Ep416 Lake Tahoe Crimes

Ep416 Lake Tahoe Crimes

Released Thursday, 17th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Ep416 Lake Tahoe Crimes

Ep416 Lake Tahoe Crimes

Ep416 Lake Tahoe Crimes

Ep416 Lake Tahoe Crimes

Thursday, 17th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

and Crime contains graphic and

0:02

explicit content which may not

0:04

be suitable for some listeners.

0:06

Listener discretion is advised. You

0:23

are listening to Wine and

0:25

Crime, the podcast where two friends

0:27

chug wine, chat true crime,

0:29

and unleash their worst Minnesotan accents.

0:32

Gosh darn it. You know

0:34

they do. I'm curious

0:36

what kind of accents might

0:38

apply to today's topic.

0:40

I've never been to that

0:42

area, so I frankly

0:44

don't know. Not much of one.

0:46

Okay. Respect. The

0:49

accents aren't super strong in the

0:51

Southwest, the American Southwest. All right.

0:53

I don't think. I mean, I didn't when

0:55

we were in New Mexico, I feel like I

0:57

did not notice any like discernible

1:00

or to me

1:02

personally discernible, personally

1:04

distinctive regional accent. But

1:07

that's that's to my ear,

1:09

which which the value I

1:11

put on this is absolute zero.

1:13

Minimal. Yeah. Yep. So

1:16

I would love, honestly, like,

1:18

voice memo me, your American Southwest

1:20

accents, because I would love

1:23

them. Because... Oh,

1:25

I'm Lucy. Yep. I'm Amanda. Sorry.

1:27

I... Yep. We got a We

1:29

started before we started. got a

1:32

little ahead of ourselves. We

1:34

did. Today we have a

1:36

very special fan pick from Dustin

1:38

Perez. Thank you, Dustin. Thank

1:40

you, Dustin. Dusty P. Dusty.

1:43

Everything is Dustin Perez.

1:46

Dustin Perez is everything.

1:49

Dustin chose the topic

1:51

of Lake Tahoe crimes.

1:54

All the photos of

1:56

Lake Tahoe. It

1:59

looks Caribbean. Oh, my

2:01

God. It's just Gorgina.

2:03

I mean, we live in

2:05

such a huge country

2:07

that I frequently forget the...

2:09

boundless natural beauties that

2:12

exist right within even just

2:14

the contiguous United States.

2:16

It's wild. Yeah. So

2:18

we should protect them. Right. Right.

2:24

Well, I'm on a razor's edge. I

2:27

am barely clinging

2:29

on. When they say

2:31

skin of my

2:34

teeth, they mean it.

2:37

Didn't know my teeth had skin until I

2:39

was there. Yeah. Yeah.

2:41

Yeah. Yeah. Okay.

2:43

Well, let's get going

2:46

because I think that this

2:48

might be a good

2:50

distraction from some of the

2:52

news. Yeah.

2:54

Okay. So,

2:56

Amanda, what is our wine

2:58

crime pairing for Lake

3:01

Tahoe Crimes? Well, Dusty P

3:03

recommended that we shout

3:05

out and check out. Tahoe

3:07

blue vodka, which

3:09

is a... Well, I literally wrote, don't

3:11

worry, the vodka itself is not

3:13

blue. Dustin would not harm us like

3:15

that. I've had my

3:18

time with Your UV

3:20

blue flashbacks, your PTSD.

3:23

You were fighting for your life

3:25

out there. dry just thinking about

3:27

it. One UV blue at a

3:29

time. No, this is a, frankly, stunning

3:32

looking vodka out of... Tahoe,

3:34

like when you go to

3:36

their website, which is TahoeBlueVodka.com,

3:38

you're greeted by literally the

3:40

glistening mountain foot waters of

3:42

Lake Tahoe. Mountain foot? Well,

3:45

you know, there's little ranges

3:47

in the background. It's gorgeous.

3:49

Yeah, it's just gorgeous. It's

3:51

just gorgeous. So the Tahoe

3:53

Blue Vodka is inspired by

3:55

Lake Tahoe. which straddles California

3:57

and Nevada with a maximum

3:59

depth of over 1 ,600

4:01

feet, which I'm sure you're

4:03

going to get to. This

4:05

is local to that region

4:08

and inspired by that region.

4:10

Okay. When you drink Tahoe

4:12

Blue Vodka, you support Lake

4:14

Tahoe because they donate a

4:16

portion of their proceeds to

4:18

help preserve both the lake

4:20

itself and the diverse environment

4:22

surrounding it. So I thought

4:24

that was pretty cool. that

4:26

you can drink, feel good

4:28

about what you're drinking because

4:31

you are supporting the conservation

4:33

and preservation of one of

4:35

our country's most gorgeous natural

4:37

features. This is the world's

4:39

only vodka crafted from pristine

4:41

Tahoe water. Oh, it's made

4:43

from the water? Sure is. It

4:46

is a three vodka blend that

4:48

finishes as clean and smooth as the

4:50

lake it's named for. So smooth,

4:52

in fact, it's claimed dozens of awards

4:54

and been named best tasting and

4:56

best in class by various judges. Well,

4:59

do they know how many corpses are

5:01

in Lake Tahoe? I don't know if they

5:03

do, but I have a feeling that

5:05

you do. Nobody

5:07

does. That you. Oh,

5:09

OK. Well, great. They

5:12

do have this at Total Wine.

5:14

They did not have it at my

5:16

local Total Wine, which makes me

5:18

really sad, but I'm going to order

5:20

it because it truly sounds spectacular.

5:22

But their website is awesome. It also

5:24

has recommendations of what to do

5:26

with your Tahoe Blue. And

5:28

they shared a couple of their

5:30

favorite recipes from among their staff, and

5:32

I'm going to share them with

5:34

you as well and then let you

5:36

know which one I'm drinking. All

5:38

right. So the founder's favorite, this is

5:40

super easy and delicious and refreshing. It's

5:42

a vodka soda, like a tall

5:44

boy with ice and one and a

5:46

half ounces, wink, wink, however much

5:48

vodka you need to put in there.

5:50

Tahoe blue vodka and then soda water.

5:52

But you garnish it with an orange

5:54

slice, which I'm a huge fan of.

5:56

Okay. In Amsterdam, they serve gin and

5:58

tonics in like a big goblet with

6:00

an orange slice. Yum. I'm

6:03

obsessed. We need more orange

6:05

garnishes. I agree. It's like

6:07

a limes. Uh -huh. Uh -huh.

6:10

Another one that is also

6:12

not blue, but the name

6:14

may confuse you, may send

6:17

you in a different direction.

6:19

A blue herring? It's a

6:21

blue herring. It's the Blue

6:23

Samurai, which is two ounces

6:25

of Tahoe Blue Vodka, an

6:27

ounce of simple syrup, a

6:29

pea -sized dollop of wasabi. Ooh.

6:32

And a cucumber slice. I

6:34

thought that one sounded awesome. Maybe.

6:36

Do you shake it then? Yeah.

6:38

You'd shake that in a or

6:40

yeah, you'd shake it. You'd make

6:43

one cocktail at a time in

6:45

your shaker. Yeah. They, of course,

6:47

have things like Bloody Marys, hard

6:49

lemonades, Tahoe Mule, you know, things

6:51

that are like the vodka classics.

6:53

But I also had to share

6:55

one that was going to fulfill

6:57

your fears. The lady in blue.

6:59

Which is, in fact, a blue

7:01

cocktail. And it is very blue.

7:03

It's like Margaritaville blue. I'm kind

7:05

of living for it. It's a

7:07

one and a half ounces of

7:09

Tahoe blue vodka, 0 .75 ounces

7:11

of lemon juice, 0 .5 ounces of

7:13

simple syrup, 0 .25 ounces of

7:15

creme de voilette, which is where

7:17

you get that some of that

7:19

blue. Then you're going to

7:21

top it off with a little blue

7:23

curacao. Of course, that blue

7:25

doesn't come natural. Nope, that's our girl.

7:28

Two drops orange flower water, and

7:30

you can garnish it with an edible

7:32

flower. So if you're looking for

7:34

something that's going to make you feel

7:36

like you're on a retired white

7:38

lady's island vacation, the lady in blue

7:41

is going to be the one

7:43

for you. If you're, what's it called?

7:45

Barb and star taking this to

7:47

Del Mar. Yep. Del Mar. You might

7:49

want to check out the lady

7:51

in blue, but I am drinking the

7:54

founder's favorite cute because I had

7:56

vodka and I had oranges and I

7:58

had soda and I want to

8:00

make clear. I did look up Tahoe

8:02

blue vodka to see if I

8:04

could get it at my local total

8:07

wine, but I could not, but

8:09

I do want to try this. So

8:11

check them out at. TahoeBlueVodka.com.

8:14

You can get recipe ideas,

8:16

learn about their business and where

8:18

you can get their stuff.

8:20

And it's just like, I want

8:22

to go to Lake Tahoe

8:24

so bad. I fucking do too.

8:26

Let's do a gals go

8:28

to Lake Tahoe. Done. Perfect. Are

8:30

you drinking anything fun or

8:32

special today? As I mentioned, I

8:34

had a cocktail before we

8:36

started. So I feel adequately pre

8:38

-lubed. Good. Great. And I got

8:40

my pen. Perfect. Then

8:42

you have everything on both ends.

8:45

I have everything I need and some

8:47

ice water. Oh, my

8:49

God. Well, let's take a quick

8:51

break to hear a word from

8:53

our sponsors so that you can

8:55

dive in to all of the

8:57

Lake Tahoe madness. Let's do it.

8:59

Springs here, people. And you know what

9:01

that means. Wedding season.

9:04

Oh, my favorite. So many weddings this

9:06

year for me personally. Whether you're

9:08

attending a bridal shower, a bachelorette party,

9:10

or the actual wedding itself, it's

9:12

time to get dressed up again. Shake

9:15

off those winter mulligrubs, those cobwebs,

9:17

and get a great outfit because a

9:19

great outfit always starts with great

9:21

shapewear. Let's be real. No one has

9:23

time for shapewear that feels uncomfortable

9:25

or restrictive or like takes you forever

9:27

to put it on or take

9:29

it off. And luckily, you don't

9:31

have to settle for that stuff. Today's episode

9:33

is brought to you by Honey Love, the

9:36

brand that's setting a new standard for shapewear. It's

9:39

wedding season for all, but it

9:41

is like thighs fusing together season for

9:43

me. Yeah. And that is where

9:45

Honey Love Superpower Short has quite literally

9:47

saved my thighs year after year.

9:49

Saved your butt. Saved my butt, lifted

9:51

it up, saved my thighs from

9:53

rubbing together. It's so comfy. It's so

9:55

easy to wear. I'm obsessed. Honey

9:57

Love uses targeted compression to sculpt and

9:59

smooth where you want it and

10:01

ease off where you don't. That means

10:03

it's super effective and comfortable to

10:05

wear all day long. It's shapewear that

10:07

works with your body, not against

10:09

it. And if you're wondering what the

10:11

difference might be there, honestly, you're

10:13

going to feel it. You're going to

10:15

see it immediately when you put

10:17

it on. Plus, it's got this flexible

10:19

boning in the side seams that

10:21

keeps it from rolling down. which

10:24

is like such a common issue

10:26

I was running into. You'll never have

10:28

to sneakily adjust yourself in public

10:31

again, even after a night of dancing.

10:33

Plus their shapewear features, lingerie inspired design

10:36

details that you'll want to show off.

10:38

So, you know, if you've got weddings

10:40

on the brain this season, honey, love

10:42

has definitely got you covered. And

10:44

here's the best part. For a limited

10:46

time, you can get Honey Love on

10:48

sale. Save 20 % off your entire

10:50

order with our exclusive link, honeylove.com slash

10:52

wine. Support the show and start your

10:54

year off right by checking them

10:56

out at honeylove.com slash wine. Treat yourself

10:58

to the most comfortable shapewear on earth

11:00

and save 20 % off site -wide at

11:03

honeylove.com slash wine. Use our exclusive

11:05

link to get 20 % off honeylove.com slash

11:07

wine. After you purchase the last

11:09

we heard about them, please support our

11:11

show and tell them they sent you.

11:13

Experience the new standard in shapewear with

11:15

Honeylove. This episode is brought

11:17

to you by IQ Bar, our

11:19

exclusive snack sponsor. IQ Bar is

11:21

the better -for -you plant -protein -based snacks

11:24

made with brain -boosting nutrients to refuel,

11:26

nourish, and satisfy hunger without the

11:28

sugar crash. I love IQ Bar.

11:30

I am so bad at, like...

11:32

myself breakfast, and IQ Bar has

11:34

fully changed the game for me.

11:36

Their plant protein bars are packed

11:38

with high -quality ingredients to keep

11:40

you physically and mentally fit. IQ

11:42

Bar is totally free from gluten,

11:44

dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial sweeteners

11:46

for a natural anytime snack. I

11:49

am in love with their flavors.

11:51

They have nine delicious flavors, including

11:53

mint chocolate chip, high, chocolate sea

11:55

salt, banana nut, toasted coconut chip.

11:57

My favorite is the lemon blueberry

11:59

i also love the peanut butter

12:01

chip and honestly with over 20

12:03

000 five -star reviews and counting more

12:05

people than ever are starting their

12:07

days on the right foot with

12:09

iq bars brain and body boosting

12:12

bars hydration mixes and mushroom coffees

12:14

i'm obsessed their hydration mixes are

12:16

so good and again don't have

12:18

all that extra sugar in them

12:20

that's gonna like spike my blood

12:22

sugar in the morning you know

12:24

i'm a diabetic early i gotta

12:26

be careful about what i put

12:28

in my body iq bar is

12:30

always an easy one for me

12:32

to reach for And right now,

12:34

IQ Bar is offering our special

12:37

podcast listeners 20 % off all

12:39

IQ Bar products, plus get free

12:41

shipping. To get your 20 % off,

12:43

text GALS to 64000. Text GALS

12:45

to 64000. That's GALS to 64000.

12:47

Message and data rates may apply.

12:49

See terms for details. Did

12:51

you know that Fast Growing Trees is

12:54

the biggest online nursery in the U .S.

12:56

with thousands of different plants and over two

12:58

million happy customers? They have

13:00

all the plants your yard needs, like

13:02

fruit trees, privacy trees, flowering trees, shrubs,

13:04

and so much more. Whatever plants you're

13:06

interested in, Fast Growing Trees has you

13:08

covered. Find the perfect fit for your

13:10

climate and space. It's so amazing that

13:12

you can literally search with your zip

13:14

code and find your zone. So you're

13:16

not like leafing, quote unquote, through plants

13:18

that won't even grow in your area. Fast

13:21

-growing trees makes it easy to get

13:23

your dream yard. Order online and get

13:25

your plants delivered directly to your door

13:27

in just a few days without ever

13:29

leaving home, our other favorite thing. Their

13:31

alive and thrive guarantee ensures your plants

13:34

arrive happy and healthy. Plus, get support

13:36

from trained plant experts on call to

13:38

help you plan your landscape, choose the

13:40

right plants, and learn how to care

13:42

for them. I got a cherry tree

13:44

from Fast Growing Trees. Same girl. I

13:46

couldn't plant it right away. She sat

13:48

on my porch for longer than I

13:50

would have liked. Popped her

13:53

in the ground a couple weeks ago.

13:55

She is thriving. Yeah. I

13:57

was shocked that I didn't accidentally kill

13:59

it because of that. Yeah, I

14:01

actually had to put mine in a

14:03

pot for the same reason and

14:05

keep it inside by a window until

14:07

the last freeze, which she can

14:10

finally be planted now. But she's already...

