Lots More on Why Neil Dutta Is Sticking With His Recession Call

Lots More on Why Neil Dutta Is Sticking With His Recession Call

Released Friday, 11th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Lots More on Why Neil Dutta Is Sticking With His Recession Call

Lots More on Why Neil Dutta Is Sticking With His Recession Call

Lots More on Why Neil Dutta Is Sticking With His Recession Call

Lots More on Why Neil Dutta Is Sticking With His Recession Call

Friday, 11th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

There

0:23

There are presentations. And then there

0:25

are Canva presentations. With Canva, you

0:27

can use AI to take your

0:30

presentation to the next level. You

0:32

can generate dynamic slides and text

0:34

with a simple prompt. You can

0:37

drag and drop graphics and charts

0:39

from Canva's media library and add

0:41

interactive elements to plus up your

0:44

deck. And with collaboration tools built

0:46

in, the whole team can work

0:48

together better. You'll love the presentations

0:51

you can easily design with Canva.

0:53

at Canva. Bloomberg

0:55

audio studios. Podcasts, radio,

0:57

news. What do you

0:59

think? Recession or no recession?

1:01

I mean, you had a really good

1:04

piece out this week in the newsletter

1:06

where you made the point, and

1:08

I had made a similar point

1:10

the day earlier, so maybe I'm

1:12

not being so nice, but like

1:14

how much of all the market

1:16

action, all the economic action, I

1:19

guess, was actually dependent on just

1:21

one guy. Donald Trump and that

1:23

you know if he came out

1:25

and said something he could end

1:27

the chaos at any moment in

1:30

time and then on Wednesday

1:32

he actually came out and did

1:34

that and then kind of kind

1:36

of well your point was yeah if

1:38

he does that we can all

1:40

go back to worrying about like

1:43

a slowdown in the labor market

1:45

or deep-seek threatening AI which so

1:47

much capital investment in the US

1:50

actually depends on. There's a

1:52

lot. I did a dead list. I am

1:54

both the most popular trader and

1:57

most successful trader at

1:59

Citadel. going viral? Uh, barges. This

2:01

is an after school special, except I've

2:03

decided I'm going to base my entire

2:06

personality going forward on campaigning for a

2:08

strategic pork reserve in the US. Black

2:10

gold. These are the important questions. Is

2:12

it robots taking over the world? No,

2:14

I think that like in a couple

2:16

years, the AI will do a really

2:18

good job of making the odd lots

2:21

podcast. One day that person will have

2:23

the mandate of heaven. How do I get

2:25

more popular and successful? We do

2:27

have the perfect guest. Welcome to

2:29

Lots More where we catch up

2:31

with friends about what's going on

2:34

right now. Because even when

2:36

Oddlots is over, there's always lots

2:38

more. And we really do have

2:40

the perfect guest. You know who had

2:42

a really good contribution

2:45

to the Oddlots newsletter?

2:47

February 2024th. Basically, the

2:49

market top. Neil data sees rising risk

2:51

to the labor market calling recession risks

2:54

right then, and essentially at the market

2:56

top. We got him back on. Neil

2:58

yesterday after Trump walked him back, by

3:00

the way, we're talking to Neil data

3:03

of Renaissance macro, Trump walked back some

3:05

of the tariffs. Goldman pulled its recession

3:07

call. You sent out an email right

3:09

away. You said, I'm sticking with my

3:11

recession call. Why do you see recession in

3:13

the cards in 2025 still? So remember that,

3:15

you know, for me, it's not really about...

3:18

and N-B-E-R-defined recession. Like that to

3:20

me is not the name of

3:22

the game. The name of the

3:24

game is trying to translate an

3:27

economic view into a market

3:29

call. And even if it's

3:31

not technically a recession, it might

3:33

as well be because the underlying

3:35

problem for the market

3:38

is not going away. And that's

3:40

the issue. You know, all the things

3:42

I mentioned in that newsletter you

3:44

highlighted in February. That's all here.

3:46

That's still here, right? We still

3:48

have a situation where labor incomes

3:50

are slowing and the Fed's not

3:53

budgeting. We still have a situation

3:55

where mortgage rates are high and

3:57

the housing market is weak and

3:59

we still have... state and local governments

4:01

cutting back. And we still have

4:03

a pretty high volume on trade.

4:05

I mean, in terms of tensions,

4:07

just because we dialed it back

4:09

a little bit yesterday doesn't mean

4:12

that the tensions are not still

4:14

high. And I think it's what

4:16

we've basically done is traded, you

4:18

know, you basically spread the distribution

4:20

of costs, I guess, I mean,

4:22

away from everyone just towards China.

