E203. Why Paternity Leave is Failing Families

E203. Why Paternity Leave is Failing Families

Released Monday, 28th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
E203. Why Paternity Leave is Failing Families

E203. Why Paternity Leave is Failing Families

E203. Why Paternity Leave is Failing Families

E203. Why Paternity Leave is Failing Families

Monday, 28th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Savings are in the air and at Ross,

0:02

where they have savings on all the

0:04

brands you love. From the latest fashion to

0:06

outdoor decor and even pet supplies, savings

0:08

are in every aisle. Go to Ross and

0:10

save 20 to 60 % off other retailers'

0:13

prices on your favorite spring finds. Calling

0:16

hard seltzer lovers. Searching

0:18

for the tastiest seltzer? Look

0:20

no further. Neutral vodka seltzer

0:22

is absolutely delicious. Made

0:24

with real vodka and real

0:27

juice, neutral keeps it tasty with

0:29

every sip. With flavors like

0:31

pineapple, watermelon, orange, and lime, there's

0:33

something for everyone. Neutral. Keep

0:35

it tasty. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2025,

0:37

Anheuser -Busch. Neutral flavored vodka and

0:39

carbonation, 4 .5 % alcohol by

0:42

volume, St. Louis, Missouri. are

0:53

supported in their role

0:55

as fathers because traditional gender

0:57

norms still often place

0:59

in primary caregiving focuses on

1:01

mothers. This week I'm

1:04

joined by Alex Lloyd Hunter,

1:06

a UK -based advocate. but

1:08

improved paternity leave and

1:10

co -founder of the dad

1:12

ship. We are the worst in Europe when

1:14

it comes to paternity leave. We are really

1:16

out of step with how I think we see

1:18

ourselves as a country and our values around

1:20

gender equality and it's well past time we changed.

1:22

For most of our children's life we know them as

1:24

adults. It's a very short amount of time that we

1:27

know them as children and I guess it plays into

1:29

that good old phrase if you kind of don't know

1:31

what you've got till it's gone. Most police

1:33

officers get the first week at full pay

1:35

but the second week is at statutory pay

1:37

and they just Most of them just can't

1:39

afford it, so 60 % are going back

1:41

up to just one week. Hello, I'm Pip,

1:43

and welcome to the Midwife Pip

1:45

Podcast, the home of expert information

1:47

and real chats on all things

1:49

pregnancy, birth, and

1:51

beyond. Many dads

1:53

feel undersupported in their

1:56

role as fathers because

1:58

traditional gender norms still

2:00

often place in primary

2:02

caregiving focuses on mothers.

2:05

While times are slowly changing,

2:07

many workplaces still offer

2:10

limited paternity leave, making

2:12

it difficult for dads to bond

2:14

with their newborns in those crucial

2:16

early weeks. Even when

2:18

paternity leave is available, there

2:20

can be pressure, either social

2:22

or professional, to return to

2:24

work quickly, reinforcing the outdated

2:26

idea that a father's primary

2:28

role is financial rather than

2:31

emotional. Without strong support

2:33

systems from employers to

2:35

parenting communities, many

2:37

dads struggle to feel included and

2:39

confident in their role, missing

2:41

out on key bonding opportunities that

2:43

are so important for them

2:46

both and also for their children.

