Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
and Crime contains graphic and
0:02
explicit content which may not
0:04
be suitable for some listeners.
0:06
Listener discretion is advised. You
0:23
are listening to Wine and
0:25
Crime, the podcast where two friends
0:27
chug wine, chat true crime,
0:29
and unleash their worst Minnesotan accents.
0:32
Gosh darn it. You know
0:34
they do. I'm curious
0:36
what kind of accents might
0:38
apply to today's topic.
0:40
I've never been to that
0:42
area, so I frankly
0:44
don't know. Not much of one.
0:46
Okay. Respect. The
0:49
accents aren't super strong in the
0:51
Southwest, the American Southwest. All right.
0:53
I don't think. I mean, I didn't when
0:55
we were in New Mexico, I feel like I
0:57
did not notice any like discernible
1:00
or to me
1:02
personally discernible, personally
1:04
distinctive regional accent. But
1:07
that's that's to my ear,
1:09
which which the value I
1:11
put on this is absolute zero.
1:13
Minimal. Yeah. Yep. So
1:16
I would love, honestly, like,
1:18
voice memo me, your American Southwest
1:20
accents, because I would love
1:23
them. Because... Oh,
1:25
I'm Lucy. Yep. I'm Amanda. Sorry.
1:27
I... Yep. We got a We
1:29
started before we started. got a
1:32
little ahead of ourselves. We
1:34
did. Today we have a
1:36
very special fan pick from Dustin
1:38
Perez. Thank you, Dustin. Thank
1:40
you, Dustin. Dusty P. Dusty.
1:43
Everything is Dustin Perez.
1:46
Dustin Perez is everything.
1:49
Dustin chose the topic
1:51
of Lake Tahoe crimes.
1:54
All the photos of
1:56
Lake Tahoe. It
1:59
looks Caribbean. Oh, my
2:01
God. It's just Gorgina.
2:03
I mean, we live in
2:05
such a huge country
2:07
that I frequently forget the...
2:09
boundless natural beauties that
2:12
exist right within even just
2:14
the contiguous United States.
2:16
It's wild. Yeah. So
2:18
we should protect them. Right. Right.
2:24
Well, I'm on a razor's edge. I
2:27
am barely clinging
2:29
on. When they say
2:31
skin of my
2:34
teeth, they mean it.
2:37
Didn't know my teeth had skin until I
2:39
was there. Yeah. Yeah.
2:41
Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
2:43
Well, let's get going
2:46
because I think that this
2:48
might be a good
2:50
distraction from some of the
2:52
news. Yeah.
2:54
Okay. So,
2:56
Amanda, what is our wine
2:58
crime pairing for Lake
3:01
Tahoe Crimes? Well, Dusty P
3:03
recommended that we shout
3:05
out and check out. Tahoe
3:07
blue vodka, which
3:09
is a... Well, I literally wrote, don't
3:11
worry, the vodka itself is not
3:13
blue. Dustin would not harm us like
3:15
that. I've had my
3:18
time with Your UV
3:20
blue flashbacks, your PTSD.
3:23
You were fighting for your life
3:25
out there. dry just thinking about
3:27
it. One UV blue at a
3:29
time. No, this is a, frankly, stunning
3:32
looking vodka out of... Tahoe,
3:34
like when you go to
3:36
their website, which is TahoeBlueVodka.com,
3:38
you're greeted by literally the
3:40
glistening mountain foot waters of
3:42
Lake Tahoe. Mountain foot? Well,
3:45
you know, there's little ranges
3:47
in the background. It's gorgeous.
3:49
Yeah, it's just gorgeous. It's
3:51
just gorgeous. So the Tahoe
3:53
Blue Vodka is inspired by
3:55
Lake Tahoe. which straddles California
3:57
and Nevada with a maximum
3:59
depth of over 1 ,600
4:01
feet, which I'm sure you're
4:03
going to get to. This
4:05
is local to that region
4:08
and inspired by that region.
4:10
Okay. When you drink Tahoe
4:12
Blue Vodka, you support Lake
4:14
Tahoe because they donate a
4:16
portion of their proceeds to
4:18
help preserve both the lake
4:20
itself and the diverse environment
4:22
surrounding it. So I thought
4:24
that was pretty cool. that
4:26
you can drink, feel good
4:28
about what you're drinking because
4:31
you are supporting the conservation
4:33
and preservation of one of
4:35
our country's most gorgeous natural
4:37
features. This is the world's
4:39
only vodka crafted from pristine
4:41
Tahoe water. Oh, it's made
4:43
from the water? Sure is. It
4:46
is a three vodka blend that
4:48
finishes as clean and smooth as the
4:50
lake it's named for. So smooth,
4:52
in fact, it's claimed dozens of awards
4:54
and been named best tasting and
4:56
best in class by various judges. Well,
4:59
do they know how many corpses are
5:01
in Lake Tahoe? I don't know if they
5:03
do, but I have a feeling that
5:05
you do. Nobody
5:07
does. That you. Oh,
5:09
OK. Well, great. They
5:12
do have this at Total Wine.
5:14
They did not have it at my
5:16
local Total Wine, which makes me
5:18
really sad, but I'm going to order
5:20
it because it truly sounds spectacular.
5:22
But their website is awesome. It also
5:24
has recommendations of what to do
5:26
with your Tahoe Blue. And
5:28
they shared a couple of their
5:30
favorite recipes from among their staff, and
5:32
I'm going to share them with
5:34
you as well and then let you
5:36
know which one I'm drinking. All
5:38
right. So the founder's favorite, this is
5:40
super easy and delicious and refreshing. It's
5:42
a vodka soda, like a tall
5:44
boy with ice and one and a
5:46
half ounces, wink, wink, however much
5:48
vodka you need to put in there.
5:50
Tahoe blue vodka and then soda water.
5:52
But you garnish it with an orange
5:54
slice, which I'm a huge fan of.
5:56
Okay. In Amsterdam, they serve gin and
5:58
tonics in like a big goblet with
6:00
an orange slice. Yum. I'm
6:03
obsessed. We need more orange
6:05
garnishes. I agree. It's like
6:07
a limes. Uh -huh. Uh -huh.
6:10
Another one that is also
6:12
not blue, but the name
6:14
may confuse you, may send
6:17
you in a different direction.
6:19
A blue herring? It's a
6:21
blue herring. It's the Blue
6:23
Samurai, which is two ounces
6:25
of Tahoe Blue Vodka, an
6:27
ounce of simple syrup, a
6:29
pea -sized dollop of wasabi. Ooh.
6:32
And a cucumber slice. I
6:34
thought that one sounded awesome. Maybe.
6:36
Do you shake it then? Yeah.
6:38
You'd shake that in a or
6:40
yeah, you'd shake it. You'd make
6:43
one cocktail at a time in
6:45
your shaker. Yeah. They, of course,
6:47
have things like Bloody Marys, hard
6:49
lemonades, Tahoe Mule, you know, things
6:51
that are like the vodka classics.
6:53
But I also had to share
6:55
one that was going to fulfill
6:57
your fears. The lady in blue.
6:59
Which is, in fact, a blue
7:01
cocktail. And it is very blue.
7:03
It's like Margaritaville blue. I'm kind
7:05
of living for it. It's a
7:07
one and a half ounces of
7:09
Tahoe blue vodka, 0 .75 ounces
7:11
of lemon juice, 0 .5 ounces of
7:13
simple syrup, 0 .25 ounces of
7:15
creme de voilette, which is where
7:17
you get that some of that
7:19
blue. Then you're going to
7:21
top it off with a little blue
7:23
curacao. Of course, that blue
7:25
doesn't come natural. Nope, that's our girl.
7:28
Two drops orange flower water, and
7:30
you can garnish it with an edible
7:32
flower. So if you're looking for
7:34
something that's going to make you feel
7:36
like you're on a retired white
7:38
lady's island vacation, the lady in blue
7:41
is going to be the one
7:43
for you. If you're, what's it called?
7:45
Barb and star taking this to
7:47
Del Mar. Yep. Del Mar. You might
7:49
want to check out the lady
7:51
in blue, but I am drinking the
7:54
founder's favorite cute because I had
7:56
vodka and I had oranges and I
7:58
had soda and I want to
8:00
make clear. I did look up Tahoe
8:02
blue vodka to see if I
8:04
could get it at my local total
8:07
wine, but I could not, but
8:09
I do want to try this. So
8:11
check them out at. TahoeBlueVodka.com.
8:14
You can get recipe ideas,
8:16
learn about their business and where
8:18
you can get their stuff.
8:20
And it's just like, I want
8:22
to go to Lake Tahoe
8:24
so bad. I fucking do too.
8:26
Let's do a gals go
8:28
to Lake Tahoe. Done. Perfect. Are
8:30
you drinking anything fun or
8:32
special today? As I mentioned, I
8:34
had a cocktail before we
8:36
started. So I feel adequately pre
8:38
-lubed. Good. Great. And I got
8:40
my pen. Perfect. Then
8:42
you have everything on both ends.
8:45
I have everything I need and some
8:47
ice water. Oh, my
8:49
God. Well, let's take a quick
8:51
break to hear a word from
8:53
our sponsors so that you can
8:55
dive in to all of the
8:57
Lake Tahoe madness. Let's do it.
8:59
Springs here, people. And you know what
9:01
that means. Wedding season.
9:04
Oh, my favorite. So many weddings this
9:06
year for me personally. Whether you're
9:08
attending a bridal shower, a bachelorette party,
9:10
or the actual wedding itself, it's
9:12
time to get dressed up again. Shake
9:15
off those winter mulligrubs, those cobwebs,
9:17
and get a great outfit because a
9:19
great outfit always starts with great
9:21
shapewear. Let's be real. No one has
9:23
time for shapewear that feels uncomfortable
9:25
or restrictive or like takes you forever
9:27
to put it on or take
9:29
it off. And luckily, you don't
9:31
have to settle for that stuff. Today's episode
9:33
is brought to you by Honey Love, the
9:36
brand that's setting a new standard for shapewear. It's
9:39
wedding season for all, but it
9:41
is like thighs fusing together season for
9:43
me. Yeah. And that is where
9:45
Honey Love Superpower Short has quite literally
9:47
saved my thighs year after year.
9:49
Saved your butt. Saved my butt, lifted
9:51
it up, saved my thighs from
9:53
rubbing together. It's so comfy. It's so
9:55
easy to wear. I'm obsessed. Honey
9:57
Love uses targeted compression to sculpt and
9:59
smooth where you want it and
10:01
ease off where you don't. That means
10:03
it's super effective and comfortable to
10:05
wear all day long. It's shapewear that
10:07
works with your body, not against
10:09
it. And if you're wondering what the
10:11
difference might be there, honestly, you're
10:13
going to feel it. You're going to
10:15
see it immediately when you put
10:17
it on. Plus, it's got this flexible
10:19
boning in the side seams that
10:21
keeps it from rolling down. which
10:24
is like such a common issue
10:26
I was running into. You'll never have
10:28
to sneakily adjust yourself in public
10:31
again, even after a night of dancing.
10:33
Plus their shapewear features, lingerie inspired design
10:36
details that you'll want to show off.
10:38
So, you know, if you've got weddings
10:40
on the brain this season, honey, love
10:42
has definitely got you covered. And
10:44
here's the best part. For a limited
10:46
time, you can get Honey Love on
10:48
sale. Save 20 % off your entire
10:50
order with our exclusive link, honeylove.com slash
10:52
wine. Support the show and start your
10:54
year off right by checking them
10:56
out at honeylove.com slash wine. Treat yourself
10:58
to the most comfortable shapewear on earth
11:00
and save 20 % off site -wide at
11:03
honeylove.com slash wine. Use our exclusive
11:05
link to get 20 % off honeylove.com slash
11:07
wine. After you purchase the last
11:09
we heard about them, please support our
11:11
show and tell them they sent you.
11:13
Experience the new standard in shapewear with
11:15
Honeylove. This episode is brought
11:17
to you by IQ Bar, our
11:19
exclusive snack sponsor. IQ Bar is
11:21
the better -for -you plant -protein -based snacks
11:24
made with brain -boosting nutrients to refuel,
11:26
nourish, and satisfy hunger without the
11:28
sugar crash. I love IQ Bar.
11:30
I am so bad at, like...
11:32
myself breakfast, and IQ Bar has
11:34
fully changed the game for me.
11:36
Their plant protein bars are packed
11:38
with high -quality ingredients to keep
11:40
you physically and mentally fit. IQ
11:42
Bar is totally free from gluten,
11:44
dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial sweeteners
11:46
for a natural anytime snack. I
11:49
am in love with their flavors.
11:51
They have nine delicious flavors, including
11:53
mint chocolate chip, high, chocolate sea
11:55
salt, banana nut, toasted coconut chip.
11:57
My favorite is the lemon blueberry
11:59
i also love the peanut butter
12:01
chip and honestly with over 20
12:03
000 five -star reviews and counting more
12:05
people than ever are starting their
12:07
days on the right foot with
12:09
iq bars brain and body boosting
12:12
bars hydration mixes and mushroom coffees
12:14
i'm obsessed their hydration mixes are
12:16
so good and again don't have
12:18
all that extra sugar in them
12:20
that's gonna like spike my blood
12:22
sugar in the morning you know
12:24
i'm a diabetic early i gotta
12:26
be careful about what i put
12:28
in my body iq bar is
12:30
always an easy one for me
12:32
to reach for And right now,
12:34
IQ Bar is offering our special
12:37
podcast listeners 20 % off all
12:39
IQ Bar products, plus get free
12:41
shipping. To get your 20 % off,
12:43
text GALS to 64000. Text GALS
12:45
to 64000. That's GALS to 64000.
12:47
Message and data rates may apply.
12:49
See terms for details. Did
12:51
you know that Fast Growing Trees is
12:54
the biggest online nursery in the U .S.
12:56
with thousands of different plants and over two
12:58
million happy customers? They have
13:00
all the plants your yard needs, like
13:02
fruit trees, privacy trees, flowering trees, shrubs,
13:04
and so much more. Whatever plants you're
13:06
interested in, Fast Growing Trees has you
13:08
covered. Find the perfect fit for your
13:10
climate and space. It's so amazing that
13:12
you can literally search with your zip
13:14
code and find your zone. So you're
13:16
not like leafing, quote unquote, through plants
13:18
that won't even grow in your area. Fast
13:21
-growing trees makes it easy to get
13:23
your dream yard. Order online and get
13:25
your plants delivered directly to your door
13:27
in just a few days without ever
13:29
leaving home, our other favorite thing. Their
13:31
alive and thrive guarantee ensures your plants
13:34
arrive happy and healthy. Plus, get support
13:36
from trained plant experts on call to
13:38
help you plan your landscape, choose the
13:40
right plants, and learn how to care
13:42
for them. I got a cherry tree
13:44
from Fast Growing Trees. Same girl. I
13:46
couldn't plant it right away. She sat
13:48
on my porch for longer than I
13:50
would have liked. Popped her
13:53
in the ground a couple weeks ago.
13:55
She is thriving. Yeah. I
13:57
was shocked that I didn't accidentally kill
13:59
it because of that. Yeah, I
14:01
actually had to put mine in a
14:03
pot for the same reason and
14:05
keep it inside by a window until
14:07
the last freeze, which she can
14:10
finally be planted now. But she's already...
