Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:03
President Trump called for the U .S.
0:05
to take territory in the Middle East.
0:07
He says the U .S. should own Gaza,
0:09
displacing 1 .8 million residents to develop
0:11
seaside real estate. What do other countries
0:13
think? The
0:22
first plane load of migrants from
0:24
the U .S. landed at Guantanamo
0:26
Bay, Cuba. Critics think they
0:28
know why. Are you using this
0:30
facility because it has the
0:32
stain of the name Guantanamo? And
0:34
of course the answer is yes. Well, here
0:36
how the White House explains the moon. Also, all
0:39
staffers at the foreign aid agency, USAID were
0:41
told thank you for your service and put on
0:43
leave. So how does that affect U .S. influence
0:45
around the world? Stay with us. We've got
0:47
all the news you need to start your day.
0:55
This This message comes from
0:57
NPR sponsor Dana Farber Cancer Institute.
0:59
It's called protein degradation. And if
1:02
you're a bad protein in a
1:04
cancer cell, you'd better get your
1:06
affairs in order. Because now, thanks
1:09
to Dana Farber's foundational work, protein
1:11
degradation can target cancer-causing proteins and
1:13
destroy them right inside the cell.
1:16
This approach is making a difference
1:18
in multiple myeloma and other blood
1:20
cancers and is how Dana Farber
1:23
is working to treat previously untreatable
1:25
cancers. This This
1:27
message comes from the Nature Conservancy,
1:30
working together to create a future
1:32
with a livable climate, healthy communities,
1:34
and thriving nature. Explore ways to
1:36
act during Earth Month and every
1:39
month at nature.org slash NPR. Support
1:41
for this podcast and the following
1:43
message come from Mint Mobile. Mint
1:45
Mobile and their premium wireless plans
1:48
started just 15 bucks a month.
1:50
Say goodbye to overpriced wireless plants.
1:52
Get three months of premium wireless
1:54
from Mint Mobile for 15 bucks
1:56
a month. Up
2:00
-front payment of $45 for 3
2:02
month 5GB plan required. New customer
2:04
offer for first 3 months only.
2:06
Then full price plan options available.
2:08
Taxes and fees extra. See Mint
2:11
Mobile for details. President Trump
2:13
is talking of another territorial acquisition by
2:15
the United States. He says he
2:17
wants the U .S. to take over
2:19
Gaza, the current home of many Palestinians.
2:22
Trump brought up the idea during a visit
2:24
to the White House by Israeli Prime Minister
2:26
Benjamin Netanyahu. The U .S. will take over the
2:28
Gaza Strip and we will do a job
2:30
with it too. We'll own
2:32
it and be responsible for dismantling
2:35
all of the dangerous unexploded bombs
2:37
and other weapons on the site. level
2:39
the site and get rid of
2:41
the destroyed buildings, level it out.
2:43
Turned into seaside real estate. The
2:46
president did not rule out the
2:48
possibility of using U .S. troops
2:50
while sending the current residents to
2:52
live somewhere else, not yet named. In
2:55
just over two weeks since his
2:57
inauguration, the president has called for the
2:59
U .S. to take over a total
3:01
of four countries or territories, Greenland,
3:03
Canada, the Panama Canal, and now a
3:05
war -torn 25 -mile strip of land
3:07
on the Mediterranean. Well,
3:17
Trump already signaled clearly many times that
3:19
he thinks Palestinians should be relocated outside
3:21
of Gaza. And he says Gaza is
3:23
now a demolition site, that it's uninhabitable.
