Commitment vs. Compatibility: Are You in the Right Relationship?

Commitment vs. Compatibility: Are You in the Right Relationship?

Released Thursday, 6th March 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Commitment vs. Compatibility: Are You in the Right Relationship?

Commitment vs. Compatibility: Are You in the Right Relationship?

Commitment vs. Compatibility: Are You in the Right Relationship?

Commitment vs. Compatibility: Are You in the Right Relationship?

Thursday, 6th March 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:04

Hello and welcome to the Let's

0:06

Talk Attachments podcast. My name is

0:08

Jessica De Silva and I

0:10

am a licensed marriage and family

0:12

therapist and an attachment coach

0:14

helping adults and their unhealthy dating

0:17

patterns and create stronger, secure

0:19

relationships. Attachment Theory gives

0:21

us insight into how we

0:23

currently experience love through understanding

0:25

our earlier attachment dynamics. I

0:27

created this podcast as a

0:30

safe space to share stories

0:32

and insights on different aspects

0:34

of attachment so that you can better

0:36

understand how this manifests in your

0:38

own life. My only request is

0:40

that you listen with an open

0:42

heart and an open mind. So

0:45

without further ado, let's get into

0:47

it. and

0:57

welcome to today's

0:59

podcast episode on commitment

1:01

versus compatibility, a

1:03

topic that hits incredibly close

1:06

to home for me. So, you

1:09

know, towards the end of

1:11

my nearly seven year relationship,

1:13

I was forcefully confronted with this

1:15

reality in a way I could

1:17

no longer ignore. And when I

1:20

say forcefully, I mean, my body

1:22

literally started shutting down. I had

1:24

debilitating back pain that left me

1:26

stuck in bed for weeks at

1:28

a time, gained tons of weight

1:30

from all the steroid treatments that

1:33

I was doing for the pain.

1:35

I fell into a deep depression,

1:37

feeling so incredibly stuck in my

1:39

life. And during this time,

1:41

I was engaged. I

1:44

was engaged to my ex, we

1:46

were living in Colorado and wrapping

1:48

up the final touches on the

1:50

home that we were building together,

1:52

a home that I once thought

1:54

symbolized our happy future, yet

1:56

now felt like a place where

1:59

I was losing myself.

2:01

And for years, I had

2:03

clung to the belief that once

2:06

we finished this project, everything

2:08

would feel right again. I

2:10

thought that if I had just

2:12

followed through with our plans, committing through

2:14

those plans, I'd finally feel a

2:16

sense of connection. in

2:18

the relationship. But when that

2:20

moment finally arrived, we

2:22

were at the last task,

2:25

that last task of

2:27

just painting the floor and

2:29

really setting that foundation

2:31

for our house, I

2:33

realized that nothing changed. nothing changed.

2:35

And that's when I had

2:37

to ask myself the question I

2:39

had been avoiding. You

2:41

know, is this actually the

2:43

right relationship for me? And

2:46

am I the right person for him?

2:48

And I wasn't necessarily It's

2:50

not that this question never

2:52

came up for me, it did,

2:54

but I really just chose

2:56

to stay committed rather than kind

2:58

of question the compatibility. So

3:01

I gave more focus and more

3:03

attention to the commitment versus

3:05

to really questioning our compatibility. And

3:08

commitment isn't enough without

3:10

compatibility. The conclusion was

3:12

that commitment isn't enough

3:14

without compatibility. So for

3:17

so long, you know,

3:19

I questioned my commitment. whether

3:21

I was trying hard enough, if

3:23

I was giving enough, if I

3:25

was being a good enough partner,

3:27

and this is the stuff that

3:29

I preach about. This is the

3:31

stuff that I preach about in

3:33

my work. So what kind of

3:35

therapist or coach would I be

3:38

if I didn't give it my

3:40

all, if I didn't quite literally

3:42

break my back to make this

3:44

relationship work? And boy was that

3:46

a lesson in itself. And honestly, I

3:49

could say the same for

3:51

him. In his defense, he

3:53

tried in his own ways

3:55

and to the capacity that

3:57

he could to meet my

3:59

needs. And that's the reality

4:01

is that we can only

4:03

do what we're able to

4:05

do. And eventually I stopped

4:07

asking, am I committed? And

4:09

started asking, are we actually

4:11

compatible? Because love

4:13

alone wasn't enough. History

4:16

and deep care weren't

4:18

enough. I realized that

4:20

true sustainable relationships require

4:22

shared values, emotional alignment,

4:24

mutual effort and attunement.

