And
9:06
within that, like everything good
9:08
and everything bad that you
9:10
could imagine. And our job,
9:12
a lot of times is
9:15
like, we can't solve the
9:17
things that are affecting these
9:19
kids, but we can
9:21
take in some of
9:23
those negative feelings and
9:25
that grief, that anger,
9:27
we can take it in
9:29
and almost dissolve it a
9:31
little bit, right? But within
9:34
that, it can affect
9:36
us so much. And
9:39
that's where, yeah, the sustainability
9:41
part of 12 a half
9:43
years in this job, that
9:45
is a lot. And we
9:47
need a lot for that
9:50
to... at all be
9:52
possible. Yeah, I
9:54
mean, there's this way
9:56
in which you're effectively... What
9:58
this job is, is you're
10:01
the person who is trying to
10:03
mitigate the impact of literally
10:05
all of the structural systems of
10:08
violence that exist in this entire
10:10
country, and how they're
10:12
just targeted down on these
10:14
kids, and your job is
10:16
to try to... protect them
10:18
as much as possible. And that's
10:20
unbelievable amount of physical
10:23
and emotional labor. And then
10:25
also, I don't
10:27
know, it seems pretty bad that there's
10:29
only been one co -worker who's been able
10:31
to graduate their kids. And
10:34
just to clarify for history,
10:36
that's been in our time there. Yeah, yeah.
10:38
There'll be other I don't know if
10:40
over the 30 years, I hope that other
10:42
people have. But yeah, in recent years,
10:44
it's only been the one. And
10:47
also, yeah, this is a
10:49
job where you are not necessarily
10:51
able to undo the systems
10:53
at play, but trying to support
10:55
them. And we,
10:57
as mentors, are
11:00
inevitably also facing those
11:02
systems against ourselves. And
11:04
one of the reasons that
11:06
I think people gravitate towards
11:08
this job. Is there empathy because
11:10
they have those shared experiences? One
11:13
of the things that is kind
11:15
of heavy in the culture of
11:17
friends is being asked your why
11:20
when you start. Like
11:22
why did you choose friends? And for
11:24
a lot of people it is because of
11:26
wanting to be the person that they
11:28
needed when they were going through those periods
11:30
of time. So there's bound
11:32
to be a lot of reactivation
11:34
of feelings inside yourself that I
11:36
think we all, I want to
11:39
say, every mentor I've worked with
11:41
has done an incredible job of
11:43
handling that and taking good care of
11:45
themselves. But it
11:47
is definitely something that takes
11:49
a lot of regulation. I
11:53
think empathy is one of the greatest
11:55
skills in this job, but it also, yeah,
11:58
it also then leads to us needing
12:00
greater needs of self -care and things like that.
12:02
Yeah. And like, I mean, I guess like to
12:04
put this in perspective for like people
12:06
listening to this is like, okay,
12:08
your job is to be the person
12:10
like in the friend group who
12:12
like manages like when someone's like having
12:14
an emotional crisis, like you have
12:16
to like help them and deal with
12:18
it. And that is your job
12:20
for like eight kids. feel
12:23
like the worst shit in the world. Like,
12:26
Jesus Christ. Oh,
12:29
good Lord. It's
12:31
honestly like hearing
12:33
this, it's always really helpful to
12:35
hear someone's outside perspective of our
12:37
job, right? Because we get... So,
12:39
so into it, so into the
12:41
muck of like what this job
12:43
can be. And I think like
12:45
overall, like, like social work, it's
12:47
not just like our job, but
12:49
like I'm sure other social workers
12:51
and people in care industries, like
12:53
we have like continuous like vicarious
12:55
trauma that makes us
12:57
forget like how How
13:01
our job is sometimes and then
13:03
it's helpful to hear other people
13:05
mention it because it's like yeah
13:07
Wow, our job is kind of
13:09
crazy and the work we do
13:11
is like really important and really
13:13
important for society and also Yeah, like
13:16
it's hard. It's
13:18
hard work It's it's hard
13:20
and it doesn't like really have an end point
13:22
like we have the hours we work with
13:24
kids and then We have
13:26
the hours we think about them and
13:28
the things going on in their lives And
13:30
sometimes it's like sweet things like a
13:32
lot of times it's sweet things where I'll
13:34
see something and be like oh my
13:36
gosh You know who would love that and
13:38
like things like that are like oh
13:40
great idea or oh, let's go see this
13:42
movie and a lot of times it's
13:44
like worrying though too and Knowing that there
13:47
is there is only so many things
13:49
we can control and some things
13:51
we just have to be the
13:53
person that's there as they have to go
13:56
through something. Which yeah,
13:58
it's hard because we also obviously
14:00
like develop such loving relationships
14:02
with these kids. It's hard to
14:04
see kids that you care
14:06
about so much that sometimes the
14:08
most you can do is
14:10
just be there. Yeah, it
14:12
definitely is a job that like
14:14
to some degree is sort of always
14:16
with you. Yeah, we have a
14:19
joke about this with this job where
14:21
it's like If you do what
14:23
you love and you'll never be free
14:25
for a single second of your
14:27
entire life, it's because you're just always
14:29
on. Yeah, it's
14:31
so true. Yeah, as
14:33
you say this, I worked till like 9 30
14:35
last night because I was like, you know what?
14:37
I'm enjoying this so much taking out with my
14:39
guys. So I'm just going to keep working. Yeah.
14:42
Yeah. So speaking of
14:44
keeping working, we need to go to ads
14:47
and then we will come back and
14:49
talk about. the ways in which this job
14:51
that requires an incredible amount of structural
14:53
support to keep people there for like over
14:55
a decade is failing to do that. And
15:07
we are back. So,
15:09
okay, now that we've sort
15:12
of talked about what
15:14
this is, let's talk about
15:16
the actual union. Yeah.
15:21
So can you talk about sort of how
15:23
did organizing for this union start and what
15:25
were the sort of issues that could have
15:27
brought everyone to be like, okay, we need
15:29
to do this? Yeah, for
15:31
sure. So we
15:33
first brought about
15:35
our petition to
15:38
unionize in March
15:40
of 2023. So
15:42
that was two years ago, a
15:45
long time ago, right? The
15:48
work for unionization, obviously the
15:50
organizing behind it started like
15:52
much before that when I
15:54
first joined friends, it was
15:56
in September of 22. And
15:59
I knew that the work
16:01
had already been like happening
16:03
the summer before. What
16:05
was the catalyst was
16:07
post COVID A, obviously a
16:09
lot of people left
16:11
given what COVID did to
16:14
a lot of industries
16:16
and especially care work. But
16:18
then likewise, a lot
16:20
of people were fired and
16:22
where many would say like
16:24
fired without like a full
16:26
on like deep process that
16:29
included a program manager. who
16:31
was really listening to
16:33
friends and advocating for
16:35
the mentor role. And
16:37
they were let go, which spurred a
16:40
lot of people to want to start
16:42
organizing some of the issues that we
16:44
face, like the pay obviously, like within
16:46
social work in general and nonprofit work,
16:48
like it's never going to match up
16:50
and never going to really be
16:53
as good as like the cost of
16:55
living, especially here in Portland, but the
16:57
pay compared to like all of the
16:59
emotional work and all the work that
17:01
we do was just not there and
17:03
not sustainable. It's why
17:05
people were not like able to
17:07
stick around because frankly, we
17:09
were looking at the same issues
17:11
that our families were facing
17:13
of like, you know, food insecurity
17:15
and needing to like get
17:18
food stamps or like
17:20
needing like rental and like housing
17:22
assistance because our pay was just
17:24
not up to par. Those are
17:26
a few of the issues. Jess,
17:28
I don't know if you have
17:30
other thoughts. Yeah, I
17:33
think you touched on a lot of them.
17:35
I think it's hard to stay in this
17:37
job. If you are looking to have a
17:39
family, there's been issues with pay, with insurance,
17:42
with other sorts of things that
17:44
have led to mentors leaving rather
17:46
than like staying there, even if
17:48
they like really wanted to
17:50
stay there just wouldn't necessarily
17:52
allow for them to have
17:54
maybe like the life they
17:56
wanted and also just honoring
17:58
I think with like bereavement
18:00
leave and critical issue leave
18:02
has been areas that haven't
18:04
really been addressed. We
18:07
have had very tragic
18:09
things happen in our
18:11
working community with the
18:13
families and that have
18:15
drastically affected Yeah,
18:17
the well -being of mentors and staff members
18:19
alike. Yeah, and I mean,
18:21
you know, this is a job
18:24
that structurally is designed to be
18:26
a kind of like, like
18:28
again, if the goal is to
18:30
have one person from like kindergarten to
18:32
tell they like like a graduating
18:34
high school, right? Like
18:36
that is something that requires
18:39
like 1950s, 1960s style
18:41
fortism. Like you have one
18:43
job for decades. And
18:45
the only way you can do
18:47
that is if people are incredibly well
18:49
supported. And it's like the fact
18:52
that it's like, okay, you're trying to
18:54
do this, but you're not paying
18:56
people enough money to fucking afford food.
18:58
Like, what the hell? Jesus
19:01
Christ. Oh
19:03
my God. Yeah,
19:05
or even, I mean, it's still
19:07
something that we're fighting, but like
19:10
our work. place doesn't provide health
19:12
insurance for dependents, which I think
19:14
is really ironic, giving how much
19:16
we care for kids. And then
19:18
some of our mentors and other
19:20
co -workers that have kids have
19:22
to spend so much money on
19:24
health insurance for their own personal
19:27
kids. Friends of some of the
19:29
kids, apparently. That's how this works.
19:32
The kids, they take. Yeah.
19:34
And honestly, big
19:37
picture thinking, the reason why
19:39
we Like started
19:41
this whole unionizing project was
19:43
because we care so
19:45
much about our kids, right?
19:48
Like I when I first started
19:50
working at friends like I I
19:53
think was the first mask mentor
19:55
to be hired in a fairly
19:57
long time after a lot of
19:59
firings of other mass mentors and
20:01
two of the youth that But
20:03
actually, it's more than two of
20:05
the youth, but the first two
20:08
youth that I was matched up
20:10
with, they hadn't had a mentor
20:12
for over two years, which
20:14
is a really long time.
20:16
Like when you are five,
20:18
six years old and you're
20:20
used to one person consistently
20:23
picking you up every single
20:25
week and hanging out with
20:27
you and spending time with
20:29
you for several hours, four,
20:32
six, over seven
20:34
years and then just like next
20:36
day, next week, maybe even
20:39
that same day you find out
20:41
like oh you no longer
20:43
have a mentor and you're not
20:45
going to have a mentor
20:47
for two more years because people
20:49
keep leaving, people aren't
20:51
wanting to apply for this job
20:53
because the pay isn't high enough,
20:55
right? That then like creates like
20:57
a lot of issues with the
21:00
kids that we're dealing with. It's
21:02
not like we are these like
21:04
saviors or like anything along those
21:06
lines, right? But when someone has
21:08
consistent support and then that support
21:10
is lost for a long time,
21:12
especially when you're a young kid
21:14
where it's been the majority of
21:16
your life you've been having that
21:18
consistent support, that then creates a
21:21
lot of trust issues and overall
21:23
attachment issues that youth could face. For
21:26
me that was the main
21:28
thing like working with these kids
21:30
and having to like regain
21:32
that trust was something that's like
21:34
still to this day is
21:36
like really emotionally like daunting and
21:38
I like I will keep
21:40
saying this I love my kids
21:42
so much like I like
21:44
can't stop thinking about them and
21:46
I want to be with
21:48
my kids until they graduate, which
21:51
would mean me staying at
21:53
this job for another eight years,
21:55
which it's a long time,
21:57
right? But I want to do
21:59
that. So I want to,
22:01
you know, get paid, have time
22:03
off when one of my, sadly,
22:06
this is something that did occur
22:08
where you've passed away that I worked
22:10
with and like didn't have time
22:12
off to like really grieve. Hard
22:15
stuff and I just want to
22:17
be able to stay there till they're
22:20
done with the program Just like
22:22
a litany of horrors. It's like one
22:24
it's like You know what when
22:26
there is like it's it's not you
22:28
know, like turnover in a normal
22:30
job sucks But this is like when
22:32
there's turnover because people can't afford
22:34
to live their lives It's like you're
22:36
just like ripping a hole in
22:38
these kids like the fabric of their
22:40
social lives and then also it's
22:42
like Yeah, one of these kids that
22:45
is literally your job to care
22:47
for dies. Did you just have to
22:49
fucking go to work the next
22:51
day? like it is
22:53
so hideous and it's just
22:55
like yeah, yeah Yeah, yeah,
22:57
no like it makes sense
22:59
that like Yeah, people are
23:01
organizing because it's like, you
23:03
know, like this organization is
23:05
just Systemically failing both the
23:07
people they're trying to help
23:09
and the people whose job
23:11
it is to like help
23:14
them and yeah Yeah Yeah,
23:16
I think one of the things
23:18
that is like hardest to
23:20
see while like working there is
23:22
the ways in which this
23:24
like job that you do like
23:26
that like I care so
23:29
much about and love doing but
23:31
like seeing this like institution
23:33
in a way be like part
23:35
be part of the problem
23:37
because if we aren't like having
23:39
it so that employees feel supported
23:42
in the way that they need
23:44
to like life happens sometimes people leave
23:46
and like move and get a
23:48
different job for various reasons but a
23:51
lot of the times it's it's
23:53
because it's not sustainable and it's really
23:55
hard to leave and like it's
23:57
a heartbreaking thing because I like I
23:59
want to graduate many of my
24:01
youth and it is something that I
24:03
think about of like how feasible
24:05
is that like I want to do
24:08
it and like also okay then
24:10
that means I got to be frugal
24:12
and all these other ways or
24:14
etc and Yeah, and working with youth
24:16
that have already kind of experienced
24:18
loss and wanting to continue to show
24:20
up for them the job itself
24:23
feels so sacred and like I feel
24:25
so lucky to be in these
24:27
kids lives and I think just a
24:29
lot of the turnover has been
24:31
out of like lack of sustainability for
24:33
Yourself like for your well -being. Um,
24:36
yeah Yeah, and I mean,
24:38
the turnover numbers were
24:40
pretty wild. I think one
24:42
time we calculated it
24:44
and mentors were, it was
24:46
like a 40 -something percent
24:48
turnover rate for mentors. Yeah,
24:51
and a lot of that
24:53
happened because in this two
24:56
-year time period where we've
24:58
been fighting for a contract, they
25:01
also froze
25:03
wage increases. I've
25:06
had the same wage for the past two
25:08
years, two and a half years that I've been
25:10
working here. And in
25:12
that same time period, inflation has
25:14
been pretty crazy and rent
25:17
for me has gone up times.
25:19
it's about to get worse. It's
25:21
about to get so much worse. Yeah.
25:25
Yeah. Which, which, you know, gladly
25:27
now we have this fight and we're
25:29
at the two year mark and
25:31
not at the zero year mark
25:33
and not looking forward to two more
25:35
years of doing this. But yeah,
25:37
it's been hard to sustain this
25:39
when everything is increasing in price and
25:42
our wages are completely stagnant. Yeah.
25:45
Yeah. So let's take one more ad
25:48
break and then we will come back
25:50
to talk about, yeah, how unionization efforts
25:52
are going and yeah. We
26:03
are back. Yes, let's talk
26:05
about how this campaign is
26:07
going. So you said you've
26:09
been in bargaining for like
26:11
two years? So
26:13
we had our petition
26:15
for recognition on
26:17
March 23rd, 2023. So
26:20
that was over
26:22
two years ago. And
26:24
then our employer
26:26
didn't formally recognize us.
26:28
But through the process
26:31
of like voting, we
26:33
got over 93%. Wow. That's
26:36
incredible. That's
26:38
incredible. It's super great.
26:40
And it's also like, wow, we all really
26:42
needed this. Yeah.
26:47
And there were some other barriers,
26:49
including not being formally recognized. We
26:51
also had management contest a
26:54
few positions that I believe
26:56
most, if not all,
26:58
we were able to successfully
27:00
have be part of our
27:02
unit. And then we didn't
27:04
have our first bargaining session
27:06
until September of 2023. So
27:08
almost six months, I think,
27:10
if I did the math
27:12
right, after we formally presented
27:14
our letter for recognition. Yeah. And
27:17
like throughout that process. So now it
27:19
has been like, Jesus is quite good
27:21
at keeping track of it. But I
27:23
think as of today, we're about at
27:27
580 days of bargaining God.
27:29
Yeah Yeah, it's been
27:31
a long one and it
27:33
hasn't been it's been
27:35
like also a choppy journey
27:37
where there has been
27:39
delays in Scheduling delays in
27:41
just getting different articles
27:43
back in time one of
27:46
the biggest ones obviously
27:48
was compensation and I think
27:50
I can't quite remember
27:52
the period of time but
27:54
we presented it and
27:56
a year ago, I think
27:58
maybe. Oh my god.
28:00
I could be wrong. And
28:03
it took several, several,
28:05
several months for us to
28:07
get anything back from
28:09
management, which, yeah, was a
28:11
big bummer amongst other
28:13
things. It sucks. It
28:15
sucks. And obviously
28:18
that's the one that we have
28:20
yet to finalize as we're talking
28:22
right now. Yeah, it is. Insurance
28:24
and compensation are still our
28:26
last two articles left. Yeah.
28:29
And some of the
28:31
difficult things, I mean,
28:34
when you are working on
28:36
a project, I
28:38
wouldn't be surprised given really
28:41
when these conversations started, if
28:43
we're looking at over 900
28:45
or 1 ,000 days of really
28:47
talking about this, but then
28:49
when you're dealing with bargaining
28:52
for 580 days.
28:55
Like it's exhausting. It is so
28:57
exhausting. We have regular meetings
28:59
that we attend to that our
29:01
bargaining meetings were specifically scheduled
29:03
outside of work hours so that
29:05
like the people on our
29:07
bargaining team and other union members
29:09
would have to put in
29:11
the extra time outside of our
29:13
40 hour week. Yeah.
29:17
And within that, like
29:19
the hardest part
29:21
is when you directly
29:24
confront your managers and your
29:26
bosses about the rights
29:28
and the things that you
29:30
need. So much of
29:32
it boils down to respect,
29:34
right? And your respect is
29:36
like a worker and the value that you
29:38
have as a worker in your organization. And
29:41
when there is the pushback on
29:43
that, it honestly is
29:45
Like for me at
29:47
times was debilitating, right? When
29:50
you're doing this work
29:52
and your workplace is stretching
29:54
things out for so
29:56
long. And you're pouring your
29:58
heart out on your kids, like
30:00
really trying to do the best.
30:03
That response from our
30:05
supervisors and managers,
30:08
like it really was
30:10
hard. It was hard for me. It was
30:12
hard for other union organizers in our workplace. And
30:14
it was hard for all of our workers
30:16
where we started thinking like, dang, what
30:18
is the value that we have in this
30:20
workplace? What is the value that we intrinsically
30:22
have in the work that we're doing with
30:24
our kids? And
30:26
it's a lot when you're facing all
30:29
these systems that our kids are facing
30:31
and taking those things in and then
30:33
are trying to change those systems, finally
30:35
able to try to change those systems.
30:37
And we learned that, oh, wait, the
30:39
place that we're working is actually part
30:41
of these systems too. And it's
30:43
doing the same things that we're like
30:45
fighting to have our kids like have
30:47
better lives. Like we're facing it right
30:49
now from inside the house. Yeah.
30:52
Yeah. I wanted to add in
30:54
to, yeah, very much realizing that
30:56
like our management is also in
30:58
a way operating, you know, maybe
31:00
like a corporation, which isn't the
31:02
hope you would have for a
31:04
nonprofit. And one of the steps
31:07
we had to take as
31:09
a union was filing a
31:11
UOP, so unfair labor practice, which
31:14
cited, like I had mentioned
31:16
before, like delays in scheduling
31:18
and also regressive bargaining, which
31:20
just means that like the
31:22
way in which they were
31:24
presenting things would have lessened
31:27
our like quality of conditions.
31:29
So definitely not what you want to be getting, not
31:32
what you want to be handed
31:34
across from the bargaining table. Yeah.
31:37
Yeah, yeah. Yeah, within this
31:39
process, they were currently salaried
31:41
workers, but they tried to change
31:43
us to hourly workers. Oh
31:46
my God. Yeah. Which
31:48
again, like, we're always working, you
31:50
know, we're always working. So
31:53
unless you want to pay me for
31:55
24 hours. You
31:59
know, talking about like, yeah, that they're behaving like
32:01
a corporation is like, oh, yeah This is exactly
32:03
what like by employer did to me which is
32:05
like like one of like one of the largest
32:07
media companies in the world and they dragged out
32:09
negotiations for two years and Like, you know, you're
32:11
talking about this sort of like just like oh,
32:13
they're like the filling of disrespect where they're just
32:16
not getting stuff back to you And it's like
32:18
I remember, you know, like we'd be sitting there
32:20
for a bargaining meeting and they wouldn't and they
32:22
would be an hour late And they'd be an
32:24
hour late because they hadn't like bothered to beforehand
32:26
spend time drafting out what their responses were going
32:28
to be So they were frantically trying to get
32:30
it done before we were there. And we're all
32:32
just sitting there for literally an hour waiting for
32:34
them to show up. And it's like, okay, there
32:36
are people in this unit whose job is to
32:38
stand next to car bombs, like, and you can't
32:40
show up on time to here, to this, to
32:42
this meeting that you have known was going to
32:44
happen for weeks. Like, it's just,
32:46
I say this every single episode is
32:48
like, this is an incredibly common YouTube
32:50
listening tactic is draw out the first
32:52
contract because that's, that's like the second
32:54
point where unions fail after like the,
32:57
after you get like, recognition
32:59
votes is like here. Yeah, for sure.
33:01
You know, like, I mean, I think
33:03
there's something that we expect corporations to
33:05
do this. But it's like, okay, this
33:07
is an NGO that's like the point
33:09
of which is supposed to be like
33:11
helping underprivileged, underprivileged youth. And then
33:14
they're like, we're going to turn around and
33:16
we're going to screw over different underprivileged youth.
33:19
Yeah, it sucks. Yeah. And
33:21
I think that's like, for me, one of the
33:23
things that just like mess with my mind
33:25
the most is that like, We're
33:27
not selling a product, right?
33:29
We're not trying to like
33:31
get revenue or anything along
33:33
those lines, right? So like
33:35
our job is a job
33:37
that we actually like fully
33:39
love and like want to
33:41
stick around like not not
33:43
just for our own like
33:46
financial piece and our own
33:48
financial security, we want to
33:50
stick around this job because
33:52
we care about the job.
33:54
That's not to like other
33:56
businesses and other workplaces that
33:58
unionize. A lot of times
34:00
people want to do that
34:02
because they want financial security.
34:04
I think for a lot
34:06
of NGOs, nonprofits and care
34:08
work, we unionize because we
34:10
want to stick around both
34:12
because of financial security, right?
