The UK Election: 9. How Does the Election Differ Across the UK?

The UK Election: 9. How Does the Election Differ Across the UK?

Released Monday, 17th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
The UK Election: 9. How Does the Election Differ Across the UK?

The UK Election: 9. How Does the Election Differ Across the UK?

The UK Election: 9. How Does the Election Differ Across the UK?

The UK Election: 9. How Does the Election Differ Across the UK?

Monday, 17th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

This is the BBC. Ryan

0:12

Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. With the price

0:14

of just about everything going up during inflation,

0:16

we thought we'd bring our prices down. So

0:19

to help us, we brought in a reverse auctioneer, which is

0:21

apparently a thing. Mint Mobile Unlimited Premium Wireless. I bet you get

0:24

30, 30, I bet you get 30, I bet you get 20,

0:26

20, 20, I bet you get 20, 20,

0:29

I bet you get 15, 15, 15, 15,

0:31

just 15 bucks a month. Sold! Give

0:33

it a try at mintmobile.com/switch. $45

0:36

up front for 3 months plus taxes and fees. Promote for

0:38

new customers for a limited time. Unlimited more than 40GB per

0:40

month. Slows. mintmobile.com. BBC

1:00

Sounds, music, radio, podcasts. Hello

1:22

and welcome to Understand the UK

1:24

Election, your essential guide to the

1:27

general election. I'm Adam

1:29

Fleming. My day job is presenting NewsCast,

1:31

which is the BBC's daily news podcast.

1:34

And I've been covering general elections since 2005,

1:38

meaning this is my sixth

1:40

general election. Today's

1:43

episode is going to be about how

1:45

the campaign plays out in the constituent

1:47

nations of the UK, other than England.

1:50

First of all, let's speak to the BBC's Scotland editor,

1:52

James Cook. Hi, James. Hi, Adam. I

1:55

noticed both Keir Starmer and

1:57

Michie Sounak went straight to

1:59

Scotland. in the first couple

2:01

of days. What do you think

2:03

was going on? Yes, it was

2:06

very striking, wasn't it? I think

2:08

that suggests that Scotland is particularly

2:10

important to particularly secure Starmer in

2:12

his attempt to get into

2:15

Downing Street. For years and years

2:17

and years, Labour returned

2:20

dozens and dozens of MPs in

2:22

Scotland. Labour leaders could turn to

2:24

Scotland to help get them into

2:26

Downing Street, and Labour really

2:29

have been the powerhouse of Scottish politics

2:31

for a long time, until 2015, when

2:34

the SNP turned

2:37

everything upside down, swept the board at

2:39

the general election, and now, we're in

2:41

a position where at the last general

2:43

election in 2019, Labour had

2:46

just one seat, just

2:48

one seat in Scotland. And

2:50

the Scottish National Party, it's probably too

2:52

strongly to put it as an identity

2:54

crisis, but they've been having a bit

2:56

of an identity issue, haven't they? Yes,

2:59

polls suggest the party has really

3:01

slumped and Labour has jumped in

3:03

Scotland since the last election, and

3:06

partly that's because they

3:08

are also an incumbent government. Since 1999,

3:10

Scotland has directly taken care of

3:15

a lot of its own domestic

3:17

political affairs, most notably health, education

3:19

and so on, in the Scottish

3:21

Parliament after devolution came in, and

3:24

the SNP has been in power running the

3:26

Scottish government since 2007. So,

3:29

it's a government that's been there for

3:31

a long time. It's had struggles with

3:33

the NHS, struggles with the education system.

3:35

The last year, there's been a lot

3:38

of debate about social issues such as

3:40

gender, and the parties to a certain extent

3:42

become bogged down in that. On

3:44

top of that, it's been under

3:46

police investigation because of

3:48

allegations relating to the funding and finances

3:50

of the party. And of course, we've

3:53

been through a couple of leaders, and

3:56

the Scottish Greens were recently part of

3:58

the government and that was part of

4:00

the down-and-down movement. the fall of Hamza

4:02

Yousif, but I suppose that's because the

4:04

electoral system for the Scottish Parliament helps

4:06

them and they haven't had that same

4:08

success when it comes to the first

4:10

past the post Westminster voting system. Yes,

4:13

that's right. It's a proportional representation system,

4:15

but that means that it is easier

4:17

for smaller parties to get

4:19

elected, whereas the history of Westminster

4:22

politics, parliamentary politics in Scotland has

4:24

been, the Labour Party has dominated.