14:12
Like sprout leaves. Yeah. Yeah. She's
14:14
in great shape. The health of these
14:16
trees. My God. So if you
14:18
have a big yard, a small yard
14:20
or no yard, they have over
14:23
6 ,000 plants to fit any space
14:25
from indoor plants. They got like house
14:27
plants. They got fruit trees, full
14:29
size privacy trees. So much more. I
14:31
have a lot of fun just
14:33
browsing their website. Also, funny anecdote, like
14:36
six years ago, I planted one
14:38
arborvitae on the side of my house.
14:40
Girl, you tried. I got it for free
14:42
from work and I was like, okay, I'm
14:45
just going to plant it. And then I
14:47
like stopped seeing it because it's just one,
14:49
you know, that's sort of an odd plant
14:51
to just have one of. And now I
14:53
got my cherry tree and I was like
14:55
looking around and like, I'm going to plant
14:57
trees all over. Like this spring, I already
14:59
have a whole landscaping plan thanks to fast
15:01
growing trees. I'm like, oh, maybe my arborvitae
15:03
needs like four or five friends. And
15:06
I have all the confidence in the world
15:08
that the ones that I get from fast
15:10
-growing trees are going to be... exceptionally
15:12
healthy and they're going to just make
15:14
my yard so beautiful. It's also just such
15:16
a great website for people who are
15:18
like maybe kind of new to gardening or
15:20
feel like they don't have a green
15:22
thumb. Like folks, these people will walk you
15:25
through every step of the process. You
15:27
can do it. If I can do it,
15:30
baby, you can do it. Okay.
15:32
I'm so confident now. So confident. And
15:34
this spring they have the best
15:36
deals for your yard up to
15:38
half off on select plants and other
15:40
deals. And listeners, to our show
15:42
get 15 % off their first purchase
15:44
when using the code GALS at
15:47
checkout. That's an additional 15 % off
15:49
at FastGrowingTrees.com using the code GALS
15:51
at checkout. FastGrowingTrees.com code
15:53
GALS now is the perfect time
15:55
to plant. Use GALS to save
15:57
today. Offer is valid for a
15:59
limited time. Terms and conditions may
16:01
apply. Welcome back to Whining Crime.
16:03
Welcome back. Welcome back. Welcome
16:05
back. Lucy,
16:08
I am excited to hear How many
16:10
bodies are in Lake Tahoe? So
16:12
would you like to present your findings
16:14
to the class? You're not going
16:16
to hear how many because so many
16:18
will never be found. Gosh,
16:20
darn it. Gosh,
16:22
darn it. It's right. Golly. So
16:24
Lake Tahoe sits on the border
16:27
of California and Nevada. Make up
16:29
your mind. And is the largest
16:31
alpine lake. Take a side. Is
16:33
the largest alpine lake in
16:35
North America. So that means.
16:37
It's at or above the
16:39
tree line. She's up there.
16:41
Which Lake Superior is not.
16:43
No. No. So she sits
16:45
at over 6 ,000 feet
16:47
above sea level. She's also
16:49
very deep. As you mentioned,
16:51
she gets to about 1 ,600
16:53
feet deep, putting her in
16:55
second place behind Crater Lake
16:57
in Oregon, who is just
16:59
a bit deeper at 1
17:01
,900 feet deep. Hey, Siri,
17:03
how deep is the deepest
17:05
part of Lake Superior? The
17:07
deepest part of Lake Superior
17:09
is 1 ,333 feet, 406 meters.
17:12
No, don't care. Don't care. Shut
17:15
your mouth. Shut up. Shut
17:17
your mouth. Wow.
17:20
Okay. So they're not like,
17:22
I mean, I would assume in
17:24
terms of depth and pressure,
17:26
that's a pretty decent difference at
17:28
300 feet. But like to
17:30
us, if you're going to walk.
17:32
1 ,300 feet versus 1 ,600
17:34
feet, it doesn't feel that different.
17:36
I don't think it really would. But
17:39
dang, that's some deep ass
17:41
fucking lakes. It's very deep, especially
17:43
considering when you think about
17:45
the pressure and what can survive
17:47
down there. Yeah. There isn't
17:49
a big difference between 1 ,600
17:51
and 1 ,900 feet. I guess
17:53
not. Once you
17:55
get into that zone, you're
17:57
crushing. Literally crushing. So
18:00
Lake Tahoe is the sixth
18:02
largest lake by volume in the
18:04
United States. So it's basically
18:06
the five Great Lakes and then
18:08
her. Interesting. I wonder
18:11
why she didn't make the cut.
18:13
Well, the Great Lakes are kind
18:15
of connected up up there, you
18:17
know, I suppose. She's kind of
18:19
alone down southwest. She's holding it
18:21
down. She's holding it down. So,
18:23
of course, this makes the lake
18:25
a hub for tourism because being
18:27
surrounded on all sides by mountains
18:29
and gorgeous forests makes for excellent
18:31
skiing in the winter and those
18:33
beaches, that water, the sheer size.
18:35
Does she freeze? I don't
18:37
think so. Yeah, because Lake Superior doesn't
18:39
really freeze either. You'll get some ice
18:41
like right along the shoreline, but it's
18:43
not a lake that you can like
18:46
skate or ice fish on. It's like,
18:48
no, it has like a fucking tide.
18:50
Well, this is also, like,
18:52
in Nevada. Right. Oh, true.
18:54
Yeah. I look at those
18:56
snow -capped mountains surrounding it, and
18:59
I'm like, oh, it's cold.
19:01
Wait. No. It gets
19:03
cold, but it's not, like, how
19:05
Lake Superior is always fucking,
19:07
like, 35 degrees or some shit.
19:09
Yeah. Much different swim in it.
19:12
It's at a higher altitude, but it
19:14
is in, it's in the desert. A
19:16
warmer, yeah. It's in a warmer region.
19:18
Mm hmm. So like I mentioned, Lake
19:20
Tahoe is unique because of its size.
19:22
It is so big that at the
19:24
widest point, which is over 100 miles,
19:27
you can't see the other side and
19:29
you but you can see the curvature
19:31
of the earth on its surface. Mm
19:33
hmm. She big. Yeah. That being said,
19:35
if the air temperature is way higher
19:37
than the water temperature, like if the
19:39
water is really cold and the air
19:42
is much warmer, the light
19:44
refracting, the light refraction
19:46
can occur, which. can
19:48
result in Fata Morgana,
19:50
which is a mirage,
19:52
like an optical illusion
19:54
created at the horizon
19:56
line that looks like
19:58
towers. It looks like
20:00
vertical. So these may
20:02
be responsible for the Tahoe
20:04
Tessie sightings. Like their Loch Ness
20:06
Monster. Yes, and I just
20:08
don't care about that kind of
20:10
thing. The exasperation in your
20:13
voice. Do not talk to Lucy
20:15
about a cryptid. Do fucking
20:17
not. care. I
20:19
just don't. They're so out there.
20:21
Listen. They're not real. Except
20:24
that weird bird. That was in
20:26
Iowa. That was a weird
20:28
one. Bigfoot is real. And I
20:30
don't care who tries to
20:32
fight me on it. I
20:35
mean, at Tahoe Tessie, can
20:37
we be a little more trite? It's just
20:39
stupid. It's on like a bunch of
20:41
their merch. Grow
20:43
up. Just
20:48
not all that righteous
20:50
indignation for Tahoe Tessie.
20:53
Sea monsters. Not your thing. I
20:55
was really into them in
20:57
third grade. For a
20:59
full year, I was really into them.
21:01
I checked out old books from
21:03
the library, like ones that didn't even
21:05
have pictures about sea monsters. Well,
21:07
that's absurd. Yeah,
21:09
I had a hard phase.
21:11
And you know what? I
21:13
was eight. Yeah, you're past
21:15
it now. I'm very much
21:18
past it. Okay. We'll get
21:20
to the creatures that I
21:22
prefer. Okay. That we attribute
21:24
these Fata Morgana sightings to.
21:26
So Fata Morgana is the
21:28
translation of Morgan the Fairy
21:30
in Italian. And so that's
21:32
from the King Arthur legend
21:34
of Morgan Le Fay. Okay.
21:36
And so these. Optical illusions
21:38
were named such by sailors
21:40
in the Strait of Messina
21:42
where these mirages were described
21:45
as fairy castles or false
21:47
land created by Morgan's magic. Weird.
21:50
Mirages are nuts to behold. Especially
21:52
when you're in the middle
21:54
of the ocean and you think
21:57
you see like land and
21:59
like a towering, glittering city. Yeah.
22:01
I mean, in the middle of
22:03
something that is so big that
22:05
it feels like an ocean, at
22:08
least in this case. Yeah, well,
22:10
the phrase Fata Morgana comes from
22:12
ocean travel. The Italian explorers. Yeah.
22:14
So when I thought of Lake
22:16
Tahoe, I got it confused with
22:18
Lake Como. Which, that's
22:20
Italy, right? Wait, which one am
22:22
I thinking of? Lake... Havasu.
22:25
I thought of, yes, Lake
22:27
Havasu. From Vanderbilt Rules. Real Housewives.
22:29
I thought of Real Housewives. They
22:31
go to Lake Tahoe in Housewives for
22:34
sure. But I know VPR went to
22:36
Havasu. It's like they can't afford Tahoe.
22:38
Orange County went to Havasu, too, because
22:40
I feel like the Gundolfsons had a
22:42
lake house there. Probably. So
22:44
upon Googling, it was Real
22:46
Housewives of Beverly Hills, season
22:49
11, episode 2. They
22:51
rented a house. Reno rented a
22:53
house. At the time, it
22:55
was $8 ,000 per night. It's
22:57
17 ,000 square feet. It has
22:59
17 bedrooms and 18 bathrooms. Okay.
23:01
It can host up to
23:03
40 people. Like sleeping comfortably with
23:05
a partner in a comfortable
23:07
sleeping arrangement. It has bed space
23:09
for 40 people. Yeah. And
23:12
there were seven ladies, maybe eight.
23:14
Well, and the crew. Well,
23:16
yeah. And also, like, of course,
23:18
they're going to be extra
23:20
anyway. But this is this is
23:22
where the two truths and
23:24
a lie episode takes place in
23:26
which Kathy Hilton doesn't understand
23:28
the basic rules of two truths
23:30
and a lie. It's a
23:32
very complex game. And then Erica
23:34
wants everyone to think that
23:37
she's super mysterious and she just
23:39
is so vapid. I can't
23:41
even stand it. I know. What
23:43
a monster. So this house
23:45
has a Himalayan salt cave, an
23:47
indoor swimming pool. A
23:49
secret tunnel to the lake and the
23:51
pier. My God. And
23:53
its own hair and nail
23:55
salon. In the house? Yeah. This
23:58
is one of those properties where it's
24:00
like rich people built this as a
24:03
house so it could be like zoned
24:05
that way or homesteaded or whatever. It's
24:07
got to be some sort of tax
24:09
thing, but it's definitely a commercial property
24:11
that they built to rent out for
24:13
like weddings. Large private
24:15
events. Yes. And no one
24:17
was ever going to live there.
24:20
It was built by Mr.
24:22
Hera of Hera's Casino Empire. That'll
24:24
do it. Yep. That'll
24:26
do it. That fits
24:28
just right. Hey,
24:31
do what you got to do.
24:33
So Ben found it on
24:35
Vrbo. It is now $12 ,000
24:38
a night. Ew. But you can
24:40
rent it. Well, one could. I
24:43
absolutely cannot. I
24:45
also found the, well, I saw
24:47
on Instagram, the house in White
24:49
Lotus where Greg slash Gary lives
24:51
with Chloe is on Airbnb for
24:53
$13 ,000 a night. Jesus. Okay,
24:55
let me do the math on
24:57
how many people I would have
25:00
to split that with to be
25:02
able to afford it. You could
25:04
split it with 40 full people.
25:06
Well, that doesn't, it's $1 ,200 a
25:08
night? $12 ,000 a night? Yes.
25:10
12 ,000 a night divided by
25:12
40 is still on the high
25:14
end of my price range. How
25:16
much a night? 300. I
25:18
also don't know 40 people I'd want
25:20
to hang out with for a whole
25:23
night. I mean, fair. Not that you
25:25
see many of them because it seems
25:27
like the place is so fucking big,
25:29
it'd be pretty easy to avoid people.
25:31
Yeah. You can pretty much all have
25:33
your own bathroom. If I'm spending 300
25:36
bucks and splitting everything with all of
25:38
my friends, I want a couple nights
25:40
out of it, not one night. Yeah,
25:42
it's still $1 ,000 basically living in a
25:44
frat house. Yeah. A really nice frat
25:46
house. The world's nicest frat house. No,
25:48
thanks. Next. Next. I'd rather split it
25:51
with fewer people, but I obviously couldn't
25:53
afford that if I won the lottery.
25:55
I think I would maximum 12 people.
25:57
Yeah. Even in a 17 ,000 square
25:59
foot house. Yeah. No. No. It's too
26:01
big. I don't like it. Pull a
26:04
Denise and get a hotel. Yeah. Okay.
26:07
Lake Tahoe is fed by
26:09
67 tributaries. So like little streams
26:11
that come down from the
26:13
mountains, but not like full. substantial
26:15
rivers so those give it
26:18
about half of its water and
26:20
the rest is from precipitation
26:22
cool there's only one outlet which
26:24
is the truckee river which
26:26
flows north through reno up past
26:28
reno about 15 miles to
26:30
pyramid lake interesting pyramid lake remember
26:33
when we were at the
26:35
convention in albuquerque and we were
26:37
talking to that guy that's
26:39
right when my gummy kicked in
26:41
when he saw he saw
26:43
the ufo Yeah. No way.
26:45
That's why I started Googling Pyramid Lake.
26:48
There's a bunch of weird UFO
26:50
stuff, but there's also what I'm about
26:52
to talk about. All right. So
26:54
Pyramid Lake is just too fun not
26:56
to give a brief moment to
26:58
before we head back south to Lake
27:00
Tahoe. So Pyramid Lake is on
27:02
the Paiute Reservation. And Paiute folklore
27:04
says that the lake was formed from
27:06
the tears of the stone mother, probably
27:09
from all the mountains. Some
27:11
other tribe legends include
27:13
water babies. Ooh. So
27:16
these are babies that were
27:18
born prematurely or that were born
27:20
with disabilities, and they were
27:22
taken to the lake to drown.
27:24
Oh, my God. That's terrible.
27:26
It is, but that wasn't uncommon
27:28
back when we didn't have
27:30
civilizations large enough to really have
27:32
the means and resources to
27:34
take care of. of course. Of
27:36
course. Like, I get it.
27:38
It's just fucking tragic. It is,
27:40
but that is a real
27:42
part of what probably every civilization
27:44
around the world has gone
27:46
through at some point. I feel
27:48
like that kind of death
27:50
is a lot quicker and much
27:52
more merciful than the inevitable
27:54
death that also comes with draining
27:56
a bunch of resources from
27:58
your community, you know? Yeah,
28:00
not my place to say. If
28:02
you were in this position,
28:04
obviously there is no fucking reason
28:06
for this. this kind of
28:09
practice now nowadays no not saying
28:11
that yes a very sad
28:13
thing a very sad fact of
28:15
life also this is legend
28:17
so i'm not even trying to
28:19
say that they really did
28:21
do this but yeah i know
28:23
that some for sure for
28:25
sure this absolutely happened across cultures
28:27
and communities in like the
28:29
early times of man this was
28:31
survival at its most brutal
28:34
yeah So it is said that
28:36
these babies never left the
28:38
lake, and their spirits still live
28:40
there, and they call out
28:42
to fishermen to lure them into
28:44
the water where the fishermen
28:46
drown. Yeah, get their revenge. Get
28:48
your revenge, water babies. But
28:51
water babies is such a sweet
28:53
name. It's like, no, they're like
28:55
creepy baby sirens. Yeah, and I'm
28:57
living for it. Yeah. Every
29:00
spring, there are reports of babies
29:02
crying on the shore of the lake.
