Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
This is a critical conversation around
0:02
truly the future of humanity. But
0:04
we don't like to talk about this. This
0:06
report is absolutely shocking. This is a
0:08
crisis and young men are struggling. So I
0:11
sat down with two leading voices on
0:13
societal issues to discuss the rise of millions
0:15
of lonely addicted men. And the most
0:17
important question is how do we fix this?
0:19
So let's start with this graph. It
0:21
shows that young women are now out earning
0:23
young men. It is true. We have given
0:25
women so many tools to achieve, but now
0:28
boys are being left behind. And that the
0:30
number of males aged 16 to 24 were
0:32
not an educational employment has increased by a
0:34
staggering 40 percent. And the data I've seen
0:36
is that when the woman in the relationship
0:39
starts making more money, they become twice as
0:41
likely to get divorce. Because traditionally women
0:43
seek partners who have more economic or
0:45
social status than they do. And emotional
0:48
intelligence is the new currency in dating.
0:50
But these guys were raised not to
0:52
be emotionally intelligent, but to be a
0:54
provider. that a lack of male involvement in
0:56
his lives is a big factor leading to
0:59
this. And once they lose a male role
1:01
model, they become much more likely to
1:03
engage in criminal activity. And so we
1:05
are just creating a lot of these
1:07
angry, young, single men who are saying,
1:10
well, this is rigged against me. We
1:12
actually have an awesome audience to write
1:14
in and this guy Jeffrey wrote in
1:16
and said, my entire life, I have
1:18
never felt like I was good enough.
1:21
Like I could never earn my place
1:23
in society. It's devastating. It's devastating. Honestly,
1:25
what I would do is. Honestly, what
1:27
I would do is... I
1:31
find it incredibly fascinating that when we look
1:33
at the back end of Spotify and Apple
1:35
and our audio channels, the majority of people
1:37
that watch this podcast haven't yet hit the
1:39
follow button or the subscribe button, wherever you're
1:41
listening to this, I would like to make
1:44
a deal with this, I would like to
1:46
make a deal with you. If you could
1:48
do me a huge favour and hit that
1:50
subscribe button, I will work tirelessly from now
1:52
until forever to make the show better and
1:54
better and better and better and better. I
1:56
can't tell you how much it helps when
1:58
you want to see. and continue to do
2:01
in this thing we love. If you
2:03
could do me that small favour and
2:05
hit the follow button, wherever you're listening
2:07
to this, that would mean the world to
2:09
me. That is the only favour I will
2:11
ever ask you. Thank you so much for
2:13
your time. Lost Boys. In March 2025, the
2:16
Centre of Social Justice released this
2:18
report which has sent a couple
2:20
of shockwaves across the UK, especially
2:22
across the media, and just to
2:24
give you a little bit of a sort
2:26
of... preface in some context on
2:28
what this report says. At the start
2:31
of the report, Andy Cook, who's the
2:33
CEO of the report, says, we listen
2:35
to those working on the front line,
2:37
the teachers, the youth workers, the charities,
2:40
and the parents who, they and they
2:42
out, see the struggles of young people.
2:44
And in recent years, they've been telling
2:46
us the same thing. Something is
2:48
going on with our boys. And because
2:50
of this, they wrote this report called
2:52
the Lost Boys, which looks at all
2:55
of the different facets of why. they're
2:57
more likely to take their own lives.
2:59
They're finding it more difficult to
3:01
find stable work and far too often
3:03
they're caught in crime. The numbers don't
3:05
lie. Something has shifted and we cannot
3:07
ignore it any longer. It's not just
3:09
about and you take or online influences.
3:11
These are symptoms, not the cause. The
3:13
deeper truth is that too many boys
3:16
are growing up without the guidance, discipline
3:18
and purpose they need to survive. And
3:20
there's some frankly horrific graphs, which
3:22
actually sent the CEO of my company,
3:24
a lady called Georgie. into quite an
3:27
emotional state. She text me and told
3:29
me she was crying, looking at some of
3:31
these graphs, which we'll talk about today. But
3:33
this is a subject that I know both
3:35
of you know very, very well. So I'm
3:37
keen to get into exactly why this is
3:39
happening and what we can do about it.
3:41
But to preface this discussion to understand where
3:44
you both come from and the perspective
3:46
you have, Logan, who are you? And who are you
3:48
do? I'm a behavioral scientist term dating coach.
3:50
So that means that I take all the
3:52
lessons from the field of behavioral science, how
3:54
we make decisions, and then I apply them
3:57
to the field of relationship science, which is
3:59
how love works. And so I'm really passionate
4:01
about this topic because for a long
4:03
time I've found that wherever I go
4:05
people say. Oh, I know all these
4:07
great single women. Do you know any
4:09
great single guys? And I just thought,
4:12
oh, okay, maybe that's always been happening.
4:14
But when I actually dug into the
4:16
data, I saw that we are truly
4:18
in a dating crisis right now, and
4:20
there is a huge mating gap between
4:22
the type of men that women are
4:24
looking for and the type of men
4:26
that are available. This is a critical
4:28
conversation around truly the future of humanity,
4:31
because marriage rates are down, that
4:33
means birth rates are down, and
4:35
so this conversation is extremely important.
4:38
And what sort of reference points do
4:40
you draw upon? Because you've got
4:42
some sort of unique access to data,
4:44
right? Right, so I work at Hinge
4:46
for the last five years, and so
4:49
I have access to tons of data
4:51
there around how data are dating now,
4:53
how data are dating differently, what sets
4:55
successful data apart. And then I also
4:58
have conducted my own research for this
5:00
conversation, so I sent out a survey
5:02
to thousands of my newsletter subscribers, and
5:04
people were very excited to talk about
5:07
this topic. So I make my living looking
5:09
at data and trying to come up
5:11
with insights. I spend most of my
5:13
career looking at data to try and
5:15
add shareholder value and then I have
5:17
the luxury now focusing on things I'm
5:19
really interested in. And I just started
5:21
stumbled upon data about the reflects
5:23
that the cohort that is ascended
5:25
fastest globally as women. And this
5:27
is a wonderful thing and a
5:30
huge collective victory. And the group
5:32
that has fallen furthest fastest is
5:34
men in Western markets. and the
5:36
data was just so overwhelming.
5:38
And also, I was close to being
5:40
one of these men. I didn't
5:43
have a lot of economic or
5:45
romantic prospects when I was a young man,
5:48
but there were programs in
5:50
an environment where I could
5:52
be successful. And I worry that
5:54
some of the temptations, the
5:56
technology, the economic trends, had
5:59
they been... where they are now
6:01
then, I could have very easily ended up
6:03
a statistic. So I just sort of relate
6:05
to these problems. I'm keen to
6:08
understand from your perspectives, what you think
6:10
like the first domino that falls in
6:12
a young man's life or a young
6:14
boy's life that causes the outcomes we're
6:16
talking about today? Like what is, where is
6:19
the first place to start? So the
6:21
research I've looked at and Richard
6:23
Reeves from your American History Boys
6:25
and Medicine, good research here, the
6:27
point of failure. If you reverse
6:29
engineered issues too, is when a boy loses
6:31
a male role model. And that is, in the
6:33
US, we have the second most single
6:36
family parent homes behind Sweden.
6:38
And what's interesting is that in
6:40
single parent homes, girls actually have
6:42
similar outcomes, similar rates of high
6:44
school attendance, income, rates of self-harm,
6:47
boys, once they lose a male role model,
6:49
become much more likely to be incarcerated,
6:51
engage in criminal activity, harm
6:53
themselves. It ends up that
6:55
while being physically stronger. Boys are
6:58
emotionally and mentally much
7:00
weaker. So the loss of a male role
7:02
model is, I would argue, kind of
7:04
the first point of failure that
7:06
predicts that a kid, a boy
7:08
is going to struggle. And that
7:11
has impacts on family
7:13
court, economic policy, and
7:15
just general and our society, where
7:17
men need to step up. If
7:19
we want better men, we need to
7:21
be better men. We need to step
7:23
into that void. Another one that Richard
7:25
Reeves talks about is that there's not enough
7:27
men in the education system So I believe
7:30
when Tim Waltz was a teacher one out
7:32
of three teachers in his school was a
7:34
man But now it's like 24% Yeah, and
7:36
so where do kids spend most of their
7:38
time in school and Who's teaching them mostly
7:40
not men? and it's and you think well
7:42
women can be fantastic teachers and it's true,
7:44
but after school programs not as many coaches
7:46
the tip typically are male male Not as
7:49
much compensation so they don't get rewarded for
7:51
being coaches for being coaches And if you
7:53
just think about it logically, who does a
7:55
teacher champion? A teacher champion is someone that
7:58
reminds them of themselves when they were a kid. So,
8:00
and also just look at the, there's
8:02
incredible bias, I would argue, against
8:04
males in school. A boy is twice
8:06
as likely to be suspended on a
8:08
behavior-adjusted basis. Twice as likely to be
8:11
suspended for the exact same infraction is
8:13
a girl. Five times is likely if
8:15
it's a black boy. And so, and
8:17
once you're suspended twice, it probably
8:19
means you're not going to college.
8:21
In addition, look at the behaviors
8:23
we promote in school. Sit still.
8:25
Be a pleaser. Be organized. Raise your
8:28
hand. You basically just described a girl. And
8:30
so, and also, quite frankly, a lot of
8:32
the jobs that require tertiary education attainment,
8:34
there's more women now in law school and
8:36
medical school, and quite frankly, good for
8:39
them. They're just better at that. They're
8:41
better students. They deserve to make more
8:43
money. They deserve it. But the reality
8:45
is, it has huge ramifications when we no
8:47
longer have wood, auto or metal shop. They've
8:49
gone away. Right. So those used to be
8:51
a pass to do some middle class jobs.
8:53
They've been replaced by computer science. So what are
8:56
the paths for the two-thirds of males
8:58
that aren't going to end up with
9:00
a traditional liberal arts college degree? Right,
9:02
and just to add a few more
9:04
stats to that, so we know that
9:06
70% of valetourines in the US are
9:09
female, and women are much more likely
9:11
to be in the top 10% of
9:13
their class, but then on the SAT,
9:15
men and women earn the same scores.
9:17
So there's definitely something happening in schools
9:19
that is prioritizing the female experience,
9:21
or that women are better at that. We
9:23
definitely want to celebrate the success of women.
9:25
I think the changes that have happened over
9:28
the last 50 years are incredible, and I
9:30
feel like I'm a beneficiary of that, and
9:32
so is my daughter. If you look at
9:34
all of the books that my daughter was
9:37
given when she was born, they're about great
9:39
women in history. You can be anything. Dream
9:41
big little one. And so I feel like
9:43
we have given women so many tools to
9:46
achieve, and in many ways those have been
9:48
manifested, but now boys are being left behind.
9:50
And so this isn't a zero-sum game. coming
9:53
on here because I thought people would say
9:55
she's a male apologist. She doesn't see how
9:57
much women are still struggling. I think everyone...
10:00
struggling. I think life is hard. But
10:02
what's happening right now is we need
10:04
to have empathy for young men and
10:06
we need to bring them up because
10:08
this isn't just a problem about young
10:10
men and patriarchy doesn't just hurt. women.
10:12
A lot of people think about the
10:15
patriarchy as something that prizes men and
10:17
hurts women, but when there's a very
10:19
narrow definition of men, everyone is hurt
10:21
by that. And that's all the research
10:23
that I've done is over and overseeing
10:25
women feel like they are not enough
10:27
good men to date, and men feel
10:30
like they're being held to a
10:32
ridiculous standard of holding both sides
10:34
of the coin, being feminine and
10:37
masculine. It turns out as you were
10:39
speaking, I was looking at the stats
10:41
around fatherless homes and it turns out
10:43
that there has been a significant increase
10:46
in the amount of young boys being
10:48
raised without a father present. About 25%
10:50
live without a biological... step or a
10:52
adoptive father, according to the National Fathhood
10:55
Initiative, in the US has the world's
10:57
highest rate of children living in a
10:59
single parent household and 92% of the
11:02
time that's with the mother alone. And
11:04
in 1968 only 11% of children lived
11:06
without, lived with only their mother compared
11:08
to 21% in 2020. So that's doubled
11:11
in the last 50 odd years, which
11:13
is pretty staggering. And then obviously
11:15
the consequence of that as
11:18
Scott described is that individuals
11:20
from father absent homes were
11:22
300% more likely to carry
11:25
drugs, to carry guns, to
11:27
deal drugs, and all of,
11:29
and there's this huge plethora
11:32
of mental health consequences if
11:34
you don't have a father
11:37
in the home. I mean, what do we
11:39
do about that? And like, where
11:41
are the fathers? Where are the
11:43
wrong? Where are they going? Where
11:45
are they going? the courts in
11:47
the financial you know our economy
11:49
make it difficult for a man
11:51
to stay involved in the kids lives
11:54
and also you know family courts
11:56
getting better at saying all right
11:58
the kids I mean just a personal
12:00
anecdote. I have a friend who recently
12:02
has gone through divorce, two daughters, very
12:05
much wants to be involved in their
12:07
lives. They're 13 and 15 year old
12:09
girls and quite frankly dad's there on
12:11
the weekends and they got their own
12:13
thing going on and they don't necessarily
12:15
make dad a priority. And dad's not
12:17
around for what I call the garbage time and
12:20
that is what I found with my boys is
12:22
the moments of serendipity and
12:24
connection happened randomly when you're
12:26
taking them to school. When you're out
12:28
in the back, you know, jumping around or
12:31
playing whatever it is, these garbage
12:33
moments, and when you're not in
12:35
the household, for whatever reason, there's
12:37
just, there isn't that much garbage
12:39
time, and I think slowly but
12:41
surely they lose sometimes connection
12:44
with their kid. There's also, there's
12:46
something weird going on, I'm curious,
12:48
slogan, if you've got date on this,
12:50
but you have a one-year-old daughter,
12:53
right? You're gonna be amazed when
12:55
my unfortunate boy had a Halloween
12:57
party. And the boys are like...
12:59
They're dopes, they're boys. There's some
13:01
14-year-old girls who look like they
13:04
could be the junior senator from
13:06
Pennsylvania. They're 5-foot-10, they're articulate, hello
13:08
Mr. Galloway, how are you at
13:10
a lovely home? The boys are like,
13:12
I don't know. And biologically, girls mature
13:14
faster. Their prefrontal cortex is 18
13:16
months ahead of a boy. An
13:18
18-year-old girl or woman is competing against
13:21
a 16 and a half-year-old when
13:23
she's competing against an 18-year-old. And
13:25
they're even finding. That it's getting
13:28
worse that women or girls
13:30
are starting to menstruate earlier
13:32
and boys testicles are descending
13:35
later So the gap in
13:37
maturity biological gap they think
13:39
might even be growing. They don't
13:41
know if it's pesticides But
13:44
when I meet my eighth graders colleagues,
13:46
there's a huge difference between between
13:48
the boys and the girls. Yeah
13:50
And Richards, one of Richard's suggestions
13:53
is that we red-shirt boys, that
13:55
we hold them a year back.
13:57
The boys start kindergarten at 6,
13:59
whereas... girls start at five? So the
14:02
research in the UK shows that 70%
14:04
of girls are ready to start school
14:06
at age five but many fewer boys
14:08
are capable of starting at that age
14:11
in terms of readiness and so if
14:13
you were to hold boys back then
14:15
they might be on more equal playing
14:18
field for those critical moments of four
14:20
to five of 13 to 13 where
14:22
the brains really develop at a different
14:24
stage. I want to talk about that
14:27
sort of early... education experience and how
14:29
it can be adapted, but also just
14:31
like if the environment of the classroom
14:34
is right for boys. As we're talking
14:36
about the point about father's listeners as
14:38
well, I found this graph, which is
14:41
also pretty shocking. And it goes into
14:43
what something you said has got. It
14:45
basically shows that the absence of a
14:47
father on a young girl doesn't cause
14:50
the same depressive symptoms, which means that
14:52
the absence of a father for a
14:54
boy... drastically increases their chance of being
14:57
depressed, whereas if for a girl it
14:59
doesn't. There's a lot of other graphs
15:01
that look like that in terms of
15:03
women and young girls are just actually
15:06
a lot more resilient in childhood. So
15:08
if you are in foster care as
15:10
a young woman, you have less negative
15:13
outcomes than young men. And so there's
15:15
this theory and parenting of is of
15:17
is your child an orchid or a
15:20
dandelion. And so the orchid really needs
15:22
very particular situations to grow. They need
15:24
a certain amount of light. They need
15:26
to be watered in a particular way.
15:29
in many situations. And so women, young
15:31
girls tend to be more dandelions in
15:33
childhood. And so that's why when you
15:36
have a boy and a girl both
15:38
in negative situations, the boy is more
15:40
negatively impacted. Boys are just weaker. There's
15:42
a crazy stat. I read that two
15:45
15-year-olds, a boy and a girl, both
15:47
sexually molested. And to be clear, they're
15:49
equally heinous crimes. But the boy who's
15:52
sexually molested is six to 10 times
15:54
more likely to kill himself later in
15:56
life. It ends up that boys are
15:59
just less resilient. Do
16:01
you think there's somehow more of a
16:04
stigma there? Like I wonder why that's
16:06
so dramatic. They can't talk about it.
16:08
Yeah, uncomfortable. Feel there's in LA, there's
16:11
a lack. I mean, I think just
16:13
until a few years ago, the social
16:15
incentives were to never speak about it.
16:17
I was on Lewis House podcast, and
16:20
he just openly said, I was sexually
16:22
abused as a child, and it was
16:24
so shocking for me to hear this
16:27
big handsome guy. Yeah. I don't think
16:29
you would have said a 10 or
16:31
20 years ago. It was his fault,
16:33
it made him less of a man.
16:36
So I think a lot of that
16:38
has hopefully gotten better, but we just
16:40
have to acknowledge boys mentally and emotionally
16:42
are weaker than girls. Lewis House didn't
16:45
admit that until a couple of years
16:47
ago. Is that right? So he's lived
16:49
with that his whole life and it
16:52
wasn't until he was, I think, having
16:54
dysfunctional relationships and a few other things
16:56
that happened that he decided he wanted
16:58
to say it publicly for the first
17:01
time, which again... feeds into your point.
17:03
We actually have asked some of our
17:05
audience to write in and one of
17:07
the people that wrote in was a
17:10
teacher in a primary slash preschool and
17:12
she said to me she was an
17:14
anonymous teacher in Germany and she says
17:17
every year it seems like more and
17:19
more children always have this new energy
17:21
to destroy the classroom dynamics. These boys
17:23
almost always have two things in common,
17:26
a lack of boundaries at home. and
17:28
unsupervised unlimited access to all kinds of
17:30
content on the internet, e.g. porn. Their
17:33
perception of what is okay and what
17:35
is right becomes completely distorted. I have
17:37
tried so many things and every Europe's
17:39
becoming an even bigger challenge. Young boys
17:42
in school. So one proposal is to
17:44
delay education for boys, put them in
17:46
education later. Is the classroom itself a
17:48
problem? Like the sitting in school listening
17:51
to someone speak at you? Someone proposed
17:53
to me on this podcast before that
17:55
boys need more sort of practical play
17:58
and the classroom isn't designed for that.
18:00
I wasn't sure if that was... Well,
18:02
in single-sex boys' school, they end up
18:04
with double the amount of recess time.
18:07
And that is if they have, I
18:09
equate boys to dogs, a happy dog
18:11
is a tired dog, and if it's
18:14
not hired, if it doesn't get to
18:16
run, it's going to cause trouble. And
18:18
I feel the same way about boys.
18:20
So in these schools where they decide
18:23
what's best for the boys, there's usually
18:25
more exercise and more free play and
18:27
more rough housing, co-ed schools. And you're
18:29
also seeing I think with boys. There's
18:32
just, we'd, by even acknowledging that men
18:34
play a critical role in boys' lives
18:36
a few years ago, that was seen
18:39
as sexist. What, you mean? What, you're
18:41
saying moms can't do this? And I
18:43
can just tell you, there are certain
18:45
moments when my partner needs me to
18:48
weigh in. I don't know if it's
18:50
the depth of my voice, my physical
18:52
size, the way they relate to me,
18:54
the fact that I'm not, you need
18:57
dad. Or that's what I found, especially
18:59
with boys. They need almost like that,
19:01
that, not physical intimidation, but it's almost
19:04
like they begin tuning out their mom
19:06
over time. I mean, they're incredibly close
19:08
to the mother, they look to her
19:10
for nurturing when they really have a
19:13
problem, I find to go to mom,
19:15
but they will constantly test the boundaries
19:17
constantly. And I think a lot of,
19:20
a lot of single mothers, quite frankly,
19:22
with boys, just can't keep a lid
19:24
on that kid. They can't control the
19:26
kid. So, and I think you're finding
19:29
it schools when there's no male kind
19:31
of, I don't know, involvement or that,
19:33
I don't know, what I'll call physical
19:35
presence, and then you add on this
19:38
dopa machine that they get used to
19:40
squeezing a dopa bag a hundred times
19:42
a day as they need it, and
19:45
then you take the dopa bag away.
