Do No Harm

Do No Harm

Released Thursday, 10th August 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Do No Harm

Do No Harm

Do No Harm

Do No Harm

Thursday, 10th August 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

After several requests, I finally

0:04

got an appointment to see a doctor. When

0:06

the day came, they

0:09

handcuffed me. They put a chainer

0:11

on my waist all the way down to my ankles.

0:15

He doesn't acknowledge me. He just

0:17

sits in front of me and starts s prepping for the

0:19

procedure, which he does not explain. So

0:26

that's a woman named Karina Cisnero

0:28

s Preciado who's testifying before

0:30

Congress. Karina is an

0:32

undocumented immigrant who was being held

0:34

at a detention center in Irwin County,

0:36

Georgia. While she was held there in

0:39

twenty twenty, the facilities doctor

0:41

subjected her to invasive reproductive

0:43

procedures without her consent. And

0:46

it turns out Karina wasn't alone.

0:49

He was doing the same thing to a lot

0:51

of other women. I

0:54

thank god that the news came

0:56

out because he didn't

0:58

get to do anything else to me. That

1:06

news came out because of a whistleblower

1:08

who was working at this detention center at

1:11

the same time, a licensed practical

1:13

nurse named Dawn Wootton. When

1:16

don learned what was happening, she raised

1:18

hell and her life has

1:20

been hell ever since. This

1:25

is the whistleblowers. On

1:28

this show, we're going deep into the heart of

1:30

power to meet people who spoke out

1:32

about wrongdoing from inside the Trump

1:34

administration. Some were

1:37

in the President's inner circle, others

1:39

were on the front lines of top agencies.

1:43

So far in this series, we've heard stories

1:45

from people like Andy McCabe,

1:47

alex Vinman, Olivia Troy,

1:50

people who spent their careers working in Washington,

1:53

DC. But Don Wootton, She's

1:55

a nurse doing the job that she'd

1:57

trained for, pretty far from the center

2:00

of political power, and yet

2:02

by becoming a whistleblower, Dawn

2:04

created a new type of power. Her

2:07

voice ended up reverberating all

2:09

the way from a corrupt detention center in rural

2:11

Georgia to the US capital itself.

2:15

In doing so, she found herself

2:17

caught in a crossfire she never

2:19

expected Episode

2:25

six, Do No Harm.

2:34

Before she was a whistleblower, Don Wootton

2:36

was first and foremost a nurse. Caregiving

2:39

was a role she felt called to from a young

2:41

age. I wanted to care

2:43

for other people. I had a grandma

2:46

she raised me from a child, and

2:48

she became sick one day

2:51

and I had to rush her to the

2:53

nearest hospital in rural Georgia,

2:56

where Dawn grew up. The nearest hospital

2:58

is at least a thirty five I've been at to drive away

3:01

her mouth began to shift to the left side

3:03

of her face. Now that we know that

3:05

there's the cva are stroke, but at the time I

3:07

couldn't explain to her what it was, and she only had a

3:09

third grade education. Not being

3:11

able to explain to her and have the answers

3:13

for her that I needed, I immediately

3:16

knew that I wanted to

3:18

become a nurse. The time she was in

3:20

the hospital, I asked questions with the physicians

3:22

and doctors, and then I progress into

3:25

nursing, which I loved

3:27

dearly. Dawn's first job

3:29

at a nursing school is at a corrections

3:31

facility. The next an immigration

3:34

detention center in Osilla County,

3:36

Georgia. The detention center is

3:38

a private prison overseen by ICE,

3:41

the Immigration and Customs Enforcement division

3:43

that falls under the Department of Homeland Security.

3:46

Working within the ICE system across

3:48

different centers, Dawn quickly learns

3:51

that the jails which house these detainees

3:53

view them as part of the business. The

3:56

facilities get paid for every inmate,

3:58

so the more people in jail, the more government

4:00

funding a facility can receive, but

4:03

Dawn doesn't see the immigrants that she works with

4:05

as numbers on a bottom line. They're

4:08

her patients. The more I worked

4:10

in detention, and the more I begin

4:12

to hear the stories of others from a

4:15

incarcerated side, it

4:17

made it just that much more interesting,

4:20

And I was like pulled or

4:23

I gravitated to wanting

4:25

to know why you're here and

4:28

what transpired in what's

4:30

going on. It brought about that

4:33

in a nurturer that I was

4:35

born with, So I became

4:38

kind of like what you would call a den

4:40

mother inside of this den it and

4:42

the stories Dawn hears from her patients give

4:44

her a clear sense of how hard this is for them

4:47

and how unjust their treatment within the immigration

4:50

system can often be. You

4:52

would think that the way that they were treated on the

4:54

inside of this facility that I

4:56

worked at, that they were mass murderers.