29:04
Whoa, that gave me a chill.
29:06
Also, springtime is when most of the
29:08
drownings occur. There's
29:10
also a legend of
29:12
a singular spurned mermaid. One
29:16
mermaid. She was so annoying about
29:18
it that no other mermaids even
29:20
wanted to live in the same
29:22
lake. Pretty much. I'm obsessed. So
29:25
the story goes that she, the
29:27
mermaid, was dating a tribesman. The
29:29
family of the tribesman did not
29:31
accept their love. And ordered him
29:33
to return the mermaid to the
29:35
lake. She is not allowed here.
29:38
No mermaids allowed. The mermaid was
29:40
pissed off. And so she cursed
29:42
the lake and everyone around it.
29:44
And so that's why there are,
29:46
again, so many drownings and mysterious
29:48
disappearances associated with lakes. Oh. Good
29:51
for her. Right. I'll
29:53
say it again. And I will
29:55
say it forever. So,
29:57
like I said, these mysterious
29:59
drownings. but perhaps even more
30:01
mysterious, the discoveries of the
30:03
drowned victims. So remember when
30:05
I said, well, okay, so
30:07
Pyramid Lake is not nearly
30:09
as deep as Lake Tahoe.
30:11
It gets up to about
30:13
350 feet deep, but it
30:15
also has like really steep
30:17
drop -offs and it has
30:19
like currents. Okay, so
30:22
I think I understood this
30:24
correctly, but my interpretation of this
30:26
was because of the altitude
30:28
of the lake, So
30:30
divers can only go about 90 feet
30:32
deep. And I think this is because
30:34
of like the air pressure in their
30:36
tanks and all that stuff. Because they
30:38
have to factor in how far above
30:40
sea level they are. Oh, that's so
30:42
interesting and scary. So
30:45
they can only go about 90 feet
30:47
out of the 350 feet deep that
30:49
the lake is. Okay. So they can't
30:51
even see what is all the way
30:53
down there in real time. They'd have
30:55
to send down some sort of device.
30:57
Well, yeah, but also like if they
30:59
weren't really paying attention, they weren't really
31:01
aware of how deep they were. All
31:03
of a sudden they can't get back
31:05
up. So divers
31:07
sometimes go missing. But the weirdest
31:09
part is that some people remember
31:12
where I remember how I said
31:14
that Lake Tahoe feeds into Truckee
31:16
Lake, which flows into Pyramid Lake. Sometimes
31:19
people who have drowned in
31:21
Pyramid Lake end up being
31:23
found in Lake Tahoe. Like
31:26
their remains made it. Reverse.
31:28
Up river. Up river. Weird.
31:30
Which means that the river
31:32
must have like flowed backwards
31:34
somehow. Or it was an
31:36
army of underwater babies. Or
31:39
a singular pissed off
31:42
mermaid. I can't even wrap
31:44
my head around that.
31:46
Isn't that gross? That's so
31:48
weird. Yeah. Oh. Yeah.
31:50
No. Like, it's weird. It's a
31:52
weird, weird place. That really creeps
31:54
me out. I know. That really
31:56
fucking creeps me out. That's one
31:58
of the creepiest things I've heard
32:00
in a long time. And you're
32:02
my best friend, so that's saying
32:04
a lot. The
32:07
fuck? And, like, it wasn't just
32:09
one. It's been, like, several. And also,
32:11
like, stories of people. Like,
32:13
it's not just a one -off. No.
32:17
Next. Absolutely not. All right.
32:19
So we're going back upriver
32:21
to Lake Tahoe, just like
32:23
those bodies. Good God. So
32:26
it is a conifer forest
32:28
around the lake. So conifer
32:30
meaning like pines. We've got
32:32
the Pinus Jeffrey, the Jeffrey
32:34
Pine. Jeffrey Penis. The Pi
32:36
Contorta, the Lodgepole Pine. And
32:39
the Pi Lambertiana. I don't
32:41
know why I'm putting an accent on it. Why
32:43
not? Pi Lambertiana.
32:45
I'm back in Italy. Or
32:47
the sugar pine. But not
32:50
the dusty pea. No dusty
32:52
pea. Okay. Only pea
32:54
contorta. Just trying to figure
32:56
out why Dustin would pick this
32:58
episode if there's no dusty
33:00
pine. I don't remember why they
33:02
picked this episode. I'll go
33:04
back in the email on our
33:06
next break. Figure that out.
33:08
So Lake Tahoe is also the
33:11
only known habitat for the
33:13
ultra rare Rorippa sabumbalata. A
33:15
.K .A. the Lake Tahoe yellowcress.
33:17
It's a bird? It's a
33:19
plant. A plant? She's real cute, too.
33:21
I have a picture of it
33:23
on the drive. Okay. I'll
33:26
bite. Little yellow. It
33:28
looks like a... Oh, that's
33:30
pretty. It's like a
33:32
fern meets a succulent with
33:34
a little yellow bud
33:36
on it. Little yellow blossoms.
33:38
Gorgeous. Yeah, it's like
33:40
a succulent fern. It's really
33:42
cool. only
33:44
grows between the low -water
33:46
mark and the high -water
33:48
mark on the shores of
33:51
Lake Tahoe. Wow. How
33:53
weird. And it's only been
33:55
observed a few dozen
33:57
times. So it's extremely rare,
33:59
a plant. It's extremely
34:01
rare. Wow. That's fucking amazing.
34:04
Mm -hmm. She's part of the
34:06
mustard family. Can you imagine? Meese
34:09
of Colonel Mustard. What? Horticulturists
34:12
must... lose their shit if
34:14
they ever see this fucker
34:16
in real life yeah between
34:18
low water low water and
34:20
high water so you have
34:22
to even right time of
34:24
year time it right right
34:26
time yeah like oh that's
34:28
so bizarre yeah lake tahoe
34:30
is fascinating well these massive
34:32
lake ecosystems are so fucking
34:34
cool and weird and now
34:36
we're way into it after
34:38
having geo on our Oh,
34:40
yeah. That episode of GAC.
34:42
Truly. I bet there's so
34:44
much Spooky Lakes Month Tahoe
34:46
content. Mm -hmm. Mm
34:48
-hmm. I'm in. Yeah.
34:51
Follow Spooky Lakes Month
34:53
Geo, Geosaurus on
34:55
TikTok. Who was named
34:57
because her mom is
34:59
like a geologist, scientist. Which
35:02
cracks me up. I'm
35:05
obsessed. Geo. Geo. Okay, so I
35:07
have some folklore, like an origin
35:10
story, some name origin story for
35:12
you. Okay. This is from a
35:14
1905 edition of Sunset Magazine in
35:16
which a member of the Washoe
35:18
tribe recounts the naming of the
35:21
lake. Okay. So in their stories,
35:23
they had the Ong, O -N -G,
35:25
and this was like a really,
35:27
really fucking big bird. Oh. It
35:29
was described as bigger than the
35:31
house of the white man. Good.
35:34
Its body was like an eagle's
35:36
and its wings were longer than
35:38
the tallest pines. Wow. It also
35:40
said like as it flew by,
35:42
like trees would like bend in
35:45
the wind that the wings made.
35:47
Damn. Quote, their words,
35:49
not mine. Its face was that of
35:51
an Indian, but covered with hard
35:53
scales and its feet were webbed. So
35:55
because it was scaled, it like
35:58
couldn't, their weapons didn't work against it.
36:00
Oh, cool. big bird that they
36:02
couldn't, you know, obviously this was like.
36:05
I've been playing Monster
36:07
Hunter recently and I
36:09
am imagining some adversaries
36:12
that I have had
36:14
to defeat that were
36:16
quite challenging. Some monstrous
36:18
adversaries. Monster Hunter is
36:20
a very hard game. You would hate it. You
36:23
would hate it so much. You
36:25
would want nothing to do with it.
36:28
I already don't. I won't even play
36:30
it by myself. It's not like it's
36:32
scary. It's just genuinely challenging combat. So
36:34
it's the only game that I'm using
36:36
my headset, getting out with my friend
36:38
Aaron, and when I'm like, meet me
36:40
at this rally point because I
36:42
have to defeat this monster, and I
36:45
need your help because I'm a little
36:47
pussy and I can't do it myself. Talk
36:50
on our little mic. Ew,
36:53
what was that gross way you
36:55
talked to each other? Oh,
36:57
no, we just... to make the
36:59
same sound effect as Link from
37:01
Ocarina of Time when he's like
37:03
fighting something. He just goes like. Oh,
37:06
right. So
37:12
I'll be over at Robbie's and like want
37:14
something from Aaron from another room and just
37:16
be like. Robbie
37:18
hates it. I hate it.
37:22
Ew. Gross. Yeah.
37:25
Why'd you go down an octave for the
37:27
last one? Oh, that was him and I
37:29
was the other. Yeah, that was him responding.
37:33
Sick. I'm never talking
37:35
to Aaron ever again. I
37:37
mean, that might be out of
37:39
your control, depending on what voice
37:41
memos I send you later this
37:43
week. Ew. Don't
37:45
make me get perverted revenge.
37:50
Back to the on. So
37:52
its nest was in the middle of
37:54
the lake. In my mind, it's floating
37:56
in the middle of the lake. Right.
37:58
So the waters of the lake come
38:00
out from the nest because they knew
38:02
that there were no real rivers feeding
38:05
it. They just had those mountain streams
38:07
like Wallace. Water has to come from
38:09
somewhere. It's coming from Ong's nest in
38:11
the middle of the lake. So the
38:13
Ong would make the waters rush out
38:15
and then flow back to the nest.
38:18
which I think is like alluding to
38:20
the currents of the lake, where
38:22
the nest would siphon out the food
38:24
for the Ong. So like fish. It
38:27
would splash around the water
38:29
and it would use the
38:31
nest as a sieve to
38:33
get its food from the
38:35
lake. But the Ong's favorite
38:37
was human flesh. Despite
38:39
this, he was described as
38:41
a coward, even though he was
38:44
really big and powerful. Birds
38:47
scare easy. They do.
38:49
So they said he wouldn't ever attack
38:51
two or more people in a group. So
38:53
basically they were like, don't ever go
38:55
out by yourself. Don't ever go
38:57
out on a boat by yourself. No.
39:00
Stay buddy system. So one day the
39:03
chief of the tribe had to choose
39:05
a husband for his daughter, Nona, before
39:07
leaving the lake for the winter. In
39:09
the hills above, a young man named
39:11
Tahoe had been meditating and praying since
39:13
he had no acts of valor to
39:15
recommend him as husband to the chief's
39:17
daughter. So he had a crush on
39:19
the chief's daughter. He basically had nothing
39:21
on his resume. Yeah. I was like,
39:24
OK, I have to do something really
39:26
drastic. Yeah. So as
39:28
he's looking out over the
39:30
lake, who shows up but Ong?
39:32
Oh, no. Young Tahoe
39:34
gets the Ong's attention like,
39:36
hey, over here. Ong
39:38
snatches him up and Ong was going
39:40
to fly up really high and
39:42
then drop him into the nest waters
39:45
so he could come down and
39:47
eat him. But the young
39:49
man, Tahoe, brought a long
39:51
buckskin rope with him and tied
39:53
the Ong's legs together and then
39:55
tied himself to the other end
39:57
so that when Ong tried to
39:59
drop him, he couldn't do it.
40:01
They were tied together. Love
40:03
it. Love There's a struggle and
40:05
then they both. careen
40:08
into the lake. The
40:10
rest of the tribe, while, you know,
40:12
upset about the loss of the young man,
40:14
well, what are you going to do?
40:16
They continue the council to select a husband
40:18
for Nona. Nona's like,
40:20
ah, but I actually really liked
40:22
him. Yeah, that's my boy. So
40:24
she sneaks off, takes a canoe
40:26
out into the lake, saying, Tahoe,
40:28
my darling Tahoe, as she searches
40:30
for the man she loves the
40:32
next morning. Okay, so. I
40:35
pictured this as like the
40:37
end of Moana. Okay. What I
40:39
think the legend says is
40:41
the two lovers arrive back on
40:43
shore riding on one of
40:45
Ong's wings while the other wing
40:47
is being used as a
40:49
sail. Oh, damn. They made a
40:51
boat out of that bird.
40:53
They made a fucking sailboat out
40:55
of Ong's remains. Sick. And
40:57
they just drift up on shore.
40:59
Yes. Tahoe was decided
41:01
that he was a worthy husband
41:03
for Nona. As
41:05
long as Ong's nest remains
41:07
in the lake, the drowned never
41:09
rise in Lake Tahoe. So
41:11
is there something in the center
41:14
of the lake? No. To
41:16
this day? It's just saying like
41:18
as long as Ong's nest
41:20
is still there, then the lake
41:22
will never give up. It's
41:24
dead. The current. But really, in
41:26
actuality, the waters in the
41:28
lake are cold enough that an
41:30
almost perfectly preserved body of
41:33
one of said divers was
41:35
found at a depth
41:37
of 300 feet 17 years
41:39
after they went missing. Damn.
41:44
Pretty preserved. So I think it's
41:46
kind of like Lake Superior where
41:48
it's so cold at a certain
41:50
depth that you're not going anywhere.
41:52
You're down there. Oh, God. Yeah. Nope.
41:56
So Lake Tahoe, fascinating. I definitely want
41:58
to go there someday. Yeah, but I'll
42:00
be staying on shore. I'll dip my
42:02
feet in. Don't go anywhere by yourself.
42:04
You'll get snatched up. That's fair. I'll
42:06
swim to the extent that, like, I
42:08
can still touch. Kind of like how
42:11
I respect the ocean. I'll
42:13
go swimming in the ocean, but not, like,
42:15
open water. I'm not jumping
42:17
off a boat. No. Into Lake Tahoe
42:19
or an ocean. Uh -uh. I wouldn't jump
42:21
off a boat into Lake Superior. I
42:23
mean, I get freaked out jumping off
42:25
a boat in Lake Minnetonka. Yeah. Water's
42:28
just a little too dark. Mm -hmm. It's
42:31
a little too... I feel like I'm jumping
42:33
off a cliff. Yeah, it's a little scary. If
42:35
you think about it too hard, it's not
42:37
great. Okay, so I
42:39
do have a case for us today. Okay.
42:41
It is tied to Lake Tahoe, but not
42:43
really till the end. But this
42:45
is the story of
42:47
the I -5 Strangler. Ooh,
42:50
yuck. And
42:52
a lot of this is from
42:54
Bruce Henderson's book called Trace Evidence,
42:56
The Hunt for an Elusive Serial
42:58
Killer. Okay, drama. Okay, give
43:00
away the ending. Roger
43:02
Reese Kibbe. Was born
43:04
on May 21st, 1939, a
43:07
Gemini in San
43:09
Diego County, California. Not
43:11
a lot known about
43:13
his upbringing, just
43:16
I think because it was,
43:18
you know, the 40s. But
43:20
his mother allegedly was abusive
43:22
and at school he was
43:24
bullied for his stutter. As
43:26
a teenager, he was arrested
43:29
for petty theft and prowling. He
43:31
was observed stealing women's
43:33
bathing suits and stockings.
43:37
Not loving this so far.