19:47
They're just more prone to emotional outbursts.
19:49
I'm curious if you've done any research
19:51
around why that... Is that emotional outburst
19:54
more common among boys than girls? I
19:56
haven't done that research, but I... I
19:58
am imagining that there's moms out there
20:00
that are raising boys on their own,
20:03
and they might be like, yes, it
20:05
is hard, but what do I do?
20:07
Right. And so for that boy, who
20:10
isn't taught by a lot of guys
20:12
in school and isn't in the Boy
20:14
Scouts, which doesn't exist anymore, or it
20:16
doesn't have big brothers, big sisters, like,
20:19
what does that mom do? So with
20:21
that, you talked about a Boy Scouts.
20:23
In America, there's scouts for America. Right.
20:26
So the question is, are I, you
20:28
know, what do you do? And I
20:30
think that we need a societal zeitgeist
20:32
that says immediately if there's no longer
20:35
a male involved, we have to get
20:37
other men involved and acknowledge that that's
20:39
not being sexist, that that's important, that
20:41
that's important, that you get men involved.
20:44
And I think, so I came from
20:46
a single parent household raised by a
20:48
single immigrant mother who lived and died
20:51
a secretary, lied of my life, as
20:53
soon as my dad's gone. And I
20:55
had wonderful men involved in my life.
20:57
I had a stockbroer, neighbor down the
21:00
hall came with his girlfriend and said,
21:02
you want to go horseback riding? You
21:04
just take me horseback riding. I don't
21:07
know if men would be comfortable doing
21:09
that in today's age. So getting men
21:11
involved in their lives after school programs,
21:13
Boy Scouts. I had a lot of
21:16
wonderful men. I used to go camping,
21:18
you know, and there were men everywhere
21:20
involved in my life. And I worried
21:22
that a lot of those institutions. and
21:25
also there's a reticence and a hesitant
21:27
for men to get involved in a
21:29
boy's life that isn't theirs for fear
21:32
they're going to be perceived as something's
21:34
wrong with them. I was thinking that,
21:36
so if we have less men in
21:38
the home raising the children and then
21:41
we go to school and the stat
21:43
says that 72% of teachers in middle
21:45
school are women as well, there's no
21:47
men at school either. It's no wonder
21:50
that boys are struggling so severely at
21:52
such a young early age for so
21:54
many reasons because... one would assume that
21:57
they're being socialised in the same way
21:59
as girls. I'm seeing
22:01
a mother at home, don't have a
22:03
father, I've got women at school, don't
22:05
have male teachers. I mean, that's a
22:08
controversial thing to say, I'm sure it
22:10
used to be, but I think people
22:12
are waking up a little bit now.
22:14
We need more male teachers, there's more
22:16
female fighter pilots per capita than male
22:18
kindergarten teachers. There's just, there's an absence,
22:21
there are some boys, not some, there
22:23
are millions of boys in America whose
22:25
first male role model is a prison
22:27
guard. And there just no men in
22:29
their lives in their lives. After school
22:32
programs being canceled, no women, very, very
22:34
few men, K-12, dad's not around. There
22:36
are, there are commune, there are literally
22:38
communities. You read articles about it. Where
22:40
it's like, where are the men? Yeah,
22:42
so I'm trying to figure out where
22:45
are they? Online. Doesn't look like they're
22:47
in work. They're not in college. The
22:49
reality is, there just aren't for a
22:51
lot of reasons, a host of reasons.
22:53
male, a lack of male involvement in
22:55
kids' lives is a big, big factor,
22:58
leaniness. There are other factors, there's socioeconomic
23:00
factors, there's a lack of vocational training,
23:02
there's outsourcing of many of the jobs
23:04
that made a man's path to male
23:06
class viable. You want to talk about
23:09
the UK, a big problem is a
23:11
lack of growth. There's just not a
23:13
lot of income opportunities for a young
23:15
man who's not exceptional. And what we've
23:17
seen in the US is essentially if
23:19
you look at our economic policies and
23:22
college, it's never been better to be
23:24
remarkable. Like if you're in the top
23:26
10% of your high school class, you're
23:28
going to make more money than the
23:30
top 10% did, 20, 30. If you're
23:32
going to make a kid at Google
23:35
who's amazing, computer science theory, it can
23:37
make millions of dollars by the time
23:39
of the 30. But I can prove
23:41
to every one of us, mathematically, the
23:43
99% of our children are not in
23:46
the top 1. And our economic policies
23:48
have basically said that school and college
23:50
is meant to identify a super class
23:52
of... percenters that we're going to try
23:54
and turn into billionaires instead of figuring
23:56
out the infrastructure in the programs to
23:59
ensure the bottom 90 have a shot
24:01
of being at the top 10. And
24:03
one of the stats is just around
24:05
college acceptance. When I applied to UCLA,
24:07
the acceptance rate was 76 percent, now
24:10
it's 9 percent. I was unremarkable for
24:12
whatever reason, prefrontal cortex, single mother, whatever
24:14
you want to call it. But back
24:16
then they had the mission and the
24:18
charge to let in unremarkable kids. And
24:20
that's no longer the case because because
24:23
because America's because America's Superpowers are optimism
24:25
and we all believe our kids in
24:27
that top 1% and the reality is
24:29
they're not. Or people think, I like
24:31
an economy where you can make a
24:33
billion dollars because that's going to be
24:36
me one day. So they have ignored
24:38
the fact that we are crowding more
24:40
and more prosperity and opportunity into the
24:42
remarkable. And for me it comes down
24:44
to what is, what do we want
24:47
in American UK? Do we want a
24:49
super class of billionaires or do we
24:51
want a society in an operating system?
24:53
that gives unremarkable people a shot of
24:55
being in the top 10%. It's become
24:57
winner-take-all. And we have purposely created a
25:00
set of economic and educational policies that
25:02
crowd a massive amount of prosperity into
25:04
the top 1%. And we have opted
25:06
for it, because we believe we have
25:08
a shot at being in that top
25:10
1%. I love that because I think
25:13
that the winner takes all applies to
25:15
a lot of different things. So I
25:17
bet the top 10% of Americans now
25:19
are healthier than they've ever been. All
25:21
the rest of the country has never
25:24
been healthy. Best health care in the
25:26
world if you're in the top 10%?
25:28
Yeah. Or in marriages, the top marriages
25:30
today are the best marriages of all
25:32
time, yet we have declining marriage rates.
25:34
So we're nearing the lowest rate of
25:37
marriage that we've ever had in American
25:39
history. So most people. or fewer people
25:41
are getting married, but if you're, you
25:43
know, two college graduates who get married
25:45
in your 30s, you might have an
25:47
even stronger bond than people in the
25:50
past. But that is a small group
25:52
at the top. Marriage has become a
25:54
luxury item. If you're in the top
25:56
quintal of income-earning households... you're 75% get
25:58
married. If you're in the bottom quintile,
26:01
only 25. If you're in the lower
26:03
quintile of income earning men, only one
26:05
in four chance of getting married. And
26:07
this has huge impact on our society
26:09
because we know that married people are
26:11
healthier, they're wealthier, they live longer, when
26:14
couples are married, they actually have lower
26:16
rates of child poverty. And so this
26:18
has huge implications for our society if
26:20
we're having fewer marriages. I want to
26:22
get into dating and marriage and love
26:24
and all those things. One of the
26:27
things that really shocked me as I
26:29
was preparing for this conversation was this
26:31
graph. Because this isn't the narrative that
26:33
we hear. Can you both see this
26:35
one? This is the reverse gender gap.
26:38
Gender gap. Gender pay gap graph. And
26:40
it shows that young women are now
26:42
earning young men. That's not what I
26:44
heard in terms of like if I
26:46
log on social media, we've been trying
26:48
to fight the gender pay gap. But
26:51
to see that young men are now
26:53
falling behind both in education, both in
26:55
education, unemployment young men face higher unemployment
26:57
nearly twice the rate of women. Looking
26:59
at the early developmental stats, this graph
27:01
was horrifying. I actually couldn't believe that
27:04
was true. That young boys are struggling
27:06
so much in education, but then to
27:08
see also that it's reflected in... So
27:10
that graph shows that... boys age 16
27:12
to 24 are making 10% less in
27:15
full-time employment than women. And so it
27:17
is true that we're seeing a reverse
27:19
income graph. But what we do need
27:21
to talk about is even when women
27:23
make more in their 20s, that changes
27:25
around age 30. When they have kids,
27:28
right? It's like this meteorite hits and
27:30
there's this huge burden placed on women.
27:32
And I think that's a big part
27:34
of the conversation that we'll talk about
27:36
when we talk about dating is women
27:38
still feel like they have to have
27:41
to have... you know, do all the
27:43
household chores and raise the kids, but
27:45
suddenly they have to earn a full-time
27:47
income too. And so so many of
27:49
the gender roles are changing. And so,
27:52
yes, that graph is true. We have
27:54
seen since 2020 that there's a shift,
27:56
but I don't want to just say,
27:58
oh, women are making more and per-
28:00
because as soon as there's kids involved
28:02
they pay the price. Do you know
28:05
you said that women feel the need
28:07
to then also earn a career and
28:09
all those things? Where did that come
28:11
from? Well, there's this idea of hypergamy.
28:13
So traditionally, women seek partners who have
28:16
more economic or social status than they
28:18
do. And for most of human history,
28:20
this worked because men had the resources.
28:22
And so there was sort of this
28:24
arrangement where women could often marry someone
28:26
who was more educated or earned more.
28:29
But over the last 50 years, that's
28:31
really changed. And so what I'm seeing
28:33
in my work working one-on-one with women
28:35
is that when they say that there
28:37
aren't enough good guys to go around,
28:39
that's actually true. So we now have
28:42
this huge mating gap where we have
28:44
these high performing, high earning women that
28:46
have done the work and gone to
28:48
therapy and work out and they're ready
28:50
for their great partner, but they're not
28:53
able to find enough guys who are
28:55
available. And if this is a problem
28:57
now with the women I work within
28:59
their 30s, we are going to be
29:01
facing a much more severe crisis. 10,
29:03
15 years from now. So currently 60%
29:06
of college enrollment is women, but soon
29:08
it's going to be for every two
29:10
women that graduate, it'll be one man.
29:12
So that means half of those women
29:14
will not have a guy who graduated
29:16
from college. And so this is a
29:19
crisis because these women are saying, okay,
29:21
if you cannot be the provider, then
29:23
you need to be offering more. Emotional
29:25
intelligence is the new currency in dating.
29:27
But these guys were raised not to
29:30
be emotionally intelligent, not to give emotional
29:32
support, but to be a provider. And
29:34
so they've been chasing this lion. I'm
29:36
going to hunt for this lion of
29:38
being a provider. But suddenly they're told,
29:40
you need to hunt for a tiger,
29:43
which is emotional intelligence. They don't have
29:45
the skills to do that. And so
29:47
women have raised the bar in terms
29:49
of what they need from men, while
29:51
men are continuously falling behind. Yeah, there's
29:53
a lot there. There's some new ones
29:56
around the pay thing. So the data
29:58
I've seen is that. Women under the
30:00
age of 30 in urban areas are
30:02
now making more money. But to your
30:04
point, the moment they have kids, where
30:07
corporate America has really failed, is it
30:09
hasn't figured out a way to maintain
30:11
a woman's professional trajectory once she decides
30:13
to deploy her over his napkits. And
30:15
there's some data saying, okay, two-thirds of
30:17
divorce can be reverse engineered to the man
30:20
starting to make less money. in the relationship
30:22
starts making more money, they become twice
30:24
as likely to get divorced, three times
30:26
as likely to use ED drugs because
30:28
the guy loses a sense of purpose
30:30
and self-esteem. What gets lost in that
30:32
data is the reality is if
30:35
a woman is stepping up and stepping
30:37
into the economic void and being more
30:39
economically, being a greater economic
30:41
contributor, then logically it would make sense
30:43
that men need to step up logistically.
30:46
And I think what a lot of women are
30:48
saying is like, okay. I'm not getting anything. You're
30:50
no longer a provider. And by the
30:52
way, you haven't filled that void. You
30:54
haven't made up the delta. So there's
30:57
some nuance around it. What also I
30:59
think is important to say is that
31:01
if women are better students and showing
31:03
the discipline and the skills to
31:05
go to college and an information
31:08
economy and making more money, then okay,
31:10
good on them. Just as for whatever reason,
31:12
men made more money. Maybe it
31:14
wasn't fair. It's not a crime against humanity
31:16
if women have the skills to make
31:18
more money. What happens, though, is the
31:20
second-order effects that you're talking about, and
31:22
that is, and we don't like to
31:24
talk about this, 75% of women say that
31:26
economic viability is hugely important in a
31:29
mate. Only 25% of men. For men
31:31
it's not a criteria. For women it
31:33
is. And Chris Williamson of the modern
31:35
wisdom podcast, he has his great stat, or
31:37
he calls out the high-heels effect. And that
31:39
is 50% of women say they won't date a
31:41
man shorter than shorter than them, a man shorter
31:44
than them. I'm curious what you think, but
31:46
I think it's more like 80%. I think it's
31:48
an embarrassing thing to say because just instinctively, women
31:50
feel like they'll be vulnerable during gestation
31:52
and they want someone they think physically
31:54
could protect them. I just think it's
31:56
hardwired into a meme if they don't know it. Women metaphorically
31:59
are getting... taller every year and
32:01
women made horizontally enough and men
32:03
horizontally and down right and when
32:06
the pool of horizontal and up
32:08
keep shrinking they just have so
32:10
this notion a ton of great women
32:12
where are the men or there's no men
32:15
there's a lot of men just not
32:17
men they'd want to date right and
32:19
men you speed ball it with the
32:21
guys who are in the top 10%
32:23
can engage in Porsche polygamy. They can get
32:25
a date every god damn night, which
32:27
does not encourage long-term or very good
32:29
behavior So the guys they all want
32:32
are not incented to enter into long-term
32:34
relationships and the bottom half of
32:36
men are literally Shut out of
32:38
the mating market and we always
32:40
kind of we always kind of in
32:42
this goes to your Ballywick kind
32:44
of portraying men as the predators and
32:46
the idiots and they just got
32:49
their act together There's something
32:51
strange going on in that is online
32:53
dating When a woman, a woman can
32:55
go out with a guy, a high-status
32:57
male, and I'll put for this thesis,
33:00
and I want you to respond to
33:02
it, she can have sex with him,
33:04
which gives her the impression
33:06
that's her weight class for a
33:08
relationship, but he's not interested in
33:10
a relationship. And then she basically
33:13
decides the bottom 90 are no
33:15
longer in her weight class. And
33:17
you can't tell a woman to
33:19
lower her expectations, but the reality
33:21
is... all of the women want
33:23
the same few guys and they shut
33:26
out the rest. Yeah, okay, so there's a few
33:28
things I'll respond to there. So one,
33:30
going back to the income graph, I
33:32
want to just call out that yes,
33:34
right now in a few urban markets,
33:36
women are making more than men. So
33:38
women in DC and New York under
33:41
30 are making more than men on
33:43
average, but in most situations men are
33:45
still making more than women, but we're
33:47
talking about a projection. Going back to
33:50
the dating research. So yes, it's exactly
33:52
as you described. What we have right
33:54
now is there's fewer and fewer men
33:56
that are hypergamous mates for women. So
33:59
if there's a. much smaller pool of
34:01
guys than what you have is you
34:03
have a bunch of women competing for
34:05
the same men. And then a bunch
34:08
of guys get ignored. But what I
34:10
also see is that those top guys
34:12
are having a hard time deciding. So
34:15
I feel like in my coaching practice
34:17
as a dating coach, I'm working with
34:19
a lot of women who say, what
34:22
do I do? I've changed my profile
34:24
the way you said I should. I
34:26
took your class, but I still feel
34:29
like there's just not enough great guys.
34:31
And then I work with these CEO
34:33
men who are having such a hard
34:36
time choosing. So many women are competing
34:38
for the same men, and then a
34:40
bunch of guys are getting ignored. And
34:43
then what ends up happening is where
34:45
do those guys go? And they go
34:47
online. That's what you see. They go
34:50
to porn. They go to porn or
34:52
they go to read it. I mean,
34:54
I love read it, but they're really
34:57
going to some of these red-pilled communities.
34:59
And so what you're seeing now is
35:01
just men really opting out of society.
35:04
And as Scott says, there's nothing scarier
35:06
than a single man, a young single
35:08
man. And so we are just creating
35:11
a lot of these angry young single
35:13
men who are saying, well, this is
35:15
rigged against me. And so that's why
35:17
I am worried about the rise of
35:20
people like Andrew Tate. And if we
35:22
wonder where are the dads, where are
35:24
the men? Well, men are finding these
35:27
father figures, but they're finding them online
35:29
and they're not the father figures that
35:31
I would choose for the majority of
35:34
men. And so I'm really worried about
35:36
this because I feel like women are
35:38
saying, guys, you need to step up
35:41
because I can provide and I don't
35:43
need that from you. And guys are
35:45
not prepared to rise to the occasion.
35:48
So I would say, you know, I
35:50
work at Hinge, but I do think
35:52
that apps have perpetuated this issue around
35:55
height, because if you can set your
35:57
height filter to something, then you might
35:59
set it higher. And then it says
36:02
if you have the dating app is
36:04
a club and you're literally have... bouncers
36:06
that prevent a bunch of guys from
36:09
getting into the club. So many women
36:11
in the US set their height filters
36:13
at six feet, but only 14% of
36:16
men in the US are six feet
36:18
or taller. what happens to the other
36:20
86% of men, and women are saying,
36:23
where's my guy? It's like, well, he's
36:25
not even showing up on your app.
36:27
And so a huge thing that I
36:29
push women to do is to change
36:32
their height filters and just say, there
36:34
is nothing that proves that you're gonna
36:36
have a successful long-term relationship if the
36:39
guy is higher. I'm married to a
36:41
short king. I love it. I feel
36:43
like I really found this gem. Scott's
36:46
point as well about they will date
36:48
one of the men in the top
36:50
10% sleep with him potentially and then
36:53
that kind of adjust their standards and
36:55
they expect all other men to meet
36:57
that standard but there isn't just there
37:00
isn't enough men to meet that standard
37:02
is there? I haven't specifically heard that
37:04
I mean there is a lot of
37:07
evidence around a sort of mating that
37:09
sort of mating that people sort of
37:11
have an internal sense of how attractive
37:14
they are and that they end up
37:16
with someone similar to date horizontally and
37:18
up and mandate horizontally and down. So
37:21
if you have two-thirds of women who
37:23
are college grads and one-third of college
37:25
grads who are men and some of
37:28
them are going to date women without
37:30
college degrees, you truly do have this
37:32
dating crisis where there's just not enough
37:35
men to meet this hypergamous mating. Again,
37:37
you can't tell women to lower their
37:39
expectations, but this is the reality. When
37:42
you ask a man, if you could
37:44
have a woman who had 80% of
37:46
everything you wanted, 75% say yeah I'm
37:48
on board when you say to a
37:51
woman a man has 80% of what
37:53
you want 75% say that's that's not
37:55
enough but if you but even look
37:58
at the media right right what is
38:00
the media tell a woman to do
38:02
he's out but he didn't open your
38:05
door he's not nice to his parent
38:07
you'd walk walk right out on that
38:09
man like it's little every piece of
38:12
media is you don't need him you're
38:14
a strong independent woman pull the rip
38:16
cord you're out and it is that
38:19
the the basic kind of communication around
38:21
this is you are a strong independent
38:23
powerful woman that is wonderful and quite
38:26
frankly you don't need the imperfect man
38:28
and they're just not they're just not
38:30
connecting I read that on tender a
38:33
man of average attractiveness has to swipe
38:35
right 200 times to get one coffee,
38:37
and then four of those five coffees
38:40
will ghost him. They will decide, they
38:42
don't want to meet him, or they
38:44
won't show up. That means a guy
38:47
of average attractiveness has to swipe right
38:49
a thousand times to get one coffee.
38:51
Now what does that tell that guy?
38:54
Women don't value me. Women make me
38:56
feel rejected. And then they go online.
38:58
and they see these misogynists telling them
39:00
it's not your fault. And these men
39:03
become much more prone to misogynistic content,
39:05
much more prone to nationalistic content, blaming
39:07
other people for the lack of economic
39:10
opportunity. They start sequestering from society. I
39:12
worry that we are literally evolving a
39:14
new species of asexual, a social male.
39:17
And if a man by the age
39:19
of 30... hasn't either lived with someone
39:21
or married someone, there's a one in
39:24
three chance he's gonna have a substance
39:26
abuse problem. In addition, it goes so
39:28
much deeper than that because if they
39:31
don't develop the skills, you know, the
39:33
reason romantic comedies are two hours and
39:35
not 15 minutes is this shit is
39:38
hard. Like finding an attractive intelligent woman.