2:49

This week, I'm joined by

2:51

Alex Lloyd Hunter, a

2:53

UK -based advocate for improved

2:55

paternity leave and co -founder

2:57

of the Dad Shift, an

2:59

organisation dedicated to campaigning

3:01

for better paternity leave policies

3:04

in the UK. After

3:06

becoming a dad, he recognised

3:08

the significant barriers that limited father's

3:10

involvement in bonding and caring

3:13

for their family. the

3:15

UK statutory paternity leave

3:17

offers just two weeks at a

3:19

rate of £184 a week, one

3:22

of the least supportive

3:24

systems in Europe. So

3:26

welcome Alex and thank you

3:28

for the important work you're

3:30

doing to raise the fact that this just

3:32

isn't good enough is it? No well

3:34

thank you for having me. No it's not good

3:36

enough at all. As you say we are the

3:38

worst in Europe. When it comes to paternity leave

3:40

we are really out of step with

3:42

how I think we see ourselves as a

3:44

country and our values around gender equality and

3:46

and it's well past time we changed so

3:48

that's what we're trying to do. Yes

3:51

literally shout that from the rooftops

3:53

this is what we need. Now

3:55

I mean perhaps it sounds it

3:57

sounds obvious to me why Alex

3:59

but tell us what led to the

4:01

dad shift being born because this is

4:03

clearly a massive passion project of yours. Yes,

4:07

it is. So I have a son. He's

4:09

just turned three. I'm going to have another

4:11

one on the way too. Oh,

4:13

congratulations. I didn't know that. No,

4:15

it's due in August. So

4:17

we're just about 21 weeks. So

4:20

that's exciting. And my

4:22

co -founder George has had a baby

4:24

three days ago. So we're very on

4:26

brand. We're all in the baby

4:28

moon. Yeah. Yeah,

4:30

I have a son who's

4:33

three and I was always very clear

4:37

when I when I became a parent I wanted to

4:39

be really active dad and I wanted to try and

4:41

do things as equally as possible with my wife

4:43

both so that she can carry on in her career

4:45

she does awesome stuff and we wanted to make sure

4:47

she could keep doing that but also

4:49

so that I got that joy

4:52

of being a big part of my son's life

4:54

and he had that bond with me and that

4:56

was particularly important to me because my dad really

4:58

didn't get that with us when we were younger

5:00

he I see men of his generation there was

5:02

no paternity leave at all So my brother

5:04

was born nine o 'clock Sunday night, he was back

5:06

at work 9am the next day. And he worked

5:09

in a really stressful job, really long hours, didn't

5:11

really see us five days a week, wasn't involved

5:13

in our care. And as a result, he ended

5:15

up, we didn't really bond with him as we

5:17

did with our mum, he ended up kind of

5:19

the outside of the family unit. And

5:21

it contributed to the breakdown of his

5:23

marriage ultimately. And he's now,

5:26

we have a good relationship as adults

5:28

and he's a very devoted soppy. grandparent

5:30

to my son in some ways to

5:32

my surprise and it's given us a

5:34

lens to start talking about his own

5:36

experience and he deeply regrets that he

5:38

wasn't more there and more able to

5:40

be there but he said you know

5:42

I didn't know anything different I didn't

5:44

know you could be different and I

5:46

think our attitudes of a society have

5:48

changed but a lot of the systems and

5:50

the barriers that make it hard for men to

5:52

be there are still in place and that

5:54

is still too often the experience of men

5:57

And so in trying to do things as equally

5:59

as possible and trying to be involved as I could, we've

6:02

been lucky that we've made it work.

6:04

But there are so many jigsaw places

6:06

that have to fall in place to

6:08

make it possible in this country because

6:10

we have all these things pushing against

6:12

more equal parenting. So really expensive childcare,

6:14

lack of flexible working. And then obviously

6:16

a big one is our rubbish

6:18

paternity leave that ends up pushing

6:20

the responsibility to look after children pretty

6:22

much solely onto mothers. Yeah

6:25

100 % how powerful of your dad

6:27

how brave because like we say today's

6:29

generation I feel like and I

6:31

don't want to speak for men but

6:33

I feel like we are more

6:35

open to talking about mental health and

6:37

gendered roles in a more dynamic

6:39

flexible way I know there's work to

6:41

be done but when I think

6:43

back to sort of my my father's

6:45

generation versus my husband I know

6:47

that for my dad actually those conversations

6:50

are really hard and for your

6:52

dad to say actually he regrets not

6:54

having more of a caring responsibility. I think

6:56

it's really brave. I agree and

6:58

you know we've talked before I launched this

7:00

campaign we started talking about it explicitly

7:02

because know people are gonna ask why am I

7:04

doing this and I can say something else if

7:06

you want but like this is the real reason

7:08

he was like yeah fine say it like talk

7:10

about it you know I really respect him for that

7:13

but he's willing to be open about it and willing

7:15

for me to be open about it. Definitely,

7:17

I think if we can have like, I

7:19

don't know how many grandparents listen to

7:21

my podcast Alex, but I want them to

7:23

listen to this one because I feel

7:25

like if they can have these conversations with

7:27

their adult sons, that actually this was

7:29

their journey and this is what they then

7:31

regret, we can start planting that seed,

7:33

can't we have changed really early? Yeah,

7:36

for sure. And I

7:38

mean, interestingly I've had... isn't

7:40

the only, the conversation with him isn't the only

7:42

one I've had with men of his generation and other

7:44

elements I've seen and I think there is a, I

7:47

mean I'd be loved to maybe have listened

7:50

to your show or write in or call

7:52

in and tell you about it but I

7:54

suspect that as men get older they realise

7:56

that the thing that really mattered in their

7:58

life was their kids and their relationship with

8:00

their kids and

8:02

they, I suspect it's

8:04

probably more common than we recognise for people

8:06

to regret that they didn't have that. Completely

8:09

agree it must be and I saw something

8:11

on social media a few weeks ago that

8:13

said that we we only have For most

8:15

of our children's life. We know them as

8:18

adults It's a very short amount of time

8:20

that we know them as children And I

8:22

guess it plays into that good old phrase

8:24

if you kind of don't know what you've

8:26

got till it's gone Yeah, so for you

8:28

know now now as your dad is a

8:30

grandparent actually seeing that kind of that almost

8:32

polar view of actually I missed these days

8:34

with you know my young family and almost

8:36

I guess trying to perhaps relive them as

8:38

a grandchild as a grandparent. yeah

8:40

I think that's exactly it and he's you

8:42

know he's lucky he's got my my son

8:44

and then his wife has got a few

8:46

grandkids as well and they're they're devoted to

8:48

him as well you know they and so

8:50

he has I see him having that bond

8:52

with these young kids that I think he

8:54

didn't have so that's really nice yeah he's he's

8:56

getting it in now how bad

8:58

is it Alex how bad is the

9:01

UK paternity system compared to maybe

9:03

other countries where it's being done better

9:06

It's very bad. So again, it's two weeks,

9:08

184 pounds a week. In fact, in

9:10

a couple of days, it's going up to

9:12

187 pounds a week. Oh, pay rise.

9:14

Yeah, we're cashing in. We're cashing I don't

9:16

think you can even get a coffee

9:18

for three pounds. Exactly. Exactly.

