Understanding the Israel-Hamas war

Understanding the Israel-Hamas war

Released Monday, 9th October 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Understanding the Israel-Hamas war

Understanding the Israel-Hamas war

Understanding the Israel-Hamas war

Understanding the Israel-Hamas war

Monday, 9th October 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

When it comes to personal style, it's not

0:02

just about a signature look. You can build

0:04

your style piece by piece. With new

0:06

colors, fabrics, and styles, it's the perfect

0:08

time to add new layers with Indochino.

0:11

From classic suits to stylish outerwear,

0:13

get made to measure quality at an off-the-rack

0:15

price. Add fresh layers to your fall

0:17

style with Indochino. Go to Indochino.com

0:20

and use code PODCAST to get 10% off

0:23

any purchase $3.99 or more. That's 10%

0:26

off at Indochino.com

0:28

code PODCAST.

0:32

I've been here for almost five

0:35

years and we've had a number of military

0:37

escalations and wars

0:40

in Gaza. But

0:42

I talked to neighbors in

0:44

their

0:45

80s who have lived through this

0:47

incredible violent history of this country

0:49

and even they say

0:51

they've never seen anything like this.

0:53

They've never felt

0:56

quite like this.

0:57

Steve Hendricks is the Jerusalem

0:59

Bureau Chief for The Post. We reached

1:02

him Monday evening Israel time to talk

1:04

about the violent attacks there by Hamas on

1:06

Saturday and

1:07

what's been unfolding since.

1:09

The foundations have shifted. Nothing

1:12

feels the same. People can't quite process

1:16

what's happening, much less what

1:19

might happen next. And none

1:21

of the scenarios are

1:24

very positive.

1:28

And Steve, where are you now? Are you safe?

1:33

People in Jerusalem always assumed they were the

1:35

safest community in Israel because

1:37

of a city that's beloved by all

1:40

the combatants, all the religions, you

1:43

know, fought over but beloved and therefore considered

1:45

to be sort of a little

1:47

bit immune from attacks

1:50

and violence. I think I'm safe

1:52

but I have to say it doesn't feel as safe as it used

1:55

to.

1:59

On Monday, Israel

2:02

announced a full siege of the Gaza Strip,

2:04

saying there would be no food, no

2:06

electricity, and no fuel. Hamas

2:09

has attacked Tel Aviv and Jerusalem

2:11

and other Israeli cities with rockets, and

2:15

taken dozens of hostages.

2:19

From the newsroom of The Washington Post, this

2:22

is Post Report. I'm Rachel

2:24

Lerman. I'm your guest host today. It's

2:26

Monday, October 9. Today,

2:29

a war in Israel. We talk

2:31

about how it started, what it means

2:33

for civilians on both sides, and

2:35

how it could end.

2:43

Steve, can you take us back a little bit? What

2:45

happened this weekend?

2:47

Well, it was the end of the long Jewish

2:50

holidays. It started with Rosh Hashanah

2:52

and then Yom Kippur, and then this was the second

2:55

weekend of the Sukkot holiday. There

2:59

were a lot of family celebrations going

3:01

on. Things were very shut down here, as

3:04

they always are on holidays. There

3:06

was this massive, basically, rave

3:09

that was happening in

3:11

the desert area in the south,

3:14

not too far from the border with

3:16

Gaza.

3:20

That's not as unusual as it might sound

3:23

to people on the outside, but there are communities

3:25

and normal life all around that area on both

3:27

sides of the barrier. After

3:30

many years in which a rhythm

3:33

of military escalations

3:35

and then peacetime

3:38

sort of become the norm, a cycle

3:40

people knew how to react to and predict.

3:43

It was a very relaxed time. Very

3:46

early on Saturday morning, just

3:49

really with the sunrise, people

3:51

on their phones get these alerts

3:55

when rockets are fired from

3:57

Gaza. Not too unusual. But

4:00

there were quite a number that went off very suddenly.

4:02

I think for many people that was the first sign

4:05

that something was

4:07

happening. The communities around

4:11

within sort of firing range of Gaza,

4:13

they did what they do, which

4:16

is to go to shelters or safe rooms. Again,

4:20

not that unusual here. Then

4:23

it took the most bizarre

4:25

and horrific turn people could imagine. At

4:29

this dance party that was happening,

4:33

they began hearing gunshots and then

4:35

the field where they were, suddenly

4:39

gunmen appeared, a great number of

4:41

them, and a tremendous panic

4:43

ensued. People were running, people

4:46

were getting shot. There's

4:48

tremendous numbers of videos

4:51

documenting all this that are sort of circulating

4:53

endlessly here. Then

5:01

we began hearing reports from

5:04

people in shelters, family

5:06

members getting texts and phone calls. There

5:10

are gunmen, there are terrorists in

5:12

our kibbutz, in our street. They're

5:14

entering houses. They're pulling people out.