39:40
Generally speaking, 75% of people who've been
39:42
married longer than 30 years say in
39:45
the beginning, one was much more interested
39:47
than the man. Women are much chooseer.
39:49
The basis of evolution is seed trying
39:52
to get everywhere, men, and women deploying
39:54
a much finer filter to select the
39:56
strongest smartest and fastest speed. So men
39:59
need an environment. demonstrate excellence. And you
40:01
hear these women talk about it, he
40:03
was kind, he was good at work.
40:06
I like the way smell, he was
40:08
funny. Where do men demonstrate excellence when
40:10
they're not going to college? They're not
40:12
going into an office because of remote
40:15
work. Where do they have, they're not
40:17
going to church, not going to temple?
40:19
Where does a woman have the opportunity
40:22
to fall in love other than these
40:24
baseline metrics? And you were talking about.
40:27
Women say, you've seen these
40:29
stick locks, over $100,000, that's
40:31
not unreasonable, and over six
40:33
feet, that's 2.2% of the
40:35
male population. So where do
40:37
they fall in love? Where
40:39
can a man demonstrate excellence?
40:41
It used to be to
40:44
go to Temple, seven single
40:46
women, seven single men, and
40:48
they kind of cared off
40:50
and worked it out. And
40:52
online dating, similar to online
40:54
e-commerce, online rentals, it's created
40:56
a winner-take-if not all environment.
40:58
And it's basically been amazing
41:00
for attractive guys, attractive wealthy
41:02
guys, tall wealthy guys. It's
41:04
been amazing for them. For
41:06
all the other guys, it's
41:08
been a disaster, and it's
41:10
been made it mildly shittier
41:12
for every woman. The digitization
41:14
of mating, I believe, has
41:16
been a disaster. It's been
41:18
disastrous for men. I
41:20
want to talk about how the gender
41:22
seems to be separating in a lot
41:24
of important ways. We know from research
41:26
around political affiliation that women are now
41:29
on average 30% more liberal than men.
41:31
So they are definitely experiencing political polarization.
41:33
Then for the first time in history,
41:35
more men are attending church than women.
41:37
And when I started this research, I
41:39
really came at it from this point
41:41
of, is it just me or they're
41:43
not as many eligible guys? But when
41:45
I dug into this, I found that
41:47
both genders really feel misunderstood. And so
41:49
I asked men and women who has
41:51
more power in relationships. So equal amounts
41:53
men and women said, oh, we have
41:55
the same amount of power. 42% of
41:58
that. But then what was so interesting
42:00
is that 46% of men said women
42:02
have more power and 46% of women
42:04
said men have more power. So there's
42:06
this huge feeling of oh the other
42:08
gender has all of this power. And
42:10
when I spoke to people I want
42:12
to tell you about three dating paradoxes
42:14
that I saw. So the first dating
42:16
paradox for men is this idea that
42:18
now that women are providers and do
42:20
not need a man to take care
42:22
of them financially. They really want guys
42:25
to step up with emotional support. But
42:27
here's the paradox. They were not raised
42:29
and they don't know how to give
42:31
that emotional support or emotional availability. So
42:33
we know women, even if they have
42:35
the same number of friends as guys,
42:37
the women are talking to their friends
42:39
much more often. Women speak. to their
42:41
kids, even starting at a very young
42:43
age. They use more emotional language with
42:45
their daughters and their sons. So constantly
42:47
we have this feeling where we're asking
42:49
men to do something when they don't
42:52
have the skills. I was talking to
42:54
my friend David and he said, women
42:56
are in graduate school when it comes
42:58
to emotional conversations and guys are in
43:00
third grade. The other part of the
43:02
paradox is that women are asking men
43:04
to be more emotionally open, but then
43:06
they get shamed when they do that.
43:08
So we have this great quote from
43:10
Brene Brown, where she says, we beg
43:12
guys to open up, we beg them
43:14
to let us in, and then when
43:16
they do, we can't stomach it. And
43:19
I heard that over and over in
43:21
my research. There's this quote where a
43:23
guy says, a woman would rather see
43:25
me die on the white horse than
43:27
fall off of it. And so there's
43:29
this sense that I have to be
43:31
perfect. I have to be the masculine
43:33
and the feminine, but I don't have
43:35
the skills to do that. And women
43:37
say that they want these guys to
43:39
be emotional, but as soon as they
43:41
show emotionality, it can freak those women
43:43
out. So one guy that I spoke
43:45
to for this said, I went on
43:48
a few dates with this woman. At
43:50
some point I told her that my
43:52
mom had had a suicide attempt. And
43:54
the next day she texted me and
43:56
said, I'm sorry, I can't process your
43:58
emotional trauma for you. And so guys
44:00
are getting a lot of mixed messages.
44:02
We want you to be feminine. want
44:04
you to support us, but when you
44:06
do, it freaks us out and so
44:08
we don't want that. And digging into
44:10
the research and I want to look
44:12
into this more, I think it's that
44:15
a lot of women want emotional support.
44:17
They want you to support them in
44:19
their emotional journeys, but they're not as
44:21
ready to have you open up in
44:23
your emotional journey. Can I put forward
44:25
a thesis and I want you to
44:27
respond to it because I haven't done
44:29
the research? And what women say they
44:31
want is an emotionally untouched man, and
44:33
what they want is a masculine man.
44:35
And that they will articulate what they
44:37
want in a man, and includes being
44:39
more emotionally available, and then they want
44:42
to have sex with a traditional masculine
44:44
man. And what I hear from a
44:46
lot of, and this is anecdotal evidence,
44:48
and it's pulse marketing, and you tell
44:50
me what the data says, but there's
44:52
just so many single women in my
44:54
age group. And it feels like there's
44:56
literally no men in my age group.
44:58
As bad as it is for people
45:00
in their 20s and 30s, try being
45:02
a woman in your 50s trying today,
45:04
right? And they tell me the same
45:06
thing. These are liberal, progressive, educated women.
45:09
They say, boy, I like a manly
45:11
man. And they say it under their
45:13
breath. So there's what supposedly is stated
45:15
around, I need more emotional availability, someone's
45:17
touch with their feelings, but what the
45:19
research shows is they want a guy
45:21
with facial hair. who's the still women
45:23
are still very attracted to traditional masculine
45:25
attributes. Yeah, I mean, I think we're
45:27
just in such a hard moment because
45:29
you have women who are saying, I
45:31
don't want to date a guy who
45:33
earns less than me. And you might
45:36
think, okay, well, the data hasn't caught
45:38
up with the dating. If more women
45:40
are in higher education and more women
45:42
are earning more, then maybe you're going
45:44
to be. the one who earns more
45:46
in your relationship. But what they feel
45:48
like is projecting out, I'm gonna end
45:50
up doing most of the housework, most
45:52
of the child care, I might as
45:54
well get a guy that can contribute
45:56
financially. So they don't wanna change their
45:58
ex. expectations around that. And so I
46:00
think we truly are in a moment
46:02
where women are being asked to do
46:05
more masculine things and men are being
46:07
asked to do more feminine things. And
46:09
I think a lot of that is
46:11
progress, but it also seems to be
46:13
creating a lot of confusion in the
46:15
dating world. Yeah, it's sort of, I
46:17
was just thinking, I coach a lot
46:19
of young men and occasionally women asked
46:21
me for data advice and you coach,
46:23
it sounds like a lot of both.
46:25
Are you in shape? What do you
46:27
look like naked? Do you have a
46:29
plan? You don't have to be rich
46:32
now, but do you have a plan?
46:34
Have you found means of being confident?
46:36
Can you demonstrate kindness and excellence across
46:38
anything? And the only investigative women is
46:40
second coffee. And that is, maybe it
46:42
wasn't great. I mean, if you don't
46:44
like the guy and you're just like
46:46
turned off fine. But if it was
46:48
just okay... Maybe give it a second
46:50
coffee. I have a chapter in my
46:52
book called Make the Second Date, the
46:54
default. And it's really because I feel
46:56
like I won the lottery with my
46:59
husband, but he is somebody that takes
47:01
longer to open up, and he's the
47:03
slow burn. We met in college, we
47:05
met again seven years later, then we
47:07
were friends for a year, and I
47:09
feel like he's this incredible partner, husband,
47:11
father, but I don't know that if
47:13
we'd met just randomly on the first
47:15
date that I would have gone on
47:17
the second date that I would have
47:19
gone on a second date. Logan, Scott
47:21
said something there about what he thinks
47:23
women want, which is these sort of
47:26
traditional masculine features. Is this what you
47:28
see in the data? What's hard is
47:30
I think Scott's right about what people
47:32
say they want versus... So stated versus
47:34
revealed preferences. So according to the research
47:36
that I did, women are saying the
47:38
number one thing that they're looking for
47:40
is kindness and compassion. That's also what
47:42
men are saying that they're looking for.
47:44
So in many ways, this is great.
47:46
People are looking for the same things.
47:48
But I just feel like there's these
47:50
huge disconnects now where people don't feel
47:53
like they can get what they want.
47:55
Men are saying they want kindness and
47:57
compassion. That was, I made them say,
47:59
what are all... the things that you
48:01
care about and then what is the
48:03
number one thing that you care about
48:05
and kindness and compassion was
48:07
first for both of them? The
48:09
stuff I've seen or the stuff I've
48:11
read is that for women and I've
48:13
talked to men about this number one
48:16
is they have to signal resources and
48:18
we don't like to say it out
48:20
loud and by the way it doesn't
48:22
necessarily mean you have to have a
48:25
range over and a panel right now
48:27
but you have to be up for work.
48:29
You work out, which shows a level of
48:31
discipline and that you can commit to
48:33
something. You're in school. You've got a good
48:35
job. This person is going to have resources.
48:38
And I don't think that's changed a
48:40
whole lot. I think a man's ability
48:42
to signal future resources has gone down.
48:44
I'm not sure it's become any less
48:47
of a criteria. Number two is intellect.
48:49
And it's very instinctual, because if you
48:51
make good decisions for the tribe, your
48:53
kids are more likely to survive.
48:56
Someone. is more likely to take
48:58
care of your offspring than someone
49:00
is stupid. What's interesting, and I
49:02
love this, is the fastest way
49:04
to communicate intellect is humor.
49:06
And I joke, and this is bad, but
49:08
I say this is my impression of a
49:11
woman. I'm laughing, I'm laughing, I'm naked. And
49:13
that is, I both thought, if a guy
49:15
can make a woman laugh, she will date
49:17
him. And then the third thing, and
49:19
this is where guys screw up. This
49:21
is what I tell a guy's secret
49:23
weapon is. It's kindness. Women want to
49:25
see that you are a good person. You treat
49:28
service staff well. You're good to
49:30
your parents. You have manners. You
49:32
treat people well even with no
49:34
reciprocal expectation. Because they know that
49:37
a kind person, if and when
49:39
she's vulnerable, and needs help,
49:41
and maybe isn't bringing in as
49:43
much to the table for certain
49:45
periods of time, that this is a kind
49:47
man. And, you know, sure, you want to
49:49
do your best to signal resources
49:51
and have a plan, sure. Maybe you're
49:54
smart, maybe you aren't, there's not a lot
49:56
you can do there. But the secret weapon I think
49:58
for men that they don't leverage... And I
50:00
do think it's a practice is to
50:02
demonstrate kindness. And we don't talk about
50:04
that enough as men. It's like, well,
50:06
okay, in its little things, have good
50:08
manners, be thoughtful, follow up with people.
50:10
And I think that, anyways, those are
50:13
the three things that I have read,
50:15
women want in men. Okay, there's so
50:17
much there. So one is I do
50:19
think we need a new definition for
50:21
modern masculinity or mature masculinity or evolved
50:23
masculinity, and I think that that's why
50:25
this moment feels so painful is that
50:27
we don't have it. Because I agree
50:29
with you, I don't think women are
50:31
saying I want a feminine man. I
50:33
think they want a modern masculine man.
50:35
And so that means somebody who is
50:38
decisive and can provide, but also somebody
50:40
who's able to communicate with them emotionally.
50:42
And so one of the suggestions that
50:44
I came here today to talk about
50:46
is this idea of men's groups. So
50:48
about a year ago, my friend David
50:50
Clavins, who happens to be a world-class
50:52
magician, came to my husband and said,
50:54
I'm going to form this men's group.
50:56
And so it's about six or seven
50:58
men, and they meet together monthly, and
51:00
they have served They have formed this
51:02
council of peers. So every month that
51:05
they get together, every guy sits down
51:07
with Post-it notes and says the two
51:09
issues that are most pressing for him.
51:11
So first of all, I think that
51:13
that's a great way of doing it
51:15
because it's actually that time to say,
51:17
what am I struggling with? I think
51:19
many people in their lives, maybe especially
51:21
men, don't sit there and say, what's
51:23
top of mind for me? So guys
51:25
get the quiet time to do that.
51:27
Then they go around in a circle
51:29
and whoever has the most pressing issue,
51:32
they get to take their time. And
51:34
some men might say, you know, these
51:36
are top of mind for me, but
51:38
it's not a priority. I'll give the
51:40
time to someone else. And each month,
51:42
they talk about what's going on for
51:44
them. They hold each other accountable, they
51:46
hold each other accountable accountable. And I
51:48
love that these men have a masculine
51:50
space to actually go through what's going
51:52
on for them, because maybe they have
51:54
wives and girlfriends. can go to. Maybe
51:56
they don't, but I think it's a
51:59
different type of advice that you get
52:01
from a council of trusted peers. And
52:03
I really do think that men's groups
52:05
could change a lot of these issues
52:07
because I can sit here and say
52:09
everybody should be in therapy. Guess what?
52:11
Therapy's really expensive and many insurance companies
52:13
will not provide it or there's a
52:15
huge waiting list. And so if we
52:17
just sit around for all these guys
52:19
to go to therapy, that's not going
52:21
to tribe of peers and I have
52:23
just seen so many changes in this
52:26
group. So David told me his story
52:28
where he had a lot of anger
52:30
about his mom's debilitating illness and he
52:32
wasn't really experiencing it and it was
52:34
coming out as anger at his mom,
52:36
but he wasn't conscious of that. But
52:38
by getting the anger out in a
52:40
safe place with men, the only place
52:42
where he felt like he could truly
52:44
be angry, he was able to get
52:46
over it and to actually treat his
52:48
mom with a lot more empathy. Or
52:51
my husband has gone to the group
52:53
and talked about ego stuff at work
52:55
or how hard the transition to becoming
52:57
a parent has been. And I feel
52:59
like the men in this group have
53:01
grown so much over the 12 months
53:03
that it's been happening that I just
53:05
paid for my brother-in-law to be at
53:07
a men's group. And I want there
53:09
to be tons of men's groups because
53:11
I really feel like this isn't an
53:13
issue that a therapist or a mom
53:15
or I can really solve. I think
53:18
men need to be solving this problem
53:20
within themselves. What you said is really
53:22
powerful because if you walk down the
53:24
hallway at Stern, there's golden seeds, venture
53:26
cap, women in venture capital, black women's
53:28
consulting club, there are women's support. There's
53:30
nothing for men. And these groups are
53:32
really wonderful. Man talks is one that
53:34
I've been looking at where they've said,
53:36
let's get together and just be supportive
53:38
of each other. And it's a fairly...
53:40
new phenomena. I think people are afraid
53:42
of men gathering because traditionally bad things
53:45
have happened in that. I mean gangs,
53:47
I'm just thinking of like many situations
53:49
in which like if once there's a...
53:51
torch I want there to be some
53:53
women there right like so there's a
53:55
reason why people have been fearful of
53:57
this or it's like when the whole
53:59
world was a men's group the men's
54:01
club you didn't need to have men's
54:03
clubs but I think in this moment
54:05
this is a really powerful organic grassroots
54:07
way for men to change so I
54:09
imagine that you have group chats with
54:12
men that are your peers that you
54:14
go to for advice and I feel
54:16
like there's men out there that don't
54:18
have that and we are meant to
54:20
make decisions by getting advice from other
54:22
people. I personally have a board of
54:24
directors that in my life when I'm
54:26
going to make a big decision, I
54:28
meet with them. So when I took
54:30
my last job, when I decided to
54:32
move, all these different things, I meet
54:34
with my board of directors and I
54:36
say, what am I not seeing? What
54:39
are my blind spots? And they've given
54:41
me a lot of good and hard
54:43
advice. And I think we all need
54:45
to be building our own board of
54:47
directors and for men that might be
54:49
this men's group. Do you mind if
54:51
I pause this conversation for a moment?
54:53
I want to talk about art. show
54:55
sponsor today which is Shopify. I've always
54:57
believed that the biggest cost in business
54:59
isn't failure, it's the time you waste
55:01
trying to make decisions. Time spent hesitating,
55:04
overthinking, or waiting for the right moment.
55:06
When I started my first company at
55:08
20 years old I had no experience
55:10
and no money. What I did have
55:12
was an idea and the willingness to
55:14
move fast and that made all the
55:16
difference. If you've been thinking about starting
55:18
your own business, Shopify makes this entire
55:20
process so much easier. With thousands of
55:22
customizable or design, skills, you just need
55:24
a willingness to start. Shopify connects all
55:26
your sales channels from your website to
55:28
social media and it handles the back-end
55:31
payments, shipping and taxes too, so that
55:33
you can stay focused on moving forward
55:35
and growing your business. If you're ready
55:37
to start, visit shopify.com/Bartlett and sign up
55:39
for a one pound per month trial
55:41
period. That shopify.com/Bartlett. It is hard is
55:43
it. as a young man to share
55:45
how you feel with other young men,
55:47
even if they're like your best friends,
55:49
it's so much easier to roast each
55:51
other. Yeah. Like my group chat with
55:53
my... is probably a little bit more
55:55
advanced in it in terms of emotional
55:58
openness, but most of it is just
56:00
like a war zone. We're like criticizing
56:02
each other, attacking each other, but that's
56:04
kind of our way of showing love.
56:06
And then you'll have, once every two
56:08
weeks, someone will be going through something.
56:10
So like one of my friends now,
56:12
they've just found out that there's a
56:14
complication with the pregnancy and the tone
56:16
shifts, and we'll become supportive. switch from
56:18
like trying to kill each other in
56:20
the most like funny way to being
56:22
really really emotionally supportive a lot of
56:25
men don't have that. Well so funny
56:27
that you said that because my husband's
56:29
really funny and so are some of
56:31
the other guys in the group and
56:33
they actually had to talk about how
56:35
they needed to be less funny because
56:37
the fun the humor was becoming a
56:39
distraction and somebody brought up you know
56:41
in their own male way like I
56:43
think that sometimes we're about to go
56:45
deep and then someone makes a joke
56:47
and even though that joke was really
56:49
good we don't go back to where
56:52
we were and we don't go as
56:54
deep so they actually work on being
56:56
less funny in that group but look
56:58
at the work that you do you
57:00
sit for hours a week and you
57:02
learn and you ask people questions and
57:04
you're working on yourself I'm not surprised
57:06
that you have a group of peers
57:08
that you can go to for that
57:10
but I would wager that the average
57:12
man doesn't have that the average man
57:14
doesn't have that and I feel like
57:17
there are going to be so many
57:19
women who are listening and watching this,
57:21
and they're like, I want that for
57:23
my husband. What is the evolutionary basis
57:25
for this? This is what I was
57:27
thinking the whole time. I was like,
57:29
did we lose the man's group at
57:31
some point in our past? And is
57:33
that why we're adding it back into
57:35
our lives? Like, what was, what used
57:37
to do this job before? So what
57:39
I've heard, and I think evolutionary biology,
57:41
you always have to take certain things
57:44
of the grand assault, because people can
57:46
kind of explain things of the grand
57:48
assault, because people can kind of explaining,
57:50
a lot of times men were sitting
57:52
next to each other and they were
57:54
having these conversations on the savanna and
57:56
that's often why like guys prefer to
57:58
do activities side by side and not
58:00
facing each other and so you had
58:02
men who were in conversation with their
58:04
peers or you know and outside and
58:06
outside yeah hey heard you getting divorced
58:08
right Right, or it's like, you know,
58:11
why it's so good to have conversations
58:13
in the car. I feel like you
58:15
had a lot of men that were
58:17
in groups at church. You had men
58:19
who were in the Elts Club, you
58:21
had veterans that were meeting. We actually
58:23
feel like this is a time where
58:25
much fewer men are getting together. And
58:27
this is all of the amazing research
58:29
that's happening now around loneliness, is that
58:31
the average young guy is spending many
58:33
fewer hours a week with their peers
58:35
face-to-face. that's the same thing. And so
58:38
I feel like we need this in-person
58:40
time with our friends to develop these
58:42
relationships and instead we have people on
58:44
TikTok, people on Twitter, watching other people
58:46
live their lives. You brought up two
58:48
interesting things. When is your your your
58:50
friend group? I have a similar group.