4:26

Then in 2014, Scotland voted

4:29

on whether or not to become independent

4:31

and maybe things that were changing already

4:33

with the advent of devolution and the

4:35

nationalist movement was building. Even

4:37

though Scotland rejected that proposition, the remarkable

4:40

thing was in the next election, the

4:42

SNP won 56 of Scotland's

4:44

59 seats, the other three parties, and this gets

4:46

to your point about first past the post now,

4:49

brutal it can be, but one

4:51

each, one seat for Labour, one seat

4:53

for the Conservatives, one seat for the

4:55

Liberal Democrats. It's a

4:57

much more varied place

4:59

than some commentary suggests, isn't

5:01

it? There's definite political zones.

5:04

Yes, I think that's an

5:06

interesting point. The Liberal Democrats

5:08

do well in some particularly

5:10

rural parts of the country,

5:12

but not exclusively. They had

5:14

four MPs at the last

5:16

election. The Conservatives have six

5:18

MPs or had and they're really clustered

5:20

in the north east, where there's a

5:22

big debate about oil and gas, hugely

5:24

important industry for Scotland now in the

5:26

process of a transition towards renewable energy.

5:29

And they've also got three seats

5:31

along the border with England, which

5:33

tells you something I think about

5:35

their adamant opposition to independence. But

5:38

yes, there's fault lines in different

5:40

ways. There's traditional left-right fault lines.

5:42

There's social, conservative and social liberal

5:44

fault lines. And then of course,

5:47

there's this underlying issue of

5:49

the constitution and independence, which might to say,

5:51

I think sent me on the back burner,

5:53

but it's not really gone away. James, thank

5:56

you very much. Thanks, Adam.

5:58

Now let's head to Cardiff and speak to... political correspondent

6:00

for BBC Wales, Catherine Half-Jones.

6:02

Hello, Catherine. Hi, Adam. Now,

6:05

often at Westminster, you hear Wales

6:07

being described as a blueprint for what

6:09

a Labour government would do nationally

6:11

because they are the government in Wales.

6:14

What's your take on just how

6:16

that is used by the parties? Yeah,

6:18

I mean, Labour has been empowering in

6:20

the West Parliament, or Senate as it

6:22

is now, for the whole of devolution,

6:25

25 years. It has consistently played into

6:27

criticism of the Labour Party more generally.

6:29

And that was true even before the

6:31

election was called. We heard Rishi Sunak

6:33

criticising the Welsh NHS for waiting lists

6:35

and missed targets and so on. And

6:38

that's really been built upon by the

6:40

Conservatives in particular during this campaign, especially

6:42

given, of course, that Keir Starmer did

6:44

call Labour in Wales a blueprint for

6:46

what Labour could achieve in power across

6:48

the whole of the UK. And

6:50

he said that from the stage

6:52

of the Welsh Labour Conference in

6:54

North Wales in March 2022. Here

6:58

in Wales, the Welsh Labour government is

7:01

the living proof of what Labour looks

7:03

like in power. How

7:05

things can be done differently and better. Every

7:08

day, you demonstrate the difference that

7:10

Labour makes, a blueprint

7:13

for what Labour can do across the

7:15

United Kingdom. He has

7:17

shied away from it in more recent

7:20

years. He's been asked about it. He

7:22

hasn't repeated it. And that's probably due

7:24

to two things, the policies that have

7:26

become a bit problematic for the Labour

7:29

brand in Wales, but also the Welsh

7:31

Labour government have been in a cooperation

7:33

agreement with Clyde Cymru up until recently.

7:35

And UK Labour are

7:37

a bit more sensitive about any

7:40

sort of cooperating or working alongside

7:42

any nationalist parties at a UK

7:44

level, having been burnt previously by

7:46

accusations that they'd work with the

7:48

SNP. Interesting. Now, let's talk about the

7:51

voters. How would you describe what the main

7:53

issues are in people's minds? Well,

7:55

the NHS has a big issue for

7:57

Welsh voters. It is in every election.

8:00

governments often say that they're constrained

8:02

in how much they can do

8:04

on house because of the money

8:06

that they have from the UK

8:08

government. So around 80% of the 20

8:11

billion pound budget that the Welsh government has

8:13

does come from the UK Treasury and the

8:15

Welsh government's argument on that is if you

8:17

had a UK Labour government they hope more

8:19

money would be coming down the m4 to

8:21

support us. But the other issue of course

8:23

that's coming up when we talk to voters

8:25

here in Wales is the cost of living

8:27

the economy. It's the price of fuel and

8:29

that's no big surprise because Wales is a pretty

8:31

rural country. And

8:33

in terms of the political geography of

8:35

the country why is it that Northeast

8:37

Wales has suddenly become so interesting? Yeah,

8:40

Northeast Wales is really interesting because

8:42

that's where the Conservatives, they took

8:44

six seats directly from Labour in

8:46

Wales in 2019 winning 14 in

8:48

all. They are looking very challenging

8:53

for the Conservatives at this election and not

8:55

just because of the polling that suggests they're

8:57

in a bit of trouble but also there

8:59

have been boundary changes here in Wales which

9:02

means the number of MPs that Wales sends

9:04

back to Westminster after this election will drop

9:06

from 40 to 32 and that's

9:09

really worked against the Conservatives not only

9:11

in Northeast Wales but also in West

9:13

Wales as well. As well of course

9:16

as the challenge from parties like the

9:18

Liberal Democrats and Reform who are challenging

9:20

on each flank of the Conservative Party.