14:12

Like sprout leaves. Yeah. Yeah. She's

14:14

in great shape. The health of these

14:16

trees. My God. So if you

14:18

have a big yard, a small yard

14:20

or no yard, they have over

14:23

6 ,000 plants to fit any space

14:25

from indoor plants. They got like house

14:27

plants. They got fruit trees, full

14:29

size privacy trees. So much more. I

14:31

have a lot of fun just

14:33

browsing their website. Also, funny anecdote, like

14:36

six years ago, I planted one

14:38

arborvitae on the side of my house.

14:40

Girl, you tried. I got it for free

14:42

from work and I was like, okay, I'm

14:45

just going to plant it. And then I

14:47

like stopped seeing it because it's just one,

14:49

you know, that's sort of an odd plant

14:51

to just have one of. And now I

14:53

got my cherry tree and I was like

14:55

looking around and like, I'm going to plant

14:57

trees all over. Like this spring, I already

14:59

have a whole landscaping plan thanks to fast

15:01

growing trees. I'm like, oh, maybe my arborvitae

15:03

needs like four or five friends. And

15:06

I have all the confidence in the world

15:08

that the ones that I get from fast

15:10

-growing trees are going to be... exceptionally

15:12

healthy and they're going to just make

15:14

my yard so beautiful. It's also just such

15:16

a great website for people who are

15:18

like maybe kind of new to gardening or

15:20

feel like they don't have a green

15:22

thumb. Like folks, these people will walk you

15:25

through every step of the process. You

15:27

can do it. If I can do it,

15:30

baby, you can do it. Okay.

15:32

I'm so confident now. So confident. And

15:34

this spring they have the best

15:36

deals for your yard up to

15:38

half off on select plants and other

15:40

deals. And listeners, to our show

15:42

get 15 % off their first purchase

15:44

when using the code GALS at

15:47

checkout. That's an additional 15 % off

15:49

at FastGrowingTrees.com using the code GALS

15:51

at checkout. FastGrowingTrees.com code

15:53

GALS now is the perfect time

15:55

to plant. Use GALS to save

15:57

today. Offer is valid for a

15:59

limited time. Terms and conditions may

16:01

apply. Welcome back to Whining Crime.

16:03

Welcome back. Welcome back. Welcome

16:05

back. Lucy,

16:08

I am excited to hear How many

16:10

bodies are in Lake Tahoe? So

16:12

would you like to present your findings

16:14

to the class? You're not going

16:16

to hear how many because so many

16:18

will never be found. Gosh,

16:20

darn it. Gosh,

16:22

darn it. It's right. Golly. So

16:24

Lake Tahoe sits on the border

16:27

of California and Nevada. Make up

16:29

your mind. And is the largest

16:31

alpine lake. Take a side. Is

16:33

the largest alpine lake in

16:35

North America. So that means.

16:37

It's at or above the

16:39

tree line. She's up there.

16:41

Which Lake Superior is not.

16:43

No. No. So she sits

16:45

at over 6 ,000 feet

16:47

above sea level. She's also

16:49

very deep. As you mentioned,

16:51

she gets to about 1 ,600

16:53

feet deep, putting her in

16:55

second place behind Crater Lake

16:57

in Oregon, who is just

16:59

a bit deeper at 1

17:01

,900 feet deep. Hey, Siri,

17:03

how deep is the deepest

17:05

part of Lake Superior? The

17:07

deepest part of Lake Superior

17:09

is 1 ,333 feet, 406 meters.

17:12

No, don't care. Don't care. Shut

17:15

your mouth. Shut up. Shut

17:17

your mouth. Wow.

17:20

Okay. So they're not like,

17:22

I mean, I would assume in

17:24

terms of depth and pressure,

17:26

that's a pretty decent difference at

17:28

300 feet. But like to

17:30

us, if you're going to walk.

17:32

1 ,300 feet versus 1 ,600

17:34

feet, it doesn't feel that different.

17:36

I don't think it really would. But

17:39

dang, that's some deep ass

17:41

fucking lakes. It's very deep, especially

17:43

considering when you think about

17:45

the pressure and what can survive

17:47

down there. Yeah. There isn't

17:49

a big difference between 1 ,600

17:51

and 1 ,900 feet. I guess

17:53

not. Once you

17:55

get into that zone, you're

17:57

crushing. Literally crushing. So

18:00

Lake Tahoe is the sixth

18:02

largest lake by volume in the

18:04

United States. So it's basically

18:06

the five Great Lakes and then

18:08

her. Interesting. I wonder

18:11

why she didn't make the cut.

18:13

Well, the Great Lakes are kind

18:15

of connected up up there, you

18:17

know, I suppose. She's kind of

18:19

alone down southwest. She's holding it

18:21

down. She's holding it down. So,

18:23

of course, this makes the lake

18:25

a hub for tourism because being

18:27

surrounded on all sides by mountains

18:29

and gorgeous forests makes for excellent

18:31

skiing in the winter and those

18:33

beaches, that water, the sheer size.

18:35

Does she freeze? I don't

18:37

think so. Yeah, because Lake Superior doesn't

18:39

really freeze either. You'll get some ice

18:41

like right along the shoreline, but it's

18:43

not a lake that you can like

18:46

skate or ice fish on. It's like,

18:48

no, it has like a fucking tide.

18:50

Well, this is also, like,

18:52

in Nevada. Right. Oh, true.

18:54

Yeah. I look at those

18:56

snow -capped mountains surrounding it, and

18:59

I'm like, oh, it's cold.

19:01

Wait. No. It gets

19:03

cold, but it's not, like, how

19:05

Lake Superior is always fucking,

19:07

like, 35 degrees or some shit.

19:09

Yeah. Much different swim in it.

19:12

It's at a higher altitude, but it

19:14

is in, it's in the desert. A

19:16

warmer, yeah. It's in a warmer region.

19:18

Mm hmm. So like I mentioned, Lake

19:20

Tahoe is unique because of its size.

19:22

It is so big that at the

19:24

widest point, which is over 100 miles,

19:27

you can't see the other side and

19:29

you but you can see the curvature

19:31

of the earth on its surface. Mm

19:33

hmm. She big. Yeah. That being said,

19:35

if the air temperature is way higher

19:37

than the water temperature, like if the

19:39

water is really cold and the air

19:42

is much warmer, the light

19:44

refracting, the light refraction

19:46

can occur, which. can

19:48

result in Fata Morgana,

19:50

which is a mirage,

19:52

like an optical illusion

19:54

created at the horizon

19:56

line that looks like

19:58

towers. It looks like

20:00

vertical. So these may

20:02

be responsible for the Tahoe

20:04

Tessie sightings. Like their Loch Ness

20:06

Monster. Yes, and I just

20:08

don't care about that kind of

20:10

thing. The exasperation in your

20:13

voice. Do not talk to Lucy

20:15

about a cryptid. Do fucking

20:17

not. care. I

20:19

just don't. They're so out there.

20:21

Listen. They're not real. Except

20:24

that weird bird. That was in

20:26

Iowa. That was a weird

20:28

one. Bigfoot is real. And I

20:30

don't care who tries to

20:32

fight me on it. I

20:35

mean, at Tahoe Tessie, can

20:37

we be a little more trite? It's just

20:39

stupid. It's on like a bunch of

20:41

their merch. Grow

20:43

up. Just

20:48

not all that righteous

20:50

indignation for Tahoe Tessie.

20:53

Sea monsters. Not your thing. I

20:55

was really into them in

20:57

third grade. For a

20:59

full year, I was really into them.

21:01

I checked out old books from

21:03

the library, like ones that didn't even

21:05

have pictures about sea monsters. Well,

21:07

that's absurd. Yeah,

21:09

I had a hard phase.

21:11

And you know what? I

21:13

was eight. Yeah, you're past

21:15

it now. I'm very much

21:18

past it. Okay. We'll get

21:20

to the creatures that I

21:22

prefer. Okay. That we attribute

21:24

these Fata Morgana sightings to.

21:26

So Fata Morgana is the

21:28

translation of Morgan the Fairy

21:30

in Italian. And so that's

21:32

from the King Arthur legend

21:34

of Morgan Le Fay. Okay.

21:36

And so these. Optical illusions

21:38

were named such by sailors

21:40

in the Strait of Messina

21:42

where these mirages were described

21:45

as fairy castles or false

21:47

land created by Morgan's magic. Weird.

21:50

Mirages are nuts to behold. Especially

21:52

when you're in the middle

21:54

of the ocean and you think

21:57

you see like land and

21:59

like a towering, glittering city. Yeah.

22:01

I mean, in the middle of

22:03

something that is so big that

22:05

it feels like an ocean, at

22:08

least in this case. Yeah, well,

22:10

the phrase Fata Morgana comes from

22:12

ocean travel. The Italian explorers. Yeah.

22:14

So when I thought of Lake

22:16

Tahoe, I got it confused with

22:18

Lake Como. Which, that's

22:20

Italy, right? Wait, which one am

22:22

I thinking of? Lake... Havasu.

22:25

I thought of, yes, Lake

22:27

Havasu. From Vanderbilt Rules. Real Housewives.

22:29

I thought of Real Housewives. They

22:31

go to Lake Tahoe in Housewives for

22:34

sure. But I know VPR went to

22:36

Havasu. It's like they can't afford Tahoe.

22:38

Orange County went to Havasu, too, because

22:40

I feel like the Gundolfsons had a

22:42

lake house there. Probably. So

22:44

upon Googling, it was Real

22:46

Housewives of Beverly Hills, season

22:49

11, episode 2. They

22:51

rented a house. Reno rented a

22:53

house. At the time, it

22:55

was $8 ,000 per night. It's

22:57

17 ,000 square feet. It has

22:59

17 bedrooms and 18 bathrooms. Okay.

23:01

It can host up to

23:03

40 people. Like sleeping comfortably with

23:05

a partner in a comfortable

23:07

sleeping arrangement. It has bed space

23:09

for 40 people. Yeah. And

23:12

there were seven ladies, maybe eight.

23:14

Well, and the crew. Well,

23:16

yeah. And also, like, of course,

23:18

they're going to be extra

23:20

anyway. But this is this is

23:22

where the two truths and

23:24

a lie episode takes place in

23:26

which Kathy Hilton doesn't understand

23:28

the basic rules of two truths

23:30

and a lie. It's a

23:32

very complex game. And then Erica

23:34

wants everyone to think that

23:37

she's super mysterious and she just

23:39

is so vapid. I can't

23:41

even stand it. I know. What

23:43

a monster. So this house

23:45

has a Himalayan salt cave, an

23:47

indoor swimming pool. A

23:49

secret tunnel to the lake and the

23:51

pier. My God. And

23:53

its own hair and nail

23:55

salon. In the house? Yeah. This

23:58

is one of those properties where it's

24:00

like rich people built this as a

24:03

house so it could be like zoned

24:05

that way or homesteaded or whatever. It's

24:07

got to be some sort of tax

24:09

thing, but it's definitely a commercial property

24:11

that they built to rent out for

24:13

like weddings. Large private

24:15

events. Yes. And no one

24:17

was ever going to live there.

24:20

It was built by Mr.

24:22

Hera of Hera's Casino Empire. That'll

24:24

do it. Yep. That'll

24:26

do it. That fits

24:28

just right. Hey,

24:31

do what you got to do.

24:33

So Ben found it on

24:35

Vrbo. It is now $12 ,000

24:38

a night. Ew. But you can

24:40

rent it. Well, one could. I

24:43

absolutely cannot. I

24:45

also found the, well, I saw

24:47

on Instagram, the house in White

24:49

Lotus where Greg slash Gary lives

24:51

with Chloe is on Airbnb for

24:53

$13 ,000 a night. Jesus. Okay,

24:55

let me do the math on

24:57

how many people I would have

25:00

to split that with to be

25:02

able to afford it. You could

25:04

split it with 40 full people.

25:06

Well, that doesn't, it's $1 ,200 a

25:08

night? $12 ,000 a night? Yes.

25:10

12 ,000 a night divided by

25:12

40 is still on the high

25:14

end of my price range. How

25:16

much a night? 300. I

25:18

also don't know 40 people I'd want

25:20

to hang out with for a whole

25:23

night. I mean, fair. Not that you

25:25

see many of them because it seems

25:27

like the place is so fucking big,

25:29

it'd be pretty easy to avoid people.

25:31

Yeah. You can pretty much all have

25:33

your own bathroom. If I'm spending 300

25:36

bucks and splitting everything with all of

25:38

my friends, I want a couple nights

25:40

out of it, not one night. Yeah,

25:42

it's still $1 ,000 basically living in a

25:44

frat house. Yeah. A really nice frat

25:46

house. The world's nicest frat house. No,

25:48

thanks. Next. Next. I'd rather split it

25:51

with fewer people, but I obviously couldn't

25:53

afford that if I won the lottery.

25:55

I think I would maximum 12 people.

25:57

Yeah. Even in a 17 ,000 square

25:59

foot house. Yeah. No. No. It's too

26:01

big. I don't like it. Pull a

26:04

Denise and get a hotel. Yeah. Okay.

26:07

Lake Tahoe is fed by

26:09

67 tributaries. So like little streams

26:11

that come down from the

26:13

mountains, but not like full. substantial

26:15

rivers so those give it

26:18

about half of its water and

26:20

the rest is from precipitation

26:22

cool there's only one outlet which

26:24

is the truckee river which

26:26

flows north through reno up past

26:28

reno about 15 miles to

26:30

pyramid lake interesting pyramid lake remember

26:33

when we were at the

26:35

convention in albuquerque and we were

26:37

talking to that guy that's

26:39

right when my gummy kicked in

26:41

when he saw he saw

26:43

the ufo Yeah. No way.

26:45

That's why I started Googling Pyramid Lake.

26:48

There's a bunch of weird UFO

26:50

stuff, but there's also what I'm about

26:52

to talk about. All right. So

26:54

Pyramid Lake is just too fun not

26:56

to give a brief moment to

26:58

before we head back south to Lake

27:00

Tahoe. So Pyramid Lake is on

27:02

the Paiute Reservation. And Paiute folklore

27:04

says that the lake was formed from

27:06

the tears of the stone mother, probably

27:09

from all the mountains. Some

27:11

other tribe legends include

27:13

water babies. Ooh. So

27:16

these are babies that were

27:18

born prematurely or that were born

27:20

with disabilities, and they were

27:22

taken to the lake to drown.

27:24

Oh, my God. That's terrible.

27:26

It is, but that wasn't uncommon

27:28

back when we didn't have

27:30

civilizations large enough to really have

27:32

the means and resources to

27:34

take care of. of course. Of

27:36

course. Like, I get it.

27:38

It's just fucking tragic. It is,

27:40

but that is a real

27:42

part of what probably every civilization

27:44

around the world has gone

27:46

through at some point. I feel

27:48

like that kind of death

27:50

is a lot quicker and much

27:52

more merciful than the inevitable

27:54

death that also comes with draining

27:56

a bunch of resources from

27:58

your community, you know? Yeah,

28:00

not my place to say. If

28:02

you were in this position,

28:04

obviously there is no fucking reason

28:06

for this. this kind of

28:09

practice now nowadays no not saying

28:11

that yes a very sad

28:13

thing a very sad fact of

28:15

life also this is legend

28:17

so i'm not even trying to

28:19

say that they really did

28:21

do this but yeah i know

28:23

that some for sure for

28:25

sure this absolutely happened across cultures

28:27

and communities in like the

28:29

early times of man this was

28:31

survival at its most brutal

28:34

yeah So it is said that

28:36

these babies never left the

28:38

lake, and their spirits still live

28:40

there, and they call out

28:42

to fishermen to lure them into

28:44

the water where the fishermen

28:46

drown. Yeah, get their revenge. Get

28:48

your revenge, water babies. But

28:51

water babies is such a sweet

28:53

name. It's like, no, they're like

28:55

creepy baby sirens. Yeah, and I'm

28:57

living for it. Yeah. Every

29:00

spring, there are reports of babies

29:02

crying on the shore of the lake.