43:39
He's a creepy motherfucker. Henderson
43:42
claims in the book that Kibbe
43:44
enjoyed tying himself up with women's
43:46
underwear and cutting the clothes up
43:49
with scissors. There was something about
43:51
cutting the women's clothes with scissors.
43:53
And when? What age were these
43:55
behaviors? Teenager. Yeah, okay.
43:57
I mean, not that
43:59
like... I'm a big fan
44:01
of that in general. No,
44:04
a specific incident was when
44:06
he was, I think, 15. But
44:08
yeah, when you're really there's
44:10
a difference, obviously, between these behaviors
44:12
when you're very young and
44:14
these behaviors as like a consenting
44:16
adult in a, you know,
44:18
trusted relation with some with another
44:21
consenting adults. Like, I don't
44:23
care when you cut up women's
44:25
clothes as long as that's
44:27
like the extent and. everyone is
44:29
consenting and it never escalates
44:31
to anything worse which it definitely
44:33
does yeah but this is
44:35
yeah this is going somewhere scary
44:37
i don't like it okay
44:39
so cutting up the clothes with
44:41
scissors one source said that
44:43
his like criminal record had a
44:45
note in it this is
44:47
when he was 15 about being
44:49
caught trying to bury a
44:51
box filled with stolen cut up
44:54
women's clothing Yikes. All right.
44:56
Cool. Cool, cool, cool, cool, cool,
44:58
cool, cool, cool, cool, cool.
45:00
As an adult, he sold furniture
45:02
as a job and in
45:04
his free time, he enjoyed skydiving.
45:07
What? Which I thought was so random
45:09
for an activity in like the
45:11
60s and 70s, but it is important.
45:13
We will get back to the
45:15
skydiving. Not at all what I thought
45:17
you were going to list as
45:20
like a hobby. It's like another Mad
45:22
Lib case. Yes, seriously. While
45:24
trying to distribute cheeseburgers to the
45:26
homeless. I don't think that episode will
45:28
have come out yet by the
45:30
time this episode comes out. Spoiler. That's
45:32
in the April gag. Teaser. Teaser. Well,
45:36
it was yesterday to me, so.
45:38
Literally, we recorded it yesterday, so it
45:40
is easy to get confused. Yeah.
45:43
Okay, so he settled down and
45:45
married a woman named Harriet,
45:47
who was allegedly very domineering, according
45:50
again to Henderson's book. But
45:52
also like same. Don't marry me
45:54
if you're. Don't marry me
45:56
if you're going to wreck all
45:58
my underwear. Right. I'm
46:00
going to be domineering if I have
46:02
like shapes cut out of my bras
46:04
and stuff. Yeah. And I'm going to
46:07
be pissed. Very domineering. That was like
46:09
the only description of his wife. So
46:12
rude. So rude.
46:14
A newspaper in Stockton also
46:16
reported that his brother was
46:19
a homicide detective. So
46:21
in hindsight, this led people
46:23
to speculate that it's possible that
46:25
he like talked to his
46:27
brother, asked his brother a lot
46:29
of questions about police procedures
46:32
and in particular evidence collection in
46:34
order to learn how to
46:36
cover his tracks. Okay. The activities
46:38
last from 1977 to 1986
46:40
or 87, about a decade, but
46:43
like that particular decade. So
46:45
think of that when we're talking
46:47
about like the evidence. Okay.
46:49
What he might have learned about the
46:51
evidence collection. Okay. Jumping
46:53
forward to September of 1977.
46:56
Best of my love by the emotions is
46:58
at the top of the charts. You got
47:00
the best of my love. You
47:02
got the best of my
47:04
love. Along with the Star
47:07
Wars theme song. Oh, hell
47:09
yeah. 77. What a year.
47:11
My parents graduated high school in
47:13
76. Oh, wow. Yeah, my parents
47:15
were definitely in college. But yeah,
47:17
that would be such a fun
47:19
year. The summer of 77. They
47:21
might have been out of college by
47:23
77. Because they waited a while before
47:25
having my sister. And then five years
47:27
later, they finally got everything they wanted.
47:29
Not me. Finally
47:32
at the jackpot. Finally at the
47:34
jackpot. After slogging through five years
47:36
alone with that nightmare. Just
47:39
kidding. We love you. You're the better of
47:41
the two. Trust me. I
47:43
second that. Trust me. Ashley,
47:45
can we talk more? Okay. Okay.
47:50
Remember when we watched the Vanderpump reunion
47:52
after Scandaball? On Zoom together. The
47:54
three of us on Zoom. That
47:57
was a good time. That was really fun.
47:59
You can talk to her whenever you want. I'm
48:01
sure she'd love it. Probably.
48:03
Who wouldn't? Who wouldn't? Apparently,
48:05
Kibbe was bored at
48:07
this time back in
48:10
September 77. No skydiving
48:12
trips? That wasn't
48:14
fulfilling him anymore. He
48:16
decided to place a fake ad in
48:18
a newspaper, like an employment ad, like looking
48:20
for an employee, know, like a job,
48:22
a job ad. Right, right. In
48:24
order to find a victim
48:27
to assault, 21 -year -old Llewellyn Burley,
48:29
Llewellyn Burley answered the ad.
48:31
Kibbe said that his, oh, my
48:33
office is under construction. Why
48:35
don't we meet in my van?
48:38
Absolutely not. But
48:41
she did. He then drove
48:43
her to Lake Berryessa in Napa
48:45
County, where he raped and
48:47
strangled her before dumping her body
48:50
in a nearby riverbed. No.
48:52
When Llewellyn was reported missing, Kibbe
48:54
was briefly considered a suspect,
48:56
according to the L .A.
48:58
Times. But alas, Llewellyn would
49:01
not be found for another
49:03
30 years. 30 plus. So
49:05
sad. On April 21st, 1986.
49:07
So this is almost a decade
49:09
later. This is like 11
49:11
and a half years later. Okay.
49:13
A woman named Laura Hedick.
49:15
One article said Lori, but more
49:17
of them said Laura. Okay.
49:20
She was also 21 years old.
49:22
She was seen getting into
49:24
the car of a man in
49:26
his 50s, and she was
49:28
never seen again. So Laura would
49:30
sometimes engage in sex work
49:32
due to her addiction issues. Of
49:34
course, that doesn't describe her
49:36
as a full individual person. Right.
49:38
Of course not. But again,
49:40
I don't have a lot of
49:42
information here, especially about the
49:44
women in this case. In
49:46
September of that year, so
49:48
that's like five or six months
49:50
later, her remains were found
49:52
off of I -5, which
49:54
was southeast of Sacramento. She had
49:57
also been raped. Investigators
49:59
noted odd shapes were cut
50:01
out of her tank top before
50:03
it was used to strangle
50:05
her. So he cut up her
50:07
shirt and then killed her
50:09
with it. Uh -huh. The pattern. Laura's
50:12
boyfriend at the time saw the man
50:14
who picked her up and described him
50:16
to the cops so they could make
50:18
a composite sketch. Okay. So they have
50:20
a composite sketch. So like I said,
50:22
that was April 1986. After
50:24
that, things really begin to
50:26
escalate like very quickly, considering
50:28
it was almost 10 years
50:30
between his first known victim
50:32
and this second known. So
50:34
that same year, 1986, in
50:36
July. So this would
50:39
be before Laura's body was discovered. Kibbe
50:41
abducts Barbara Ann Scott, age 29,
50:43
before killing her and dumping her
50:46
body along a stretch of road
50:48
in Contra Costa County. That
50:50
was on July 3rd. On July
50:52
15th, 19 -year -old Stephanie Brown was
50:54
abducted. Her car was found abandoned
50:56
on I -5 and her body
50:58
was found in a drainage ditch. Like
51:02
the other victims, she had
51:04
also been raped and strangled. The
51:06
NBC Sacramento affiliate said that
51:08
portions of her hair had been
51:10
cut with scissors. Oh, so
51:13
this isn't like hair that had
51:15
been like grabbed maybe in
51:17
a struggle. This was like taking
51:19
as a memento cut. It
51:21
was cut. Intentional. Oh,
51:23
no. Yeah. One
51:26
month later on October
51:28
17th, Charmaine Sabra,
51:30
age 26. This
51:32
is so gross. Was
51:34
driving home with her mother when their
51:36
car broke down along I -5. Surprise,
51:39
surprise. What do you know? A good
51:41
Samaritan stops by to help. But oh
51:43
no, he can only take one person
51:45
in his car into town. No.
51:48
Charmaine's remains were not discovered
51:50
for three months. Her
51:52
body showed signs of sexual abuse,
51:54
strangulation, and both her clothing
51:56
and her hair had portions cut.
51:58
Away with scissors. Wow.
52:01
So obviously now people are worried
52:03
there's a serial killer on the
52:05
loose. Because they have a string
52:07
of bodies. Then they were all
52:09
found along I -5. The
52:11
police began to utilize
52:13
undercover female officers to pose
52:15
as broken down motorists. Witness
52:18
statements described the suspect as a
52:20
middle -aged man with a big
52:22
nose. So that kind of went
52:24
into the composite sketch. During
52:26
this dragnet operation, Kibbe actually
52:28
did get stopped on a
52:31
routine traffic violation. But they
52:33
didn't put it together. They
52:35
didn't clock it as him.
52:37
The cops were surprised at
52:39
how much he looked like
52:41
the composite sketch. So
52:43
I have a picture of the composite sketch
52:45
and his mugshot. Oh, my God. This is
52:47
so funny because I also have a side -by
52:49
-side composite and mugshot in my case. It's
52:51
not the same case, but there are similarities. Do
52:54
you see it? The
52:56
jawline, the lips, the nose. That's
53:00
shocking. Uh -huh. Whoa.
53:03
Yeah. I'm kind of surprised
53:05
they missed his mole in
53:07
the composite, but otherwise. Yeah.
53:10
I mean, I don't know who
53:12
else were the witnesses. Sure. Except
53:14
for the boyfriend of Laura. Okay.
53:16
And I think she got into
53:18
his car at night. Okay. So
53:20
she might not have seen it.
53:22
Yeah, it's like, I don't if
53:24
they didn't meet like face to
53:26
face. I
53:28
don't know. But yeah, considering how
53:31
little they had to go
53:33
on from a singular witness testimony
53:35
to make this composite, it's
53:37
very good. Maybe
53:39
Charmaine's mother also would have been able to
53:41
give, you know, because she she was
53:43
with Charmaine when the car broke down
53:45
and Charmaine went with. Sure. She would have
53:48
seen him. Yeah. But
53:50
OK, so I. Different
53:52
sources said different things. So
53:54
either the cops saw him, looked
53:56
at the composite sketch and
53:58
was like, oh, shit. And he
54:00
was driving a similar car
54:03
that matched the witness statements. OK.
54:05
Either they just photographed his
54:07
car and sent him
54:09
on his way or they
54:12
searched his car at
54:14
this point where they found
54:16
nylon parachute cord. Oh, the
54:18
skydiving. Mm hmm. scissors, and
54:21
handcuffs. Oh, it's not looking good
54:23
for you, Kibbe. Either way,
54:25
he was questioned but released without
54:27
charges being filed because they
54:29
just did not have sufficient evidence,
54:31
whether they had just photographed
54:34
the car or if they searched
54:36
the car at this time
54:38
or in the next incident. I
54:41
mean, I guess, but I
54:43
hate that. Before the end
54:45
of 1986, Kibbe would kill
54:47
another woman named Catherine Kelly
54:49
Quinonez, aged 25. Finally,
54:52
in September of 1987, he
54:54
was arrested after he tried to
54:56
abduct a sex worker in
54:58
downtown Sacramento. So this badass fought
55:00
back when he was trying
55:02
to handcuff her and just screamed.
55:05
Good for her. And a
55:07
cop intervened, heard her screaming. And
55:09
after taking him into custody. They
55:11
impounded his car and they found
55:14
evidence which linked him to the
55:16
I -5 killings. So whether they
55:18
searched his car earlier when they
55:20
stopped him for that traffic stop
55:22
or they didn't search it till
55:25
they impounded his car now. They
55:27
eventually found. They eventually found evidence. And
55:30
since they wanted time to gather all the evidence because
55:32
they were like, oh, my God, if this guy is
55:34
responsible for these. Five or
55:36
six other homicides. We need time
55:38
to get all the evidence and
55:40
build all the cases. Sure. So
55:42
in the meantime, they were able
55:44
to get him for battery and
55:46
solicitation for trying to abduct the
55:48
woman in Sacramento, which put him
55:50
behind bars for eight months while
55:52
they could continue their investigation. Damn. He
55:55
was first brought to trial
55:57
for the murder of 17
55:59
-year -old Darcy Frackenpole. Hmm. So
56:01
she was a runaway whose
56:03
body had been found in
56:06
1987 near Lake Tahoe, where
56:08
Kibbe's brother, the homicide investigator,
56:11
lived. Wait. So that's the connection
56:13
to Lake Tahoe. It's kind of
56:15
tenuous. I'm sorry. Wait, did I
56:17
miss that Kibbe's brother was investigating? I
56:20
don't think he was investigating this
56:22
case, but he was a homicide investigator.
56:25
Jesus. Because that's when we
56:27
said, well, in hindsight. Some people think
56:29
that he was able to ask his
56:31
brother about evidence collection. Okay. And that's
56:33
why it took them so long to
56:35
get him. Yep. I
56:38
mean, that is a very
56:40
reasonable speculation. Not
56:42
all of our speculations are reasonable,
56:44
but like... We'll kind of get...
56:46
We'll get to it a little
56:48
bit more. Oh, fuck. Okay. So
56:50
Darcy had been strangled using that
56:52
same type of cord that Kivy
56:54
had been using for skydiving, the
56:56
parachute cord. the fibers of
56:58
which were also linked to
57:00
three other killings. So he used
57:02
the exact same cord. Oh.
57:05
Parachute cord. Oh,
57:07
God. He had
57:09
a literal murder
57:11
kit containing handcuffs
57:13
and a pair
57:15
of his mother's
57:17
scissors, his abusive
57:19
mother's scissors. That's
57:21
what he was using to cut up. happens
57:23
when you don't heal from your trauma? It
57:26
kind of reminded me of you when you
57:28
stole your mom's sewing scissors. Yeah, but I stole
57:30
them because they were cute and their handles
57:32
were like little goose. It was like a little
57:34
goose. Oh, I know. And I wanted to
57:36
try cutting my own bangs. And it was a
57:38
disaster. As long as you're
57:41
not cutting anyone else's bangs. was five.
57:43
I know. His mother's scissors.
57:45
You kind of remind me of this serial killer
57:47
who used his mom's scissors. I didn't say you
57:49
reminded me. I don't think I said that. Meant
57:52
to say this reminds
57:54
me. You remind me
57:56
of a girl that
57:58
I once knew. Anyway.
58:00
In 1991, Kibbe
58:02
is convicted of first degree murder
58:04
and sentenced to 25 to life.