4:59

A lot of these women were separated from their

5:01

children. A lot of these guys

5:04

that came in had minor traffic

5:06

citations. They would oftentime be

5:08

told they didn't belong here and making

5:10

them feel like that they

5:13

had committed the worst crime ever by

5:15

coming to the United States having grown

5:17

up as a black woman in Georgia, Dahn

5:19

says that she sees something she's all

5:22

too familiar with. I live here in the Deep

5:24

South. They still believe in racism

5:26

here. So inside of the ICE facilities

5:29

where now gravitated decades

5:31

from slavery, changing to where

5:33

nice migrants, immigrants now

5:36

they have reversed roles from the

5:38

African American community. Now

5:40

we're gonna persecute immigration, immigrant

5:42

workers. And when Trump takes

5:44

office, Don realizes that the

5:46

President's sensational rhetoric about

5:49

immigration finds a welcome audience

5:51

among the many staffers working

5:53

for these ICE prisons. I feel

5:56

as though Trump stirred up a lot of

5:58

the systemic racism. He awokea

6:00

era that we were beginning

6:03

to not really die down,

6:05

but it was more hidden and it

6:08

was more suffocated. These

6:10

are people, these

6:12

are animals, and we're taking him out

6:14

of the country at a level and at a rate that's

6:16

never happened before. That's

6:19

President Trump speaking at a White House

6:21

briefing on sanctuary cities. And

6:24

this is one of his gentler comments about

6:27

America's undocumented immigrants. During

6:29

the campaign, he'd said, quote,

6:32

they're bringing drugs, they're bringing

6:34

crime, their rapists, some

6:37

I assume are good people. It

6:39

was like he took the plastic bag

6:42

off of the head of racism

6:44

and allowed it to breathe again

6:47

inside of these detention centers.

6:51

Despite the political climate outside,

6:53

Dawn continues to build strong relationships

6:56

with the detainees inside the prison

6:58

walls, asking questions and

7:00

showing compassion. It built

7:02

up a relationship with the

7:05

detention immigrants that were in the

7:07

detention center to trust that I

7:09

was going to make sure that everything for them was

7:11

okay. It's

7:15

March twenty twenty. You remember,

7:18

COVID is starting to shut down the country. Nobody

7:20

knows what to do, how to stay safe,

7:23

or how bad it's going to get. And

7:25

like a lot of people we started to call essential

7:28

workers, Dawn doesn't have the option

7:30

to go into lockdown or stay home. She

7:32

has patience to see. And Dawn's

7:34

patients are already facing the devastating

7:37

reality of deportation. Now

7:40

everyone is also facing this scary,

7:43

unknown thing, the pandemic.

7:46

I'm sick. I've got a call I can't

7:48

get rid of. I've been coughing for a while, I've got a

7:50

fever, I've got a headache. Did

7:52

not know this was COVID at the time,

7:55

but I work sick not thinking

7:57

about it twice. There's still a lot of confusion

8:00

about safety protocols, but by early

8:02

April, the CDC has at least advised

8:05

that masks can slow the spread of COVID,

8:07

and yet the President doesn't

8:10

exactly lead. By example, the

8:12

CDC is advising the use of non

8:15

medical cloth face covering, but

8:18

this is voluntary. I

8:20

don't think I'm going to be doing it. I'm feeling

8:23

good. I don't know. Somehow I

8:25

don't see it for myself. Something

8:33

else that President Trump doesn't see for

8:35

himself is a wicked case of COVID

8:38

that he gets about six months later, and

8:40

it nearly kills him. So, yes,

8:42

there are mixed messages coming out of Washington,

8:45

but there's enough information out there for Dawn to

8:47

see that the protocols within the ice

8:49

center fall well short of what's

8:51

needed to keep both her staff and her

8:53

patients safe. More

8:56

of my employees is seek we're not wearing

8:59

masks because we were told that we

9:01

didn't need to wear a mask at this time. The detainees

9:03

inside the facility is not wearing masks. The

9:05

transport guys and officers are going out

9:07

picking up the detainees and bringing in more

9:10

immigrants into the facility that are sick.

9:12

So we were sending people to the hospital. COVID

9:16

Transport guy became sick, tested

9:18

positive for COVID. COVID

9:21

transport guy dies with

9:24

COVID. And even

9:26

if everyone agreed on the safety

9:28

protocols, there just aren't enough masks

9:30

to go around the detainees. They

9:33

start tearing up jumpsuits, towels,

9:35

making masks, socks, making

9:37

masks to cover their face. At

9:39

this point, I go inside of

9:41

the facility and if I'm not mistaken,

9:43

there are forty five positive cases inside

9:46

of this facility at this time. About

9:48

three weeks into the pandemic. In mid April,

9:51

some of the women being detained at the Irwin Center

9:54

make a YouTube video pleading

9:56

to be released because conditions are

9:58

so dangerous. Power.

10:14

She is saying, quote, we need

10:16

protection. Please. All we ask

10:18

is that people listen to their conscience and

10:20

their hearts. There are so many mothers

10:23

here who are suffering the humiliations.

10:25

My god, why can't Ice understand?

10:28

Unquote? The guards

10:30

are pissed. After the video is

10:33

posted, they put the women on lockdown,

10:35

some end up in solitary confinement. Then

10:39

Don hears that one of the other nurses

10:41

has COVID. She's sick. I remember

10:44

we celebrated her birthday in May.

10:46

She's sick. Long story sharp, she

10:49

dies COVID positives.

10:51

The next thing that we hear is

10:53

that the person that takes her place is saying

10:55

she got it from a family gathering. But

10:58

this story that the nurse had contracted

11:01

at a family gathering, not at work. Dawn

11:04

knows that's not true, and for her,

11:06

this sparks the first flicker of suspicion.