9:21

That's true, you can't. So

9:23

yeah, 184 pounds a week, that is

9:26

187. That's less than half a minimum

9:28

wage, technically below the level of poverty

9:30

pay. Wow. And

9:32

by comparison, the average

9:34

across Europe is the equivalent

9:36

of eight weeks at full pay. So

9:39

if you take our two weeks at £184 a week

9:41

and compare it to the average salary, it

9:43

works out two days of full pay

9:45

on an average salary compared to eight weeks

9:47

average across Europe. And then the

9:49

countries who are doing it best, you look

9:51

at, for example, Spain. To Spain where we

9:53

were seven years ago, they had two weeks

9:55

and they have gradually increased it a year,

9:57

a week or two at a time over

10:00

a course of a few years. It's

10:02

now 16 weeks at 100 % pay. And

10:04

they're looking to, it's been such a success, they're looking

10:06

to increase it to 20 weeks, 100 % pay. In

10:09

Sweden, you have 90 days for each parent that

10:11

it's ring fence for that parent so that only

10:13

they can use it. And then

10:15

on top 300 days that you can share

10:18

between each parent, all at a good

10:20

level of pay. You can go on

10:22

and on that there are, we

10:24

are miles and miles behind wherever countries

10:26

are. And finally, the other thing

10:28

that we do badly when it comes

10:30

to paternity leave is self -employed people

10:32

are entitled to absolutely nothing. which

10:34

again is unusual. Most European countries give

10:36

self -employed people the same entitlement as

10:38

employed people. And I've spoken

10:40

to, for example, a self -employed

10:42

tradesman, a lot of builders, plumbers and so

10:44

on, who are self -employed. And one

10:46

guy in particular who had two emergency

10:48

C -sections, where his wife did for

10:50

his two kids, both were

10:52

born premature and ended up in C -sections. Each

10:55

time he took six weeks off to look after

10:57

and he did the right thing, stepped up. And

11:00

the financial pressure that's put on them

11:02

has almost destroyed him. And still, he

11:04

said six years on, I've not recovered

11:06

financially. It's destroyed his mental health, his

11:08

wife's mental health. He attempted suicide at

11:10

one point, it got so bad. And

11:13

then this is all for the sake

11:15

of properly supporting new parents with a few

11:17

thousand pounds in the first weeks of their life.

11:19

And the cost of not doing that is

11:21

enormous. My

11:23

brand new bit, midwife Pip's

11:26

guide to a positive birth is

11:28

now available. So much

11:30

more than a book, this

11:32

is a guide that allows me

11:34

to hold your hand through

11:36

your birth preparation journey with over

11:38

a decade of experience and

11:40

knowledge packed in to ensure

11:42

you really are empowered in

11:44

the way you deserve to

11:47

achieve a positive birth regardless of

11:49

the twists and turns that

11:51

crop up. Make sure that

11:53

you get your hands on midwife

11:55

pips guide to a positive birth

11:57

book now. and are

11:59

empowered to have the birth

12:01

experience that you deserve. below

12:19

the line of poverty. It's just, and this

12:21

is families, this is children that we're really trying

12:23

to work to protect and we're actually failing

12:25

them before we sometimes even get out of hospital.

12:28

And I think what I was

12:30

thinking when you were talking there,

12:32

Alex, was we're in this awful

12:34

duo because I know that, you

12:36

know, as a midwife and as

12:38

a mum, the support for mums,

12:40

for example, that dad whose partner

12:42

had had an emergency cesarean section,

12:44

we're in a place now where

12:46

women are expected the day

12:49

after major surgery or having birth their

12:51

baby with who knows what physical and

12:53

psychological trauma to get to clinic appointments.

12:55

They once come into their house very

12:57

often now, they're expected to attend appointments.

12:59

The support is much, much less in

13:01

the community. Therefore, we need to be

13:03

able to rely on the partner and

13:06

we can't when there isn't that shift

13:08

either. So we've kind of taken away

13:10

social support in every single way for

13:12

families, both from a healthcare point of

13:14

view, but also from a family unit

13:16

point of view. And it is no

13:18

wonder we're in this place where actually

13:21

families are struggling so much. Yeah, absolutely.

13:23

I mean, you know, I don't need

13:25

to tell you this, you'll know it's

13:27

far better than me or anyone, but

13:29

we've collected, we have a survey where

13:31

people can share their experiences and some

13:33

6 ,000 people are filled it in now.

