How We Used to Live (Levittown, Progress, and Expectations)

How We Used to Live (Levittown, Progress, and Expectations)

Released Thursday, 24th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
How We Used to Live (Levittown, Progress, and Expectations)

How We Used to Live (Levittown, Progress, and Expectations)

How We Used to Live (Levittown, Progress, and Expectations)

How We Used to Live (Levittown, Progress, and Expectations)

Thursday, 24th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

of my favorite quotes is from David

0:02

Packard, who once said, I

0:05

see

0:08

this all the time. It is so common with

0:10

money, whether it is for you individually

0:12

or for your business, that people get

0:14

so tangled up in the big complex projects

0:17

that they drop the ball on the

0:19

small stuff. To do well over time,

0:21

you have to get the simple stuff right

0:23

first. And one of those

0:25

fundamentals in business that often gets

0:27

overlooked is expense management. And

0:30

that is why 25 ,000

0:32

businesses use Ramp. Ramp

0:34

is a corporate card that includes

0:36

the best expense tracking and reporting

0:38

software that I have ever seen.

0:40

It makes expense management so simple

0:42

by automatically capturing every transaction the

0:45

moment a card is swiped. For

0:47

listeners of the show, Ramp is offering metal

0:49

cards for the next 30 days. Just

0:51

go to ramp.com slash Morgan.

0:54

That's ramp.com slash

0:56

Morgan. Cards were issued by

0:58

Sutton Bank, number FDIC, terms and conditions

1:01

apply. Before

1:08

I start today's episode, I want to share

1:10

with you an article that I

1:12

just stumbled across just before I hit

1:14

record just now that I thought was so

1:16

fascinating and got me thinking about a lot of

1:18

different things. There's an article

1:20

in Scientific American that talked

1:23

about these eye doctors who

1:25

recently, I have no idea

1:27

who would sign up to do

1:29

this experiment, but these eye doctors, Ibiscus

1:31

did a very extreme form of

1:33

LASIK eye surgery on five patients to

1:36

manipulate their retinas. And

1:38

after the surgery, this was the idea, these

1:41

patients, there are five of them, can

1:43

now see a color

1:45

that you and I and everybody else

1:48

cannot. Now, by definition,

1:50

it's impossible to explain what that color would

1:52

be because, like, how do you explain the

1:54

color red to someone who's never seen red

1:56

before? It's impossible. It's just red. And

1:58

so this color, they explain it as

2:00

a version of teal with a

2:02

level of saturation that my

2:04

brain and your brain cannot even

2:07

fathom. And that's amazing on its

2:09

own because the idea that You

2:11

and I think that we can see the

2:13

world. We have eyes. We can see everything. Everything

2:15

is in front of me. This plant, this

2:17

desk, this computer, this microphone I'm speaking to. We

2:20

can see it. And it's true, but there's

2:22

a lot out there that we cannot see. In

2:24

this case, literally. There are colors out there

2:26

that our eyes and our brains cannot even percept.

2:29

And once you do a surgery like this, all of

2:31

a sudden there's a world out there that you

2:33

didn't even know existed before. I think

2:35

that is a good analogy. for

2:37

how a lot of things in the

2:39

world works. We were talking about

2:41

politics, the economy, investing,

2:44

science, whatever it might be. It is

2:46

very common for everybody. The natural state

2:48

of affairs is to assume that you

2:50

can see all of the world, that

2:52

you understand at least the world that

2:54

you live in without the knowledge that

2:56

there is so much out there going

2:58

on that you cannot even perceive. Ideas

3:01

that you're unaware of, science

3:03

that you're unaware of, cultures

3:07

values, views of the world that are

3:09

having a big impact on the

3:12

world that you and I cannot even

3:14

perceive. That happens all the time.