4:24

But that's still pretty bad in

4:27

and of itself. I don't think

4:29

it takes a rocket science to

4:31

figure it out, Joe. I mean,

4:33

you're basically trying to break up

4:35

the relationship with us and our

4:37

third major trading partner. There's no

4:39

scenario or that doesn't create some

4:41

issues for the marketplace. It is

4:44

true we've ratcheted down tariffs for

4:46

countries X China, but as you

4:48

say, we've basically gone back to

4:50

what we were worried about before,

4:52

right? And the funny thing, I

4:54

got to say about that Goldman

4:56

note, and it just underscores how

4:58

quickly things are changing in the

5:01

current environment, you know they published

5:03

that. They published the recession call

5:05

basically an hour before Trump did

5:07

his big Wednesday announcement and then

5:09

right after that like I didn't

5:11

realize that within 60 minutes they

5:13

had to come out and say

5:15

actually we're rescinding it. As Lenin

5:18

said there are hours where nothing

5:20

happens in minutes where days happen

5:22

and we've had two minutes in

5:24

now we're seeing a lot of

5:26

that right now. Do you have

5:28

like a little book of Lenin

5:30

quotes that you keep with you?

5:33

Where are you getting this from?

5:35

I also might be mangling the

5:37

quote a little bit. I mean,

5:39

you should trade tensions are high,

5:41

but tariffs are really high right

5:43

now. I mean, that's really like

5:45

the core thing. Well, that's the

5:47

other thing, right, Joe? Is that

5:50

his tension, it's reality? A hundred

5:52

percent. And I kind of sympathize

5:54

with it, right? Like, it's the

5:56

uncertainty that he's creating. No, no.

5:58

is going to weigh on investment

6:00

by itself, right? Because if you

6:02

introduce tariffs and you actually follow

6:04

through with the tariffs, the uncertainty

6:07

around what you're doing is going

6:09

down, the reality of what you're

6:11

doing is what businesses will. respond

6:13

to through growth expectations and they'll

6:15

pull back, right? Because ultimately what

6:17

drives investment is what's happening with

6:19

growth. If real growth is slowing,

6:22

then it's inevitable that investment spending

6:24

will follow suit because largely what

6:26

investment responds to is sort of

6:28

an accelerated effect, right? That's basically

6:30

the idea that is. growth picks

6:32

up, investment tends to rise more.

6:34

So the fact that growth is

6:36

slowing and expectations around growth are

6:39

coming down, that's ultimately what's going

6:41

to pull down investment. So it's

6:43

not so much the uncertainty, although

6:45

that that's probably not good. It's

6:47

also what he's actually doing. Wait,

6:49

just on that note. So you

6:51

sent an email earlier this week

6:53

where you said the S&P 500

6:56

trading like Fark coin is probably

6:58

not a good thing. There's a

7:00

sentence. I never thought I would

7:02

necessarily read out loud. But the

7:04

S&P 500 trading like that. Is

7:06

that mostly a reflection of the

7:08

uncertainty aspect of all of this

7:10

or are you implying that it's

7:13

going to feed into things like

7:15

funding costs and the capital investment

7:17

environment and I guess the wealth

7:19

effect for the US economy as

7:21

well? Yeah I think so. I

7:23

mean I think the stock market

7:25

going down is usually bad and

7:28

I think that'll have effects on

7:30

household psychology for sure. And remember,

7:32

like a lot of the a

7:34

lot of the reason why consumer

7:36

spending ran so much more rapidly

7:38

than real income growth last year

7:40

was because The savings rate was

7:42

going down and one of the

7:45

reasons why the savings rate was

7:47

going down was probably because stock

7:49

prices were going up and that

7:51

was juicing, you know, enthusiasm for

7:53

the high-end consumer. Yeah, I think

7:55

this is really important. Like, if

7:57

you think that consumer spending was

7:59

driving a lot of the surprising

8:02

growth in some respects that we've

8:04

seen recently, then you should really

8:06

focus on what the higher end

8:08

consumer was doing. And most of

8:10

those higher end consumers have stock

8:12

portfolios. Yeah, I think that's right.

8:14

And I guess the other thing

8:16

I would say is, you know,

8:19

there's a whole literature I think

8:21

about, you know, the stock market

8:23

as a passive informant or... an

8:25

active informant, right? So is there

8:27

anything about the share price of

8:29

a company that tells the CEO

8:31

of that company something about their

8:34

firm they don't already know? Usually

8:36

it's probably not, but if you

8:38

get this sort of macro type

8:40

environment, which is kind of where

8:42

we are right now, then the

8:44

stock market takes on more of

8:46

a role of an active informant.

8:48

And you know, then you kind

8:51

of have business, the business community,

8:53

kind of looking at the stock

8:55

market as a, aggregator of macro

8:57

risk. And right now, you know,

8:59

the fact is that stock prices

9:01

are down quite a bit from

9:03

their February highs. And that's probably

9:05

creating a cautionary mood for most

9:08

of corporate America. I'm a big

9:10

fan of this stocks matter, a

9:12

hypothesis. I've been banging the drums.

9:14

Stocks matter. Don't just dismiss the

9:16

stock market as this thing that

9:18

us Wall Street elites, which we

9:20

are. are obsessed with. They actually

9:23

matter. In this family, I do

9:25

not believe in Wall Street versus

9:27

Main Street. I only believe in

9:29

one constant contiguous street that connects

9:31

all roads in America. Neil. Wait,

9:33

wait. Isn't that Neil saying that,

9:35

you know, people say that the

9:37

stock market is not the economy,

9:40

but it's not not the economy?