13:36

And so many of the stories are

13:38

from mothers who had a caesarean section and were

13:40

told this is going to take you six

13:42

weeks to recover and some were lucky and it

13:44

healed very quickly some were unlucky and it

13:46

took six weeks or longer yeah and they said

13:49

I was just left they were told you

13:51

you can't lift your baby it's too heavy and

13:53

I was just left and one person who

13:55

said uh you know the day my husband went

13:57

back from paternity leave was just the worst

13:59

day of my life because I was in agony

14:01

and eventually her stitches ripped on the caesarean

14:03

because you know it wasn't healing properly and she

14:05

was doing all this stuff she wasn't meant

14:07

to do and it's it's bad

14:09

is one part of the puzzle

14:11

where the support that we're offering families

14:13

through paternity leave and of course

14:15

this applies not just to dads but

14:17

it applies to non birthing parents

14:19

of all kinds in mums and same

14:22

-sex relationships non binary parents one half

14:24

from an adoptive couple but the

14:26

support we are providing just doesn't match

14:28

the physical reality of birthing and

14:30

looking after a small child and let's

14:32

be honest we're talking about like

14:34

just allowing parents to survive

14:36

you know if we want parents to

14:38

actually be able to thrive like that's

14:40

like a whole other conversation like the

14:43

the current the current sort of situation

14:45

is at the point where people just

14:47

physically can't meet the day -to -day needs

14:49

it's not even this beautiful glamourized idea

14:51

of having lots of time right yeah

14:53

absolutely and the mental health aspect of

14:55

it is the other obviously enormous issue

14:58

with our current system in the

15:00

immediate term, before you get into stuff

15:02

around how it determines how people

15:04

parent long term, which I'm sure we

15:06

can come on to, but in

15:09

the immediate term, there is very clear

15:11

evidence that better paternity leave improves

15:13

mental health outcomes for mothers as well

15:15

as for fathers. And

15:17

what we find is that two

15:19

thirds of men say they weren't

15:21

mentally ready to go back after

15:23

two weeks. And

15:25

you enter into this sort of as a man, you

15:28

enter into this pressure cooker where you've got having

15:30

a baby is very expensive. I think we all know

15:32

that, you know, the pram is like buying a

15:34

car these days, some of them are so expensive. So

15:37

your financial pressure is going up at the

15:39

same time as your earnings are massively plummeting

15:41

at your paternity leave. On an average salary,

15:43

it costs you a grand to take that

15:45

paternity leave and lost earnings. Your

15:47

partner is on maternity leave, which is also really

15:49

poorly paid. And

15:52

then you've got that pressure on top of the

15:54

pressure of work. It hasn't changed. They expect you to

15:56

be there 100 % doing your job. And then you're

15:58

trying to be a good parent. You're trying to

16:00

be there for your partner and your baby, and you're

16:02

probably stressed that they're struggling as well. And

16:04

so you see a lot of dads

16:06

more than I think we recognize really suffering.

16:09

And then of course, for mothers, they

16:11

are often left on their own without sleep,

16:13

without support. And so it has a

16:15

massive impact on maternal mental health as well.

16:18

And again, that's just one of

16:20

the... from the the kind of

16:22

moral element of this, there is

16:24

a very pragmatic case for the

16:26

government to improve this because it

16:28

will reduce the pressure on mental

16:31

health services. PW PricewaterhouseCoopers did some

16:33

modeling that better paternity leave would

16:35

save something like £1 .5 billion in

16:37

mental health costs to the NHS

16:39

over 20 years and stop half

16:41

a million cases of depression and

16:43

new parents just from better paternity

16:46

leave. Yeah. I can see

16:48

it. I totally get it. And

16:50

I think also like if we

16:52

zoom out, we know like there's

16:54

so much out there about maternal

16:56

and paternal mental health and anxiety

16:59

disorders and how that impacts child

17:01

mental wellbeing and emotional intelligence and

17:03

attachment. So actually we are going

17:05

to have even more saving on

17:07

that child and breastfeeding rates. You

17:09

know, we know breastfeeding rates are.

17:12

their initiation rates are great and

17:14

then they plummet because there's no support.

17:17

We're spending so much time and energy telling

17:19

people how great it is for babies

17:21

and how great it is for mums but

17:23

there's actually no support for people to

17:25

do it and then when you are left

17:27

on your own recovering partners gone back

17:29

to work it feels like an absolutely impossible

17:31

task but we know if we improve

17:33

that we would also save so much money

17:36

in childhood illnesses and hospital admissions so

17:38

it seems I mean it seems like a

17:40

no -brainer but it's just not happening. right?