5:19

Unbelievable things that people are still

5:21

trying to really comprehend. But

5:25

as the day unfolded, it became clear that this

5:27

was a major, very well

5:29

planned, very well executed military

5:31

attack with

5:34

strategies and contingencies and multiple

5:37

modes of entry. They came in out

5:40

of a breach in the

5:42

security wall on motorcycles.

5:45

They went over on paragliders. They went

5:47

offshore and came

5:49

up on the beaches. It

5:51

was a proper invasion from a force

5:55

that has really never been considered to

5:57

have those kind of capabilities.

5:59

How did Israeli intelligence miss

6:02

this? Well,

6:04

that's a question that's going to consume

6:08

this country for years to come. There

6:10

are no answers at this point. This

6:13

is still unfolding. There are still Hamas

6:16

fighters coming out of Gaza, replacing

6:21

troops that have been fighting. It's still

6:24

such an active combat zone in some

6:27

places. The Israeli military say

6:29

they are very close to containing the

6:32

last of those hot spots. But after

6:35

this comes a response

6:38

of a scale that we don't know yet, but it's certainly

6:40

going to be intense. The 1973

6:43

Yom Kippur War has

6:46

always stood up in Israeli history

6:49

as the biggest failure of

6:51

intelligence, of readiness, of

6:53

anticipating the attack

6:55

from multiple Arab neighbors,

6:58

it is an all-out war. That's how Israeli

7:00

Defense Minister Moshe Dayan describes an

7:02

invasion of the Golan Heights and the east bank

7:04

of the Suez. This is already being discussed

7:07

on a level with that. And as

7:09

the death count rises

7:11

and the fate of these dozens

7:13

and dozens of hostages, many

7:16

of them civilians, it

7:18

remains unknown. This

7:21

could become the most notorious

7:23

day of unpreparedness in this

7:26

country's history.

7:28

And what has been Israel's response so

7:30

far?

7:31

The military was absolutely

7:34

clearly caught off guard. There's

7:38

a lot of discussions here that they had

7:40

built this, the estimate

7:42

is something like a billion dollar high-tech

7:45

security barrier between Gaza

7:48

and Israel. It includes concrete fences,

7:50

subterranean barriers, radar,

7:54

detectors of all kinds. But

7:56

then they largely left it without

7:58

enough personnel to monitor. That

8:01

seems to be some early analysis. Now,

8:04

we don't know what

8:07

the particulars are of deployments, but

8:09

for whatever reason, there

8:12

was not a ready military presence

8:14

at the site of this attack. So

8:16

for the last many hours now, they've

8:19

been trying to mount that with air attacks, with

8:22

moving tremendous numbers of personnel

8:25

into the area, going house

8:27

by house and village by village in the early

8:29

hours. And now they

8:31

tell us, they think they're close to having the

8:34

area completely cleared and secure.

8:38

But we always seem to get another

8:39

report of more

8:42

Hamas people coming out, and the

8:44

fighting just continues.

8:46

So can you tell us how civilians

8:49

are feeling right now inside Israel?

8:51

I mean, this is a population that's

8:55

used to warfare. They're used to rocket

8:57

attacks. They're used to air raid sirens. They're

9:00

used to terrorist attacks. I've

9:03

never felt a mood like this in

9:05

the country. I don't even quite know how to describe

9:07

it. It's certainly fear. There's

9:10

a sort of a gut-churning

9:12

uncertainty about what's happening

9:15

now and what's likely to happen. But

9:17

even about the future of

9:20

the country, comparing it to

9:22

9-11 and the feeling that a lot of

9:24

Americans had, just

9:27

not knowing what the future would look like

9:29

or feel like when

9:32

our assumptions were so shattered

9:35

by shocking events.

9:37

Right. And it's still so raw. I mean, it

9:39

just happened less than

9:41

three days ago.

9:42

It's still so raw, and it's just replayed

9:45

on a loop on social media videos. There's

9:48

so much documentary evidence of really

9:51

horrific scenes of people being killed.

9:54

I just talked to a young woman today

9:56

whose grandmother very elderly,

9:58

lived alone on a kibbutz. for

10:00

most of her life. They

10:02

lost touch with her after she said

10:05

someone was coming in the house and

10:07

then they saw a video of her being

10:10

driven in her own golf cart with

10:12

four Hamas fighters across the

10:14

barrier into Gaza.

10:16

That's the last they know of her. She's very

10:18

elderly and

10:21

they

10:21

really have very little hope, her safety.