3:16

And I think it explains a lot of what's

3:18

going on in the world today. Most

3:20

arguments in the world about the

3:22

economy, about politics, about culture are not

3:24

really people arguing with each other,

3:26

so to speak. They're not really disagreeing

3:28

with each other. It's people who

3:30

have seen a very different side of

3:32

the world talking over each other. And

3:35

I think when you View it through

3:37

the lens, no pun intended, of there are

3:39

literally colors in the world that our

3:41

brains cannot conceive. So of course,

3:43

are there ideas and values that we

3:46

are completely oblivious and unaware of? Of

3:48

course. I love that idea. I just

3:50

wanted to share it with you before we get into

3:52

the bigger idea that I want to talk about today. And

3:55

what I want to talk about today is a

3:57

topic that I think has always been important, that I

3:59

wrote a little bit about in my book, Same

4:01

As Ever. But I think it's

4:03

probably more important Today over the

4:05

last year and probably going forward

4:07

for the next couple years then

4:09

it's been in a long time

4:11

and that is understanding shifts and

4:13

expectations and what the average ordinary

4:16

American considers to be an average

4:18

ordinary life. It's very easy to

4:20

look over the fact that what

4:22

counts as a decent, dignified life

4:24

today has shifted dramatically over the

4:26

last 80 years. And why that's

4:28

important today is because, of course,

4:30

there is a lot of talk

4:32

about going back to a world

4:35

that we used to have. Tariffs

4:37

are largely based around that idea. We've

4:39

talked about this in previous episodes that

4:42

we used to have a very strong

4:44

manufacturing base and good manufacturing jobs, and

4:46

we don't anymore. Now, there

4:48

is truth to that. As I spoke about

4:50

two episodes ago, a lot of that is

4:52

simply automation. It's not necessarily shipping those jobs

4:54

elsewhere, although that has been a factor, of

4:56

course. But the general idea here

4:58

is that we want to go back to

5:00

a time that was better. We used to

5:03

have a great economy. We don't anymore. Let's

5:05

go back. This isn't working. Let's go

5:07

back to that. I understand and empathize

5:09

with those feelings. And to some extent,

5:11

a lot of that can be true.

5:14

There are parts of the economy that

5:16

used to be more prosperous than

5:18

there are today. There are cities and

5:20

towns and regions that used to

5:22

be more prosperous than they are. Of

5:24

course, that is true. But I

5:26

want to use an example of what

5:29

I think was the peak of

5:31

Americana middle class prosperity that I think

5:33

if you wanted to put an

5:35

image on the nostalgia that we're trying

5:37

to go back to, it would

5:39

be this. I'm going

5:41

to start the story. at the

5:43

end of World War II,

5:45

1945, when 16 million American soldiers

5:47

came home. And of

5:49

course, when they came home, they had

5:51

just suffered and adored and took part

5:53

in the ravages of World War II,

5:55

the most horrific event of the 20th

5:57

century. And before that, before that began,

6:00

most of the GIs grew up as

6:02

children during the Great Depression. and

6:04

experience the poverty, watch their parents

6:06

endure the poverty of those eight years

6:08

or so of the Great Depression.