58:52
Same eight guys I live with my
58:54
freshman year at UCLA. For 30 or
58:56
40 years we've been kind of constant
58:58
contact email now on what's up. When...
59:00
Your friend had something bad happen to
59:02
him. I think for a long time
59:05
men have weighed in and stood empathy
59:07
for each other. What none of my
59:09
male friends have ever done, their friend
59:11
group would say, is I've never heard
59:13
one of my male friends go, I'm
59:15
depressed. I'm just super fucking lonely and
59:17
depressed. You just don't hear that from
59:19
them. I'm struggling with anger. I'm, I
59:21
have, all of a sudden, I have
59:23
erect all this function. You would just,
59:25
I've never heard one of my male
59:27
friend. when their mom dies or they
59:30
get divorced we weigh in with a
59:32
lot of empathy but you never hear
59:34
them really open up because men are
59:36
worried that if we display weakness another
59:38
man might kill us and take our
59:40
shit from us or the women aren't
59:42
going to want to have sex with
59:44
us so there's still I think a
59:46
huge inability for men to proactively talk
59:48
about how they're really feeling and then
59:50
you talked about a board of directors
59:52
a great board of directors for a
59:54
man in his 20s unfortunately Not unfortunately,
59:57
is a girlfriend. Yeah. And I'll just
59:59
use personal experience. I had a great
1:00:01
girlfriend when I was 24, and she basically
1:00:03
said to me, if you don't stop getting
1:00:05
high every night, I'm going to stop having
1:00:08
sex with you. That was very motivating
1:00:10
for me. I really liked being with
1:00:12
a partner. Without the guardrails of
1:00:14
a romantic relationship, I think
1:00:16
men are just, I don't want to say, lost,
1:00:18
but women create more social
1:00:20
connections outside of a romantic
1:00:23
relationship. And sometimes that absence
1:00:25
of a romantic relationship, they
1:00:27
pour that energy... into friendships and
1:00:29
their professional life, whereas men start
1:00:31
pouring it into video games and
1:00:34
read it and porn. So the fact that
1:00:36
only one in three men in America
1:00:38
under the age of 30 has a
1:00:40
girlfriend and two in three women has
1:00:43
a boyfriend, you think, well that's mathematically
1:00:45
impossible. It's not because women are
1:00:47
dating older, because they want more
1:00:49
economically and emotionally viable men. If
1:00:51
I hadn't been in relationships that were
1:00:54
great guardrails for me in terms of
1:00:56
my own behavior, my own ambition, Without
1:00:58
the prospect or the existence
1:01:00
of a romantic relationship, men
1:01:02
have worse outcomes than women
1:01:05
who don't have. And do you agree with
1:01:07
what I'm saying? Does the research
1:01:09
bear that out? You know, it's
1:01:11
interesting because part of me where my
1:01:13
head goes is like, are you asking
1:01:15
women to do the emotional labor of
1:01:17
raising men? And when you phrase it like
1:01:20
that... it sounds really negative, but from anecdotal experience
1:01:22
from my own life, you know, I've been with
1:01:24
my husband for 10 years, I think we both
1:01:26
really shaped each other. But like even yesterday, he
1:01:28
text me and he's like, I'm going to get
1:01:31
an Uber instead of renting a car at the
1:01:33
airport. You've taught me how to be such a
1:01:35
savvy traveler. Like that's a small example, but it's
1:01:37
like you really do influence each other. And I
1:01:40
think that I think sometimes about my single friends
1:01:42
and how they go to bed at night and
1:01:44
they don't have a person next to them to
1:01:46
give them advice and to listen to them talk
1:01:49
about their day. And I think that
1:01:51
when we're in long-term relationships there's
1:01:53
an element of raising each other
1:01:55
and building memories together and making
1:01:57
each other better and having that
1:01:59
investment. Right. That's why I just all
1:02:01
these women that come to me and
1:02:03
all these men that are looking for
1:02:05
love that want relationships and something is
1:02:08
happening right now where the gap just
1:02:10
seems to be widening and these relationships
1:02:12
aren't happening. And this is even true
1:02:14
in teenage relationships. So it used to
1:02:16
be that for baby boomers and Gen
1:02:18
X, three quarters of men had had
1:02:21
a relationship in their teen years. And
1:02:23
now it's... under 50%. And so if
1:02:25
you start building your relational skills at
1:02:27
an early age, then you get better
1:02:29
and better at dating over time. But
1:02:31
if, as you said, by the time
1:02:34
you're 30, you haven't been in a
1:02:36
relationship. That's seen as a red flag
1:02:38
to a lot of people. And so
1:02:40
I think we have a problem now,
1:02:42
but I'm really projecting that we're going
1:02:44
to have a much greater problem in
1:02:47
the future. for people in their 20s
1:02:49
that we haven't talked a lot about.
1:02:51
I had Dr. Analemke from Stanford on
1:02:53
my pod talking about addiction and something
1:02:55
we're just starting to come to grips
1:02:57
with and as I read more about
1:03:00
it, I think porn is really... Let's
1:03:02
talk about porn. Well, personal experience. I
1:03:04
used to go on camp and the
1:03:06
only reason I graduated from UCLA, I
1:03:08
graduated with a 2.27 GPA. If I
1:03:10
graduated with a 1.97, I wouldn't graduate
1:03:13
it. Not an it not the only
1:03:15
motivator but a real motivator for me
1:03:17
was the prospect of meeting someone I
1:03:19
could go on to campus and there
1:03:21
might be a chance I'd meet friends
1:03:23
be social and Possibly meet a potential
1:03:26
romantic partner. It was very motivating and
1:03:28
if I'd had porn on this and
1:03:30
on my screen always available I'm not
1:03:32
sure I would have gone on campus.
1:03:34
I would just would have spent a
1:03:36
lot more time at home And unfortunately
1:03:39
the deepest pocketed most talented companies in
1:03:41
the world are trying to convince young
1:03:43
people that they can have a reasonable
1:03:45
facsimile of life on a screen with
1:03:47
an algorithm. And what I say to
1:03:49
young men I coach is it, I'm
1:03:52
not going to tell you not to
1:03:54
consume porn, but try to modulate it
1:03:56
because I think that fire of wanting
1:03:58
to meet... someone and wanting to demonstrate
1:04:00
excellence and being, having perseverance and enduring
1:04:02
rejection and getting your shit together and
1:04:05
dressing well and smelling nice and showering
1:04:07
for God's sakes, that mojo that desire
1:04:09
is incredibly important for society and we're
1:04:11
taking young men's mojo away with frictionless
1:04:13
open access on-demand porn. Have you seen
1:04:15
these no-fap communities? Yeah. Have you seen
1:04:18
this? Yes. Okay, so I was listening
1:04:20
to this episode of Modern William, Chris
1:04:22
Williamson, and he was interviewing Hamza, who
1:04:24
was self-identifying as a former red-pilled person.
1:04:26
And he was talking about how much
1:04:28
it changed his life to try to
1:04:31
enter the no-fap community. Which means no
1:04:33
masturbation. And so I do think that
1:04:35
porn is a huge problem. My first
1:04:37
job out of college. was running the
1:04:39
porn pod for Google. So what this
1:04:41
meant was that we would sell ads
1:04:44
for the porn advertisers. This team does
1:04:46
not exist anymore. This was a long
1:04:48
time ago. My parents were like, I
1:04:50
sent you to Harvard and now you're
1:04:52
selling ads for pornography. But. When I
1:04:54
look back, I'm like, what was I
1:04:57
perpetuating? Because I feel like there's just
1:04:59
so many problems with what technology is
1:05:01
doing in terms of replacing human connection.
1:05:03
So let's just project out. Chat TPT
1:05:05
is already amazing. I'm currently in my
1:05:07
Google feed getting ads for replica. And
1:05:10
the ads say, get your perfect AI
1:05:12
boyfriend, always there for you. So you
1:05:14
think about the fact that. Real life
1:05:16
relationships are messy. I tell my husband
1:05:18
on a weekly basis, please throw your
1:05:20
contact lens in the garbage. And every
1:05:23
week we have a disagreement about that.
1:05:25
Well, guess what? Your online girlfriend, she
1:05:27
doesn't mag you. She doesn't tell you
1:05:29
to pick up your socks. She only
1:05:31
tells you how great you are and
1:05:33
always tells you that you're doing the
1:05:36
right thing and how was your day.
1:05:38
Then you insert sex robots. Okay, so
1:05:40
you have your emotional needs met. Maybe
1:05:42
you're watching porn. while engaging with your
1:05:44
sex robots? Why would you want to
1:05:46
go through the very challenging potential rejection
1:05:48
of real-life relationships? And I feel like
1:05:51
if all these things come to pass,
1:05:53
which it seems very likely that they
1:05:55
will, we are truly in a crisis
1:05:57
moment when it comes to birth rate
1:05:59
and future generations. And it impacts them,
1:06:01
it'll impact the economy because the skills
1:06:04
you have to develop to be successful
1:06:06
in the mating market are life skills.
1:06:08
You have to be able to endure
1:06:10
rejection. You have to have a sense
1:06:12
of humor. You have to be able
1:06:14
to read the room. Show me a
1:06:17
guy who's good in a bar. I'll
1:06:19
see a guy probably be good in
1:06:21
a boardroom. And the skills you have
1:06:23
to develop as a young man, if
1:06:25
you want a romantic and a sexual
1:06:27
relationship, pay dividends the rest of your
1:06:30
life. And if you don't develop those
1:06:32
skills, I think it impacts your life
1:06:34
across a bunch of dimensions. This is
1:06:36
something I'm worried about for Gen Z
1:06:38
in general. So I did a ton
1:06:40
of research with post-pandemic Gen Z dataers,
1:06:43
men and women in the UK and
1:06:45
the United States. And such a big
1:06:47
theme that came out of it was
1:06:49
that they don't have rejection resilience. And
1:06:51
I think that we hear this in
1:06:53
many aspects of life. So someone that
1:06:56
I'm close to, he's the former Dean
1:06:58
of Brown, he's a professor of It
1:07:00
used to be that his office hours
1:07:02
were empty and that's when he could
1:07:04
do his reading or play solitaire. But
1:07:06
now students come basically saying, tell me
1:07:09
exactly what's going to be on the
1:07:11
test. Tell me exactly what to write
1:07:13
in my paper because they are not
1:07:15
willing to fail. I have friends who
1:07:17
are managers at Google and they give
1:07:19
somebody feedback in a Google doc and
1:07:22
the person is crying because they take
1:07:24
that as extreme rejection. And so if
1:07:26
you don't have the resilience built up
1:07:28
to fail, then you are not going
1:07:30
to take riskss. And so I feel
1:07:32
that I have my dream job. Nobody
1:07:35
messaged me on LinkedIn and said, hey
1:07:37
Logan, do you want to study dating
1:07:39
and relationships? No, I invented this job
1:07:41
and now I get to have it.
1:07:43
And same thing is true with relationships.
1:07:45
It's not about waiting for the perfect
1:07:48
person to show up. It's about becoming
1:07:50
a great person who somebody else chooses.
1:07:52
and going after what you want. I
1:07:54
want to talk about all of this,
1:07:56
and it specifically offers some solutions to
1:07:58
the young, to the parents, to the
1:08:01
boys, to the men that are listening.
1:08:03
We had a young man actually write
1:08:05
in on this subject, and he said,
1:08:07
I've suffered with crippling loneliness, and so
1:08:09
I've spent over $1,000 hiring women online
1:08:11
just to talk to me and to
1:08:14
keep me company. On top of that,
1:08:16
I've spent several thousand dollars more engaging
1:08:18
in other business with them. After doing
1:08:20
this for nearly a year now, I
1:08:22
still feel incredibly unfulfilled. And on the
1:08:24
subject of porn, 30% of internet traffic
1:08:27
is now related to porn. With about
1:08:29
80% of that porn traffic coming from
1:08:31
men and 20% coming from women, I
1:08:33
actually had a conversation on this podcast
1:08:35
before about porn. And finally enough, the
1:08:37
top comment was, by the way, us
1:08:40
women, what get porn addicted to. Because
1:08:42
it was a bit of a blind
1:08:44
spot to me, but I think that's
1:08:46
something that's worth acknowledging. And the stats
1:08:48
are staggering in terms of how higher
1:08:50
porn consumption correlates to higher probabilities of
1:08:53
depression. What do you do about it?
1:08:55
Like on an individual level, I get
1:08:57
it, try not to watch porn, but
1:08:59
I mean, that doesn't seem like incredibly
1:09:01
great advice because if you're lonely, you're
1:09:03
not getting laid. No one wants to
1:09:06
date you for all the reasons we've
1:09:08
talked about today. Restraint seems to be
1:09:10
a pretty shitty solution. Okay, so I
1:09:12
coach young men I take two to
1:09:14
three on at any time, and I
1:09:16
don't know if this is a right
1:09:19
way But it's my way. I'm like
1:09:21
you got to lean into your advantage
1:09:23
when you're our age you have more
1:09:25
You have capital you have more money
1:09:27
than time. They have capital they have
1:09:29
a lot of time and I ask
1:09:32
them to unlock their screen and I
1:09:34
say to them I gamble with options
1:09:36
I gamble and my age I still
1:09:38
gamble I preach about low-cost index funds
1:09:40
and I buy call options it's gambling,
1:09:42
but I know it I watch porn.
1:09:44
I try and modulate my use so
1:09:47
I can put the majority of my
1:09:49
sexual energy into my partner, but I
1:09:51
watch porn. Because I want them to
1:09:53
not feel like I'm going to judge
1:09:55
them. And they unlock their phone. And
1:09:57
I say, we're going to... find eight
1:10:00
to 12 hours. And then we're going
1:10:02
to reinvest that capital and
1:10:04
we're going to reinvest that capital
1:10:06
and hire ROI investments. It is so
1:10:08
easy to find eight to 12 hours. I can sometimes
1:10:11
find seven hours or 15 hours
1:10:13
just in TikTok. You look at screen
1:10:15
time. I look at screen time and I say,
1:10:17
all right, come through with me, we're going to
1:10:19
find eight to 12 hours. And then we're going
1:10:21
to reinvest that capital and
1:10:23
three investments. One, we're going to
1:10:25
start working out and getting fit. You're
1:10:28
going to work out three times a week with weights.
1:10:30
You should be able, the human male form is
1:10:32
spectacular. You should be able to walk
1:10:34
into any room under the age of 30 if you're
1:10:36
a man, and know that if shit got real you
1:10:39
could kill and eat everybody or outrun them. I
1:10:41
need you to be strong. You're going to be
1:10:43
more mentally healthy. You're going to
1:10:45
be kinder. Look at the people who
1:10:47
break up fights at bars. They're big
1:10:50
strong men. Look at the people who
1:10:52
defend their country. You want to be
1:10:54
strong as a man? It feels fucking
1:10:56
amazing. Testosterone, your bone structure, your muscle
1:10:59
mass, it's amazing. Lean into that. We're
1:11:01
going to get strong. Two, you've
1:11:03
got to start making some money.
1:11:05
And the kids, you know, to be honest,
1:11:07
the kids I'm coaching are
1:11:09
really struggling. These are kids at home
1:11:11
at the age of 23 with their mom,
1:11:14
not getting along with their mom. Nothing
1:11:16
going on. If you have a phone, you
1:11:18
can make money. I don't care if it's
1:11:20
lift, task rocket, because you get a taste
1:11:22
for the flesh. And the way to start
1:11:24
making a lot of money is to start
1:11:26
making a little bit of money. Because you
1:11:28
start to figure out the economy, how could
1:11:30
I make more money? Maybe at some point,
1:11:32
could I buy a car and hire a
1:11:34
driver to be an oob? What is the way?
1:11:37
Could I get a certification in plump? You
1:11:39
start figuring out and you start getting your
1:11:41
gregelands get going, oh my God, it's awesome
1:11:43
money. I can go to a concert. It
1:11:46
gets those Greek guns going and then the
1:11:48
third thing we're going to do is we're
1:11:50
going to put ourselves in the company
1:11:52
of strangers in the agency of something
1:11:54
bigger than ourselves twice a week. Church
1:11:56
groups, softball league, non-profit, chair,
1:11:59
whatever it is. And then, 3A, and
1:12:01
this is, I just started doing this,
1:12:03
I believe in it two times, and
1:12:05
it's an exercise, and I say, and
1:12:07
it goes to your, I think no
1:12:09
is the weight to success. Show me
1:12:12
someone who's successful, I'm gonna show you
1:12:14
a shit ton of nose. I've been,
1:12:16
I ran for sophomore, junior, senior, class
1:12:18
president, lost, I applied to 38 jobs,
1:12:20
I got one offer, nine schools, rejected
1:12:22
by seven. And that's why I'm successful,
1:12:24
is I was able to endure it.
1:12:27
So I said, this is what I
1:12:29
want you to do. I need you
1:12:31
to go up to a stranger at
1:12:33
wherever we're doing, church group, rider club,
1:12:35
riders club, whatever it might be, online
1:12:37
education, not online, excuse me, education, continuing
1:12:39
education, and you're gonna ask them out
1:12:42
for coffee, it's a friend. Hey, what
1:12:44
are you doing? You wanna watch the
1:12:46
game? Do you wanna watch the Liverpool
1:12:48
game? Let's the Liverpool. The goal is
1:12:50
no. And we're going to celebrate no.
1:12:52
Because you're going to call me and
1:12:54
I'm going to say, did you ask
1:12:57
someone out for coffee or to a
1:12:59
bar? And most likely, they'll have said
1:13:01
no. It'll be polite. They'll become excused.
1:13:03
And then I'm going to ask you
1:13:05
if you're OK. And you're going to
1:13:07
say yes. And that's the victory. It's
1:13:09
interesting, because if you go on Tech
1:13:12
Talk or if you go on X,
1:13:14
you'll find a lot of videos of.
1:13:16
women filming themselves as a guy inappropriately
1:13:18
came and made a gesture to them
1:13:20
and then like publicly shaming them on
1:13:22
the internet. It's very popular to do
1:13:24
it in the gym. They set up
1:13:27
a phone, they're working out, a guy
1:13:29
comes over and asks if they need
1:13:31
help with the weights, it then goes
1:13:33
viral online because that guy was being
1:13:35
inappropriate. Like you shouldn't. So like as
1:13:37
a guy it's quite complicated to know
1:13:40
how and where you can roll up
1:13:42
without being filmed and going viral. So
1:13:44
we talked about the first dating paradox,
1:13:46
which is the idea that women now
1:13:48
need more for men and are raising
1:13:50
the bar because they can be providers
1:13:52
on their own, but men weren't taught
1:13:55
how to do that and they're sometimes
1:13:57
shame for it. So I think the
1:13:59
second big dating paradox is that men
1:14:01
are expected to lead and to approach,
1:14:03
but I truly feel like in a
1:14:05
post- me too era, era, it's much
1:14:07
more confusing. And so so many people
1:14:10
say to me, I don't want to
1:14:12
meet on an app that's not romantic,
1:14:14
I want to meet in real life.
1:14:16
But I'm not finding that people are
1:14:18
meeting in real life because people are
1:14:20
afraid to approach each other. I think
1:14:22
one is being afraid of being called
1:14:25
creepy, but the other one, which is
1:14:27
what you're talking about, is that this
1:14:29
culture of making Tik Talks or going
1:14:31
online with this data. There's a lot
1:14:33
of women waiting for men to approach
1:14:35
them, but then shaming the men who
1:14:37
do. I think one of the solutions
1:14:40
there is we should allow people to
1:14:42
shoot their shot in a non-creepy way.
1:14:44
Can I just say something to that?
1:14:46
If the guy rolls up and he's
1:14:48
six, four and he's, you know, gorgeous,
1:14:50
it's fine, it seems. The difference between
1:14:52
creepy and romantic is the perceived attractiveness
1:14:55
of the person making the overture. I
1:14:57
think that that is true. If you
1:14:59
are super hot, it's less likely to
1:15:01
be perceived as creepy. But you have
1:15:03
all these people that are saying, I
1:15:05
want to be approached and they're not
1:15:08
being approached. And so there was this
1:15:10
rise of run clubs last summer, right?
1:15:12
Everyone said, the new dating app is
1:15:14
the run club. I asked everywhere I
1:15:16
go, have you met someone at a
1:15:18
run club? No, people are not really
1:15:20
meeting there. So since 2017, the number
1:15:23
one way that people are meeting is
1:15:25
meeting, want more things to happen offline,
1:15:27
they actually have to approach each other.
1:15:29
And I'm just not seeing that happen.
1:15:31
But my understanding is the majority of
1:15:33
women still expect the man to take
1:15:35
the initiative. Absolutely. And this is one
1:15:38
of the most frightening stats I've seen.
1:15:40
According to Pew, more than 50% of
1:15:42
men between the ages of 18 and
1:15:44
24 have never asked a woman out
1:15:46
in person. And I just find that
1:15:48
so upsetting and Because that means they're
1:15:50
either not asking people out or they're
1:15:53
asking them out online, or quite frankly,
1:15:55
they can't demonstrate any sense of excellence.