9:23

And Welsh national politics has continued

9:26

unabated and Vaughan Gessing, the relatively

9:28

new First Minister, faced a vote

9:30

of no confidence recently and he

9:33

lost it. Yeah, Vaughan Gessing has

9:35

been in post as First Minister in Welsh

9:37

Labour leader for about three months now and

9:39

it comes off the back of months of

9:41

questions around a £200,000 donation to Vaughan Gessing's

9:45

Campaign to become Labour leader and then duly

9:48

First Minister. Now Vaughan Gessing Despite that vote,

9:50

despite all the questions, seems to want to

9:52

tough it out. He is getting a lot

9:54

of support from senior UK Labour figures on

9:56

that at the moment and no support. Private:

9:59

both there's an election have thinks the last

10:01

thing. They want us to lose a first

10:03

minister in the middle of all of that.

10:05

Capture Thank you very much A know

10:08

we can cross the Londonderry to speak

10:10

to Endemic Lafferty, who's Bbc Northern Ireland's

10:12

political editor hello under. Hi

10:14

Adam I suppose Islay everyone's talking about. Oh,

10:16

who's gonna be the next government of the

10:18

Uk actually Northern Ireland. Been waiting for a

10:20

government in Northern Ireland for a long time

10:22

when he finally got one. That's the thing.

10:25

This really dominate his politics. Their yes Anna

10:27

misses the first time in fact a nine

10:29

years that we're going into a general election

10:31

was a functioning government in place and Northern

10:33

Ireland at Stormont on the previous occasions where

10:35

women to a general election with lots of

10:37

recrimination. a lot of angry parties at the

10:39

fact that we did not have diva loosen

10:41

up and running and that in a sense

10:43

was the main same. Running through those

10:45

previous elections. And. And register

10:48

introduce people to the political parties in Northern

10:50

Ireland. I'd give us a sort of sketch

10:52

of the standings at the moment. Well, we

10:54

have eighteen seats up for grabs, a Northern

10:56

Ireland last a mind and twenty nineteen. The

10:59

As A D P that are just Unionist

11:01

party here secured eight of those seats. As

11:03

and of course to me a nice as

11:05

Republican parties and Northern Ireland six or seven

11:08

of those seats. Sdlp packed. Updates on the

11:10

Alliance picked up the last remaining seat of

11:12

the it taints us are things broke down

11:14

bikes and of course things have changed since.