58:07
Everyone is certain that he's the I -5
58:09
strangler at this point. But apparently there
58:11
were like jurisdictional complications and like a
58:13
lack of hard evidence. And it just
58:15
took a while. He also like wasn't
58:18
really talking. It took him a while
58:20
to like. say anything
58:22
about where these where these victims
58:24
were okay okay so here
58:26
is the grossest part according to
58:28
me the prosecutors alleged that
58:30
kibbe would handcuff his victims to
58:32
abduct them he'd wrap duct
58:35
tape all way around their head
58:37
and their mouth to silence
58:39
them oh my god then he
58:41
would do whatever he did
58:43
assault them cut their clothes use
58:45
his parachute cord to strangle
58:47
them sometimes he turned it into
58:50
a garrotte Oh, God. And
58:52
then he would use the scissors
58:54
to cut the tape off
58:56
of their hair so he wasn't
58:58
leaving any tape behind. Tape
59:00
evidence. Because they could
59:03
get fingerprints off of tape. Oh,
59:05
he was thinking more about the
59:07
fingerprints than the actual like. The
59:09
homicide investigator brother. Oh, yeah.
59:11
Wait, what the fuck? I think
59:13
that he knew that they could get
59:15
fingerprints off of things like duct
59:17
tape. so instead of just ripping i
59:19
don't know he used the scissors
59:21
to get the tape off of the
59:23
girl's head totally so the the
59:26
cut hair wasn't even a memento it
59:28
was just uh yeah something that
59:30
happened when he was cutting the tape
59:32
off as part of his mo
59:34
i could have been both but yeah
59:36
isn't that fucking gross that's so
59:38
gross it's all gross but like i
59:40
assumed you meant that like locks
59:42
of hair were cut but that like
59:44
the hair as a whole wasn't
59:46
necessarily super disturbed but yeah if you're
59:48
wrapping the whole there's probably a
59:50
lot of hair that was cut oh
59:52
oh my god because none of
59:55
the articles said like you know like
59:57
a lock of her you know
59:59
like no a chunk of her hair
1:00:01
was cut it just said her
1:00:03
her hair had been cut with scissors
1:00:05
yep oh isn't that nasty i
1:00:07
hate it Okay, so
1:00:09
he's sitting in jail at this point.
1:00:11
Finally, in the 2000s, we get the
1:00:13
technology to analyze DNA evidence. Because
1:00:15
remember, I think all of these
1:00:17
women were sexually assaulted. In
1:00:20
2008, Kibbe was indicted on
1:00:22
six counts of murder and
1:00:24
multiple special circumstances. Meaning
1:00:26
there was evidence of him doing
1:00:29
something extra fucked up that would like
1:00:31
amp up the sentence. Do you
1:00:33
know what I'm saying? Pile
1:00:36
on those charges, bitch. So
1:00:38
he got one special circumstance
1:00:40
for each victim, which made
1:00:42
him eligible for the death
1:00:44
penalty. On September 29th, 2009,
1:00:46
he pled guilty to the
1:00:48
rape and murders of Llewellyn
1:00:50
Burley, Laura Hedick, Barbara Ann
1:00:52
Scott, Stephanie Brown, Charmaine
1:00:54
Smith, and Catherine Kelly Quinonez.
1:00:56
Damn. This plea, as well
1:00:58
as agreeing to lead investigators
1:01:00
to his first victim, Llewellyn,
1:01:02
was enough to keep the
1:01:05
death penalty off the table. So
1:01:08
he did bring them to like
1:01:10
a it was like a site
1:01:12
near like a river. Yeah. He's
1:01:14
just to save his own ass
1:01:16
from the death penalty. But they
1:01:18
didn't find anything. And then like
1:01:20
two years later, they brought him
1:01:22
back there. They again didn't find
1:01:24
anything. Two years after that, an
1:01:26
investigator went back to that site
1:01:28
by himself and ended up finding
1:01:31
finding. a bone that belonged to
1:01:33
her damn so she really was
1:01:35
where he said she was right
1:01:37
they just didn't find her they
1:01:39
just didn't find her those two
1:01:41
times where kibby was with the
1:01:43
investigators it was another person who
1:01:45
went like you know off the
1:01:47
clock or whatever yeah and when
1:01:49
you think about it her her
1:01:51
remains had been out there for
1:01:53
so long animals the elements like
1:01:56
because that was in 70s Yeah.
1:01:58
And this was in 2011. It's not
1:02:00
not about to do that math. It's not
1:02:02
unbelievable to think that he would give
1:02:05
the right location, but that they wouldn't find
1:02:07
anything there for a long time. I'm
1:02:09
glad that they eventually fucking did. Mm
1:02:11
hmm. Oh, God. These poor
1:02:13
women. Here's the best part.
1:02:15
In March of 2021, Kibbe was
1:02:17
found unresponsive in his jail
1:02:19
cell. Bye. Medical
1:02:21
staff immediately responded. He was transported to
1:02:23
the prison's health care facility, and
1:02:25
despite life -saving measures, he was pronounced
1:02:28
dead at 1 .20 a .m. An
1:02:30
investigation led to his cellmate,
1:02:32
Jason Boudreaux, himself a convicted
1:02:34
killer and a Satanist. Not
1:02:36
that that matters. And he
1:02:39
was charged with murder in
1:02:41
Kibbe's death. Guess how he
1:02:43
killed him? Well... were
1:02:45
cellmates, so they probably didn't have
1:02:47
a whole lot of access to
1:02:49
stuff, but I'm going to lean
1:02:51
into irony and say he tore
1:02:53
up parts of his clothes or
1:02:55
something and choked him. Well, he
1:02:57
strangled him to death. Okay. But
1:02:59
given the fact that he was
1:03:01
called the I -5 Strangler and
1:03:03
he killed at least seven women,
1:03:05
six or seven women by strangling
1:03:07
them. You know? Seems like a,
1:03:10
you know. It's fitting. Not that
1:03:12
I condone, you know, whatever, blah,
1:03:14
blah, blah, blah, blah. Seems like
1:03:16
a fitting end for this fucking
1:03:18
asshole. It's fucking fitting. All
1:03:20
right. That's the I -5 Strangler.
1:03:22
Damn. What a turd. little
1:03:24
bit about Lake Tahoe. Lake Tahoe. I want
1:03:26
to go real bad. I do too.
1:03:28
I want to go to Pyramid Lake. Oh,
1:03:30
well, let's take a break to hear
1:03:32
a word from our sponsors, the sponsors that
1:03:34
we need so that one day we
1:03:36
can go to Lake Tahoe and Pyramid Lake.
1:03:39
Also join us on Uncorked. That would also
1:03:41
help us get there. Shopping
1:03:45
can be a nightmare. The
1:03:47
lighting in those dressing rooms is
1:03:49
a targeted attack. It's a
1:03:51
paid actor and it's offensive and
1:03:53
I want her fired. I
1:03:55
want her offset immediately. And this
1:03:58
is why I am so
1:04:00
in love with Stitch Fix online
1:04:02
personal styling. It makes it
1:04:04
so easy. Shopping and figuring
1:04:06
out your style. It's overwhelming.
1:04:08
It just is. And I, when
1:04:10
I panic, if I'm at the
1:04:12
store, I just go to all
1:04:14
the black items. My whole closet
1:04:16
is black. Yep. And I'm trying
1:04:18
to really branch out like very
1:04:21
intentionally this year. And look, I'm
1:04:23
wearing gray right now. Obsessed. I
1:04:25
just need more color. And I told
1:04:28
my stylist this and they're sending me.
1:04:30
the cutest stuff that's still like kind
1:04:32
of boxy and shapeless the way that
1:04:34
I like my clothes but it's like
1:04:36
fun patterns new styles when it comes
1:04:38
to getting dressed I get these pieces
1:04:40
from my stylist. They make me look
1:04:42
great. It's a real confidence boost. So
1:04:45
I just give my stylist my size,
1:04:47
my style, my budget preferences. And I
1:04:49
can order boxes when I want and
1:04:51
how I want with no subscription required.
1:04:53
And then she just sends just for
1:04:55
me pieces, plus outfit recommendations and styling
1:04:57
tips. I really love the little pamphlet
1:04:59
that comes with it. I do too.
1:05:02
It's so helpful and cute. I know.
1:05:04
Even if it's like, yeah, dummy, you
1:05:06
wear this with a pair of jeans
1:05:08
and some. loafers and
1:05:10
a cute little bag. It's
1:05:12
like genius. Genius. It's just
1:05:14
really fun to look at and
1:05:16
it just feels so individual to
1:05:18
me. I keep what
1:05:20
I love. I send back the rest. It
1:05:23
could not be easier. My stylist sends
1:05:25
personalized pieces and the fit is flawless. I
1:05:27
know I've said this before. The only
1:05:29
jeans I wear. Same. Two pairs,
1:05:31
both from Stitch Fix. I'll never go back.
1:05:33
I have like six pairs of Stitch Fix
1:05:35
jeans now. And yeah, same. Never go back.
1:05:37
Never go back. I don't know how they
1:05:39
do it, but they do it. It's like
1:05:41
having my own personal style support person. Emotional
1:05:44
support stylist. So no stores, no
1:05:46
crowds, no stress. Just personalized looks you're
1:05:48
going to love. Stitch Fix makes
1:05:50
it all so easy. Personal
1:05:52
styling for everyone. Get started
1:05:54
today at stitchfix.com slash
1:05:56
wine and crime. That's stitchfix.com
1:05:58
slash wine and crime. This
1:06:01
episode of Wine and Crime
1:06:03
is brought to you by Graza,
1:06:05
my new favorite olive oil.
1:06:08
It's fresh, it's never blended, and
1:06:10
it comes from a single
1:06:12
type of olive, the Piquel, straight
1:06:14
out of high -end Spain, where
1:06:16
over half of the world's
1:06:18
olive oil is produced. Listen, high
1:06:20
-end is high -end, because this
1:06:22
olive oil is, like, the best
1:06:24
in the world. It is
1:06:26
just single origin goodness. It's made
1:06:28
with only one olive from
1:06:31
one region. There's no mystery blends.
1:06:33
That means a traceable, fresher
1:06:35
product without mixing in any lower
1:06:37
grade or mystery oils. It's
1:06:39
pure, people. No more messy
1:06:41
tins or drippy spouts. Just aim
1:06:43
that cute little squeeze bottle
1:06:46
and spray it right in your
1:06:48
hot pan and go from
1:06:50
there. The trio has
1:06:52
three types of olive oil for
1:06:54
any task. They have the frizzle,
1:06:56
which is their newest one. It
1:06:58
has a higher smoke point of
1:07:00
490 degrees Fahrenheit. So this is
1:07:02
perfect for like frying, crisping or
1:07:05
grilling. If you are the type
1:07:07
to set off your smoke alarm
1:07:09
in the kitchen with regularity. Are
1:07:11
you speaking to me? Yes, I
1:07:13
am speaking to you. I see you. The
1:07:16
frizzle might just be exactly what you
1:07:18
need. It's not going to, like, blow
1:07:23
up your whole spot. Yeah.
1:07:25
Concerns from the neighbors have decreased
1:07:27
considerably since switching to frizzle
1:07:29
to cook. I should get my
1:07:31
neighbors this trio because their
1:07:33
smoke alarm goes off kind of
1:07:35
a lot when they're cooking.
1:07:37
And I always text. I just
1:07:39
said, King, are you good?
1:07:41
Making a roast? They
1:07:45
also have their sizzle oil. So
1:07:47
this has a 410 degree smoke
1:07:49
point. So this is your everyday
1:07:51
cooking oil for roasting, marinating, and
1:07:53
sauteing. And then... my favorite, the
1:07:55
drizzle. It's this bold, punchy finishing
1:07:57
oil you can sprinkle on salads.
1:07:59
You can put it on ice
1:08:01
cream. Dip your bread in it.
1:08:04
This is like your table olive
1:08:06
oil. That's just absolutely delicious. So
1:08:08
you get 10 % on your
1:08:10
first order on Graz's site, but
1:08:12
I personally suggest grabbing that trio
1:08:14
that I told you about. That's
1:08:16
all three squeezy bottles. You got
1:08:18
your sizzle, your frizzle, and your
1:08:20
drizzle. So you are set for
1:08:22
every style of cooking. So
1:08:24
head to Graza .co and use
1:08:26
code GALS to get 10 %
1:08:29
off TRIO, which includes sizzle, frizzle,
1:08:31
and drizzle, and get cooking
1:08:33
your next chef -quality meal. A
1:08:35
good book is great, but
1:08:37
what if you had an
1:08:39
endless library of delicious romance
1:08:42
at your fingertips? With
1:08:44
Galatea, you don't just read. You
1:08:46
get swept away in every stolen
1:08:48
glance and every heart -pounding touch
1:08:50
you just can't stop thinking about.
1:08:52
Whatever kind of love story you
1:08:55
crave, you'll find it on Galatea.
1:08:57
Galatea is a reading app where
1:08:59
anyone craving a little me time
1:09:01
can dive into a library of
1:09:03
romance stories that leave you feeling
1:09:05
recharged and fulfilled. There are
1:09:07
over a thousand bestsellers to choose
1:09:10
from shifter romance to bad
1:09:12
boy billionaires, forbidden love, werewolf alphas,
1:09:14
slow burn fantasy, teen drama,
1:09:16
and much, much more. Galatea is
1:09:18
home to original series and
1:09:20
standalone stories with an exclusive catalog
1:09:22
of bestselling authors with new
1:09:25
chapters. dropping daily, babes. So there
1:09:27
is always something new to
1:09:29
explore. If you are like ravenous
1:09:31
for the literature, Galatea is
1:09:33
your girl. She's your gal. Over
1:09:35
30 million people have fallen
1:09:37
in love with reading on Galatea.
1:09:40
So join now to indulge
1:09:42
in stories that make you feel
1:09:44
like yourself again. Right now,
1:09:46
Galatea is offering our listeners an
1:09:48
extra 25 % off on top
1:09:50
of an already irresistibly affordable
1:09:52
subscription when you go to galatea.com
1:09:55
slash gals. That's G -A -L -A
1:09:57
-T -E -A dot com slash gals
1:09:59
to indulge in unlimited stories
1:10:01
for even less. Galatea dot com
1:10:03
slash gals. My
1:10:06
case is also really sad and
1:10:08
there are a lot of similarities
1:10:10
and it's from the 70s. It's
1:10:12
not the same, but it's kind
1:10:14
of crazy. Great. It's kind of
1:10:16
crazy. How that panned out. Today,
1:10:18
I'm going to be taking you
1:10:20
back to 1970s Lake Tahoe and.
1:10:23
The story of the brutal murders of
1:10:25
two young women, Bryn
1:10:27
Rainey and Carol Anderson. For
1:10:30
decades, their families lived with unanswered
1:10:32
questions and their cases were just
1:10:34
getting colder and colder with each
1:10:36
passing year. There was definitely long
1:10:38
stretches of time when these families
1:10:40
likely assumed that they would never
1:10:42
know exactly what happened to their
1:10:44
children. So they knew they were
1:10:46
dead. They were found dead, but
1:10:49
they didn't know what happened. Correct.
1:10:52
Our first story begins in the summer
1:10:54
of 1977. Bryn Rainey,
1:10:56
a 27 -year -old originally from Ohio,
1:10:58
had recently moved to South Lake Tahoe
1:11:00
after falling in love with the
1:11:02
area while attending a family wedding there.
1:11:04
How cute is that? She
1:11:06
just loved it. just loved it. Drawn to
1:11:08
the beauty of the lake, she took a
1:11:11
job in that area as a Keno runner
1:11:13
at the Sahara Tahoe Casino in Stateline, Nevada.
1:11:15
And Keno is a lottery game that I,
1:11:17
like, I guess it's kind of like a
1:11:19
card game, but also kind of like bingo.