34:14
But also because we just
34:16
like care so much about
34:18
the work that we're doing
34:21
and to be faced with
34:23
actions by our workplace that,
34:25
you know, tried to dissuade
34:27
us from that, tried to
34:29
like, you know, in a
34:31
sense, like it felt like
34:33
stopping us from wanting to
34:35
stick around. Like that,
34:37
again, really hard, really hard. And I
34:39
think like a really like
34:41
psychologically hard part that comes
34:43
with unionizing in the care
34:45
work field in the like
34:47
nonprofit space. Yeah, like this
34:49
isn't a job that people
34:51
are going to take for
34:53
the money. But we do
34:55
need to be receiving like
34:57
equitable pay and benefits so
34:59
that we stay at this
35:01
job. Like this by all
35:03
means and like still like
35:06
this is the same way
35:08
I feel about it to
35:10
this day. I remember reading
35:12
the little job description for
35:14
this role and was like,
35:16
oh, this is, dude, this
35:18
is my dream job. This
35:20
is 100 % what I want
35:22
to spend my energy towards.
35:26
Yeah, I think that's a huge
35:28
part of why we were able
35:30
to get like that 93 % and
35:33
to have also like routine support
35:35
for different actions and stuff is
35:37
just because we have people that
35:39
care so much about wanting to
35:41
stick around. Yeah. And
35:44
that's the thing that NGOs, you know, and
35:46
you see this in abortion work, you see
35:48
this in like, you see this in nursing,
35:50
you see this in all of these different
35:52
fields, like that's the thing that these NGOs
35:54
use to exploit people. is, you
35:56
know, like, I mean, is the
35:59
basic human empathy and love and care
36:01
that we have for the people
36:03
who are caring for it. And these
36:05
people are like, aha, look at
36:07
this. Aha, these people, they care about
36:09
the thing that they're doing. We
36:11
can underpay them and overwork them. It's
36:13
like, why is there
36:15
just a work like this? What
36:19
a terrible way to
36:21
design an economic system. It's
36:23
just, good Lord. Oh,
36:26
let's talk a little bit about like, you know,
36:28
what kinds of organizing things you all have been able
36:30
to do and the kinds of things you've been
36:32
able to accomplish by, you know, working together even in
36:34
these really kind of like, I
36:36
don't know, structurally difficult conditions.
36:39
Yeah, we've had, um, we've
36:42
had a multitude of different actions
36:44
over the past, you know, over
36:46
the past 580 days. Um, I
36:48
think one of our One
36:51
of our biggest ones by far,
36:53
which was I think also was
36:55
just one of our most beautiful
36:57
in a way was November of
36:59
last year we did an info
37:01
picket and it was one of
37:03
those things too where it Was
37:05
very well planned out, but also
37:07
even with the best of planning
37:09
midway through it. We had a
37:11
shift location based off of just
37:13
changing information we were getting and
37:15
we had One of our
37:17
little bits is because our
37:19
union is called fun. A
37:21
lot of our posters
37:24
were SpongeBob themed, so
37:26
instead of imagination, it's
37:28
compensation. And
37:31
I think it's indicative of
37:34
also how much people that
37:36
work with us are playful
37:38
and sweet and are good
37:40
at our jobs of working
37:42
with kids. Yeah,
37:46
we had very high turnout.
37:48
I think we had 40 -something
37:50
people within our own organization
37:52
that showed up for that.
37:54
We've done smaller actions too
37:56
by just asking for community support.
37:59
We've had caregivers write letters
38:01
of support to different people
38:03
in management. We've also done
38:05
a few pack the rooms for
38:07
bargaining sessions, especially when there have
38:09
been times that have felt like there's
38:11
been some semblance of stalling. Yeah,
38:13
those are just some of them. Hey, Steve, chime
38:15
in with others. Yeah, within that.
38:17
And I think an interesting
38:19
thing about nonprofits, our revenue
38:21
comes from donors. So we have
38:23
to play this fun game of,
38:25
OK, how do we communicate with
38:27
our donors so that we make
38:29
sure that they know that you
38:32
know, this is part of like
38:34
what they're donating to, but then
38:37
within that also like, you know,
38:39
ask for money as well, right?
38:41
Because we do want, you know,
38:43
better pay and better benefits, right?
38:45
So we've contacted donors and we'll
38:47
still plan to do that
38:49
with both that ask of like support the union
38:51
and support our organization, right? Because the thing
38:54
that we care about the most is the work
38:56
that we do with our kids and for
38:58
that to happen. We want
39:00
our organization to like stay afloat,
39:02
truly, right? Yeah, some
39:04
of the wins that we've
39:06
gotten, I mentioned earlier
39:08
that they were trying to
39:10
have us be hourly workers.
39:13
And that was a big
39:15
campaign that we were fighting
39:17
back on for a long
39:19
time. It's also what
39:21
precipitated the ULP filing. I
39:24
made too many buttons.
39:27
That's it. Um,
39:29
you could never have to anybody
39:31
truly, um, that said I work
39:33
40 plus hours a week because
39:35
one of the people on the
39:37
bargaining team for management at the
39:39
bargaining table asked if we even
39:41
work 40 hours a week. Um,
39:44
while we were talking about this
39:46
and that's like one of those
39:48
instances that I mean, like, yeah,
39:50
wow, that's like a little disrespectful
39:52
and like really bites. So we
39:54
all were wearing these pins regularly. We,
39:57
you know, we signed a strike.
39:59
pledge where we had like 80
40:01
something percent of the unit say
40:03
that like if we came to
40:05
voting for a strike people would
40:07
strike and the big win was
40:09
like okay great we get to
40:11
stay a salaried workers because they
40:13
walk back on that on that
40:15
threat we are time off We
40:17
have a time off contract or
40:19
agreement now that like some of
40:22
my co -workers that have been around
40:24
a long time once the contract
40:26
gets ratified, they'll have like two
40:28
more weeks of time off. Hell
40:30
yeah. Hell yeah. Because they haven't,
40:32
they've been around for seven years
40:34
and they're still at the same
40:36
amount of time off basically that
40:38
I'm at and that I've been
40:40
at since the beginning. Yeah. And
40:42
when it comes to wages, like
40:44
we're still Figuring
40:46
that out, but some of the
40:48
gains that we are potentially looking
40:51
at is like incredible like I
40:53
looked at the numbers yesterday of
40:55
like what hopefully given like where
40:57
we're at right now in in
40:59
the agreements like well I would
41:01
hopefully get and I straight up.
41:04
like teared up looking at the
41:06
number because it felt like such
41:08
a big change in my financial
41:10
status right and yesterday like as
41:12
i said i worked on 9
41:14
30 pm with my kids probably
41:17
because i had this like massive
41:19
like weight of you know this
41:21
financial doom that i'm looking at
41:23
somewhat lifted at the hope of
41:25
the wins that we might get
41:28
from this contract. So
41:30
it's been incredibly hard, incredibly long,
41:32
way too long, and all
41:34
of it is going to be
41:36
so worth it, right? I
41:38
hope that's something that the
41:40
listeners really get, that this
41:42
is hard work, but in
41:44
the end, is the change
41:46
that we were hoping for.
41:49
Yeah. Recently,
41:52
one of the things that we did
41:54
do just like a run through of
41:56
just to kind of boost morale since
41:58
the bargaining has gone on for so
42:00
long was compile all the wins that
42:02
we have so far just through TAs.
42:04
So still tentative, but yeah, it did
42:06
map out a lot of huge things.
42:08
One of the things we do a
42:11
lot in this job is drive and
42:13
we don't have many things in policy
42:15
about. Cleaning or
42:17
repairs when something happens in your car
42:19
with the youth like say they
42:21
throw up It happens with kids like
42:23
that isn't necessarily something that would
42:25
have been like covered We would have
42:27
had to just pay for that
42:29
cleaning ourselves and like mileage is a
42:32
huge thing where one of our
42:34
Potential like big wins is that we'll
42:36
get like full mileage covered Rather
42:38
than having to like deduct time from
42:40
like this illusion of having an
42:42
office where we would have to minus
42:44
some mileage in whatever way
42:46
made sense with where our buildings
42:49
were located, despite even
42:51
if our kids were like totally somewhere
42:53
else where we were picking them up. It
42:55
definitely wasn't like the most sensical way
42:57
for us to be like being fully
43:00
reimbursed for what we were doing. And
43:02
those are all huge wins
43:04
that we do have. Like obviously,
43:07
compensation and insurance are two of
43:09
the biggest that we're still
43:11
working on. I think recently, almost
43:13
within this week, we've started
43:16
to tip in a way that
43:18
feels like we may be
43:20
close to having a contract soon,
43:22
which I do want to say, as
43:24
inspiration to everybody out there that
43:27
works for a non -profit, unionize
43:29
and you know what? It
43:31
might farewell for you. I have hope
43:33
for everybody. Right now,
43:35
I think a lot of our Like
43:38
a lot of my co -workers are starting
43:40
to have hope again, because I do
43:42
think, like you said, it is totally
43:44
a manipulation tool to have it drawn
43:46
out so long. And yeah, it is
43:48
exhausting to be basically stalled in your
43:50
wage for two and a half years.
43:53
But we are gaining some traction
43:55
again, which I do think is
43:57
something that we're still being cautious
43:59
with just because... now it does
44:02
feel like management is working with
44:04
us a little bit more, but
44:06
I also think that there are
44:08
Reasonings around that like we're about
44:10
to have in a few weeks
44:12
our biggest Fundraiser for our work
44:14
because like Hsu said we are
44:16
majority donor based and I do
44:18
think there's an appeal to management
44:20
to have a contract by then
44:22
Yeah, it adds to the whole
44:24
we're doing good work and we
44:26
treat our employees well. I hope
44:28
that that is something then that
44:30
is fulfilled by them in an
44:33
honest way, not just a superficial
44:35
way, because we are still pushing
44:37
for a little bit more right
44:39
now and have bargaining coming up
44:41
next week. I'm really
44:43
hoping that what they're showing us
44:45
isn't just performative, that we
44:47
really might be able to get
44:49
to a point where there
44:51
is something that is truly good
44:54
for us, because we're all
44:56
ready for a contract. Yeah,
44:59
as you know, as someone
45:01
who got our contract like it
45:03
doesn't it doesn't magically solve
45:05
everything but like my god It
45:07
is absolutely worth it. Yeah
45:09
Okay, so how can people support
45:11
y 'all both sort of locally
45:13
here and then just like
45:15
broader because most people are not
45:17
here Honestly, most of our
45:20
like People in like management positions
45:22
information is public if you
45:24
want to email them in support
45:26
go for it Also just
45:28
like encouraging either your workplace if
45:30
you work in kind of
45:32
a social work setting or like
45:34
you know if you know
45:36
people that are because this
45:38
whole field of work takes such
45:40
a toll on people and it is
45:42
the most necessary work. And I
45:44
think it's really easy to fall into
45:46
the mindset of I'm doing this
45:48
for the greater good, not, you know,
45:50
not for money, not for these
45:53
things, but like you also deserve to
45:55
feel okay and taken care of
45:57
and like have the things you need
45:59
to be saying. Yeah.
46:01
Hey, say something else. Do you want to
46:03
add? Yeah, I
46:05
mean, I We
46:08
would add that we have
46:10
an Instagram, right? That's friends,
46:12
pdx union network. It's a
46:14
mouthful, but we'll link the
46:16
inscription. Yeah, great. And
46:18
then within that, if
46:21
you're in Portland, make
46:23
sure to follow us and pay
46:25
attention to what we're posting because
46:27
hopefully we do not have to
46:29
get to a point in striking,
46:31
especially The place that
46:33
we're at right now with our contract
46:36
but in truth like we're looking
46:38
at 580 days and that is quite
46:40
a long time Yeah, and then
46:42
also like if if listeners do have
46:44
the ability to donate if they
46:46
could donate some funds for friends of
46:48
the children Portland and somehow in
46:51
their notes be like I support the
46:53
union like I think that could
46:55
also be a really interesting way to
46:57
show the support that like our Supporters
47:00
have like for both the work
47:02
that we're doing on the youth level,
47:05
but then also like in the
47:07
union side of things too. There's
47:09
been a lot of like communication of
47:11
like, oh, this is really going to impact
47:13
like. the development side
47:15
of our organization and like
47:17
all of the things that
47:19
like our fundraising team is
47:21
gonna have to do to
47:23
like meet these, which again,
47:26
I think that would be
47:28
more true if like
47:30
our executive director wasn't making
47:32
like. what like five
47:34
times as much money as I am.
47:37
Jesus Christ. Yeah. But
47:39
yeah, showing that support like it
47:41
doesn't have to be a lot,
47:43
but showing our our bosses just
47:45
how much like the populace like
47:47
is supporting our unionization efforts like
47:49
that power to really don't too.
47:51
And then also like it impacts
47:53
our kids like our kids like
47:55
that's the truth of it all
47:57
like I want my kids
47:59
to have the best life that they could
48:01
possibly have. And sadly, we
48:03
live in a world where
48:06
money really dictates that. Yeah.
48:10
Yeah. Yeah. So
48:12
we will have links in the
48:14
description to all of that. And
48:16
yeah, thank you to both so much
48:18
for coming on the show. And I
48:21
hope you win. And yeah, I hope
48:23
you get to go back to caring
48:25
for these kids and also while not
48:27
having to worry about like being able
48:29
to live your lives. Thank you so
48:31
much. Yeah. Yeah,
48:33
thank you so much for having us. Yeah,
48:36
of course. Honestly, it's been
48:38
great talking about the work because it
48:40
is it is really important work
48:42
and I'm happy we get to do
48:44
it. Yeah, it's it's wonderful. And
48:46
yeah, and so this is yeah, this
48:48
this is been a good happen here.
48:50
And yeah, I'd also go unionize your
48:53
workplace. You can do it. I guarantee
48:55
it. It
49:13
is Ryan and I have a question
49:15
for you. What do you do when
49:18
you win? when you are you a Like
49:20
are you a fist-pumper? hand clap or a
49:22
high fiver. If you want to hone
49:24
in on those winning moves, check
49:26
out If you Choose from hundreds of social
49:28
those games for your chance to redeem
49:30
serious cash prizes. There are new
49:33
game releases of social daily bonuses. So don't
49:35
wait. Start having the most fun redeem
49:37
serious cash prizes. There by Chumba Casino, no
49:39
purchase necessary. weekly plus, prohibited by law.
49:41
18 plus terms and conditions apply. So
49:44
good. Your bill, ladies? I got
49:46
it. No, I got it. Seriously,
49:49
I insist. I insisted first. Oh,
49:51
don't be silly. You don't be
49:53
silly. People with the Wells Fargo
49:55
Active Cash Credit Card prefer to
49:57
pay because they earn unlimited 2
49:59
% cash back on purchases. OK.
50:01
Rock, paper, scissors for it. Rock,
50:03
paper, scissors, shoot! No! The
50:06
Wells Fargo Active Cash
50:08
Credit Card. Visit wellsfargo.com slash
50:10
activecash terms apply. Does
50:12
this podcast make you happy? Of
50:14
course it does. That's why you're
50:16
here. But it only comes out
50:19
once a week. For happiness every
50:21
night? You need Adam and Eve.
50:23
Yes, I'm talking about sex toys.
50:26
It's cool. It's cool. You have earbuds in, right? Adam
50:29
and Eve, America's most trusted source
50:31
for adult products, has been making people
50:33
very happy for over 50 years.
50:35
with thousands of toys for both men
50:37
and women. of toys for both men and women. Just
50:39
go to Adam and eve.com now
50:41
and enter code I heart for
50:43
50% off almost any one item.
50:45
Plus free discrete shipping. That's Adam
50:47
and eve.com code I heart for
50:49
50% off. Company. And
50:55
no matter what the day holds, we
50:57
come to the Today Show for all
50:59
of it. When things are tough, we
51:01
talk about it. When there's something to
51:03
figure out, we dig into it. And
51:05
when there's joy, we celebrate it. Because
51:07
today is where it's all happening. We
51:09
get the best start to every
51:11
morning because we started together. Watch the
51:13
Today Show with Savannah Guthrie and
51:16
Craig Melvin weekdays at 7 a .m.
51:18
on NBC. Hello
51:24
and welcome to the show. It's
51:26
me, James, today, and I am
51:28
joined by Garrison Davis. Hi, Garrison.
51:30
Hello. Hello. Garrison has just said some
51:33
words about something that's happening on
51:35
social media that I don't understand. And
51:38
it's made me feel very old. This
51:40
was happening today in my world. It's
51:42
very sad. We're gathered
51:44
here today to talk about the
51:46
earthquake in Myanmar, right? I
51:48
think most of you will probably have
51:50
been made aware of the earthquake. It's
51:53
somewhat odd that Corporate media has really
51:55
not reported on the revolution in any
51:58
substantial way since 2021. But the earthquake
52:00
apparently justified a lot of networks sending
52:02
people to Myanmar for the first time.
52:04
Very amusingly, people DMing me on Blue
52:06
Sky and Twitter asking how to get
52:08
a visa from the Burmese Hunter, which
52:10
is not a thing I have ever
52:13
done. The last communication I had with
52:15
them came in the form of a
52:17
car bomb that they set off near
52:19
to a place where we were. If
52:22
you're not aware, the earthquake happened
52:25
on the 28th of March this year,
52:27
just before one in the afternoon. It
52:30
was the biggest earthquake in Myanmar
52:32
since 1912, and it registered 7
52:34
.7 on the Richter scale, which
52:36
is huge. Because it's very
52:38
hard for foreign journalists to get
52:40
a visa to enter Myanmar, I
52:42
love the initial reporting focused on
52:44
Bangkok and the damage done in
52:46
Thailand. But the episode
52:48
was in Sargang, which is near
52:50
Mandalay, Mandalay's second biggest city in
52:52
Myanmar. And that was
52:54
where the worst of the destruction
52:56
happened. Almost every street
52:58
in Mandalay has collapsed buildings.
53:01
It's a little difficult for us to
53:03
get a sense of the exact
53:05
scale of the damage because the Hunter
53:07
refuses to allow... Some media has
53:10
been allowed in. The BBC, I saw,
53:12
like, sneaked somebody in. It's very
53:14
difficult for media to move and report
53:16
freely. In addition to
53:18
this, the hunter has continued his
53:20
practice of cutting off internet for
53:22
people in Myanmar, right? Even during
53:24
emergency situations? Yes, especially
53:26
during emergency. They've cut it off
53:28
as a response to this because I
53:30
guess they perceive it to be
53:32
something that makes them look weak. This
53:34
is a tendency that
53:37
the hunter has displayed before.
53:39
So in 2008, Cyclone
53:41
Nargis affected Myanmar and killed
53:43
over 130 ,000 people and
53:45
they blocked international aid. They
53:48
said that people didn't need
53:50
the quote chocolate bars that the
53:52
US and other countries were
53:54
trying to deliver and that they
53:56
could exist by like hunting
53:58
frogs and ditches was their suggestion.
54:01
I don't think people realize
54:03
like how far down
54:05
the North Korea scale that
54:07
the Burmese hunter is.
54:09
But they're very worried that
54:12
any interaction with the
54:14
outside world, specifically with, I
54:16
guess, Western neoliberal powers
54:18
will be damaging for their
54:20
ability to control the
54:23
population. So for
54:25
that reason, we
54:27
don't know how many people have died,
54:29
right? From what I've
54:31
heard on the ground, the death
54:33
toll is substantially higher than the 3
54:35
,600 number being reported. The US Geological
54:37
Survey estimated that an earthquake of
54:39
that magnitude in that region would kill
54:41
between 10 ,000 and 100 ,000 people. Obviously,
54:44
that's quite a big kind of delta there. What
54:47
I can tell you is that
54:49
I've heard firsthand that there are some
54:52
parts of Mandalay and Sagang where
54:54
the stench of rotting bodies is so
54:56
powerful that people have stopped returning
54:58
to their homes. There
55:00
have been so many aftershocks that people
55:02
are still sleeping in the street
55:04
because they're worried about the damage structures
55:06
falling down. The UN
55:09
has an estimate of 17
55:11
million people across 57 townships.
55:13
Townships are like the administrative
55:15
districts that are used in
55:17
Myanmar have been affected with
55:19
over 9 million people facing
55:21
severe hardship. And of
55:23
course, this is all compounded by the fact
55:25
that there were already 20 million people in
55:27
Myanmar who needed humanitarian assistance. And
55:29
there are about three and a half million
55:31
internally displaced people as a result of the fighting
55:33
that's happened after the revolution. So
55:35
it really came at a pretty
55:38
difficult time in a place where
55:40
the government is not willing to...
55:42
They said after the earthquake they
55:44
wanted international aid, but as we'll
55:46
see later in this script, they've
55:48
only accepted it from certain countries.
55:51
I spoke to a friend who has
55:53
family in Mandalay yesterday. He told
55:55
me that The way they're assessing the
55:57
damage is using like open source
55:59
intelligence. They're trying to look in
56:01
the backgrounds of people's videos on Facebook
56:03
to like work out if their childhood
56:05
homes failed out, right? They
56:07
were using satellite imaging software when I
56:09
spoke to them yesterday to try
56:11
and ascertain if their families were okay.
56:15
They told me Saigang has very famous
56:17
pagodas and the pagodas are all on
56:19
a hill and apparently a lot of
56:21
those pagodas have fallen down and even
56:23
the hill itself is like listing. So
56:25
there's been massive cultural damage
56:27
as well. Another
56:30
way in which the damage was
56:32
compounded by Myanmar's politics was the quake
56:34
strike, like I said, at 1
56:36
p .m. on a Friday, which is
56:38
Friday prayers. This happened during Ramadan, specifically
56:40
the day before Idul Fitta, which
56:42
is a very busy day for mosques,
56:44
if you're not aware. Successive
56:46
governments of Myanmar since the
56:49
1960s have refused to allow
56:51
even basic maintenance for mosques.
56:53
That means that these buildings
56:55
were in great states of
56:57
disrepair, right? Myanmar, there
56:59
is an ultra -nationalist Buddhist movement,
57:02
which has been embraced to a
57:04
great degree by the Hunter, but
57:06
also limited even like the National
57:08
League for Democracy, which was the
57:10
relatively neoliberal aligned party that had
57:12
previously been empowering Myanmar or somewhat
57:15
in power, I suppose. ultra
57:17
-nationalist Buddhist monks like Ashin Murathu
57:19
and his 969 movement have kind
57:21
of condemned anything that they did
57:23
as making a pro -Muslim. And they
57:25
have this, essentially they have a
57:27
great replacement theory, right, that Muslims
57:29
are trying to come in through
57:31
Bangladesh to replace Buddhists in Myanmar.