11:09

Why is management trying to downplay the

11:11

thread of this virus spreading at the

11:13

center. Then she sees

11:15

something that really shocks her.

11:19

COVID begin to spread like wildfire.

11:21

The nurses that works with me is

11:23

shredding the sick. Calls the medical

11:26

documentation facts from the hospital.

11:28

I have no better than the white child,

11:31

sins to say, hey, what the hell is going on

11:33

in here? The Irwin

11:35

County Detention Center disputes

11:38

Don's allegations. Don

11:40

immediately starts raising concerns about

11:42

what she's witnessed internally with colleagues

11:45

and with her supervisors, and she's

11:47

told don't touch that, leave

11:49

that alone. And the reason why

11:51

it was to be covered up because we

11:54

would have to be isolated

11:56

at this time. If

11:58

COVID was in your facility, you live

12:01

there, you slept there, you ate

12:03

there, You were in that community

12:05

until it was marginalized

12:08

or control. Nobody wanted to be quarantine.

12:10

None of the administration up front

12:13

was agreeing to do that. Oh

12:16

hecknah, I'm going home. Our facility

12:18

would have had to have been locked down

12:21

and could not receive any more

12:23

immigrants because we were a contaminated

12:26

whole place now, which would stop

12:29

the revenue from entering the place.

12:32

So basically, if there's no documentation

12:35

of the COVID cases, Ice can

12:37

keep bussing more immigrants into the facility.

12:40

This is just good for business. They

12:42

need to keep the detainees flowing in

12:44

order to keep the money flowing. It's

12:47

a cruel and cynical calculation, and

12:50

Dawn starts to learn there are other

12:52

calculations that the ICE prison

12:54

is making, calculations

12:56

that put profit over people's lives.

12:59

The sloppy COVID protocols, the retaliation,

13:02

the mistreatment, all of this is

13:05

just the tip of the iceberg. Compared

13:07

to what Dawn learns next. As

13:24

Dawn is being told by her bosses to stop

13:26

asking so many questions about masks

13:28

and quarantines, she's approached

13:30

by some of the center's female detainees.

13:34

They tell her there's this doctor for the facility

13:36

under contract with ICE. They say

13:38

this doctor has been giving women

13:41

gyneological procedures for reasons

13:43

they don't understand and that they didn't

13:46

consent to. His name

13:48

is doctor Mahendra Amine. The

13:51

women ask Dawn to look in their medical

13:53

files so she can explain what

13:55

procedures were performed on them,

13:57

and Dawn is shocked to see complex

14:00

surgeries like hysterectomies in

14:03

their records. I go to demit cart one

14:05

day and I take back, you had a hysterectomy,

14:07

you had tubes remove, you had ovaries

14:10

remove. Doctor Tammy Rowan,

14:13

the leading obstetrician and gynecologist

14:15

at uc San Francisco, offers

14:17

context and what these types of surgeries

14:20

entailed. A hysterectomy specifically,

14:22

is just the uterus. If you remove the uterus,

14:24

you have taken away someone's ability to carry

14:27

a pregnance. If you take out their

14:29

tubes, that takes away their ability

14:32

to have a spontaneous pregnancy,

14:34

but if they wanted to be pregnant

14:36

in the future, they actually could do something like

14:38

an invitro fertilization and then

14:41

implant that pregnancy into their uterus.

14:43

If you remove someone's ovaries, you're

14:45

taking away their ability in

14:48

any capacity to ever have a biological

14:50

child ever. In other words,

14:53

these are invasive, big decision

14:55

procedures, life changing operations

14:58

like sterilization. And these

15:00

women are telling Dawn not only did

15:02

they not give their consent, but in many cases

15:05

they didn't even know the procedure was

15:07

being performed in the first place, or

15:09

if they had agreed to the procedure, it

15:12

was because the doctor told them it

15:14

was for something else. A

15:16

lot of these women were telling me that they

15:19

had really huge cists

15:21

and they had to have them taken out for

15:24

a risk of cancer. I got a

15:26

lot of them telling me that they

15:28

were told that it could be cancer.

15:30

They needed this surgery for cancer.

15:33

I had one girl was twenty three and she was scared

15:35

to death. She had a total history. Me had twenty

15:37

three and she came into the cit

15:39

call office. I'll never forget I was a sit call

15:41

nurse, had my own office and I pulled the door

15:44

and she was crying profusely and

15:46

she was like, my husband's gonna leave me. I

15:48

was like why. She was like, cause I can't have any more children.

15:53

Sure enough, I opened a chart. She

15:55

has a full history to me, and I'm

15:57

like, well, you don't remember, she said,

15:59

I didn't sign nothing for it.

16:02

It's hard to overstate what's happening here.

16:05

A woman goes to the doctor and

16:07

is told she has a cancerous

16:09

cist. She agrees to a procedure

16:11

to remove it, but instead, Dawn

16:14

says, she receives a hysterectomy,

16:17

and now we'll never be able to bear

16:19

children. Across the

16:21

board, doctor Amane is relying

16:23

on procedures that are more aggressive

16:25

than the usual go to treatments. At

16:28

least forty of the cases for which he performed

16:30

invasive surgery could have been handled

16:33

with simple hormonal therapy.