1:11:21
I could not for the life of me
1:11:23
figure it out. So if you want to
1:11:25
know more about that game, I am not
1:11:27
the one. Okay, listeners. I think it's, I
1:11:29
get it confused with Plinko. Yeah,
1:11:32
I mean, there's like a little card and
1:11:34
then there's like. You can play it on
1:11:36
like the big video screen. Yeah. Yeah,
1:11:39
I I couldn't figure it out
1:11:41
and I lost interest in trying
1:11:43
to understand it. I'm sorry, but
1:11:45
she was into it and she
1:11:47
worked at the casino like running
1:11:49
Kino. Okay. On the evening
1:11:51
of July 23rd, 1977, Brynn
1:11:53
had some spare time before her 2
1:11:55
a .m. shift because the casino is
1:11:57
open 24 hours. So people are on.
1:11:59
Shifts that wouldn't seem normal to us,
1:12:01
but that's normal for her. Imagine starting
1:12:03
work at 2 a .m. Girl, my body
1:12:05
could never, but, like, good for her.
1:12:07
Good for her. So she probably just
1:12:09
was like, all right, well, I'm awake.
1:12:11
I don't work till 2 a .m.
1:12:13
I'm going to go grab a drink
1:12:15
at the Bitter Creek Saloon before work.
1:12:17
The bartender later recalled seeing her that
1:12:19
night and noted that no one seemed
1:12:22
to bother her. No one even saw
1:12:24
her leave. Like, she was there. She
1:12:26
kept to herself. She had a drink
1:12:28
or two. It's she seemingly
1:12:30
just left of her own accord. We didn't
1:12:32
see anybody specifically with her or like trying
1:12:34
to lure her out or harassing her or
1:12:36
anything like that. Seems like a good thing.
1:12:38
It's a very good thing. But then Bryn
1:12:40
didn't show up for that 2 a .m.
1:12:42
shift. And her co -workers were
1:12:44
the first to notice her absence because she was
1:12:46
like always on time, such a good employee. And
1:12:49
fortunately, they tried to get in
1:12:51
touch with her and couldn't and cared
1:12:53
enough to call the police. And
1:12:56
have like a wellness check done on
1:12:58
her apartment. When authorities checked her
1:13:00
apartment on Emerald Bay Road in South
1:13:02
Lake Tahoe, they found the apartment
1:13:04
empty and nothing disturbed. It was like
1:13:06
Brynn had just vanished into thin
1:13:08
air. Or like left for work. Yeah,
1:13:10
but like left for work but
1:13:12
never made it to work. Had been
1:13:14
seen, clearly had been in her
1:13:16
apartment at some point, but it was
1:13:19
perfectly clean. Didn't pack anything. Last
1:13:21
place anybody else saw her was at
1:13:23
the bar and there was... weird
1:13:25
that happened at the bar. She quietly
1:13:27
had a drink and then she
1:13:29
left and then poof, she's gone. Never
1:13:31
makes it to work. For
1:13:33
nearly a month, she was
1:13:35
missing and they were family, friends,
1:13:37
authorities were looking for her.
1:13:40
I just can't imagine the constant
1:13:42
literal heartache of having a
1:13:44
loved one missing. No. The not
1:13:46
knowing is a kind of
1:13:48
hell that I can't even fathom.
1:13:50
I know. I think about
1:13:53
it every time we talk about
1:13:55
someone who's just, especially someone's
1:13:57
child is just missing. Yeah. I
1:13:59
can't, don't want to wrap
1:14:01
my head around that. No. Then
1:14:03
on August 20th, 1977, a
1:14:05
horseback rider at Stateline Stables made
1:14:08
a grim discovery. Oh, I
1:14:10
hate a grim discovery. I know.
1:14:12
A shallow grave along the
1:14:14
trails that they were riding. In
1:14:17
the grave, police found Bryn's
1:14:19
badly decomposed body. Her purse was
1:14:21
still there. Containing her identification.
1:14:23
It was buried nearby, but it
1:14:25
was like on the site.
1:14:27
You know, it did it. It
1:14:30
indicated that it wasn't like a
1:14:32
robbery. How did how did horseback
1:14:34
riders find a shallow grave? I
1:14:36
think it was just a foot
1:14:38
was sticking out. I think it
1:14:41
was very shallow and just very
1:14:43
obvious that like something was off.
1:14:45
It was haphazard to say the
1:14:47
least. OK. While
1:14:49
the extent of decomposition made it
1:14:52
difficult to determine the official cause
1:14:54
of death, because it would have
1:14:56
been August in this area, so
1:14:58
it's not cold. Yeah.
1:15:01
And she's in a very shallow grave
1:15:03
where I think she was exposed
1:15:05
to the elements, possibly animals, like... There's
1:15:07
animals around. For sure. So this
1:15:09
all made it difficult to determine the
1:15:11
official cause of death, but forensic
1:15:13
evidence suggested that Brynn had been sexually
1:15:16
assaulted and strangled. There was not
1:15:18
a lot of evidence at the scene.
1:15:20
They collected everything that they felt
1:15:22
was important at that time. You know,
1:15:24
they did the autopsy. They determined,
1:15:26
like, we can't be 100 % sure,
1:15:28
but we're pretty confident her cause of
1:15:30
death was strangulation. They were able
1:15:33
to find in some of the, like,
1:15:35
tissue that was left at the
1:15:37
arms and legs that there were possible
1:15:39
ligature marks. But again, it's like,
1:15:41
we're not 100 % sure, but it
1:15:43
could be this. If all
1:15:45
that... tissue is gone
1:15:47
or going away. Yeah.
1:15:50
It always kind of shocks
1:15:52
me how forensic pathologists
1:15:55
and coroners can kind even
1:15:57
get what they do
1:15:59
get. Yeah. Yeah. That
1:16:01
book Autopsy that I read by
1:16:03
that Australian dude, when I told
1:16:05
you about the death because you
1:16:07
move your neck wrong. Yeah, thanks.
1:16:11
It's like eagle neck syndrome or
1:16:13
something. No.
1:16:16
Him just going through the autopsies
1:16:18
of these various crazy deaths.
1:16:20
He's like, I noticed X, Y,
1:16:23
and Z. I'm like, how? That
1:16:25
training is really
1:16:27
important. remarkable. It is
1:16:30
remarkable. So good. So they don't
1:16:32
have a ton of evidence.
1:16:34
They don't have any witnesses. And
1:16:36
Bryn's case quickly goes cold.
1:16:38
Two years later, in the summer
1:16:40
of 1979, tragedy struck again.
1:16:42
16 -year -old Carol Ann Anderson lived
1:16:44
in Stateline, Nevada. On
1:16:46
June 30th, 1979, she went to a
1:16:48
house party near the Heavenly Ski
1:16:50
Resort. According to a 2015 news article,
1:16:52
Carol's sister mentioned that the teenager
1:16:55
had epilepsy and that her mother rarely
1:16:57
allowed her to go out because
1:16:59
of her condition, which to me, I
1:17:01
think, alludes to the possibility that
1:17:03
Carol snuck out. She's 16. She wants
1:17:05
to go do teenager things like
1:17:07
knowing her mom would likely say no.
1:17:09
This could easily have been any
1:17:11
of us at that age. We literally
1:17:13
did do this. Yeah. So
1:17:16
my first thought was hereditary when
1:17:18
the mom makes the brother take the
1:17:20
little sister, but she has like
1:17:22
this crazy nut allergy. Yeah. No, as
1:17:24
far as I know, Carolyn's sister
1:17:26
wasn't at the party. Okay. But that
1:17:28
Carolyn had just commented like, yeah,
1:17:30
she went to the party. Our mom
1:17:32
almost never let like anyone go
1:17:35
out. or never let her go out
1:17:37
because of her epilepsy. Mm -hmm. It
1:17:39
just triggered the hereditary. A thousand
1:17:41
percent. A thousand percent. So she
1:17:43
goes to the party, and as the night
1:17:45
wore on, Carol's friends left the party one
1:17:47
by one, each offering her a ride home,
1:17:49
which she declined. She wanted to stay and
1:17:51
make the most of a rare night out.
1:17:53
It's like, especially if she snuck out, it's
1:17:55
like, I'm going to get in trouble. I'm
1:17:57
making every minute count. Absolutely. The
1:17:59
last time anyone remembers seeing Carol
1:18:01
was around 1130 p .m., still at
1:18:03
the party. Police believe she likely left
1:18:05
the party on foot alone and
1:18:07
perhaps hitched a ride with a stranger,
1:18:09
which was a common practice for
1:18:12
teenagers in the 1970s, as we know
1:18:14
from the hitchhiking episode and many,
1:18:16
many times that's come up. Mm
1:18:18
-hmm. The following morning, someone
1:18:20
called the police to report finding
1:18:22
a body on Sundown Trail. Now,
1:18:24
this... read a couple things that -
1:18:26
Sundown Trail. I know, kind of
1:18:28
scary. But Sundown Trail, I think,
1:18:30
was like a side road because
1:18:33
another report said that she was
1:18:35
spotted by a passing motorist. So
1:18:37
I don't think this was a
1:18:39
hiking trail, kind of like the
1:18:41
horseback riding thing. This was clearly
1:18:43
- A road. But like this
1:18:45
area where she was found, it
1:18:48
wasn't exactly bustling, but it was
1:18:50
clear that he wasn't trying to
1:18:52
hide her. Okay. So that's like,
1:18:54
that's the distinction that I, that
1:18:56
I'm making from Bryn's site of
1:18:58
discovery and Carol's site of discovery.
1:19:00
Got it. The manner of her
1:19:03
death. Oh, sorry. It says, unlike
1:19:05
Bryn, no attempt had been made
1:19:07
to conceal Carol's body. So she
1:19:09
wasn't even in a shallow grave.
1:19:11
She was just like dropped there.
1:19:13
Passed out of the car. Possibly.
1:19:15
Or, you know, like,
1:19:18
yeah, I'm not sure. Because even
1:19:20
these crime scenes, like, because it
1:19:22
wasn't. Because there wasn't like blood
1:19:24
because they were strangled. They may
1:19:26
have been killed there. They may
1:19:28
have been killed somewhere else and
1:19:30
then left there. We're not sure.
1:19:32
We still don't know. The manner
1:19:34
of her death, Carol's death, bore
1:19:36
a chilling similarity to Brynn's death,
1:19:38
despite the fact that Carol wasn't
1:19:40
buried the way that Brynn was.
1:19:42
Ligature marks on Carol's wrists indicated
1:19:44
she'd been bound. And like Brynn,
1:19:46
Carol had been strangled and there
1:19:49
was evidence of sexual assault. though
1:19:51
Carol was fully clothed when her
1:19:53
remains were found. I don't know
1:19:55
exactly what the state of Bryn's
1:19:57
dress or undress was. I didn't
1:19:59
see that in what I read,
1:20:01
just that her remains were badly
1:20:03
decomposed. I also
1:20:05
saw that both of the
1:20:07
young women were considered like,
1:20:09
quote unquote, brutally beaten. So
1:20:11
they definitely sustained a lot
1:20:13
of injuries that whether or
1:20:15
not the decomposition had been were
1:20:18
still able to be picked up
1:20:20
like on Bryn's autopsy. But I don't
1:20:23
think Carol was because she was
1:20:25
so haphazardly left. I don't think she
1:20:27
was dead for nearly as long
1:20:29
as Bryn because it was like weeks
1:20:31
before Bryn was found. I think
1:20:33
Carol was found pretty soon after it
1:20:35
happened. So they were able to
1:20:37
actually get more, you know, quote unquote
1:20:40
evidence or at least of what
1:20:42
happened to her off of her actual
1:20:44
body. Yeah. A newspaper report at
1:20:46
the time suggested that police were looking
1:20:48
for two suspects. I'm
1:20:50
not sure why they thought it might
1:20:52
have been two. I don't think
1:20:54
they knew right away that these cases
1:20:56
were connected and that they noticed
1:20:58
that they were similar. But they I
1:21:00
don't think had at that point
1:21:02
wrapped their heads around the fact that,
1:21:04
yeah, it's in a very similar
1:21:07
area. It's probably the same guy. They're
1:21:09
like, oh, these two different attacks.
1:21:11
This is so weird. But. Still no
1:21:13
leads were found in Carol's case
1:21:15
either. So neither Carol or Bryn's cases,
1:21:17
despite, you know, being a couple
1:21:19
of years apart in a similar fashion
1:21:21
in a similar area. We just,
1:21:23
nobody was coming forward. Nobody saw anything.
1:21:25
Nobody knew what the fuck was
1:21:27
going on. And then Carol's case also
1:21:29
went cold. So for decades, both
1:21:31
Bryn and Carol's families mourned unaware of
1:21:33
the connection that would eventually link
1:21:35
their murders. Like they didn't even know.
1:21:38
Nobody connected them? I don't
1:21:40
think so. Not at this
1:21:42
time. Jesus. They just, again, it's
1:21:44
like that two suspects thing. They weren't
1:21:47
looking for two suspects each in the same
1:21:49
attack. They were looking for like two
1:21:51
different suspects in two different attacks. I don't
1:21:53
think that they thought at all that
1:21:55
they were connected. So
1:21:57
for over four decades, over
1:21:59
40 years, the murders
1:22:01
of Bryn Rainey and Carol
1:22:03
Anderson remained unsolved mysteries. And
1:22:06
as I was reading about these
1:22:08
girls, It just this cases like
1:22:10
this and this particular case like
1:22:13
really makes me wonder and try
1:22:15
to look deeper at what investigators
1:22:17
are doing in these long stretches
1:22:19
of cold cases. And the reality
1:22:21
is not that much, which is
1:22:23
why there's so little for me
1:22:25
to report on from that 40
1:22:27
year plus stretch of time from
1:22:29
when this happened and when we
1:22:32
found out who did it. Yeah.
1:22:34
And as much as we
1:22:36
have opinions about police. I'm about
1:22:39
to get to it. When
1:22:41
it comes to cold cases, in
1:22:43
a lot of cases, they
1:22:45
know that the technology to advance
1:22:47
something is coming down the
1:22:49
turnpike. It's definitely yet. I mean,
1:22:52
it's definitely a yes and
1:22:54
situation. That is certainly a factor.
1:22:56
Lack of evidence is certainly
1:22:58
a factor. But like this made
1:23:00
me want to look into
1:23:02
this. So I did. Because,
1:23:05
you know, I'm not one to
1:23:07
give the justice system a pass at
1:23:09
any point, even when I am.
1:23:11
I can also hold the truth that
1:23:13
some of these cases do not
1:23:15
have enough for a determination to be
1:23:17
made. I do understand that. But
1:23:19
it is another angle of the structure
1:23:21
of police funding that begs to
1:23:23
be scrutinized and reevaluated, because even like
1:23:25
today, we're sitting on mountains of
1:23:27
evidence that just hasn't been tested because
1:23:29
we don't have the resources for
1:23:31
it. The backlog. Yeah. So
1:23:33
while, of course, the advancements we
1:23:35
have now weren't available during this
1:23:37
investigation, a lot of cold cases
1:23:40
stay cold because resources are reallocated
1:23:42
to new cases that have more
1:23:44
evidence and cold cases have very
1:23:46
little hope of being reopened until
1:23:48
compelling new evidence arises to put
1:23:50
resources back on that case. Yeah.
1:23:52
And they're just sitting in a
1:23:55
folder or whatever. And as. The
1:23:57
victims' families, even in some of
1:23:59
these cases, literally die and there's
1:24:01
no one left advocating for them.