17:42

Yes, absolutely. And the other point to this

17:44

is there's a really good economic argument

17:47

as well. So this is the only advantage

17:49

really of being absolutely bottom of the

17:51

table as you can see how this has

17:53

panned out in every other country that

17:55

has improved things. And

17:57

the Joseph Roundtree Foundation recently did a

17:59

model that showed that if you

18:01

move paternity leave up to six weeks

18:03

of 90 % pay, which really is

18:05

an absolute bare minimum for what

18:07

we should be having in the short

18:09

term, you Because

18:12

it helps the evidence of other countries is

18:14

that it helps mothers who want to go back

18:16

to work when they want to so they

18:18

might take on more days of work or they

18:20

might go back to work when actually where

18:22

they would have left Yeah, you end up growing

18:24

the economy by 2 .6 billion pounds But the

18:26

cost to the Treasury is is a absolute

18:28

fraction of that sort of 200 million So it's

18:30

for every pound you put in you get

18:32

13 pounds back and obviously you get better outcomes

18:34

for kids And it

18:36

improves gender equality over the long term. It

18:38

brings down the gender pay gap. There's

18:40

very clear evidence of that as well. And

18:43

on your point around breastfeeding, that's something

18:45

that people sort of say, you see

18:47

on social media, some people say, well,

18:50

dad's can't do anything to help with breastfeeding. What's the

18:52

point in them being there with breastfeeding? And

18:55

I sort of say to people, our experiences are

18:57

some really struggled to establish feeding and you had a

18:59

tongue tie. He lost a huge amount of weight

19:01

after he was born. and

19:03

my wife was really determined to do it

19:05

and push through and she spent six

19:07

months pumping and we did top -up for

19:09

feeding and stuff and eventually she got there

19:11

and she ended up breastfeeding Infinity two

19:14

years in total but the fact that I

19:16

was there when it was really difficult

19:18

early on and could help her get some

19:20

sleep when she needed it between the

19:22

feeding and could do all the sterilizing and

19:24

the washing up and everything all the

19:26

other stuff and just like make sure she

19:29

didn't have to worry about it like

19:31

we've talked about it since she said if

19:33

that support wasn't there she just would

19:35

have given up straight away there would be

19:37

no choice to have carried on. So

19:39

there is a huge amount that a supportive

19:41

partner can do even when it comes

19:43

to things like breastfeeding obviously you can't physically

19:46

do. 100 % oh my goodness

19:48

Alex I've breastfed both our boys I'm

19:50

still on still breastfeeding Alfie who's 10 months

19:52

and I remember saying with our first

19:54

son who's also three to my husband on

19:56

day three if I didn't have the

19:58

support from him at that stage. I wouldn't

20:00

have carried on breastfeeding him. It was,

20:03

we've had difficult breastfeeding journeys with both and

20:05

I'm a midwife. Like I understand this

20:07

stuff, but the reality is it's hard and

20:09

it's such a big adjustment and you're

20:11

tired and you're recovering. And we

20:13

know that like the hormonal shift in women

20:15

when you've just given birth is the

20:17

biggest you'll ever go through in your entire

20:19

life. So your mood is super low

20:21

and you feel really vulnerable. And actually that

20:24

is a time where family units need

20:26

to be tight, not, you know, pulled apart.

20:29

Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. And

20:31

I think the other part

20:33

of this then that's crucial is

20:35

how it establishes the way

20:37

you parent longer term, you know,

20:39

there's those kind of crucial

20:41

few weeks. So what you see,

20:44

we have, we have a really unusual paternity and

20:46

maternity leave system in this country and that

20:48

paternity leave is very short and poorly paid, obviously.