11:17

Sense. From and censor one of those D

11:19

P seats was occupied by as a D

11:21

P meter at the time Sir Jeffrey Donaldson

11:23

status and step back from our front line

11:26

politics because his face and stoical sex sizes

11:28

was is planning to contest and as a

11:30

result the Dpr coming in to this election

11:32

with seven as he like sitting mps at

11:34

Westminster what's A and to just as a

11:37

whole new dimension a thing for the the

11:39

party's Us Time roads damn we have smaller

11:41

parties here as well like the Traditional Union

11:43

His voice. We also have the other Green

11:45

Party and People Before Profit. Will also

11:47

be contesting seats, but given the nature of the

11:50

voting system here that as far as past the

11:52

post their unlikely it's to feature when it comes

11:54

to the final sector. Code. Of

11:56

people in Northern Ireland feel when the leaders

11:58

of the main Westman. The party's turn up

12:01

on their parties aren't even standing in the

12:03

election. The Northern Ireland will add a something

12:05

that we've become accustomed to northern Ireland the

12:07

fact that we have a Labour and Tory

12:09

government there. but of course people here feel

12:11

so much detached because Labour and the Conservatives

12:13

do not stand candidate sir and Northern Ireland

12:15

was expectation of winning Any said so and

12:17

a sense there's no mandate risk for the

12:19

parties in Northern Ireland. So there was a

12:21

sense sometimes it that we get left behind

12:23

here by the part is it beats at

12:25

Westminster and that the something com to Northern

12:27

Ireland two and a sense tick a box

12:29

at times. And that's why sometimes people here

12:31

can feel a little bit politically helpless and

12:33

will ever be a time where Sinn Fein

12:36

take up their seats at Westminster well as

12:38

a by question of one this continually pose

12:40

to Sensei. And not least of course Journey

12:42

brags at times when we had so many

12:45

nice edge votes at Westminster. People here in

12:47

Northern Ireland who were sandhu remember voted by

12:49

a majority to a man was an the

12:51

A you are putting pressure on Sensei and

12:54

to get more involved in Westminster to take

12:56

the seats and be involved and that voting

12:58

process there's every chance as time. And saddam

13:00

that sense in may well become the largest

13:02

parties at Westminster from Northern Ireland that titus

13:05

been held by the Dp, but only by

13:07

one seat on this time and a thing

13:09

sense in are pretty confident that they will

13:11

be able to surpass a d you pay.

13:14

You. Mentioned the be word brags there and of

13:16

course Northern Ireland's got special status under that

13:18

the brag that deal for a fact as

13:20

I have on the election campaign. the shared

13:22

you reckon. Well. As puts

13:25

a D P, I think in a difficult

13:27

position because the party as you know were

13:29

locked in a bottle with the government over

13:31

trying to negotiate a deal. Post brags a

13:33

poster ones are framework because the feeling among

13:35

union as here it's as are they didn't

13:37

get brags. that's where the rest of the

13:39

Uk dead and a sense that they were

13:41

not part of the overall scheme that was

13:43

finally negotiated, that they were still been lying

13:45

to the Edu, Fourth Foods and for a

13:48

single market access and that they were very

13:50

much left behind to the Dp has been

13:52

continually citing A bottles to say very much.

13:54

that their blessing campaigns going to be

13:56

framed around restoring northern ireland space within

13:58

the uk as they put it. As

14:00

for the other parties, they're much focusing

14:02

on the positives that now flow from

14:04

Northern Ireland's position, having dual market access,

14:06

access to both the UK and also

14:08

the EU market. And they say we

14:10

need to bank these gains now and

14:13

press forward and ensure that we can

14:15

cash in by way of attracting future

14:17

inward investment. So it has been framed

14:19

around the election campaign, but for very different

14:21

reasons by the different parties. Enda, thank you

14:23

very much. Cheers, Adam. Thanks for that. And

14:27

that's all for this episode. Next time, we'll be looking at

14:30

what happens on election day itself.

14:32

And you can find more episodes on BBC

14:35

Sounds. Just search for understand the UK election.

14:37

And if you want to keep up to

14:39

date with the day to day, below by

14:41

below news from the campaign trail, then you

14:44

can listen to my other podcast newscast every

14:46

single day. And I will speak to you

14:48

again soon. Bye. Well

14:54

done for getting to the end of this

14:56

podcast. My name is Amol Rajan. And I'm

14:58

Nick Robbins. And together we host the Today

15:00

podcast. It's made by the same superb team

15:03

that make this podcast. And right now we're

15:05

busy making lots of episodes all about the

15:07

election. We thought you might fancy joining us

15:09

every Monday, every Thursday to talk it through.

15:12

Yes, the Today podcast is our moment twice

15:14

a week now to take a step back

15:16

from the news and indeed from the Today

15:18

programme and try to work out what is

15:20

really going on. So if

15:23

you like podcasts, maybe

15:25

you even listen to the Today

15:27

programme each weekday morning and on

15:29

a Saturday too. Then give us

15:31

a try. It's called the Today

15:33

podcast. And we are very much

15:35

available on BBC Sounds where you

15:37

really should subscribe. Bye. Host

15:43

the ultimate backyard barbecue with Whole

15:45

Foods Market. It's the hot grill

15:47

summer event through July 16th with

15:49

sizzling sales on no antibiotics ever.

15:51

Boneless beef ribeye steak and beef

15:53

New York strip steak. Plus check

15:56

out sales on sustainable wild cod

15:58

Alaska sockeye salmon, organic strawberry, and

16:00

more. In a hurry? Choose grab-and-go favorites

16:02

like picnic salads and sushi, plus

16:05

plenty of cooler friendly beverages. Make it

16:07

a hot grill summer at Whole Foods

16:09

Market. Sooner or later you'll need to

16:12

upgrade your tech, but you don't have

16:14

to pay full price. We're BackMarket, a

16:16

leading online marketplace for refurbished smartphones, laptops,

16:18

tablets, and other tech. All up to

16:21

70% less than brand-new.

16:23

Each device sold on BackMarket is tested

16:25

and restored to perfect working condition by

16:27

industry experts, and they all come with

16:30

a one-year warranty and 30 days to

16:32

change your mind. So never pay full

16:34

price for tech again. Visit the BackMarket

16:36

app or backmarket.com to save up to

16:38

70% on your next device.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features