29:04

Whoa, that gave me a chill.

29:06

Also, springtime is when most of the

29:08

drownings occur. There's

29:10

also a legend of

29:12

a singular spurned mermaid. One

29:16

mermaid. She was so annoying about

29:18

it that no other mermaids even

29:20

wanted to live in the same

29:22

lake. Pretty much. I'm obsessed. So

29:25

the story goes that she, the

29:27

mermaid, was dating a tribesman. The

29:29

family of the tribesman did not

29:31

accept their love. And ordered him

29:33

to return the mermaid to the

29:35

lake. She is not allowed here.

29:38

No mermaids allowed. The mermaid was

29:40

pissed off. And so she cursed

29:42

the lake and everyone around it.

29:44

And so that's why there are,

29:46

again, so many drownings and mysterious

29:48

disappearances associated with lakes. Oh. Good

29:51

for her. Right. I'll

29:53

say it again. And I will

29:55

say it forever. So,

29:57

like I said, these mysterious

29:59

drownings. but perhaps even more

30:01

mysterious, the discoveries of the

30:03

drowned victims. So remember when

30:05

I said, well, okay, so

30:07

Pyramid Lake is not nearly

30:09

as deep as Lake Tahoe.

30:11

It gets up to about

30:13

350 feet deep, but it

30:15

also has like really steep

30:17

drop -offs and it has

30:19

like currents. Okay, so

30:22

I think I understood this

30:24

correctly, but my interpretation of this

30:26

was because of the altitude

30:28

of the lake, So

30:30

divers can only go about 90 feet

30:32

deep. And I think this is because

30:34

of like the air pressure in their

30:36

tanks and all that stuff. Because they

30:38

have to factor in how far above

30:40

sea level they are. Oh, that's so

30:42

interesting and scary. So

30:45

they can only go about 90 feet

30:47

out of the 350 feet deep that

30:49

the lake is. Okay. So they can't

30:51

even see what is all the way

30:53

down there in real time. They'd have

30:55

to send down some sort of device.

30:57

Well, yeah, but also like if they

30:59

weren't really paying attention, they weren't really

31:01

aware of how deep they were. All

31:03

of a sudden they can't get back

31:05

up. So divers

31:07

sometimes go missing. But the weirdest

31:09

part is that some people remember

31:12

where I remember how I said

31:14

that Lake Tahoe feeds into Truckee

31:16

Lake, which flows into Pyramid Lake. Sometimes

31:19

people who have drowned in

31:21

Pyramid Lake end up being

31:23

found in Lake Tahoe. Like

31:26

their remains made it. Reverse.

31:28

Up river. Up river. Weird.

31:30

Which means that the river

31:32

must have like flowed backwards

31:34

somehow. Or it was an

31:36

army of underwater babies. Or

31:39

a singular pissed off

31:42

mermaid. I can't even wrap

31:44

my head around that.

31:46

Isn't that gross? That's so

31:48

weird. Yeah. Oh. Yeah.

31:50

No. Like, it's weird. It's a

31:52

weird, weird place. That really creeps

31:54

me out. I know. That really

31:56

fucking creeps me out. That's one

31:58

of the creepiest things I've heard

32:00

in a long time. And you're

32:02

my best friend, so that's saying

32:04

a lot. The

32:07

fuck? And, like, it wasn't just

32:09

one. It's been, like, several. And also,

32:11

like, stories of people. Like,

32:13

it's not just a one -off. No.

32:17

Next. Absolutely not. All right.

32:19

So we're going back upriver

32:21

to Lake Tahoe, just like

32:23

those bodies. Good God. So

32:26

it is a conifer forest

32:28

around the lake. So conifer

32:30

meaning like pines. We've got

32:32

the Pinus Jeffrey, the Jeffrey

32:34

Pine. Jeffrey Penis. The Pi

32:36

Contorta, the Lodgepole Pine. And

32:39

the Pi Lambertiana. I don't

32:41

know why I'm putting an accent on it. Why

32:43

not? Pi Lambertiana.

32:45

I'm back in Italy. Or

32:47

the sugar pine. But not

32:50

the dusty pea. No dusty

32:52

pea. Okay. Only pea

32:54

contorta. Just trying to figure

32:56

out why Dustin would pick this

32:58

episode if there's no dusty

33:00

pine. I don't remember why they

33:02

picked this episode. I'll go

33:04

back in the email on our

33:06

next break. Figure that out.

33:08

So Lake Tahoe is also the

33:11

only known habitat for the

33:13

ultra rare Rorippa sabumbalata. A

33:15

.K .A. the Lake Tahoe yellowcress.

33:17

It's a bird? It's a

33:19

plant. A plant? She's real cute, too.

33:21

I have a picture of it

33:23

on the drive. Okay. I'll

33:26

bite. Little yellow. It

33:28

looks like a... Oh, that's

33:30

pretty. It's like a

33:32

fern meets a succulent with

33:34

a little yellow bud

33:36

on it. Little yellow blossoms.

33:38

Gorgeous. Yeah, it's like

33:40

a succulent fern. It's really

33:42

cool. only

33:44

grows between the low -water

33:46

mark and the high -water

33:48

mark on the shores of

33:51

Lake Tahoe. Wow. How

33:53

weird. And it's only been

33:55

observed a few dozen

33:57

times. So it's extremely rare,

33:59

a plant. It's extremely

34:01

rare. Wow. That's fucking amazing.

34:04

Mm -hmm. She's part of the

34:06

mustard family. Can you imagine? Meese

34:09

of Colonel Mustard. What? Horticulturists

34:12

must... lose their shit if

34:14

they ever see this fucker

34:16

in real life yeah between

34:18

low water low water and

34:20

high water so you have

34:22

to even right time of

34:24

year time it right right

34:26

time yeah like oh that's

34:28

so bizarre yeah lake tahoe

34:30

is fascinating well these massive

34:32

lake ecosystems are so fucking

34:34

cool and weird and now

34:36

we're way into it after

34:38

having geo on our Oh,

34:40

yeah. That episode of GAC.

34:42

Truly. I bet there's so

34:44

much Spooky Lakes Month Tahoe

34:46

content. Mm -hmm. Mm

34:48

-hmm. I'm in. Yeah.

34:51

Follow Spooky Lakes Month

34:53

Geo, Geosaurus on

34:55

TikTok. Who was named

34:57

because her mom is

34:59

like a geologist, scientist. Which

35:02

cracks me up. I'm

35:05

obsessed. Geo. Geo. Okay, so I

35:07

have some folklore, like an origin

35:10

story, some name origin story for

35:12

you. Okay. This is from a

35:14

1905 edition of Sunset Magazine in

35:16

which a member of the Washoe

35:18

tribe recounts the naming of the

35:21

lake. Okay. So in their stories,

35:23

they had the Ong, O -N -G,

35:25

and this was like a really,

35:27

really fucking big bird. Oh. It

35:29

was described as bigger than the

35:31

house of the white man. Good.

35:34

Its body was like an eagle's

35:36

and its wings were longer than

35:38

the tallest pines. Wow. It also

35:40

said like as it flew by,

35:42

like trees would like bend in

35:45

the wind that the wings made.

35:47

Damn. Quote, their words,

35:49

not mine. Its face was that of

35:51

an Indian, but covered with hard

35:53

scales and its feet were webbed. So

35:55

because it was scaled, it like

35:58

couldn't, their weapons didn't work against it.

36:00

Oh, cool. big bird that they

36:02

couldn't, you know, obviously this was like.

36:05

I've been playing Monster

36:07

Hunter recently and I

36:09

am imagining some adversaries

36:12

that I have had

36:14

to defeat that were

36:16

quite challenging. Some monstrous

36:18

adversaries. Monster Hunter is

36:20

a very hard game. You would hate it. You

36:23

would hate it so much. You

36:25

would want nothing to do with it.

36:28

I already don't. I won't even play

36:30

it by myself. It's not like it's

36:32

scary. It's just genuinely challenging combat. So

36:34

it's the only game that I'm using

36:36

my headset, getting out with my friend

36:38

Aaron, and when I'm like, meet me

36:40

at this rally point because I

36:42

have to defeat this monster, and I

36:45

need your help because I'm a little

36:47

pussy and I can't do it myself. Talk

36:50

on our little mic. Ew,

36:53

what was that gross way you

36:55

talked to each other? Oh,

36:57

no, we just... to make the

36:59

same sound effect as Link from

37:01

Ocarina of Time when he's like

37:03

fighting something. He just goes like. Oh,

37:06

right. So

37:12

I'll be over at Robbie's and like want

37:14

something from Aaron from another room and just

37:16

be like. Robbie

37:18

hates it. I hate it.

37:22

Ew. Gross. Yeah.

37:25

Why'd you go down an octave for the

37:27

last one? Oh, that was him and I

37:29

was the other. Yeah, that was him responding.

37:33

Sick. I'm never talking

37:35

to Aaron ever again. I

37:37

mean, that might be out of

37:39

your control, depending on what voice

37:41

memos I send you later this

37:43

week. Ew. Don't

37:45

make me get perverted revenge.

37:50

Back to the on. So

37:52

its nest was in the middle of

37:54

the lake. In my mind, it's floating

37:56

in the middle of the lake. Right.

37:58

So the waters of the lake come

38:00

out from the nest because they knew

38:02

that there were no real rivers feeding

38:05

it. They just had those mountain streams

38:07

like Wallace. Water has to come from

38:09

somewhere. It's coming from Ong's nest in

38:11

the middle of the lake. So the

38:13

Ong would make the waters rush out

38:15

and then flow back to the nest.

38:18

which I think is like alluding to

38:20

the currents of the lake, where

38:22

the nest would siphon out the food

38:24

for the Ong. So like fish. It

38:27

would splash around the water

38:29

and it would use the

38:31

nest as a sieve to

38:33

get its food from the

38:35

lake. But the Ong's favorite

38:37

was human flesh. Despite

38:39

this, he was described as

38:41

a coward, even though he was

38:44

really big and powerful. Birds

38:47

scare easy. They do.

38:49

So they said he wouldn't ever attack

38:51

two or more people in a group. So

38:53

basically they were like, don't ever go

38:55

out by yourself. Don't ever go

38:57

out on a boat by yourself. No.

39:00

Stay buddy system. So one day the

39:03

chief of the tribe had to choose

39:05

a husband for his daughter, Nona, before

39:07

leaving the lake for the winter. In

39:09

the hills above, a young man named

39:11

Tahoe had been meditating and praying since

39:13

he had no acts of valor to

39:15

recommend him as husband to the chief's

39:17

daughter. So he had a crush on

39:19

the chief's daughter. He basically had nothing

39:21

on his resume. Yeah. I was like,

39:24

OK, I have to do something really

39:26

drastic. Yeah. So as

39:28

he's looking out over the

39:30

lake, who shows up but Ong?

39:32

Oh, no. Young Tahoe

39:34

gets the Ong's attention like,

39:36

hey, over here. Ong

39:38

snatches him up and Ong was going

39:40

to fly up really high and

39:42

then drop him into the nest waters

39:45

so he could come down and

39:47

eat him. But the young

39:49

man, Tahoe, brought a long

39:51

buckskin rope with him and tied

39:53

the Ong's legs together and then

39:55

tied himself to the other end

39:57

so that when Ong tried to

39:59

drop him, he couldn't do it.

40:01

They were tied together. Love

40:03

it. Love There's a struggle and

40:05

then they both. careen

40:08

into the lake. The

40:10

rest of the tribe, while, you know,

40:12

upset about the loss of the young man,

40:14

well, what are you going to do?

40:16

They continue the council to select a husband

40:18

for Nona. Nona's like,

40:20

ah, but I actually really liked

40:22

him. Yeah, that's my boy. So

40:24

she sneaks off, takes a canoe

40:26

out into the lake, saying, Tahoe,

40:28

my darling Tahoe, as she searches

40:30

for the man she loves the

40:32

next morning. Okay, so. I

40:35

pictured this as like the

40:37

end of Moana. Okay. What I

40:39

think the legend says is

40:41

the two lovers arrive back on

40:43

shore riding on one of

40:45

Ong's wings while the other wing

40:47

is being used as a

40:49

sail. Oh, damn. They made a

40:51

boat out of that bird.

40:53

They made a fucking sailboat out

40:55

of Ong's remains. Sick. And

40:57

they just drift up on shore.

40:59

Yes. Tahoe was decided

41:01

that he was a worthy husband

41:03

for Nona. As

41:05

long as Ong's nest remains

41:07

in the lake, the drowned never

41:09

rise in Lake Tahoe. So

41:11

is there something in the center

41:14

of the lake? No. To

41:16

this day? It's just saying like

41:18

as long as Ong's nest

41:20

is still there, then the lake

41:22

will never give up. It's

41:24

dead. The current. But really, in

41:26

actuality, the waters in the

41:28

lake are cold enough that an

41:30

almost perfectly preserved body of

41:33

one of said divers was

41:35

found at a depth

41:37

of 300 feet 17 years

41:39

after they went missing. Damn.

41:44

Pretty preserved. So I think it's

41:46

kind of like Lake Superior where

41:48

it's so cold at a certain

41:50

depth that you're not going anywhere.

41:52

You're down there. Oh, God. Yeah. Nope.

41:56

So Lake Tahoe, fascinating. I definitely want

41:58

to go there someday. Yeah, but I'll

42:00

be staying on shore. I'll dip my

42:02

feet in. Don't go anywhere by yourself.

42:04

You'll get snatched up. That's fair. I'll

42:06

swim to the extent that, like, I

42:08

can still touch. Kind of like how

42:11

I respect the ocean. I'll

42:13

go swimming in the ocean, but not, like,

42:15

open water. I'm not jumping

42:17

off a boat. No. Into Lake Tahoe

42:19

or an ocean. Uh -uh. I wouldn't jump

42:21

off a boat into Lake Superior. I

42:23

mean, I get freaked out jumping off

42:25

a boat in Lake Minnetonka. Yeah. Water's

42:28

just a little too dark. Mm -hmm. It's

42:31

a little too... I feel like I'm jumping

42:33

off a cliff. Yeah, it's a little scary. If

42:35

you think about it too hard, it's not

42:37

great. Okay, so I

42:39

do have a case for us today. Okay.

42:41

It is tied to Lake Tahoe, but not

42:43

really till the end. But this

42:45

is the story of

42:47

the I -5 Strangler. Ooh,

42:50

yuck. And

42:52

a lot of this is from

42:54

Bruce Henderson's book called Trace Evidence,

42:56

The Hunt for an Elusive Serial

42:58

Killer. Okay, drama. Okay, give

43:00

away the ending. Roger

43:02

Reese Kibbe. Was born

43:04

on May 21st, 1939, a

43:07

Gemini in San

43:09

Diego County, California. Not

43:11

a lot known about

43:13

his upbringing, just

43:16

I think because it was,

43:18

you know, the 40s. But

43:20

his mother allegedly was abusive

43:22

and at school he was

43:24

bullied for his stutter. As

43:26

a teenager, he was arrested

43:29

for petty theft and prowling. He

43:31

was observed stealing women's

43:33

bathing suits and stockings.