1:15:57
And I think the beautiful thing about
1:15:59
human sexuality is sometimes you don't even
1:16:01
know why you're trying. because someone, you
1:16:03
like the way they smell, you find
1:16:05
out they're funny. And that happens in
1:16:08
person. But we need one more third
1:16:10
spaces, more places people can meet. And
1:16:12
also, I actually think it would be
1:16:14
helpful to have in the senior of
1:16:16
high school a class called adulting, or
1:16:18
amongst other things you teach them about,
1:16:20
the interest rate on a credit card.
1:16:23
In a little thing, my kid can
1:16:25
do integers, and he doesn't understand the
1:16:27
interest rate on his credit card. And
1:16:29
also, quite frankly, I think young men
1:16:31
need guidance around how to express romantic
1:16:33
interest while making the other person feel
1:16:36
safe. And also, that if you express
1:16:38
romantic interest and ask someone out for
1:16:40
coffee and they say, no, you're both
1:16:42
going to be fine. You haven't committed
1:16:44
a crime against humanity. As long as
1:16:46
you're respectful and you don't make the
1:16:48
person feel uncomfortable, but men aren't even
1:16:51
asking women out. Everything you're saying is
1:16:53
what I'm seeing. So I was talking
1:16:55
to this incredible 16-year-old girl who built
1:16:57
this AI chatbot called Ask El and
1:16:59
she's taken all the relationship science research
1:17:01
that she's seen and she's trained this
1:17:03
chatbot and she's trying to help teens
1:17:06
get safe and empowered dating advice. I
1:17:08
asked her what is the number one
1:17:10
question that you're getting and it's how
1:17:12
to ask someone out. And so I
1:17:14
think people are really struggling. It's not
1:17:16
that teens in all of human history
1:17:18
had the secret, it's that they were
1:17:21
willing to do it and fail, and
1:17:23
now we're just not seeing that. And
1:17:25
so I think that we have glossed
1:17:27
over the pandemic. It was this really
1:17:29
traumatic time, really scary stuff happened, and
1:17:31
we don't want to talk about it.
1:17:33
But people that came of age during
1:17:36
the pandemic, their social skills are worse.
1:17:38
They missed out on critical moments of
1:17:40
becoming a human, and we are seeing
1:17:42
that. that came from something, it came
1:17:44
from parenting, it came from digital addiction,
1:17:46
it came from the pandemic and online
1:17:49
learning. And I think that if you
1:17:51
do not have the social skills to
1:17:53
approach someone and ask them out, there
1:17:55
just will be literally fewer couples. I
1:17:57
want to throw a malltoff cocktail into
1:17:59
this and something that's controversial. I've got
1:18:01
a pushback on. I think one of
1:18:04
the enemies amating is that there's too
1:18:06
little drinking. If you look at millennials,
1:18:08
they spent 30 billion dollars in alcohol.
1:18:10
Gen Z, it's crashed to two billion.
1:18:12
Peter Atia and Andrew Huberman have declared
1:18:14
war on drinking. I think young people
1:18:16
need to drink more and go out
1:18:19
and make a series of bad decisions
1:18:21
that might pay off. I don't see
1:18:23
drunkenness, I see togetherness. And I don't
1:18:25
know how it was for you and
1:18:27
your relationship and your relationship and your
1:18:29
relationship. and the romantic opportunities I've had,
1:18:31
not always, but often alcohol played a
1:18:34
role. And I worry that with a
1:18:36
lack of going out, being out of
1:18:38
the house, and also a lack of
1:18:40
drinking, that we've taken away a social
1:18:42
lubricant that breaks down some of the
1:18:44
walls and some of the initial awkwardness
1:18:46
and entry. into a potential romantic relationship?
1:18:49
I think some of the increase in
1:18:51
being sober, sober curious, comes from interest
1:18:53
in being healthy. So we hear from
1:18:55
Gen Z. I don't want to have
1:18:57
anxiety the next day. They are much
1:18:59
less likely. And it's expensive. Yeah, they
1:19:01
are much less likely to millennials to
1:19:04
feel like there's a two-ging. drink minimum
1:19:06
for dates. But in general, we're seeing
1:19:08
less risk-taking behavior from Gen Z. They
1:19:10
are getting their licenses far later, if
1:19:12
at all. They are losing their virginity
1:19:14
much later, if at all. And so
1:19:17
I feel like there's this rise of,
1:19:19
or there's this decrease in risk-taking behavior,
1:19:21
which in some ways is great, you
1:19:23
know, fewer kids dying in car crashes
1:19:25
and people being responsible. But I just
1:19:27
feel like people are having... People are
1:19:29
missing out on the experience to make
1:19:32
mistakes as a young person. And I
1:19:34
think when I think back to my
1:19:36
college experience, if there had been cameras
1:19:38
that have high quality video on them
1:19:40
at all times, I would have lived
1:19:42
a very different college experience. I am
1:19:44
so grateful that Instagram was not there
1:19:47
when I was in college. And so
1:19:49
if you live in a surveillance culture
1:19:51
where at any moment somebody is snapping
1:19:53
the room and they could see what
1:19:55
you're doing, you're going to take fewer
1:19:57
risks. And I just feel like there's
1:19:59
this in... culture of people being very
1:20:02
safe and part of dating, part of
1:20:04
mating, is making mistakes, taking risks and
1:20:06
failing. So what do we do about it
1:20:08
Logan? Speaking, Scott gave a really good
1:20:10
sort of advice for the young man
1:20:12
or the young person who's trying to
1:20:15
increase their mating value, their dating value.
1:20:17
If I mean, what advice would you give to
1:20:19
a young man about how to be attractive?
1:20:21
Because there's going to be a lot of
1:20:23
young men listening right now. So first of
1:20:25
all, I love what Scott said in terms
1:20:27
of his advice, and I feel like it's
1:20:29
one of those things where the secret to
1:20:31
happiness, the secret to success, is simple, but
1:20:33
hard. So it's not like there's infinite
1:20:35
things you need to do. It's actually quite
1:20:37
a simple plan, but it's quite a simple
1:20:40
plan, but it's quite hard to execute on
1:20:42
it. A few things that I would add.
1:20:44
So one is I have this friend, Sam
1:20:46
Pampar, he started the hustle, the podcast, the
1:20:49
podcast, the podcast, My First Million, My First
1:20:51
Million. My First Million. My First Million. My
1:20:53
First Million. develop these passions and really talk
1:20:55
about them on dates because he found that
1:20:58
women were really drawn to the fact that
1:21:00
he was pursuing other activities. So he got
1:21:02
really into denim and he would talk about
1:21:04
these denim meets that he would go to
1:21:07
and he found that women were really drawn
1:21:09
to that. He's very into the growth
1:21:11
mindset and working on himself. He felt like
1:21:13
that was something that women were so drawn
1:21:16
to, how he was growing because if you
1:21:18
think about the projections, well, when he
1:21:20
met my friend Sarah, he wasn't making a
1:21:22
lot more than him. but she could see
1:21:24
that he had a great path ahead of
1:21:27
him because he was constantly working and improving
1:21:29
himself. The other thing I would tell
1:21:31
men is, through my research, I found that
1:21:33
men think, I need to be perfect, I
1:21:36
need to be six feet tall. Look, women
1:21:38
are not expecting you to fly
1:21:40
them to the moon. They want effort.
1:21:42
Remember the name of their best friend.
1:21:44
Text them when they had a hard meeting
1:21:46
and say, how did it go? Plan a
1:21:49
thoughtful date. And so I think that you
1:21:51
have men over here saying, if I'm not
1:21:53
six feet tall, I don't have a chance.
1:21:55
So why participate anyway? And then you have
1:21:58
women saying, in some ways, I just... I
1:22:00
just want you to be an effortful nice
1:22:02
person and I'm not even getting that. And
1:22:04
so I think that for men they can
1:22:06
actually get much farther than they think and
1:22:09
be better than 90% of men by doing
1:22:11
some of these bare minimum things that other
1:22:13
men aren't doing. So I have this question
1:22:15
that I ask in my book, which is
1:22:17
when you're deciding if you should break up
1:22:20
with someone. If your partner were a piece
1:22:22
of clothing in your closet, what would they
1:22:24
be? Is it my clothes or her clothes?
1:22:26
Yeah, yeah, your clothes. Oh, okay. And it
1:22:28
really has to be gut reactions. So Scott,
1:22:30
if you thought of one, I want to
1:22:33
hear it. I thought of like a black
1:22:35
silk shirt, and that's probably because that's where
1:22:37
we spend quality time together. It's when I'm
1:22:39
wearing a black silk shirt. Special occasions, date
1:22:41
night, restaurant. Make an effort. Do you feel
1:22:44
good in it? Yeah, of course, I feel
1:22:46
my best in it. Yeah. Do you have
1:22:48
one for your wife? Brunel, Kuchenel, Kashmir, Phoenix,
1:22:50
Swire, makes me look fantastic, makes me better,
1:22:52
and is beautiful. Yes, and mine for my
1:22:55
husband would be this awesome orange robe that
1:22:57
I have that represents being at home, I
1:22:59
love the orange color that's really bright, and
1:23:01
it represents our family time. So I've asked
1:23:03
this question to... I feel ashamed I felt
1:23:06
like mine was so super crucial. No, no,
1:23:08
no, yours was great! cashmere viewing actually not.
1:23:10
I think your answer. Family orange, I feel
1:23:12
so shamed. No, no, no. I think your
1:23:14
answer is wonderful and I actually in general
1:23:16
find that outer wear answers are very strong
1:23:19
because it means that you feel warm around
1:23:21
them. It's you at your best. It's your
1:23:23
best. It's your fucking fabulous. That's all that
1:23:25
matters. Your answer was great. The answers that
1:23:27
worry me or something like a wool sweater
1:23:30
that feels good, but then it's itchy. So
1:23:32
I take it. So I take it. So
1:23:34
I take it. So I take it. So
1:23:36
I take it. So I take it. So
1:23:38
I take it. So I take it. So
1:23:41
I take it. So I take it. So
1:23:43
I take it. Point is, for years I've
1:23:45
been asking people this question. Well, now I
1:23:47
want to ask people the question of, if
1:23:49
you were a piece of clothing in your
1:23:52
closet, what would you be? And I feel
1:23:54
like we spend so much time saying, I'm
1:23:56
looking for this in a partner, this is
1:23:58
the checklist. Well, look in the mirror. Do
1:24:00
you have those traits? And so for somebody
1:24:02
who says, I'm a ratty sweatshirt. and it's
1:24:05
not the thing that I would choose to
1:24:07
wear, well, then work on yourself. And so
1:24:09
I feel like there's a lot of feelings
1:24:11
of I'm gonna relation shop, I'm gonna look
1:24:13
for a partner the way I look for
1:24:16
Bluetooth headphones. Well, a lot of that is
1:24:18
about breaking people down into these parts. And
1:24:20
I feel like we should spend less time
1:24:22
thinking about the checklist for a partner and
1:24:24
more time thinking about who am I and
1:24:27
am I somebody who would be chosen. Which
1:24:29
demographic of women do you find struggle the
1:24:31
most as it relates to mating and dating?
1:24:33
So I work with a lot of very
1:24:35
successful women and that's also because I'm expensive
1:24:38
to work with and that's who my clients
1:24:40
are. But I have a newsletter where I
1:24:42
hear from 85,000 people. And so what I'm
1:24:44
hearing is that a lot of women are
1:24:46
saying men are intimidated by... The amount of
1:24:49
money that I make they say that they're
1:24:51
not going to be but the more successful
1:24:53
I become the more threatened they are I'm
1:24:55
just talking to tons of women personal friends.
1:24:57
I feel like At my house on one
1:24:59
side of me and then two sides over
1:25:02
are women who are having babies Could they
1:25:04
call it like single mother by choice where
1:25:06
they literally were just like I can't find
1:25:08
a man and I want to become a
1:25:10
mom So I'm gonna do it by myself.
1:25:13
And so I feel like there are just
1:25:15
all these great women who are saying Logan
1:25:17
I'm following your advice I'm putting myself out
1:25:19
there I do all these things, but they're
1:25:21
just not finding partners Do you find that
1:25:24
the more successful woman becomes the more difficult?
1:25:26
a man that will not feel emasculated by
1:25:28
her success? I don't think that there's an
1:25:30
exact correlation, because it really depends who the
1:25:32
guy is. There are guys out there who
1:25:35
are like, let's be a power couple. But
1:25:37
I feel like there are women who just
1:25:39
feel like there is not enough good guys
1:25:41
for them. And I'm curious what you think
1:25:43
about this, but I live in the Bay
1:25:45
Area. I'm seeing so much polyamery. And I
1:25:48
think polyamery is interesting. I'm pro-polyamery. 50% of
1:25:50
marriages end in divorce, obviously are one size
1:25:52
50. it's all approached marriages and working. But
1:25:54
I'm also wondering, well, let me tell you
1:25:56
the story. I went to this dating event,
1:25:59
and the dating event had five single women
1:26:01
who were great, and their friends were hyping
1:26:03
them up. And then there was two guys,
1:26:05
and they were both polyamorous. And so I
1:26:07
wonder, if you're a guy who feels like
1:26:10
there's not that many good guys, why should
1:26:12
I have to choose? I feel like that's
1:26:14
a trend that I'm worried about. Porsche polygamy.
1:26:16
If it's never been better than better than
1:26:18
better to be. a very attractive male, but
1:26:21
you have so much opportunity, it does not
1:26:23
incent good behavior or long-term relationships. And I
1:26:25
work with these guys, and you might think
1:26:27
that they're the happiest people in the world.
1:26:29
They are having sex. They are getting a
1:26:32
lot of attention, but they're suffering from decision
1:26:34
paralysis. And these are some of the guys
1:26:36
that hit... 40, 42, and they haven't gotten
1:26:38
married, they don't have kids, and they sort
1:26:40
of are like, why would I ever settle
1:26:42
down if I don't have to, or I'm
1:26:45
going to wait as long as possible, but
1:26:47
they don't understand the opportunity costs, which is
1:26:49
building a life with someone, having kids. Every
1:26:51
year that you wait to have kids is
1:26:53
a year that your kids will be alive
1:26:56
without you. And so I really feel like
1:26:58
these people in the top percentage, yes, they're
1:27:00
having a much easier time, but they also
1:27:02
have problems because they're having decision paralysis and
1:27:04
they're not settling down. But I would just
1:27:07
say, I think the reality though on the
1:27:09
ground is that if you're a high status
1:27:11
male, you think ages on your side. And
1:27:13
it is. And because the reality is the
1:27:15
ballot, the math is just unfair to women.
1:27:18
It is. Because if you're a 30-year-old male
1:27:20
making really good money, and you know, relative,
1:27:22
like just not unattractive, at 40, you're going
1:27:24
to be even sexier. Your sexual currency goes
1:27:26
up. I do think that there's a point
1:27:28
where it starts to go down, and I've
1:27:31
seen that with my coaching clients, and part
1:27:33
of that is just how the dating apps
1:27:35
work, that if you are unattractive woman. and
1:27:37
you set your age maximum at 40, I
1:27:39
do see that those men see diminishing returns
1:27:42
after that age. Well, especially if they haven't
1:27:44
ever been in a long-term relationship. Right. Then
1:27:46
that is seen as a clear red flag.
1:27:48
No matter where I am in the world,
1:27:50
it seems like everyone is drinking matcher. And
1:27:53
there's a good chance that that matcher you're
1:27:55
drinking is made by a company that I've
1:27:57
invested more than seven figures in, who are
1:27:59
a sponsor of this podcast called Perfect Ted,
1:28:01
because they're the brand used globally by cafes
1:28:04
like Blank Street Coffee and Joe in the
1:28:06
Juice and many, many more. Not only can
1:28:08
you get Perfect Ted match in cafes, but
1:28:10
you can now also make it at home.
1:28:12
Much cheaper. In seconds, using our flavoured matcha
1:28:15
powders that I have here in front of
1:28:17
me, perfect TED Matcha is ceremonial grade and
1:28:19
sourced from Japan. It is smooth, it is
1:28:21
naturally sweet, not like those bit of grassy
1:28:23
matches that I tried before perfect TED. And
1:28:25
if you are one of those people that
1:28:28
have told yourself you don't like Matcha, it's
1:28:30
probably because you haven't tried our perfect Ted
1:28:32
Matcha. And you can find perfect Ted Matcha
1:28:34
in the UK and the UK. Albert Hein
1:28:36
if you're in the Netherlands. And on Amazon
1:28:39
in the USA, we'll get the full range
1:28:41
online at perfect ted.com, you can get 40%
1:28:43
off your first order using code diary 40.
1:28:45
What role does feminism and the rise of
1:28:47
feminism play in all of this? Because I've
1:28:50
had people on my podcast. I think actually
1:28:52
our last episode we published was a lady
1:28:54
who's a child psychology. She's been that way
1:28:56
for three decades. And she came on and
1:28:58
said that. the feminist movement has let men
1:29:01
and women down in some ways. There's been
1:29:03
great upsides, but there's also been a cost.
1:29:05
And one of the things she was really
1:29:07
big on, which I thought would be extremely
1:29:09
controversial, it turns out it wasn't in the
1:29:11
comment section, is that she believes women should
1:29:14
be there for the first two years of
1:29:16
a child's life. And I was like, I
1:29:18
questioned her and that was like. And then
1:29:20
I looked at the stats and I looked
1:29:22
at the research and she basically makes the
1:29:25
case that because the mother is producing certain
1:29:27
hormones. So I searched, it was true, we
1:29:29
fact-checked that episode. And then beyond there, the
1:29:31
man, the father, brings out another... hormones
1:29:33
in the young child,
1:29:36
which are about play
1:29:38
and adventure and all
1:29:40
these kinds of things.
1:29:42
So she makes the
1:29:44
case that we've kind
1:29:47
of lied to women
1:29:49
and we've told them
1:29:51
that they can have
1:29:53
it all. They can
1:29:55
have an incredible career.
1:29:58
They can also be
1:30:00
incredible mothers. And she
1:30:02
says that in her
1:30:04
office, she often sees
1:30:06
mothers coming in saying
1:30:08
that they're 39 years
1:30:11
old, they're struggling, they're
1:30:13
trying to do IVF,
1:30:15
they feel like they
1:30:17
will lie to, throwing
1:30:19
all of that out
1:30:22
there. I'm going to quote Scott
1:30:24
to Scott, which is you can have it all
1:30:26
just not at the same time. Yeah, I don't,
1:30:28
you know, it's, we can
1:30:30
talk about what is the best hormone balance and
1:30:32
brings out the best in kids. And then
1:30:34
there's the real world. And my
1:30:37
partner was working at Goldman Sachs with two babies and
1:30:39
getting up at five in the morning and it was
1:30:41
hell for her. And at the
1:30:43
same time, and I, you know,
1:30:45
at the same time, I was
1:30:47
struggling with trying to get economic traction
1:30:49
because my whole identity as a man, I'm
1:30:51
not proud of this, has been defined by money.
1:30:54
So is mine. I didn't think
1:30:56
men say this enough. Like,
1:30:58
yeah, I, I thought this was really
1:31:01
weird because we're in Austin right
1:31:03
now. And my team put me up in
1:31:05
a hotel and it's just like a normal hotel. I'm
1:31:07
like, so I don't give a fuck. My girlfriend comes
1:31:09
to town tonight. Immediately, my brain goes,
1:31:11
oh my God, we need to move into a
1:31:13
better hotel at Airbnb because my girlfriend, I've been with
1:31:15
her for seven years, she doesn't give a fuck.
1:31:17
She doesn't care about material things. She doesn't have a
1:31:19
Louis Vuitton anything. She's a breathwork. She's a yogi, right?
1:31:22
But there's still this part of me, even
1:31:24
at this stage where I'm like convinced she's
1:31:26
not going anywhere where I constantly think about I
1:31:30
need to be successful. I need to have
1:31:32
money. I need to demonstrate strength. Or
1:31:35
she won't like me. It's
1:31:37
so, it's so weird because it's not true. Like objectively,
1:31:39
I know it's not true, but it's in me. I
1:31:42
don't know. I think it's mostly true. I
1:31:46
think in a capitalist society, the
1:31:48
healthcare of your children, the opportunities your
1:31:50
children have, your
1:31:52
ability to provide, your
1:31:55
ability to take care of your
1:31:57
parents, unfortunately in our society, is
1:31:59
so... correlated to money? That I
1:32:01
think at the end of the day,
1:32:03
masculinity kind of comes down to
1:32:05
provider, protector, and perpetrator. And I
1:32:08
think every young man should take at
1:32:10
least start with the notion they're
1:32:12
going to be the economic provider.
1:32:14
And by the way, that might mean getting out of
1:32:16
the way and being more supportive of your
1:32:18
partner who happens to be better at
1:32:20
the whole money thing than you have.