4:26

And when I took

4:29

a hard look at

4:31

our relationship, I really

4:33

saw this misalignment. On the surface,

4:35

you know, we had so much in common. A

4:38

love for travel, adventure, we

4:40

really... craved and

4:43

valued freedom. Some

4:45

of my best memories with him

4:47

were on the road, you know,

4:49

in his camper experiencing new places

4:51

together. And that sense of excitement

4:53

really bonding us, you know, it

4:55

made us dream really big and

4:57

plan a future where we'd build,

4:59

you know, our own expedition vehicle

5:01

and travel around the world. But

5:03

underneath that shared vision, our

5:06

emotional needs were worlds

5:08

apart. And one of the

5:10

biggest lessons I learned

5:12

is that just because someone

5:14

supports the emotional work

5:16

you do doesn't mean they

5:18

value or practice it

5:20

themselves. My ex was always

5:22

so encouraging of my

5:24

therapy and my coaching work,

5:26

but he never engaged

5:28

in that work himself. He

5:31

was incredibly self -aware on

5:33

an intellectual level, but when

5:35

it came to emotional vulnerability

5:37

and emotional growth, it was

5:39

a different story. It just

5:41

wasn't important to him. So

5:43

for a long time, you

5:46

know, I respected his emotional

5:48

boundaries. But what I failed

5:50

to acknowledge was how much

5:52

I actually needed emotional depth

5:54

in a relationship. You know,

5:56

I craved attunement and deeper

5:58

connection and a desire to

6:00

grow. on an emotional

6:02

and relational level and I wasn't

6:04

getting it. And where he felt

6:07

as though he was carrying a

6:09

lot of the physical weight of

6:11

the relationship, working on the house

6:13

and making sure we had a

6:15

heater and we had walls and

6:17

we had insulation and our shelter

6:19

needs were met. I

6:22

was carrying the emotional weight

6:24

and making sure our emotional

6:26

needs were being met. And

6:28

soon I felt like I was almost

6:30

doing both in a sense, right? When things

6:32

got rocky, well, let me pick up

6:34

the slack here. You're unhappy with work. Well,

6:36

let me take care of these bills. You

6:39

know, we're having issues with

6:41

these things. Well, let me

6:43

do more and let me

6:45

do more and more and

6:47

more, you know, overly emphasizing.

6:49

my commitment to the relationship

6:51

and overriding my own emotional

6:53

well -being and happiness. And

6:55

that's my fault, right? That

6:57

is completely and entirely my

6:59

fault and tapping into my

7:01

own codependency issues where I

7:03

wasn't setting boundaries and wasn't

7:05

creating realistic expectations for the

7:07

relationship. Okay, so we got

7:09

to take accountability for our

7:11

own doing in the relationship. I

7:14

also started to realize that, you

7:16

know, while we both valued freedom

7:18

and we, you know, value travel

7:20

and adventure, our motivations

7:22

behind those desires were

7:24

very different. For him,

7:26

it was about hyper

7:28

independence, right? Not

7:30

being tied to one place,

7:33

having that total autonomy

7:35

and escaping, you know, the

7:37

structure of a normal

7:39

life. For me, it was

7:42

about deepening our connection,

7:44

creating a shared experience, feeling

7:46

bonded with each other,

7:48

creating more closeness in our

7:51

relationship. So clearly, you

7:53

guys, I really, really do

7:55

value relational closeness and

7:57

bonding through being together

7:59

and getting to know each other

8:01

and connecting on more of

8:03

an emotional level. So just two

8:06

different motivations for our goals

8:08

and for the values that we

8:10

both shared. And at

8:12

first, I convinced myself that

8:14

If we just got back to

8:16

traveling, I'd finally feel the closeness

8:18

that I was longing for. But

8:20

eventually I had to face the

8:22

truth that I would never receive

8:24

the connection that I craved from

8:27

him because he hadn't built that

8:29

connection with himself, right?