20:51

Our maternity leave is unusually long, but also

20:53

really poorly paid, right? It's still one of

20:55

the worst in Europe when it comes to

20:57

maternity pay. So that really

20:59

pushes families, whether or not they

21:01

want to, into a stay

21:03

at home homemaker mum, breadwinner dad

21:05

dynamic, where the father often

21:07

gets only a couple of weeks

21:09

to learn how to be

21:11

a parent and to bond with

21:13

their child. And often that's

21:15

just not enough. And so you

21:17

might, even if it is, you know, you're there for those two

21:19

weeks, your hands on, you feel like you're getting the hang

21:22

of it, and then you're gone. And your partner is the one

21:24

who's taking everything on. and then they're

21:26

the one who learns or this is what this

21:28

particular crime means or this is what they

21:30

like to eat or this is how you cut

21:32

this piece of food so they don't throw

21:34

it away and then the father tries to get

21:36

involved and says they don't want me, they're

21:38

not bonded with me, they want their mum and

21:41

that slowly builds in and then you get

21:43

to a point a year in where the mother

21:45

is coming back off maternity leave and you

21:47

look at the cost of childcare and

21:49

you realize it's basically the same as one

21:51

of your salaries and you can't work flexibly around

21:53

school pickup and stuff because your employer won't

21:55

work so you say okay who's going to take

21:57

a step back and at that point it's

21:59

it's almost default it's some other and I've spoken

22:01

to people with someone who used the phrase

22:03

you know we wanted to do everything equally and

22:05

then we work up one day and found

22:07

ourselves in the 1950s and like this isn't necessarily

22:10

what most people want and if it is

22:12

what they want that's great that's fine like what

22:14

we want is more choice but

22:16

at the moment that choice is taken

22:18

away from a lot of people and so

22:20

this is why you see the motherhood

22:22

penalty as a lot of people call it

22:24

where the gender pay gap is something

22:26

like 75 % driven by motherhood and the

22:28

fact that women often whether or not they

22:31

want to take a step back from

22:33

work they get discriminated at work because they

22:35

are seen as more like to go

22:37

off and have a baby so they're overlooked

22:39

for promotions they lose their jobs and

22:41

there's really really clear evidence from other countries

22:43

that better paternity leave means that men

22:45

taking on make take on much more childcare

22:47

longer term it improves gender equality and

22:49

it improves outcomes for kids they end up

22:52

happier they do better at school and

22:54

it's really good for fathers themselves who have

22:56

happier longer lives i've read some study

22:58

that you know you're more productive at work

23:00

you're less likely to abuse drugs even

23:02

like always benefits you get from being closer

23:04

to your kids and paternity leave is

23:06

really the kind of the sort of root

23:09

the roots in the ground you need

23:11

for that and if you don't give

23:13

people that time then it just never

23:15

happens for a lot of people 100 %

23:17

and I think you know like that

23:19

first two weeks Alex especially in a

23:21

way with your first child you overnight

23:23

change who you are like your life

23:25

completely changes doesn't it and nothing can

23:27

quite prepare you for being a duo

23:29

and then all of a sudden having

23:32

this small person that is dependent on

23:34

you 24 seven and I think you

23:36

definitely to start with run on this

23:38

like almost shell shock adrenaline and also

23:40

what I see so much in dads

23:42

or in birth partners is the impact

23:44

of birth trauma and actually if we

23:46

are back to work after two weeks

23:48

of just running on adrenaline and what

23:50

on earth happened and what have we

23:52

done and I've no idea you know

23:54

what I should or shouldn't be doing

23:56

and are we getting this right and

23:58

all of that second guessing and sleep

24:00

deprivation we don't even consider trauma until

24:02

much later down the line and I

24:04

think you know in terms of mental

24:06

health we need we need that space

24:09

because I know there's so many dads

24:11

that then get you know pregnant again

24:13

and haven't addressed trauma from their last birth because

24:15

they just then had to get on with

24:17

that treadmill of life and that's just not acceptable

24:19

either. Yes, totally. Yeah,

24:22

I've heard from people who,

24:24

you know, won't feel traumatic bore

24:26

birth experiences and have struggled,

24:29

like really struggled even really sadly

24:31

from people who, you

24:33

know, lost their baby during the birth

24:35

and then back to work, you

24:37

know. basically straight away and they just

24:39

never had, you know, the mother

24:41

was left at home alone on maternity

24:43

leave without the baby, struggling with

24:45

that grief. The part was straight back

24:47

to work, didn't have space to

24:50

grieve. I mean, really awful. And

24:52

even beyond that, I mean, actually, we

24:55

had a story out yesterday about paternity

24:57

leave in the police. There's a lot

24:59

of problems with the way paternity leave

25:01

is happening in the police. And one

25:03

of them is that most police officers

25:06

get the first week at four pay, but the

25:08

second week is a statutory pay. And they

25:10

just most of them just can't afford it. So

25:12

60 % are going back after just one week.

25:14

We've had stories and people are saying, you

25:16

know, the day I was back a week or

25:18

two after my child was born, I'm not

25:20

sleeping or anything. I'm driving with the

25:23

blue lights on high speed through town centers.

25:25

Someone said, you know, my mate's an NHS surgeon,

25:27

he was back to work after two weeks

25:29

doing operations on no sleep. I mean, it's just

25:31

a there's a safety, there's a

25:33

basic safety issue in a lot of jobs.

25:35

Again, going back to tradesmen, we did some

25:37

research with tradesmen who a third of them

25:39

don't take a single day, they just can't

25:41

afford to take one day because they're self -employed,

25:43

they go straight back. And

25:45

you know, again, over half said I

25:47

just felt unsafe, like I'm operating power

25:49

tools on a building site on zero

25:51

sleep and I didn't feel safe being

25:54

there. And I think

25:56

in a world where the expectation

25:58

was fathers would sit in

26:00

the waiting room reading the FT whilst

26:02

the birth happened and have nothing really

26:04

to do with the baby then there

26:06

may be but now that's just not

26:08

what we want or how things work

26:10

and men expected to want to and

26:12

should play an active role in supporting

26:14

the partner looking after the baby and

26:16

in that world you need to create

26:18

the space to to care for just

26:20

their basic needs around that time. We're

26:26

just hitting pause for a moment.

26:28

whilst I share something new and

26:30

exciting with you. Have

26:32

you ever wondered what's normal and what's

26:34

not when it comes to your

26:36

baby's poo? The colour, texture

26:38

and frequency of your baby's

26:40

poo can provide valuable insight

26:43

into their health and development.

26:46

It can also help you determine

26:48

when to seek advice from a

26:50

healthcare professional. App to

26:52

clubs new, AI, PooTool. makes

26:54

it easy to understand what

26:56

your baby's poo might indicate.

26:59

You can even upload a photo

27:01

and the tool will analyse

27:03

it to provide helpful information. You

27:07

can check it out now

27:09

at actaclub .co .uk forward slash

27:11

baby forward slash baby tools

27:13

forward slash poo tracker. Yeah,

27:16

well Alex the work you're honestly

27:18

doing is just so important. How

27:20

far away are we from any

27:22

change? Is there any light

27:24

at the end of the tunnel? Yeah, we're

27:26

optimistic. So the government has recognised it's

27:28

not very good. a

27:31

good first step, right? So that's one of

27:33

the reasons we started the campaign is the

27:35

government committed in their manifesto in the election last

27:37

summer to reviewing parental leave. They said, you

27:39

know, it's not working at the moment. We're

27:41

going to review it as a whole. And

27:44

they've now committed to starting that

27:46

in June this year. And

27:48

it's going to run for a year. And

27:50

so our job as a campaign and

27:52

all the MPs who are supporting the campaign

27:54

are a ton of MPs who are supporting this

27:56

issue. Huge grounds swell of

27:58

support in the as well. All

28:01

of our jobs is to feed into that

28:03

review and say, this is what's not working. This

28:05

is what we need. We need longer, better

28:07

paid paternity leave. So our hope

28:09

is that that review will recommend better

28:11

paternity leave and the government will take

28:13

action. So there's a good case scenario

28:16

here where we've got change in a

28:18

couple of years, you know, a new

28:20

paternity leave. law on the statute books.