1:32:22
That's part of masculinity too. But a
1:32:25
good place to start is to assume
1:32:27
in a capitalist society that... you're
1:32:29
just, you have a responsibility
1:32:31
to be economically viable and
1:32:33
every piece of incentive in our
1:32:35
society. I remember in the 70s when I
1:32:38
was in grade school, our principal
1:32:40
was a cool guy. He wore cool
1:32:42
jackets and he had great hair and
1:32:44
he smelled aquavela and he drove a
1:32:46
240-Z. You could be a high character
1:32:48
handsome interesting cool guy into karate or
1:32:51
whatever. Now I just think it's all about
1:32:53
the Benjamin's. I just... It's just
1:32:55
so much our society,
1:32:57
democracy, your rights, your
1:32:59
sexual attractiveness is a man. I don't
1:33:01
care what, yeah, write me an
1:33:03
article about how men just need
1:33:05
to be emotionally available. Bull shit.
1:33:08
It's so disappointingly about
1:33:10
money in my view. All the
1:33:12
incentives telling young men, and so
1:33:14
they go to these get-rich quick schemes.
1:33:17
If they can't make money, they
1:33:19
feel like losers. But what you're feeling,
1:33:21
quite frankly, is common sense from every
1:33:23
signal that if for some reason it
1:33:25
doesn't work out with your mate, your
1:33:27
selection set of mates, how interesting you
1:33:29
are to other men, your opportunities, your
1:33:31
rights, your democracy is going to be
1:33:34
based on your ability to be
1:33:36
economically powerful. It's not the way the world should
1:33:38
be, but it is the way the world is. And
1:33:40
when I say to young men is, there's just
1:33:42
no getting around it. you have
1:33:45
to be economically viable. Would you
1:33:47
say the same thing to women or
1:33:49
would you say there's no getting around
1:33:51
it you have to be hot? No, I
1:33:53
think women, I think women, unfortunately,
1:33:57
so this is base analysis,
1:33:59
women. Men get turned on
1:34:01
with their eyes. It's more important for
1:34:03
a woman to be aesthetically attractive than
1:34:05
a man. Men, women get turned on
1:34:07
with their ears. That's the way I
1:34:10
would describe it. I think women, economic
1:34:12
liberation and independence, is paramount. You know,
1:34:14
the thing that was the hardest thing
1:34:16
in my life growing up, you know,
1:34:19
whatever trauma I had, was not having,
1:34:21
not having a dad in my life.
1:34:23
It was that me and my mom
1:34:25
didn't have any fucking money. And it
1:34:28
was humiliating for us. It was very
1:34:30
hard on her. It was emotionally very
1:34:32
trying on her because she felt like
1:34:34
she was feeling as a mother. So
1:34:37
I think women absolutely, women making a
1:34:39
lot of money is a collective victory
1:34:41
of our society. It is hugely important
1:34:43
and wonderful. We should do nothing to
1:34:46
get in the way of that. That
1:34:48
doesn't in any way, though, obviate the
1:34:50
fact that a man's opportunity, sexual currency,
1:34:52
and place in our society. is almost
1:34:54
going to have an R of one,
1:34:57
regardless of how many subscriptions to the
1:34:59
Atlantic or the New York Times you
1:35:01
have, if his economic viability. And I
1:35:03
just don't, I think it's gotten worse.
1:35:06
I don't think it's got, you used
1:35:08
to be able to, if you were
1:35:10
a high character kind of cool, interesting
1:35:12
nice guy who was a principal at
1:35:15
a junior high school, you had sexual
1:35:17
currency. Now I think you can be
1:35:19
a fucking dip shit, but if you
1:35:21
sold $10 million dollars in Doja coin,
1:35:24
you can get laid. And it's just
1:35:26
getting worse because our capitalist economy is
1:35:28
providing so many advantages solely based on
1:35:30
money. And it sends the wrong signal,
1:35:33
but I just tell dudes you have
1:35:35
to be economically viable. And some of
1:35:37
that is just having discipline around saving
1:35:39
money and showing that you have your
1:35:42
act of that. Maybe you don't make
1:35:44
a lot of money, but I'm responsible.
1:35:46
I'll be a good mate. I'll be
1:35:48
a good partner. Maybe you're making more
1:35:51
money than me, but I'll bring discipline.
1:35:53
I know how to fix it. I
1:35:55
can be a good mate. But one
1:35:57
of the things I really worry about
1:35:59
in America is just everything has... become
1:36:02
about the Benjamin's character is being squeezed
1:36:04
out by money. That sounded awful. I
1:36:06
want to ask you, have you ever
1:36:08
felt what Scott describes? Have you ever
1:36:11
felt that your sort of sense of
1:36:13
self-worth equates to how much money you
1:36:15
have? Because I felt that. I don't
1:36:17
think I as much have money equals
1:36:20
identity. and self-worth, but I do think
1:36:22
for many people there's a sense that
1:36:24
money equals security and so we're all
1:36:26
chasing that dollar which is security. But
1:36:29
I think for men it's much stronger.
1:36:31
I don't relate to what you're talking
1:36:33
about. Yeah, so this is I've never
1:36:35
actually asked a woman this before but
1:36:38
it's the number one topic of conversation
1:36:40
in my group chat with my boys
1:36:42
is how much are we working? sat
1:36:44
in Sunday to make more money and
1:36:47
make ourselves more successful. And then one
1:36:49
of my friends, who's not in my
1:36:51
group chat, but one of my extended
1:36:53
friends went through financial hardship and he's
1:36:55
in the lead-up to starting a family
1:36:58
excret and he went through a moment
1:37:00
where he was going to be declared
1:37:02
bankrupt and he was inconsolably depressed. His
1:37:04
partner was fine. She was kind of
1:37:07
like, you know, we'll get through this,
1:37:09
but he was like, he actually said
1:37:11
to me, he goes, I've never felt
1:37:13
more worthless. And that's something that I've
1:37:16
heard echoed by many men who go
1:37:18
through sort of economic financial rollercoasters. That
1:37:20
was actually one of the stats in
1:37:22
that report, the Lost Boys Report, Richard
1:37:25
Reeves talks about this. I think that's
1:37:27
actually where it comes from. So Richard
1:37:29
Reeves says that the number one cause
1:37:31
of death for young men under 15
1:37:34
is suicide, and that men in general,
1:37:36
the things that they described in their
1:37:38
notes, when they commit suicide, are these
1:37:40
words worthless. and useless. And so if
1:37:43
men feel like their identity and their
1:37:45
value and their worth comes from money,
1:37:47
when they don't have money or they
1:37:49
can't be a provider and they're sort
1:37:51
of on the edge of society, then
1:37:54
they're literally opting out sometimes with their
1:37:56
lives. Okay. I want to take the
1:37:58
metaphorical iPad and ask you guys some
1:38:00
questions. Because I feel like I've kind
1:38:03
of said what I want to say
1:38:05
about this topic, but I'm sure there
1:38:07
are just millions of people that look
1:38:09
up to both of you as symbols
1:38:12
of masculinity. Scott, this is true, right?
1:38:14
Mom's talked to you all the time
1:38:16
and say, how can I help my
1:38:18
son? And so, like, there's things that
1:38:21
I want to know because this topic
1:38:23
is the thing I'm most passionate about.
1:38:25
but they will listen to you. So
1:38:27
I want to learn from you. So
1:38:30
if you could teach a dating boot
1:38:32
camp to all guys and even talk
1:38:34
about what you would have them on
1:38:36
learn, what are some of those messages?
1:38:39
I would, a dating boot camp. Yeah.
1:38:41
Or being a human boot camp. Let's
1:38:43
just expand. We have module one, comedy.
1:38:45
Because the only thing that got me
1:38:47
laid when I was broke was I
1:38:50
was like slightly funny sometimes. I could
1:38:52
be broken funny and I would have
1:38:54
like some sense. This could be just,
1:38:56
yeah, keep going. Something around confidence, which
1:38:59
is just standing, I noticed that posture
1:39:01
correlates to dating success. So I'd have
1:39:03
men learn to stand up straight and
1:39:05
to control their posture and take up
1:39:08
more space. And I mean that in
1:39:10
the nicest possible way, which is don't
1:39:12
be shriveled. pulls you out a little
1:39:14
bit as well. Typical, but going out
1:39:17
of fashion, male manners. Open up the
1:39:19
door. I still open up the door
1:39:21
for my girlfriend every single day, even
1:39:23
though apparently they went through a phase
1:39:26
where that was seen as like not
1:39:28
okay to do. But I've always taken
1:39:30
great pride in it. And finally enough,
1:39:32
opening up the door for my partner
1:39:35
makes me feel good. I'm like doing
1:39:37
it for selfish reasons. It makes me
1:39:39
feel like a man. It makes me
1:39:41
feel like a man. I love that
1:39:44
when we cross a road, I'm the
1:39:46
one that's looking out. I love that
1:39:48
I stand on the roadside of the
1:39:50
pavement etc. So I teach men these
1:39:52
kind of behaviors and definitely going to
1:39:55
the gym and then as Scott said
1:39:57
like entrepreneurship. or making some money, that
1:39:59
would be central to my book. I'll
1:40:01
give you one more. It would be
1:40:04
conflict resolution. And this goes to like
1:40:06
the emotional empathy point. One thing that
1:40:08
I struggle with, or at least I
1:40:10
struggled with, until my girlfriend coached me.
1:40:13
And I did this podcast so many
1:40:15
times that I learned some lessons, is
1:40:17
just how to deal with conflict when
1:40:19
the aspiring partner is a woman. Because
1:40:22
men in conflict, we have a certain
1:40:24
way typically, but learning the skill of
1:40:26
hearing and understanding your partner. which is
1:40:28
very difficult and like, listen, this might
1:40:31
just be me. I find it incredibly
1:40:33
difficult to sit and to listen to
1:40:35
my partner for 90 minutes when she
1:40:37
tells me indirectly all the things I
1:40:40
did wrong. I've had to learn the
1:40:42
skill of doing that. And I sat
1:40:44
here with someone who's a psychologist and
1:40:46
said, they said to me, if you're
1:40:48
a man, you have to learn the
1:40:51
skill of sitting down for 90 minutes
1:40:53
a week. and letting your partner tell
1:40:55
you everything that they're feeling and going
1:40:57
through. With my boys, we don't do
1:41:00
that. But we go on holiday, it
1:41:02
is total silence, we're eating fucking Pringles
1:41:04
and watching the game. But when I'm
1:41:06
with my partner and what I'm sure
1:41:09
when she's with her friends, it's talking.
1:41:11
So I always, I've developed the skill
1:41:13
now of just like sitting and listening.
1:41:15
And then sometimes I take notes. And
1:41:18
then sometimes I repeat back to what
1:41:20
she just said to me. And this
1:41:22
is totally alien to me. I find
1:41:24
it so uncomfortable. Like I find it
1:41:27
really really uncomfortable to do that. Even
1:41:29
though this is something you spend hours
1:41:31
a week doing for a job. 100%
1:41:33
is so unnatural to me. But you've
1:41:36
worked on it. I've worked on it.
1:41:38
I did it like three days ago.
1:41:40
My girlfriend said I was traveling around
1:41:42
the world. I don't even know what
1:41:44
country we're in. She goes I've got
1:41:47
some things I want to talk about.
1:41:49
Can we put some time in the
1:41:51
calendar? Do you have some time in
1:41:53
the calendar? for about 45 minutes. I
1:41:56
don't have anything to say. I'm sitting
1:41:58
there and listen. And in between the
1:42:00
lines, it's like things I could do
1:42:02
better. She's not blaming me or anything,
1:42:05
but it's... hard for me. My boys
1:42:07
would never do that. Our friendship isn't
1:42:09
contingent on those things, so that's what
1:42:11
I would say. I love that. Like
1:42:14
I don't know if that you relate
1:42:16
to that, but... I think about the
1:42:18
slob of my boys, and I think
1:42:20
kind of the three legs of the
1:42:23
stool are provider. I'm probably over focused
1:42:25
on the economics, that doesn't necessarily mean
1:42:27
making a lot of money, but at
1:42:29
least being disciplined and responsible about it,
1:42:32
developing skills, certification, having a plan. Don't
1:42:34
be the guy ordering a bottle of
1:42:36
gray goose at 2 in the morning.
1:42:38
I'm going home because I've got to
1:42:41
get up. I have a plan. And
1:42:43
I have a vision for how I'm
1:42:45
going to be a good provider. A
1:42:47
protector, good manners. Your default system is
1:42:49
protection. You constantly speak well of people
1:42:52
behind their backs. You hear someone being
1:42:54
critical of someone else. Your inclination is
1:42:56
to defend them. You don't demonize special
1:42:58
interest groups your default setting if somebody
1:43:01
needs help anywhere or is being threatened
1:43:03
It just it's so heartbreaking to me
1:43:05
that women feel unsafe When they see
1:43:07
men when they see a group of
1:43:10
men coming down the street Service show
1:43:12
women are inclined to cross the street
1:43:14
And it just feels like from an
1:43:16
early age men need to be taught
1:43:19
Anyone small or anyone more vulnerable than
1:43:21
you anyone in a special interest group
1:43:23
Your default is protection. That's what men
1:43:25
do. Think about masculinity, a soldier, a
1:43:28
cop, a fireman. What do they do?
1:43:30
At the end of the day, they
1:43:32
protect. That is your default operating system
1:43:34
as a move to protection. And then
1:43:37
Pro Creator, I think you should want
1:43:39
to have sex. I think you should
1:43:41
be willing to take risks. I tell
1:43:43
my boys, I did this for a
1:43:45
while. They can't get back in the
1:43:48
house unless they talk to a stranger.
1:43:51
And my oldest no problem. Hey,
1:43:53
what's going on? My youngest, not
1:43:55
as easy. Just go up and
1:43:57
pet their dog. I think there's
1:43:59
so many men out there that
1:44:01
have no willingness or ability to
1:44:03
open to, you know, to just
1:44:05
say hi, where are you from,
1:44:07
to just open, and to want
1:44:10
a romantic relationship is a wonderful
1:44:12
thing. There's nothing wrong with that.
1:44:14
Modulate your porn. Decide, ask yourself,
1:44:16
would you want to have sex
1:44:18
with you? Get strong, get fit,
1:44:20
get fit, get fit, get, get
1:44:22
your act together. smell nice, groom,
1:44:24
if you can't dress well, find
1:44:26
someone who can dress you, and
1:44:28
initiate contact and want to have
1:44:31
a relationship with someone. That's a
1:44:33
wonderful thing. That mojo is the
1:44:35
most purposeful, wonderful thing in my
1:44:37
life is that I'm raising two
1:44:39
patriotic, decent men. And it started
1:44:41
with me really wanting to have
1:44:43
sex with this woman I saw
1:44:45
at the pool at the Raleigh
1:44:47
Hotel. Right? And that sounds crass.
1:44:50
It's like, I looked at her
1:44:52
and thought, I'm really attracted to
1:44:54
this woman. So I'm going to
1:44:56
take a risk in the middle
1:44:58
of the day without the benefit
1:45:00
of alcohol. I'm going to walk
1:45:02
up and introduce myself to her
1:45:04
and another guy and a woman
1:45:06
she was with. Hey, where are
1:45:08
you guys from? And then 18
1:45:11
months later, our first son was
1:45:13
born, middle name Raleigh, after the
1:45:15
hotel. Your default system is a
1:45:17
protector and there's nothing wrong with
1:45:19
wanting to be a pro-creator. I
1:45:21
love everything you said and then
1:45:23
one thing was going through my
1:45:25
head as you said it was
1:45:27
it feels really sad that in
1:45:29
this moment at time we have
1:45:32
to tell people to become pro-creators.
1:45:34
Don't you feel like there's something
1:45:36
sick in our society if that
1:45:38
has to be taught? Evolutionarily all
1:45:40
of our software is towards... pro
1:45:42
creation. Like that is how we
1:45:44
are wired. Yet people are so
1:45:46
sick from the food that they
1:45:48
eat, from all the medications that
1:45:50
people are on. from all the
1:45:53
pornography from all the technology that
1:45:55
you literally have to teach your
1:45:57
sons the importance of procreation and
1:45:59
that's why I'm here and that's
1:46:01
why I'm really freaked out by
1:46:03
all this stuff because we are
1:46:05
at a point in society where
1:46:07
in South Korea of a hundred
1:46:09
people of childbearing age they are
1:46:11
going to produce 12 grandchildren based
1:46:14
on a point seven birth rate
1:46:16
and the fact that you talk
1:46:18
about the pee of procreation, like
1:46:20
I'm so worried about our society.
1:46:22
It's 60% of 30 year olds,
1:46:24
40 years ago, used to have
1:46:26
a kid, not 27%. So when
1:46:28
I was on the plane on
1:46:30
the way here, I told this
1:46:32
woman who was saying next to
1:46:35
me what I was going to
1:46:37
be talking about. And her gut
1:46:39
reaction was, oh, why do we
1:46:41
have to worry about that? Women
1:46:43
are doing better than men, like,
1:46:45
great, let us do that for
1:46:47
the first time for the first
1:46:49
time in history. lowest marriage rate
1:46:51
near, we're approaching the lowest marriage
1:46:54
rate in US history. The birth
1:46:56
rate has gone down 20% to
1:46:58
20 years. And she didn't know
1:47:00
these numbers. And I feel like
1:47:02
people are afraid to talk about
1:47:04
this topic because they think it's
1:47:06
a zero-sum game where when men
1:47:08
lose women win and vice versa.
1:47:10
But right now we're all losing.
1:47:12
It's huge economic impact too because
1:47:15
it used to be 12 people
1:47:17
working age to support every senior.
1:47:19
Now it's three to one. If
1:47:21
we don't have kids. we're going
1:47:23
to go into economic decline. Yeah,
1:47:25
South Korea is replacing its nursery
1:47:27
schools with its nursing homes. Like,
1:47:29
they are the anti-examble for us,
1:47:31
and I think people need to
1:47:33
be paying attention. By 2050, about
1:47:36
40% of the population will be
1:47:38
senior citizens, and the labor force
1:47:40
could have halved within the next
1:47:42
40 years. The Bank of Korea
1:47:44
warns that if current trans persists,
1:47:46
the Korean economy could begin contracting
1:47:48
in 10 years' time. is present
1:47:50
to national service risk as the
1:47:52
country relies on its conscripted military
1:47:54
and this will fall by hundreds
1:47:57
and hundreds of thousands of people
1:47:59
by 2025. Bill half, oh my
1:48:01
gosh, could fall. from 250,000 troops
1:48:03
to 125,000 troops. Politics is the
1:48:05
last thing I wanted to talk
1:48:07
about, and how this sort of
1:48:09
intertwines with everything we've talked about
1:48:11
today. Obviously, Trump is now in
1:48:13
power. And as we saw in
1:48:15
the data, and it was touched
1:48:18
on early run, young men have
1:48:20
become more right-leaning and more conservative
1:48:22
than ever before. The left hasn't
1:48:24
necessarily offered the best vision of
1:48:26
masculinity. The young men is something
1:48:28
Scots talked about previously. I was
1:48:30
wondering, I think this morning in
1:48:32
the hotel, I was wondering, how
1:48:34
is the left going to get
1:48:37
men back? Is that possible? Because
1:48:39
the vision of masculinity, this is
1:48:41
something Scots talked about, that the
1:48:43
left portrays, is not, doesn't seem
1:48:45
to be in line with all
1:48:47
the things we've just described that
1:48:49
we feel intuitively as men, the
1:48:51
things we think are important, like
1:48:53
economic viability, being strong, you know.
1:48:55
I'll let's govers. Well on the
1:48:58
right, they've conflated. They've conflated. masculinity
1:49:00
with coarseness and cruelty. The two
1:49:02
kind of role models, you know,
1:49:04
President Trump, who in my opinion
1:49:06
demonstrates a lack of grace and
1:49:08
a lack of empathy and a
1:49:10
lack of kindness, and Elon Musk
1:49:12
is currently being sued by two
1:49:14
women for sole custody of their
1:49:16
kid because he hasn't seen the
1:49:19
kid. I mean, is that those
1:49:21
are the role models we want
1:49:23
for young men? And on the
1:49:25
left, their vision of masculinity is
1:49:27
act more like a woman. I
1:49:29
don't think that's helpful either. I
1:49:31
went to the Democratic National Convention
1:49:33
and there was a parade of
1:49:35
special interest groups. Everyone was represented.
1:49:37
Except for the group that needs
1:49:40
the most representation right now, in
1:49:42
my view, and that is young
1:49:44
men. If you go to the
1:49:46
DNC website, they list 16 special
1:49:48
interest groups and they say who
1:49:50
we serve. They call it out,
1:49:52
who we serve. Asian Pacific Islanders,
1:49:54
seniors, the disabled, immigrants. black Americans,
1:49:56
and I added it up. It's
1:49:58
74% of the U.S. population. And
1:50:01
when you say you're actively advocating
1:50:03
for 74% you're not advocating for
1:50:05
the 74% you're discriminating against the
1:50:07
26% and who are the 26%?