16:35

Doctor Rowan explains how doctor

16:37

Amine performs surgeries that were

16:40

often just unnecessary

16:42

in general for cists. You can just remove

16:44

a cyst unless you think it's cancer. You can

16:46

just remove a cyst without removing the ovaries.

16:49

So that's just an extra layer of

16:51

inappropriate medical care

16:54

that this person was providing, and that's the baby

16:56

tip of iceberg for something like

16:59

that. This still doesn't

17:01

hit you until others start

17:03

poking at the same bear and

17:06

they're asking the same questions and

17:08

they're all having the same issues.

17:11

They're comparing their diagnosis

17:13

together. She's got a large

17:15

fibroids sets. She's got a large fibroids

17:18

sets. She's being put on birth control

17:20

pills for the fibroids sets. The next

17:22

time she goes, she's being told that she has to

17:24

have surgery. The next time she goes, she's

17:26

actually having the surgery. Donna

17:32

is a medical professional, and she knows

17:34

what she's seen is not normal. Doctor

17:37

Rowan, Again, as somebody

17:39

who operates in an insurance

17:42

based system, I have to

17:44

document very clearly why

17:48

and how I'm planning to do a surgery,

17:50

and so I frequently will be

17:52

told by insurance that Nope, this, especially

17:55

for a hysterectomy, this is not indicated.

17:58

You haven't done enough other things.

18:00

I'm very thoughtful and thorough.

18:03

So one of the most striking things about

18:05

this is is there any oversight

18:07

in this person's ability to perform surgery?

18:10

There's clearly no oversight.

18:13

If what Dawn is saying is true. Now,

18:17

to be clear, hysterectomies are common,

18:19

many women get them, but given

18:21

what's at stake, consent is crucial,

18:24

especially given the risks Doctor

18:27

Rowan, again, obviously,

18:30

anything that's done to your body,

18:32

you should be aware of what we call it. We

18:34

have three components to it. So what are

18:36

the risks, what are the benefits, and what

18:38

are the alternatives? And so

18:40

those are the three components. And it's crucial

18:43

before anybody can make a decision

18:45

about anything that's done to them, that they understand

18:48

those three criteria. The

18:51

women who came to Dawn didn't understand

18:54

any of those criteria.

18:56

Now let's talk big picture for a

18:58

second. There's an uncomfortable

19:01

truth about these procedures. Given

19:03

the circumstances for the doctor

19:05

performing it, there's a clear financial

19:07

incentive they can Bill Moore,

19:10

and without oversight, no one

19:12

can say it was unnecessary. This

19:14

is bad. But what's worse is

19:17

that Ice could have seen this coming, could

19:19

have or should have prevented it. And

19:22

that's because doctor Amine had

19:24

a history. In twenty thirteen,

19:27

the Department of Justice and the State of

19:29

Georgia filed a lawsuit against

19:31

him at Erwin County Hospital over

19:34

allegations of medicaid fraud and

19:37

performing unnecessary gyneological

19:39

procedures. But seven years

19:41

later, ICE has him under contract

19:43

again to work with the women at the

19:45

center. I talked to Dana

19:48

Gould, Dawn's lawyer and an attorney

19:50

with the Government Accountability Project who

19:52

specializes in immigration. She

19:55

says, the US immigration system

19:57

is riddled with these types of cases. It's

20:00

just known that these facilities that

20:02

there's week oversight, repeat

20:05

offenses, and no contract

20:07

consequences between the perverse

20:09

incentives for money, the

20:11

perverse incentives for not reporting

20:14

compliance, and how there's basically

20:16

a pass to not be in compliance

20:18

because it's expensive. It's expensive to

20:21

keep being safe. All these things cost

20:23

time and money, so cost

20:26

savings comes at the expense of

20:29

the immigrants and attention. The oversight

20:31

Dana is talking about is whether ICE is making

20:33

sure everything is operating appropriately

20:36

in these privately run prisons. The

20:38

agency is outsourcing to contractors

20:41

to run detention operations, but

20:43

it still has an obligation to make sure they

20:45

are up to standards, including, for

20:47

instance, making sure doctors aren't

20:50

going rogue. We're delegating,

20:52

like a really important government function

20:54

to private contractors without

20:56

adequate vetting and without adequate oversight.

20:59

There have been problems with oversight at detention

21:01

centers for a long time, over several

21:04

administrations, from President Bush

21:06

to Obama and finally to Trump,

21:09

but nothing quite like this. I

21:11

worked at the Department of Homeland Security during

21:13

the Trump administration. I had left

21:16

by the time this case happened in Georgia,

21:18

but I remember Congress starting to raise

21:20

questions about the conditions at facilities

21:22

like this early on, and

21:25

the growing frustration that the problems

21:27

weren't getting fixed fast enough. Too

21:30

often abuses got swept under the rug

21:32

in the Trump years, in part because

21:34

the president's immigration crackdown caused

21:37

these centers to become hugely overcrowded.

21:40

DHS officials warned about it, but

21:43

the White House went forward anyway.

21:47

Back at the Irwin Center in that spring

21:49

of twenty twenty, Dawn is seen exactly

21:52

this play out. Lack of vetting,

21:55

check just look at doctor Aman's

21:57

background, lack of oversight.