57:33
Yeah, lots of people
57:36
here have this like
57:38
very orientalist perspective of
57:40
like Buddhism, TM, as
57:42
this like, you know, like peaceful
57:44
blah, blah, blah, blah. And like,
57:46
you know, like Buddhism, like every religion has
57:48
a variety of sex. Yes. And
57:51
the Buddhist national sex can
57:53
be particularly nasty. Yeah. I mean,
57:55
as vicious as any other, people,
57:58
I'm sure, will be familiar with the
58:00
Rohingya genocide. And like, there are a lot
58:02
of monks that supported that, including where
58:04
Arthur is the most notable one, but there
58:06
are plenty more, right? And they're part
58:08
of that. I mean, he's literally explicitly expressed,
58:10
like, how much he looks up to
58:12
the English Defense League. Jesus. Yeah,
58:15
these are people who,
58:17
they are part of this
58:19
global nativist movement. People's
58:21
Orientalism, I think, sometimes stops them
58:23
seeing that or appreciating that this extends
58:25
outside of white global North countries. One
58:29
thing that I did think that
58:31
really touched me in the days
58:33
after the earthquake was young Buddhist
58:35
Bama people of the majority ethnicity
58:37
reaching out to me and being
58:40
like, hey, man, This happened
58:42
in Friday prayers during Ramadan, and
58:44
it has devastated the Muslim population. Thousands
58:47
of people, hundreds of mosques have gone, and thousands
58:49
of people are trapped in a rubble, and no one's
58:51
talking about it. Why is no one talking about
58:53
it? This is terrible. And
58:55
it would have been inconceivable
58:58
to hear young Bama Buddhist
59:00
people so concerned with the
59:02
well -being of their Muslim countrymen
59:04
before the coup in 2021.
59:06
This was a country that
59:08
had been manufacturing consent for
59:10
genocide against its Muslim minorities
59:12
for four or five years
59:14
by that point, right? Specifically
59:16
on Facebook, there's a behind -the -bastards episode
59:18
on this. You can also listen. If
59:21
you're new to the show, Robert and I
59:23
have made two scripted series about the revolution
59:25
in Myanmar, which we'll include in the show
59:27
notes. But that
59:29
change to... a
59:32
real genuine solidarity and care between these
59:34
two groups, which was really touching in
59:36
the moments after the earthquake and the
59:38
days after the earthquake. When
59:40
we come back, I want to talk a little bit
59:42
more about the revolution and I want to talk
59:44
about how the revolution has been responding to this and
59:46
the impact it's had on the revolution. We
59:58
are back. And of
1:00:00
course, The revolution hasn't stopped
1:00:02
because of the earthquake. The
1:00:04
conflict is still ongoing, and
1:00:06
the PDFs and their Allied
1:00:09
Ethnic Business Organisations are still
1:00:11
fighting against the Hunter. In
1:00:13
fact, within an hour of the
1:00:15
earthquake, the Hunter began using paramotors
1:00:17
to drop bombs on Hangu Village
1:00:19
in Sugai. This has
1:00:21
been a thing that they've started to
1:00:24
do recently. In a sense,
1:00:26
I guess it's a good sign because it
1:00:28
shows that maybe their jets and other aircraft
1:00:30
are in a poor state of repair, or
1:00:32
that they're struggling to keep enough of them
1:00:34
airborne. Initially, I wondered if
1:00:37
they were using the paramotors because
1:00:39
their runways had been damaged, but that
1:00:41
doesn't seem to be the case.
1:00:43
They've been air striking just as much
1:00:45
as they ever did, which is
1:00:47
unfortunate. Satellite images or reports
1:00:49
from my source on the ground suggest
1:00:51
that they're able to continue carrying out
1:00:54
bombing raids at a pretty similar rate
1:00:56
from when they did before. Despite
1:00:58
this, The national unity government, which
1:01:00
is kind of the shadow government, composed
1:01:02
mostly of people who were elected
1:01:05
and then deposed by the coup in
1:01:07
2021. And the PDF,
1:01:09
who in theory are commanded by
1:01:11
the national unity government, called a two
1:01:13
week ceasefire right after the earthquake
1:01:15
to allow for like a humanitarian pause.
1:01:18
The Three Brotherhood Alliance, which is
1:01:20
an alliance of the three most
1:01:22
powerful ethnic resistance organizations in Myanmar,
1:01:24
also called what they called a
1:01:26
humanitarian pause for a month. In
1:01:28
both cases, They said they wouldn't
1:01:30
undertake offensive operations, but they would defend
1:01:32
themselves, right? Because I think they had a
1:01:35
sense that the Hunter wasn't going to
1:01:37
stop attacking them. The Hunter
1:01:39
did declare its own ceasefire
1:01:41
on April 3rd, and the Kuchin
1:01:43
Independence Army, which is another
1:01:45
ethnic resistance organization, followed shortly thereafter.
1:01:48
Notably, that ceasefire from the Hunter came
1:01:50
the day after its troops fired
1:01:52
on a Chinese Red Cross convoy, which
1:01:55
is not a great look for them. No,
1:01:57
never loved to see that. Yeah, we don't love
1:01:59
to see people firing on the Red Cross. This
1:02:02
is especially bad for the Hunter because China
1:02:04
has been growing closer and closer to the
1:02:06
Hunter and supporting it. China's had
1:02:08
this weird back and forth relationship
1:02:10
with the revolution. At times it supported
1:02:12
the revolution, it seems like, specifically
1:02:14
supporting the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army,
1:02:17
which is a group that broke off
1:02:19
the Communist Party of Burma in the
1:02:21
1980s. Yeah, that makes sense. There's
1:02:23
also the United States Army, which isn't
1:02:25
part of the revolution, which is the which
1:02:28
has the strongest relationship with the PRC,
1:02:30
and they're just chilling. They haven't really entered
1:02:32
the conflict. It's called straight chilling, by
1:02:34
the way, James. Straight chilling? Yeah, there you
1:02:36
go. That's how they use it. I've
1:02:39
marked myself out yet again.
1:02:41
Straight chilling. United Water
1:02:43
State Army. Thank you,
1:02:45
Garrison. Actually,
1:02:48
I spoke to some cadres
1:02:50
from the... Burmese Communist Party
1:02:52
recently. The Communist Party of
1:02:54
Burma re -entered after 2021, and
1:02:57
they're not focusing on proselytizing
1:02:59
the Maoist gospel to people,
1:03:01
they're focusing on fighting the
1:03:03
Hunter and developing alliances. And
1:03:06
it's interesting to see where that
1:03:08
will go given Marxist -Leninist Maoism is
1:03:10
definitely not the majority of
1:03:12
the revolution. Most people are committed
1:03:14
to some form of federal democracy, which
1:03:16
when you speak to different fighters
1:03:19
varies from We want what you guys
1:03:21
have in the US to something
1:03:23
more akin to the democratic confederalism that
1:03:25
people might be familiar with in
1:03:27
Rishabha. China is competing with
1:03:29
Russia in Myanmar. So both
1:03:31
of them are interested in supporting
1:03:33
the Hunter, right? And obviously,
1:03:35
both their ideologies are far from
1:03:37
liberatory. They're interested in propping
1:03:39
up a totalitarian state. So
1:03:42
we have seen both Russia
1:03:44
and China send support. to
1:03:46
the hunters and like rescue
1:03:48
teams after the earthquake. Meanwhile,
1:03:50
the US offered $2 million,
1:03:53
which I was kind of surprised
1:03:55
they offered anything. That is
1:03:57
low key surprising considering Mark Rubio.
1:04:00
Right, yeah. Well, I think Rubio is
1:04:02
more of a like a slightly,
1:04:04
Rubio's a neocon. Yeah, I guess like
1:04:06
it makes sense. Mark Rubio, like
1:04:08
five years ago, it doesn't make sense,
1:04:10
like post like you say to
1:04:13
being gutted. They were like, oh, you're
1:04:15
still doing that kind of stuff,
1:04:17
huh? Yeah, there's like a weird like
1:04:19
mix of things because yes, like
1:04:21
a traditional neocon style rubio, this tracks,
1:04:23
but all of the movements that
1:04:25
the Trump administration's been doing more recently,
1:04:27
this seems like seems like a
1:04:30
Some kind of DEI shenanigans, if you
1:04:32
ask me. Yeah, actually they added
1:04:34
another seven million later. Nine million. Which
1:04:36
is, yeah, it's not a lot
1:04:38
of money compared to what we would
1:04:40
normally expect. And at the same
1:04:42
time they did it, three
1:04:44
USAID workers, at least three I should
1:04:46
say, three that I'm aware of,
1:04:48
were laid off like literally they received
1:04:51
emails telling them that they no
1:04:53
longer had a job while they were
1:04:55
on the ground assisting earthquake survivors.
1:04:57
Department of Government Efficiency strikes again. Highly
1:04:59
efficient. We'll send you the money
1:05:01
and then also pull out our own people who I guess
1:05:03
are supervising how the money is spent or would be. It
1:05:06
definitely shows a strategic shift
1:05:08
in the region. China and Russia,
1:05:11
China obviously is interested in
1:05:13
Myanmar because of its rare
1:05:15
earth metals because of jade. China
1:05:18
has originally had a lot of
1:05:20
jade trade with Myanmar and then because
1:05:23
it controls a large amount of sea
1:05:25
front, right? Which China wouldn't want to
1:05:27
fall into like what it would see
1:05:29
as like someone with adversarial interests. Russia
1:05:31
is still interested in just kind of
1:05:33
projecting itself as a global power even
1:05:35
as it continues to shrink every day
1:05:37
in terms of its global ability to
1:05:39
project power. But there definitely
1:05:41
are both Chinese and Russian
1:05:43
assistance helping the Myanmar Hunter now.
1:05:46
Meanwhile, the US doesn't seem to give
1:05:48
a shit what happens here now. Like
1:05:50
this is kind of Not that the
1:05:52
Biden administration was doing very much either,
1:05:54
but at least we had USAID and
1:05:57
like USIP was very invested in Myanmar
1:05:59
and actually did a really good job
1:06:01
of kind of almost like being the
1:06:03
foreign affairs, not branch, but like
1:06:05
they explained the revolution to the world. Like
1:06:07
whenever a journalist wanted to understand the
1:06:09
revolution in Myanmar was USIP they went to.
1:06:11
Obviously all the countries that have a
1:06:13
USIP have now been doged, which is a
1:06:15
shame. So despite the
1:06:17
ceasefire, Right. I said they
1:06:19
fired on these Chinese troops.
1:06:21
The Hunter has in fact
1:06:24
not stopped bombing earthquakes, drug
1:06:26
areas, since the earthquake. Madeleine
1:06:28
PDF, who I'm in contact with,
1:06:30
they're the revolutionary forces in the area that
1:06:32
was most affected by the earthquake. On April
1:06:34
7th, told me that they were aware of
1:06:36
10 airstrikes in their area of operations. Since
1:06:39
the earthquake, a three -month -old baby and
1:06:41
a 10 -year -old child were killed in
1:06:43
an air raid on Naikav village in
1:06:45
Papuntownship. that was in Korean state. On
1:06:48
April 10th, they bombed a school. It's
1:06:50
something that the hunter likes to do
1:06:52
a lot, and they dropped two 500
1:06:54
pound bombs on a food court. They
1:06:56
then circled back and dropped another bomb
1:06:58
on the people responding to and giving
1:07:00
aid to the people they'd initially bombed
1:07:02
in the food court. By food court
1:07:04
here, just to clarify, I'm not talking
1:07:06
about like at the shopping mall, I'm
1:07:09
talking about like a market where people
1:07:11
can buy like prepared food, right? They've
1:07:14
killed... best I
1:07:16
can collate from various sources at
1:07:18
least 72 people and injured
1:07:20
about 100 people in addition to
1:07:22
thousands who died after the
1:07:24
earthquake. There are also
1:07:26
reports that hunter quote unquote recruiters
1:07:28
here are engaging in forced conscription
1:07:30
in the disaster zone. I read
1:07:32
of at least one person who
1:07:34
was on a search and rescue
1:07:36
team that they were trained search
1:07:39
and rescue volunteer right so they
1:07:41
were moving rubble to rescue people
1:07:43
and they were forcibly conscripted while
1:07:45
they were doing that. Obviously that's
1:07:47
had a chilling effect on people
1:07:49
going out to help others right.
1:07:52
What the country is not doing
1:07:54
is rescuing its citizens the
1:07:56
military is. Detested in
1:07:58
most of me and my even the
1:08:00
areas that it controls and it's failure to
1:08:02
even try and track people rest you
1:08:04
the rubber won't help this there was a
1:08:06
video that went viral recently of hunter
1:08:08
troops like literally a line of soldiers rescuing
1:08:10
bricks. They've gone to a collapsed
1:08:12
building and they're they're inspecting the bricks to see
1:08:14
if the bricks are whole and then passing
1:08:16
them down the line and stacking them up don't
1:08:18
worry the bricks are safe yeah the bricks
1:08:20
are safe the people are not. It
1:08:23
was genuinely infuriating to see it.
1:08:25
I can't imagine for people who have
1:08:28
lost family members how it must
1:08:30
feel. Even rescue workers,
1:08:32
like I said, have been
1:08:34
forcibly conscripted. Equality Myanmar
1:08:36
has noted more than 100 cases
1:08:38
of forced conscription since the earthquake. Myanmar
1:08:41
has a conscription rule law, so anyone...
1:08:43
and now women between certain ages can
1:08:45
be forcibly conscripted into the Hunter's army.
1:08:47
So they're just finding people displaced from
1:08:49
the earthquake and forcing them. Yeah, it's
1:08:51
people who have been hiding in their
1:08:53
homes, right, who now don't have homes
1:08:55
to hide it. Yeah. Or people who
1:08:58
came out in order to save their
1:09:00
neighbors. And now they're forcing them to
1:09:02
be, to fight for them. Just
1:09:04
as the Hunter did with Cyclone
1:09:06
Nargis, they've also delayed and in
1:09:08
cases blocked aid. A team
1:09:10
came from France to assist in a
1:09:12
search and rescue. They spent
1:09:15
24 hours sitting in an airport
1:09:17
waiting for their visa to be
1:09:19
approved, and then they spent
1:09:21
one day working in search and rescue efforts
1:09:23
before being told that search and rescue
1:09:25
efforts had now finished and they were to
1:09:27
go home. They traveled around the entire
1:09:29
world and didn't save a single life. Abundance.
1:09:31
Yeah, it's great. Presumably
1:09:34
because the Hunter wanted to placate China,
1:09:36
a Taiwanese team was straight up refused
1:09:38
entry into Myanmar. that Taiwan
1:09:41
had a search and rescue team that they're
1:09:43
willing to send who could have saved people
1:09:45
lives and that they weren't allowed to enter.
1:09:47
All tourist visas have been suspended so it's
1:09:49
not like the hunter is overwhelmed with visa
1:09:51
applications but they're not allowing search and rescue
1:09:53
teams to enter from countries I guess they're
1:09:55
not politically aligned with. This kind
1:09:57
of horrific indifference to human suffering has
1:09:59
characterized the top of the door for decades
1:10:01
and it's really unlikely to change as
1:10:03
it grows even more desperate and it loses
1:10:05
even more territory, it's just going to
1:10:08
clamp down harder and harder on its people.
1:10:10
B1 in the liberated areas, aid
1:10:12
is being mobilized using the mutual aid structures
1:10:14
which have existed for decades in the absence of
1:10:16
the state. In significant and
1:10:18
growing parts of Myanmar, people
1:10:20
are relying on each other instead
1:10:22
of the government for aid, and
1:10:24
that has its benefit. People have
1:10:26
been out rescuing people from the
1:10:28
rubble, but they're also desperately short
1:10:30
of resources. I spoke to Mandalay
1:10:32
PDF rescue team at the first
1:10:34
week of April, and they
1:10:36
literally sent me, they have a notebook.
1:10:38
of a list of, like, we've run
1:10:41
out of gauze, we've run out of
1:10:43
tourniquets, we've run out of adhesive dressings,
1:10:45
we've run out of elastic bandages, right?
1:10:47
The literal nuts and bolts of saving
1:10:49
people's lives they run out of. We
1:10:51
did a fundraising campaign for them through
1:10:53
Behind the Bastards. We raised nearly $2 ,000,
1:10:55
which is great. So they're restocking their
1:10:57
supplies, which is fantastic, but that's just
1:10:59
one township all across the country. People
1:11:01
are struggling for the basic supplies that
1:11:03
they need to save lives. The
1:11:05
military has also blocked Ada Medicine from
1:11:07
entering their areas, right? So the military
1:11:10
controls a lot of roadblocks and it
1:11:12
uses its control of those roadblocks to
1:11:14
stop Ada Medicine. Often it's kind of
1:11:16
hoarding it in the capital city, which
1:11:18
is Napidore. People aren't familiar, Napidore is
1:11:20
a city that they've come to build
1:11:22
for itself to govern from, the seat
1:11:24
of kings. Also in
1:11:26
Napidore right now is the US
1:11:29
aid agency Samaritan's Purse. You familiar
1:11:31
with Samaritan's Purse, Garrison? I don't
1:11:33
think so. It sounds vaguely familiar,
1:11:35
but all of these humanitarian organizations
1:11:37
all have like the same like
1:11:39
four words that they shuffle around
1:11:41
in different ways, so... Yeah, yeah,
1:11:43
yeah. Samaritan's Purse, perhaps most famous
1:11:45
for being run by Franklin Graham.
1:11:47
Okay, yes, yes. do know what
1:11:50
this is and who this is,
1:11:52
yes. Yeah, having all their volunteers
1:11:54
sign like a statement of faith
1:11:56
and being extremely homophobic. For
1:11:58
some reason, Samaritan's Purse is establishing a
1:12:00
field hospital in Napidore right now. They're
1:12:02
going to force people to convert to
1:12:04
evangelical Christianity before they give services like
1:12:07
they do in some cases. Yeah. Or
1:12:09
just leave them like they did in
1:12:11
Afghanistan if they're not Christian. I cannot
1:12:13
work out for the life of me
1:12:15
what the fuck they're doing. Because
1:12:17
like the hunter has made a
1:12:19
consistent policy of bombing Christians in Myanmar,
1:12:21
right? In Korean and Korean estate,
1:12:23
there a lot of Christian people on
1:12:26
Christmas Day. The hunter bombed people
1:12:28
going to services because it knew that
1:12:30
Christians would be going to services
1:12:32
at churches, right? The Kareni
1:12:34
Christians this year, I saw celebrated
1:12:36
Christmas in caves because they
1:12:38
were so afraid of big bombed,
1:12:40
right? Like, I have no
1:12:42
idea what logical leap you have
1:12:44
to make. Bizarre. Yeah, it's...
1:12:47
And they're not even at the...
1:12:49
In Segang, the only people, the
1:12:51
only international aid I'm aware of that was able
1:12:53
to make it to Segang was a Malaysian team.
1:12:56
who were able to save some lives. Unfortunately,
1:13:00
there were really strong rains this week, and
1:13:02
that made all the collapse structures even more
1:13:04
unstable, and the Malaysian team I saw have
1:13:06
now returned home. We're going to take another
1:13:08
ad break here. When we come back, we
1:13:10
will talk about what you can do to
1:13:12
help. All
1:13:23
right, and we're back. First,
1:13:25
I want to, I guess, have some good news. Despite
1:13:28
everything, the military has still been taking
1:13:30
massive losses. The Orberma
1:13:32
Students' Democratic Front captured remaining
1:13:34
Hunter positions in Indore. The
1:13:37
Orberma Students' Democratic Front are a
1:13:39
group that's been around since 1988,
1:13:41
right? And they have armed up
1:13:43
and re -entered the revolution since
1:13:45
2021. One of the things
1:13:47
that they captured on Monday was
1:13:49
a underground Japanese field hospital from World
1:13:52
War II. which I guess had
1:13:54
been like an entrenched position. I
1:13:56
guess they're not covered technically by the
1:13:58
ceasefire, but there was a unit under
1:14:01
the National Unity Government's command that operated
1:14:03
with them. And from what I understand,
1:14:06
this began as a defensive
1:14:08
action. They'd surrounded the Hunter, I
1:14:10
think it's called Japan Cave Hill. They'd
1:14:12
surrounded them on Japan Cave Hill for a
1:14:15
long time, and then the Hunter obviously
1:14:17
seeing the earthquake and everything, thereafter decided that
1:14:19
now was the time for them to
1:14:21
break out. of this encirclement. They did not
1:14:23
break out, they took a fat L
1:14:25
and as a result, they've all been captured
1:14:27
now. Meanwhile, in
1:14:30
Chinland, if people haven't listened to
1:14:32
the episode I did a couple of weeks
1:14:34
ago with Azad from the anti -fascist internationalist
1:14:36
front, I would suggest going back and listening
1:14:38
to that to understand Chinland. But
1:14:40
the AIF and a lot of their
1:14:42
allied forces from the Chinland Defense Force
1:14:44
and the Chin Brotherhood had a significant
1:14:46
victory in capturing the rest of the
1:14:48
Hunter's positions in Phalaam last week. And
1:14:50
I think it's very much like on
1:14:52
the table that we will see the
1:14:55
whole of Chinlain liberated in the next
1:14:57
few months or by the end of
1:14:59
the year, which would be great to
1:15:01
see. So people are wondering
1:15:03
like what they can do to help,
1:15:05
right? And I think it's a very
1:15:07
valid question because I saw today that
1:15:09
the UN was meeting with the hunter
1:15:11
in Naipetor. And I just have no
1:15:13
faith that any money that goes to
1:15:16
the hunter is going to get to
1:15:18
people who need it. Yeah, no, absolutely
1:15:20
not. You cannot. They
1:15:22
want them to die. No,
1:15:25
they're like evil. Yeah,
1:15:27
yeah, they are literally genocide or
1:15:29
they have done a genocide that
1:15:32
has been prosecuted international criminal court.
1:15:34
I have no understanding why people
1:15:36
continue to, international organizations continue to
1:15:39
funnel money to them other than
1:15:41
because they have a status quo
1:15:43
bias, I guess. So don't be
1:15:45
doing that, but there are groups
1:15:47
who are making a really big
1:15:49
difference. And one of them that I wanted to highlight, and
1:15:52
Robert and I both very
1:15:54
familiar with their work from the
1:15:56
last time that we were
1:15:58
overreporting is community partners international. CPI
1:16:00
are really cool because they
1:16:02
work by empowering members of the
1:16:04
local community to be health
1:16:06
volunteers, as opposed to dropping in
1:16:09
some doctors from America or
1:16:11
doctors from... Kingdom or whatever. And
1:16:13
then when those people leave,
1:16:15
they take their skills with them.
1:16:17
CPI, the thing is to educate
1:16:19
folks within the community so that
1:16:21
they can take care of one
1:16:24
another. And it's sort of CPI
1:16:26
has a matching donations thing right now, which
1:16:28
is pretty cool. So like
1:16:30
if you donate, someone else will
1:16:32
match your donation and that will
1:16:34
double the amount that you receive.
1:16:37
Otherwise, I will provide a list of
1:16:39
mutual aid funds that have been shared
1:16:41
with me. Most of them are like
1:16:43
GoFundMe's or things like that. I'll put
1:16:45
it all in the show description. They've
1:16:48
all been vetted and like, I
1:16:50
know people are sometimes reluctant to give
1:16:52
to GoFundMe's and they'd rather give
1:16:54
to like a 501c3 or like an
1:16:57
organization which has a little bit
1:16:59
more, I guess like online presence. In
1:17:01
this case, you have to understand
1:17:03
that like a lot. of orgs just
1:17:05
aren't operating in the liberated areas.