1:24:03
They're just collecting dust, even when
1:24:05
there is new technology. So, like,
1:24:07
if we reallocated resources to more
1:24:09
cold cases, what evidence could, A,
1:24:12
be uncovered if investigators were actually
1:24:14
tasked to keep investigating rather than
1:24:16
wait for something new to come
1:24:18
across the desk or for some
1:24:20
new technology to emerge? So
1:24:23
that's neither here nor there. It's a
1:24:25
frustrating issue that we see time and time
1:24:27
again on this show. It sent me
1:24:29
down a bit of a rabbit hole on
1:24:31
cold cases. I did find a study
1:24:33
from the Council of State Governments Justice Center
1:24:35
that highlighted just how pervasive unsolved cases
1:24:37
are even now in the modern era of
1:24:40
forensic technology. And like that's more of
1:24:42
a resource allocation issue, not we don't have
1:24:44
the technology to solve it. Yeah. So
1:24:46
this said, quote, in 2022, which is when
1:24:48
they completed this study. So obviously there's
1:24:50
probably more data now, but like this was
1:24:52
so recent enough that I found this
1:24:54
really compelling. 63 % of
1:24:56
violent crimes in the United States
1:24:59
that were reported to police went
1:25:01
unsolved. 63%. Of violent
1:25:03
crimes. Of violent crimes. This
1:25:05
means in a single year,
1:25:07
there was no one arrested,
1:25:09
charged, and referred for prosecution
1:25:12
in over 800 ,000 violent
1:25:14
crimes that included an estimated
1:25:16
10 ,000 homicides, 525 ,000 aggravated
1:25:18
assaults, 169 ,000 robberies, and 98
1:25:20
,000 rapes. Oh, my God.
1:25:23
Meanwhile, states that have reallocated
1:25:25
funding and invested in not
1:25:27
only detectives, and I'm not
1:25:29
saying regular cops, I mean
1:25:31
like detectives, legitimate investigators, but
1:25:33
also invested in community involvement
1:25:36
and collaboration have all seen
1:25:38
better outcomes, not in just
1:25:40
solving violent crimes and cold
1:25:42
cases, but preventing these crimes
1:25:44
from happening in the first
1:25:46
place. So like we have
1:25:49
these bloated police budgets in
1:25:51
every state and the data shows
1:25:53
time and time again that
1:25:55
reallocating those budgets because cops really
1:25:57
don't need fucking tanks and
1:25:59
millions in weaponry and tactical gear
1:26:01
has reallocating those kinds of
1:26:03
resources has a very positive impact
1:26:05
on communities and on like
1:26:07
actual solve rates of crime as
1:26:09
well as crime prevention. So
1:26:11
when I just wanted to like.
1:26:13
focus on that for a
1:26:15
fucking second because i feel like
1:26:17
people really bulk and recoil
1:26:19
at the defund the police of
1:26:21
it all and we have
1:26:23
to remember that like the reallocation
1:26:25
of the of the budget
1:26:28
is the main part of what
1:26:30
that means those budgets don't
1:26:32
go up consistently without the outcomes
1:26:34
to back up the need
1:26:36
for that spending because or the
1:26:38
budgets go up sorry consistently
1:26:40
across the united states for police
1:26:42
every year because It
1:26:44
goes into a lot of unnecessary shit
1:26:46
that makes a cop on the
1:26:48
street like a militarized cool guy rather
1:26:50
than pouring it into community programs
1:26:53
that reduce crime and trained investigative teams
1:26:55
that actually solve cases and investing
1:26:57
in the kind of crime labs. Empirical
1:26:59
evidence showing that it does
1:27:01
work. Like crime labs, autopsy, coroner
1:27:03
reports. These are all part
1:27:06
of the justice system that need
1:27:08
funding because we need those
1:27:10
scientists. Those experts that can
1:27:12
look at a decomposed 27 year
1:27:14
old woman and tell us every
1:27:16
fucking possible thing we could possibly
1:27:18
learn to find their killer. I
1:27:20
was so energized after the crime
1:27:22
lab and after our hosts, our
1:27:24
tour guides kind of like gave
1:27:26
us a little like empowerment speech.
1:27:29
They were like, it's the cops
1:27:31
and the bureaucracy and the system
1:27:33
that is preventing us from doing
1:27:35
our job. It's like, you guys
1:27:37
are so fucking cool. You have
1:27:39
all the tools in the world.
1:27:41
They really do. And it's not
1:27:43
to say that there hasn't been
1:27:45
corruption at those levels as well.
1:27:47
Of There absolutely has. But it's
1:27:49
not to the level where people
1:27:52
are marching in the street calling
1:27:54
for the defunding of a coroner,
1:27:56
of their local coroner. Like, there's
1:27:58
a difference. Yes. And
1:28:00
I also think that when
1:28:02
you have these cold case
1:28:04
units, which are, of course,
1:28:06
Crucial, important. But in
1:28:08
a lot of respects, it's
1:28:10
allowing them to cherry pick
1:28:12
the cases that they want
1:28:14
to take and guess which
1:28:17
cases they're not fucking up.
1:28:19
Well, and those cold case
1:28:21
investigators are not even necessarily
1:28:23
part of a dedicated we
1:28:25
focus on cold cases team.
1:28:27
It's usually a task force.
1:28:29
It's not a department. So
1:28:31
it's a task force that
1:28:33
is already extending. the capacity
1:28:35
of investigators that are working on
1:28:37
active scenes that do have more
1:28:39
evidence. Again, it's
1:28:41
that like allocation of resources.
1:28:43
So these cold cases get the
1:28:45
back burner and like, I
1:28:48
get it, but why do we
1:28:50
have these multi -billion dollar police
1:28:52
budgets and we don't infuse
1:28:54
them into departments that could solve
1:28:56
more crimes? literally
1:28:58
raising your numbers that's not even
1:29:00
me saying like just get rid
1:29:02
of it get rid of all
1:29:04
of that it's like could we
1:29:06
actually infuse that with people who
1:29:09
know what the fuck they're doing
1:29:11
and have the proper training to
1:29:13
work with the scientists to work
1:29:15
with the the labs and like
1:29:17
keep these cases important alive yeah
1:29:19
it's just it makes me so
1:29:21
sad and you know numbers are
1:29:23
astounding in a year 98 000
1:29:25
rapes yep And that's only, those
1:29:27
are the 98 ,000 that went
1:29:29
unsolved that had been reported. Been
1:29:31
reported. So can you even fucking
1:29:33
imagine? I'm like, again. 10 ,000 homicides
1:29:35
in a year. In a year.
1:29:37
10 ,000 that had no, no
1:29:40
arrests at all. Jesus Christ. Yeah.
1:29:42
So it's very sad. It's very
1:29:44
frustrating. And, you know, you too
1:29:46
can get involved in your local
1:29:48
ACAB chapter and connect with like
1:29:50
minded people who want to push
1:29:52
for this kind of budget reallocation
1:29:55
on the state level. And that's
1:29:57
where getting involved in local politics
1:29:59
is so important because you can't
1:30:01
really change the like federal fucking
1:30:03
police and defense budget. That's a
1:30:05
much bigger. elephant to
1:30:07
eat one bite at a time but
1:30:09
you can get involved on a local
1:30:11
level where your city council and your
1:30:13
mayor are like working on those budgets
1:30:15
together you can get involved with your
1:30:17
governor a little bit louder when you
1:30:19
when there aren't that many other people
1:30:21
standing with you yeah i don't know
1:30:23
that's just like to think of not
1:30:25
just these women but like all of
1:30:27
these families that we have discussed where
1:30:29
the cases were called for fucking decades
1:30:32
And like you said earlier, thinking about
1:30:34
these people who, yes, they know their
1:30:36
children are now gone, but they don't
1:30:39
know why. They don't know who. They
1:30:41
don't know. Like, they don't know anything.
1:30:43
That's not fucking justice. You might be
1:30:45
able to finally say, OK, I don't
1:30:47
have to look for her anymore. Yeah.
1:30:49
But I don't know how much better
1:30:51
that is. And then you're just another
1:30:53
flavor of excruciating pain. And your cold
1:30:55
case task force is like barely working
1:30:57
on anything. And if these honestly, in
1:30:59
a lot of cases, if these families
1:31:02
aren't the ones advocating. for the continuation
1:31:04
of their children's case. Then no one
1:31:06
is. No one is. And
1:31:08
they get completely left in
1:31:10
the dust. And then when these
1:31:12
tech advancements and forensic advancements
1:31:14
do happen, no one is standing
1:31:16
there going, okay, check my
1:31:18
daughter's file. Check my daughter's evidence.
1:31:21
They just get lost. And
1:31:23
it's fucking devastating. Anyway,
1:31:26
end of the backlog. Not just of
1:31:28
rape kits, but like... shit. Everything. I
1:31:30
know. I know. Which is, I get
1:31:32
it. That's a big undertaking, but doesn't
1:31:34
mean we shouldn't try. It doesn't mean
1:31:36
we can't take one step toward that.
1:31:38
Correct. One single step toward that. Correct. It's
1:31:41
a huge mountain to climb. We'll
1:31:43
probably never get through it all, but
1:31:45
that doesn't mean you can't. Try
1:31:47
to get through some of it. You
1:31:50
can't accomplish something. Yeah. You can't
1:31:52
piece together, back together the lives of
1:31:54
a few people. But you could
1:31:56
even, I don't know, save the lives
1:31:58
of future people. Mmm. Wow,
1:32:00
what a leap. I know, but
1:32:02
that's not what the cops do.
1:32:05
So anyway, decades later, in 2007,
1:32:07
the El Dorado County Sheriff's Office
1:32:09
formed a cold case task force
1:32:11
that re -examined these two murders. The
1:32:13
first significant breaks came in
1:32:15
the years that followed. So, after
1:32:17
2007. Between 2012 and
1:32:20
2013, investigators were able
1:32:22
to obtain male DNA profiles
1:32:24
from evidence in both
1:32:26
cases. Now, I don't know.
1:32:30
Exactly what the DNA
1:32:32
was. They were
1:32:34
like swabs taken from
1:32:36
bodies. One was
1:32:38
blood on a shirt. So
1:32:40
there was a swab taken from
1:32:42
Carol's body during her 1979
1:32:44
autopsy that yielded a male DNA
1:32:46
profile. There was blood from
1:32:48
a shirt that Bryn had been
1:32:50
wearing that also had a
1:32:52
partial profile. I think there was
1:32:54
additional DNA, but the crucial
1:32:56
DNA came from these two things.
1:32:58
I tried to get more
1:33:00
information in Carol's case on what
1:33:02
was swabbed as there had
1:33:04
been evidence or at least the
1:33:06
suggestion of sexual assault in
1:33:08
both cases. It's entirely possible that
1:33:10
this was like a semen
1:33:12
swab. But also keep in mind
1:33:14
that these are small samples
1:33:16
because back in at that time,
1:33:18
we didn't have this technology.
1:33:20
So even though we were like.
1:33:22
oh yeah, we should collect
1:33:24
this because one day that will
1:33:26
be useful. How much is
1:33:28
collected is typically a lot less
1:33:30
in these older cases. And
1:33:33
then they sit in evidence lockers
1:33:35
and they do deteriorate over
1:33:37
time. So it's very exciting when
1:33:39
you find DNA, but it doesn't necessarily
1:33:41
end up being, as we've discussed before,
1:33:43
like the quote unquote smoking gun that
1:33:45
people get. a robust profile. Exactly. It's
1:33:47
like, okay, all we can get off
1:33:49
of this right now is that it's
1:33:51
like a dude with these specific potential
1:33:54
markers. male excreter. These profiles
1:33:56
were uploaded to the Combined
1:33:58
DNA Index System, or CODIS, but
1:34:00
unfortunately no matches were found.
1:34:02
The cases were shelved again until
1:34:04
2017 when the task force
1:34:06
turned to a groundbreaking technique, genetic
1:34:08
genealogy. Ever heard of it?
1:34:10
Yeah, I'm not going to go
1:34:12
over this in too much
1:34:14
detail because we obviously, most of
1:34:16
us know, but in case
1:34:18
you don't, the long and short...
1:34:20
This method goes beyond direct
1:34:22
DNA matches in criminal databases, and
1:34:25
instead, investigators employed a private
1:34:27
company, Paraben Nanolabs, which is a
1:34:29
DNA tech company, to analyze
1:34:31
the DNA evidence beyond what the,
1:34:33
you know, Eldorado Crime Lab
1:34:35
was able to get from those
1:34:37
samples. Paraben used genetic genealogy,
1:34:39
the same process that ultimately identified
1:34:41
the Golden State Killer, to
1:34:43
build a quote -unquote family tree
1:34:45
by comparing the crime scene DNA
1:34:47
to user -submitted DNA kits in
1:34:49
public databases like gedmatch.com or
1:34:51
what's the other one? 23andMe. Ancestry.com.
1:34:53
Ancestry. Like, you can opt
1:34:56
to have those shared so that
1:34:58
you could be contacted in
1:35:00
the event of something exactly like
1:35:02
this. Or just like, oh,
1:35:04
I'm your sixth cousin. Right. Let's
1:35:06
email. Mm -hmm. This process rarely
1:35:08
identifies a suspect directly, but
1:35:10
instead helps narrow down the pool
1:35:12
by finding close genetic relatives.
1:35:14
Through this painstaking process, Paraben was
1:35:16
able to identify three deceased
1:35:18
brothers as potential sources of the
1:35:20
DNA. All three brothers were
1:35:22
deceased? Yes. So they found
1:35:24
these three dead brothers that had
1:35:27
a lot of genetic similarities with what
1:35:29
they were able to get off
1:35:31
of that DNA swab. These three dead
1:35:33
brothers. dead brothers. And they
1:35:35
were like, okay, it's probably one
1:35:37
of these three dead brothers. Let's
1:35:39
look at their descendants. Okay. So
1:35:41
they looked at their descendants, and
1:35:43
this led them to the family
1:35:45
of Joseph Stephen Holt. Holt was
1:35:47
born in the Bay Area in
1:35:49
1947. He graduated from Cupertino High
1:35:51
School and attended UC Berkeley. He
1:35:54
moved to South Lake Tahoe in
1:35:56
1974 and worked in real estate
1:35:58
in the Tahoe area. He
1:36:00
died in 2014 at the age of
1:36:02
66. I'm not exactly sure how he died,
1:36:04
and I don't give enough of a
1:36:06
fuck about him to have checked. I had
1:36:08
already written a lot. I didn't fucking
1:36:10
bother. Bye. Crucially, Holt
1:36:12
lived less than two miles from
1:36:14
where both Bryn and Carol's bodies
1:36:17
were discovered. And as a realtor,
1:36:19
he frequently traveled between San Jose
1:36:21
and South Lake Tahoe. So he
1:36:23
would have been very familiar with
1:36:25
that whole area. Hmm. Weird.
1:36:28
I couldn't find any of those
1:36:30
sound bites that we often see
1:36:32
in cases like these attesting to
1:36:34
his character or how quiet or
1:36:36
affable or what a pillar of
1:36:38
the community he may have been.
1:36:40
I don't know. And I don't
1:36:42
care. But his descendants had no
1:36:44
idea that he had done this
1:36:46
or had this dark past. And
1:36:49
they willingly cooperated. Like his sons were
1:36:51
like, yep, we'll give you anything you
1:36:53
need. They cooperated in his investigation. One
1:36:55
of his sons, oh, we're about to
1:36:57
get to it, so I won't say
1:37:00
that. But they haven't made any public
1:37:02
statements about Joseph. And frankly, I don't
1:37:04
fucking blame them. I like cannot even
1:37:06
imagine. You're pinged out of
1:37:08
the blue by the by an
1:37:10
investigation team that's like, hey, we're checking
1:37:12
these old swabs from two murders
1:37:14
in the 70s. Yeah. Might have been
1:37:16
your dad. It might have been
1:37:18
your dad. And then the DNA matches
1:37:20
and they find out like he
1:37:22
was definitely in the area at that
1:37:25
time. It's like, holy shit. Yeah.