43:37

Not loving this so far.

43:39

He's a creepy motherfucker. Henderson

43:42

claims in the book that Kibbe

43:44

enjoyed tying himself up with women's

43:46

underwear and cutting the clothes up

43:49

with scissors. There was something about

43:51

cutting the women's clothes with scissors.

43:53

And when? What age were these

43:55

behaviors? Teenager. Yeah, okay.

43:57

I mean, not that

43:59

like... I'm a big fan

44:01

of that in general. No,

44:04

a specific incident was when

44:06

he was, I think, 15. But

44:08

yeah, when you're really there's

44:10

a difference, obviously, between these behaviors

44:12

when you're very young and

44:14

these behaviors as like a consenting

44:16

adult in a, you know,

44:18

trusted relation with some with another

44:21

consenting adults. Like, I don't

44:23

care when you cut up women's

44:25

clothes as long as that's

44:27

like the extent and. everyone is

44:29

consenting and it never escalates

44:31

to anything worse which it definitely

44:33

does yeah but this is

44:35

yeah this is going somewhere scary

44:37

i don't like it okay

44:39

so cutting up the clothes with

44:41

scissors one source said that

44:43

his like criminal record had a

44:45

note in it this is

44:47

when he was 15 about being

44:49

caught trying to bury a

44:51

box filled with stolen cut up

44:54

women's clothing Yikes. All right.

44:56

Cool. Cool, cool, cool, cool, cool,

44:58

cool, cool, cool, cool, cool.

45:00

As an adult, he sold furniture

45:02

as a job and in

45:04

his free time, he enjoyed skydiving.

45:07

What? Which I thought was so random

45:09

for an activity in like the

45:11

60s and 70s, but it is important.

45:13

We will get back to the

45:15

skydiving. Not at all what I thought

45:17

you were going to list as

45:20

like a hobby. It's like another Mad

45:22

Lib case. Yes, seriously. While

45:24

trying to distribute cheeseburgers to the

45:26

homeless. I don't think that episode will

45:28

have come out yet by the

45:30

time this episode comes out. Spoiler. That's

45:32

in the April gag. Teaser. Teaser. Well,

45:36

it was yesterday to me, so.

45:38

Literally, we recorded it yesterday, so it

45:40

is easy to get confused. Yeah.

45:43

Okay, so he settled down and

45:45

married a woman named Harriet,

45:47

who was allegedly very domineering, according

45:50

again to Henderson's book. But

45:52

also like same. Don't marry me

45:54

if you're. Don't marry me

45:56

if you're going to wreck all

45:58

my underwear. Right. I'm

46:00

going to be domineering if I have

46:02

like shapes cut out of my bras

46:04

and stuff. Yeah. And I'm going to

46:07

be pissed. Very domineering. That was like

46:09

the only description of his wife. So

46:12

rude. So rude.

46:14

A newspaper in Stockton also

46:16

reported that his brother was

46:19

a homicide detective. So

46:21

in hindsight, this led people

46:23

to speculate that it's possible that

46:25

he like talked to his

46:27

brother, asked his brother a lot

46:29

of questions about police procedures

46:32

and in particular evidence collection in

46:34

order to learn how to

46:36

cover his tracks. Okay. The activities

46:38

last from 1977 to 1986

46:40

or 87, about a decade, but

46:43

like that particular decade. So

46:45

think of that when we're talking

46:47

about like the evidence. Okay.

46:49

What he might have learned about the

46:51

evidence collection. Okay. Jumping

46:53

forward to September of 1977.

46:56

Best of my love by the emotions is

46:58

at the top of the charts. You got

47:00

the best of my love. You

47:02

got the best of my

47:04

love. Along with the Star

47:07

Wars theme song. Oh, hell

47:09

yeah. 77. What a year.

47:11

My parents graduated high school in

47:13

76. Oh, wow. Yeah, my parents

47:15

were definitely in college. But yeah,

47:17

that would be such a fun

47:19

year. The summer of 77. They

47:21

might have been out of college by

47:23

77. Because they waited a while before

47:25

having my sister. And then five years

47:27

later, they finally got everything they wanted.

47:29

Not me. Finally

47:32

at the jackpot. Finally at the

47:34

jackpot. After slogging through five years

47:36

alone with that nightmare. Just

47:39

kidding. We love you. You're the better of

47:41

the two. Trust me. I

47:43

second that. Trust me. Ashley,

47:45

can we talk more? Okay. Okay.

47:50

Remember when we watched the Vanderpump reunion

47:52

after Scandaball? On Zoom together. The

47:54

three of us on Zoom. That

47:57

was a good time. That was really fun.

47:59

You can talk to her whenever you want. I'm

48:01

sure she'd love it. Probably.

48:03

Who wouldn't? Who wouldn't? Apparently,

48:05

Kibbe was bored at

48:07

this time back in

48:10

September 77. No skydiving

48:12

trips? That wasn't

48:14

fulfilling him anymore. He

48:16

decided to place a fake ad in

48:18

a newspaper, like an employment ad, like looking

48:20

for an employee, know, like a job,

48:22

a job ad. Right, right. In

48:24

order to find a victim

48:27

to assault, 21 -year -old Llewellyn Burley,

48:29

Llewellyn Burley answered the ad.

48:31

Kibbe said that his, oh, my

48:33

office is under construction. Why

48:35

don't we meet in my van?

48:38

Absolutely not. But

48:41

she did. He then drove

48:43

her to Lake Berryessa in Napa

48:45

County, where he raped and

48:47

strangled her before dumping her body

48:50

in a nearby riverbed. No.

48:52

When Llewellyn was reported missing, Kibbe

48:54

was briefly considered a suspect,

48:56

according to the L .A.

48:58

Times. But alas, Llewellyn would

49:01

not be found for another

49:03

30 years. 30 plus. So

49:05

sad. On April 21st, 1986.

49:07

So this is almost a decade

49:09

later. This is like 11

49:11

and a half years later. Okay.

49:13

A woman named Laura Hedick.

49:15

One article said Lori, but more

49:17

of them said Laura. Okay.

49:20

She was also 21 years old.

49:22

She was seen getting into

49:24

the car of a man in

49:26

his 50s, and she was

49:28

never seen again. So Laura would

49:30

sometimes engage in sex work

49:32

due to her addiction issues. Of

49:34

course, that doesn't describe her

49:36

as a full individual person. Right.

49:38

Of course not. But again,

49:40

I don't have a lot of

49:42

information here, especially about the

49:44

women in this case. In

49:46

September of that year, so

49:48

that's like five or six months

49:50

later, her remains were found

49:52

off of I -5, which

49:54

was southeast of Sacramento. She had

49:57

also been raped. Investigators

49:59

noted odd shapes were cut

50:01

out of her tank top before

50:03

it was used to strangle

50:05

her. So he cut up her

50:07

shirt and then killed her

50:09

with it. Uh -huh. The pattern. Laura's

50:12

boyfriend at the time saw the man

50:14

who picked her up and described him

50:16

to the cops so they could make

50:18

a composite sketch. Okay. So they have

50:20

a composite sketch. So like I said,

50:22

that was April 1986. After

50:24

that, things really begin to

50:26

escalate like very quickly, considering

50:28

it was almost 10 years

50:30

between his first known victim

50:32

and this second known. So

50:34

that same year, 1986, in

50:36

July. So this would

50:39

be before Laura's body was discovered. Kibbe

50:41

abducts Barbara Ann Scott, age 29,

50:43

before killing her and dumping her

50:46

body along a stretch of road

50:48

in Contra Costa County. That

50:50

was on July 3rd. On July

50:52

15th, 19 -year -old Stephanie Brown was

50:54

abducted. Her car was found abandoned

50:56

on I -5 and her body

50:58

was found in a drainage ditch. Like

51:02

the other victims, she had

51:04

also been raped and strangled. The

51:06

NBC Sacramento affiliate said that

51:08

portions of her hair had been

51:10

cut with scissors. Oh, so

51:13

this isn't like hair that had

51:15

been like grabbed maybe in

51:17

a struggle. This was like taking

51:19

as a memento cut. It

51:21

was cut. Intentional. Oh,

51:23

no. Yeah. One

51:26

month later on October

51:28

17th, Charmaine Sabra,

51:30

age 26. This

51:32

is so gross. Was

51:34

driving home with her mother when their

51:36

car broke down along I -5. Surprise,

51:39

surprise. What do you know? A good

51:41

Samaritan stops by to help. But oh

51:43

no, he can only take one person

51:45

in his car into town. No.

51:48

Charmaine's remains were not discovered

51:50

for three months. Her

51:52

body showed signs of sexual abuse,

51:54

strangulation, and both her clothing

51:56

and her hair had portions cut.

51:58

Away with scissors. Wow.

52:01

So obviously now people are worried

52:03

there's a serial killer on the

52:05

loose. Because they have a string

52:07

of bodies. Then they were all

52:09

found along I -5. The

52:11

police began to utilize

52:13

undercover female officers to pose

52:15

as broken down motorists. Witness

52:18

statements described the suspect as a

52:20

middle -aged man with a big

52:22

nose. So that kind of went

52:24

into the composite sketch. During

52:26

this dragnet operation, Kibbe actually

52:28

did get stopped on a

52:31

routine traffic violation. But they

52:33

didn't put it together. They

52:35

didn't clock it as him.

52:37

The cops were surprised at

52:39

how much he looked like

52:41

the composite sketch. So

52:43

I have a picture of the composite sketch

52:45

and his mugshot. Oh, my God. This is

52:47

so funny because I also have a side -by

52:49

-side composite and mugshot in my case. It's

52:51

not the same case, but there are similarities. Do

52:54

you see it? The

52:56

jawline, the lips, the nose. That's

53:00

shocking. Uh -huh. Whoa.

53:03

Yeah. I'm kind of surprised

53:05

they missed his mole in

53:07

the composite, but otherwise. Yeah.

53:10

I mean, I don't know who

53:12

else were the witnesses. Sure. Except

53:14

for the boyfriend of Laura. Okay.

53:16

And I think she got into

53:18

his car at night. Okay. So

53:20

she might not have seen it.

53:22

Yeah, it's like, I don't if

53:24

they didn't meet like face to

53:26

face. I

53:28

don't know. But yeah, considering how

53:31

little they had to go

53:33

on from a singular witness testimony

53:35

to make this composite, it's

53:37

very good. Maybe

53:39

Charmaine's mother also would have been able to

53:41

give, you know, because she she was

53:43

with Charmaine when the car broke down

53:45

and Charmaine went with. Sure. She would have

53:48

seen him. Yeah. But

53:50

OK, so I. Different

53:52

sources said different things. So

53:54

either the cops saw him, looked

53:56

at the composite sketch and

53:58

was like, oh, shit. And he

54:00

was driving a similar car

54:03

that matched the witness statements. OK.

54:05

Either they just photographed his

54:07

car and sent him

54:09

on his way or they

54:12

searched his car at

54:14

this point where they found

54:16

nylon parachute cord. Oh, the

54:18

skydiving. Mm hmm. scissors, and

54:21

handcuffs. Oh, it's not looking good

54:23

for you, Kibbe. Either way,

54:25

he was questioned but released without

54:27

charges being filed because they

54:29

just did not have sufficient evidence,

54:31

whether they had just photographed

54:34

the car or if they searched

54:36

the car at this time

54:38

or in the next incident. I

54:41

mean, I guess, but I

54:43

hate that. Before the end

54:45

of 1986, Kibbe would kill

54:47

another woman named Catherine Kelly

54:49

Quinonez, aged 25. Finally,

54:52

in September of 1987, he

54:54

was arrested after he tried to

54:56

abduct a sex worker in

54:58

downtown Sacramento. So this badass fought

55:00

back when he was trying

55:02

to handcuff her and just screamed.

55:05

Good for her. And a

55:07

cop intervened, heard her screaming. And

55:09

after taking him into custody. They

55:11

impounded his car and they found

55:14

evidence which linked him to the

55:16

I -5 killings. So whether they

55:18

searched his car earlier when they

55:20

stopped him for that traffic stop

55:22

or they didn't search it till

55:25

they impounded his car now. They

55:27

eventually found. They eventually found evidence. And

55:30

since they wanted time to gather all the evidence because

55:32

they were like, oh, my God, if this guy is

55:34

responsible for these. Five or

55:36

six other homicides. We need time

55:38

to get all the evidence and

55:40

build all the cases. Sure. So

55:42

in the meantime, they were able

55:44

to get him for battery and

55:46

solicitation for trying to abduct the

55:48

woman in Sacramento, which put him

55:50

behind bars for eight months while

55:52

they could continue their investigation. Damn. He

55:55

was first brought to trial

55:57

for the murder of 17

55:59

-year -old Darcy Frackenpole. Hmm. So

56:01

she was a runaway whose

56:03

body had been found in

56:06

1987 near Lake Tahoe, where

56:08

Kibbe's brother, the homicide investigator,

56:11

lived. Wait. So that's the connection

56:13

to Lake Tahoe. It's kind of

56:15

tenuous. I'm sorry. Wait, did I

56:17

miss that Kibbe's brother was investigating? I

56:20

don't think he was investigating this

56:22

case, but he was a homicide investigator.

56:25

Jesus. Because that's when we

56:27

said, well, in hindsight. Some people think

56:29

that he was able to ask his

56:31

brother about evidence collection. Okay. And that's

56:33

why it took them so long to

56:35

get him. Yep. I

56:38

mean, that is a very

56:40

reasonable speculation. Not

56:42

all of our speculations are reasonable,

56:44

but like... We'll kind of get...

56:46

We'll get to it a little

56:48

bit more. Oh, fuck. Okay. So

56:50

Darcy had been strangled using that

56:52

same type of cord that Kivy

56:54

had been using for skydiving, the

56:56

parachute cord. the fibers of

56:58

which were also linked to

57:00

three other killings. So he used

57:02

the exact same cord. Oh.

57:05

Parachute cord. Oh,

57:07

God. He had

57:09

a literal murder

57:11

kit containing handcuffs

57:13

and a pair

57:15

of his mother's

57:17

scissors, his abusive

57:19

mother's scissors. That's

57:21

what he was using to cut up. happens

57:23

when you don't heal from your trauma? It

57:26

kind of reminded me of you when you

57:28

stole your mom's sewing scissors. Yeah, but I stole

57:30

them because they were cute and their handles

57:32

were like little goose. It was like a little

57:34

goose. Oh, I know. And I wanted to

57:36

try cutting my own bangs. And it was a

57:38

disaster. As long as you're

57:41

not cutting anyone else's bangs. was five.

57:43

I know. His mother's scissors.

57:45

You kind of remind me of this serial killer

57:47

who used his mom's scissors. I didn't say you

57:49

reminded me. I don't think I said that. Meant

57:52

to say this reminds

57:54

me. You remind me

57:56

of a girl that

57:58

I once knew. Anyway.

58:00

In 1991, Kibbe

58:02

is convicted of first degree murder

58:04

and sentenced to 25 to life.