9:42

Where did you get that? Neil,

9:44

where did you get that? Oh,

9:46

we're going to settle this. Neil.

9:48

I got it from Joe Weisenfeld.

9:50

Yeah, all right. Oh, okay. I

9:52

know. The most painful thing is

9:54

Tracy has to acknowledge I get

9:57

some credit for something. It's a

9:59

good quote. Thank you. That's why

10:01

I thought you'll have it. like

10:03

developing strategic insights that help drive

10:05

M&A success and embedding AI solutions

10:07

into your business to sustain competitive

10:09

advantage or deploying tech-enabled audits to

10:11

deliver more accurate and transparent It's

10:14

how KPMG makes the difference. It's

10:16

how KPMG makes the difference every

10:18

day. KPMG makes the difference. Learn

10:20

more at www.KPMG.us slash insights. Thrivent

10:22

can help you plan your finances

10:24

for the people, causes, and community

10:26

you love. What makes Thrivent different?

10:29

A combination of financial services and

10:31

generosity programs. Thrivet offers advice, investments,

10:33

insurance, banking, and generosity, as well

10:35

as resources to fund service projects

10:37

or direct dollars to causes you

10:39

care about. With more than 120

10:41

years serving clients, you can plan

10:43

your finances with confidence. Visit thrivet.com

10:46

to learn more. Thrivet, where money

10:48

means more. Outside of Elder Care,

10:50

do you feel confident that there

10:52

is a single major sector of

10:54

the US economy right now that's

10:56

adding headcount? and elder

10:58

care and health care? Not really,

11:01

no. I mean, most of the

11:03

growth in employment has been in

11:05

sort of what you would call

11:07

like acical industries like private education

11:10

and health care. You know, when

11:12

you look at the more cyclically

11:14

sensitive areas of the job market,

11:16

I mean, that's clearly slowing down.

11:19

You look at residential construction employment.

11:21

I mean, that's actually down against

11:23

last year. You know, I mean,

11:25

service sector, I mean, the other

11:28

thing, of course, is that if

11:30

the tariffs come on, that's likely

11:32

to push up goods prices, right?

11:34

Given the fact that the labor

11:37

markets are slowing down to the

11:39

extent that people have to allocate

11:41

more of their household budgets towards

11:43

goods, that'll leave less left over

11:46

for everything else, which means they'll

11:48

ultimately have to start cutting back

11:50

on services consumption. and that'll drive

11:52

down the prices for services. So

11:55

that to me is a bigger

11:57

concern because obviously service sector employment

11:59

is huge in the US. That's

12:01

where most of the meat is.

12:04

So, you know, leisure and hospitality,

12:06

you know, things like that, I

12:08

mean, that's going to come under

12:10

pressure, I would think. As the

12:13

quarters go on. We are recording

12:15

this on Thursday, April 10th, and

12:17

we did just see CPI actually

12:19

come in lower than expected, but

12:22

everyone's talking about imminent tariffs impact.

12:24

And I guess my question on

12:26

inflation is, like, a lot of

12:28

people seem to be debating between,

12:31

well, most people agree the terrorists

12:33

will immediately. push-up prices, the big

12:35

question is, at what point will

12:37

enough demand destruction actually kick in

12:40

to reduce demand for consumer goods

12:42

and potentially lower prices? But it's

12:44

really interesting that you're saying that,

12:46

you know, we could have the

12:49

impact feed into services and then

12:51

if you get higher unemployment, that

12:53

would certainly add to the demand

12:55

destruction dynamic. The Fed's policy at

12:58

the moment is to be behind

13:00

the curve. Proceed accordingly. That's all

13:02

I can tell you. I mean,

13:05

they're basically telling you that they're

13:07

waiting for growth conditions to deteriorate

13:09

before they cut. That's all that

13:11

really matters. They're not changing the

13:14

nominal anchor just yet. I mean,

13:16

so that basically tells you that

13:18

their solution to the inflationary consequences

13:20

of tariffs is disinflation. As of

13:23

right now, NASDAQ down 6%, that

13:25

big green candle we got yesterday.

13:27

rapidly melting S&P 500 down 5.4%

13:29

U.S. tenure yields up on the

13:32

date, not a cocktail you want

13:34

to see. What if, um, what

13:36

if this just keeps going for

13:38

the next four years? It might

13:41

be. How

14:31

can you grow your business from

14:34

idea to industry leader? Bring

14:36

your vision to life with

14:38

smart business buying tools and

14:40

technology from Amazon business. From

14:43

fast free shipping to in-depth

14:45

buying insights and automated purchase

14:47

approvals. They deliver everything you

14:49

need to achieve your goals.

14:52

It's not easy to stand out from

14:54

the crowd. Simplify how you stock

14:56

up to get ahead. Go to Amazon

14:58

business.com for support. support.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features