22:00

Check what

22:03

they do in the facility that

22:05

I worked in. They fill out

22:07

a request, they send it up to ICE

22:10

saying that this needs to be done, and Ice

22:12

is the one that approves it. In

22:14

this case, it was female reproductive

22:17

procedures that they sent them up. If

22:19

I could catch it at the lower level that I

22:22

was at not looking for it,

22:24

then I'm gonna say there was poor oversight

22:27

on ICE's behalf

22:30

of whoever was handling these, because

22:33

it should have set up a red flag

22:35

that every week I'm getting

22:38

so many requests to be sent out

22:41

for female surgical

22:44

implementations. In

22:46

other words, it was piss

22:48

poor managed. Once Dune

22:50

starts putting the pieces of this awful puzzle

22:52

together, she again wastes no

22:55

time in raising her concerns.

22:57

She marches over to the head of the nursing office

23:00

looking for answers. I

23:03

asked a coworker that I sat

23:05

side by side with, and I was like, I just

23:07

came from down line, And one

23:09

of the detained women was like, what

23:11

is he the uterus collector? I was like, what is going

23:14

on? She puts her hand on top of my hand

23:16

and say, wooting, you want to leave that alone.

23:19

My supervisor at the time rolls

23:22

out of the office cause we're in one space

23:24

together. So she rolls out of a little room, leans

23:27

back in her chair non chalantley says,

23:29

girl, he getting that money

23:32

laughs and rolls back to her desk.

23:36

Why is no one else alarmed by

23:38

reports about a doctor whose nickname

23:41

is literally the uterus

23:43

collector? Safe to say?

23:45

When she hears that Wooten

23:47

does not leave this alone. From

24:01

April twenty twenty through that summer, Dawn

24:03

continues to try and push her supervisor's

24:06

for answers. I get up every morning

24:08

five o'clock shilling to work, to

24:11

do what I'm supposed to do, and I'm a mandated reporter.

24:14

I'm a nurse. I'm mandated to report those things

24:16

that are not I didn't sign on just for

24:18

a paycheck. I signed on to care about people,

24:20

and this is the area that I

24:23

chose to care about people in. I'm

24:26

asking. I'm told leave this alone,

24:28

leave that alone. Her bosses

24:31

start trying to find ways to say Dawn is

24:33

not a good employee, pointing to a single

24:35

day she didn't show up for work as an

24:37

example of her unreliability. But

24:40

it was an approved sick day.

24:42

Dawn, diligent as she is, of

24:44

course, had documented why she had to take

24:46

the day, providing a dated doctor's

24:49

note showing that she'd been sick. But

24:51

they're trying to find any reason to demote

24:53

her and to shut

24:55

her up and being inquisitive.

24:58

I find myself no from

25:01

a write up to where I was a no call, no show.

25:04

I had a doctor's excuse they didn't even put

25:06

in the file. So I'm like, okay, so

25:08

I gotta be on to something because now

25:10

they're trying to constructively get

25:12

rid of me by write up.

25:15

This goes on for months. The

25:17

facility starts freezing her out,

25:19

even though Dawn sees that they are urgently

25:22

trying to fill nursing jobs at the prison,

25:25

until one day she's asked to

25:27

go from a full time nursing position at the

25:29

center to an on call role.

25:33

It's a clear message. When I talked

25:35

to the warden, it was like it was almost

25:37

scripted and rehearsed. He spends

25:39

his chair around after I ask him what is going

25:41

on here? I've never been written up, I've

25:44

never been a problem. You are always glad

25:46

to see me coming. You know, I'll do my job and

25:48

sear. He told me you would call me when he needed

25:50

me, or, as Dana Gould explains it,

25:52

moved from a full time position nursing position

25:55

to an on call position and then never

25:57

called again. I was told in other words,

26:00

you take your woman questioning

26:02

black self and get it on up out

26:04

of my facility because you're trouble. So that's

26:07

what it was. They dismissed me. When

26:09

I left, traveling home. I

26:11

remember talking to God and I was like, okay,

26:14

what do I have to do? And I'm crying. I'm like, I

26:16

don't have a job, Like what is going on? It

26:19

was mortified because

26:21

I'm a single parent. This is how I feed

26:23

my kids. Dawn's

26:26

not technically fired, she's

26:29

benched, put in professional

26:31

purgatory, and there's no clear direction

26:34

about what she should do next. So

26:36

she's scared, but she knows one

26:38

thing. She has to expose

26:41

what's going on at the detention center.

26:43

Thoughts, racing, hearts, racing, emotions

26:45

are all over the place. Now, I'm worried

26:48

about the treatment of these people inside the facility.

26:50

So she starts looking for someone to help her, and

26:53

she meets Dana. I remember the first time

26:55

hearing her talk, and I was

26:57

just like, she's a force of nature. She's

27:00

just a force of nature. Despite

27:04

the fears she feels about coming forward

27:06

publicly, Dawn decides to file

27:08

an official whistleblower complaint through

27:11

an organization called Projects South. Meanwhile,

27:14

Dana and her team, whose law firm

27:16

helps protect whistleblowers, work

27:18

on Dawn's retaliation complaint related

27:21

to her unlawful dismissal. Dawn

27:24

decides to put her name on those complaints,

27:27

a brave move. I was told

27:29

that my disclosures might not be as effective

27:31

if I was anonymous as it would

27:34

be public. Sometimes you don't need

27:36

to think things through. Sometimes you need

27:38

to be put in that position to where

27:40

your heart pressed, deliver it and

27:42

then we'll deal with the repercussions

27:45

behind it. And she also doesn't

27:47

shy away from appearing publicly, first,

27:50

speaking at an immigration rights rally

27:52

in Atlanta. I remember that

27:54

my two kids at the time was seventeen

27:57

and fifteen. They would not let me go by myself because

27:59

they afraid that something's gonna happen. I

28:01

was pissed, this is not right.