58:07

Everyone is certain that he's the I -5

58:09

strangler at this point. But apparently there

58:11

were like jurisdictional complications and like a

58:13

lack of hard evidence. And it just

58:15

took a while. He also like wasn't

58:18

really talking. It took him a while

58:20

to like. say anything

58:22

about where these where these victims

58:24

were okay okay so here

58:26

is the grossest part according to

58:28

me the prosecutors alleged that

58:30

kibbe would handcuff his victims to

58:32

abduct them he'd wrap duct

58:35

tape all way around their head

58:37

and their mouth to silence

58:39

them oh my god then he

58:41

would do whatever he did

58:43

assault them cut their clothes use

58:45

his parachute cord to strangle

58:47

them sometimes he turned it into

58:50

a garrotte Oh, God. And

58:52

then he would use the scissors

58:54

to cut the tape off

58:56

of their hair so he wasn't

58:58

leaving any tape behind. Tape

59:00

evidence. Because they could

59:03

get fingerprints off of tape. Oh,

59:05

he was thinking more about the

59:07

fingerprints than the actual like. The

59:09

homicide investigator brother. Oh, yeah.

59:11

Wait, what the fuck? I think

59:13

that he knew that they could get

59:15

fingerprints off of things like duct

59:17

tape. so instead of just ripping i

59:19

don't know he used the scissors

59:21

to get the tape off of the

59:23

girl's head totally so the the

59:26

cut hair wasn't even a memento it

59:28

was just uh yeah something that

59:30

happened when he was cutting the tape

59:32

off as part of his mo

59:34

i could have been both but yeah

59:36

isn't that fucking gross that's so

59:38

gross it's all gross but like i

59:40

assumed you meant that like locks

59:42

of hair were cut but that like

59:44

the hair as a whole wasn't

59:46

necessarily super disturbed but yeah if you're

59:48

wrapping the whole there's probably a

59:50

lot of hair that was cut oh

59:52

oh my god because none of

59:55

the articles said like you know like

59:57

a lock of her you know

59:59

like no a chunk of her hair

1:00:01

was cut it just said her

1:00:03

her hair had been cut with scissors

1:00:05

yep oh isn't that nasty i

1:00:07

hate it Okay, so

1:00:09

he's sitting in jail at this point.

1:00:11

Finally, in the 2000s, we get the

1:00:13

technology to analyze DNA evidence. Because

1:00:15

remember, I think all of these

1:00:17

women were sexually assaulted. In

1:00:20

2008, Kibbe was indicted on

1:00:22

six counts of murder and

1:00:24

multiple special circumstances. Meaning

1:00:26

there was evidence of him doing

1:00:29

something extra fucked up that would like

1:00:31

amp up the sentence. Do you

1:00:33

know what I'm saying? Pile

1:00:36

on those charges, bitch. So

1:00:38

he got one special circumstance

1:00:40

for each victim, which made

1:00:42

him eligible for the death

1:00:44

penalty. On September 29th, 2009,

1:00:46

he pled guilty to the

1:00:48

rape and murders of Llewellyn

1:00:50

Burley, Laura Hedick, Barbara Ann

1:00:52

Scott, Stephanie Brown, Charmaine

1:00:54

Smith, and Catherine Kelly Quinonez.

1:00:56

Damn. This plea, as well

1:00:58

as agreeing to lead investigators

1:01:00

to his first victim, Llewellyn,

1:01:02

was enough to keep the

1:01:05

death penalty off the table. So

1:01:08

he did bring them to like

1:01:10

a it was like a site

1:01:12

near like a river. Yeah. He's

1:01:14

just to save his own ass

1:01:16

from the death penalty. But they

1:01:18

didn't find anything. And then like

1:01:20

two years later, they brought him

1:01:22

back there. They again didn't find

1:01:24

anything. Two years after that, an

1:01:26

investigator went back to that site

1:01:28

by himself and ended up finding

1:01:31

finding. a bone that belonged to

1:01:33

her damn so she really was

1:01:35

where he said she was right

1:01:37

they just didn't find her they

1:01:39

just didn't find her those two

1:01:41

times where kibby was with the

1:01:43

investigators it was another person who

1:01:45

went like you know off the

1:01:47

clock or whatever yeah and when

1:01:49

you think about it her her

1:01:51

remains had been out there for

1:01:53

so long animals the elements like

1:01:56

because that was in 70s Yeah.

1:01:58

And this was in 2011. It's not

1:02:00

not about to do that math. It's not

1:02:02

unbelievable to think that he would give

1:02:05

the right location, but that they wouldn't find

1:02:07

anything there for a long time. I'm

1:02:09

glad that they eventually fucking did. Mm

1:02:11

hmm. Oh, God. These poor

1:02:13

women. Here's the best part.

1:02:15

In March of 2021, Kibbe was

1:02:17

found unresponsive in his jail

1:02:19

cell. Bye. Medical

1:02:21

staff immediately responded. He was transported to

1:02:23

the prison's health care facility, and

1:02:25

despite life -saving measures, he was pronounced

1:02:28

dead at 1 .20 a .m. An

1:02:30

investigation led to his cellmate,

1:02:32

Jason Boudreaux, himself a convicted

1:02:34

killer and a Satanist. Not

1:02:36

that that matters. And he

1:02:39

was charged with murder in

1:02:41

Kibbe's death. Guess how he

1:02:43

killed him? Well... were

1:02:45

cellmates, so they probably didn't have

1:02:47

a whole lot of access to

1:02:49

stuff, but I'm going to lean

1:02:51

into irony and say he tore

1:02:53

up parts of his clothes or

1:02:55

something and choked him. Well, he

1:02:57

strangled him to death. Okay. But

1:02:59

given the fact that he was

1:03:01

called the I -5 Strangler and

1:03:03

he killed at least seven women,

1:03:05

six or seven women by strangling

1:03:07

them. You know? Seems like a,

1:03:10

you know. It's fitting. Not that

1:03:12

I condone, you know, whatever, blah,

1:03:14

blah, blah, blah, blah. Seems like

1:03:16

a fitting end for this fucking

1:03:18

asshole. It's fucking fitting. All

1:03:20

right. That's the I -5 Strangler.

1:03:22

Damn. What a turd. little

1:03:24

bit about Lake Tahoe. Lake Tahoe. I want

1:03:26

to go real bad. I do too.

1:03:28

I want to go to Pyramid Lake. Oh,

1:03:30

well, let's take a break to hear

1:03:32

a word from our sponsors, the sponsors that

1:03:34

we need so that one day we

1:03:36

can go to Lake Tahoe and Pyramid Lake.

1:03:39

Also join us on Uncorked. That would also

1:03:41

help us get there. Shopping

1:03:45

can be a nightmare. The

1:03:47

lighting in those dressing rooms is

1:03:49

a targeted attack. It's a

1:03:51

paid actor and it's offensive and

1:03:53

I want her fired. I

1:03:55

want her offset immediately. And this

1:03:58

is why I am so

1:04:00

in love with Stitch Fix online

1:04:02

personal styling. It makes it

1:04:04

so easy. Shopping and figuring

1:04:06

out your style. It's overwhelming.

1:04:08

It just is. And I, when

1:04:10

I panic, if I'm at the

1:04:12

store, I just go to all

1:04:14

the black items. My whole closet

1:04:16

is black. Yep. And I'm trying

1:04:18

to really branch out like very

1:04:21

intentionally this year. And look, I'm

1:04:23

wearing gray right now. Obsessed. I

1:04:25

just need more color. And I told

1:04:28

my stylist this and they're sending me.

1:04:30

the cutest stuff that's still like kind

1:04:32

of boxy and shapeless the way that

1:04:34

I like my clothes but it's like

1:04:36

fun patterns new styles when it comes

1:04:38

to getting dressed I get these pieces

1:04:40

from my stylist. They make me look

1:04:42

great. It's a real confidence boost. So

1:04:45

I just give my stylist my size,

1:04:47

my style, my budget preferences. And I

1:04:49

can order boxes when I want and

1:04:51

how I want with no subscription required.

1:04:53

And then she just sends just for

1:04:55

me pieces, plus outfit recommendations and styling

1:04:57

tips. I really love the little pamphlet

1:04:59

that comes with it. I do too.

1:05:02

It's so helpful and cute. I know.

1:05:04

Even if it's like, yeah, dummy, you

1:05:06

wear this with a pair of jeans

1:05:08

and some. loafers and

1:05:10

a cute little bag. It's

1:05:12

like genius. Genius. It's just

1:05:14

really fun to look at and

1:05:16

it just feels so individual to

1:05:18

me. I keep what

1:05:20

I love. I send back the rest. It

1:05:23

could not be easier. My stylist sends

1:05:25

personalized pieces and the fit is flawless. I

1:05:27

know I've said this before. The only

1:05:29

jeans I wear. Same. Two pairs,

1:05:31

both from Stitch Fix. I'll never go back.

1:05:33

I have like six pairs of Stitch Fix

1:05:35

jeans now. And yeah, same. Never go back.

1:05:37

Never go back. I don't know how they

1:05:39

do it, but they do it. It's like

1:05:41

having my own personal style support person. Emotional

1:05:44

support stylist. So no stores, no

1:05:46

crowds, no stress. Just personalized looks you're

1:05:48

going to love. Stitch Fix makes

1:05:50

it all so easy. Personal

1:05:52

styling for everyone. Get started

1:05:54

today at stitchfix.com slash

1:05:56

wine and crime. That's stitchfix.com

1:05:58

slash wine and crime. This

1:06:01

episode of Wine and Crime

1:06:03

is brought to you by Graza,

1:06:05

my new favorite olive oil.

1:06:08

It's fresh, it's never blended, and

1:06:10

it comes from a single

1:06:12

type of olive, the Piquel, straight

1:06:14

out of high -end Spain, where

1:06:16

over half of the world's

1:06:18

olive oil is produced. Listen, high

1:06:20

-end is high -end, because this

1:06:22

olive oil is, like, the best

1:06:24

in the world. It is

1:06:26

just single origin goodness. It's made

1:06:28

with only one olive from

1:06:31

one region. There's no mystery blends.

1:06:33

That means a traceable, fresher

1:06:35

product without mixing in any lower

1:06:37

grade or mystery oils. It's

1:06:39

pure, people. No more messy

1:06:41

tins or drippy spouts. Just aim

1:06:43

that cute little squeeze bottle

1:06:46

and spray it right in your

1:06:48

hot pan and go from

1:06:50

there. The trio has

1:06:52

three types of olive oil for

1:06:54

any task. They have the frizzle,

1:06:56

which is their newest one. It

1:06:58

has a higher smoke point of

1:07:00

490 degrees Fahrenheit. So this is

1:07:02

perfect for like frying, crisping or

1:07:05

grilling. If you are the type

1:07:07

to set off your smoke alarm

1:07:09

in the kitchen with regularity. Are

1:07:11

you speaking to me? Yes, I

1:07:13

am speaking to you. I see you. The

1:07:16

frizzle might just be exactly what you

1:07:18

need. It's not going to, like, blow

1:07:23

up your whole spot. Yeah.

1:07:25

Concerns from the neighbors have decreased

1:07:27

considerably since switching to frizzle

1:07:29

to cook. I should get my

1:07:31

neighbors this trio because their

1:07:33

smoke alarm goes off kind of

1:07:35

a lot when they're cooking.

1:07:37

And I always text. I just

1:07:39

said, King, are you good?

1:07:41

Making a roast? They

1:07:45

also have their sizzle oil. So

1:07:47

this has a 410 degree smoke

1:07:49

point. So this is your everyday

1:07:51

cooking oil for roasting, marinating, and

1:07:53

sauteing. And then... my favorite, the

1:07:55

drizzle. It's this bold, punchy finishing

1:07:57

oil you can sprinkle on salads.

1:07:59

You can put it on ice

1:08:01

cream. Dip your bread in it.

1:08:04

This is like your table olive

1:08:06

oil. That's just absolutely delicious. So

1:08:08

you get 10 % on your

1:08:10

first order on Graz's site, but

1:08:12

I personally suggest grabbing that trio

1:08:14

that I told you about. That's

1:08:16

all three squeezy bottles. You got

1:08:18

your sizzle, your frizzle, and your

1:08:20

drizzle. So you are set for

1:08:22

every style of cooking. So

1:08:24

head to Graza .co and use

1:08:26

code GALS to get 10 %

1:08:29

off TRIO, which includes sizzle, frizzle,

1:08:31

and drizzle, and get cooking

1:08:33

your next chef -quality meal. A

1:08:35

good book is great, but

1:08:37

what if you had an

1:08:39

endless library of delicious romance

1:08:42

at your fingertips? With

1:08:44

Galatea, you don't just read. You

1:08:46

get swept away in every stolen

1:08:48

glance and every heart -pounding touch

1:08:50

you just can't stop thinking about.

1:08:52

Whatever kind of love story you

1:08:55

crave, you'll find it on Galatea.

1:08:57

Galatea is a reading app where

1:08:59

anyone craving a little me time

1:09:01

can dive into a library of

1:09:03

romance stories that leave you feeling

1:09:05

recharged and fulfilled. There are

1:09:07

over a thousand bestsellers to choose

1:09:10

from shifter romance to bad

1:09:12

boy billionaires, forbidden love, werewolf alphas,

1:09:14

slow burn fantasy, teen drama,

1:09:16

and much, much more. Galatea is

1:09:18

home to original series and

1:09:20

standalone stories with an exclusive catalog

1:09:22

of bestselling authors with new

1:09:25

chapters. dropping daily, babes. So there

1:09:27

is always something new to

1:09:29

explore. If you are like ravenous

1:09:31

for the literature, Galatea is

1:09:33

your girl. She's your gal. Over

1:09:35

30 million people have fallen

1:09:37

in love with reading on Galatea.

1:09:40

So join now to indulge

1:09:42

in stories that make you feel

1:09:44

like yourself again. Right now,

1:09:46

Galatea is offering our listeners an

1:09:48

extra 25 % off on top

1:09:50

of an already irresistibly affordable

1:09:52

subscription when you go to galatea.com

1:09:55

slash gals. That's G -A -L -A

1:09:57

-T -E -A dot com slash gals

1:09:59

to indulge in unlimited stories

1:10:01

for even less. Galatea dot com

1:10:03

slash gals. My

1:10:06

case is also really sad and

1:10:08

there are a lot of similarities

1:10:10

and it's from the 70s. It's

1:10:12

not the same, but it's kind

1:10:14

of crazy. Great. It's kind of

1:10:16

crazy. How that panned out. Today,

1:10:18

I'm going to be taking you

1:10:20

back to 1970s Lake Tahoe and.

1:10:23

The story of the brutal murders of

1:10:25

two young women, Bryn

1:10:27

Rainey and Carol Anderson. For

1:10:30

decades, their families lived with unanswered

1:10:32

questions and their cases were just

1:10:34

getting colder and colder with each

1:10:36

passing year. There was definitely long

1:10:38

stretches of time when these families

1:10:40

likely assumed that they would never

1:10:42

know exactly what happened to their

1:10:44

children. So they knew they were

1:10:46

dead. They were found dead, but

1:10:49

they didn't know what happened. Correct.

1:10:52

Our first story begins in the summer

1:10:54

of 1977. Bryn Rainey,

1:10:56

a 27 -year -old originally from Ohio,

1:10:58

had recently moved to South Lake Tahoe

1:11:00

after falling in love with the

1:11:02

area while attending a family wedding there.

1:11:04

How cute is that? She

1:11:06

just loved it. just loved it. Drawn to

1:11:08

the beauty of the lake, she took a

1:11:11

job in that area as a Keno runner

1:11:13

at the Sahara Tahoe Casino in Stateline, Nevada.

1:11:15

And Keno is a lottery game that I,

1:11:17

like, I guess it's kind of like a

1:11:19

card game, but also kind of like bingo.

