The Good: The friendship between the two main characters is fantastic and the show's best example of positive masculinity is in their platonic affection for each other, especially since one of them is gay. Their banter is fun and their closeness develops organically. Some of the friendship/found family moments outside of this relationship are also pretty solid. Half the townsfolk are endearing and some are even interesting. The production and voice acting are solid. Sometimes the show nails drama and character conflict in a way that kept me invested. Some of the supernatural shenanigans (Jack-in-the-Box Jesus, werewolf puppies) are fun. Problematic elements (mentioned below) improve over time.The Bad: The show ends on a huge cliffhanger after 100 episodes, with several unresolved plot threads. The show's adherence to its framing device ruins some of the tension, as characters will be in danger at the end of some episodes and two weeks later they're fine. It also calls into question why certain things are being discussed on air. The other half of the townsfolk are annoying, though the worst ones don't show up as much past episode 40. Miscommunication runs rampant, creating some manufactured drama. Nowhere is this more apparent than in main character Ben, who is likeable 60% of the time and insufferable the rest, though he grows over time (with occasional moments of regression). The main romance (Ben and Emily), which has sweet moments, would be more enjoyable if it started with more subtlety and it didn't seem like it existed for Ben's benefit more than Emily's. The show's problematic elements - an offensive portrayal of Native American culture (skinwalkers), Incredibly Super Hot Love Interest Emily being unable to exist without someone commenting on her physical appearance, a sexist character who isn't called out soon enough and other male entitlement, and a character who exists for racist Shock Value humor - cast a shadow over the show's good intentions.