1:17:07
The two that I'm aware of, CPI
1:17:09
and FreeBurma ranges. I spoke
1:17:11
to Dave from FreeBurma ranges. They're
1:17:13
trying to get to as many people as
1:17:15
they can as well. That would be another great
1:17:17
place to donate. I would include a list
1:17:19
of vetted GoFundMe's. If you want to have a
1:17:21
look through those and see if any of
1:17:23
them speaks to you more, you can
1:17:25
do that too. What this will
1:17:27
mean for the future of Myanmar, We
1:17:31
don't know yet, right? We
1:17:33
have really no sense of how
1:17:35
many people have died of
1:17:37
what it's done to the hunters
1:17:39
ability to control those areas.
1:17:41
But until the revolution has a
1:17:43
way to stop planes bombing
1:17:45
people, we will continue to see
1:17:47
the same dynamic of the
1:17:49
hunter losing terrain on the ground,
1:17:51
pulling back its soldiers, and
1:17:53
then bombing civilians in the areas that it's
1:17:55
lost. That is its
1:17:57
game plan. It's continuing
1:18:00
to get more drones from
1:18:02
China, it's getting aircraft
1:18:04
munitions and jet fuel from
1:18:06
China. And until there
1:18:08
is an embargo on jet fuel
1:18:10
and munitions to the Hunter, then we
1:18:12
will see this same pattern continue,
1:18:14
right? They lose terrain, they
1:18:16
bomb a school, they lose terrain, they bomb a
1:18:18
hospital. Again, it's the same stuff
1:18:21
that Israel is doing. And they, of
1:18:23
course, previously been armed by Israel as well.
1:18:25
But we don't see as much solidarity
1:18:27
for the people of Burma. If
1:18:30
you want to stay in touch with what's
1:18:32
happening on the ground, I think the Irawari,
1:18:35
I -R -R -A -W -A -D -D -Y does a
1:18:37
really good job of doing daily
1:18:39
summaries right now. So I would suggest
1:18:41
checking out what's happening there. And
1:18:43
of course, we'll keep you updated on
1:18:46
developments in the spring revolution as they come. Looking
1:19:06
for excitement? Chumba Casino is here. Play
1:19:08
anytime, play anywhere. Play on the train, play
1:19:10
at the store, play at home, play
1:19:12
when you're bored. Play today for your chance
1:19:14
to win and get daily bonuses when
1:19:16
you log in. So what are you waiting
1:19:18
for? Don't delay. Chumba Casino is free
1:19:20
to play. Wasn't
1:19:37
that delicious? So good. Your
1:19:39
bill, ladies? I got it. No,
1:19:41
I got it. Seriously,
1:19:43
I insist. I insisted first. Oh,
1:19:46
don't be silly. You don't be
1:19:48
silly. People with the Wells Fargo
1:19:50
Active Cash Credit Card prefer to
1:19:52
pay because they earn unlimited 2
1:19:54
% cash back on purchases. OK.
1:19:56
Rock, paper, scissors for it. Rock,
1:19:58
paper, scissors, shoot! No! The
1:20:00
Wells Fargo Active Cash
1:20:02
Credit Card. Visit wellsfargo.com slash
1:20:04
activecash terms apply. Does
1:20:07
this podcast make you happy? Of
1:20:09
course it does. That's why you're
1:20:11
here. But it only comes out
1:20:13
once a week. For happiness every
1:20:15
night? You need Adam and Eve.
1:20:17
Yes, I'm talking about sex toys.
1:20:20
It's cool. It's cool. You have earbuds in, right? Adam
1:20:23
and Eve, America's most trusted source
1:20:25
for adult products, has been making people
1:20:27
very happy for over 50 years.
1:20:29
with thousands of toys for both men
1:20:32
and women. Just go to
1:20:34
adamaneve.com now and enter code iHeart
1:20:36
for 50 % off almost any
1:20:38
one item. Plus free discreet
1:20:40
shipping. That's adamaneve.com code iHeart for
1:20:42
50 % off. Every
1:20:45
morning brings a fresh new
1:20:47
energy. This is today. And
1:20:49
no matter what the day holds, we
1:20:51
come to the Today Show for all
1:20:53
of it. When things are tough, we
1:20:55
talk about it. When there's something to
1:20:57
figure out, we dig into it. And
1:20:59
when there's joy, we celebrate it. Because
1:21:01
today is where it's all happening. We
1:21:04
get the best start to every
1:21:06
morning because we started together. Watch
1:21:08
the Today Show with Savanica 3
1:21:10
and Craig Melvin weekdays at 7am
1:21:12
on NBC. This
1:21:17
is It Could Happen Here.
1:21:20
I am not going to El
1:21:22
Salvador. It's not going to
1:21:24
happen. No way. No thank you,
1:21:26
Mr. President. I'm
1:21:28
Garrison Davis. I'm joined by
1:21:31
James Stout. Hi Garrison. We're here
1:21:33
to talk about possibly the
1:21:35
most upsetting thing I've seen in
1:21:37
American politics in like the
1:21:39
past six months to maybe even,
1:21:42
I don't know, this really had hit
1:21:44
me for like the past few years.
1:21:46
Like, yeah, what happened on Monday in
1:21:48
the Oval Office was is kind of
1:21:50
the most black pill they've ever been,
1:21:52
which is not a great way to
1:21:54
start an episode. Yeah, like... It made
1:21:56
me feel like I found 2023 very
1:21:59
hard, like going out and seeing people
1:22:01
freezing in the desert and then coming
1:22:03
home and seeing Joe Biden the ice
1:22:05
cream on the timeline. But like this
1:22:07
was different. This was so like blatant.
1:22:09
There's like a level of like intentional
1:22:11
depravity that you're reminded of more blatantly. And
1:22:14
like Bukele's trolling
1:22:16
of everyone. So
1:22:19
we're gonna be talking about
1:22:21
an Oval Office meeting between President
1:22:23
Trump and El Salvador President
1:22:25
Bukele. I guess I could
1:22:27
learn his first name. Naib Bukele?
1:22:30
There you go. You know he's
1:22:32
Palestinian Salvadorian. Are you fucking serious?
1:22:34
No, his dad's an Imam. I
1:22:36
don't even have time for that. This
1:22:39
is just fucking... I'm
1:22:41
sorry if anyone's driving and
1:22:43
has had an accident
1:22:45
upon hearing that. So as
1:22:48
you probably know, Recently,
1:22:50
the United States government has
1:22:52
sent upwards of 300
1:22:54
people, immigrants, to
1:22:56
the El Salvador Terrorism
1:22:58
Confinement Center, this
1:23:00
prison black site that people
1:23:03
never return from. I
1:23:05
guess I could point to, for a
1:23:07
pop culture reference, which feels a little bit
1:23:09
in bad taste, but you
1:23:11
could point to like the prison in
1:23:13
the TV show Andor. as being a very
1:23:15
comfortable facility, frankly, except they turn off
1:23:17
the lights in Andorra. They do not turn
1:23:20
off the lights in Seacot. Lights run
1:23:22
all the time. They put 10
1:23:24
to 20 people per cell. It's
1:23:26
pretty bad. Jameson has done episodes
1:23:28
on Seacot in the past. We'll probably
1:23:30
keep doing more. The lights
1:23:32
thing, by the way, was
1:23:34
a specific policy change by Bukele.
1:23:36
There was a particularly violent
1:23:38
weekend in El Salvador. And
1:23:41
as a result, He stopped letting people
1:23:43
who were detained for gang crimes go outside
1:23:45
and stopped building windows into the prison
1:23:47
and just put the lights on. Like there's
1:23:49
a way of punishing, I guess, the
1:23:51
gangs by punishing the people who were detained
1:23:53
there. Yeah, they can't go outside. They
1:23:55
stay in their cell for almost 24 hours
1:23:57
a day. They might occasionally get 30
1:23:59
minutes outside, but that's not even confirmed because
1:24:01
no one's even allowed inside to see
1:24:04
what's going on in there. And
1:24:06
we've sent upwards of 300
1:24:08
immigrants there. The vast majority
1:24:10
of which have no criminal
1:24:13
record, even if you do
1:24:15
have a criminal record, being
1:24:17
renditioned to a foreign prison
1:24:19
camp is still bad. But
1:24:21
this is something that Trump
1:24:23
hopes to expand on greatly, and
1:24:26
they are currently defending their ability to
1:24:28
do so in the courts. Since it
1:24:30
has been learned that a few people
1:24:32
sent there may have been partially sent
1:24:34
by accident, but the Trump
1:24:36
administration is refusing to return these
1:24:38
people and is instead still trying
1:24:40
to convince the public that these
1:24:42
are dangerous terrorists that deserve to
1:24:44
be disappeared. So let's
1:24:46
kind of start with that
1:24:48
main case. The case
1:24:51
that's receiving the most public
1:24:53
attention right now is of
1:24:55
a Maryland man named Kilmer
1:24:57
Abrego Garcia, who's a subject of
1:24:59
a district court case that has been
1:25:01
sent up to the Supreme Court and
1:25:03
then sent back to the district court
1:25:05
on whether this man can be returned
1:25:07
home to his US citizen wife and
1:25:09
child. And then on
1:25:11
Monday, April 14th, in the Oval Office
1:25:13
meeting, President Bukele said
1:25:15
that he will not return this
1:25:17
Maryland immigrant with protected legal status
1:25:19
back to the United States, who
1:25:22
ICE admits was sent to CCOT
1:25:24
based on a quote, unquote, administrative
1:25:26
error. Bukele said, quote,
1:25:28
how can I smuggle a terrorist into the
1:25:30
United States? Of course I'm not going to
1:25:32
do it. The question is preposterous, unquote. The
1:25:35
El Salvador president also bulked at
1:25:37
the idea of releasing Garcia from
1:25:39
CCOT since he can't have a
1:25:41
quote -unquote terrorist free in his
1:25:43
country. Lying about Garcia
1:25:45
being a criminal. I
1:25:47
am gonna play a few clips in this
1:25:50
episode because I think it is necessary to
1:25:52
listen to these people actually say the words
1:25:54
that they are saying in the tone that
1:25:56
they're saying them and the exact phrasing on
1:25:58
these I think is actually pretty important right
1:26:00
now. So unfortunately you are gonna have to
1:26:02
hear the voices of a few people who
1:26:04
you might not rather hear from, including the
1:26:07
president of El Salvador. So I'll play this
1:26:09
first clip. Can
1:26:12
President Bukele weigh in on this? Do you
1:26:14
plan to return him? Well, I guess. I'm
1:26:16
supposed to have suggested that I smuggle terrorists
1:26:18
into the United States, right? How can I
1:26:20
smuggle? How can I return him to the
1:26:22
United States? It's like, could I smuggle him
1:26:25
into the United States? Or what do I
1:26:27
do? Of course, I'm not going to do
1:26:29
it. It's like, I mean,
1:26:31
the question is for busters. How can
1:26:33
I smuggle a terrorist into the United States?
1:26:35
I don't have the power to return
1:26:37
him to the United States. It's
1:27:05
just insane. like the whole pretense
1:27:07
of any serious engagement with reality there.
1:27:10
It's just gone. Yeah, and they're
1:27:12
both like miming that neither of them
1:27:14
have the ability to make any
1:27:16
kind of deal between each other, to
1:27:18
send people back, even though they
1:27:20
have the ability to make a deal
1:27:22
to send people there. Yeah, as
1:27:24
they sit in the same room. The
1:27:26
whole time Bacala is talking, Trump
1:27:28
has like this growing smirk on his
1:27:31
face. Yeah. But Kaley is talking
1:27:33
about this this preposterous notion of smuggling
1:27:35
a US immigrant back into the
1:27:37
United States Despite a Supreme Court order
1:27:39
to facilitate the return of this
1:27:41
immigrant back into the country The whole
1:27:43
smuggling framing is is obviously absurd
1:27:45
with him saying like I don't have
1:27:47
the power to return him to
1:27:49
the United States All he needs to
1:27:52
do is release him from Seacaw
1:27:54
and the US can fly him back
1:27:56
right just as we flew him
1:27:58
to El Salvador Like the two
1:28:00
heads of state are sitting right next
1:28:02
to each other. They could agree to
1:28:04
do this at any time. But now
1:28:06
everyone's pretending that suddenly they don't have
1:28:08
the power to undo what they seemingly
1:28:10
had the power to do in the
1:28:12
first place. Like Bukele has ruled and
1:28:14
we're going to do a whole episode
1:28:17
of Bukele and like his rise to
1:28:19
power and then his use of power.
1:28:21
But like he's ruled under a state
1:28:23
of exception for years in El Salvador,
1:28:25
which allows them to detain people without
1:28:27
warrants, without trials, right? And like It's
1:28:29
that state of exception that is now
1:28:31
the norm there. And that's kind of
1:28:33
what he seems to be referring to,
1:28:35
right? Like, we just
1:28:37
get to lock people up. Why
1:28:39
would I not do that? In effect,
1:28:41
they are arguing that every single
1:28:44
human being that is sent to sea
1:28:46
caught by the United States is
1:28:48
unable to ever leave the prison alive.
1:28:51
That's basically what they're saying. They're saying both
1:28:53
parties, both Trump and Bukele, are unable. to
1:28:55
have someone who's been sent there to
1:28:57
return. So they're just saying no one's able
1:28:59
to do anything. They're just stuck there
1:29:01
until they die. And this is part of
1:29:03
the design of Seacot. The
1:29:05
person who runs the Seacot security has
1:29:07
said that they do not intend
1:29:10
in any person ever being released from
1:29:12
Seacot. You are not designed to
1:29:14
get out. You are stuck there forever.
1:29:16
No one's ever left there. It's
1:29:19
just where you get disappeared. And
1:29:21
that's all that it is. And I
1:29:23
think part of why... They're so unwilling
1:29:25
to send Garcia back because then you
1:29:27
have someone like the first person who's
1:29:29
ever gotten out and can talk about
1:29:31
what it's actually like in there when
1:29:33
you don't have like Christina and propaganda
1:29:35
cameras pointed at at the prison bars.
1:29:37
Yeah. Bukele is very resistant
1:29:40
to release anyone for that reason. And
1:29:42
like there are plenty of allegations and
1:29:44
like I think time magazine has published
1:29:46
this. It's not usually controversial that he
1:29:48
made deals with gangs in the past
1:29:50
in El Salvador to get them to
1:29:52
reduce the murder rate. And like,
1:29:54
he certainly wouldn't like to hear
1:29:56
that testified to certainly not in the
1:29:59
United States Court, right? So like,
1:30:01
he doesn't want people to be released
1:30:03
from there either. Like you
1:30:05
say, they don't want anyone to be able
1:30:07
to go to any international human rights courts
1:30:09
and testify as to what happened to them
1:30:11
there. So it's kind of in his interest
1:30:13
to never have anyone be released. It's
1:30:15
not just also, I guess, like in
1:30:17
his interest, he's also being paid, right? $20
1:30:19
,000 per detainee per year by the United
1:30:21
States right now. So he also has
1:30:23
a financial interest in keeping people in there.
1:30:25
Even this per year deal makes, now
1:30:27
kind of makes zero sense because both of
1:30:29
them are arguing that there's no way
1:30:31
to send anyone back. Right. So like, it's
1:30:33
not that it's even like, oh, they're
1:30:35
only going to be there for one year.
1:30:37
It's like, they're just, they're
1:30:40
just there. And like, who
1:30:42
knows if they're going to like still
1:30:44
be alive. by the time that some
1:30:46
of these people would be able to
1:30:48
get out, whether that's through the miraculous
1:30:50
Donald Trump impeachment of 2026, which will
1:30:52
never happen. Or like, however, like these
1:30:54
people are they they are to stuck
1:30:56
there because he's not going to release
1:30:58
them into his country. We
1:31:00
are seemingly unable to take
1:31:02
anyone back from there. I
1:31:05
think unwilling, right? Like the
1:31:07
US is theoretically able. It's argued
1:31:09
that we're unable as as
1:31:11
as as people get into more
1:31:13
after this. bad break. Okay,
1:31:25
we are back. One
1:31:27
thing that we've seen across the
1:31:29
Trump administration the past 80 days
1:31:31
or so, something that we saw
1:31:33
very evident in this meeting, is
1:31:36
that whenever a single person is
1:31:38
asked a question about the outrageous,
1:31:40
possibly illegal possibly not but just
1:31:42
immoral or evil things that are
1:31:44
being done. The first instinct is
1:31:46
always to pass the bell count to someone else.
1:31:48
We saw this a lot with SignalGate, how it
1:31:50
was always someone else's faults. No
1:31:53
single person could get hammered down of being like,
1:31:55
okay, you are the person that's gonna be accountable
1:31:57
for this. And throughout this Oval
1:31:59
Office meeting, eventually they started taking questions
1:32:01
from journalists and reporters and propagandists who
1:32:03
were in the room. And you saw
1:32:05
this trend of... if someone asks Trump
1:32:07
about what's going on, he passes the
1:32:09
buck to Stephen Miller, who passes the
1:32:12
buck to Bukele, who then passes the
1:32:14
buck to Mark Rubio. And it's
1:32:16
like this big circle of like, everyone's just
1:32:18
talking around each other because no one really has
1:32:20
the authority to speak on what's going on
1:32:22
or how to fix this problem because they don't
1:32:24
see it as a problem. So instead, they
1:32:26
just talk in a circle. And I
1:32:28
think Miller was one of the most
1:32:30
effective at this. And unfortunately, we're going to
1:32:32
play the longest clip in
1:32:34
this episode, just under two minutes
1:32:36
from Stephen Miller, where he lays out
1:32:39
the Trump admin thought process and
1:32:41
strategy behind what they are doing. And
1:32:43
I apologize for this, but
1:32:45
it is useful to hear
1:32:47
from Himmler too. So
1:32:50
here we go. With
1:32:52
respect to you, he's a
1:32:54
citizen of El Salvador. So...
1:32:56
very arrogant even for American media to
1:32:58
suggest that we would even tell El
1:33:00
Salvador how to handle their own citizens
1:33:02
as a starting point. As two immigration
1:33:04
courts found that he was a member
1:33:06
of MS -13, when President
1:33:09
Trump declared MS -13 to be a
1:33:11
foreign terrorist organization, that
1:33:13
meant that he was no longer eligible under federal
1:33:15
law, which I'm sure you know, you're very
1:33:17
familiar with the INA, that he was
1:33:19
no longer eligible for any form of immigration
1:33:21
relief in the United States. So he
1:33:23
had a deportation order that
1:33:25
was valid which meant that under our
1:33:27
law he's not even allowed to be
1:33:30
present in the United States and had
1:33:32
to be returned because of the foreign
1:33:34
terrorist designation. This issue was
1:33:36
then by a district court judge
1:33:38
completely inverted and a district court
1:33:40
judge tried to tell the administration
1:33:42
that they had to kidnap a
1:33:45
citizen of El Salvador and fly
1:33:47
back here. That issue was raised
1:33:49
to the Supreme Court and the
1:33:51
Supreme Court said the district court
1:33:53
order was unlawful and its main
1:33:55
components were reversed 90 unanimously, stating
1:33:58
clearly that neither Secretary of State
1:34:00
nor the President could be compelled
1:34:02
by anybody to forcibly retrieve a
1:34:04
citizen of El Salvador from El
1:34:06
Salvador, who again is a member
1:34:08
of MS -13, which as
1:34:10
I'm sure you understand, rapes little girls, murders
1:34:13
women, murders children, is engaged in the most
1:34:15
barbaric activities in the world, and I can
1:34:17
promise you, if he was your neighbor, you
1:34:19
would move right away. And
1:34:23
what was the ruling in the Supreme
1:34:25
Court, Steve? Was it 9 -0? Yes, it
1:34:27
was a 9 -0. In our
1:34:29
favor. In our favor against the District
1:34:31
Court ruling, saying that no district court has
1:34:33
the power to compel the foreign policy
1:34:35
function of the United States. As Pam said,
1:34:38
the ruling solely stated that if this
1:34:40
individual at El Salvador's sole discretion
1:34:42
was sent back to our country, that
1:34:44
we could deport him a second
1:34:46
time. So
1:35:00
there's a lot there. Yeah, I
1:35:02
think I'm gonna start with I can
1:35:04
promise you if he was your
1:35:06
neighbor you would move right away and
1:35:08
I think that is really the
1:35:10
heart of what this Trump administration is
1:35:12
is doing like it's appealing to
1:35:15
this most basic like suburban crime panic
1:35:17
fear racism of well if he
1:35:19
was your neighbor you wouldn't want him
1:35:21
living next to you. Yeah like
1:35:23
if that goes to neighborhood kind of.
1:35:25
Well, just completely lying about like
1:35:27
the the context of this case yeah
1:35:29
with you know Miller saying it's
1:35:31
arrogant suggest that we the most powerful
1:35:34
country in the world are used
1:35:36
to be before the tariffs can tell
1:35:38
El Salvador how to handle its
1:35:40
citizens Falsely claiming that immigration courts deemed
1:35:42
him a member of MS -13, which
1:35:44
just just is not true Yeah
1:35:46
talking about kidnapping him from Seacot to
1:35:48
return him to the United States
1:35:51
as if ice didn't just kidnap hundreds
1:35:53
of people with no criminal records
1:35:55
and send them to a foreign gulag
1:35:57
And then also lied about the
1:35:59
Supreme Court ruling saying they found
1:36:01
the District Court order to return
1:36:03
Garcia unlawful and grossly mischaracterizing the
1:36:05
scope of what the Supreme Court
1:36:07
ruling was and how it was
1:36:09
sent back to the District Court
1:36:11
to work on the details on
1:36:14
what facilitate the return actually means. And
1:36:16
again, I think like the one of
1:36:18
the most telling parts is how he
1:36:20
ends by saying, quote, no version of
1:36:22
this ever ends up with him living
1:36:25
here. And yeah, they're gonna
1:36:27
look for any way to make this
1:36:29
test cased work, right? And if they
1:36:31
can do this to someone with protected
1:36:33
legal status who is not a terrorist,
1:36:35
who is not an actual MS -13 gang
1:36:37
member, right? This is kind of ideal
1:36:40
for them, because that means they can
1:36:42
paint anybody as a foreign policy threat
1:36:44
enough to be sent to a foreign
1:36:46
gulag. Then at the very end of
1:36:48
the clip, he passes the buck off
1:36:50
to Bukele. to have
1:36:52
him answer this question, again, perfectly
1:36:55
laying out their strategy. There's
1:36:57
a lot to break down in what
1:36:59
minister. It's also just kind of interesting how
1:37:01
Miller is like amongst the press. He's
1:37:03
not one of the people like sat on
1:37:05
the couches supposed to be giving the
1:37:07
press conference, right? He just kind of wades
1:37:09
in to, I guess, like, like offer
1:37:11
this opinion and kind of like be the
1:37:14
kind of embassy of this, of their
1:37:16
response, I guess, in a sense. I think,
1:37:18
crucially, like, Abrago Garcia's protection was from
1:37:21
being returned to El Salvador, right?