6:10

So when they came home in 1945,

6:12

there was such an overwhelming desire

6:14

to relax and enjoy the life that

6:16

they had not been able to

6:18

enjoy up until that point, at any

6:21

point during their adult lives, or

6:23

even in any part of their life

6:25

that they could remember. So

6:27

much what happened during the Great

6:29

Depression was people moved Inwards physically inwards

6:31

you had if you had a

6:33

house or an apartment your grandmother your

6:35

cousin maybe even your neighbors moved

6:37

in with you That was what happened

6:39

when you lost your house to

6:41

foreclosure You couldn't for the rent anymore

6:43

people moved in housing got very

6:45

very dense and as World War two

6:47

ended and the people came home

6:49

What was so common among the soldiers

6:52

who returned home was I want

6:54

space I don't want to live

6:56

in a tiny apartment in Brooklyn with

6:58

my grandmother and my cousins and my

7:00

aunt and my uncle. I want my

7:02

own space. I deserved it. I've earned

7:04

it. And that view was noted very

7:06

clearly by a guy named William Levitt. William

7:09

Levitt worked in what was kind of like

7:11

the Army Corps of Engineers in World War

7:13

II. And when he came home from the

7:15

war, he noticed there was going to be

7:17

incredible demand to take farmland

7:19

that was on the outskirts of big

7:21

cities and turn them into what we know

7:23

today as suburbs. That was kind of

7:25

a new idea back in the 1940s and

7:27

1950s. Up until that point, you pretty

7:30

much had two places to live, a

7:32

farm in the middle of nowhere or a

7:34

dense urban city. William Levitt

7:36

really pioneered the idea of the

7:38

suburb. A lot of these were on

7:40

the outskirts of cities, not not far

7:42

from New York or Philadelphia, where

7:44

you could live in a nice area

7:46

where you had your own house.

7:48

in a backyard. It wasn't a

7:50

cramped apartment, but you could still

7:53

drive into the city to work. That

7:55

was a new pioneering idea made

7:57

part by and large by the automobile,

7:59

which that too was a fairly

8:01

new idea and the new interstate highway

8:03

system and roads that were being

8:05

built. And so Leviton Sons, the home

8:08

building company, started buying up hundreds

8:10

of acres of farmland in New York

8:12

and Pennsylvania and later in other

8:14

areas around the United States to build

8:16

what were known then and now

8:18

as Levittown. The first was

8:20

Levittown, New York, and then it moved

8:23

into Pennsylvania. I think there's one in New

8:25

Jersey. And Levittowns are kind of the

8:27

peak ideal of what Americana was. It

8:29

was these gigantic communities. They eventually

8:31

built more than 50 ,000 homes in

8:33

America. And this there are

8:35

so many documentaries that were made about

8:37

Levittown because it is the ideal

8:39

leave it to beaver neighborhood. That was

8:41

the view then and I think

8:43

to a large extent the view now.

8:45

The idea of a middle -class family,

8:48

a working husband, a stay -at

8:50

-home mom, three kids, a dog named

8:52

Spot, a white picket fence. The

8:54

kids came home and they were well

8:56

behaved and they played baseball in the

8:58

front yard and everyone was happy and

9:00

they had picnics and they took the

9:02

canoe out on the lake on the

9:05

weekend. Like the ideal perfect Norman Rockwell

9:07

American life. That was Levittown. I

9:09

found this documentary about Levittown. It

9:11

was made in the 1990s. And

9:13

the name of the documentary, I

9:15

think sums up the feeling that

9:17

people had for Levittown then and

9:19

in modern times. The name of

9:21

the documentary is Wonderland because that

9:24

was what Levittown felt like. It

9:26

was absolutely incredible that a middle

9:28

class. working American family, the

9:30

vast majority of whom were GIs

9:32

could come home and buy their

9:34

own house. They weren't

9:36

renting an apartment. They weren't even living

9:38

in a cramped apartment. They had

9:40

their own house with a backyard and

9:43

a driveway. That was absurd. That

9:45

was amazing. It felt just

9:47

bonkers to people that you could

9:49

do this. And when you contrasted that,

9:51

that life when they were buying

9:53

these homes in the 1950s to the

9:55

war and the Great Depression and

9:57

the cramped apartment in Brooklyn that they

9:59

had experienced up until then, Levittown,

10:01

the American suburb, felt like

10:03

a dream. There's

10:05

a quote in the documentary of a woman

10:08

who had lived in Levittown for 40

10:10

years at that point. And she says, quote,

10:12

when we moved to Levittown, it was like

10:14

a utopia. That was

10:16

that was the only way that you could describe

10:19

it. a wonderland, a utopia. It was the ideal

10:21

of America, like this leave it to beaver land.