10:25

That's terrifying. So people are watching

10:27

these things over and over. I mean,

10:29

I'm sure some families know

10:32

how to avoid that, but it's in the air and

10:34

it's just repeating itself.

10:37

Can you tell us a little bit about the hostages,

10:39

about the hostage taking and

10:42

what Israel is doing to try to get

10:44

people back?

10:45

This is a country that's had a lot of hostage situations

10:49

through its history. We've had commando

10:51

raids to rescue, hijack passengers

10:53

on airliners. We've

10:55

had a lot of deals to release

10:58

Hamas prisoners in exchange for

11:00

a captured Israeli soldier, for example.

11:03

None of that compares to what's happened

11:05

here, effectively the mass kidnapping

11:07

of children

11:10

and families and elderly

11:12

people, and then all being

11:14

held in a very hostile territory.

11:16

The options are really

11:18

not good in any case. And the mood here

11:21

is probably not one for some grand

11:23

bargain. So there are various

11:26

estimates, but at least between 100 and 130 capis being held. And

11:32

their families have a very real prospect

11:35

of watching a massive military

11:37

operation unfold that probably

11:39

will not go well for

11:41

anyone in Gaza, captive

11:44

or president.

11:45

So Netanyahu has vowed to destroy

11:48

Hamas, but what does that mean for the

11:50

people in Gaza? Is there a way for civilians

11:52

to leave?

11:54

I'm afraid the options to leave Gaza

11:56

are incredibly limited. plenty

12:00

of people want to. I know because

12:02

our very close,

12:06

long-time Washington Post colleague,

12:09

Hasem...

12:15

Take your time. There's no hurry.

12:20

Hasem Balusha is

12:23

trying to get out with his wife and two

12:25

young sons. We've been

12:28

working to find a way There

12:30

aren't many. Some people are getting out through

12:33

the crossing with Egypt, but

12:35

even that is restricted. There

12:38

are lists and there are great

12:41

barriers to that. Thousands

12:45

of other people have yet to overcome. Many

12:49

many people are basically trapped there. That's

12:51

very scary. Steve,

12:54

can you take us back a little bit? This is

12:57

a really big question. I know there's a lot

12:59

of history here about land and

13:01

religion, but Can you

13:03

remind us why Hamas and Israel are fighting

13:05

now?

13:06

Well, Hamas is recognized

13:09

as a terrorist group by Israel, the United States, the

13:12

European Union. It

13:15

came to power when it surprisingly, more

13:18

than 15 years ago, won an election.

13:21

After that, Israel had to make a decision

13:23

about, and the rest of the

13:25

world, how to relate

13:28

to this terrorist

13:30

organization that was suddenly

13:32

effectively the government of the Sanclia

13:35

of two million people. It's been

13:38

messy. It's been complicated. There's been exchanges

13:41

and military fighting across

13:43

the border for all

13:45

of that period, including some quite major

13:48

and deadly full-out wars. There's

13:51

a mix of people who try to influence

13:54

Hamas and steer it, including the Qataris

13:57

and the Egyptians. It's

13:59

a rival. of the other major

14:01

Palestinian party, Fatah, which

14:04

is dominant in the West Bank and

14:06

controls the Palestinian Authority,

14:09

which is the governing body of

14:11

the West Bank. And

14:14

it's always been a bit of a back and forth about exactly

14:16

how militant and how terroristic is

14:19

this group, or are they becoming more moderated

14:21

as they have had the responsibilities

14:23

of governing. It's a

14:26

very difficult place, Gaza. I was just there

14:28

a few weeks ago. There's not reliable

14:30

freshwater. There's not reliable

14:33

electricity. Part of that

14:35

is the effect of a very tight

14:37

economic embargo that Israel maintains.

14:40

Part of it is certainly Hamas mismanagement,

14:43

misgovernment, corruption, and really

14:45

their priority being a

14:47

resistance to the Israeli occupation.

14:50

And what I think we've just seen is

14:53

throwing away all of the other aspirations

14:56

they may have had as an entity

14:59

to govern or to play

15:01

a positive role, and full-on

15:04

commitment to the armed resistance

15:07

and attack on Israel.

15:09

And is it fair to say that tensions

15:11

between Israel and Hamas have been escalating

15:14

recently?

15:15

Yeah, they definitely cycle. My colleague,

15:17

Hazem, and I just did a story last

15:21

month about how

15:23

it seemed to be ticking up again. It's been relatively

15:26

calm for several months,

15:29

even as the West Bank has seen almost

15:32

nightly military clashes

15:34

in various cities and camps.