1:37:23
Because he had been harassed by gang
1:37:25
members when leaving El Salvador and
1:37:27
when living in El Salvador. He's lived
1:37:29
in the States since 2011, and
1:37:31
he left El Salvador to flee harassment
1:37:33
and abuse from gang members. Yeah,
1:37:35
the gangs that he's been accused of
1:37:38
being a part of. But like, it
1:37:40
then follows that like it would be
1:37:42
legal for them to deport him to
1:37:45
a third country, right? And that is
1:37:47
the path that they followed with all
1:37:49
the Venezuelan migrants, right? They've accused them
1:37:51
of being members of Trenderagua. I have
1:37:53
not seen a compelling case made that
1:37:55
any of them are yet. I'm
1:37:58
sure people from Trenderagua have come to this country,
1:38:00
but no, they have not provided any evidence that
1:38:02
the people they have sent to say, God, are
1:38:04
those people? No, like we said, like 14 people
1:38:06
are like accused of some kind of like violent
1:38:08
crime, like murder or rape. And
1:38:10
the other like 275 do not
1:38:12
have a criminal record whatsoever. Yeah,
1:38:14
and the bulk of this is reliant
1:38:16
on some kind of idea that they have
1:38:19
entirely created from fiction, that there are
1:38:21
tattooing practices when one enters Trenderagua. And
1:38:23
for them, right, even if they can't be
1:38:25
returned to Venezuela, they feel that they have
1:38:27
this end realm, which is, okay, we'll send
1:38:29
them to El Salvador, but for the Salvadorans,
1:38:31
that's a different question, right? And
1:38:33
that is what they're trying to find
1:38:35
here. And that is worrying because the
1:38:38
case here that it's getting the most
1:38:40
publicity that seems to be the one
1:38:42
that the Supreme Court has taken up.
1:38:44
It's about the Salvadoran man. And I
1:38:46
hope that doesn't mean that like the
1:38:48
ship has sailed for the Venezuelans, right?
1:38:50
That essentially, like they don't have a
1:38:52
case because that was the vast bulk
1:38:55
of them. I think there was only
1:38:57
like 60 Salvadoran citizens and the rest
1:38:59
Venezuelans. No, hundreds of people have been
1:39:01
like forgotten in this. After
1:39:04
Miller's rant there, Mark Rubio jumped
1:39:06
in. to state that, quote, no court
1:39:08
in the United States has the
1:39:10
right to conduct the foreign policy of
1:39:12
the United States, unquote. And
1:39:14
Stephen Miller hopped back in to talk
1:39:16
about this Supreme Court case that they're
1:39:18
falsely saying they won nine to zero,
1:39:20
which is not how that case went.
1:39:23
And they start talking more broadly about what
1:39:25
can be allowed if it has to do
1:39:27
with the foreign policy of the United States
1:39:29
and how the courts don't have the ability
1:39:31
to intervene in that process. No,
1:39:34
the foreign policy of the United States is conducted
1:39:36
by the President of the United States, not by
1:39:38
a court. And no court in the
1:39:40
United States has a right to conduct the foreign
1:39:42
policy of the United States. It's that simple. Part
1:40:03
of what I find so
1:40:05
disturbing about this idea of, you
1:40:07
know, no habeas corpus, no
1:40:09
due process. if you aren't
1:40:11
on foreign soil, is that this
1:40:13
idea of the courts having no
1:40:16
jurisdiction over foreign policy decisions means
1:40:18
that as long as you, whether
1:40:20
you're a citizen, whether you're a
1:40:22
permanent resident, documented or undocumented immigrant,
1:40:24
as long as you are forcibly
1:40:26
removed from the United States soil,
1:40:29
your rights and your due process
1:40:31
has been forfeit and the US
1:40:33
has neither the obligation nor sometimes
1:40:35
the ability to return you to
1:40:37
US soil if that is their
1:40:39
foreign policy interest. And this is
1:40:42
such a troubling broad concept that
1:40:44
the portions of the courts are
1:40:46
kind of allowing them to claim
1:40:48
right now. And the complete removal
1:40:50
of due process is like slowly
1:40:52
getting encroached upon at first with
1:40:55
undocumented immigrants and green card holders.
1:40:57
But as we will see in
1:40:59
the next section, they
1:41:01
are also absolutely going to be
1:41:03
targeting US citizens. Yeah, I think
1:41:05
we should just point out, obviously, the
1:41:07
court is not conducting the foreign policy
1:41:09
of the United States. It's ruling on
1:41:11
the legality of the action taken by
1:41:13
the president, which is exactly what it's
1:41:15
supposed to do. Yeah, and as it
1:41:17
relates to your rights for due process,
1:41:19
if you are in the United States.
1:41:21
Yeah, like every single US person, right,
1:41:23
US person, would be anybody
1:41:25
who resides in the US be they
1:41:27
documented or done documented migrant citizen will
1:41:29
have you like has a stake in
1:41:32
this. We're going to go
1:41:34
on break and then come back
1:41:36
to discuss the expansion of the
1:41:38
CCOT detention program and the possible
1:41:40
targeting of US citizens. Okay,
1:41:52
we're back. So on
1:41:54
April 7th a few weeks ago
1:41:56
while on Air Force One President
1:41:58
Trump told reporters that he would
1:42:01
be quote -unquote honored for the president
1:42:03
of El Salvador to take a
1:42:05
US citizens quote -unquote American grown
1:42:07
and born criminals and Put them
1:42:09
in C cot the terrorism confinement
1:42:11
Center prison black site saying quote
1:42:13
Why should it stop just at
1:42:15
people that cross the border illegally
1:42:17
unquote? A few days later, the
1:42:19
White House Presbyterian reiterated that this is
1:42:21
something that Trump is discussing both publicly and
1:42:23
privately. And later, during
1:42:25
the April 14th Oval Office meeting,
1:42:28
Trump said that if Salvador was
1:42:30
to build more of these
1:42:32
torture mega -presidents, the United States
1:42:35
would quote -unquote help them out
1:42:37
if the Trump administration could disappear
1:42:39
more American immigrants and U .S.
1:42:41
citizens. to these prison black
1:42:43
sites. I'd
1:42:47
do something. We'd help them out. They're
1:42:50
great facilities, very
1:42:52
strong facilities, and they
1:42:54
don't play games. I'd
1:42:57
like to go a step further. I
1:42:59
said it to Pam. I don't know what
1:43:01
the laws are. We always have to
1:43:03
obey the laws, but we also have homegrown
1:43:05
criminals that push people into subways. Hit
1:43:09
elderly ladies on the back
1:43:11
of the head with a
1:43:13
baseball bat when they're not
1:43:15
looking that are Absolute monsters.
1:43:17
I'd like to include them in the group of
1:43:19
people to get them out of the country But
1:43:21
you'll have to be looking at the laws on
1:43:23
that state, okay? So
1:43:27
this is just the start
1:43:29
of a long process that is
1:43:31
going to be deeply Troublesome
1:43:34
and worrying and again like this
1:43:36
is something that they keep
1:43:38
talking about. I think they're
1:43:40
still looking for some kind of legal
1:43:42
justification or they're looking for something
1:43:44
that maybe, if not allows for this,
1:43:46
explicitly prohibits this in a way
1:43:48
that they can't get around. Yeah,
1:43:50
did you notice he called out Miller, he
1:43:52
said you'll have to look at the laws
1:43:54
and let's see if obviously Miller is not
1:43:56
the attorney general. He also did mention attorney
1:43:58
general Pam Bondi, who's also
1:44:00
looking into this option right now.
1:44:02
Right, but Miller is often credited
1:44:04
with being the kind of mastermind
1:44:07
behind Title 42, which was an
1:44:09
extremely obscure piece of public health
1:44:11
law that was immobilized by the
1:44:13
first Trump administration to immediately return
1:44:15
migrants to Mexico without giving them
1:44:17
their right to an asylum hearing.
1:44:20
And that's what I'm wondering if they're
1:44:22
going for again. Steve Miller has
1:44:24
been very good at this, at finding
1:44:26
obscure justifications in the United States
1:44:28
federal law. for shit that they want
1:44:30
to do. I think this is
1:44:32
why they're definitely trying to stretch this
1:44:34
foreign policy claim as far as
1:44:36
they can. That if it's if it's
1:44:38
outside US soil, there's a limited
1:44:41
way US courts can actually interfere or
1:44:43
undo things that have already been
1:44:45
done. And again, like the
1:44:47
idea that we're going to like
1:44:49
fund the construction of even more
1:44:51
of these El Salvador mega prisons
1:44:53
just to house American grown and
1:44:55
born criminals as well as immigrants.
1:44:57
like you we're just funding like
1:44:59
gulag camps on foreign soil to
1:45:02
send the undesirables to and no
1:45:04
matter how much Trump talks about
1:45:06
how we're old legalists and quote
1:45:08
-unquote like American criminals there uh
1:45:10
as we've seen with with secot
1:45:12
so far like no like they
1:45:14
the majority of people they are
1:45:16
sending do not have criminal criminal
1:45:18
histories i don't think anyone can
1:45:20
trust the Trump administration's definition of
1:45:23
what is and isn't a criminal
1:45:25
to this extent anymore. Later
1:45:27
in the same meeting, Trump
1:45:29
reiterated the same idea about sending
1:45:31
US citizens who his administration
1:45:33
deems criminals to this foreign black
1:45:35
site. Here's another clip. Just
1:45:38
a follow -up question on clarification. You
1:45:41
mentioned that you're open to deporting
1:45:43
individuals that aren't foreign aliens but
1:45:45
are criminals to El Salvador. Does
1:45:47
that include potentially U .S. citizens
1:45:49
fully naturalized in America? If
1:45:52
they're criminals and if they
1:45:54
hit people with baseball backs over
1:45:56
their head that happen to
1:45:58
be 90 years old and if
1:46:00
they rape 87 -year -old women
1:46:02
in Coney Island, Brooklyn, Yeah,
1:46:05
yeah, that includes them. Why do you
1:46:07
think there's special category of person there
1:46:09
as bad as anybody that comes in?
1:46:11
We have bad ones, too. And
1:46:13
I'm all for it. We
1:46:15
have others negotiating with you. But
1:46:18
no, if it's if it's if
1:46:20
it's a homegrown criminal, I have no
1:46:22
problem. He's really obsessed with the
1:46:24
baseball bats thing. I don't quite know
1:46:26
what that's about. It seems like
1:46:28
a specific case that he's referring to.
1:46:30
Maybe it's something he remembers like
1:46:32
30 years ago, like it really got
1:46:35
stuck in his head. Right. But
1:46:37
also later, he says that they're negotiating
1:46:39
with other countries to send US
1:46:41
citizens to, not just El Salvador. Yeah.
1:46:45
I mean, they've sent migrants, third
1:46:47
country migrants to Panama before,
1:46:49
right? And detained them there.
1:46:51
Honduras, I believe, is building like
1:46:53
a prison that's not dissimilar to Secort.
1:46:55
Like... be guessing this
1:46:57
will be their sort of way
1:47:00
of courting allies in the hemisphere.
1:47:02
Like they'll sort of pay them
1:47:04
a relatively large amount in order
1:47:06
to attempt to offshore people they
1:47:08
don't like. Yeah. And again, like
1:47:10
as we've seen the past few
1:47:12
years and increasingly so now the
1:47:14
the efforts to label like activists
1:47:16
or people who are vocally opposed
1:47:18
to the United States, foreign policy,
1:47:20
the United States and the state
1:47:23
of Israel, deeming them terrorists. And
1:47:25
then by extension, if you charge them
1:47:27
with a crime, then criminals, the
1:47:29
idea that they can be housed
1:47:31
in a place like Seacot now,
1:47:33
with very, very limited to no
1:47:36
due process, the whole due process
1:47:38
question is still very up in
1:47:40
the air for how they're going
1:47:42
to handle that aspect. But you
1:47:44
can't just take this as like,
1:47:46
oh, you know, that that's just
1:47:48
Trump talking like, no, this is
1:47:50
something they really want to do.
1:47:52
And it's like one of the
1:47:54
freakiest things that I've seen in
1:47:56
like domestic U .S. politics in
1:47:58
a long time. Earlier, Trump was
1:48:00
recorded half whispering to Bukele, telling
1:48:02
him that El Salvador needs to
1:48:04
build five more sea -caught -style torture
1:48:06
prisons to house U .S. citizens, as
1:48:08
Trump says, homegrown criminals. Bukele
1:48:10
replies that they will have
1:48:12
enough room, and then the entire
1:48:15
Oval Office laughs. It's
1:48:30
the bleakest clip I've ever
1:48:32
seen before. Yeah. Talking about
1:48:34
how home groans are next. Got to build
1:48:36
five more places. Oh, we have enough
1:48:38
space. Everyone laughs. And then Trump shows off
1:48:40
the new gold frames for the portraits
1:48:42
in the Oval Office. Yeah. It's
1:48:44
like a dinner party joke
1:48:46
for them. It might just be
1:48:48
worth noting that like every
1:48:50
totalitarian regime has housed its dissidents
1:48:53
outside of the imperial core,
1:48:55
right? Like Germany did this in
1:48:57
the east, right? Russia sent
1:48:59
people to Siberia for Russia, Soviet
1:49:01
Union. Creating these like stateless
1:49:03
zones where like the regular laws
1:49:05
of your like fatherland state
1:49:07
do not apply. Right. And
1:49:09
where the horrors are so far
1:49:11
from the populace that the populace
1:49:13
can't really grasp them. Yeah. No,
1:49:15
this is like elementary school stuff.
1:49:18
It says like, like the first thing you learn about
1:49:20
is concentration camps and gulags and how that's like
1:49:22
this symbol of evil. And now
1:49:24
it's something you laugh about
1:49:26
in the Oval Office to
1:49:29
send home groans to five
1:49:31
disappearing torture camps. Yeah. And
1:49:33
like, just to be like
1:49:35
even clearer, guess what distinguishes a concentration camp
1:49:37
from a prison is that There is no
1:49:39
due process, right? People are sent there because
1:49:41
of who they are, not because of what
1:49:43
they did. Like if you're a Venezuelan man,
1:49:45
who may or may not have a tattoo. Yeah,
1:49:48
like we are, I
1:49:50
don't know what it will take for
1:49:53
some people to realize what's happening here.
1:49:55
And like the president of El Salvador
1:49:57
is so on board for this. Yeah,
1:49:59
I mean, he doesn't hide from that
1:50:01
reputation, right? He embraces it. His Twitter
1:50:03
for a while had world's coolest dictator
1:50:05
in the bio. I don't know if
1:50:07
it still does. And like both him
1:50:09
and Trump have openly align themselves with
1:50:11
quote -unquote nationalism and nationalists. They're openly
1:50:14
saying this. Trump said, dictator on day
1:50:16
one, that wasn't just a rhetorical device,
1:50:18
that was literal. This is what he's
1:50:20
doing. The El Salvador president told
1:50:22
Trump, you have 350 million people
1:50:24
to liberate, but to liberate 350 million
1:50:26
people, you have to imprison some. And
1:50:29
he followed that up by saying that he is
1:50:31
eager to help with that. In
1:50:33
fact, Mr. President, you
1:50:36
have 350 million people to
1:50:38
liberate you. But
1:50:40
to liberate 350 million people, you have
1:50:42
to imprison some. That's the
1:50:44
way it works, right? You cannot just free
1:50:46
the criminals and think that crime is
1:50:48
going to go down magically. You have to
1:50:50
imprison them so you can liberate 350
1:50:52
million Americans that are asking for the end
1:50:54
of crime and the end of terrorists.
1:50:57
Many can be done. I mean, you're doing
1:50:59
it already. So
1:51:01
I'm really happy to be here
1:51:03
honored and eager to help. This
1:51:05
whole liberation through imprisonment thing is elementary
1:51:08
school stuff here. You don't have to
1:51:10
have a PhD in the history of
1:51:12
the 1930s to have someone tell you
1:51:14
that liberation of the chosen nation by
1:51:16
purging of the undesirables is fascist shit.
1:51:18
But I'm here with one to tell
1:51:20
you if that's what you need. This
1:51:24
is textbook stuff like Garrison's
1:51:26
saying, this is not debatable. I
1:51:29
know we spent the last four years
1:51:31
debating is Trump a fascist or not.
1:51:33
I don't think that matters hugely. This
1:51:35
is a fascist thing. It's so much
1:51:37
more disturbing that now, according to polls,
1:51:40
around half the population, maybe a
1:51:42
little bit less, just agree with
1:51:44
the current way that deportations are
1:51:46
happening and Trump's immigration policy on
1:51:48
a completely flat basis. And if
1:51:50
you spend any time on X,
1:51:52
the Everything app, watching videos of
1:51:54
these press conferences, it's full of
1:51:56
people just like, cheering this on
1:51:58
completely, like completely blankly. I think
1:52:00
that's a very skewed sample of
1:52:02
people who paid for Elon Musk's
1:52:04
payout. Of course, of course. But
1:52:06
like the number of people. Yeah,
1:52:09
it's real humans. Like these are real
1:52:11
people who just just completely, completely blankly
1:52:13
think this is a this is this
1:52:15
is a net good and like this
1:52:17
is this people are unreachable. You cannot
1:52:19
come back from that. Like you is
1:52:21
there is no coming back from that
1:52:23
if you believe that the way deportations
1:52:25
are currently happening is fair, just and
1:52:28
right. Like, I cannot understand you as
1:52:30
a human anymore. That is so, like,
1:52:32
divorced and, like, alien. Yeah, you've
1:52:34
gone past the point of no return, right? Like...
1:52:36
Liberals who, like, shield their eyes from,
1:52:38
like, the horrors at the border. Like, I
1:52:40
don't agree with that, but in some
1:52:42
ways, I can, like, understand it. The open,
1:52:44
like, cheering on of this is, like,
1:52:46
a whole other level. Yeah, it's not like
1:52:48
I can't bear to see it. I'm
1:52:50
gonna ignore it because it'll cause me to
1:52:52
confront the contradictions. It's... I'm seeing it,
1:52:54
I'm watching it, and I think it's fucking
1:52:56
great. The last thing I'm gonna play
1:52:58
here, a CNN reporter asked
1:53:00
Trump if he would obey a
1:53:03
Supreme Court order to return someone
1:53:05
to the United States. Instead of
1:53:07
answering this question, Trump attacked the
1:53:09
reporter and complained about how she
1:53:11
wasn't praising him for deporting criminals. Yeah,
1:53:37
mad. Very
1:53:39
textbook authoritarian like blanket stuff like
1:53:41
there's nothing to like commentate about
1:53:43
that. It just is what it
1:53:46
is I guess we do have
1:53:48
some breaking news because we're recording
1:53:50
this on Tuesday James want to
1:53:52
do want to in possibly five
1:53:54
minutes or less Fill us in
1:53:56
about the the update from it
1:53:58
from the district court on Garcia's
1:54:00
since it was sent back to
1:54:02
the district court from the Supreme
1:54:04
Court last week regarding his possible
1:54:06
facilitated return to the United States
1:54:08
Right. So much of this has
1:54:10
hinged over what facilitate means, right?
1:54:12
Like they found a legal concept
1:54:14
that they can argue ad nauseam.
1:54:16
And in this case, it's the
1:54:18
word facilitate. DOJ didn't
1:54:20
present any new information
1:54:22
today, but we see that like
1:54:24
there's some hopeful things from a district
1:54:26
court judge, and then it kind of all
1:54:28
goes up in flames. But I think
1:54:31
genus is XI and I. S is how
1:54:33
the name is spelled. I
1:54:35
believe it's genus. I said that every day
1:54:37
that he's there, it's a day of
1:54:39
further irreparable harm. She talks
1:54:41
about the process being at the roots of
1:54:43
the Constitution. She's ordered for
1:54:45
two weeks more of discovery, which
1:54:48
is going to mean that both sides have
1:54:50
more time to repair their cases. She wants people
1:54:52
to testify in front of the court. So
1:54:54
the administration has argued that
1:54:57
facilitating his return would consist of
1:54:59
them allowing him to enter
1:55:01
the United States if Bukele released
1:55:03
him, and possibly providing a
1:55:05
flight for that to happen, but
1:55:07
not crucially ensuring his release
1:55:09
from Secord, right? And so
1:55:12
anything else subsequent to that doesn't matter. Ginny
1:55:14
said that their interpretation of the
1:55:16
word flies in the face of the
1:55:18
plain meaning of the word, quote,
1:55:21
when a wrongfully removed individual is And
1:55:23
then I'm adding to the quote here, I
1:55:25
guess, or context. She means when
1:55:27
a wrongfully removed individual is taken outside the
1:55:29
US, it's not so cut and dried that
1:55:31
all you have to do is remove obstacles
1:55:33
domestically. She also said, quote, to
1:55:35
the Department of Justice here, you made your
1:55:37
jurisdiction or arguments, you made your venue arguments,
1:55:39
you made your arguments on the merits, you
1:55:41
lost. This is now about
1:55:43
the scope of the remedy, right? This
1:55:46
is the case that Miller is claiming
1:55:48
they won. That's pretty unequivocal for a
1:55:50
justice. However, She does
1:55:52
not seem to think that it
1:55:54
is within her power to
1:55:56
request his return from El Salvador.
1:55:59
She's calling for things to move
1:56:01
quickly. They want to
1:56:03
conduct depositions by the 23rd of April.
1:56:06
She said, quote, cancel vacations, cancel other appointments. I'm
1:56:08
usually pretty good about it, not this time.
1:56:10
I'm going to be available if you need to
1:56:12
do it odd hours or weekends. That's what
1:56:14
I'm talking about. Anything
1:56:18
short of a judge saying you have
1:56:20
to go to secote remove him from the
1:56:23
cell put him on the plane and
1:56:25
bring him back to America It's going to
1:56:27
be interpreted by the Trump administration to
1:56:29
mean that they don't have to do that
1:56:31
Yeah, they're gonna weasel their way around
1:56:33
it the same way you heard Stephen Miller
1:56:35
weasel his way around every question and
1:56:37
with truth being used as a flexible medium
1:56:39
to shape a sculpture of their choosing.
1:56:41
And they've done that right. The word facilitate,
1:56:43
I think most people who are first
1:56:45
language English speakers have a fairly good grasp
1:56:47
of what that means, and it doesn't
1:56:49
mean like remove barriers domestically. That's
1:56:51
what they've gone for. The
1:56:53
only way that he is getting
1:56:55
out is a majority Supreme Court
1:56:57
decision that is extremely explicit, that
1:56:59
directs. the Trump administration to go
1:57:01
to El Salvador and remove him
1:57:04
from that prison. I haven't
1:57:06
seen anything to indicate that
1:57:08
we're getting that anytime soon. And
1:57:10
as the judge said, every day he's there.