28:04

Why did this keep happening? So

28:06

it wasn't hard to go and have this conversation

28:08

because their adrenaline is still pumping. There

28:11

needs to be attention brought to

28:13

ic DC. The management

28:16

needs to be changed. As

28:19

a nurse, I took an oath said

28:21

my life when I stepped in no longer

28:23

was my life. It became the lives of others.

28:27

And at the rally, she talks to the media

28:29

anything to draw attention to this issue,

28:32

and as you've heard, Donna's pretty

28:34

outspoken, so she doesn't hold back. People

28:37

have warned her that this is risky for her

28:40

personally, but she still doesn't back

28:42

down. That's when

28:44

the hate really starts. I

28:47

remember coming back from Atlanta after doing

28:49

this and I was like, what did I just do?

28:53

I got intel. I don't know how true it was that

28:55

somebody said they were gonna lynch me. I live

28:57

in the South, so I'm getting

28:59

all of this. It's crazy mahammock

29:02

stuff coming to me. Dawn realizes

29:04

that many of the threats are coming

29:06

from her old co workers at the Irwin

29:09

Center. The threats I got

29:11

here were like the people that worked

29:13

to the facility, they were gonna jump on me, oh

29:15

when they saw me downtown, you know, and going down

29:17

to the grocery store here. You

29:19

know, I have people I bet you wish you had to keep your mouth

29:21

clothes. You talk

29:24

too damn much. And I canna

29:26

understand them being angry about their job

29:28

because that was their livelihood.

29:30

But at this point, I'm like, you need to be angry with the person

29:32

that was committing the crime, not me. The

29:36

truth is a lot of these ice facilities

29:38

are the big employer in the area.

29:41

They're a big part of the local economy. People

29:44

rely on them. Here's Dana

29:46

Gould. It's like a high paying job

29:49

for workers in the community. It's a

29:51

concentration of jobs and poor locations

29:54

typically where these facilities are, so

29:56

there's an incentive to stay

29:58

quiet in the face of problems

30:00

that you might see because the job is

30:03

valuable to workers. The death

30:05

threats keep coming, but Dawn

30:07

continues to tell her story on

30:09

new shows and to reporters

30:11

until her advocacy team becomes

30:14

genuinely worried for her

30:16

and her family in Atlanta.

30:18

They help relocate them to safety in

30:21

several undisclosed locations.

30:23

Then they supply a bodyguard. Her

30:27

family is in and out of random hotels

30:29

until they decide it's finally

30:31

safe to go home. We were in the hotel

30:34

for a couple of months trying to find

30:36

for ourselves, and I had a child that has a developmental

30:38

disability, and then my daughter

30:41

is at the same time, she's a

30:43

teenager in her first relationship,

30:45

and she snatched away from society itself.

30:48

We all slept in one bed at one time because

30:50

it was so depressing. It was Helen Wheels,

30:52

I hated it. While Dawn is fearing

30:55

for her life on the receiving end of

30:57

a very angry community, her makes

31:00

its way to the Office of the Inspector

31:02

General at DHS and

31:04

then onto Congress, where

31:07

it explodes, our

31:09

findings are deeply disturbing.

31:14

It's November twenty twenty two. Senator

31:17

John Assoff of Georgia is opening

31:19

a hearing of the Senate's Committee on Homeland

31:21

Security to review the findings

31:24

of an eighteen month investigation into

31:26

the treatment of women in immigration

31:28

detention. It is the bipartisan

31:31

finding of the subcommittee that

31:33

female detainees in Georgia were

31:36

subjected by a DHS contracted

31:38

doctor to excessive,

31:41

invasive and often unnecessary

31:44

gynecological surgeries and procedures,

31:47

with repeated failures to obtain informed

31:49

medical consent. The complaint

31:52

from Dawn that goes in front of Congress

31:54

detailed everything she had been seen,

31:57

the sloppy COVID protocols that were

31:59

putting lives in danger, the cover

32:01

up of test results, the alarming

32:03

number of invasive gyneological surgeries,

32:06

the lack of consent, and the

32:08

retaliation against the women who spoke

32:11

out. The Senate investigation

32:13

confirms the women at Irwin faced

32:16

egregious medical mistreatment. This

32:18

is an extraordinarily disturbing finding

32:21

and in my view, represents a catastrophic

32:24

failure by the federal government

32:26

to respect basic human rights. Among

32:29

the serious abuses this subcommittee

32:31

has investigated during the last two years,

32:35

subjecting female detainees to

32:37

non consensual and unnecessary

32:39

gynecological surgeries is

32:42

one of the most nightmarish and disgraceful.