1:50:09
Young men. Is this a consequence
1:50:11
of DEA? I think that's part
1:50:13
of it. I think there's been
1:50:15
so many groups that have been
1:50:17
discriminated against and the way I
1:50:19
would just loosely ascribe to the
1:50:22
democratic party is we have the
1:50:24
right ideas and then we just
1:50:26
take it too far. You know
1:50:28
there were women have gotten a
1:50:30
raw deal. So they need advantage.
1:50:32
You know, gays have been persecuted.
1:50:34
Non whites have had, there were
1:50:36
12 black people and 60 years
1:50:38
ago in Princeton, Harvard, and Yale
1:50:41
combined. That was a problem. This
1:50:43
year, more than 60% of Harvard's
1:50:45
freshman class identify as non-white. So
1:50:47
I think we got to get
1:50:49
out of identity politics, but the
1:50:51
notion, this, it largely came from
1:50:53
the left, this notion of toxic
1:50:55
masculinity. There's no such thing because
1:50:57
there's violence, there's people who are
1:50:59
criminals, there's people who are unkind,
1:51:02
that means they're not masculine. Masculinity
1:51:04
is being a protector, a provider,
1:51:06
a procreator, and the Democratic Party
1:51:08
seems to believe that leaning into
1:51:10
anything around your advantage of being
1:51:12
male in terms of your strength,
1:51:14
your kindness, your wanting to procreate,
1:51:16
your initiating sexual contact, or sexual
1:51:18
romantic interest is somehow a threat.
1:51:20
and somehow toxic. I just think
1:51:23
they've sent absolutely the wrong signal.
1:51:25
And into that void has stepped
1:51:27
basically thinly veiled misogyny. It is
1:51:29
just so ugly. You know, the,
1:51:31
the, and he, Trump flew right
1:51:33
into it. The reason Trump won
1:51:35
this election, in my view, is
1:51:37
the groups that pivot it hardest
1:51:39
from. Blue to red 2020 to
1:51:41
2024 were Latinos, who were sick
1:51:44
of being categorized by their identity.
1:51:46
But numbers two and three were
1:51:48
people under the age of 30,
1:51:50
especially males. are not doing very
1:51:52
well and feel like Donald Trump
1:51:54
feels their pain and women age
1:51:56
45 to 64. And my thesis
1:51:58
is that's their mothers. Because if
1:52:00
your son isn't doing well, you
1:52:02
don't care about territorial sovereignty and
1:52:05
Ukraine or gender rights. You just
1:52:07
want to change. My son isn't
1:52:09
doing well. Those are the people
1:52:11
that whisper to me in the
1:52:13
streets about these conversations. It's the
1:52:15
40 to 55 year old mother
1:52:17
who has a son, who doesn't
1:52:19
feel like she can speak up,
1:52:21
but says to me privately. that
1:52:23
she's worried about her kids. And
1:52:26
actually we had some mothers write
1:52:28
in, all of which wanted to
1:52:30
stay anonymous, saying this exact same
1:52:32
thing. They've got an 18-year-old son,
1:52:34
they're super concerned, they've got a
1:52:36
16-year-old son, the son looks lost.
1:52:38
As the start show from the
1:52:40
report, they're not leaving home. In
1:52:42
the same way that women, their
1:52:45
daughters leave home, but they don't
1:52:47
know what to do about it.
1:52:49
So for those parents that are
1:52:51
listening now, we can't change society,
1:52:53
what would you recommend a parent
1:52:55
of a parent of a young
1:52:57
boy? Does first thing
1:52:59
is forgive yourself. There's this natural
1:53:01
Part of a separation where and
1:53:03
I think this is true of
1:53:05
girls with especially boys Where to
1:53:08
make the separation easier where you
1:53:10
don't get along with our parents
1:53:12
In our senior year in high
1:53:14
school and That doesn't mean your
1:53:16
son doesn't love you that doesn't
1:53:18
mean your son's not gonna figure
1:53:20
it out, but to forgive yourself.
1:53:22
There's but going back to more
1:53:24
actionable things trying to mail, trying
1:53:26
to get men involved in his
1:53:28
life. And then, you know, dumb
1:53:30
stuff, like, my mom made sure
1:53:32
I was in Boy Scouts. My
1:53:34
mom, when I got caught from
1:53:36
the high school basketball and football
1:53:38
team, she enrolled me in city
1:53:40
leagues so I could continue to
1:53:42
play sports. But it was mostly,
1:53:44
she wasn't sure that I had
1:53:46
men in my life. And I
1:53:48
think that was really, really important
1:53:50
for me. But, you know, I
1:53:53
would just say that. I feel
1:53:55
like I need to coach men
1:53:57
more. But I say to boy,
1:53:59
one of the first thing I
1:54:01
say to boy is I had lunch
1:54:03
with, and I was never, I had lunch
1:54:05
with someone who's a fairly famous news anchor
1:54:07
and her son, and I asked the mom
1:54:10
to excuse, they started going at it, and
1:54:12
I asked the mom to excuse herself,
1:54:14
and I said, I'm like, he realizes is
1:54:16
the only person in your life ever that wants
1:54:18
you to be more successful than you.
1:54:21
You just got to cut this shit out. This
1:54:23
woman is not your enemy. And I've
1:54:25
heard that and I was a
1:54:27
bit ashamed because I remember like
1:54:29
being such an asshole to my
1:54:31
mother, you know. So I think, but I
1:54:33
think I could say that to him because
1:54:36
I could look him in the eyes and
1:54:38
say, what the fuck you doing? So I
1:54:40
just think that male involvement
1:54:42
for single mothers, and I
1:54:44
think men are really willing to
1:54:47
get involved, whether it's someone
1:54:49
down the street, a coach, you're,
1:54:51
you know, a sibling, your brother,
1:54:53
whatever it is. Again, the research
1:54:55
shows that the point of failure is
1:54:57
when a boy loses a male role
1:54:59
model. And also to forgive yourself,
1:55:02
being a single parent with a
1:55:04
son, I think that's hard. I
1:55:06
just think it's hard. Logan, you've
1:55:08
got some questions I can see.
1:55:10
Oh yeah, I do have some questions
1:55:13
for Scott, but I would love for
1:55:15
you to answer them too. So one
1:55:17
of them is what is something about
1:55:19
being a man that you learn growing
1:55:21
up that you have had to unlearn?
1:55:23
And I'm wondering specifically in how you're
1:55:26
raising your sons to avoid some
1:55:28
of those things. I think a great proxy
1:55:30
for masculinity and manhood
1:55:32
is in Richard Reeves introduced me this.
1:55:35
I think it's so powerful and that
1:55:37
is surplus value. It's not about a
1:55:39
religious ceremony. It's not about having
1:55:42
sex. It's not about an age. It's
1:55:44
about getting the point of surplus
1:55:46
value. You create more tax revenue
1:55:48
than you absorb. I say to
1:55:50
my boys, you're negative value. You're
1:55:52
negative value. Look at all the resources
1:55:54
going into you. Look at all the
1:55:56
love. We love you so much more
1:55:59
than you of us. are spending all this
1:56:01
time and energy and you're
1:56:03
giving, you aren't giving
1:56:05
anything back. At some point that
1:56:07
needs to pivot. So creating
1:56:09
more tax revenue, noticing
1:56:12
people's life, registering more
1:56:14
complaints from other people than
1:56:16
you are complaining, protecting
1:56:18
people, you know, adding surplus
1:56:21
value. So, you know, these notions
1:56:23
that, and I wasn't that guy, I
1:56:26
wanted more from everyone else than
1:56:28
I was giving. I was the guy
1:56:30
that when someone honked to me, I was
1:56:32
the guy that sped up and honked back
1:56:34
to restore the universe to its place. If
1:56:36
a delta, if a ticket counter agent at
1:56:38
the airline counter was rude to me, I
1:56:41
needed to get back in their face to
1:56:43
restore harmony to the universe because I'm a
1:56:45
fucking bawler. And what you realize is being
1:56:47
a man is occasionally taking a hit.
1:56:49
Right? It's having surplus value. It's
1:56:51
noticing people's lives. It's listening to
1:56:53
complaints. It's occasionally thinking, well, maybe
1:56:55
this person who's coming off in
1:56:57
traffic, I don't know what's going
1:57:00
on with them. Maybe their kid
1:57:02
has diabetes. Maybe they're going to do
1:57:04
divorce. It's adding more value than you're
1:57:06
taking. And until the age of like 40, I
1:57:08
looked at every relationship. Am I getting more
1:57:10
out of this than I'm getting? And if
1:57:12
I'm not, I'm out. And what you realize
1:57:15
is good business partnerships. You add as much
1:57:17
or more value than your partners.
1:57:19
Good relationships. You witness the person's
1:57:21
life. You make them feel fucking
1:57:23
awes. If you leave this world
1:57:25
a little bit in debt, that's the
1:57:27
whole point. That's the whole point, or
1:57:30
a little bit, the world's in debt to
1:57:32
you. That's the win. And I used to
1:57:34
think as a young man, that man I
1:57:36
needed to ask for the relationship. I'm
1:57:38
not getting more money or services
1:57:40
than I'm giving. I'm not getting
1:57:42
more kindness and I'm not giving,
1:57:44
I'm not getting more hot experiences
1:57:46
with this romantic partner than they're
1:57:48
giving me, I'm out. No, it's
1:57:50
the other way around being a man
1:57:53
is surplus value. Yeah, I've never thought
1:57:55
about that before, but it's so true that
1:57:57
like, as a man, you should aspire to be
1:57:59
considered... generous. And actually, the first
1:58:01
time someone called me generous was like,
1:58:03
such an unbelievably wonderful compliment to me
1:58:06
because it means that people see you
1:58:08
as someone that's giving things. But to
1:58:10
answer your question, for me, it was just
1:58:12
a willingness to express my emotions when
1:58:14
I'm struggling. That's like the, that's always
1:58:17
been a difficult thing for me, especially because
1:58:19
of everything I've said earlier about wanting to
1:58:21
be a provider. There are going to be
1:58:23
moments where regardless of how well you play
1:58:26
the game of life, you're going to struggle.
1:58:28
and I did not have the tools. I
1:58:30
still really don't have great tools for this,
1:58:32
but to turn to someone and say, I'm
1:58:35
really struggling with this and not to feel
1:58:37
emasculated. And I would say that because as
1:58:39
a man, pretty much the only person you
1:58:41
have in your life typically that you
1:58:43
can turn to is your romantic partner,
1:58:46
that's also the last person you want
1:58:48
to turn to and say you're struggling
1:58:50
because again for me, that felt like
1:58:52
I was being emasculated. I remember the
1:58:55
day very vividly when I was like
1:58:57
30 years old turning to my girlfriend
1:58:59
and like running the experiment of
1:59:01
letting her know that I was
1:59:03
struggling with something and how difficult that
1:59:06
was but the only reason I did
1:59:08
it was because I almost felt like
1:59:10
I had no fucking choice. I'd like
1:59:12
gotten to the point I was like I need
1:59:14
to tell someone this and she was the
1:59:16
only person and I still don't think I
1:59:18
tell my my my girlfriend's everything.
1:59:21
I would tell them some things, but I
1:59:23
don't think I'd tell them everything. And when
1:59:25
I look at the stats around mental health
1:59:27
and depression, which are absolutely horrific, and some
1:59:29
of these quotes that we had from some
1:59:32
of the guys that wrote into the show,
1:59:34
this guy Liam said, for me, the biggest
1:59:36
challenge that young men face today is I
1:59:38
feel like I'm striving for meaning but I
1:59:40
can't find anywhere. I struggle to even sleep
1:59:43
at night with some form of substance because
1:59:45
my brain is constantly firing different, different scenarios
1:59:47
I am. and how I need to change
1:59:49
everything in my life. And the hardest part
1:59:51
is I can't even tell anybody this because
1:59:54
I would feel weak. And in this guy
1:59:56
Jeffrey wrote in and said, my entire life,
1:59:58
I have never felt like... I was good
2:00:00
enough. Like I could never earn my place
2:00:02
in society. And even though I think I've
2:00:04
achieved some things by the age of 18, I
2:00:07
still feel like deep inside I will never
2:00:09
be enough and I'm still not enough
2:00:11
and I can't tell anybody. And I think
2:00:13
that's a problem that's quite unique
2:00:15
to men. It might be a problem
2:00:17
unique to my upbringing, but I just
2:00:20
don't have the tools. So when I
2:00:22
look at the stats around depression and
2:00:24
men killing themselves, 75% of suicides in
2:00:26
the UK are men. and 75% of them
2:00:28
worldwide are men. And suicide, as you said
2:00:30
I think earlier, is the leading cause of
2:00:32
death amongst young men in 50 countries. Yeah,
2:00:34
if you feel that meaningless and you feel
2:00:36
that worthless and you don't have anyone to
2:00:38
console about it, to maybe tell you that
2:00:41
you're wrong, you know. That's why when Scott
2:00:43
said that you don't necessarily buy the
2:00:45
research that women are looking for someone
2:00:47
who's emotionally intelligent. Fine, then don't
2:00:49
do it for your partner. Do it
2:00:51
for yourself. Yeah. I just saw the
2:00:53
standout out special by Kumel Nangiami. I'm
2:00:55
sure it'll like come out on streaming
2:00:58
soon, but the last 20 minutes was
2:01:00
pretty incredible. It basically turned from like
2:01:02
sort of silly stand-up into kind of
2:01:04
like his TED Talk. So he told
2:01:06
this amazing story about how one day
2:01:09
he was speaking to the press and
2:01:11
he said, I started to go to
2:01:13
therapy when there were a bunch of
2:01:15
bad reviews about my movie because I
2:01:17
realized so much of my identity was
2:01:19
tied up in external factors. And this
2:01:21
turned into headlines around the world that
2:01:23
said bad reviews land, Kubeel Nangyanian therapy.
2:01:26
And he was really frustrated by this.
2:01:28
So in the stand-up special, he took
2:01:30
the five most popular things that people
2:01:32
said criticizing him and he broke down
2:01:34
each one. So for example, one of them
2:01:36
was, oh, boohoo, poor, you know, super rich
2:01:38
movie-rich movie star. are feel sad about bad
2:01:40
reviews. We should all feel sad for him.
2:01:42
And he's like, no, you don't have to
2:01:44
feel sad for me, but I can feel
2:01:46
sad for me. And he went through all
2:01:49
these things. And he talked about his therapy
2:01:51
journey and how before therapy, he thought, I
2:01:53
just don't experience negative emotions. I don't experience
2:01:55
sadness. And through therapy, he understood, oh, I
2:01:57
experienced sadness all the time. But I don't.
2:02:00
myself to feel it. So it just
2:02:02
comes out as anger. So he told
2:02:04
the story about talking to his dad
2:02:06
on the phone, his dad had just
2:02:09
been in a car accident, but was
2:02:11
fine, and then he helped his dad
2:02:13
through that experience. And then a few
2:02:16
hours later, he's like, where the fuck
2:02:18
is my Ninja Turtle t-shirt? And it's
2:02:20
like, he needed therapy to explain to
2:02:22
him, he's not upset about the t-shirt,
2:02:25
he's upset about his dad. But I
2:02:27
think that the fact that the fact
2:02:29
that he, you know that he, you
2:02:32
know in his 40, you know in
2:02:34
his, you know in his dad, in
2:02:36
his dad, in his dad, Everyone needs
2:02:38
to learn that. If it's not for
2:02:41
a romantic partner, then it's for yourself.
2:02:43
Because a life sucks. If you can't
2:02:45
cry, you can't express emotions, you don't
2:02:48
have people to talk to. And so
2:02:50
forget about attracting a mate, just not
2:02:52
killing yourself, just being a happier person.
2:02:55
I think we just need more room
2:02:57
for men to express emotions. The first
2:02:59
time I went to a therapist was
2:03:01
when I was about 30, 30, 31,
2:03:04
and I put it off for so
2:03:06
fucking log for this reason. Because every
2:03:08
part of it made me feel like
2:03:11
a masculated and as a man you're
2:03:13
like I know I can deal with
2:03:15
everything myself and I've got this like
2:03:17
like I said when the bus comes
2:03:20
I put my hand in front of
2:03:22
my girlfriend. I'm always the protector So
2:03:24
when you find yourself in a position
2:03:27
like these men who've written into the
2:03:29
show where you feel meaningless or you
2:03:31
feel hopeless or there's some other challenge
2:03:34
in your life You think it's your
2:03:36
job to fix. I'm always like holding
2:03:38
for for everybody So you learn to
2:03:40
like keep a fucking straight face. The
2:03:43
business is on fire. We have no
2:03:45
money to pay 170 people's wages and
2:03:47
it's Friday and they're expecting like you
2:03:50
learn this skill of like numbness and
2:03:52
that doesn't serve you when you're trying
2:03:54
to resolve something. And this is why
2:03:56
I think porn gambling addiction become the
2:03:59
avenue because there's not another avenue to
2:04:01
sort of take pressure off the pressure
2:04:03
valve. So yeah, it's difficult. It's difficult.
2:04:06
The email you just read from that
2:04:08
young man. I've stopped, and it sounds
2:04:10
crass, I can't handle the emails I
2:04:13
get anymore. I'm getting so many emails
2:04:15
from young men who are just, I
2:04:17
mean, you read an email like that
2:04:19
and you just like, it's devastating. You
2:04:22
know, I haven't gone over the death
2:04:24
of my father, I'm living alone, I've
2:04:26
become addicted to, oh, I mean, you
2:04:29
just hear the shit, like I know
2:04:31
I have value to add, I just
2:04:33
can't figure it out, I just can't
2:04:35
figure it out, I just can't figure
2:04:38
it out, I mean, there's just so
2:04:40
many of these men out there, and
2:04:42
I think a lot of it is.
2:04:45
I always look to economics, and we've
2:04:47
got to figure out vocational programming. I
2:04:49
think we should have national service, so
2:04:52
people feel a sense of identity and
2:04:54
connection and purpose. Some of the lowest
2:04:56
levels of young adult depression are in
2:04:58
Israel, despite all the existential threats, because
2:05:01
they all serve in the IDF for
2:05:03
two to three years. I think we
2:05:05
need... more freshmen seats at colleges. I
2:05:08
think we need more third places where
2:05:10
people, I think a lot of it
2:05:12
comes down to economics and policy programs.
2:05:14
I think there's a lot we can
2:05:17
do to help young men, but in
2:05:19
the US it's now 77% moving to
2:05:21
80% suicides. It's four to one. If
2:05:24
there was any special interest group, you
2:05:26
go into a morgue in America and
2:05:28
five people died by suicide, four men.
2:05:30
If that was any other special interest
2:05:33
group versus the control group, they'd weigh
2:05:35
in with programs. But because of the
2:05:37
enormous advantage, I registered. And let's be
2:05:40
honest, it was enormous. Basically, all prosperity
2:05:42
in America, which was unprecedented, was crammed
2:05:44
into 30% of the population, basically white
2:05:47
males. So we just had, we had
2:05:49
staggering advantage. And now 19-year-old males are
2:05:51
paying the price for my advantage. There's
2:05:53
really a lack of empathy for them.
2:05:56
What I do think is hopeful is
2:05:58
that mothers and women in society now
2:06:00
realize that the country and women are
2:06:03
not going to continue to flourish. if
2:06:05
men are flailing. And it finally feels
2:06:07
like we're having a real program. The
2:06:09
governor of Maryland, Westmore, has said that
2:06:12
his focus for his administration, this is
2:06:14
the governor of a state, a liberal
2:06:16
state, is going to be on helping
2:06:19
the state's young men. I mean, that
2:06:21
took such fucking balls for him to
2:06:23
say that. And you know what? The
2:06:26
populace received it well, because on the
2:06:28
ground, people are feeling it. They're really
2:06:30
feeling how much young men are struggling.
2:06:32
So... I'm actually quite hopeful that we've
2:06:35
turned a corner in terms of the
2:06:37
dialogue. Because when I started talking about
2:06:39
this four or five years ago, right
2:06:42
away, oh, your hair wasn't on fire
2:06:44
when women were, I mean, just, oh,
2:06:46
it was such, there was such a
2:06:48
gag reflex, it has changed so dramatically
2:06:51
in the last four or five years.
2:06:53
Where do we send these guys? That's
2:06:55
a great question, and I wish I
2:06:58
had. a list of resources and I'm
2:07:00
trying to assemble it around alright. I
2:07:02
mean, I'm involved with it because it's
2:07:05
difficult to discern between ordinary young adult
2:07:07
or adolescent problems and when a kid's
2:07:09
suicidal. I wish I had some sort
2:07:11
of AI filter that would go. This
2:07:14
kid needs help right away. Like here
2:07:16
are some resources. Here are some men's
2:07:18
groups. You know, and I do a
2:07:21
shitty job. I can't talk to all
2:07:23
of them. A couple of them, I
2:07:25
take the lazy. I say, here's 500.