15:37

Gaza had actually kind of settled

15:40

down for the summer. And a lot

15:42

of workers who had permits across the border

15:45

into Israel did that, up to more

15:47

than 15, 16,000 of them. But

15:51

then just in the last few weeks, the

15:53

cycles seemed to turn and maybe turn faster

15:56

than we recognized.

18:00

turning outerwear for your sidewalk stride.

18:02

Customize your new fall pieces however you want.

18:05

Buttons, vents, pockets, lapels, you

18:07

name it, they'll build it. Just submit your

18:09

measurements online or book a showroom appointment

18:11

to work with an Indochino expert style guide

18:14

in person. Add fresh layers to

18:16

your fall style with Indochino. Go

18:18

to indochino.com and use code

18:20

podcast to get 10% off any purchase

18:23

of 399 or more. That's 10% off

18:25

at indochino.com,

18:28

promo code podcast. So Steve, this conflict comes at a

18:30

time

18:34

when

18:37

there's already a lot of political upheaval

18:39

within Israel. Last time you

18:41

were on the show, it was to talk about the political

18:43

crisis over a move from Netanyahu's

18:46

government to weaken the judiciary, which

18:48

a lot of people in Israel saw as anti-democratic.

18:51

Can you remind us of that context?

18:53

That's a great example of how the last

18:56

two days have really just shifted

18:58

the plates here entirely.

19:02

This year has marked the most intense

19:05

domestic political upheaval in Israel's

19:08

history.

19:10

Massive, massive protest

19:13

every week in reaction to

19:15

this government's plan

19:17

to restructure the judicial

19:20

system here, basically limiting the power

19:22

of the prosecutors in the Supreme

19:24

Court, limiting the power

19:26

of the Supreme Court to overturn certain government

19:30

rules that it deemed unreasonable

19:33

or unconstitutional, even

19:35

though Israel doesn't have a written constitution.

19:38

Those concepts are the same as

19:41

in the United States. As

19:43

part of those protests, for the

19:46

first time ever, really, at large scale,

19:49

members of the military took part, protesting

19:51

the government. Thousands of

19:54

reservists, who are really a backbone

19:56

of the Israeli military,

19:58

said they would not.

19:59

turn out for training in

20:02

the course of this, as their leverage

20:04

point to stop this legislation.

20:08

So there were a lot of concerns, a lot of security

20:10

officials were saying publicly

20:12

that it was a dangerous moment for

20:15

readiness, that Israel wasn't prepared

20:19

as it tries always to be. There

20:22

was a lot of questions about what would happen if

20:25

in a major emergency. So

20:27

the emergency came and the response

20:30

from the protesters and those

20:33

reservists who had joined them was

20:36

immediately to put

20:38

on uniforms for the reservists

20:41

to cancel the protests for

20:43

the demonstrators. I

20:46

would say with no exceptions

20:48

that I can see, the country is

20:50

responding here with one voice

20:53

and all of that concern, all

20:56

of that controversy, it will

20:58

come back in some form right now, but it has

21:01

just been wiped away from the

21:02

country's consciousness. Wow, so that's a pretty

21:04

dramatic shift very quickly.

21:06

Overnight, in hours that happened.

21:09

How has the international

21:12

community responded so far to this conflict?

21:14

What kind of response are we seeing from

21:16

outside Israel?

21:17

Well, the waves of shock just

21:19

keep radiating outward and endless

21:23

expressions of support. Some

21:26

countries are trying

21:28

to organize evacuations of their

21:31

citizens. It's not

21:33

that, for example, the United States has called for

21:35

Americans to leave, as

21:37

the State Department will do in some very

21:40

dangerous circumstances, but there are very

21:42

few flights coming

21:44

in and out. They're trying

21:47

to find avenues for people who want to leave,

21:50

and I know that's true for many

21:52

embassies. But

21:55

more materially, we

21:57

see that Washington is deploying.

24:03

Steve Hendricks covers Israel for The Post.

24:06

That's it for Post Reports. Thanks for listening.

24:09

Today's show was produced by Emma Talcoff

24:11

with help from Ariel Platnick. It was

24:14

mixed by Sean Carter and edited by

24:16

Maggie Penman. If you want to show

24:18

your support for the show, please subscribe to The Washington

24:20

Post. It's a great way to help us do this

24:22

work. Go to washingtonpost.com. I'm

24:27

Rachel Lerman. We'll be back tomorrow with

24:29

more stories from The Washington Post.

24:45

When it comes to personal style, it's all

24:47

about layers, especially now. Add

24:49

layers to your fall style with new colors,

24:51

fabrics, and styles from Indochino. Go

24:54

to indochino.com and use code PODCAST

24:56

to get 10% off any purchase, $3.99 or more.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features