3:25
And this is largely true after nearly
3:27
16 months of war and Israeli airstrikes
3:29
that also killed nearly 50 ,000 Palestinians
3:31
with the U .N. and Gaza's health officials
3:33
saying at least 10 ,000 more bodies
3:36
are buried under that rubble. Now, rather
3:38
than live in what he called a
3:40
hellhole, Trump said yesterday that nearly 2
3:42
million Palestinians and Gaza should go elsewhere,
3:44
other countries. This can be paid for
3:46
by neighboring countries of great It could
3:48
be one, two, three, four, five, seven,
3:50
eight, 12. It could be in numerous
3:52
sites or it could be one large
3:54
site. It's really unclear if this is
3:56
actual policy ideas being formulated or his
3:58
musings at this point, but Trump, who's
4:00
an international real estate developer as well,
4:02
said he envisions the US taking over
4:04
this coastal enclave long -term and turning it
4:07
into what he called the Riviera of
4:09
the Middle East. We're going to take
4:11
over that piece and we're going to
4:13
develop it, create thousands and thousands of
4:15
jobs. and it'll be something that
4:17
the entire Middle East can be very
4:19
proud of. And Trump has said that it's
4:21
an idea that everyone he's spoken to
4:23
loves, but is it something that Palestinians and
4:25
Gaza would support? You know,
4:27
half of those two million people in Gaza
4:29
are children. They need security stability. They haven't
4:31
been in school for two years now. There
4:33
isn't even electricity or running water in Gaza.
4:35
So yeah, some families would leave given this
4:37
reality. They have said that to us. But
4:39
also people have lived in Gaza for generations
4:41
and leaving would mean the end of any
4:43
hopes for a Palestinian state. And in Israel,
4:45
expelling Palestinians from Gaza was an idea that
4:47
had mostly been relegated to the far right
4:49
corners of Israeli society. You know, Israel's prime
4:51
minister didn't comment directly on Trump's idea yesterday,
4:53
but he praised his quote willingness to think
4:56
outside the box. with fresh ideas and he
4:58
said this after the jaws drop people scratch
5:00
their heads and they say you know he's
5:02
right all right so that's one view from
5:04
the Middle East but what are other countries
5:06
in the region saying So
5:08
the major Arab states, they don't want Hamas
5:10
to rule Gaza, but they also don't
5:12
see mass displacement as a solution either. And
5:14
certainly publicly, I don't see how they
5:16
could get behind this. Now, Egypt has made
5:18
clear it will not accept the forced
5:20
expulsion of Palestinians. Egypt has called
5:22
this an injustice that they won't take part
5:24
in. And Saudi Arabia, one of the countries
5:26
of great wealth that the president referred to
5:28
that would be needed to pay for whatever
5:30
comes next in Gaza, says it rejects attempts
5:32
to displace Palestinians. They say their position is
5:35
non -negotiable and that they've made this clear
5:37
to the Trump administration. administration. That's MPR's Abe
5:39
Batraoui. Thank you very much. Thank you. The
5:47
Trump administration has started sending
5:49
migrants from the United States
5:51
to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. The
5:53
first plane load arrived yesterday.
5:56
White House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt gave
5:58
this reason. President Trump is not messing
6:00
around, and he's no longer going to
6:02
allow America to be a dumping ground
6:04
for illegal criminals from nations all over
6:07
this world. The president has said he
6:09
wants to make room for 30 ,000 migrants
6:11
at Guantanamo. NPR Sasha Pfeiffer has been
6:13
talking with some lawyers who question the
6:15
legality of that plan, so how many
6:17
people have been sent there so far?
6:19
The U .S. has not released an
6:21
official figure, but it appears to be
6:23
a small number, possibly just one flight
6:26
with about a dozen migrants on board. The
6:28
Department of Homeland Security says
6:30
they're all members of a Venezuelan
6:32
organized crime group called Tren
6:34
de Aragua, and overnight it released
6:37
photos of handcuffed men in
6:39
gray sweatpants outfits, some with
6:41
neck tattoos being led onto military
6:43
planes. And several hundred US
6:45
service members were deployed to Guantanamo in the
6:47
past few days to prepare for these arrivals.
6:49
And where are they going to be held
6:51
in Guantanamo? The US says they will not
6:53
be housed alongside the accused foreign terrorists held
6:55
at the military prison there. Instead,
6:57
a, Guantanamo's US Naval Base has had
6:59
a detention facility used for migrants
7:01
intercepted at sea, usually Haitians and Cubans.