28:23

The challenge is that we

28:25

need to overcome is the

28:27

government's very worried about the

28:29

economy of economic pictures. The

28:31

movie is never great and so

28:33

that's why it's so important to illustrate

28:35

there's a really strong economic argument

28:38

for this as well. It's something that

28:40

basically should pay for itself and

28:42

some and it's a really good longer

28:44

-term investment in our kids, their development

28:46

and but also just in the

28:48

basic workforce of the economy. Yeah.

28:50

Oh, I'm, I can't wait to, to see

28:52

kind of what unfolds because yeah, we just,

28:54

I feel like it just is not sustainable,

28:56

is it? Where we, we kind of currently

28:58

are. Where, where are we really currently? What

29:00

are, what options do dads have at the

29:02

moment? We've talked about that kind of two

29:04

week that you said the police have where

29:06

they have that one week and then a

29:08

week of statutory. What kind of options are

29:10

you seeing from the dads you speak to?

29:14

So most companies now offer some kind

29:16

of top -up on paternity leave, but most

29:18

commonly that's just two weeks at full

29:20

pay. So the pay really does matter,

29:22

like a crucial point. We get longer

29:24

paternity leave, but it's still poorly paid.

29:26

Then just exclude a bunch of people

29:29

who can't afford it so that you

29:31

need both. So the pay

29:33

does really matter, but two weeks is just not

29:35

long enough. So the vast majority of people

29:37

are still just getting two weeks. At the top

29:39

end, you see people getting sort of six

29:41

months or more at full pay. Actually, one of

29:43

my co -founders, George, came into this because he

29:45

is really lucky to work for a company

29:48

where he had months at full pay and it

29:50

was just, he found it a transformational experience

29:52

and he knows if he hadn't had that time,

29:54

he wouldn't be an active parent because he

29:56

really struggled early on and it took time to

29:58

push through that barrier. So

30:00

that's at the top end. And

30:03

then obviously self -employed people get nothing.

30:05

So there is a real range and

30:07

that's part of the problem is increasingly

30:09

becoming a two -tier system. If you work

30:11

for a big, wealthy company who recognizes

30:13

the benefits to them for staff productivity,

30:15

morale, recruitment, and they offer you enhanced

30:17

percentage leave, that's great. But if you

30:20

work a smaller company that can't afford

30:22

it, then you don't. So that's why

30:24

we need government action to bring it

30:26

up for everyone. The

30:28

other option on the table is

30:30

shared parental leave. So that

30:32

allows you to transfer up to

30:34

48 weeks from the birthing

30:36

parent to the non birthing parent,

30:38

of which 37 are at

30:40

the statutory rate of pay. So

30:42

180 pounds a week. So

30:44

in theory, that sounds good. The problem is that

30:46

absolutely no one uses it. Almost no one uses

30:49

it. It's less than 2 % of families use

30:51

it. And the reason for

30:53

that is one, it's so poorly paid that

30:55

most people were just excluded. But

30:57

the other is that we, without having

30:59

proper designated paternity, the ring fence paternity

31:01

leave, there's still the sense that you're

31:03

taking away maternity leave from the mother

31:05

and maternity leave really matters too, right?

31:07

Mother understandably want that time. And so

31:10

a lot of people are reluctant to

31:12

give that up just so that the

31:14

father gets some time themselves. And that's

31:16

why other countries have tried exactly the

31:18

same thing and it hasn't worked and

31:20

it's only worked when they brought in

31:22

better ring fence paternity leave. So There

31:24

is shared parental leave, if you can

31:27

use it, that's amazing. We've heard really

31:29

positive stories from people who have, but

31:31

it's just out of reach for most people and it's

31:34

not the solution the longer term. What

31:36

do you want to see, Alex? What's

31:38

the dad shifts like gold

31:40

standard? Gold standard, I

31:42

think, is something like Sweden, where the boxes

31:45

it ticks are, there's a good amount

31:47

of ring fence time for each parent, so

31:49

it's use it or lose it. If

31:51

dads don't take that time, they can't transfer

31:53

it over and that's really... it's a

31:55

lot of evidence that you need that. It's

31:58

a good level of pay, but then on

32:00

top it also has that flexibility. Over 300

32:02

days that you can share, which

32:04

allows each couple to decide what works best

32:06

for them, rather than having it dictated to

32:09

them by their gender. So

32:11

that's absolutely best standard. Sweden has been

32:13

working on this for about 50 years,

32:15

so they are quite far down the

32:17

road from where we are. and we're

32:19

really realistic that bats we're not going

32:22

to jump to that kind of system

32:24

overnight you know that costs a lot

32:26

more it would require higher taxes and

32:28

so on so the absolute bare minimum

32:30

needs to be six weeks and ninety

32:32

percent we would like to see more

32:34

and we'd like to push for more

32:36

but that's the absolute bare minimum that

32:39

we need and you're envisaging that almost

32:41

as like a path to something better

32:43

over time but actually let's get let's

32:45

start shifting it a bit Yes, that

32:47

shouldn't be the end of the road.

