Yes, It’s Still a Bad Idea to Cheat on Your Taxes

Yes, It’s Still a Bad Idea to Cheat on Your Taxes

Released Tuesday, 8th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Yes, It’s Still a Bad Idea to Cheat on Your Taxes

Yes, It’s Still a Bad Idea to Cheat on Your Taxes

Yes, It’s Still a Bad Idea to Cheat on Your Taxes

Yes, It’s Still a Bad Idea to Cheat on Your Taxes

Tuesday, 8th April 2025
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

This This message comes from Green Light, Ready

0:02

to start talking to your kids

0:05

about financial literacy? Meet Greenlight, the debit

0:07

card and money app that teaches

0:09

kids and teens how to earn, save,

0:11

spend wisely, to and invest spend wisely, and

0:13

in place. With With Greenlight, you can

0:15

send money to kids quickly, can up

0:18

chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye

0:20

on your kids spending with real -time

0:22

notifications. Join millions of parents and

0:24

kids building healthy financial habits together on

0:26

Greenlight. Get started risk -free at greenlight.com

0:28

together on Green Light. I

2:00

don't know if you

2:02

knew this, but anyone

2:04

can get the same

2:06

premium wireless for $15

2:08

a month plan that

2:10

I've been enjoying. It's

2:13

not Ryan Reynolds here for

2:15

Mint Mobile. I don't know if

2:17

you knew this, but anyone can

2:20

get the same premium wireless for

2:22

$15 a month plan that I've

2:24

been enjoying. It's not just for

2:27

celebrities, so do like I did,

2:29

and have one of your assistance

2:32

assistance to switch you to

2:34

Mint Mobile today. I'm told

2:36

it's super easy to do

2:38

at Mint Mobile today. I'm

2:40

told it's super easy to

2:42

do at mintmobile.com. available. Taxes

2:44

and fees extra. See full

2:47

terms at MintMobile. Com. While

2:49

the IRS may be shrinking,

2:51

it's still far from toothless.

2:53

Wall Street Journal tax reporter

2:55

Laura Saunders joins me. Laura,

2:57

what kinds of things do

3:00

people usually try to fudge

3:02

on their tax return? It's a

3:04

range. They might omit income, just

3:06

leave it off. They might exaggerate

3:08

deductions or credits and claim... deductions

3:10

and credits that they shouldn't, or

3:13

they might just not file altogether.

3:15

And that'll get you in a

3:17

world of trouble, which I want

3:19

to get into. But since the

3:22

Trump administration took office, thousands of

3:24

IRS workers have been laid off,

3:26

and tax enforcement has been reduced.

3:28

Does this mean that people feel like

3:30

this is the year to cheat on

3:32

their tax return? A lot of them

3:34

seem to think that. And we talked

3:36

to some preparers who said they're getting

3:38

pushback. Do I really have to put

3:41

that in? They're not looking anyway. Yeah,

3:43

they'll never notice. And they said they're

3:45

getting more of that this year. So what are

3:47

some of the ways that the IRS knows that

3:49

you cheated? Under the law. People who

3:51

make payments to individuals very often

3:53

have to also tell the IRS

3:55

about those payments. Think about your

3:57

W-2 form. It has what you're...

4:00

pays you, it has a lot of

4:02

other information. And the IRS gets something

4:04

like 250 million of those a year.

4:07

That's a good place for it to

4:09

start. But beyond that, there are all

4:11

these 1099 forms. Did you get money

4:13

from a brokerage account, dividends, interest, capital

4:16

gains? Did you have gambling winnings? Did

4:18

you get unemployment benefits? All these things

4:20

are reported to the IRS as well

4:23

as to you. And so the IRS

4:25

has wonderful computers that can match these

4:27

up and they send you a letter

4:30

and say, what about? that money? What

4:32

about those gambling winnings that we didn't

4:34

hear about from you? And the other

4:37

thing is that perhaps you didn't file

4:39

at all. Well, if they get one

4:41

of those forms, they might say, where

4:44

is the return? And that could be

4:46

trouble. So even with all of these

4:48

slashes to its workforce, the IRS can

4:51

still detect these crimes. How does it

4:53

do that? Well, it matches with a

4:55

computer, and it'll probably start that about

4:57

the end of this year and go

5:00

on for a year or two. Then

5:02

the computer generates letters. What about this?