1:11:21

I could not for the life of me

1:11:23

figure it out. So if you want to

1:11:25

know more about that game, I am not

1:11:27

the one. Okay, listeners. I think it's, I

1:11:29

get it confused with Plinko. Yeah,

1:11:32

I mean, there's like a little card and

1:11:34

then there's like. You can play it on

1:11:36

like the big video screen. Yeah. Yeah,

1:11:39

I I couldn't figure it out

1:11:41

and I lost interest in trying

1:11:43

to understand it. I'm sorry, but

1:11:45

she was into it and she

1:11:47

worked at the casino like running

1:11:49

Kino. Okay. On the evening

1:11:51

of July 23rd, 1977, Brynn

1:11:53

had some spare time before her 2

1:11:55

a .m. shift because the casino is

1:11:57

open 24 hours. So people are on.

1:11:59

Shifts that wouldn't seem normal to us,

1:12:01

but that's normal for her. Imagine starting

1:12:03

work at 2 a .m. Girl, my body

1:12:05

could never, but, like, good for her.

1:12:07

Good for her. So she probably just

1:12:09

was like, all right, well, I'm awake.

1:12:11

I don't work till 2 a .m.

1:12:13

I'm going to go grab a drink

1:12:15

at the Bitter Creek Saloon before work.

1:12:17

The bartender later recalled seeing her that

1:12:19

night and noted that no one seemed

1:12:22

to bother her. No one even saw

1:12:24

her leave. Like, she was there. She

1:12:26

kept to herself. She had a drink

1:12:28

or two. It's she seemingly

1:12:30

just left of her own accord. We didn't

1:12:32

see anybody specifically with her or like trying

1:12:34

to lure her out or harassing her or

1:12:36

anything like that. Seems like a good thing.

1:12:38

It's a very good thing. But then Bryn

1:12:40

didn't show up for that 2 a .m.

1:12:42

shift. And her co -workers were

1:12:44

the first to notice her absence because she was

1:12:46

like always on time, such a good employee. And

1:12:49

fortunately, they tried to get in

1:12:51

touch with her and couldn't and cared

1:12:53

enough to call the police. And

1:12:56

have like a wellness check done on

1:12:58

her apartment. When authorities checked her

1:13:00

apartment on Emerald Bay Road in South

1:13:02

Lake Tahoe, they found the apartment

1:13:04

empty and nothing disturbed. It was like

1:13:06

Brynn had just vanished into thin

1:13:08

air. Or like left for work. Yeah,

1:13:10

but like left for work but

1:13:12

never made it to work. Had been

1:13:14

seen, clearly had been in her

1:13:16

apartment at some point, but it was

1:13:19

perfectly clean. Didn't pack anything. Last

1:13:21

place anybody else saw her was at

1:13:23

the bar and there was... weird

1:13:25

that happened at the bar. She quietly

1:13:27

had a drink and then she

1:13:29

left and then poof, she's gone. Never

1:13:31

makes it to work. For

1:13:33

nearly a month, she was

1:13:35

missing and they were family, friends,

1:13:37

authorities were looking for her.

1:13:40

I just can't imagine the constant

1:13:42

literal heartache of having a

1:13:44

loved one missing. No. The not

1:13:46

knowing is a kind of

1:13:48

hell that I can't even fathom.

1:13:50

I know. I think about

1:13:53

it every time we talk about

1:13:55

someone who's just, especially someone's

1:13:57

child is just missing. Yeah. I

1:13:59

can't, don't want to wrap

1:14:01

my head around that. No. Then

1:14:03

on August 20th, 1977, a

1:14:05

horseback rider at Stateline Stables made

1:14:08

a grim discovery. Oh, I

1:14:10

hate a grim discovery. I know.

1:14:12

A shallow grave along the

1:14:14

trails that they were riding. In

1:14:17

the grave, police found Bryn's

1:14:19

badly decomposed body. Her purse was

1:14:21

still there. Containing her identification.

1:14:23

It was buried nearby, but it

1:14:25

was like on the site.

1:14:27

You know, it did it. It

1:14:30

indicated that it wasn't like a

1:14:32

robbery. How did how did horseback

1:14:34

riders find a shallow grave? I

1:14:36

think it was just a foot

1:14:38

was sticking out. I think it

1:14:41

was very shallow and just very

1:14:43

obvious that like something was off.

1:14:45

It was haphazard to say the

1:14:47

least. OK. While

1:14:49

the extent of decomposition made it

1:14:52

difficult to determine the official cause

1:14:54

of death, because it would have

1:14:56

been August in this area, so

1:14:58

it's not cold. Yeah.

1:15:01

And she's in a very shallow grave

1:15:03

where I think she was exposed

1:15:05

to the elements, possibly animals, like... There's

1:15:07

animals around. For sure. So this

1:15:09

all made it difficult to determine the

1:15:11

official cause of death, but forensic

1:15:13

evidence suggested that Brynn had been sexually

1:15:16

assaulted and strangled. There was not

1:15:18

a lot of evidence at the scene.

1:15:20

They collected everything that they felt

1:15:22

was important at that time. You know,

1:15:24

they did the autopsy. They determined,

1:15:26

like, we can't be 100 % sure,

1:15:28

but we're pretty confident her cause of

1:15:30

death was strangulation. They were able

1:15:33

to find in some of the, like,

1:15:35

tissue that was left at the

1:15:37

arms and legs that there were possible

1:15:39

ligature marks. But again, it's like,

1:15:41

we're not 100 % sure, but it

1:15:43

could be this. If all

1:15:45

that... tissue is gone

1:15:47

or going away. Yeah.

1:15:50

It always kind of shocks

1:15:52

me how forensic pathologists

1:15:55

and coroners can kind even

1:15:57

get what they do

1:15:59

get. Yeah. Yeah. That

1:16:01

book Autopsy that I read by

1:16:03

that Australian dude, when I told

1:16:05

you about the death because you

1:16:07

move your neck wrong. Yeah, thanks.

1:16:11

It's like eagle neck syndrome or

1:16:13

something. No.

1:16:16

Him just going through the autopsies

1:16:18

of these various crazy deaths.

1:16:20

He's like, I noticed X, Y,

1:16:23

and Z. I'm like, how? That

1:16:25

training is really

1:16:27

important. remarkable. It is

1:16:30

remarkable. So good. So they don't

1:16:32

have a ton of evidence.

1:16:34

They don't have any witnesses. And

1:16:36

Bryn's case quickly goes cold.

1:16:38

Two years later, in the summer

1:16:40

of 1979, tragedy struck again.

1:16:42

16 -year -old Carol Ann Anderson lived

1:16:44

in Stateline, Nevada. On

1:16:46

June 30th, 1979, she went to a

1:16:48

house party near the Heavenly Ski

1:16:50

Resort. According to a 2015 news article,

1:16:52

Carol's sister mentioned that the teenager

1:16:55

had epilepsy and that her mother rarely

1:16:57

allowed her to go out because

1:16:59

of her condition, which to me, I

1:17:01

think, alludes to the possibility that

1:17:03

Carol snuck out. She's 16. She wants

1:17:05

to go do teenager things like

1:17:07

knowing her mom would likely say no.

1:17:09

This could easily have been any

1:17:11

of us at that age. We literally

1:17:13

did do this. Yeah. So

1:17:16

my first thought was hereditary when

1:17:18

the mom makes the brother take the

1:17:20

little sister, but she has like

1:17:22

this crazy nut allergy. Yeah. No, as

1:17:24

far as I know, Carolyn's sister

1:17:26

wasn't at the party. Okay. But that

1:17:28

Carolyn had just commented like, yeah,

1:17:30

she went to the party. Our mom

1:17:32

almost never let like anyone go

1:17:35

out. or never let her go out

1:17:37

because of her epilepsy. Mm -hmm. It

1:17:39

just triggered the hereditary. A thousand

1:17:41

percent. A thousand percent. So she

1:17:43

goes to the party, and as the night

1:17:45

wore on, Carol's friends left the party one

1:17:47

by one, each offering her a ride home,

1:17:49

which she declined. She wanted to stay and

1:17:51

make the most of a rare night out.

1:17:53

It's like, especially if she snuck out, it's

1:17:55

like, I'm going to get in trouble. I'm

1:17:57

making every minute count. Absolutely. The

1:17:59

last time anyone remembers seeing Carol

1:18:01

was around 1130 p .m., still at

1:18:03

the party. Police believe she likely left

1:18:05

the party on foot alone and

1:18:07

perhaps hitched a ride with a stranger,

1:18:09

which was a common practice for

1:18:12

teenagers in the 1970s, as we know

1:18:14

from the hitchhiking episode and many,

1:18:16

many times that's come up. Mm

1:18:18

-hmm. The following morning, someone

1:18:20

called the police to report finding

1:18:22

a body on Sundown Trail. Now,

1:18:24

this... read a couple things that -

1:18:26

Sundown Trail. I know, kind of

1:18:28

scary. But Sundown Trail, I think,

1:18:30

was like a side road because

1:18:33

another report said that she was

1:18:35

spotted by a passing motorist. So

1:18:37

I don't think this was a

1:18:39

hiking trail, kind of like the

1:18:41

horseback riding thing. This was clearly

1:18:43

- A road. But like this

1:18:45

area where she was found, it

1:18:48

wasn't exactly bustling, but it was

1:18:50

clear that he wasn't trying to

1:18:52

hide her. Okay. So that's like,

1:18:54

that's the distinction that I, that

1:18:56

I'm making from Bryn's site of

1:18:58

discovery and Carol's site of discovery.

1:19:00

Got it. The manner of her

1:19:03

death. Oh, sorry. It says, unlike

1:19:05

Bryn, no attempt had been made

1:19:07

to conceal Carol's body. So she

1:19:09

wasn't even in a shallow grave.

1:19:11

She was just like dropped there.

1:19:13

Passed out of the car. Possibly.

1:19:15

Or, you know, like,

1:19:18

yeah, I'm not sure. Because even

1:19:20

these crime scenes, like, because it

1:19:22

wasn't. Because there wasn't like blood

1:19:24

because they were strangled. They may

1:19:26

have been killed there. They may

1:19:28

have been killed somewhere else and

1:19:30

then left there. We're not sure.

1:19:32

We still don't know. The manner

1:19:34

of her death, Carol's death, bore

1:19:36

a chilling similarity to Brynn's death,

1:19:38

despite the fact that Carol wasn't

1:19:40

buried the way that Brynn was.

1:19:42

Ligature marks on Carol's wrists indicated

1:19:44

she'd been bound. And like Brynn,

1:19:46

Carol had been strangled and there

1:19:49

was evidence of sexual assault. though

1:19:51

Carol was fully clothed when her

1:19:53

remains were found. I don't know

1:19:55

exactly what the state of Bryn's

1:19:57

dress or undress was. I didn't

1:19:59

see that in what I read,

1:20:01

just that her remains were badly

1:20:03

decomposed. I also

1:20:05

saw that both of the

1:20:07

young women were considered like,

1:20:09

quote unquote, brutally beaten. So

1:20:11

they definitely sustained a lot

1:20:13

of injuries that whether or

1:20:15

not the decomposition had been were

1:20:18

still able to be picked up

1:20:20

like on Bryn's autopsy. But I don't

1:20:23

think Carol was because she was

1:20:25

so haphazardly left. I don't think she

1:20:27

was dead for nearly as long

1:20:29

as Bryn because it was like weeks

1:20:31

before Bryn was found. I think

1:20:33

Carol was found pretty soon after it

1:20:35

happened. So they were able to

1:20:37

actually get more, you know, quote unquote

1:20:40

evidence or at least of what

1:20:42

happened to her off of her actual

1:20:44

body. Yeah. A newspaper report at

1:20:46

the time suggested that police were looking

1:20:48

for two suspects. I'm

1:20:50

not sure why they thought it might

1:20:52

have been two. I don't think

1:20:54

they knew right away that these cases

1:20:56

were connected and that they noticed

1:20:58

that they were similar. But they I

1:21:00

don't think had at that point

1:21:02

wrapped their heads around the fact that,

1:21:04

yeah, it's in a very similar

1:21:07

area. It's probably the same guy. They're

1:21:09

like, oh, these two different attacks.

1:21:11

This is so weird. But. Still no

1:21:13

leads were found in Carol's case

1:21:15

either. So neither Carol or Bryn's cases,

1:21:17

despite, you know, being a couple

1:21:19

of years apart in a similar fashion

1:21:21

in a similar area. We just,

1:21:23

nobody was coming forward. Nobody saw anything.

1:21:25

Nobody knew what the fuck was

1:21:27

going on. And then Carol's case also

1:21:29

went cold. So for decades, both

1:21:31

Bryn and Carol's families mourned unaware of

1:21:33

the connection that would eventually link

1:21:35

their murders. Like they didn't even know.

1:21:38

Nobody connected them? I don't

1:21:40

think so. Not at this

1:21:42

time. Jesus. They just, again, it's

1:21:44

like that two suspects thing. They weren't

1:21:47

looking for two suspects each in the same

1:21:49

attack. They were looking for like two

1:21:51

different suspects in two different attacks. I don't

1:21:53

think that they thought at all that

1:21:55

they were connected. So

1:21:57

for over four decades, over

1:21:59

40 years, the murders

1:22:01

of Bryn Rainey and Carol

1:22:03

Anderson remained unsolved mysteries. And

1:22:06

as I was reading about these

1:22:08

girls, It just this cases like

1:22:10

this and this particular case like

1:22:13

really makes me wonder and try

1:22:15

to look deeper at what investigators

1:22:17

are doing in these long stretches

1:22:19

of cold cases. And the reality

1:22:21

is not that much, which is

1:22:23

why there's so little for me

1:22:25

to report on from that 40

1:22:27

year plus stretch of time from

1:22:29

when this happened and when we

1:22:32

found out who did it. Yeah.

1:22:34

And as much as we

1:22:36

have opinions about police. I'm about

1:22:39

to get to it. When

1:22:41

it comes to cold cases, in

1:22:43

a lot of cases, they

1:22:45

know that the technology to advance

1:22:47

something is coming down the

1:22:49

turnpike. It's definitely yet. I mean,

1:22:52

it's definitely a yes and

1:22:54

situation. That is certainly a factor.

1:22:56

Lack of evidence is certainly

1:22:58

a factor. But like this made

1:23:00

me want to look into

1:23:02

this. So I did. Because,

1:23:05

you know, I'm not one to

1:23:07

give the justice system a pass at

1:23:09

any point, even when I am.

1:23:11

I can also hold the truth that

1:23:13

some of these cases do not

1:23:15

have enough for a determination to be

1:23:17

made. I do understand that. But

1:23:19

it is another angle of the structure

1:23:21

of police funding that begs to

1:23:23

be scrutinized and reevaluated, because even like

1:23:25

today, we're sitting on mountains of

1:23:27

evidence that just hasn't been tested because

1:23:29

we don't have the resources for

1:23:31

it. The backlog. Yeah. So

1:23:33

while, of course, the advancements we

1:23:35

have now weren't available during this

1:23:37

investigation, a lot of cold cases

1:23:40

stay cold because resources are reallocated

1:23:42

to new cases that have more

1:23:44

evidence and cold cases have very

1:23:46

little hope of being reopened until

1:23:48

compelling new evidence arises to put

1:23:50

resources back on that case. Yeah.

1:23:52

And they're just sitting in a

1:23:55

folder or whatever. And as. The

1:23:57

victims' families, even in some of

1:23:59

these cases, literally die and there's

1:24:01

no one left advocating for them.