32:49

I mean, that still brings us below

32:51

the European average for context. So that

32:53

needs to be a stepping point. And

32:56

again, we're going to push

32:58

for something better. And coming

33:00

back to Spain's model, we think the way

33:02

they've done it, a phasing increase over a number

33:04

of years, so you don't just jump

33:06

to 16 weeks, but you went there in

33:08

five weeks, seven weeks, eight weeks, so on. That's

33:11

a potentially a model where we could follow as

33:13

well. So you could end up with with more

33:15

than six weeks. But the level of pay is

33:17

really important. There's no good giving people 20 weeks

33:19

and then paying it all at 184 pounds a

33:21

week. Yeah, exactly. It's completely unsustainable. And

33:23

Alex, you said like, you know, MPs

33:25

are getting behind there. She needs members of

33:28

the public behind it. What can people

33:30

listening do to support this change if they

33:32

are really passionate about it? Which I'm

33:34

sure everyone's going to be because it seems

33:36

completely nonsensical to not support it. But

33:38

what can people do to help? So

33:40

the best thing to do is you go

33:42

on to our website, which is dadshift .org .uk

33:44

And there's a button at the top to add

33:46

your name for better paternity leave. And if

33:48

you do that... We can then send you emails.

33:50

We have actions that people to take all

33:53

the time. So for example, yesterday we were asking

33:55

people to get in touch with their local

33:57

police and crime commissioner and ask them to sort

33:59

out paternity leave in the police because obviously

34:01

police officers deserve that support. But if we can

34:03

get the police to do something, then it

34:05

puts pressure on the government to take action nationally.

34:07

So that's the first thing to do. Go

34:10

go to our website and sign up and we'll

34:12

then give you actions. If you're on social

34:14

media. We're on Instagram and

34:16

TikTok at Dadshift UK. And

34:18

to be honest, just liking, engaging, sharing stuff

34:20

is really important as well. It means that we

34:23

reach more people, more people get involved and

34:25

it has that snowball effect. Yeah, build

34:27

that momentum. So guys, please, please do that

34:29

now. It sounds like it's a super quick

34:31

and easy thing to do just to go

34:33

onto the Dadshift website. I'm going to be

34:35

doing it too because it doesn't just benefit

34:37

dads. They're really important. This is going to

34:39

benefit our children. It benefits us selfishly as

34:41

well. Like this only benefits absolutely everybody. So.

34:44

Thank you, Alex. Now, everyone that comes on

34:46

the podcast, I always ask for three

34:48

top tips. I feel like one of them

34:50

should definitely be get behind the dad

34:52

shift and support a change. But what would

34:54

your three top tips be when you're

34:56

listening? Oh, I

34:59

well, once one potentially themed top

35:01

tip is there are some banks,

35:03

if you've got a mortgage, who

35:05

will give you a mortgage holiday

35:07

when you're on parental leave. So

35:09

they'll say you don't have to

35:11

pay your mortgage for a few

35:13

months. And then that can obviously

35:15

be a massive help with the financial side. So that

35:17

if you're about to go on parental leave, have

35:19

a look into that, your bank might be able to

35:21

do that for you. So that's one one. That's

35:24

a great initiative, isn't it? Yeah, it's

35:26

something that we found out for a

35:28

Scandinavian bank is doing it. And I

35:30

looked into it and actually like very

35:32

few banks here, they don't make a

35:34

big deal out of it, but you

35:37

can do it a few of them.

35:39

So that's one tip. And

35:42

then another tip. We

35:45

recently got into,

35:49

obviously everyone loves the Julia Donaldson books, but I

35:51

recently found that she's done a bunch of

35:53

audio book recordings with her husband. They like read

35:55

them all out and they're all on Spotify. And

35:58

so they are keeping my son

36:00

very happy during happy changes when

36:02

he's otherwise. Yeah, I that.

36:04

So reluctant. So

36:06

yeah, the Julia Donaldson audiobooks and

36:08

Spotify are where we're at at the

36:11

moment. Julia Donaldson is

36:13

just a hero, isn't she? Absolutely

36:15

incredible. As are you and all

36:17

the work you're doing. So thank you so

36:19

much, Alex. And make sure you do, if you're

36:21

listening, go and make sure you give the

36:23

dad shift some support because we have got to

36:25

create a big old change in the UK

36:27

when it comes to this. Thank you so much,

36:29

Alex. My pleasure. If

36:42

you have listened to

36:44

this fair story, enjoy

36:46

it and feel that

36:48

you are ready to

36:51

really embrace and dedicate

36:53

yourself to having the

36:55

most informed, supported and

36:57

empowered journey. And

36:59

want to see if we may

37:01

be able to support you

37:03

in YPJ, your pregnancy and postnatal

37:05

journey. Please drop me a

37:07

Instagram DM at midwife underscore pip.

37:09

or get in touch on

37:11

my email pip at midwifepip .com

37:13

and let's chat through things and

37:16

see if we might be

37:18

a good match for each other.

37:20

I hope you've enjoyed listening and

37:22

wishing you all the best

37:24

on your journey through pregnancy, birth

37:27

and beyond. A

37:39

cursed mansion cloaked in

37:41

legend. I'm Sasha Auerbach.

37:43

Join me and Tom Ward every

37:45

Wednesday and Sunday as we reveal

37:47

the mysteries and histories of abandoned

37:49

places around the world and ask,

37:51

where did everyone go? Brought

37:53

to you by Like a Shot, makers of

37:55

forbidden history. Search for Where Did Everyone

37:57

Go on your favorite podcast platform.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features