32:46

That investigation had involved four hundred

32:48

and fifty thousand pages of records

32:51

and seventy witnesses, which

32:53

brings us back to the woman we met at the

32:55

beginning of this episode. My

32:57

name is Kernasrosprisio. I

33:00

was brought to the United States when I was eight years

33:02

old. I am no twenty three

33:05

year old mother up two. When

33:07

my daughter was four months old, I called

33:09

the police to stop ongoing abuse from

33:11

her father. This led to me being

33:14

arrested, and even though the

33:16

charges were dropped, I still ended up at ICDC

33:20

for almost seven months, away from my daughter,

33:22

away from my family ic

33:25

DC, which is the ice detention

33:27

facility in Georgia. At

33:30

ICDC, I became seven

33:33

two one seven six instead

33:35

of Karna. At

33:38

CDC, I

33:41

went through hell. Karina

33:46

Preciado's experience with doctor Amine

33:49

didn't involve a hysterectomy. For

33:51

her, it was a shot of birth control, which

33:53

he administered without her consent. If

33:56

he had asked her, he would have known she had

33:58

a family history of serious

34:00

health complications from taking birth control.

34:03

Dawn had not named doctor Amine and her

34:06

complaint only referring to him

34:08

as quote the doctor, So

34:10

the Senate hearing is an opportunity for

34:12

the women of ICDC to

34:14

publicly condemn him.

34:17

I had suffered

34:20

from sexual assault before as

34:22

a child. The experience

34:24

with doctor I mean made me feel the same thing I

34:26

felt. It made me feel like I had an no control

34:29

for my body. I had no say, no vote,

34:31

no nothing. As the nurse had told me, I

34:34

was getting a papsmir. I didn't

34:36

ask any questions. I thought I couldn't. Fifty

34:39

seven women who were victims of the unwanted

34:42

medical procedures came forward

34:44

after Dawn's complaint became public,

34:47

and a number of those women came together to

34:49

file a class action lawsuit over

34:51

the medical mistreatment that they endured. That

34:54

lawsuit is still pending. According

34:58

to Dawn, after her port came

35:00

out, many of the women who came forward

35:02

faced retaliation. Some

35:05

were immediately deported, but in

35:07

one case, a woman who was on board

35:09

a plane about to be deported was

35:12

abruptly pulled off and returned

35:14

to the center. Let's

35:16

say that this woman paid a price for

35:18

returning back to the facility because

35:21

they talked about how she was treated, you know, water

35:24

off, no food, no commissary,

35:26

no visitation. They were like

35:30

hustling her not to speak. But

35:36

the brave actions of Dawn and

35:38

the women at the center are not in vain.

35:41

The complaint leads to bipartisan condemnation,

35:44

one of the only times during and after

35:47

the Trump administration that Democrats

35:49

and Republicans have been united

35:51

in an opinion that this

35:54

was wrong and there are real

35:56

consequences for the facility. Dana

35:59

Gould that

36:01

facility. The ice contract was ordered

36:04

to be ended. There are no immigrants

36:06

at the Rowancounted Attention Center anymore.

36:09

Within a year. They also stop

36:11

affiliating with the doctor. He can't

36:13

he wasn't practicing there. These women were

36:15

able to file this lawsuit

36:18

concerning the things that they were done, so they were able to

36:20

do this jointly and that was wonderful.

36:27

But at the end of the day, don still

36:29

misses the women she cared for. I

36:31

missed my birds. To them, I was

36:34

the eagle and they were my eaglets. You could come into

36:36

my sit call office and

36:38

I would always have inspirational music.

36:40

Because I was raised in the church,

36:42

I would always have that encouragement. If you wanted

36:45

prayer, we would pray. I would

36:47

love to know where they are and how

36:49

they're doing, and what

36:51

is transpiring with them, and how

36:54

were they emotionally even

36:56

through the process. It's emotional for

36:58

me, so I can only imagine me is

37:00

talking about it. Daunt

37:05

did everything that you'd want a nurse to do.

37:08

She pushed back against medical mistreatment.

37:10

She spoke up at work again and again,

37:13

and when the problems didn't get fixed, she

37:15

filed a formal complaint. Amidst

37:18

the denials and attempts to cover up

37:20

the problem, she decided to testify

37:22

about it on the national stage, even

37:24

if that meant putting her family on the run. The

37:28

first few months after the disclosures were

37:30

especially hard. I

37:33

was depressed. I stayed

37:35

in the bed four months. There

37:37

were days I didn't shower, there

37:39

were days I didn't eat. There were days

37:41

I just didn't function. I

37:44

was suicidal at one point, but I

37:46

quickly turned it off. My nine

37:48

year old told me, he was like, Mom, you gotta get up, get

37:50

rock and roll and get shaken. You'd

37:53

think all of this would make her a hero. Instead,

37:56

back in Georgia, at least, Dawn still

37:59

finds herself the target of community

38:01

harassment, blacklisted,

38:03

and until very recently, struggling

38:06

to find a job despite her nursing

38:08

qualifications. Going to a job

38:10

interview and they're like, that's sho, that's sho, that

38:12

ship that sho, And I'm like, who are you talking about? You

38:15

know, I would deny who I was.

38:18

Was not ashamed of who I was. But I

38:20

had kids and they were like, when you're

38:22

that lady. I was like, no, I'm not her. You have me mixed

38:24

up. I actually muzzle

38:27

my identity, not for a

38:29

fear of safety, but for

38:31

a fear of being unemployed. So

38:33

my life is like a fruit basket turnover.