1:24:03

They're just collecting dust, even when

1:24:05

there is new technology. So, like,

1:24:07

if we reallocated resources to more

1:24:09

cold cases, what evidence could, A,

1:24:12

be uncovered if investigators were actually

1:24:14

tasked to keep investigating rather than

1:24:16

wait for something new to come

1:24:18

across the desk or for some

1:24:20

new technology to emerge? So

1:24:23

that's neither here nor there. It's a

1:24:25

frustrating issue that we see time and time

1:24:27

again on this show. It sent me

1:24:29

down a bit of a rabbit hole on

1:24:31

cold cases. I did find a study

1:24:33

from the Council of State Governments Justice Center

1:24:35

that highlighted just how pervasive unsolved cases

1:24:37

are even now in the modern era of

1:24:40

forensic technology. And like that's more of

1:24:42

a resource allocation issue, not we don't have

1:24:44

the technology to solve it. Yeah. So

1:24:46

this said, quote, in 2022, which is when

1:24:48

they completed this study. So obviously there's

1:24:50

probably more data now, but like this was

1:24:52

so recent enough that I found this

1:24:54

really compelling. 63 % of

1:24:56

violent crimes in the United States

1:24:59

that were reported to police went

1:25:01

unsolved. 63%. Of violent

1:25:03

crimes. Of violent crimes. This

1:25:05

means in a single year,

1:25:07

there was no one arrested,

1:25:09

charged, and referred for prosecution

1:25:12

in over 800 ,000 violent

1:25:14

crimes that included an estimated

1:25:16

10 ,000 homicides, 525 ,000 aggravated

1:25:18

assaults, 169 ,000 robberies, and 98

1:25:20

,000 rapes. Oh, my God.

1:25:23

Meanwhile, states that have reallocated

1:25:25

funding and invested in not

1:25:27

only detectives, and I'm not

1:25:29

saying regular cops, I mean

1:25:31

like detectives, legitimate investigators, but

1:25:33

also invested in community involvement

1:25:36

and collaboration have all seen

1:25:38

better outcomes, not in just

1:25:40

solving violent crimes and cold

1:25:42

cases, but preventing these crimes

1:25:44

from happening in the first

1:25:46

place. So like we have

1:25:49

these bloated police budgets in

1:25:51

every state and the data shows

1:25:53

time and time again that

1:25:55

reallocating those budgets because cops really

1:25:57

don't need fucking tanks and

1:25:59

millions in weaponry and tactical gear

1:26:01

has reallocating those kinds of

1:26:03

resources has a very positive impact

1:26:05

on communities and on like

1:26:07

actual solve rates of crime as

1:26:09

well as crime prevention. So

1:26:11

when I just wanted to like.

1:26:13

focus on that for a

1:26:15

fucking second because i feel like

1:26:17

people really bulk and recoil

1:26:19

at the defund the police of

1:26:21

it all and we have

1:26:23

to remember that like the reallocation

1:26:25

of the of the budget

1:26:28

is the main part of what

1:26:30

that means those budgets don't

1:26:32

go up consistently without the outcomes

1:26:34

to back up the need

1:26:36

for that spending because or the

1:26:38

budgets go up sorry consistently

1:26:40

across the united states for police

1:26:42

every year because It

1:26:44

goes into a lot of unnecessary shit

1:26:46

that makes a cop on the

1:26:48

street like a militarized cool guy rather

1:26:50

than pouring it into community programs

1:26:53

that reduce crime and trained investigative teams

1:26:55

that actually solve cases and investing

1:26:57

in the kind of crime labs. Empirical

1:26:59

evidence showing that it does

1:27:01

work. Like crime labs, autopsy, coroner

1:27:03

reports. These are all part

1:27:06

of the justice system that need

1:27:08

funding because we need those

1:27:10

scientists. Those experts that can

1:27:12

look at a decomposed 27 year

1:27:14

old woman and tell us every

1:27:16

fucking possible thing we could possibly

1:27:18

learn to find their killer. I

1:27:20

was so energized after the crime

1:27:22

lab and after our hosts, our

1:27:24

tour guides kind of like gave

1:27:26

us a little like empowerment speech.

1:27:29

They were like, it's the cops

1:27:31

and the bureaucracy and the system

1:27:33

that is preventing us from doing

1:27:35

our job. It's like, you guys

1:27:37

are so fucking cool. You have

1:27:39

all the tools in the world.

1:27:41

They really do. And it's not

1:27:43

to say that there hasn't been

1:27:45

corruption at those levels as well.

1:27:47

Of There absolutely has. But it's

1:27:49

not to the level where people

1:27:52

are marching in the street calling

1:27:54

for the defunding of a coroner,

1:27:56

of their local coroner. Like, there's

1:27:58

a difference. Yes. And

1:28:00

I also think that when

1:28:02

you have these cold case

1:28:04

units, which are, of course,

1:28:06

Crucial, important. But in

1:28:08

a lot of respects, it's

1:28:10

allowing them to cherry pick

1:28:12

the cases that they want

1:28:14

to take and guess which

1:28:17

cases they're not fucking up.

1:28:19

Well, and those cold case

1:28:21

investigators are not even necessarily

1:28:23

part of a dedicated we

1:28:25

focus on cold cases team.

1:28:27

It's usually a task force.

1:28:29

It's not a department. So

1:28:31

it's a task force that

1:28:33

is already extending. the capacity

1:28:35

of investigators that are working on

1:28:37

active scenes that do have more

1:28:39

evidence. Again, it's

1:28:41

that like allocation of resources.

1:28:43

So these cold cases get the

1:28:45

back burner and like, I

1:28:48

get it, but why do we

1:28:50

have these multi -billion dollar police

1:28:52

budgets and we don't infuse

1:28:54

them into departments that could solve

1:28:56

more crimes? literally

1:28:58

raising your numbers that's not even

1:29:00

me saying like just get rid

1:29:02

of it get rid of all

1:29:04

of that it's like could we

1:29:06

actually infuse that with people who

1:29:09

know what the fuck they're doing

1:29:11

and have the proper training to

1:29:13

work with the scientists to work

1:29:15

with the the labs and like

1:29:17

keep these cases important alive yeah

1:29:19

it's just it makes me so

1:29:21

sad and you know numbers are

1:29:23

astounding in a year 98 000

1:29:25

rapes yep And that's only, those

1:29:27

are the 98 ,000 that went

1:29:29

unsolved that had been reported. Been

1:29:31

reported. So can you even fucking

1:29:33

imagine? I'm like, again. 10 ,000 homicides

1:29:35

in a year. In a year.

1:29:37

10 ,000 that had no, no

1:29:40

arrests at all. Jesus Christ. Yeah.

1:29:42

So it's very sad. It's very

1:29:44

frustrating. And, you know, you too

1:29:46

can get involved in your local

1:29:48

ACAB chapter and connect with like

1:29:50

minded people who want to push

1:29:52

for this kind of budget reallocation

1:29:55

on the state level. And that's

1:29:57

where getting involved in local politics

1:29:59

is so important because you can't

1:30:01

really change the like federal fucking

1:30:03

police and defense budget. That's a

1:30:05

much bigger. elephant to

1:30:07

eat one bite at a time but

1:30:09

you can get involved on a local

1:30:11

level where your city council and your

1:30:13

mayor are like working on those budgets

1:30:15

together you can get involved with your

1:30:17

governor a little bit louder when you

1:30:19

when there aren't that many other people

1:30:21

standing with you yeah i don't know

1:30:23

that's just like to think of not

1:30:25

just these women but like all of

1:30:27

these families that we have discussed where

1:30:29

the cases were called for fucking decades

1:30:32

And like you said earlier, thinking about

1:30:34

these people who, yes, they know their

1:30:36

children are now gone, but they don't

1:30:39

know why. They don't know who. They

1:30:41

don't know. Like, they don't know anything.

1:30:43

That's not fucking justice. You might be

1:30:45

able to finally say, OK, I don't

1:30:47

have to look for her anymore. Yeah.

1:30:49

But I don't know how much better

1:30:51

that is. And then you're just another

1:30:53

flavor of excruciating pain. And your cold

1:30:55

case task force is like barely working

1:30:57

on anything. And if these honestly, in

1:30:59

a lot of cases, if these families

1:31:02

aren't the ones advocating. for the continuation

1:31:04

of their children's case. Then no one

1:31:06

is. No one is. And

1:31:08

they get completely left in

1:31:10

the dust. And then when these

1:31:12

tech advancements and forensic advancements

1:31:14

do happen, no one is standing

1:31:16

there going, okay, check my

1:31:18

daughter's file. Check my daughter's evidence.

1:31:21

They just get lost. And

1:31:23

it's fucking devastating. Anyway,

1:31:26

end of the backlog. Not just of

1:31:28

rape kits, but like... shit. Everything. I

1:31:30

know. I know. Which is, I get

1:31:32

it. That's a big undertaking, but doesn't

1:31:34

mean we shouldn't try. It doesn't mean

1:31:36

we can't take one step toward that.

1:31:38

Correct. One single step toward that. Correct. It's

1:31:41

a huge mountain to climb. We'll

1:31:43

probably never get through it all, but

1:31:45

that doesn't mean you can't. Try

1:31:47

to get through some of it. You

1:31:50

can't accomplish something. Yeah. You can't

1:31:52

piece together, back together the lives of

1:31:54

a few people. But you could

1:31:56

even, I don't know, save the lives

1:31:58

of future people. Mmm. Wow,

1:32:00

what a leap. I know, but

1:32:02

that's not what the cops do.

1:32:05

So anyway, decades later, in 2007,

1:32:07

the El Dorado County Sheriff's Office

1:32:09

formed a cold case task force

1:32:11

that re -examined these two murders. The

1:32:13

first significant breaks came in

1:32:15

the years that followed. So, after

1:32:17

2007. Between 2012 and

1:32:20

2013, investigators were able

1:32:22

to obtain male DNA profiles

1:32:24

from evidence in both

1:32:26

cases. Now, I don't know.

1:32:30

Exactly what the DNA

1:32:32

was. They were

1:32:34

like swabs taken from

1:32:36

bodies. One was

1:32:38

blood on a shirt. So

1:32:40

there was a swab taken from

1:32:42

Carol's body during her 1979

1:32:44

autopsy that yielded a male DNA

1:32:46

profile. There was blood from

1:32:48

a shirt that Bryn had been

1:32:50

wearing that also had a

1:32:52

partial profile. I think there was

1:32:54

additional DNA, but the crucial

1:32:56

DNA came from these two things.

1:32:58

I tried to get more

1:33:00

information in Carol's case on what

1:33:02

was swabbed as there had

1:33:04

been evidence or at least the

1:33:06

suggestion of sexual assault in

1:33:08

both cases. It's entirely possible that

1:33:10

this was like a semen

1:33:12

swab. But also keep in mind

1:33:14

that these are small samples

1:33:16

because back in at that time,

1:33:18

we didn't have this technology.

1:33:20

So even though we were like.

1:33:22

oh yeah, we should collect

1:33:24

this because one day that will

1:33:26

be useful. How much is

1:33:28

collected is typically a lot less

1:33:30

in these older cases. And

1:33:33

then they sit in evidence lockers

1:33:35

and they do deteriorate over

1:33:37

time. So it's very exciting when

1:33:39

you find DNA, but it doesn't necessarily

1:33:41

end up being, as we've discussed before,

1:33:43

like the quote unquote smoking gun that

1:33:45

people get. a robust profile. Exactly. It's

1:33:47

like, okay, all we can get off

1:33:49

of this right now is that it's

1:33:51

like a dude with these specific potential

1:33:54

markers. male excreter. These profiles

1:33:56

were uploaded to the Combined

1:33:58

DNA Index System, or CODIS, but

1:34:00

unfortunately no matches were found.

1:34:02

The cases were shelved again until

1:34:04

2017 when the task force

1:34:06

turned to a groundbreaking technique, genetic

1:34:08

genealogy. Ever heard of it?

1:34:10

Yeah, I'm not going to go

1:34:12

over this in too much

1:34:14

detail because we obviously, most of

1:34:16

us know, but in case

1:34:18

you don't, the long and short...

1:34:20

This method goes beyond direct

1:34:22

DNA matches in criminal databases, and

1:34:25

instead, investigators employed a private

1:34:27

company, Paraben Nanolabs, which is a

1:34:29

DNA tech company, to analyze

1:34:31

the DNA evidence beyond what the,

1:34:33

you know, Eldorado Crime Lab

1:34:35

was able to get from those

1:34:37

samples. Paraben used genetic genealogy,

1:34:39

the same process that ultimately identified

1:34:41

the Golden State Killer, to

1:34:43

build a quote -unquote family tree

1:34:45

by comparing the crime scene DNA

1:34:47

to user -submitted DNA kits in

1:34:49

public databases like gedmatch.com or

1:34:51

what's the other one? 23andMe. Ancestry.com.

1:34:53

Ancestry. Like, you can opt

1:34:56

to have those shared so that

1:34:58

you could be contacted in

1:35:00

the event of something exactly like

1:35:02

this. Or just like, oh,

1:35:04

I'm your sixth cousin. Right. Let's

1:35:06

email. Mm -hmm. This process rarely

1:35:08

identifies a suspect directly, but

1:35:10

instead helps narrow down the pool

1:35:12

by finding close genetic relatives.

1:35:14

Through this painstaking process, Paraben was

1:35:16

able to identify three deceased

1:35:18

brothers as potential sources of the

1:35:20

DNA. All three brothers were

1:35:22

deceased? Yes. So they found

1:35:24

these three dead brothers that had

1:35:27

a lot of genetic similarities with what

1:35:29

they were able to get off

1:35:31

of that DNA swab. These three dead

1:35:33

brothers. dead brothers. And they

1:35:35

were like, okay, it's probably one

1:35:37

of these three dead brothers. Let's

1:35:39

look at their descendants. Okay. So

1:35:41

they looked at their descendants, and

1:35:43

this led them to the family

1:35:45

of Joseph Stephen Holt. Holt was

1:35:47

born in the Bay Area in

1:35:49

1947. He graduated from Cupertino High

1:35:51

School and attended UC Berkeley. He

1:35:54

moved to South Lake Tahoe in

1:35:56

1974 and worked in real estate

1:35:58

in the Tahoe area. He

1:36:00

died in 2014 at the age of

1:36:02

66. I'm not exactly sure how he died,

1:36:04

and I don't give enough of a

1:36:06

fuck about him to have checked. I had

1:36:08

already written a lot. I didn't fucking

1:36:10

bother. Bye. Crucially, Holt

1:36:12

lived less than two miles from

1:36:14

where both Bryn and Carol's bodies

1:36:17

were discovered. And as a realtor,

1:36:19

he frequently traveled between San Jose

1:36:21

and South Lake Tahoe. So he

1:36:23

would have been very familiar with

1:36:25

that whole area. Hmm. Weird.

1:36:28

I couldn't find any of those

1:36:30

sound bites that we often see

1:36:32

in cases like these attesting to

1:36:34

his character or how quiet or

1:36:36

affable or what a pillar of

1:36:38

the community he may have been.

1:36:40

I don't know. And I don't

1:36:42

care. But his descendants had no

1:36:44

idea that he had done this

1:36:46

or had this dark past. And

1:36:49

they willingly cooperated. Like his sons were

1:36:51

like, yep, we'll give you anything you

1:36:53

need. They cooperated in his investigation. One

1:36:55

of his sons, oh, we're about to

1:36:57

get to it, so I won't say

1:37:00

that. But they haven't made any public

1:37:02

statements about Joseph. And frankly, I don't

1:37:04

fucking blame them. I like cannot even

1:37:06

imagine. You're pinged out of

1:37:08

the blue by the by an

1:37:10

investigation team that's like, hey, we're checking

1:37:12

these old swabs from two murders

1:37:14

in the 70s. Yeah. Might have been

1:37:16

your dad. It might have been

1:37:18

your dad. And then the DNA matches

1:37:20

and they find out like he

1:37:22

was definitely in the area at that

1:37:25

time. It's like, holy shit. Yeah.