8:31

We can only meet people

8:33

as deeply as we've met

8:35

ourselves and we can't force

8:37

that process onto anyone. It

8:39

is time, you guys. It

8:42

is time to actually put this

8:44

information into practice, no more

8:46

just talking about your attachment problems,

8:48

but actually doing something about

8:50

them. So if you are ready

8:52

to learn practical evidence -based strategies

8:55

to change your insecure ways

8:57

of thinking, feeling and behaving, I

8:59

am now taking on one -on

9:01

-one attachment coaching clients where we

9:03

will work closely to address

9:06

your self -sabotaging patterns, create your

9:08

secure self blueprint and teach you

9:10

the methods to navigate your

9:12

dating or relationship challenges in healthier

9:14

ways that create authentic and

9:16

fulfilling connections. To learn more, you

9:19

can book a free clarity

9:21

call with me via the link

9:23

in my show notes or

9:25

by visiting Jessica to Silva coaching

9:27

.com. And the hard

9:29

part is, you know, I could

9:32

have stayed in that relationship. I

9:34

could have waited for this change

9:36

to possibly happen. And

9:38

despite our differences, you know, I

9:40

could have kept going because in many

9:42

ways it was really comfortable. You

9:44

know, he was a good person. He

9:46

was kind. He was well -intentioned. He was

9:48

caring. You know,

9:50

we had love and support for

9:53

each other. We had built a

9:55

life together, but deep down, I

9:57

knew that staying meant sacrificing the

9:59

emotional depth and connection that I

10:01

truly needed. Also the emotional support

10:03

that I needed because I felt

10:06

like I was carrying all of

10:08

that relationship weight and all of

10:10

that relationship responsibility. And that just

10:12

wasn't fair. It wasn't fair. And

10:14

for a long time, you know,

10:16

I wasn't ready to accept. It

10:19

wasn't ready to accept that I

10:21

was kind of carrying all of

10:23

that. just

10:26

wanting to believe that things could get

10:28

better and that he could change. So

10:31

this is why getting

10:33

clear on values beyond just

10:36

commitment is important. This

10:38

experience taught me how

10:40

crucial it is to define

10:42

what our values actually

10:44

mean to us. So

10:46

if you say you value marriage,

10:48

what does that look like

10:50

for you? If you say you

10:53

value growth, what does that

10:55

mean in practice? If you

10:57

say you value adventure or

10:59

connection or financial stability, even how

11:01

do those things align in

11:03

your daily life? Because two people

11:06

can claim to share the

11:08

same values, but if their interpretations

11:10

of those values are completely

11:12

different, the relationship will eventually feel

11:14

misaligned and unsustainable, right? You're

11:17

going to have a lot of

11:19

clashing. a lot of

11:21

conflict. So commitment

11:23

alone doesn't make

11:25

a relationship work. Love

11:28

alone isn't enough. If

11:31

you find yourself questioning the

11:33

relationship, I really encourage you

11:35

to shift the focus from

11:37

commitment to compatibility and really

11:39

ask yourself, do we

11:41

truly align? in what matters

11:43

most? Do I feel

11:45

deeply seen and heard and

11:48

supported, right? Do I

11:50

feel supported in this relationship? Am

11:52

I here out of

11:54

mutual reciprocity or out of

11:56

obligation and a fear

11:58

of change? Because at

12:00

the end of the day, a

12:03

relationship should feel like a place

12:05

where you can grow, not a

12:07

place where you feel stuck. And

12:09

for many of us with insecure

12:11

attachment, whether you have anxious dismissive

12:13

avoidant or fearful avoidant or any

12:16

variation of those, it can be

12:18

difficult to distinguish whether our feelings

12:20

are coming from our own insecurities

12:22

or if they're rooted in valid

12:24

concerns about the relationship. But here's

12:26

the truth. Your feelings

12:28

are always valid. They're always

12:31

telling you whether your needs

12:33

are being met or not.

12:35

And from a scientific perspective,

12:37

if our needs aren't being met,

12:39

we aren't happy people, right?

12:42

The state of our well -being

12:44

is directly tied to whether

12:46

our emotional needs are being fulfilled

12:48

and our physical needs, of

12:50

course. So the more you

12:52

tune into your feelings and your

12:54

needs, the better you can assess

12:57

how your relationship is affecting your

12:59

overall happiness and sense of security.

13:01

So I'm going to say that

13:03

one more time. The more you

13:05

tune in to your feelings and

13:07

needs, the better you can assess

13:09

how your relationship is affecting your

13:11

overall happiness and sense of security.

13:13

And don't wait to learn the

13:15

way I did, right? Please don't

13:18

wait to learn the way I

13:20

did. But that might be your

13:22

own journey, right? You might have

13:24

to go through that path and

13:26

through that experience to learn in

13:28

your own way. I know that's

13:30

definitely. my own process.

13:32

People can tell me all sorts of things

13:34

and I just kind of have to experience

13:36

it on my own to really gain the

13:38

wisdom myself. But just know

13:40

that, you know, circumstances

13:43

are never an excuse for

13:45

a lack of connection. And,

13:47

you know, if someone isn't

13:49

emotionally or mentally where you

13:51

need them to be, Take

13:53

that at face value. Don't

13:55

hold onto the hope of

13:57

a future when, right? When

13:59

they change, when things improve,

14:02

when circumstances get better. Just know

14:04

that your time is precious And

14:07

though it may take, you

14:09

know, it take time for you

14:11

to find someone who is

14:13

more comparably aligned with your needs,

14:15

it's ultimately worth the wait.

14:18

Okay. So that's all I got

14:20

for you today. If this

14:22

was insightful, please leave a rating

14:24

or review. I can't express

14:26

enough how helpful your encouragement is.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features