7:03
It's had that for years. But
7:05
it's been mostly empty for a long
7:08
time. It's not ready for large
7:10
numbers of people. So the
7:12
military has also circulated photos of service
7:14
members putting up green army tents
7:16
to help with what it's calling a
7:18
migrant operation center expansion. And the
7:20
defense secretary says migrants will be held
7:22
at Guantanamo only temporarily until the
7:24
U .S. finds other countries to take
7:27
them. Okay, now to the legality question,
7:29
can the Trump administration legally send
7:31
migrants from the U .S. to Guantanamo?
7:33
Can they do that? I've gotten conflicting
7:35
answers from lawyers. Some say yes,
7:37
some say no. One who thinks it
7:39
is not legal is a lawyer
7:42
at UCLA named Ahilan Arulanatham. He
7:44
says U .S. immigration law dictates
7:46
where these migrants can be sent. And
7:49
if Cuba has presumably not agreed to
7:51
take them, he says it's an illegal
7:53
deportation. But Steve Vladek at
7:55
Georgetown Law School thinks it's legal.
7:57
He argues a deportation is not
7:59
official until the U .S. has
8:01
relinquished custody of the migrants And
8:03
that won't happen until they're moved to
8:05
another country after being at Guantanamo. But you
8:08
know that they disagree, suggest we're in
8:10
murky legal territory. Vladek also
8:12
thinks the Trump administration is sending
8:14
migrants there as a kind of
8:16
macho performance art. Here's Steve Vladek.
8:18
All you're doing this for is
8:20
the symbolism, to be able to
8:22
say, look, I moved these folks
8:24
from the detention center across town
8:26
to Guantanamo. It's all like very,
8:28
very expensive flash with very little
8:30
substance. So you mentioned symbolism. What
8:32
symbolism is there by sending migrants
8:34
to Guantanamo? You know, he points
8:36
out it would be cheaper and
8:38
easier to hold them somewhere in
8:40
some big open space elsewhere in
8:42
the US. But by shipping them
8:44
to Guantanamo, you send a certain
8:46
message. Here's how the editor of
8:48
the website Lawfare, Ben Wittes, put
8:50
it. Are you using this facility
8:52
because it has the stain of
8:55
the name Guantanamo? And of
8:57
course, the answer is yes, that's
8:59
exactly why he's attracted to it.
9:01
He is attracted to it for
9:03
the same reason that it repels
9:05
human rights groups. And
9:07
by the way, all those people
9:09
I interviewed are skeptical that
9:11
30 ,000 migrants will ever end
9:13
up at Gitmo, given the legal
9:15
questions plus financial, political, practical
9:17
barriers. But even sending a handful
9:19
is getting a ton of public attention, which
9:21
is part of the point. NPR's Sasha
9:23
Pfeiffer, thanks a lot. You're welcome. The
9:33
Trump administration is telling all
9:35
employees of the United States Agency
9:37
for International Development to stop
9:39
doing their jobs. Yeah, the workers
9:41
are told to go on
9:43
administrative leave by Friday at 11
9:45
.59 p .m. According to a
9:47
new directive sent to agency staff globally and
9:50
posted on the website. This comes after more
9:52
than two weeks of chaos at the agency.
9:54
as the president and Elon Musk said they
9:56
were in the process of shutting it
9:58
down. NPR global health correspondent Fatma Tannis joins
10:00
us now to tell us all about
10:02
this. So who exactly signed off on this?
10:05
Well, it was a short note. It
10:07
was not signed by any official, and
10:10
it said that there would be some
10:12
exceptions that essential personnel expected to continue
10:14
working would be notified by Thursday afternoon. Now,
10:17
around 10 ,000 people work for USAID. Most
10:19
of them are serving overseas, and they've
10:21
been given 30 days to pack up and
10:23
come back home. The note ended with
10:25
the words, thank you for your service. So
10:27
what are you hearing from the people
10:29
who work there? Well, they're shocked
10:31
and gutted. I spoke to several officials
10:33
of the agency who didn't want to
10:35
be named because they're not authorized to
10:37
speak publicly and they said that this
10:39
is effectively a shutdown of the agency
10:41
and they call the process inhumane. Now
10:43
for staff who are overseas, there are other concerns.