10:23

One other guy who had lived there since he

10:25

was a child, he'd been there for about 40

10:27

years at this point. He said, quote, it

10:29

was so perfect. It was like a sitcom. We

10:32

were expecting there to be a laugh track in

10:34

the background. Just these perfect,

10:36

ideal family suburb. Everyone's

10:38

happy. That's the view of it. But

10:41

there's another part in the documentary that

10:43

I think is the most important. And

10:45

this was back in the

10:47

1990s. Levittown was just starting

10:49

to lose its charm, lose

10:51

the glamour, lose this Americana

10:53

utopia that it used to

10:56

be. And it interviewed

10:58

someone who had been there since the original

11:00

1940s. Remember, this is in the 90s. So

11:02

there were a couple of residents who had

11:04

been there since day one. And

11:06

he's talking about how

11:08

he, for his generation, the

11:10

greatest generation, Levittown

11:12

was as good as it got. Even when

11:14

they lived there for decades, it still felt

11:16

like a utopia. But for his children and

11:18

maybe his grandchildren, it wasn't. They

11:20

wanted to get out. They hated it. They wanted to

11:23

make as soon as they graduated high school or college,

11:25

they couldn't wait to get out of there. And so

11:27

this guy who lived there for 50 years said, quote,

11:30

the idea was probably great 40 years

11:32

ago, but something happened along the way

11:34

to take away the dream. He

11:36

said, quote, this is my

11:39

dream come true because this is what I

11:41

expected to have in my lifetime. I

11:43

don't know what my children expect, but

11:45

this is what I wanted. This

11:47

is my dream come true. And

11:50

what he was pointing to is that Levittown

11:52

for him was amazing. It exceeded his expectations by

11:54

so much that even when he had lived

11:56

there for almost half a century, it was still

11:58

the utopia that it felt like when he

12:00

moved in. But for his children's

12:03

generation, it wasn't. They

12:05

didn't like it. They hated it. They wanted to

12:07

move. And so we

12:09

could go down that idea for

12:11

a long time, but I want

12:13

to sum this up. I mean,

12:15

I put a pin in this

12:17

idea with one statistic of the

12:19

50 ,000 Levittown homes that were built.

12:22

How many today have been altered

12:24

as in have a new

12:26

addition put on them? A

12:28

garage that was added on a

12:30

third or fourth bedroom that was

12:32

added on a new family room

12:34

or dining room that was added

12:36

on to them? And the answer

12:38

is virtually every single one of

12:40

them. except for one. Apparently the

12:42

address is 52 Oak Tree Lane

12:44

that is effectively untouched in its

12:46

original footprint. Virtually all

12:49

of the other 50 ,000

12:51

plus Levittown homes have been

12:53

added to. Because this

12:55

is really important, the original

12:57

Levittown house, the original footprint,

12:59

they were all virtually the

13:01

same, was 750 square feet.

13:04

It didn't have a garage. It didn't

13:06

have a basement. It didn't have a deck, it

13:08

didn't have a porch, didn't have air conditioning. It

13:11

was two bedrooms, a

13:13

living room, and a kitchen, and one bathroom,

13:15

and that was it. So

13:17

imagine, by the way, the typical 1950s

13:19

leave -it -to -beaver family that had three

13:21

and a half kids, they were living

13:23

in a house with two bedrooms. Your

13:26

three and a half kids shared a

13:28

bedroom. Everybody shared one bathroom. Air

13:30

conditioning. forget about it. Garage, forget

13:32

about it. Porch, forget about it. The

13:34

average lot size for the Levittown

13:36

house was 6 ,000 square feet, which

13:38

I had looked this up so I

13:40

can't really contextualize that, is very

13:42

small. The average new house

13:44

today in the United States, the

13:46

lot is almost 9 ,000 square

13:48

feet. So almost 50 % bigger than

13:50

it was back then. The point

13:52

I want to make is that

13:54

what was considered to be a

13:57

life that was so incredible you

13:59

could only describe it as a

14:01

utopia. Those Levittown houses back in

14:03

the 1950s would be considered barely

14:05

livable by today's standards. Again,

14:07

let me explain that with

14:09

some statistics. The median new

14:12

house in the United States

14:14

in 2024 was 2 ,157

14:16

square feet. It was

14:18

three times the size of the Levittown

14:20

utopia house. three times the size. The

14:22

average new house today is, of course,

14:24

two stories. It has a two -car garage.