5:04

What about that? We didn't hear about

5:07

that. Come on, tell us about the

5:09

other. How does the IRS... penalize unpaid

5:11

taxes. Oh, there's so many ways. And

5:14

Congress has provided the IRS with a

5:16

toolbox of penalties. The first thing that

5:18

happens is interest. It's not a penalty

5:21

per se, but it feels like a

5:23

penalty. And right now, the interest rate

5:25

on unpaid taxes is 7% a year.

5:28

It used to only be 3%. That's

5:30

a lot more. And then there are

5:32

penalties on top of that. Penalties for

5:35

failure to file, penalties for failure to

5:37

pay. Both of those can mount up

5:39

to 25% very quickly. Beyond that, one

5:41

of the most famous ones that people

5:44

really fear is it called a substantial

5:46

understatement penalty. And that means if you

5:48

understate your tax by a certain amount,

5:51

you get a higher penalty. And if

5:53

the income is severely... understated, then they

5:55

have six years to find you instead

5:58

of three years to find you. On

6:00

top of that, if you've done something

6:02

willfully fraudulent, the penalty on that is

6:05

75% of the tax you owe and

6:07

there is no statute of limitations. Wow,

6:09

so it could just keep, it could

6:12

haunt you forever. I'm curious. Do these

6:14

penalties stack up on top of each

6:16

other? Yes, they absolutely do. Now with

6:19

failure to file and failure to pay,

6:21

there's some offsets between them that bring

6:23

them down just a little bit, but

6:25

generally they just stack up. And then

6:28

the last penalty, which is kind of

6:30

wild, is the one for frivolous tax

6:32

returns. Now that's where the tax protesters

6:35

come in. Say that you submitted a

6:37

tax return that said that under the

6:39

Constitution, nobody should have to pay income

6:42

tax. That could be liable for a

6:44

frivolous tax penalty. Or what if you

6:46

took your paper tax return and you

6:49

colored it and then sent it in

6:51

that way, but you didn't put any

6:53

information or numbers or anything like that

6:56

on it? That would also be a

6:58

candidate for a frivolous tax penalty. So

7:00

these penalties have gotten... more expensive, meaning

7:03

this really isn't the time to mess

7:05

around? That's right. The big thing that's

7:07

gotten it more expensive is the interest

7:10

rights, and they, of course, the interest

7:12

rates run on the penalties as well

7:14

as the tax. So it's a pretty

7:16

serious business now. And you spoke to

7:19

some tax professionals who have clients that

7:21

have tried to push the envelope this

7:23

year. What did they say about it?

7:26

Absolutely. The professionals said to me that

7:28

they're hearing more about, oh, they'll never

7:30

know. We don't have to tell them

7:33

that. This is a big tough year.

7:35

They're not going to know. And then

7:37

the professionals turn around and say, no,

7:40

this has to be correct. Was that

7:42

really a business meal? Or was it

7:44

just a pleasure meal? One thing that's

7:47

important to know here is that tax

7:49

professionals have to ascertain that the information

7:51

on return is correct, and if it's

7:54

not, they could lose their licenses. So

7:56

that gives them a really good reason

7:58

to push back against clients. And that

8:00

applies to about half of taxpayers. The

8:03

other half do them themselves, maybe with

8:05

commercial software. There are not as many

8:07

restraints on them. Yeah. And you write

8:10

in your story, which can be found

8:12

in our show notes, that nearly 80

8:14

million Americans prepare their own tax returns.

8:17

What is self-filers need to know if

8:19

they're tempted to test the IRS's limits

8:21

this year? Well, they need to know

8:24

all the things we've just talked about,

8:26

all the ways they have to find

8:28

you, and all the penalties they can

8:31

impose on you. A former commissioner said

8:33

that he tells his clients that when

8:35

you dance with a bear, you dance

8:38

till the bear gets tired. That means

8:40

if you attract attention from the IRS,

8:42

it may go on and on and

8:44

on it. That's a good reason not

8:47

to attract their attention. And there's an

8:49

even better reason. It is that you'll

8:51

be able to sleep well at night.

8:54

Yeah. You don't want to be haunted

8:56

about what you did wrong. Which is

8:58

priceless. Yes. That's W.S.G. reporter Laura Saunders,

9:01

and that's it for your money briefing.

9:03

This episode was produced by me with

9:05

supervising producer Melanie Roy. I'm Mariana Aspudu

9:08

for the Wall Street Journal. Thanks for

9:10

listening.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features