1:57:12
He's a reputable harm is done to him.
1:57:15
And that's where we're at right
1:57:17
now, right? With people arguing over
1:57:19
the definition of a word, as
1:57:21
hundreds of people are locked up
1:57:23
having done nothing wrong in a
1:57:26
giant torture prison. And this is
1:57:28
not the only person who We
1:57:30
believe it was was quote -unquote mistakenly
1:57:32
sent others reporting today coming out
1:57:34
of documented New York Yeah, good
1:57:36
outlet by the way a father
1:57:38
of a 19 year old legal
1:57:40
legal immigrant from Brooklyn this 19
1:57:42
year old with with no no
1:57:44
tattoos Was kidnapped off the streets
1:57:46
of New York the quote from
1:57:48
his father reads quote the officers
1:57:51
grabbed him and two other boys
1:57:53
right at the entrance to our
1:57:55
building one said no He's not
1:57:57
the one like they were looking
1:57:59
for someone else. One officer to
1:58:01
be clear. Correct. Yeah. But
1:58:03
the other officer said,
1:58:05
take him anyway, unquote.
1:58:08
And now this father exactly
1:58:10
a month later is still
1:58:12
looking for his missing son
1:58:14
who is disappeared into an
1:58:16
El Salvador torture prison. Yeah,
1:58:18
Jesus. Like I've said before
1:58:21
on this show, like one of the
1:58:23
things that I learned and the daring
1:58:25
gap was how much people can care
1:58:27
about their kids and like this shit
1:58:29
that I saw people do to ensure
1:58:31
their kids have a better life like
1:58:33
broke my heart in a way that
1:58:36
war hasn't they're like anything else I've
1:58:38
seen in my life hasn't and it's
1:58:40
like honestly really hard for me to
1:58:42
hear stuff like that and and like
1:58:44
not react just being really sad or
1:58:46
really angry like it's fucking brutal. Things
1:58:49
are looking a lot more grim in my
1:58:51
mind than they were when we recorded that.
1:58:53
Should you leave the United States episode? I
1:58:56
still think the things I
1:58:58
said there, I stand by and
1:59:00
I stand by the only
1:59:02
recommendation I have is to create
1:59:04
options for yourself. And I
1:59:06
think those options should be created
1:59:08
as soon as possible, especially
1:59:10
if your citizenship is a topic
1:59:12
of debate according to the
1:59:14
United States government. But even
1:59:17
that will not keep you safe
1:59:19
as we've talked about today. Your options
1:59:21
include creating networks to take care
1:59:23
of one another. The
1:59:25
things that will probably affect
1:59:27
more of you than
1:59:29
direct state violence, our economic
1:59:31
downturns, our recessions, things
1:59:34
like this, those are things that you
1:59:36
can take care of one another through. You
1:59:39
should plan to do that too. You
1:59:41
should think about... are you going to pay your bills?
1:59:43
How are you going to feed each other? How are you
1:59:45
going to take care of your medical needs? Because
1:59:48
I don't think that the world
1:59:50
is going to want to keep
1:59:52
doing business with a country that
1:59:54
acts like this. Both
1:59:56
economically and in terms of its
1:59:59
conduct towards migrants. So your
2:00:01
plans don't have to be to
2:00:03
leave. Your plans should
2:00:05
also include what to do if
2:00:07
things get really bad in an
2:00:09
economic sense. I'm not going to
2:00:11
tell you what that means, but...
2:00:13
It's all the stuff we've already
2:00:15
talked about, right? It's mutual aid.
2:00:17
It's all the basic preparedness stuff
2:00:19
that is not as big and
2:00:21
scary as leaving the country, but
2:00:23
is nonetheless vital. We
2:00:26
will continue to report on the
2:00:28
Garcia case, other court cases
2:00:31
regarding these 300 people
2:00:33
renditioned to El Salvador and
2:00:35
CCOT in the next
2:00:37
few weeks. Yeah. Just
2:00:39
to finish up. As things
2:00:41
continue to get worse, people keep
2:00:43
reaching out to us, which
2:00:45
we appreciate. If you would like
2:00:48
to, you can email us
2:00:50
coolzontipsatproton .me. We will read it.
2:00:52
We might not get back to you. Your
2:00:54
email is not end to end encrypted unless the
2:00:56
email that you're sending from is also encrypted. But
2:00:59
you can reach out to us there. See you
2:01:01
on the other side. Wasn't
2:01:19
that delicious? So good. Your
2:01:21
bill, ladies? I got it. No,
2:01:23
I got it. Seriously,
2:01:25
I insist. I insisted first. Don't
2:01:27
be silly. You don't be silly.
2:01:29
People with the Wells Fargo Active
2:01:31
Cash Credit Card prefer to pay
2:01:33
because they earn unlimited 2 %
2:01:36
cash back on purchases. OK. Rock,
2:01:38
paper, scissors for it. Rock, paper,
2:01:40
scissors. Shoot. No! The
2:01:42
Wells Fargo Active Cash Credit
2:01:44
Card. Visit wellsfargo.com slash activecash.
2:01:46
Terms apply. Does
2:01:48
this podcast make you happy? Of
2:01:51
course it does. That's why you're
2:01:53
here. But it only comes out once
2:01:55
a week. For happiness every night? You
2:01:57
need Adam and Eve. Yes,
2:01:59
I'm talking about sex toys. It's
2:02:02
cool. It's cool. You have earbuds in, right?
2:02:05
Adam and Eve, America's most trusted source
2:02:07
for adult products, has been making
2:02:09
people very happy for over 50 years,
2:02:11
with thousands of toys for both
2:02:13
men and women. Just go
2:02:15
to adamandve.com now and enter code
2:02:17
iHeart for 50 % off almost
2:02:19
any one item, plus free,
2:02:21
discreet shipping. That's adamandve.com code iHeart
2:02:24
for 50 % off. Every
2:02:26
morning brings a fresh new
2:02:28
energy. This is today. And
2:02:31
no matter what the day holds we
2:02:33
come to the today show for all
2:02:35
of it. When things are tough, we
2:02:37
talk about it. When there's something to
2:02:39
figure out, we dig into it. And
2:02:41
when there's joy, we celebrate it. Because
2:02:43
today is where it's all happening. We
2:02:45
get the best start to every
2:02:48
morning because we started together. Watch
2:02:50
the Today Show with Savannah Guthrie
2:02:52
and Craig Melvin weekdays at 7am
2:02:54
on NBC. Get this,
2:02:56
adults with financial literacy skills have
2:02:58
82 % more wealth than those who
2:03:00
don't. From swimming lessons to piano classes,
2:03:02
us parents invest in so many
2:03:04
things to enrich our kids' lives, but
2:03:06
are we investing in their future
2:03:08
financial success? With Greenlight, you
2:03:10
can teach your kids financial literacy
2:03:13
skills like earning, saving, and
2:03:15
investing, and this investment costs less
2:03:17
than that after -school treat. Start
2:03:19
prioritizing their financial education in
2:03:21
future today with a risk -free
2:03:23
trial at greenlight.com slash iHeart, greenlight.com
2:03:26
slash iHeart. We
2:03:47
haven't really done much coverage of just
2:03:49
straight up, how do you do a
2:03:51
strike? So today we are
2:03:53
going to be covering a pretty long running
2:03:55
strike. We're going to say how many days
2:03:57
it's been going. It's unclear when this episode
2:03:59
is going to come out. So who fucking
2:04:02
knows how long it'll be when you hear
2:04:04
it. But yeah, with me to talk about
2:04:06
this strike is Spencer Jordan, who is a
2:04:08
rank and file member of the Urban Orworkers
2:04:10
Union. Spencer, welcome to the show. Hey, thank
2:04:12
you so much for having me. Yeah. Yeah,
2:04:14
I'm excited to talk to you about this.
2:04:16
So this is what day is it today?
2:04:18
I should know this. April 15th.
2:04:20
And as of April 15th, you've been
2:04:22
on strike for 25 days. Yeah, that's
2:04:24
just about right. Yeah, it started on
2:04:26
the of March. We
2:04:29
held our strike vote
2:04:31
like a solid 12 days
2:04:33
before we actually went
2:04:35
out on the picket line
2:04:37
and One that
2:04:39
strike vote with 14 yeses
2:04:41
a single no and I think
2:04:43
four four abstentions Yeah, yeah,
2:04:45
so 93 % of those voting
2:04:47
voted yes. Yeah, which good good
2:04:49
ratios good ratios. I think
2:04:51
like Typically you want at least
2:04:54
like mid 70s. Mm -hmm if
2:04:56
we're gonna do this kind
2:04:58
of thing But you know as
2:05:00
listeners of the show hopefully
2:05:02
understand by now you can't just
2:05:04
like call a strike and
2:05:06
have it happen you know,
2:05:08
you have to do a whole bunch of
2:05:10
organizing. So I want to kind of start
2:05:12
at the dynamics of the organizing of how
2:05:14
the shop got going because this is a
2:05:16
pretty small shop from the sounds of it. And
2:05:19
yeah. Yeah. So do you want to talk
2:05:21
a bit about what the basic process of
2:05:23
getting this organizing started was like and what
2:05:25
the sort of like social mapping looked like
2:05:27
and stuff like that? Yeah.
2:05:29
So the organization process
2:05:31
started around like
2:05:33
a year and a
2:05:35
half before We actually
2:05:37
had our unionization vote, which was
2:05:40
actually, we had the vote in
2:05:42
March and we got our win
2:05:44
on April 7th two years ago.
2:05:46
So we actually just had
2:05:48
our union two year birthday. Oh, happy
2:05:51
birthday. But
2:05:53
yeah, so preceding that was like,
2:05:55
like I said, about a year
2:05:57
and a half of organizing that
2:05:59
involved, you know, the typical thing
2:06:01
of like one -on -one conversations with
2:06:04
like all the staff making the,
2:06:06
you know, color coded spreadsheet and
2:06:08
everything, which all of
2:06:10
this was not my my purview.
2:06:12
I'm a lot more involved now
2:06:14
than I was at the start
2:06:16
of the process. And I was
2:06:18
approached by like one of our
2:06:21
lead organizers really shortly after being
2:06:23
hired just to kind of, you
2:06:25
know, read the dipstick as to
2:06:27
like my sentiments about it and
2:06:29
whatnot. I was pretty on
2:06:31
board right away. I mean, you
2:06:33
know, like I'm from the Bay
2:06:36
Area, so... There are only two
2:06:38
types of people from the Bay
2:06:40
Area. We wouldn't be having one
2:06:42
of them on the show. Yeah,
2:06:44
exactly. So I'm of
2:06:46
the latter type. So, you know,
2:06:48
being pro -union isn't like a foreign
2:06:50
thing to my background. Uh -huh.
2:06:52
Uh -huh. You don't look like a
2:06:54
tech worker. Yeah, no. Yeah,
2:06:57
especially like my family's from the Midwest
2:06:59
and everything. So there's my... My aunt actually
2:07:01
just learned that she was like a
2:07:03
clerk working for the railroads back in the
2:07:05
day when like railroad jobs were still
2:07:07
like a big thing you could have. Anyways.
2:07:11
But yeah, so I had had my
2:07:13
like own sort of like just
2:07:15
observations of like, whoa, like what's what's
2:07:17
going on in the workplace? Aside
2:07:19
from like my own just like
2:07:21
predilection to thinking, you know, more
2:07:24
worker power is better. Yeah. Also
2:07:26
kind of seeing like some of
2:07:28
the factors that precipitated it. Like
2:07:30
for instance, like When I was
2:07:32
hired here, I was hired
2:07:34
in my interview. It was
2:07:36
one of the owners and
2:07:38
the manager of my department,
2:07:40
my department being Salvagen Recycling
2:07:42
Department of Urbanor, which is
2:07:44
kind of like not super
2:07:46
public facing. We go to
2:07:48
the dump and like root
2:07:51
around through the garbage like, you
2:07:54
know, whatever, get to get stuff for the store. But
2:07:57
that manager, You
2:07:59
know, he was there in
2:08:01
the interview and we got
2:08:03
to the portion where the
2:08:05
owner explained what at will
2:08:07
employment is. Oh, and she
2:08:09
and she went. So we're
2:08:11
at will here. So,
2:08:13
um, Sam. Well, Sam was
2:08:15
my manager. Sam. Well, how long have
2:08:18
you been here? 21 years. He's there.
2:08:20
Hands folded on the table. Yes.
2:08:22
What that will means is, uh, it
2:08:25
could be tomorrow. I could say,
2:08:27
you know, Sam. Well, It's been a
2:08:29
great 21 years. I really
2:08:31
appreciate all the work you've done. Today's your last day. Why
2:08:34
would you say that? And he has to
2:08:36
sit there and go, hmm. Jesus
2:08:39
Christ. And then she says, of
2:08:42
course, likewise, tomorrow someone could
2:08:44
come to me and say, hey, Mary
2:08:46
Lou, it's been 21
2:08:49
years. I've enjoyed it.
2:08:51
I'm quitting. So, you
2:08:53
know, the sort of sword over his
2:08:55
neck. It's being cast as
2:08:57
somehow equal to him not
2:08:59
being like indentured. Yes.
2:09:02
What are we doing here? This also
2:09:04
just, I mean, like, you know, yeah,
2:09:06
on the basic level, yeah, it's like,
2:09:09
okay, your opponent, I guess they are
2:09:11
your opponent. Your boss can just instantly
2:09:13
fire you for any reason whatsoever, for
2:09:15
any amount of time. And then also
2:09:17
you could quit the job. And
2:09:20
then I'll say it, I feel
2:09:22
like just as a management tactic,
2:09:24
like, Are you, like,
2:09:26
trying to piss off your support units? Like,
2:09:29
what? I
2:09:31
have never had a boss, like,
2:09:33
just do that in a hiring
2:09:35
meeting. What? Yeah,
2:09:37
I mean, have you worked
2:09:39
at, like, a
2:09:41
sort of small, like, mom and
2:09:44
pop, quote unquote, business before?
2:09:46
Yeah, I mean, that's probably why,
2:09:48
because I've usually had, like,
2:09:50
larger E. My shitty jobs
2:09:52
have either been like government jobs or
2:09:54
like, like larger companies. So there
2:09:56
was less of the like, I
2:09:58
heard a line recently that I wish
2:10:01
I remember where it was from. It might
2:10:03
be a line from Star Trek. Like
2:10:05
one of the Ferengi rules is just
2:10:07
like treat your employees like family, exploit them
2:10:09
ruthlessly, which I
2:10:11
like. You know, that's a,
2:10:13
that's a traditional line in
2:10:15
business, especially in small business.
2:10:17
And it's a, it's no
2:10:20
stranger here. Yeah, that question
2:10:22
of like, wanting to piss
2:10:24
off your subordinates or whatever, it's,
2:10:26
I don't know if
2:10:28
pissing off is necessarily like
2:10:30
the concern, but ownership
2:10:32
here, definitely, I've
2:10:35
gotten the impression that they
2:10:37
enjoy showing their power. And
2:10:39
I've gotten the impression that
2:10:41
the sort of like uncertainty
2:10:43
and like, yeah, my mom
2:10:45
would call it jockeying for
2:10:47
position that you have to
2:10:49
do is a dynamic that
2:10:51
they... I really can't say
2:10:53
they honestly because the other
2:10:55
owner, he hasn't been very
2:10:57
active in the business since
2:10:59
my hiring, but at
2:11:01
least Mary Lou tends to
2:11:03
lean on. That's kind of
2:11:05
like the special quality that
2:11:08
you get with a small business
2:11:10
and organizing in a small
2:11:12
workplace. You can see
2:11:14
sort of in their public
2:11:16
communications the way that... The
2:11:18
zucks and the basis is
2:11:21
the rest of them feel
2:11:23
about their employees and you
2:11:25
know You can get a
2:11:27
sense of perhaps how them
2:11:30
might act towards their employees
2:11:32
if they like interact with
2:11:34
them on a daily basis
2:11:36
But it in a small
2:11:38
business setting you really get
2:11:41
a keen view into how
2:11:43
like the power of the
2:11:45
employer mixes very readily with a
2:11:49
person's predilection
2:11:51
towards discipline, predilection
2:11:53
towards personal, what
2:11:57
did you call it? Personal
2:11:59
battling, almost. Yeah. And
2:12:01
it's also like, it's inescapable in a way
2:12:03
that it isn't with, if you're
2:12:05
dealing with people who are, you're at a larger company,
2:12:07
you're not dealing with the person. There's
2:12:09
an old Chinese expression that it's like, heaven
2:12:12
is high and the emperor is far away. So,
2:12:15
you know, it's like, you know, like a lot
2:12:17
of times you're dealing with, okay, yeah, there is
2:12:19
like, you know, your Zuckerberg is there, but he's like,
2:12:21
he never interacts with you. But with this, it's
2:12:23
like, no, the small business tyrant is right there
2:12:25
in your face all the time, and all of
2:12:27
the weird petty shit that they want to do,
2:12:30
and all of this sort of like, you
2:12:32
know, and I would say this isn't just like a
2:12:34
unique thing of like small business owners, like people in
2:12:36
all positions, like in all
2:12:38
portions of like the class society, have
2:12:41
in them kind of like the capacity
2:12:43
for cruelty and there's just people like that.
2:12:45
But they don't normally have the ability
2:12:47
to just do it to you directly
2:12:50
in your face. And that's, yeah, and
2:12:52
that's like, you know, this is what you've been
2:12:54
talking about is like, yeah, you have like these small
2:12:56
business tyrants like every suddenly in the same way
2:12:58
that like, I don't know, you're dealing with like. Like
2:13:01
one of the random King
2:13:03
Louis and you're like in the
2:13:05
court and suddenly just like
2:13:07
the fact that this guy doesn't
2:13:09
like people going to the
2:13:11
bathroom means that everyone around him
2:13:14
doesn't get a doesn't get
2:13:16
a shit, right? Like it's just
2:13:18
like yeah No, exactly. It's
2:13:20
like it's actually an argument that
2:13:22
She's deployed in her reddit
2:13:24
correspondence, which has been seemingly a
2:13:26
pretty active part of her
2:13:29
spare time that she's not spending
2:13:31
at the bargaining table with
2:13:33
us You know made this comparison
2:13:35
of like this isn't a
2:13:37
question about oligarchs or whatever and
2:13:39
it's true like the small
2:13:41
businessman is not an oligarch but
2:13:44
the small business is a
2:13:46
microcosm of like the larger capitalist
2:13:48
social order and while the
2:13:50
small business man might not have
2:13:52
the scope of power of
2:13:54
the oligarch or like the actual
2:13:57
capital resources of an oligarch,
2:13:59
the behavior certainly rhymes at least.
2:14:01
Yeah. And again, it's a
2:14:03
lot of it is about, it's
2:14:05
just how much power you
2:14:07
have access to, right? Lots
2:14:10
of people can be like this,
2:14:12
but only the few, the proud, the
2:14:14
small business type get to do it. Yeah,
2:14:17
totally. And ultimately,
2:14:20
the employer, wherever they are, they're
2:14:22
in this privileged position of being
2:14:24
able to, you spend
2:14:27
most people more than like a third of your life
2:14:29
at work. The employer has
2:14:31
this unique power to dictate what that
2:14:33
third of your life looks like. We
2:14:36
talk about, I mean,
2:14:38
shit, we don't. People are
2:14:40
not so much talking about democracy
2:14:43
writ large in the US
2:14:45
in the same way now that
2:14:47
they used to, but
2:14:49
you talk about this idea of
2:14:51
like living in a democracy, but
2:14:54
democracy ends at the shop door.
2:14:56
yeah and and like the the
2:14:59
kind of power that these people
2:15:01
have is something that like these
2:15:03
people get to control when you
2:15:05
can go to the bathroom like
2:15:07
what clothes you wear like literally
2:15:09
what you can do what you
2:15:12
can say at any given time
2:15:14
if you employed the exact level
2:15:16
of control that your boss has
2:15:18
over you on a state, it would be
2:15:20
a totalitarian state. And yet, everyone
2:15:22
seems to think that this is sort of
2:15:24
like, you know, and this is
2:15:26
an argument I've been making about, like,
2:15:28
Trump, is that like, yeah, this is,
2:15:30
this is, this is what sort of Trump and Elon
2:15:32
and like that whole cadre and, you know, know, and,
2:15:34
know, if you want to go into this sort of
2:15:37
ideologues behind it too, this is what people like Peter
2:15:39
Thiel Want when they say
2:15:41
run the government like a business what
2:15:43
they mean is that they want
2:15:45
to like to import the sort of
2:15:47
like just the pure tyranny of
2:15:49
the workplace and Expand it into the
2:15:51
entire political system so that they're
2:15:53
there like sort of pure like Totalitarian
2:15:55
corporate rule can't be challenged. Yeah.
2:15:57
Yeah, I mean wasn't it Mussolini who
2:15:59
coined the term the corporate state? Probably
2:16:02
although it would not surprise me if
2:16:04
it was like some other fascist theorist
2:16:06
and Mussolini just started saying it because
2:16:10
Yeah, but yeah, like that's you know, that's
2:16:12
a substantive thing here and what this
2:16:14
also means is that like Even in ways
2:16:17
that are sort of hard to see
2:16:19
like a fight over democracy in the workplace
2:16:21
Right is a is a part of
2:16:23
the larger struggle against all of all the
2:16:25
thing that's happening because if you know
2:16:27
if we're gonna survive this and if we're
2:16:29
gonna make sure that We don't all
2:16:31
live in a world where like if you
2:16:34
say the wrong thing you can be
2:16:36
sent to a prison camp Democracy,
2:16:38
if you want this to survive, is going
2:16:40
to have to march into the layer of
2:16:42
the beast. It is going to have to
2:16:44
go into the source of this tyranny itself,
2:16:46
which is the workplace, and it's going to
2:16:48
have to crush it there. Yeah,
2:16:51
I mean, you said it
2:16:53
very aptly there, like the
2:16:55
corporate structure mirrors the totalitarian
2:16:57
structure. And
2:17:00
not only does fighting
2:17:02
the corporate structure at
2:17:04
the level of labor
2:17:06
make sense, And that,
2:17:08
right, labor is what
2:17:10
enables the flow of
2:17:13
capital that sustains the
2:17:15
totalitarian state. But also, like
2:17:18
you said, you're addressing the
2:17:20
structure in its, I don't
2:17:22
know, I almost think of
2:17:24
it as like the, you
2:17:26
know, like Grendel's mother in
2:17:28
the Fenn or whatever. And
2:17:30
like, you know, the...
2:17:32
The authoritarian thing is
2:17:35
like, is like Grendel maybe
2:17:37
and like Grendel's mother
2:17:39
is like this capitalist hierarchical
2:17:41
structure. Yeah. You know,
2:17:43
you take it on with
2:17:45
an insistence on workplace
2:17:47
democracy as kind of Libby
2:17:49
as that's that sounds. Okay,
2:17:53
speaking of capitalist utilitarianism, I
2:17:55
hear the ads that we are
2:17:57
required to run by our
2:18:00
corporates. Oh, beautiful, beautiful. Let's
2:18:02
hear them. And
2:18:14
we are back.