14:26

It has air conditioning. It has a

14:28

porch made from half a deck. The

14:31

Levittown houses had none of those

14:33

things. And I found

14:35

this New York Times article from 2007

14:37

that was trying to find an

14:39

original Levittown house. And this journalist is

14:41

on the hunt for an untouched

14:43

Levittown house. And he can't find one

14:45

anywhere. Because as we now know,

14:47

virtually none of them exist. Every one

14:49

of them has had another bedroom

14:51

attached, a garage attached, a huge new

14:53

addition that has a new kitchen

14:55

or a new living room. They've all

14:57

been added to because nobody in

15:00

the year 2024 or for a long

15:02

time wants to live in a

15:04

700 square foot house with no garage

15:06

and no air conditioning. And

15:08

this article finds this guy who buys an

15:10

original Levittown house and he's very quickly about

15:12

to add to it. He's going to add

15:14

a garage and add a bedroom to it.

15:16

And there was a museum back then that

15:18

wanted to buy the original Levittown house. And

15:20

when they learned that this gentleman bought one,

15:22

but he's about to alter it and turn

15:24

it into a modern house, they're like, no,

15:27

no, no, please don't do it. And this

15:29

guy who buys a house, his name is

15:31

Mr. Schrader. He says, quote, I

15:33

hate to disappoint the historical society, but

15:35

I need a home, not a

15:37

museum. I mean, it's cool

15:39

living in a bare bones Levittown house.

15:41

People do tell me, wow, it's an

15:43

original levite. That must be very rare.

15:45

But people don't want to raise a

15:47

family in a house that size anymore. That

15:51

last line is so important. People

15:53

don't want to raise a family in a house

15:55

that size anymore. The world

15:57

that we have so much nostalgia

15:59

to for the 1950s would be considered

16:01

a deep poverty today. I don't

16:04

think that's an exaggeration whatsoever. In

16:06

2024, America, if you're trying to

16:08

raise four kids, in a house

16:10

that has two bedrooms, no air

16:12

conditioning, no garage, 700 square feet, that

16:14

would not be considered within 10

16:16

miles of middle class. In the vast

16:18

majority of America, I don't think

16:20

that's an exaggeration whatsoever. Now,

16:23

of course, people do that, or many

16:25

people who do that in the United States

16:27

in apartments and whatnot, but nobody in

16:29

that situation, literally nobody would be using words

16:31

like wonderland and utopia to describe raising

16:33

four kids in a 700 square foot house.

16:36

And so look, the very simple, but I think

16:39

very important point that I want to make

16:41

is that the definition of what a good life

16:43

is has shifted. It's increased

16:45

substantially in the last 80 years

16:47

or so. By the way, what do

16:49

you call that shift in expectations? Progress

16:52

is what you call it. It's wonderful.

16:54

It's not a bad thing that it used

16:56

to be a 700 square foot house

16:58

with no air conditioning was utopia. And now

17:00

We have 2 ,200 square foot houses with

17:02

three car garages and four bathrooms and

17:04

air conditioning and going down the list. And

17:07

that's considered average. That's what

17:09

progress looks like. That's great. I

17:11

want to live in a world in which our

17:13

definition of a good life expands. But

17:15

I think this is true, too, for

17:17

the jobs that we yearn for. As

17:20

we go through tariffs, we're trying to

17:22

bring manufacturing back to the United States

17:24

and yearning for a time when middle

17:26

class people could work in manufacturing jobs

17:28

that we now think have been disappeared

17:30

to China and Mexico and Canada and

17:32

other places. It's true.

17:34

Look, to some extent, that is true.