38:37

I worked myself off of welfare. I

38:39

felt pretty good about. Hey, I have five

38:41

kids. I've been on welfare all my life,

38:44

food stamps and Medicaid, so I had worked

38:46

myself off of that. I became depressed because

38:48

I'm back on food stamps and medicaid. It's

38:51

where I am now depending on the government to

38:53

take care of a nurse who has

38:56

a degree but can't get a job, not

38:58

because she can't perform the dude, but

39:00

because you're afraid that I'm gonna find

39:03

some discrepancies inside of your facility

39:05

and I'm gonna blow the whistle. After

39:08

we recorded this interview, Dawn

39:10

was finally offered a job and tell

39:12

a medicine but she's not doing

39:14

nursing a profession. She

39:17

still sorely misses. I

39:19

put on my uniform

39:21

and I walk around the house and I wear

39:23

it, you know, and I cry.

39:26

It's a daily process. Given

39:29

all that it's cost her, you might

39:31

think Dawn regrets ever speaking out,

39:34

but she doesn't. I just believe

39:36

that the universe is gonna take care of you

39:39

for sparing the lives

39:41

of other people and speaking out

39:43

about the treatment so we can stop a lot

39:45

of these generational curses

39:48

and a lot of these generational

39:50

foundations that have been set,

39:53

there's names in words, the power glaring

40:04

injustices do remain throughout

40:07

the immigration detention system.

40:09

Here's Dana Gould. We actually

40:12

know that there have been immigrants

40:14

who have died in facilities.

40:16

We know that there's been abuse of

40:19

like people have been put in solitary confinement

40:21

civil detainees, which is defined

40:23

as torture, putting mentally

40:25

ill and medically vulnerable detainees in solitary

40:28

confinement for months. Sometimes.

40:30

There are so many examples of horrors

40:33

and failures, like gross

40:35

medical failures to basically protect

40:38

immigrants and detention, and

40:40

the failures in many ways transcend

40:43

political parties. This administration

40:46

still struggling with the issue of enormous

40:48

numbers of migrants at the border. It's

40:51

still a problem when things aren't

40:53

regulated, there isn't enough oversight. There

40:55

are pieces of legislation

40:57

moving, but you know when you talk about pieces of legislation

40:59

moving that you're in congress

41:01

land in the most politicized issue

41:04

you can think of. Right, So,

41:08

with no political solutions, who

41:11

bears the burden of preventing

41:13

these kinds of abuses going forward.

41:16

That's why we need whistleblowers. That's actually why

41:18

we need whistleblowers because at least they're kind

41:20

of preventing the

41:23

apocalypse, right, or preventing disaster

41:25

essentially by at least saying, hey, not okay.

41:28

The system is geared

41:30

to not inherently protect those interests,

41:32

but whistleblowers kind of tell that story.

41:35

They help us see that story.

41:37

The responsibility drops in everybody's

41:40

lap. It drops from

41:42

governmental down to the privately

41:44

owned sector, comes down to immigration,

41:47

customs and enforcement. It drops

41:50

down to the local facility that I worked

41:52

at, the management that was in there. It

41:54

files in the lap of the physician, It

41:56

files in the lap of my supervisor. And

42:00

at the bottom of that tree, I lie

42:02

as the roots at the bottom of that tree, screaming

42:04

to these leaves that are steady filing

42:06

off that there needs to be held

42:19

next time. On the Whistleblowers, mass

42:23

firings, dossiers of

42:25

opposition research, spies,

42:28

sex in the office, and threats

42:30

of murder suicide not

42:33

what you associate with a government run news

42:35

service. But all of this

42:37

becomes a disturbing reality when

42:39

the White House sends their guide to shake

42:41

up a little known federal agency.

42:58

The Whistleblowers is a production of Higheart

43:00

Podcasts in partnership with Best Case Studios

43:02

and ARC Media. It was hosted by me Miles

43:05

Taylor and written by me Isabel Evans

43:07

and Adam Pinkiss. Isabel Evans is

43:09

also our producer. Associate producers

43:11

are Hannah leebewooz Lockhard and Ashley Warren.

43:14

Darcy Peekel is consulting producer. Zach

43:17

Herman is the VP of Development of ARC Media.

43:19

This episode was edited by Daniel Turik

43:22

with assistance from Max Michael Miller. Original

43:24

music is by James Newberry. Executive

43:26

producers are Me Miles Taylor, Adam Pinkis

43:29

for Best Case Studios, and Barrett Goodman for

43:31

ARC Media. Beth Ann Macalouso

43:33

is our executive producer for iHeartMedia, along

43:36

with Ali Perry. Special thanks to Kevin

43:38

Phamm, all of our contributors and interviewees,

43:40

and our intern an A. Levitt, and a

43:42

big thanks to the teams at Government Accountability

43:45

Project and Whistleblower Aid, two

43:47

of the best organizations for government and private

43:49

sector whistle blowers seeking legal support.

43:52

Follow and rate the Whistleblowers on the podcast

43:55

site of your choice to hear what these

43:57

whistleblowers and others have to say

43:59

about what they eve will happen under

44:01

a second Trump administration or in the White

44:03

House of AMaGA successor. You can pick up

44:05

my new book, Blowback, from Simon and

44:07

Schuster

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features