2:18:18
So let's get back a little
2:18:20
bit towards the more concrete parts
2:18:22
of the Union, although I do
2:18:24
have more to say eventually at
2:18:26
some point about the way
2:18:28
that sort of labor liberalism co -opted democracy
2:18:30
in the workplace from like, you know,
2:18:32
the old sort of like anarchist idea
2:18:34
of workers control, right? But, okay, so
2:18:36
one thing I wanted to talk about
2:18:39
before we sort of get into the
2:18:41
more formal stuff about the strike is
2:18:43
I'm really interested to hear you talk
2:18:45
about what the process of kind of
2:18:47
onboarding you to get more involved in
2:18:49
the union is because this is something
2:18:52
that like, okay, every functional
2:18:54
union wants to do this. Like if
2:18:56
your union is not trying to bring
2:18:58
People like its members like more to
2:19:00
get more involved in the union and
2:19:02
become more of the people becoming like
2:19:04
core organizers and becoming You know like
2:19:06
there's people who are doing your bargain
2:19:08
people are doing anything like your union
2:19:10
is There's weird shit about it and
2:19:12
you should probably like be looking into
2:19:14
that But it's pretty hard. So yeah,
2:19:16
can you talk a bit about the
2:19:18
process of like how you were brought
2:19:20
in and What sort of worked and
2:19:22
what didn't? Well, I
2:19:24
think Ultimately,
2:19:26
the easiest thing is
2:19:29
a sort of ramping
2:19:31
up degree of responsibility
2:19:33
within the organization. So
2:19:35
at the start, I would come
2:19:37
to some of the meetings. I
2:19:40
would miss some of them. I'd be
2:19:42
like, oh, I'm fucking so busy with
2:19:44
whatever is going on in my life.
2:19:46
And I was supportive and sort of
2:19:48
involved, but I wasn't
2:19:50
like... master wasn't doing things
2:19:53
like this. And,
2:19:56
you know,
2:19:58
eventually, one,
2:20:00
we kind of persisted as a union
2:20:03
over a longer period of time. The
2:20:05
necessity of involvement
2:20:08
became more obvious
2:20:10
to me, right?
2:20:13
And that's a hard ask,
2:20:15
you know, like, you're organizing, you
2:20:18
want momentum and you want
2:20:20
Yeah, you want to be able
2:20:23
to change your conditions for the
2:20:25
better as soon as possible. Yeah,
2:20:27
and with with urban or You
2:20:29
know Lots of workplaces that need
2:20:31
unionization have high turnover, right? And
2:20:33
urban or is no different
2:20:35
and so I saw you know,
2:20:37
like some of the more
2:20:39
committed elements of the bargaining unit
2:20:41
fired or quit or whatever
2:20:44
and You know, they'd be replaced
2:20:46
with other people and you
2:20:48
have to begin the work of
2:20:50
organizing over again and with
2:20:52
some of them you succeed with
2:20:54
something you don't. You have
2:20:56
different dynamics. I feel like
2:20:58
the hiring procedures may have changed a little
2:21:00
bit after one of our elections. But
2:21:03
I can't say that for certain. So
2:21:06
the necessity of keeping that
2:21:08
flame going, especially after we had
2:21:10
won the election, we were
2:21:12
in contract bargaining for a long
2:21:14
period of time, made
2:21:16
me feel a sense of
2:21:19
I need to be more active
2:21:21
in this because this is an
2:21:23
important struggle. And I
2:21:25
see our main organizers
2:21:28
taking on a fuckload
2:21:30
of work and needing
2:21:32
more voices at the
2:21:34
table, needing more people
2:21:36
to be more involved.
2:21:39
And so I volunteered
2:21:41
to run for
2:21:44
treasurer. I was the
2:21:46
only candidate. But
2:21:48
theoretically, I could have been voted down. They could have
2:21:50
been like, I don't know about Spencer. And
2:21:54
I ended up having a little
2:21:56
bit more direct responsibilities. I was
2:21:58
receiving some of the donations to
2:22:00
our strike fund. Once we started
2:22:02
fundraising for the strike, I had
2:22:04
to keep track of those and
2:22:06
put them in a special bank
2:22:08
account. And then eventually, take that
2:22:10
money, get it to the IWW
2:22:12
branch, hand it.
2:22:14
Hand a big check to
2:22:16
Dino That kind of
2:22:19
stuff and just like having
2:22:21
like little things to
2:22:23
be doing like spurs involvement
2:22:25
Other people, you know
2:22:27
became responsible for like parts
2:22:29
of social media outreach
2:22:32
make graphics stuff like that
2:22:34
and Also like sort
2:22:36
of I guess giving people
2:22:38
the opportunity to Leverage
2:22:41
their individual connections within the work
2:22:43
because every workplace is like clicks and
2:22:45
groups and subgroups and all that
2:22:47
To leverage those connections in like service
2:22:49
of bettering everyone's conditions So like
2:22:52
to a certain degree I've I've been
2:22:54
like important as like an envoy
2:22:56
to my particular department because it's our
2:22:58
Job takes us away from the
2:23:00
job site or like from like the
2:23:02
main the main work site often
2:23:04
and stuff like that so there's
2:23:07
less of a direct avenue for communication
2:23:09
there. So I can say
2:23:11
that's my experience. As far
2:23:13
as organizing goes, I'm easy.
2:23:16
I was already believing in
2:23:18
it. And there
2:23:20
are others that
2:23:22
it's been harder. I
2:23:25
will say, though,
2:23:27
that the strike itself
2:23:29
is, I mean, a
2:23:32
strike is a conflict. And
2:23:34
when you're in conflict together, it's
2:23:36
an extremely co -hearing force Yeah,
2:23:38
which doesn't just say that
2:23:40
like necessarily you want your unionization
2:23:43
to come to a strike
2:23:45
but Perhaps like raising a sort
2:23:47
of consciousness of like the
2:23:49
fact that like you are ultimately
2:23:51
like in conflict with the
2:23:53
boss Yeah, the boss doesn't want
2:23:55
you to unionize The boss
2:23:57
doesn't want you to force concessions
2:23:59
out of them and that
2:24:01
like as a union we are
2:24:03
taking on this responsibility to
2:24:05
look after each other's interests and
2:24:07
to support each other tangibly
2:24:09
in terms of what we do
2:24:11
and also intangibly in terms
2:24:14
of the kind of conversations we
2:24:16
have around morale, planning
2:24:18
and stuff like that to
2:24:20
succeed together. I think
2:24:22
those are really potent,
2:24:24
coherent forces and it
2:24:26
helps to have a
2:24:28
good opponent. The boss
2:24:30
is the best organizer. At
2:24:33
Urbanor, you don't
2:24:35
go along without
2:24:37
coming head to
2:24:39
head with conflict
2:24:41
with ownership or
2:24:43
with ownership through
2:24:45
the mediator of
2:24:47
management. Although
2:24:49
support for the union
2:24:52
might be divided
2:24:54
a bit at the
2:24:56
workplace. One thing
2:24:58
that's pretty universal is frustration
2:25:00
with ownership. Yeah. So,
2:25:02
okay, speaking of, speaking of a frustration
2:25:04
with ownership, it is time for us
2:25:06
to go to ads one last time.
2:25:09
Oh, beautiful. But then after we come
2:25:11
back, strike, strike, strike, strike, strike, strike,
2:25:13
strike. Just after this message. Oh,
2:25:15
God. Okay,
2:25:26
we are back from a bunch of people who
2:25:28
almost assuredly do not want you to go on
2:25:30
strike, but Yeah, so
2:25:33
let's get into the
2:25:35
process of how you
2:25:37
actually organize a strike.
2:25:40
Yeah, let's start from just like the
2:25:42
very beginning. What are the kind
2:25:44
of things that were happening that made people think that
2:25:46
you needed to do this in the first place? So
2:25:49
the strike itself is
2:25:51
a result specifically like
2:25:53
this is a ULP
2:25:55
strike. So it's
2:25:57
in response to something
2:26:00
that falls under the category
2:26:02
of unfair labor practice, according to
2:26:04
the National Labor Relations Act.
2:26:06
And it's backed up by charges
2:26:08
filed with the board, as
2:26:10
opposed to what's called an economic
2:26:13
strike, which is a strike
2:26:15
that is specifically about economic issues
2:26:17
at the workplace. So
2:26:19
the specific ULP that's being cited
2:26:21
for our strike is bad faith bargaining.
2:26:24
And for us, what that's
2:26:26
looked like is two
2:26:28
years of completely stalled negotiations
2:26:30
where we are basically
2:26:32
being faced with a take
2:26:34
it or leave it
2:26:36
offer of the status quo
2:26:38
in the vast majority
2:26:41
of our proposals. Bargaining
2:26:43
is very, very slow
2:26:46
and ownership has held
2:26:48
tightly to the offense
2:26:50
at us having unionized
2:26:52
at all, which to
2:26:55
my understanding is pretty
2:26:57
typical of small workplaces.
2:27:00
The ownership takes it very personally
2:27:02
and that personal feeling of the
2:27:04
trail or whatever becomes like a
2:27:06
like like a stumbling block in
2:27:09
the negotiation process. I know that
2:27:11
was the case with Moe's another
2:27:13
is a bookshop in Berkeley
2:27:15
that also unionized with the IWW. So,
2:27:19
you know, we've had our whole
2:27:21
proposal on ownership's table for a
2:27:23
year and a half now. We
2:27:25
had started with bargaining
2:27:27
proposal by proposal. They
2:27:29
said, well, how can we possibly
2:27:31
agree to any of this without understanding
2:27:33
the full context, especially the economic
2:27:35
context? And so we gave them
2:27:37
a full proposal and they said, oh my
2:27:39
God, how do you expect us to
2:27:41
read all of this in time to bargain?
2:27:44
This is way too much. How are we going
2:27:46
to evaluate this all? We
2:27:48
got to do a proposal by proposal. So
2:27:50
it's been really unclear to
2:27:52
us. If ownership has even actually
2:27:55
read the entirety of our collective
2:27:57
bargaining agreement that we put on
2:27:59
their desk, I know that
2:28:01
in the past, the lawyers have
2:28:03
said things like, oh, my eyes
2:28:05
glazed over when I read your
2:28:07
email, so I missed such
2:28:09
and such part of it. This
2:28:11
is literally your job! You're
2:28:14
a contract worker! You have
2:28:16
one job! Yeah, you
2:28:18
would think a lawyer would have
2:28:20
a little bit more than beyond
2:28:22
a tweet -sized reading capacity. Well,
2:28:24
they give anyone law degrees. Yeah.
2:28:28
Or, like, ownership saying, like,
2:28:31
well, I just thought it was so ridiculous I didn't feel
2:28:33
the need to read all of it. Stuff
2:28:35
like that. Oh, my God. Does this
2:28:37
read as bad faith bargaining? Yeah,
2:28:39
that's bad by, like, the
2:28:41
standards of, like, normal.
2:28:44
It takes two years to do a fucking
2:28:46
contract because they're just not doing shit.
2:28:49
Like, good lord. Usually...
2:28:51
long contract negotiations by two years
2:28:53
at least there's like been some
2:28:55
progress. Yeah, they've read
2:28:58
the proposals. Like,
2:29:00
yes, okay, will your boss show up to
2:29:02
your meeting an hour and a half late
2:29:04
because they didn't bother to look through the proposals
2:29:06
until literally right the time the meeting was
2:29:08
going to start? Yes, but will they have
2:29:10
done it? Usually, yes. In
2:29:13
fact, in the company
2:29:15
propaganda, where they're claiming that
2:29:17
this like bad faith
2:29:19
bargaining charge has no grounds.
2:29:21
They're like, ownership has
2:29:23
come to like 25 to
2:29:25
30 bargaining sessions, neglecting
2:29:27
dimension. There have been somewhere in the range of
2:29:30
like 50 to 60. And
2:29:32
of course, maybe
2:29:35
they've shown up to more than
2:29:37
half. I don't want to be libelous,
2:29:39
but yeah, but still like.
2:29:41
If at the point at which you
2:29:43
are failing to show up for
2:29:45
any bargaining session I think you can
2:29:47
like look I have always advocated
2:29:49
that if that if that if management
2:29:51
doesn't show up to a bargaining
2:29:53
session You should just be allowed to
2:29:55
take the company because clearly they're
2:29:57
not serious about it, but huh Hey,
2:29:59
you know, they've been talking about
2:30:01
a worker cop for 20 years non
2:30:04
-reformist reforms But yeah, so those kind
2:30:06
of things and then like finally
2:30:08
like one of the bigger precipitating factors
2:30:10
is like We've been trying to
2:30:12
bargain over economics. Ownership
2:30:14
has implied a lot of times
2:30:16
that they cannot afford to pay
2:30:18
what we're asking. They
2:30:20
say it'll ruin the company. They say a company
2:30:23
will go bankrupt. They say it's unsustainable. They say
2:30:25
this and that. And then when they get to
2:30:27
the table, they say we have never and will
2:30:29
never argue inability to pay. Because
2:30:31
the thing is, is that to say inability
2:30:33
to pay, right? It
2:30:35
obligates you to furnish information
2:30:37
and prove that. And they, for
2:30:39
whatever reason, do not
2:30:42
want British financial
2:30:44
information. So these have
2:30:46
been some of the sticking points,
2:30:48
and that's why we've been out on
2:30:50
the picket line for about three
2:30:52
weeks now. Still waiting for them to
2:30:54
come to the table. God damn
2:30:56
it. So, okay, let's talk about the
2:30:58
process of how the discussions went
2:31:01
for doing this. What did those look
2:31:03
like and how did you plan
2:31:05
this thing out? Well, I guess the
2:31:07
process towards like deciding that I
2:31:09
needed to come into a strike was
2:31:11
like, you know, that is a
2:31:13
sort of thing that builds over a
2:31:15
long period of time. You know,
2:31:17
you see ownership doing bad faith bargaining,
2:31:19
you go, what more conciliatory approaches
2:31:21
can we take first? You
2:31:23
know, can we try this? Can we
2:31:26
try offering this to make, you know, can
2:31:28
we try this display of good faith?
2:31:30
Can we offer this compromise? One
2:31:32
of the things that was a
2:31:34
big part was of a some of
2:31:36
the not exactly contract related discussions, but
2:31:39
like I should have been talking for
2:31:41
a long time about a co -op
2:31:43
transition that has never happened. It's been
2:31:45
20 years. And
2:31:47
now that we've unionized, they're like, are people
2:31:49
who we were talking to about doing the co
2:31:51
-op thing, they don't work with unions. And
2:31:54
so the only way that there were going
2:31:56
to be a co -op is if the
2:31:58
union goes away. And so in response to
2:32:00
that, we said, well, we're totally open to
2:32:02
a transition to a co -op that involves the
2:32:04
union. And here is such -and -such organization. It
2:32:07
was our leading negotiator who
2:32:09
actually provided information somewhere in the
2:32:11
name of the organization. But,
2:32:13
you know, here's such -and -such organization
2:32:15
that actually specifically deals with
2:32:18
union co -op workplace transitions was
2:32:20
not received with interest. So
2:32:23
it's like, you master this catalog
2:32:25
of bad faith bargaining, and you
2:32:27
end up in your strategy discussions
2:32:29
with the whole unit, testing the
2:32:31
wires of like, when is
2:32:34
too much what's our red line
2:32:36
that we need to take more
2:32:38
direct action. And
2:32:40
what that began with for
2:32:42
us was first, well, if
2:32:45
we're gonna have a strike, we
2:32:47
need funds for it.
2:32:49
The IWW is an organization
2:32:51
that affords its unions
2:32:53
a lot of freedom and
2:32:55
a lot of mutual
2:32:57
support and solidarity is not
2:32:59
an organization with a
2:33:01
huge amount of money. And
2:33:04
so we did start
2:33:06
with trying to get
2:33:08
a sense of what
2:33:10
we could get from
2:33:12
the branches reserve. And
2:33:15
we moved on from that to
2:33:17
how we were going to fundraise
2:33:19
and stuff like that. So we
2:33:21
held informational pickets that had donations.
2:33:24
We sold shirts, posters, stuff
2:33:26
like that. We held a
2:33:28
big strike fundraiser. Hell yeah. I think
2:33:30
something around like a month in advance
2:33:32
of our, or it was maybe like
2:33:34
a month and a half in advance
2:33:36
of our strike. We also
2:33:38
gave management like a courtesy
2:33:40
notice about this as they could
2:33:43
pass it on to ownership
2:33:45
saying, hey, we've started fundraising for
2:33:47
a strike. In the hopes
2:33:49
that like being aware that we're
2:33:51
taking active preparations to go
2:33:53
on strike would facilitate bargaining. Sometimes
2:33:55
it works. I've seen it
2:33:57
before. I've seen it before. Sometimes it works.
2:34:00
Yeah. And sometimes, you know,
2:34:02
sometimes you end up on
2:34:04
a podcast talking about how
2:34:06
it didn't. You
2:34:09
never know until you try. Yeah,
2:34:11
you never know. But
2:34:14
we did, yeah, we did give
2:34:16
them that sort of early warning.
2:34:19
And our readiness to strike kind of
2:34:21
like depended then on like where
2:34:23
we were at in the fundraising process.
2:34:26
So we continue soliciting donations, reaching out
2:34:28
to various organizations in the area
2:34:30
that are, you know, pro
2:34:32
-labor, you know,
2:34:34
we've talked to like DSA and
2:34:37
whatever, because, you know, they have
2:34:39
their like a workplace organizing committee.
2:34:41
Yeah, you walk. Yeah. Yeah.
2:34:43
And various other, you
2:34:45
know, yeah, organizations that are
2:34:47
pro -labor. And once we
2:34:49
got to a point where
2:34:51
we felt like we were reasonably
2:34:53
like prepared to sustain a
2:34:55
open -ended strike because that's what we're
2:34:58
doing. This is a strike with
2:35:00
no set end date. Then we
2:35:02
announced our intention to hold a
2:35:04
strike vote. We held a strike vote.
2:35:06
Strike vote passes. The
2:35:08
ownership was made aware at the bargaining
2:35:10
session before the strike vote. So it
2:35:12
was like the Monday before the strike
2:35:14
vote, which is on, I think, I
2:35:16
guess Saturday. So in
2:35:19
total, it was around maybe
2:35:21
two weeks in change that
2:35:23
they knew definite
2:35:25
possibility. Pass the
2:35:27
strike vote. 12 days later, the
2:35:29
strike begins with unfortunately no bargaining
2:35:31
in between. Good Lord. Yeah.
2:35:33
The whole way, you hope that they'll
2:35:36
come to the table. You hope that they
2:35:38
will come to their senses. Yeah.
2:35:40
Take it. Take the risk
2:35:42
seriously. Take the risk seriously. And
2:35:45
unfortunately, this is not what's happened
2:35:47
here. Yeah. And I think part
2:35:49
of that is maybe an age
2:35:51
thing here. Ownership is is in
2:35:53
their 80s and they pretty consistently
2:35:56
held the view that like the
2:35:58
union is like a bunch of
2:36:00
young people who don't know what
2:36:02
the hell they're talking about, you
2:36:04
know, even though like
2:36:06
the age range of our union
2:36:08
spans the age range of
2:36:10
the workplace. We've got people in
2:36:13
their 50s and 40s and
2:36:15
30s and 20s, you know, which
2:36:17
is of course the problematic
2:36:19
group. But yeah, the unraticals. Yeah,
2:36:23
so there's there's been this sort of
2:36:25
patronizing attitude that I think has resulted
2:36:28
in like a real strategic failure on
2:36:30
their part to seriously prepare for the
2:36:32
strike or You know bargain to avoid
2:36:34
it. Yeah one more fundraising thing that
2:36:36
I just I just want to mention
2:36:38
this for people if you're if you're
2:36:40
trying to fundraise for your own thing
2:36:43
something that's actually we've had a lot
2:36:45
of success with up in Portland is
2:36:47
Getting bands to do benefit shows So
2:36:49
like because it's Portland, right? Like the
2:36:51
local hardcore scene has a lot of
2:36:53
bands that, you know, are just
2:36:55
supportive of stuff. And we've done this for a
2:36:57
whole bunch of different causes. And
2:37:00
this can also be a good way to
2:37:02
just sort of do fundraising things that
2:37:04
are fun and also raise morale because, yeah,
2:37:06
you're doing the show. Yeah, I was...
2:37:08
I was I was hoping to have that
2:37:10
be more of a thing with our
2:37:12
fundraiser. But yeah, it can be hard to
2:37:15
organize sometimes. Yeah, the people I knew
2:37:17
were didn't get quite the response. I was
2:37:19
hoping from the community. If
2:37:21
you are a hardcore band, if
2:37:23
you are a band Berkeley, there's
2:37:26
still time. I
2:37:29
believe in you. That is that is
2:37:31
totally a good option. What we did,
2:37:33
but we ended up doing that. There
2:37:35
was music, but it's also like one
2:37:37
of our organizers is really into cooking,
2:37:39
like a barbecue thing, sold
2:37:42
food, stuff like that,
2:37:44
and had a raffle.
2:37:46
A raffle is a great way
2:37:49
to fundraise. For us, we
2:37:51
raffled off stuff we have. But
2:37:54
honestly, you can even do
2:37:56
a straight, monetary raffle is still
2:37:58
a great fundraising tool where
2:38:00
everyone puts in money, the
2:38:03
top three winners or whatever get a
2:38:05
certain percentage of the total pool and
2:38:07
the rest of the pool is is
2:38:09
to the cause. It's really simple, really
2:38:12
effective. Yeah. There's a
2:38:14
reason, it's not good, but there is a reason
2:38:16
why a whole bunch of state education budgets are
2:38:18
funded by the lottery. It does
2:38:20
work. The people
2:38:22
love to gamble. Much better. Yeah.
2:38:27
Mia says, having turned
2:38:29
off her path of exile
2:38:31
to lunch break to come
2:38:33
to this interview, it's
2:38:36
pretty such cases. Okay,
2:38:38
so let's, let's, speaking of, I guess this is something
2:38:40
that's been tied in to sort of all of
2:38:42
what we've been saying here, but yeah, let's talk about,
2:38:44
you know, sort of maintaining the strike when it
2:38:46
starts and sort of, yeah, what would have been
2:38:48
the processes of like keeping morale up and keeping people
2:38:50
engaged and yeah. Yeah,
2:38:52
I mean, definitely when you go
2:38:55
into a strike, you want to
2:38:57
go in with a militant core
2:38:59
group. You want to basically be
2:39:01
sure that everyone is committed to
2:39:03
holding the line until a collective
2:39:05
decision is made otherwise. You
2:39:07
don't want people like peeling off. That's
2:39:10
really bad PR for your strike. Yeah.