10:46
People have kids in school, spouses who
10:48
have jobs, they have pets. It's gonna
10:50
be hard to brood their lives in
10:52
30 days and many are expecting the
10:54
next step to be mass layoffs. I
10:56
also heard concerns about what this
10:58
means for the US. I spoke
11:01
with Susan Reich Lee, a retired
11:03
USAID official, and here's how she
11:05
put it. This is taking away
11:07
a critical element of our national
11:09
security, and it's affecting people's lives
11:11
from not just a humanitarian perspective,
11:13
but we're leaving a huge vacuum
11:15
for China and Russia. I mean,
11:17
it seems like the Trump administration
11:19
wants to get rid of this
11:21
agency. Why would they want to
11:23
do that? Well, President
11:25
Trump has been saying that USAID is
11:27
too independent, that it is full
11:29
of, quote, radical left lunatics, and that
11:31
its programs are not in line
11:34
with his America First policy. Now,
11:36
people who work in the agency, they say
11:38
their allegiance is to the Constitution and not
11:40
to any political party. Many of
11:42
them served under multiple administrations, and
11:44
they say that everything they do down
11:46
to the countries and the issues
11:48
that they work on is approved by
11:50
Congress. Now, since Congress chartered
11:52
USAID, legal experts say the administration
11:54
doesn't have the authority to abolish it
11:56
on its own, but there are
11:58
still a lot of questions about how
12:00
this is going to play out.
12:03
And they've have programs all over the
12:05
world, so what happens now to
12:07
all of those things? Well, for now,
12:09
most programs receiving U .S. foreign aid
12:11
have been halted. And you know,
12:13
there are multiple disease outbreaks going on,
12:15
Ebola in East Africa. There's
12:17
a different hemorrhagic fever in Bolivia. These
12:20
are part of USAID's work overseas. Here's
12:22
Matt Kavanaugh, the Director of Global
12:25
Health Policy at Georgetown University. team
12:28
was literally preparing to
12:30
respond to these new outbreaks
12:32
that occurred literally as
12:34
the president was being inaugurated.
12:36
And now that's stopped. So
12:39
have distributions of HIV
12:41
medication and pox vaccines, a
12:44
therapeutic food for malnourished kids.
12:46
Millions of people around the world aren't getting
12:49
those services anymore. All right, so a lot
12:51
still up in the air. That's NPR's Fatma
12:53
Tannis. Thank you very much for letting us
12:55
know about all this. Thank you. And
13:01
that's up first for Wednesday, February
13:03
5th. I mean, Martinez. And I'm Stephen
13:05
Skeep. Don't forget, you can hear
13:07
this podcast sponsor -free while financially supporting
13:09
public media with Up First Plus. Learn
13:12
more at plus .npr .org, plus .npr
13:14
.org. Today's episode of Up First
13:16
was edited by Nishant Dahiya,
13:18
Barry Hartiman, Rebecca Davis, Janea Williams,
13:20
and Alice Wolfley was produced
13:22
by Zia Bocz, Mia Dumas, and
13:24
Christopher Thomas. We get engineering
13:26
support from Simon Laszlo Janssen, and
13:28
our technical director is Nisha
13:30
Heinis. Join us again tomorrow. Want
13:46
to hear this podcast without
13:48
sponsor breaks? Amazon Prime members can
13:50
listen to Up First sponsor -free
13:52
through Amazon Music. Or you
13:54
can also support NPR's vital journalism
13:56
and get Up First Plus
13:59
at plus .npr .org. plus
14:01
.npr .org. This
14:04
message comes from Warby Parker. What
14:06
makes a great pair of glasses?
14:08
At Warby Parker, it's all the
14:10
invisible extras, without the extra cost,
14:12
like free adjustments for life. Find
14:15
your pair at Warby parker.com or
14:17
visit one of their hundreds of
14:19
stores around the country. This message
14:21
is from Synchrony Bank, who
14:23
can help you get your
14:25
do-nothing savings to work hard
14:27
with their high-yield savings account.
14:29
Put your lazy savings to
14:31
work at synchrony.com/NPR, member FDIC. FDIC.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More