2:07:27
just be, but I gotta be honest,
2:07:30
I don't know. I mean, I think
2:07:32
we should put together this list of
2:07:34
resources, and I feel like there are
2:07:37
good guys out there. I put Chris
2:07:39
Williamson in this group, I put both
2:07:41
of you out there. Podcasts are... how
2:07:44
a lot of modern wisdom is being
2:07:46
expressed right now, right? You don't go
2:07:48
to church, you get your sermon through
2:07:50
your airpods. So like, who are the
2:07:53
guys that are saying healthy things? And
2:07:55
I feel like if we can fill
2:07:57
their ears with the healthy messages of
2:08:00
masculinity, we are taking away the space
2:08:02
and the attention from the people that
2:08:04
are really profiting from. these negative messages.
2:08:06
I think you need a place to
2:08:09
send the people who email you. And
2:08:11
I appreciate the offering we should do
2:08:13
this, but we should have a list
2:08:16
that says, all right, what are you
2:08:18
struggling with? And here's some, here's some
2:08:20
resources or things you should think about.
2:08:23
But even what you both said to
2:08:25
my answer or to my question around,
2:08:27
like, what's the boot camp or what
2:08:29
would you tell guys? Like, that's not.
2:08:32
a crazy list. I think it's like
2:08:34
for a lot of these guys to
2:08:36
have you as sort of a male
2:08:39
role model of like go to the
2:08:41
gym, make money, be kind, look out
2:08:43
for others like I just feel like
2:08:45
that can be condensed into and maybe
2:08:48
that's what your new book is but
2:08:50
like truly I think people are looking
2:08:52
for a script with the lack of
2:08:55
religion, lack of institution. We've lost all
2:08:57
these scripts that tell people what to
2:08:59
do. Let's write a new script. It's
2:09:01
on you brother. You've got more tread
2:09:04
on you. You've got he's look at
2:09:06
all these cameras. I mean somebody's gonna
2:09:08
watch this and pull it together into
2:09:11
all of your advice But I'm just
2:09:13
saying I like the idea of a
2:09:15
collective it needs to get out there
2:09:18
because if you don't fill the space
2:09:20
Somebody else will and they already are
2:09:22
and it's not the messages that you
2:09:24
want to have the next population the
2:09:27
next generation having I agree We'll talk
2:09:29
about the same camera. One, two, three,
2:09:31
man. Anything else wanted to ask us?
2:09:34
I know you've got to hear of
2:09:36
yours. If you've got any questions, you
2:09:38
wanted to ask? No, I'm just really
2:09:40
glad that we're having this conversation. I
2:09:43
feel like maybe I wouldn't have had
2:09:45
this conversation a year ago. I do
2:09:47
think the tide is turning. I think
2:09:50
the title of the report as Lost
2:09:52
Boys is very helpful. everyone so that
2:09:54
we're all thriving and yeah, let's help
2:09:57
these lost boys and also help women.
2:09:59
Any closing points when it's why it's
2:10:01
gotten? Well, just a message to young
2:10:03
people in general. The arc of happiness
2:10:06
is a smile, and that is kind
2:10:08
of zero to 18 is prom, football,
2:10:10
you know, making out. It's generally pretty
2:10:13
happy. The least happy years for people
2:10:15
are usually kind of 18 to 45.
2:10:17
Economic stress, relationships are hard. You probably
2:10:19
are someone you love a great deal,
2:10:22
get sick and dies. And if you're
2:10:24
struggling, what I would just say is,
2:10:26
you know, don't be afraid to reach
2:10:29
out for help, but also realize that
2:10:31
if you're not a member of Parliament
2:10:33
and you don't have a fragrance named
2:10:36
after you, it doesn't mean you're failing.
2:10:38
And to forgive yourself and to recognize
2:10:40
that those are tough years. You know,
2:10:42
when my first kid was born, I
2:10:45
tell this story a lot. It's supposed
2:10:47
to be angel singing in bright lights.
2:10:49
I felt nothing but shame. I was
2:10:52
42 and I was broke. I had
2:10:54
put everything into my tech company. A
2:10:56
great financial session came along. I think
2:10:58
I have my account calling and said,
2:11:01
you're worth a negative $2 million. If
2:11:03
we look at your debts, you're worth
2:11:05
negative $2 million. And about that time,
2:11:08
my oldest son had the poor judgment
2:11:10
to come rotating out of my girlfriend.
2:11:12
And all I felt with this kid
2:11:15
was shame. I have failed myself. And
2:11:17
now I failed on an entirely new
2:11:19
dimension as a provider in a father.
2:11:21
That was the first thing I felt
2:11:24
when my son was born. And I
2:11:26
wrote about it, and I can't tell
2:11:28
you how many men I heard from.
2:11:31
That all I felt when I had
2:11:33
my first kid or kids was a
2:11:35
sense of embarrassment and that I was
2:11:37
already failing. That energy that you felt
2:11:40
at that moment, did you channel it
2:11:42
into something or were you tempted? Nausea.
2:11:44
I was in the delivery room? And
2:11:47
they were more worried about me and
2:11:49
they thought it was because I was
2:11:51
grossed out by birthing. It was because
2:11:53
I was so ashamed. I would just
2:11:56
immediately... I felt like, oh my God,
2:11:58
how did I put myself in a
2:12:00
position where I'm a terrible provider on
2:12:03
day one? I just felt a tremendous
2:12:05
amount of shame. And I think most
2:12:07
people when you talk to them at
2:12:10
some point have felt really down and
2:12:12
really like embarrassed. And I just don't
2:12:14
think that's anything unusual. And you want
2:12:16
to forgive yourself. You want to say
2:12:19
to yourself. I can add value to
2:12:21
a company. I can make someone very
2:12:23
happy, you know, and try and surround
2:12:26
yourself with people that make you feel
2:12:28
good about yourself. And every day, just
2:12:30
little baby steps, write some things down,
2:12:32
try and exercise, try and eat well.
2:12:35
I can tell when I'm getting depressed
2:12:37
and I have this method of getting
2:12:39
out of it. I call it SCAFA,
2:12:42
SCAFA sweat. It's like recets my operating
2:12:44
system, clean, try and eat really well,
2:12:46
at home, abstinence. And when I say
2:12:49
absence, absence, from pot and alcohol, both
2:12:51
of which I love, and I'm really
2:12:53
good at them, they add a value
2:12:55
to my life, but when I'm not
2:12:58
feeling good, I take them out of
2:13:00
my life, because whatever's going on with
2:13:02
my sensors, I just don't want to
2:13:05
mess with them. F is family, I
2:13:07
find being around my dogs laying on
2:13:09
me or my boys. I'll say to
2:13:11
my boys, let's instinctivelyly throw their legs
2:13:14
on mine. Not necessarily sex, but affection
2:13:16
with my partner. Those are the things
2:13:18
that get me out of a dark
2:13:21
place. So try and figure out, if
2:13:23
you can, what things help you get
2:13:25
out of a dark place, but recognize
2:13:28
everyone struggles. And I'm not saying that
2:13:30
you shouldn't reach out and find help,
2:13:32
but everything online is telling you you
2:13:34
should be in a golf stream and
2:13:37
parting in St. Bart's. No, that's just
2:13:39
not, that's not the real world. And
2:13:41
trying to support system. and also forgive
2:13:44
yourself. Life is happiness is a smile,
2:13:46
20 to 45. usually, you know, it's
2:13:48
full of a lot of joy, but
2:13:50
it's also full of a lot of,
2:13:53
you know, oftentimes a lot of anxiety.
2:13:55
Do you go to therapy? No. Have
2:13:57
you ever been? I did. My first
2:14:00
marriage, we went to marriage counseling, and
2:14:02
after the first session, we decided to
2:14:04
get divorced, so I'm a little traumatized
2:14:07
by therapy. Yeah. And he got right
2:14:09
to it. Save me real money. Yeah.
2:14:11
Oh, Stephen, I wanted to add one
2:14:13
more thing. I think an underappreciated resource
2:14:16
for men for building empathy is reading
2:14:18
fiction books. So I'm in a book
2:14:20
club, I read fiction all the time.
2:14:23
Fiction builds a lot of empathy because
2:14:25
you are truly inside the mind of
2:14:27
somebody else for two or three hundred
2:14:29
pages. When I talk to guys, they
2:14:32
so rarely read fiction. Do you read
2:14:34
any fiction? Not at all. a lot
2:14:36
of guys that I talk to, they
2:14:39
say, oh, I read nonfiction. And there's
2:14:41
so many lists online of like the
2:14:43
hundred nonfiction books to get your NBA.
2:14:46
And it's like we're all reading so
2:14:48
much nonfiction on our phone at all
2:14:50
times. Read a book of fiction, get
2:14:52
inside the head of somebody else, get
2:14:55
inside the head of a woman. I
2:14:57
think that for zero dollars at the
2:14:59
local library, you can actually become a
2:15:02
better person. You know, it's interesting. There's
2:15:04
a reason why men read books about
2:15:06
how. Because it goes back to everything
2:15:08
we've said. If I said to my
2:15:11
boys, boys, we're going to start reading
2:15:13
fiction, then my friends read stuff that's
2:15:15
going to help them build the business,
2:15:18
make money, or gain muscle mass. Yeah,
2:15:20
but can I convince? What if you're
2:15:22
single and I'm going to say, read
2:15:24
this fiction and you're going to get
2:15:27
laid? Like, why can't we just reframe
2:15:29
and change the narrative on fiction? Yeah.
2:15:31
I mean, I just feel like there's
2:15:34
so many examples of times that I
2:15:36
haven't really known. But I can think
2:15:38
about them more. And I just feel
2:15:41
like, look, if you are not having
2:15:43
success with women and you don't have
2:15:45
any women in your life, read a
2:15:47
fucking book by a woman. Just a
2:15:50
quick anecdote. When I was a senior
2:15:52
in high school and a freshman in
2:15:54
college, I remember thinking, I'm strange. I
2:15:57
remember feeling very insecure about my own
2:15:59
psychological make. up and that didn't help.
2:16:01
And then I read a bunch of
2:16:03
John Irving novels, the world according to
2:16:06
Garp, Sider House rules, and the
2:16:08
people in it were just so
2:16:10
fucking strange, it made me feel
2:16:12
better about myself. I'm like, oh,
2:16:14
there's other weirdos out there. So
2:16:16
what you say really resonates. It
2:16:18
made me feel less self-conscious about
2:16:20
how unusual I thought I was. So
2:16:22
it just dawned on me that that
2:16:24
was a big help for me. Tic-talk
2:16:26
is not going to give you the
2:16:29
empathy that spending 300 pages inside the
2:16:31
mind of a person different from yourself
2:16:33
will. Thank you both. For so
2:16:35
many reasons. Scott, you're actually writing a
2:16:38
book at the moment, which is going
2:16:40
to be published shortly. We've talked about
2:16:42
it a few times. What is the title
2:16:44
of that book and what is it
2:16:46
about? Well, I determine, I don't know
2:16:48
how it is for you with books,
2:16:50
but basically your publisher does nothing and
2:16:52
then obsesses over the title. So I
2:16:55
had it worked, it was supposed to be
2:16:57
originally about masculine and then I realized that
2:16:59
I don't have the skills of the domain
2:17:01
expertise to summarize masculinity. So I changed it
2:17:03
to work in progress, notes on becoming a
2:17:06
man, and I just talk about stories that
2:17:08
I've written about, about some of the things
2:17:10
we talked about today, and trying to use
2:17:12
masculinity as a code, I think everyone needs
2:17:14
a code, whether it's the military, the religion,
2:17:17
their family values. And I think masculinity
2:17:19
can serve as a code, if defined correctly for
2:17:21
young men. but it's just a series of
2:17:23
like stories about things I've gone through some
2:17:26
of my many ways I've failed and what
2:17:28
I learned about trying to become a
2:17:30
man trying to be a good dad trying to
2:17:32
be a good partner when is it published it'll
2:17:34
be on the fall on the fall okay
2:17:36
and Logan you have an incredible book
2:17:39
which is I mean one of the
2:17:41
I think the book on this subject
2:17:43
matter called how to not dialogue the
2:17:45
surprising science that will help you find
2:17:47
love and what does someone discover in
2:17:49
that book Well, it's really about understanding
2:17:51
the blind spots that hold people back
2:17:53
from finding love and then making a
2:17:56
plan to overcome them. I'm going to
2:17:58
link all of Scott's books and I'm all... Logan's
2:18:00
book in the comments below for anybody
2:18:02
to read. I also wanted to say
2:18:04
a huge thank you to the Center
2:18:06
of Social Justice for making this report
2:18:09
because again it's caused a huge conversation
2:18:11
in the UK now around the world
2:18:13
around Lost Boys and we have a
2:18:15
closing tradition on this podcast leaves a
2:18:17
question for the next guest not knowing
2:18:20
who they're leaving it for and the question
2:18:22
I'm going to ask both of you is Logan
2:18:24
what are you most scared off? I'm most
2:18:27
scared of losing my husband. Because
2:18:30
he has had a brush with death,
2:18:32
he had very serious bone
2:18:34
cancer. I feel like we've just
2:18:36
been through such hard stuff with
2:18:38
him medically, that right now I'm
2:18:40
here today with you, he's climbing.
2:18:43
I was just thinking, you know,
2:18:45
what happens if something happens
2:18:47
to him with climbing? And
2:18:49
we have a one-year-old daughter.
2:18:51
And so maybe the most
2:18:53
obvious answer is something to
2:18:55
happen to my husband. The
2:18:57
way I took that was what am I
2:19:00
most worried about? I'm really worried about
2:19:02
an epidemic of loneliness From
2:19:04
a societal standpoint that
2:19:06
people are starting to believe they
2:19:08
can disengage from life And that
2:19:10
leads to anxiety and depression and
2:19:12
polarization that makes the world
2:19:15
a less safe place Personally
2:19:17
my fears always been the same. I'm
2:19:19
always worried that my kind of
2:19:21
selfish instincts manifest
2:19:24
in an ugly way and I end up
2:19:26
alone and old. You know, that's my, that's
2:19:28
my biggest fear that I end
2:19:30
up dying under bright lights, you know,
2:19:33
surrounded by strangers. That's my
2:19:35
biggest fear. Because your selfish
2:19:37
instincts manifest, you do something wrong
2:19:39
in your relationship or you fuck
2:19:41
up your own? Yeah, just always,
2:19:43
my dad is not a very,
2:19:45
my dad ended up, my dad's
2:19:47
basically alone at 95 and some
2:19:49
of his less, some of his lower...
2:19:51
character quality attributes I see
2:19:53
in myself and that's a fear.
2:19:56
My fear is that you know end up dying
2:19:58
surrounded by strangers. Steve,
2:20:00
you're yours. The first thing that comes
2:20:03
to mind is something happening to
2:20:05
my partner. I just can't imagine, I
2:20:07
just see her as this like perfect
2:20:09
human being, that was like this angel.
2:20:11
So thinking, I just can't imagine ever
2:20:13
finding anybody comparable. So something happening to
2:20:16
her, finding out she was sick, I
2:20:18
think is the first thing that comes
2:20:20
to mind. It comes to mind, but
2:20:22
actually above anything in my life. And
2:20:24
then I do have a little bit
2:20:27
of Scots fear, which she expressed. there
2:20:29
which is that I will
2:20:31
make bad decisions based on,
2:20:33
I'm going to just say
2:20:35
it, just like the temptation
2:20:38
of life and that will lead
2:20:40
me up, lead me to be
2:20:42
a bad father, not be around
2:20:44
for my kids, not be able
2:20:46
to be around for my kids
2:20:49
and be lonely and old
2:20:51
and rich and miserable.
2:20:53
It's like kind of a fear
2:20:55
I've always had. It's interesting
2:20:57
I said the word temptation. Yeah. Because in
2:21:00
the world, you know, there's a lot of
2:21:02
temptation. There is. People don't talk about it a
2:21:04
lot. Thank you, Scott. Thank you. I want to say thank
2:21:06
you to you in particular because you've been
2:21:08
one of the leading voices in this
2:21:10
fight. That's a generous thing to say.
2:21:12
No, but it's absolutely not generous because
2:21:14
it's absolutely true. When people think of
2:21:16
this subject matter, they think of you
2:21:18
now. And you also stuck your neck
2:21:21
out and started speaking about this subject
2:21:23
long before it was okay to speak
2:21:25
about this subject. And you spoke about
2:21:27
it in such an eloquent, hilarious, wise
2:21:29
way that both sides listened. And I think
2:21:31
you're one of the key people on
2:21:34
this subject matter who's even allowed these
2:21:36
kind of reports to exist. Because I'm
2:21:38
actually not sure that if it wasn't
2:21:41
for you, reports like this would exist.
2:21:43
I think you're wrong, but I'll take it. Like
2:21:45
I actually think I'm right because the reach you've
2:21:47
had on this subject matter is hundreds and hundreds
2:21:49
of millions of people across the clips, across the
2:21:51
podcasts you've done. And like I said, listen, there
2:21:53
wasn't a lot of people saying it before you
2:21:55
could say it. You've actually given cover to a
2:21:57
lot of people. You've even given cover to me.
2:22:00
and it's because of the wonderful science
2:22:02
and art that you deploy as it
2:22:04
relates to communication. And Logan, thank you
2:22:06
as well, because you've made the decision
2:22:09
as well to lend your voice to this
2:22:11
subject matter, which is complicated and
2:22:13
it's like problematic and it's full
2:22:15
of like landmines it feels like.
2:22:17
But you're adding an incredibly important
2:22:20
perspective when that comes from tremendous
2:22:22
research, lived experience, and you're a
2:22:24
very important, I think, individual in
2:22:26
this fight. to speak to speak
2:22:28
and to sort of create a
2:22:30
better world for our young and
2:22:32
lost boys. Thank you. Can I thank Scott
2:22:35
too? You know, just to make you
2:22:37
uncomfortable. Okay. Yeah, so as I've been
2:22:39
talking to people about my interest in
2:22:41
this, the first thing they always say
2:22:43
is, oh, the stuff that Scott Galloway
2:22:45
is talking about. And if you weren't
2:22:47
talking about it, I don't think they would
2:22:49
have anyone to point to. But I just
2:22:52
needed. I feel like a plagiarist because
2:22:54
the majority of my good data comes
2:22:56
from Richard Reeves. I know that that's
2:22:58
true, but the point is you are
2:23:01
the most effective communicator in the world
2:23:03
right now. Your ability to turn stories
2:23:05
and facts into persuasion is something that
2:23:08
no one else is doing. So you're
2:23:10
taking Richard's data and combining your lived
2:23:12
experience and you're getting this message out
2:23:14
there in a way that no one
2:23:17
else is doing. I think that's generous.
2:23:19
Thank you. And no one else could reach
2:23:21
both sides. in such an effective way, which I
2:23:23
think is really important. So again, thank you,
2:23:25
Scott. Thank you. Thank you for being so generous
2:23:27
with your time. Really appreciate it. We launched these
2:23:30
conversation cards and they sold out. And we launched
2:23:32
them again and they sold out again. We launched
2:23:34
them again and they sold out again. Because people
2:23:36
love playing these with colleagues at work, with friends
2:23:38
at home, and also with family. And we've also
2:23:41
got a big audience that used them as journal
2:23:43
prompts. Every single time a guest comes on the
2:23:45
diary of a CEO, they leave a question for
2:23:47
the next guest in the diary. And I've sat
2:23:50
here with some of the most incredible people in
2:23:52
the world. And they've left all of these questions
2:23:54
in the diary. And I've ranked them from
2:23:56
one to three in terms of the depth,
2:23:58
one being a starter question. And level three,
2:24:00
if you look on the back here,
2:24:02
this is a level three, becomes a
2:24:05
much deeper question that builds even more
2:24:07
connection. If you turn the cards over
2:24:09
and you scan that QR code, you
2:24:11
can see who answered the card and
2:24:13
watch the video of them answering it
2:24:15
in real time. So if you would
2:24:17
like to get your hands on some
2:24:19
of these conversation cards, go to the
2:24:21
diary.com or look at the link in
2:24:24
the description below. I find it incredibly
2:24:26
fascinating that when we look at the
2:24:28
back end of Spotify and Apple and
2:24:30
Art audio channels, the majority of people
2:24:32
that watch this podcast haven't yet hit
2:24:34
the follow button or the subscribe button,
2:24:36
wherever you're listening to this, I would
2:24:38
like to make a deal with this,
2:24:40
I would like to make a deal
2:24:42
with you, if you could do me
2:24:45
a huge favour and hit that subscribe
2:24:47
button, I would like to make a
2:24:49
deal with you, to do in this
2:24:51
thing we love. If you could do
2:24:53
me that small favour and hit the
2:24:55
follow button, wherever you're listening to this,
2:24:57
that would mean the world to me.
2:24:59
That is the only favour I will
2:25:01
ever ask you. Thank you so much
2:25:04
for your time.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More