2:39:12
And like the bosses will grab
2:39:14
on that. So like,
2:39:17
for instance, like, you know,
2:39:19
we have some people who are respecting
2:39:21
our picket line, but chose not to
2:39:23
pick it with us, which is fine
2:39:25
as far as I'm concerned. But the
2:39:27
issue with that PR wise is that
2:39:29
now the bosses are saying and they're
2:39:31
like tallying up of who's working and
2:39:33
who's not working. They're counting them as
2:39:35
working, you know. They're like, oh, there's
2:39:37
only whatever. They've been
2:39:39
saying eight people. I think
2:39:41
it's more like nine or 10 who are
2:39:43
on the picket line. But the
2:39:45
rest of the employees are working. They
2:39:47
count themselves as employees in that count, of course.
2:39:51
And they count these people who are
2:39:53
not crossing the picket line but
2:39:55
not on it also as among that
2:39:57
count of the rest of the
2:39:59
employees that are working. And
2:40:02
they've had the opportunity
2:40:04
to really inflate that
2:40:06
count because and a classic
2:40:08
move. Really, all the
2:40:11
moves are classic. You read your organizing
2:40:13
books and you're like, can it happen
2:40:15
here? It does. We
2:40:18
got a lot of new assistant
2:40:20
managers after we won our election.
2:40:22
God. Right now, the composition of
2:40:24
the workplace, right? Got 34 people,
2:40:27
15 managers. I really wonder when
2:40:29
we're going to see the day
2:40:31
where you have companies that have
2:40:33
six like, non -managers and 55
2:40:35
managers. Like, I feel like we're
2:40:37
not that far out. Well, we're leading the
2:40:39
charge here. We have a department that's two people,
2:40:41
a manager and an assistant manager. Who's
2:40:44
the assistant manager managing? Oh, God.
2:40:51
So, yeah, you know, they've had
2:40:53
these particular angles to, you
2:40:55
know, sort of do their
2:40:57
propaganda from and... honestly, I
2:41:00
think a big part of,
2:41:02
again, the boss is the
2:41:04
best organizer. And
2:41:06
like a thing that keeps you committed on
2:41:08
the line is like reading all this
2:41:10
bullshit they say about you and knowing otherwise
2:41:12
and being able to talk to each
2:41:14
other and be like, have you seen this?
2:41:16
Isn't this crazy? Like, what the hell?
2:41:18
Yeah. Also, you
2:41:20
know, is this is where
2:41:22
the sort of like
2:41:25
seeds of organizing All
2:41:27
the way that you start all the way
2:41:29
back at the beginning of your union
2:41:31
campaign become you know show themselves like really
2:41:33
important again because like the start right
2:41:35
anyone will tell you is like getting to
2:41:37
know people like being like you know
2:41:39
being on like a hey how's it going
2:41:41
kind of level you know and having
2:41:43
like a personal rapport with the people you're
2:41:45
on the line with is vital just
2:41:47
in the sense that you know obviously like
2:41:49
you know each other you're sort of
2:41:51
friends you're gonna be more likely to stick
2:41:53
up for each other. But also,
2:41:56
you're out there nine hours walking
2:41:58
in a circle with these people. You
2:42:01
got to have positive, strong relationships
2:42:03
with them. You want to be able
2:42:05
to have the kind of rapport
2:42:07
where you can talk to people about
2:42:09
what they're feeling anxious about, where
2:42:12
they're worried in the
2:42:14
strike strategy. You
2:42:16
need to have that trust between each other that
2:42:18
you can have an open dialogue about how it
2:42:20
feels to be on the picket line. You're
2:42:23
not going to maintain morale if
2:42:25
everyone feels like they've got things they
2:42:28
got a hold in about it. There's
2:42:30
room to be like, shit, are they going
2:42:32
to close the business? And what are we
2:42:34
going to do? And sort
2:42:37
of talk through that from a
2:42:39
place beyond, you're not letting
2:42:41
it speak into a crowd of
2:42:43
a million people or whatever. You're
2:42:45
just two people. And
2:42:48
going through a stressful experience together. Yeah.
2:42:50
Yeah, and you have to actually
2:42:52
grapple with that in a way that's
2:42:54
not the sort of like weird
2:42:56
corporate like we got to improve morale
2:42:58
things like that's not what that
2:43:00
means it means like you know it
2:43:02
means actually grappling and engaging with
2:43:04
people's feelings and how and what they
2:43:06
need in a moment and yeah
2:43:08
and their fears and their concerns and
2:43:11
Yeah, you can't just sort of
2:43:14
brush them aside. You have to
2:43:16
actually grapple with it because that's
2:43:18
that's that's what doing this stuff
2:43:20
means Yeah, exactly having like these
2:43:22
authentic conversations with people because like
2:43:24
like yeah, that's like a totally
2:43:26
great point you bring up there
2:43:28
like the HR speak That's the
2:43:30
bosses tool and it's the bosses
2:43:32
tool To divide and create disunity
2:43:34
so you can't lean on that
2:43:36
model for morale within your union.
2:43:38
It just creates distrust Yeah,
2:43:41
and mean, I've seen that happen with
2:43:43
unions where it's like, you guys did
2:43:45
not do a good job of like
2:43:47
talking to people about this and like, yeah,
2:43:50
and it can be really disruptive to attempts to
2:43:52
do this. But on the other hand, if you
2:43:54
do it well, it's the
2:43:56
most powerful single thing that
2:43:58
you can like possibly do is
2:44:00
like forging relationships that are
2:44:02
based on like the actual experience
2:44:04
of having gone. through struggle
2:44:07
together and having had to like literally
2:44:09
had to face your feels on the picket
2:44:11
line. Yeah. Yeah. Like
2:44:13
ideally, you know, the union is
2:44:15
a community and it's a community
2:44:17
of interest, right? It's a community
2:44:19
of work interest, but it is
2:44:21
ideally a community. It's not a
2:44:23
family, right? And it's certainly
2:44:26
not a family in the way that
2:44:28
the bosses will tell you the workplaces, but
2:44:30
it is a community and
2:44:33
it's a community in the
2:44:35
way that that an employer's
2:44:37
idea of a community is
2:44:39
fundamentally like incompatible with. Yeah.
2:44:43
this Vicky Osterwald line that I think
2:44:45
about a lot from her book in
2:44:47
defensive fluting where she talks about how
2:44:49
I feel like it was Ferguson that
2:44:51
this is about where like the police
2:44:53
chief is talking about the damage to
2:44:55
the community and they keep saying our
2:44:57
Walmart. It's like going
2:44:59
into a Walmart and buying something
2:45:01
is not a community, right? Like
2:45:04
you know, they like that, like
2:45:06
those, those kind of relations are not
2:45:08
actual community relations. But when
2:45:10
the bosses talk about community, that's
2:45:12
what they mean. They mean like, like
2:45:14
our collective community Walmart. They
2:45:16
mean preserving the relation of extraction that
2:45:18
they have. And
2:45:20
we are, you know, using the
2:45:22
same word and reading something
2:45:25
literally so radically different than that.
2:45:27
And you have to make sure in
2:45:29
your, in the way that you're
2:45:32
acting that That radically different meaning is
2:45:34
clear. Yeah, and yeah, it's funny
2:45:36
you bring that up because that's just
2:45:38
bringing to mind like You see the difference
2:45:40
in those attitudes like when you're out
2:45:42
there on the picket line like interact because
2:45:44
you know our picket line a really
2:45:46
pivotal part of it because there are so
2:45:48
many managers in there that they're able
2:45:50
to maintain this like skeleton crew is the
2:45:52
community outreach part is like talking to
2:45:54
every single person who's coming up and being
2:45:56
like Hey, how's it going? Did a
2:45:58
guy been on strike such such and such
2:46:00
long? This is what's up? Please don't
2:46:02
cross my picket line. And,
2:46:04
you know, I've noticed you get this real funny
2:46:07
situation where there are the people who are like,
2:46:09
I've shopped here for 20 years. You don't know
2:46:11
what the hell you're talking about. I don't know
2:46:13
you. And I have to be like, well, I'm
2:46:15
normally at the dump getting the merchandise you're buying.
2:46:17
But and who attribute the
2:46:20
entire attribute everything they like
2:46:22
about the business to the
2:46:24
bosses. And then there's the
2:46:26
other part of the community
2:46:28
that is coming by frequently. and
2:46:31
like hanging out with us on on
2:46:33
the picket line. You know, I pet the
2:46:35
dog and we chat about what's going
2:46:37
on. They're like, how's the strike going? They're
2:46:39
like, you know, I know it's been
2:46:41
rough on you guys for such and such.
2:46:43
And like, these people are our shoppers
2:46:45
too, right? But they like, they, it highlights
2:46:47
that like, sort of divide in like, what
2:46:50
you think of as like community and
2:46:52
your responsibility or community. Because like, these people
2:46:54
also love Urban Order and come here
2:46:56
all the time. But they
2:46:58
recognize that like, it's
2:47:00
the workers at Urbanor that
2:47:03
create it every day. And
2:47:05
it is a company that
2:47:07
was founded by an individual. The
2:47:10
individual still owns it. He did found
2:47:12
it with his labor and all that.
2:47:14
He did the labor back when it
2:47:16
was only a few people and stuff
2:47:18
like that. But ultimately, a
2:47:21
business like any social phenomenon has
2:47:23
to be constantly recreated in order
2:47:25
to exist. And the people
2:47:27
who do the work that makes it.
2:47:29
more than just like a room full of
2:47:31
garbage, RS. And a
2:47:33
lot of the like regulars recognize that.
2:47:35
And a lot of them, you
2:47:38
know, flip me off as they cross
2:47:40
the text line, whatever. I
2:47:45
think this is a good place to
2:47:47
sort of start coming to a close.
2:47:49
This is a fundamental question about what
2:47:51
the nature of our society is going
2:47:53
to be, right? Like, is
2:47:55
the fundamental nature of our society
2:47:58
that a community is a bunch of people
2:48:00
who buy things and a bunch of people
2:48:02
who make money from you buying things and
2:48:04
who make money from the labor that you
2:48:06
do, right? And then take credit
2:48:08
for the labor and take credit both financially for
2:48:10
the labor and in public for the labor, right? Is
2:48:13
our society going to just be a bunch
2:48:15
of pure commercial relations where a bunch of
2:48:17
people get very, very rich off the labor
2:48:19
of everyone else in the society and get
2:48:21
to rule them as sort of like these
2:48:24
petty tyrant kings? Or is
2:48:26
it going to be a society where
2:48:28
the people who produce the society control
2:48:30
it, right? And that society
2:48:32
is a democratic society, is a
2:48:34
egalitarian society, is a society where people
2:48:36
are free to do the things that
2:48:38
they need to do and people are
2:48:40
free to have a life where they
2:48:43
can fucking pay for their groceries, right?
2:48:45
Where they're not forced to go
2:48:47
to the market for all of the
2:48:49
things that they need to... live where
2:48:51
you can survive in a way that
2:48:53
doesn't involve like subjecting yourself to
2:48:55
just a tyrant for like a third
2:48:57
of your life. Yeah, where like the
2:48:59
place that you spend like a third
2:49:01
of your life is a place
2:49:03
where you actually have like dignity. Yeah,
2:49:05
dignity and freedom and where you don't
2:49:07
have to go home at the
2:49:09
end of a day of making your
2:49:12
boss money, worrying about whether you're going
2:49:14
to be able to eat or not.
2:49:17
And that's also a society that
2:49:19
does not involve, again, at
2:49:21
the very highest level, like
2:49:23
you getting thrown into prison camps
2:49:25
because your God King hates you. And
2:49:28
we can do this. We can
2:49:30
live in that society. Yeah. The demands
2:49:32
are not that crazy. No.
2:49:35
And that's like the thing that
2:49:37
we've encountered over and over
2:49:39
again is this constant push and
2:49:41
pull of people saying that
2:49:43
like the expectation of bettering our
2:49:45
conditions whether it be like
2:49:47
us on the picket line, just trying
2:49:50
to get like a stable wage and
2:49:52
just cause employment and stuff like that,
2:49:54
or whether it be, you know, those
2:49:56
larger societal changes that like you're talking
2:49:58
about, you just butt up against these
2:50:00
people who have such like a paucity
2:50:02
of imagination about what's possible. Yeah. And
2:50:04
like about the legitimacy of
2:50:06
trying to make something better. The
2:50:09
legitimacy of saying, sure,
2:50:11
I can subsist on this,
2:50:13
but yeah. There's so
2:50:15
much more that's possible. Yeah. So
2:50:18
I maintain that there's something more
2:50:20
that's possible. Yeah. I think
2:50:22
it's possible too. And that's the thing about
2:50:24
this world, right? Is that our enemies
2:50:26
have figured out that it actually can change.
2:50:28
Mm -hmm. That's why they have to fight
2:50:30
so hard. Yeah. But the thing is, the fact that it can
2:50:32
change for the worse also means that it can change for
2:50:34
the better. Oh, beautiful stuff. Okay. Where
2:50:36
can people find your strike fund to also
2:50:38
put it in the description? Oh, yeah.
2:50:40
Great. So it's on GoFundMe. I'll
2:50:42
send you the link and it'll
2:50:45
be down there. But also
2:50:47
people can hit up our
2:50:49
union Instagram. It's
2:50:51
a urban or workers with underscores between
2:50:53
the words urban underscore or underscore worker
2:50:55
that we've got the link to like
2:50:57
strike fund and also hey if you're
2:50:59
if you're in Berkeley you can sign
2:51:01
up for a big shift and you
2:51:03
get to enjoy listening to me discourse
2:51:06
for nine hours instead of One. It's
2:51:08
great. It's fun. Pickets are cool and
2:51:10
good. If you haven't been on one,
2:51:12
you should go on one. They're great.
2:51:14
They're great. Yeah. It's
2:51:16
a good time. Wasn't
2:51:35
that delicious? So good. Your
2:51:37
bill, ladies? I got it. No,
2:51:39
I got it. Seriously,
2:51:41
I insist. I insisted first. Oh,
2:51:43
don't be silly. You don't be
2:51:45
silly. People with the Wells Fargo
2:51:47
Active Cash Credit Card prefer to
2:51:49
pay because they earn unlimited 2
2:51:51
% cash back on purchases. OK.
2:51:53
Rock, paper, scissors for it. Rock,
2:51:55
paper, scissors. Shoot. No! The
2:51:57
Wells Fargo Active Cash
2:52:00
Credit Card. Visit wellsfargo.com slash
2:52:02
activecash terms apply. Does
2:52:04
this podcast make you happy? Of
2:52:06
course it does. That's why you're
2:52:08
here. But it only comes out
2:52:10
once a week. For happiness every
2:52:13
night, you need Adam and Eve.
2:52:15
Yes, I'm talking about sex toys.
2:52:18
It's cool. It's cool. You have earbuds in, right? Adam
2:52:21
and Eve, America's most trusted source
2:52:23
for adult products, has been making
2:52:25
people very happy for over 50
2:52:27
years, with thousands of toys for
2:52:29
both men and women. Just go
2:52:31
to adamany.com now and enter code
2:52:33
I heart for 50 % off
2:52:35
almost any one item plus free
2:52:37
discreet shipping that's adamany.com code I
2:52:39
heart for 50 % off. Because
2:52:59
today is where it's all happening. We
2:53:01
get the best start to every
2:53:03
morning because we started together. Watch the
2:53:05
Today Show with Savannah Guthrie and
2:53:07
Craig Melvin weekdays at 7 a .m.
2:53:10
on NBC. You're a
2:53:12
hustler. You get things done, but you don't
2:53:14
always do things for yourself. With
2:53:16
JLo Beauty, it takes just a few
2:53:18
minutes a day to look like facials
2:53:20
are a regular part of your routine.
2:53:22
JLo Beauty's fresh and flawless skincare kit
2:53:24
includes six skincare products that work as
2:53:27
hard as you do. They'll hustle to
2:53:29
brighten, firm, and hydrate your complexion morning
2:53:31
and night. This skincare kit is a
2:53:33
one and done solution that is clinically
2:53:35
proven to visibly tighten and lift for
2:53:37
instant and long lasting results. Cleanse,
2:53:39
treat, moisturize, protect. The fresh and
2:53:42
flawless skincare kit does it all.
2:53:44
See why the kit's a best
2:53:46
seller today. Visit JLObeauty.com slash Deluxe
2:53:48
and get an extra 25 %
2:53:50
off your first shipment plus free
2:53:52
gifts with code Deluxe. If you're
2:53:54
not satisfied, return the bottles within
2:53:56
60 days for your money back.
2:53:59
See the website for details. That's
2:54:01
JLObeauty.com slash Deluxe to get
2:54:03
that J -LowGlo. This
2:54:10
is, it could happen here, Executive
2:54:12
Disorder, our weekly newscast covering what's happening
2:54:14
in the White House, the crumbling
2:54:16
world and what it means for you.
2:54:19
I'm Garrison Davis. Today I'm
2:54:21
joined by Dr. James Stout
2:54:23
and Reverend Dr. The Honorable
2:54:25
Robert Evans. That's right.
2:54:27
That's right. Reverend Dr. The Honorable
2:54:29
Evans, who is currently hacking up
2:54:32
a fucking lung. No
2:54:34
idea why. I feel otherwise
2:54:36
fine. Well, I'm sure you
2:54:38
feel otherwise fine due to this great
2:54:40
week in American history we've all
2:54:42
been through together. Yeah. Which
2:54:44
started... with a meeting between
2:54:47
President Donald Trump and El
2:54:49
Salvador President Buquele on Monday
2:54:51
morning in the Oval Office,
2:54:53
where they discussed the possibility
2:54:55
of the United States helping
2:54:57
to build more Seacot -style facilities
2:54:59
to disappear U .S. citizens
2:55:02
and immigrants that the Trump
2:55:04
administration deems criminals or terrorists. Yes.
2:55:08
I mean, I keep getting asked, is
2:55:10
this the panic moment? And I
2:55:12
don't think panic. is particularly productive. But
2:55:14
like, yeah, this is the worst
2:55:16
case scenario. The worst case scenario is
2:55:18
happening. The president's talking about sending
2:55:20
citizens overseas to a concentration camp. Honestly,
2:55:23
I'm on the verge of thinking it's
2:55:25
okay to call it a death camp, but
2:55:27
we just don't have the data yet.
2:55:29
There's some very concerning satellite shots that appear
2:55:31
to show piles of bodies. Yeah,
2:55:33
that's from March of 2024. Yeah.
2:55:35
Yeah. I mean, yeah, but it won't have
2:55:37
gotten better. No, no. Yeah.
2:55:39
Yeah. So, I don't know.
2:55:41
This is about as bad as it could
2:55:43
be, folks. We're in
2:55:45
it. During that meeting, both President
2:55:47
Bukele and the Trump Cabinet argued that
2:55:50
there is simply no way for
2:55:52
people sent to see God to ever
2:55:54
return to the United States, coming
2:55:56
up with a whole bunch of absurd
2:55:58
reasons for why is impossible due
2:56:00
to foreign policy and safety of both
2:56:02
El Salvador and the United States.
2:56:04
Me and James did a whole episode
2:56:06
on this earlier this week that
2:56:08
you can check out on the It
2:56:11
Could Happen Here feed. I'm
2:56:13
going to move on to
2:56:15
an update on the student crackdowns.
2:56:18
So ICE has targeted a
2:56:20
third green card holder
2:56:23
for deportation based on pro
2:56:25
-Palestinian activism. Mohozen
2:56:27
Marui is a Palestinian from the West
2:56:29
Bank who has lived in the US
2:56:31
with a green card for a decade.
2:56:34
While studying philosophy at Columbia,
2:56:36
he co -founded the Columbia -Palestinian
2:56:38
Student Union in 2023 with
2:56:40
Mahmoud Khalil. Madawi
2:56:43
was arrested by ICE last
2:56:45
Monday, April 14th, at
2:56:47
his citizenship interview in Vermont.
2:56:50
Now, after Khalil was arrested last
2:56:52
month, Madawi went into hiding,
2:56:54
and he suspected that this citizenship
2:56:56
interview could be a honeypot, but
2:56:58
decided to go anyway after waiting
2:57:00
a long time for this appointment.
2:57:03
His lawyers quickly filed a habeas corpus
2:57:05
petition, arguing his detention is unlawful and
2:57:07
violates the First Amendment. A
2:57:09
U .S. district judge issued an order
2:57:11
hours later that he was, quote,
2:57:13
not to be removed from the United
2:57:15
States or moved out of the
2:57:17
territory of the district of Vermont, pending
2:57:19
further order of this court. Zionist
2:57:22
doxing accounts targeted Marui
2:57:24
in recent weeks. I'm
2:57:27
going to play, actually, this
2:57:29
two -minute clip of Marui talking. This
2:57:32
is from December of
2:57:34
2023 on the program
2:57:36
60 Minutes. What was
2:57:38
your initial reaction when
2:57:40
you heard about the
2:57:42
Hamas attack on October
2:57:44
7th? I could not
2:57:46
believe what my eyes
2:57:48
were seeing. Where I
2:57:50
see Hamas members getting
2:57:52
into settlements and so
2:57:54
on. But also the
2:57:56
first moment I saw that I put my
2:57:58
hand on my heart. And
2:58:02
I started praying knowing
2:58:04
that there will be a
2:58:06
huge level of revenge
2:58:08
from the Israelis. And
2:58:10
I was praying that this
2:58:12
will not be the result
2:58:15
because it would be disastrous.
2:58:18
The night of the rally,
2:58:20
I believe someone in
2:58:22
the crowd said something very
2:58:24
anti. Jewish, not
2:58:27
just anti -Israeli, but
2:58:29
anti -Jewish. Yes. This
2:58:31
was a walkout on
2:58:33
November 9th. And
2:58:35
a person who's not
2:58:37
affiliated with Colombia,
2:58:39
we've never seen him.
2:58:42
We don't know who is
2:58:44
this guy, comes down
2:58:47
the stairs, yelling, death to
2:58:49
Jews. I
2:58:52
was shocked. And
2:58:54
they walked directly to the
2:58:56
person and they told him,
2:58:58
you don't represent us because
2:59:00
this is not something that
2:59:02
we agree with. And directly
2:59:04
what I've done, I
2:59:06
took the megaphone and they
2:59:08
gave a speech and they
2:59:10
said, we here are conscious,
2:59:12
educated students and we know
2:59:14
how to separate right from
2:59:16
wrong. And what this
2:59:18
guy has said
2:59:21
is wrong. What
2:59:23
this guy has
2:59:25
said is clearly anti
2:59:27
-semitic against Jews anti
2:59:29
-semitic to be anti
2:59:31
-semitic is unjust is
2:59:33
unjust and the
2:59:35
fight for the freedom
2:59:37
of Palestine and
2:59:39
the fight against anti
2:59:41
-semitism go hand in
2:59:43
hand because injustice
2:59:45
anywhere is a threat
2:59:47
to justice everywhere
2:59:49
Yeah, I mean He
2:59:51
said everything That would make
2:59:53
him a respectable Protester at
2:59:55
least based on like what
2:59:57
the fucking dims were saying
2:59:59
last
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More