Why California's high speed rail was always going to blow out

Why California's high speed rail was always going to blow out

Released Thursday, 6th June 2024
 1 person rated this episode
Why California's high speed rail was always going to blow out

Why California's high speed rail was always going to blow out

Why California's high speed rail was always going to blow out

Why California's high speed rail was always going to blow out

Thursday, 6th June 2024
 1 person rated this episode
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:01

NPR. In

0:12

2011, Dan Richard got a call

0:14

from California's governor at the time,

0:16

Jerry Brown. And Jerry Brown

0:18

had a job offer for him. That

0:21

actually turned down. But they kept talking.

0:24

And eventually they got to this other idea that

0:26

had been around for decades. And

0:28

then they got to the high speed rail. A super fast

0:31

train that would take passengers from LA to

0:33

San Francisco in just two and a half

0:35

hours. Nothing like this had ever

0:37

been done before in the US. And

0:39

at this time, it was more than a dream. It

0:41

had a budget. $33 billion

0:43

when it went to voters a few years prior.

0:46

It had a completion date, 2020. It

0:48

also had a board. So Dan,

0:51

a veteran transport executive, said, I

0:53

could help there. And

0:55

I believe I literally said the words to him,

0:57

how hard could that be? So

1:00

he gave me an opportunity to find out. How

1:05

hard could it be? Well,

1:07

Dan soon learned that California high

1:09

speed rail was victim to what

1:12

often plagues mega projects, enormous

1:14

cost overruns and delays. Today on

1:16

the show, how to build big.

1:19

From California high speed rail to the

1:21

Sydney Opera House, we will learn the

1:24

do's and don'ts on leading ambitious projects.

1:29

This message comes from NPR sponsor Greenlight.

1:31

Want to teach your kids financial literacy?

1:34

With Greenlight, kids and teens use a

1:36

debit card of their own while parents

1:38

can keep an eye on kids spending

1:40

and savings in the app. Get your

1:43

first month free at greenlight.com/NPR. Support

1:46

for NPR and the following message come

1:48

from Carvana. On a mission to make

1:50

car buying more convenient and affordable than

1:53

ever before. In minutes, you can browse

1:55

thousands of options under $20,000. Visit

1:59

carvana.com. or download the app

2:01

today to get started. On

2:03

this week's episode of Wild Card, comedian Bowen

2:05

Yang says you don't have to feel bad

2:08

for falling short on mindfulness. I get in

2:10

my own way by like overprivileged

2:13

the present. That's

2:15

so interesting because everyone wants to be in the

2:17

present. I feel like being present

2:20

is overrated. I'm Rachel Martin, join

2:22

us for NPR's Wild Card Podcast, the

2:24

game where cards control the conversation. To

2:28

learn how to build big projects

2:30

like high-speed rail, Bent Floupayer is

2:32

the go-to guy. He's a professor

2:34

at Oxford University and IT University

2:36

of Copenhagen. And Bent

2:38

and his colleagues have discovered this

2:41

striking pattern with megaprojects. As in

2:43

railroads, tunnels, mines, airports, that kind

2:45

of thing, he calls

2:47

this pattern the iron law of

2:49

megaprojects. The best majority of

2:51

projects are unsuccessful and not

2:53

just by a little, by a lot. Bent

2:56

found that 99.5% of megaprojects were

2:59

over time, over budget, or had

3:02

lower benefits than expected, often

3:04

a combination of these things. And California

3:06

high-speed rail has gone over time and

3:08

budget, which is not that unusual. Rail

3:11

projects are typically 40% over budget, but

3:14

by 2011, costs for the high-speed

3:16

rail had tripled. Bent's research has

3:19

uncovered a few lessons that megaprojects

3:21

like high-speed rail could learn from.

3:24

And the first lesson is the

3:26

importance of actual experience in the

3:28

exact type of project. Experience, as

3:30

he really makes a difference. And

3:33

often this is disregarded when you

3:35

talk about project leadership. Bent points

3:37

out there are no modern high-speed rails in

3:39

the US at the moment. So essentially there's

3:42

no experience building those in this country. And

3:44

he's particularly critical of the California

3:46

high-speed rail project for not awarding

3:49

contracts to overseas companies with experience.

3:51

They didn't hire the people who are planning to

3:53

build high-speed rail lines before. They decided

3:56

to reinvent the wheel. Several countries

3:58

have high-speed rail, famously.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features