1:37:27

It's really fucking odds of it not

1:37:29

being him are very slim. very

1:37:31

very very very very slim

1:37:33

and i there of course

1:37:35

he's not alive to stand

1:37:38

trial but they're this case

1:37:40

at least for these two

1:37:42

women these two murdered women

1:37:44

it's pretty unequivocally accepted that

1:37:46

he killed them like too

1:37:48

much adds up family interviews

1:37:50

family history there's also some

1:37:52

evidence that they get from

1:37:54

these kids so in 2018

1:37:56

investigators contacted Holt's living family,

1:37:58

including a biological son who

1:38:00

fully cooperated with all of

1:38:03

their inquiry. The son provided

1:38:05

his own DNA and even

1:38:07

an old toothbrush that belonged

1:38:09

to his father, Joseph. Ooh,

1:38:11

creepy. Subsequent DNA

1:38:14

testing confirmed the undeniable link Joseph

1:38:16

Holt's DNA matched the DNA found

1:38:18

on Bryn Rainey's shirt and Carol

1:38:20

Anderson's body. El Dorado County

1:38:22

District Attorney Vern Pearson announced

1:38:24

the identification of Holt as

1:38:26

their suspect on February 25th,

1:38:29

2019. Wow. I

1:38:31

mean, these girls were killed

1:38:33

in 1977 and 1979. And this

1:38:35

man's name is finally being

1:38:37

spoken publicly in 2019. OK,

1:38:39

so your dad is dead.

1:38:42

Yes, he is. Let's go. If

1:38:44

you found yourself in this

1:38:46

exact scenario where you were approached

1:38:48

by investigators and like your

1:38:50

dad has been really definitively linked

1:38:52

to these murders, will you

1:38:54

help us close this case? Wouldn't

1:38:58

a big part of you want to

1:39:00

be like, don't talk about my dad that

1:39:02

way? I think it

1:39:04

would be really hard, but I think

1:39:06

the part of me that cares about

1:39:08

other people would not let me not

1:39:10

cooperate in something like that. And the

1:39:12

work of figuring out how to grapple

1:39:14

with the discovery of what my father

1:39:17

had done is mine and isn't the

1:39:19

fault of those families or those girls

1:39:21

or the people that were still out

1:39:23

here looking for them for the last

1:39:25

40 years. I

1:39:27

think that would be one of

1:39:29

the most impossible and unfathomable things to

1:39:31

be confronted with that you could

1:39:33

ever imagine. And I really

1:39:35

commend this specifically his son for his

1:39:37

willingness to do that, because I can completely

1:39:40

understand the urge to be like, no,

1:39:42

I don't want to know these things. And

1:39:44

I wouldn't I wouldn't I don't want

1:39:46

to help the world confirm these things. No,

1:39:48

I think it would be unbelievably hard,

1:39:50

but I don't think I personally could. could

1:39:52

say no and then like look at

1:39:55

myself in the mirror ever again. I don't

1:39:57

think I could either. I don't think

1:39:59

you could. Especially if he was already dead.

1:40:01

If he was alive, that would be

1:40:03

a lot. I mean, I think

1:40:05

that would be more complicated. Yeah, and

1:40:07

it would be my job in therapy to

1:40:10

figure out how to preserve the things

1:40:12

about my father that I loved and that

1:40:14

were meaningful and the things that I

1:40:16

didn't know. But again,

1:40:19

that's not the response, you know, that's

1:40:21

not the responsibility of these girls

1:40:23

and their families. No. That's my shit.

1:40:25

Let their families get... Some kind

1:40:27

of closure. The way that they've been

1:40:29

feeling for the last, like, fucking

1:40:31

40 years or whatever. It's like... You

1:40:34

can handle it. I can be

1:40:36

up. You can get therapy. He's already

1:40:38

dead. Yeah, he gone. Yeah.

1:40:40

But yeah, no, I mean, I

1:40:42

thought about that too when I was

1:40:44

writing this. I was like, fuck.

1:40:46

I mean, I really feel for his

1:40:48

son. Yeah. And his surviving family. This

1:40:51

would be earth shattering. Your whole

1:40:53

world would change. Yeah. Especially if

1:40:55

you had no fucking inkling that

1:40:57

he was like an asshole. No

1:40:59

clue. And, you know, you have

1:41:01

these ideas of who your parents

1:41:03

are, but also that like earth

1:41:05

shattering sense of self. that would

1:41:07

get completely fucking thrown in the

1:41:09

garbage can because like your parents

1:41:11

and you know for a lot

1:41:13

of people like make you raise

1:41:15

you make you who you are

1:41:17

your entire origin story the

1:41:19

fuck am i if my dad was

1:41:22

a fucking murderer and then you'd have to

1:41:24

think about like how old was i

1:41:26

in 1977 yeah he probably wasn't born but

1:41:28

yeah did he come home and have

1:41:30

dinner with us that night who knows Who

1:41:33

knows? Also, the clove hitch

1:41:35

killer. I think it's on Netflix.

1:41:37

Yeah, it's very it's a

1:41:39

very the vibe is clove hitch

1:41:41

golden state. I mean, clove

1:41:43

hitch isn't real, but, you know,

1:41:45

it's based on BTK. Yeah.

1:41:47

BTK for sure. Similar vibe. So

1:41:51

interestingly, investigators discovered that, quote,

1:41:53

Joseph Holt was never on

1:41:55

the radar prior to the

1:41:57

DNA breakthrough. They had never

1:41:59

even looked at him. As

1:42:01

a suspect, which is frustrating

1:42:04

because of something we're about

1:42:06

to get to. So further

1:42:08

investigation into Holt's remaining personal

1:42:10

effects yielded even more suggestive

1:42:12

evidence. They found a 1975

1:42:14

news clipping about an unsolved

1:42:16

non -fatal shooting in Los

1:42:18

Gatos. The cats. And

1:42:20

there was a sketch produced

1:42:23

by Los Gatos police at the

1:42:25

time of that non -fatal shooting.

1:42:27

That bore a striking resemblance

1:42:29

to a contemporary picture of

1:42:31

Holt. I'm going to the

1:42:33

drive. Yeah. So, so much

1:42:35

so that Holt is now

1:42:37

considered a suspect in that

1:42:39

crime as well. It's

1:42:42

him. Like, I'm sorry.

1:42:45

Someone handed him a

1:42:47

picture. Yeah. And said, draw

1:42:50

this man. And then they

1:42:52

drew him and forgot the bottom

1:42:54

half of his goatee, basically.

1:42:56

Yeah, man. So, you know, that's

1:42:58

another thing that is so

1:43:00

frustrating to read about after the

1:43:02

fact, because it's like if

1:43:04

any of these precincts were in

1:43:06

the habit of sharing information

1:43:08

with each other about some of

1:43:10

the cases or, you know,

1:43:12

whatever, then like maybe Los Gatos,

1:43:14

like this area isn't that

1:43:16

far from where he'd already been

1:43:18

hanging around in the in

1:43:20

the mid 70s. Like if only.

1:43:23

And I know hindsight's 20 -20,

1:43:25

but, like, if only we had

1:43:27

had, or, you know, anyone

1:43:29

in connection with the investigation into

1:43:31

Bryn or Carol's deaths had

1:43:33

had access to that and, like,

1:43:35

other people talking about these

1:43:37

possibilities or whatever. I know it

1:43:39

was, like, a different crime.

1:43:41

It just makes you think about,

1:43:43

like, what could have been.

1:43:45

It's like, that fucking good of

1:43:47

a sketch is sitting connected

1:43:49

to a different crime in a

1:43:51

different precinct. somewhere else and

1:43:53

so it's like it's so close

1:43:55

but it's so far away

1:43:57

so it's like now the police

1:43:59

are still looking into his

1:44:01

past because it's like well fuck

1:44:03

this was probably him the

1:44:05

timeline pans out the sketch is

1:44:07

fucking spot on wildly accurate

1:44:09

it's a photocopy yeah and we

1:44:11

know he was in that

1:44:13

area like what else could he

1:44:15

have gotten up to Mm

1:44:17

hmm. And that's what I always

1:44:19

think about, too. It's like, OK,

1:44:22

you got caught for murdering two women. How

1:44:24

many other people did you abuse and potentially

1:44:26

murder? How many women did you assault? That's

1:44:28

what I want to know. We're going to

1:44:30

get there. I'm almost done. But like, I

1:44:32

have my thoughts on that. And I think

1:44:34

that they are shared. I really think that

1:44:36

you'll feel exactly the same way. So while

1:44:39

Joseph Holt died in 2014 and will never

1:44:41

face trial for the murders of Bryn Rainey

1:44:43

and Carol Anderson. The identification

1:44:45

of him has brought a

1:44:47

measure of closure to their

1:44:49

families after decades of agonizing

1:44:51

uncertainty. Carol's family did

1:44:53

release a public statement saying that through

1:44:55

the hard work and efforts of

1:44:57

the investigators, they were able to give

1:44:59

the family some answers and some

1:45:01

closure. And to ultimately allow Carol Anderson

1:45:03

to rest in peace with the

1:45:05

knowledge of who did this to her.

1:45:07

What guts me is that with

1:45:09

him dead, we'll never know his... for

1:45:12

these murders though it's certainly speculated

1:45:14

that they were acts of sexual

1:45:16

violence it's possible that he had

1:45:18

intended to rape these girls and

1:45:20

things either got out of hand

1:45:22

or he wanted to get away

1:45:24

with it and not leave the

1:45:26

girls alive to implicate him yeah

1:45:28

but like you were just i

1:45:30

think getting to with crimes as

1:45:32

violent and potentially sexually motivated i

1:45:34

mean it seems pretty clear that

1:45:36

they were as these not just

1:45:38

because there's evidence of sexual assault

1:45:40

but a lot of like Tying

1:45:42

up the strangulation, that's all very

1:45:44

closely connected to sexually motivated crime.

1:45:47

It's ritualistic, and you don't

1:45:49

just jump to that. No,

1:45:51

it's highly unlikely these were

1:45:53

his only two victims, even

1:45:55

if they were the only

1:45:58

two that he killed. Yeah. So...

1:46:00

To that end, the El Dorado

1:46:02

County Case Task Force continues its

1:46:04

investigation into Joseph Holt, seeking to

1:46:06

determine if he may be responsible

1:46:08

for other unsolved crimes in the

1:46:10

South Lake Tahoe and San Jose

1:46:12

areas. They're asking for the public's

1:46:15

help in identifying any crimes that

1:46:17

may have been witnessed or if

1:46:19

you know any victims that may

1:46:21

have been associated with Holt. Anyone

1:46:23

with information is urged to contact

1:46:25

the task force. Hotline at 530

1:46:27

-621 - four five nine zero and

1:46:29

there was another article talking about

1:46:31

the this task force and this

1:46:33

case and they put together a

1:46:35

picture of like joseph holt through

1:46:37

the years so that it can

1:46:39

make it a little bit easier

1:46:41

maybe for people from different eras

1:46:43

to be like oh shit yeah

1:46:45

i did see that guy because

1:46:47

he does look kind of different

1:46:50

i mean he has the same

1:46:52

fucking googly eyes he does but

1:46:54

his facial hair his but his

1:46:56

levels of baldness like things do

1:46:58

kind of seem to change a

1:47:00

little over over time but it

1:47:02

sounds like his son or surviving

1:47:04

family provided a lot of these

1:47:06

photos so that if they're they're

1:47:08

what they're still looking into this

1:47:10

dead man to be like what

1:47:12

the fuck else did this guy

1:47:14

do because i think they feel

1:47:16

similarly that that we do where

1:47:18

it's like this is a lot

1:47:20

And now this weird shooting thing

1:47:22

happened over here. And that sketch

1:47:25

is really accurate. And he would

1:47:27

have been there at that time.

1:47:29

We think that was him. What

1:47:31

else might he have done? We

1:47:33

don't know. So

1:47:35

if any of these photos or,

1:47:37

you know, this story or

1:47:39

that region of South Lake Tahoe

1:47:41

or the surrounding area in

1:47:43

that time is like ringing any

1:47:45

bells for you. You got

1:47:48

something weird that never really made

1:47:50

sense or somebody went missing

1:47:52

or someone you know was harassed

1:47:54

or approached by this guy.

1:47:56

Call that fucking task force. Yes.

1:47:58

So that we can really

1:48:00

close the book on this asshole.

1:48:02

Because holy shit. And that's

1:48:04

my case. Well, that sounds great.

1:48:08

Also, I did look up Dusty

1:48:10

P's original email. Yes. They live

1:48:12

about 30 minutes away from the

1:48:14

lake. That makes a lot of

1:48:16

sense. I kind of figured it

1:48:18

was just a geographical location choice,

1:48:20

but you never know. Well, thank

1:48:23

you, Dusty P, for your topic

1:48:25

choice. Seriously, fascinating. Yeah, kind

1:48:27

of dark. Oh, yeah. But I really

1:48:29

want to go to Pyramid Lake. Not

1:48:31

that that's what the episode was about.

1:48:33

Fuck Lake Tahoe. That place is a

1:48:35

hellhole. Well,

1:48:38

people vanish all the time.

1:48:40

I heard that they found a

1:48:42

massive underground nuclear power plant

1:48:44

under Pyramid Lake. Oh! Potentially

1:48:47

built by the Tahoe Sea

1:48:49

Monster. I heard there was a

1:48:51

big scaly bird flying around

1:48:53

using Lake Tahoe as his own

1:48:55

personal whirlpool. Listen, that I'd

1:48:57

believe. Well, the

1:49:00

Ong. The Ong lives. Rest in

1:49:02

peace. The drowned will never be

1:49:04

given up. May your spirit. Continue

1:49:07

to soar with the eagles.

1:49:10

Minus your wings because they were

1:49:12

used as a sailboat. Oops. My

1:49:14

bad. That was rough. Anyway, we

1:49:16

love you all. Thank you so

1:49:18

much for listening. And yeah, if

1:49:20

you want to hear this ad

1:49:22

free, hop over to our uncorked

1:49:24

page. It's out. We put the ad

1:49:26

free episodes up the same day so you

1:49:28

don't have to wait. It's right there for your

1:49:31

ear holes, baby. It's right

1:49:33

there. Thanks so much for

1:49:35

listening and we will see

1:49:37

you next week. Bye -bye. Thanks

1:49:39

for listening to Wine and

1:49:41

Crime. Our cover art is

1:49:43

by Danielle Sylvan. Music by

1:49:45

Phil Young and Corey Wendell.

1:49:47

Editing by Jonathan Camp. Our

1:49:49

production manager is Andrea Gardner.

1:49:51

For photos, sources, and other

1:49:53

resources, head to WineAndCrimePodcast.com. You

1:49:55

can follow us on all

1:49:57

the socials at WineAndCrimePod. If

1:49:59

like to show your support

1:50:01

and get access to all

1:50:03

sorts of wine bonus

1:50:05

content, check out

1:50:07

our premium channel

1:50:10

at wineandcrimepodcast.com. uncorked.

1:50:12

Cheers! content.

1:51:22

content.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features