1:37:27
It's really fucking odds of it not
1:37:29
being him are very slim. very
1:37:31
very very very very slim
1:37:33
and i there of course
1:37:35
he's not alive to stand
1:37:38
trial but they're this case
1:37:40
at least for these two
1:37:42
women these two murdered women
1:37:44
it's pretty unequivocally accepted that
1:37:46
he killed them like too
1:37:48
much adds up family interviews
1:37:50
family history there's also some
1:37:52
evidence that they get from
1:37:54
these kids so in 2018
1:37:56
investigators contacted Holt's living family,
1:37:58
including a biological son who
1:38:00
fully cooperated with all of
1:38:03
their inquiry. The son provided
1:38:05
his own DNA and even
1:38:07
an old toothbrush that belonged
1:38:09
to his father, Joseph. Ooh,
1:38:11
creepy. Subsequent DNA
1:38:14
testing confirmed the undeniable link Joseph
1:38:16
Holt's DNA matched the DNA found
1:38:18
on Bryn Rainey's shirt and Carol
1:38:20
Anderson's body. El Dorado County
1:38:22
District Attorney Vern Pearson announced
1:38:24
the identification of Holt as
1:38:26
their suspect on February 25th,
1:38:29
2019. Wow. I
1:38:31
mean, these girls were killed
1:38:33
in 1977 and 1979. And this
1:38:35
man's name is finally being
1:38:37
spoken publicly in 2019. OK,
1:38:39
so your dad is dead.
1:38:42
Yes, he is. Let's go. If
1:38:44
you found yourself in this
1:38:46
exact scenario where you were approached
1:38:48
by investigators and like your
1:38:50
dad has been really definitively linked
1:38:52
to these murders, will you
1:38:54
help us close this case? Wouldn't
1:38:58
a big part of you want to
1:39:00
be like, don't talk about my dad that
1:39:02
way? I think it
1:39:04
would be really hard, but I think
1:39:06
the part of me that cares about
1:39:08
other people would not let me not
1:39:10
cooperate in something like that. And the
1:39:12
work of figuring out how to grapple
1:39:14
with the discovery of what my father
1:39:17
had done is mine and isn't the
1:39:19
fault of those families or those girls
1:39:21
or the people that were still out
1:39:23
here looking for them for the last
1:39:25
40 years. I
1:39:27
think that would be one of
1:39:29
the most impossible and unfathomable things to
1:39:31
be confronted with that you could
1:39:33
ever imagine. And I really
1:39:35
commend this specifically his son for his
1:39:37
willingness to do that, because I can completely
1:39:40
understand the urge to be like, no,
1:39:42
I don't want to know these things. And
1:39:44
I wouldn't I wouldn't I don't want
1:39:46
to help the world confirm these things. No,
1:39:48
I think it would be unbelievably hard,
1:39:50
but I don't think I personally could. could
1:39:52
say no and then like look at
1:39:55
myself in the mirror ever again. I don't
1:39:57
think I could either. I don't think
1:39:59
you could. Especially if he was already dead.
1:40:01
If he was alive, that would be
1:40:03
a lot. I mean, I think
1:40:05
that would be more complicated. Yeah, and
1:40:07
it would be my job in therapy to
1:40:10
figure out how to preserve the things
1:40:12
about my father that I loved and that
1:40:14
were meaningful and the things that I
1:40:16
didn't know. But again,
1:40:19
that's not the response, you know, that's
1:40:21
not the responsibility of these girls
1:40:23
and their families. No. That's my shit.
1:40:25
Let their families get... Some kind
1:40:27
of closure. The way that they've been
1:40:29
feeling for the last, like, fucking
1:40:31
40 years or whatever. It's like... You
1:40:34
can handle it. I can be
1:40:36
up. You can get therapy. He's already
1:40:38
dead. Yeah, he gone. Yeah.
1:40:40
But yeah, no, I mean, I
1:40:42
thought about that too when I was
1:40:44
writing this. I was like, fuck.
1:40:46
I mean, I really feel for his
1:40:48
son. Yeah. And his surviving family. This
1:40:51
would be earth shattering. Your whole
1:40:53
world would change. Yeah. Especially if
1:40:55
you had no fucking inkling that
1:40:57
he was like an asshole. No
1:40:59
clue. And, you know, you have
1:41:01
these ideas of who your parents
1:41:03
are, but also that like earth
1:41:05
shattering sense of self. that would
1:41:07
get completely fucking thrown in the
1:41:09
garbage can because like your parents
1:41:11
and you know for a lot
1:41:13
of people like make you raise
1:41:15
you make you who you are
1:41:17
your entire origin story the
1:41:19
fuck am i if my dad was
1:41:22
a fucking murderer and then you'd have to
1:41:24
think about like how old was i
1:41:26
in 1977 yeah he probably wasn't born but
1:41:28
yeah did he come home and have
1:41:30
dinner with us that night who knows Who
1:41:33
knows? Also, the clove hitch
1:41:35
killer. I think it's on Netflix.
1:41:37
Yeah, it's very it's a
1:41:39
very the vibe is clove hitch
1:41:41
golden state. I mean, clove
1:41:43
hitch isn't real, but, you know,
1:41:45
it's based on BTK. Yeah.
1:41:47
BTK for sure. Similar vibe. So
1:41:51
interestingly, investigators discovered that, quote,
1:41:53
Joseph Holt was never on
1:41:55
the radar prior to the
1:41:57
DNA breakthrough. They had never
1:41:59
even looked at him. As
1:42:01
a suspect, which is frustrating
1:42:04
because of something we're about
1:42:06
to get to. So further
1:42:08
investigation into Holt's remaining personal
1:42:10
effects yielded even more suggestive
1:42:12
evidence. They found a 1975
1:42:14
news clipping about an unsolved
1:42:16
non -fatal shooting in Los
1:42:18
Gatos. The cats. And
1:42:20
there was a sketch produced
1:42:23
by Los Gatos police at the
1:42:25
time of that non -fatal shooting.
1:42:27
That bore a striking resemblance
1:42:29
to a contemporary picture of
1:42:31
Holt. I'm going to the
1:42:33
drive. Yeah. So, so much
1:42:35
so that Holt is now
1:42:37
considered a suspect in that
1:42:39
crime as well. It's
1:42:42
him. Like, I'm sorry.
1:42:45
Someone handed him a
1:42:47
picture. Yeah. And said, draw
1:42:50
this man. And then they
1:42:52
drew him and forgot the bottom
1:42:54
half of his goatee, basically.
1:42:56
Yeah, man. So, you know, that's
1:42:58
another thing that is so
1:43:00
frustrating to read about after the
1:43:02
fact, because it's like if
1:43:04
any of these precincts were in
1:43:06
the habit of sharing information
1:43:08
with each other about some of
1:43:10
the cases or, you know,
1:43:12
whatever, then like maybe Los Gatos,
1:43:14
like this area isn't that
1:43:16
far from where he'd already been
1:43:18
hanging around in the in
1:43:20
the mid 70s. Like if only.
1:43:23
And I know hindsight's 20 -20,
1:43:25
but, like, if only we had
1:43:27
had, or, you know, anyone
1:43:29
in connection with the investigation into
1:43:31
Bryn or Carol's deaths had
1:43:33
had access to that and, like,
1:43:35
other people talking about these
1:43:37
possibilities or whatever. I know it
1:43:39
was, like, a different crime.
1:43:41
It just makes you think about,
1:43:43
like, what could have been.
1:43:45
It's like, that fucking good of
1:43:47
a sketch is sitting connected
1:43:49
to a different crime in a
1:43:51
different precinct. somewhere else and
1:43:53
so it's like it's so close
1:43:55
but it's so far away
1:43:57
so it's like now the police
1:43:59
are still looking into his
1:44:01
past because it's like well fuck
1:44:03
this was probably him the
1:44:05
timeline pans out the sketch is
1:44:07
fucking spot on wildly accurate
1:44:09
it's a photocopy yeah and we
1:44:11
know he was in that
1:44:13
area like what else could he
1:44:15
have gotten up to Mm
1:44:17
hmm. And that's what I always
1:44:19
think about, too. It's like, OK,
1:44:22
you got caught for murdering two women. How
1:44:24
many other people did you abuse and potentially
1:44:26
murder? How many women did you assault? That's
1:44:28
what I want to know. We're going to
1:44:30
get there. I'm almost done. But like, I
1:44:32
have my thoughts on that. And I think
1:44:34
that they are shared. I really think that
1:44:36
you'll feel exactly the same way. So while
1:44:39
Joseph Holt died in 2014 and will never
1:44:41
face trial for the murders of Bryn Rainey
1:44:43
and Carol Anderson. The identification
1:44:45
of him has brought a
1:44:47
measure of closure to their
1:44:49
families after decades of agonizing
1:44:51
uncertainty. Carol's family did
1:44:53
release a public statement saying that through
1:44:55
the hard work and efforts of
1:44:57
the investigators, they were able to give
1:44:59
the family some answers and some
1:45:01
closure. And to ultimately allow Carol Anderson
1:45:03
to rest in peace with the
1:45:05
knowledge of who did this to her.
1:45:07
What guts me is that with
1:45:09
him dead, we'll never know his... for
1:45:12
these murders though it's certainly speculated
1:45:14
that they were acts of sexual
1:45:16
violence it's possible that he had
1:45:18
intended to rape these girls and
1:45:20
things either got out of hand
1:45:22
or he wanted to get away
1:45:24
with it and not leave the
1:45:26
girls alive to implicate him yeah
1:45:28
but like you were just i
1:45:30
think getting to with crimes as
1:45:32
violent and potentially sexually motivated i
1:45:34
mean it seems pretty clear that
1:45:36
they were as these not just
1:45:38
because there's evidence of sexual assault
1:45:40
but a lot of like Tying
1:45:42
up the strangulation, that's all very
1:45:44
closely connected to sexually motivated crime.
1:45:47
It's ritualistic, and you don't
1:45:49
just jump to that. No,
1:45:51
it's highly unlikely these were
1:45:53
his only two victims, even
1:45:55
if they were the only
1:45:58
two that he killed. Yeah. So...
1:46:00
To that end, the El Dorado
1:46:02
County Case Task Force continues its
1:46:04
investigation into Joseph Holt, seeking to
1:46:06
determine if he may be responsible
1:46:08
for other unsolved crimes in the
1:46:10
South Lake Tahoe and San Jose
1:46:12
areas. They're asking for the public's
1:46:15
help in identifying any crimes that
1:46:17
may have been witnessed or if
1:46:19
you know any victims that may
1:46:21
have been associated with Holt. Anyone
1:46:23
with information is urged to contact
1:46:25
the task force. Hotline at 530
1:46:27
-621 - four five nine zero and
1:46:29
there was another article talking about
1:46:31
the this task force and this
1:46:33
case and they put together a
1:46:35
picture of like joseph holt through
1:46:37
the years so that it can
1:46:39
make it a little bit easier
1:46:41
maybe for people from different eras
1:46:43
to be like oh shit yeah
1:46:45
i did see that guy because
1:46:47
he does look kind of different
1:46:50
i mean he has the same
1:46:52
fucking googly eyes he does but
1:46:54
his facial hair his but his
1:46:56
levels of baldness like things do
1:46:58
kind of seem to change a
1:47:00
little over over time but it
1:47:02
sounds like his son or surviving
1:47:04
family provided a lot of these
1:47:06
photos so that if they're they're
1:47:08
what they're still looking into this
1:47:10
dead man to be like what
1:47:12
the fuck else did this guy
1:47:14
do because i think they feel
1:47:16
similarly that that we do where
1:47:18
it's like this is a lot
1:47:20
And now this weird shooting thing
1:47:22
happened over here. And that sketch
1:47:25
is really accurate. And he would
1:47:27
have been there at that time.
1:47:29
We think that was him. What
1:47:31
else might he have done? We
1:47:33
don't know. So
1:47:35
if any of these photos or,
1:47:37
you know, this story or
1:47:39
that region of South Lake Tahoe
1:47:41
or the surrounding area in
1:47:43
that time is like ringing any
1:47:45
bells for you. You got
1:47:48
something weird that never really made
1:47:50
sense or somebody went missing
1:47:52
or someone you know was harassed
1:47:54
or approached by this guy.
1:47:56
Call that fucking task force. Yes.
1:47:58
So that we can really
1:48:00
close the book on this asshole.
1:48:02
Because holy shit. And that's
1:48:04
my case. Well, that sounds great.
1:48:08
Also, I did look up Dusty
1:48:10
P's original email. Yes. They live
1:48:12
about 30 minutes away from the
1:48:14
lake. That makes a lot of
1:48:16
sense. I kind of figured it
1:48:18
was just a geographical location choice,
1:48:20
but you never know. Well, thank
1:48:23
you, Dusty P, for your topic
1:48:25
choice. Seriously, fascinating. Yeah, kind
1:48:27
of dark. Oh, yeah. But I really
1:48:29
want to go to Pyramid Lake. Not
1:48:31
that that's what the episode was about.
1:48:33
Fuck Lake Tahoe. That place is a
1:48:35
hellhole. Well,
1:48:38
people vanish all the time.
1:48:40
I heard that they found a
1:48:42
massive underground nuclear power plant
1:48:44
under Pyramid Lake. Oh! Potentially
1:48:47
built by the Tahoe Sea
1:48:49
Monster. I heard there was a
1:48:51
big scaly bird flying around
1:48:53
using Lake Tahoe as his own
1:48:55
personal whirlpool. Listen, that I'd
1:48:57
believe. Well, the
1:49:00
Ong. The Ong lives. Rest in
1:49:02
peace. The drowned will never be
1:49:04
given up. May your spirit. Continue
1:49:07
to soar with the eagles.
1:49:10
Minus your wings because they were
1:49:12
used as a sailboat. Oops. My
1:49:14
bad. That was rough. Anyway, we
1:49:16
love you all. Thank you so
1:49:18
much for listening. And yeah, if
1:49:20
you want to hear this ad
1:49:22
free, hop over to our uncorked
1:49:24
page. It's out. We put the ad
1:49:26
free episodes up the same day so you
1:49:28
don't have to wait. It's right there for your
1:49:31
ear holes, baby. It's right
1:49:33
there. Thanks so much for
1:49:35
listening and we will see
1:49:37
you next week. Bye -bye. Thanks
1:49:39
for listening to Wine and
1:49:41
Crime. Our cover art is
1:49:43
by Danielle Sylvan. Music by
1:49:45
Phil Young and Corey Wendell.
1:49:47
Editing by Jonathan Camp. Our
1:49:49
production manager is Andrea Gardner.
1:49:51
For photos, sources, and other
1:49:53
resources, head to WineAndCrimePodcast.com. You
1:49:55
can follow us on all
1:49:57
the socials at WineAndCrimePod. If
1:49:59
like to show your support
1:50:01
and get access to all
1:50:03
sorts of wine bonus
1:50:05
content, check out
1:50:07
our premium channel
1:50:10
at wineandcrimepodcast.com. uncorked.
1:50:12
Cheers! content.
1:51:22
content.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More