17:36

And this gets more touchy because you're talking

17:38

about people's dignity of their work and

17:40

their employment. But what's true is that a

17:43

lot of the manufacturing jobs that existed

17:45

50 or 80 or 100 years ago would

17:47

not be considered good jobs at all

17:49

anymore, would not be considered acceptable jobs in

17:51

the slightest. Let me give

17:53

you one statistic to put a point on this. Building

17:55

the Hoover Dam, which is

17:57

like incredible feat of engineering when

17:59

it took place. Just an amazing thing

18:02

that happened. 96

18:04

workers died building the

18:06

Hoover Dam. If something

18:08

like that happened today, before we got even

18:10

remotely close to that, before when 10 people

18:12

died, we would have shut the whole project

18:14

down. Workplace deaths in the

18:16

1950s, that's not when the Hoover Dam was

18:18

built, but just using that as a

18:20

reference point, were almost four times higher than

18:23

than they are today. People just

18:25

had much more tolerance for the indignity,

18:27

the physical pain, the physical suffering, and

18:29

even the death that was required of

18:31

the manufacturing jobs back then than they

18:33

are today. And look, maybe this is

18:35

the wrong way to phrase it. But

18:37

to the extent that people are softer

18:40

now than they used to be, that

18:42

they will not put up with a

18:44

job where 96 of your coworkers are

18:46

going to die around you building one

18:48

project, the fact that we don't put

18:50

up with that anymore, that

18:52

too is progress. Isn't that great? Don't you

18:54

want to live in a world where dying

18:56

on the job is not acceptable anymore like

18:58

it used to be? But

19:01

that too is an example that

19:03

our definition of a good job

19:05

has shifted over time. I

19:07

think it is largely true

19:09

that a big chunk of

19:12

America, particularly in urban and

19:14

suburban America, the definition

19:16

of a good life in the

19:18

eyes of let's say a 22 year

19:20

old is a bachelor's

19:22

degree from a flagship university, a

19:25

six -figure job waiting for them when they're done, a

19:28

2 ,500 -square -foot house with a

19:30

30 -year fixed -rate mortgage to buy

19:32

it with. That's like

19:34

the baseline level of success. That's what

19:36

they expect. Now, that

19:38

too, I'll say for the 10th time on

19:40

this podcast, that's progress. Compare Levittown

19:43

and dying on the job

19:45

to that today, that's progress, but

19:47

is a massive shift in

19:49

expectations. And I

19:51

think when we fall for the siren

19:53

song of nostalgia, of wanting to go

19:55

back, we should always keep that in

19:57

mind that the definition of a good

19:59

life has changed substantially and that we

20:01

might be surprised and shocked in a

20:03

bad way if we are constantly yearning

20:05

to go back and we actually take

20:07

a step back. Because I

20:09

think the fact is if you and I

20:11

had a time machine and we can

20:14

go back to Levittown in 1958, let's say,

20:17

and we stepped off that time machine.

20:19

we would instantly see two things. One

20:22

is, I think, yes, people were

20:24

happy. They were pretty satisfied. They

20:27

couldn't believe that they were living in this utopia.

20:30

That would be our first realization. The second realization

20:32

is, I think, we would look around and

20:34

say, that's the house you live in. That's

20:37

where you live. That tiny little thing, that's

20:39

your house. That's your utopia. I

20:41

think a lot of us would say that. Now,

20:44

I know that could be a touchy point. It's different

20:46

for everybody. Maybe it's actually good.

20:48

This was unintentional that I started this

20:50

podcast with the Experimental Surgery and these

20:52

people who can see new colors because

20:54

all of us me included everybody Has

20:56

that in their own world When we're

20:58

trying to make sense of the world

21:01

and defining what a good life is

21:03

and taking stock of how other people

21:05

live how we live and our expectations

21:07

Everybody is a little blind to what

21:09

others are going through But more importantly,

21:11

I think it's easy to become blind

21:13

to what we ourselves used

21:15

to be in the past, the lives

21:18

that we used to live, the definition

21:20

of success that we used to have. That's

21:22

true in your individual life, and

21:24

it's true for society as a whole.

21:29

That's it for this episode. Thanks

21:31

again for listening, and we'll see you next time.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features